• 9 hours ago
The Atlanta Constitution,

Friday, 24th October 1913,

PAGE 1, COLUMN 2.

Evidence Against

Jurors

Henslee and

Johenning the

Most Important To

Be

Introduced.

ATTITUDE OF

CROWDS

WILL BE

STRESSED

Verdict in Trial Was

Delayed

for Two Days on

Account

of Fear of Mob

Violence,

Roan Admits.

It developed Thursday during Frank hearing for a new trial

that the verdict in the original trial was delayed two days for fear

of mob violence to the accused man.

Also, that Judge Roan was prevailed upon by the editors of

the three Atlanta newspapers, militia, officials and the chief of

police to make this move of continuance. It was feared if the

verdict was submitted on the trial's final Saturday, during which

day the crowds were largest, that violence might result.

During the close of the trial, while Solicitor Dorsey was

ending his historical argument, Judge Roan ordered adjournment

at noon on Saturday, August 2. This was his action to prevent any

possible outbreak of the crowds. Had court not been adjourned at

that time, the solicitor's speech would have been finished before

nightfall and the verdict returned by earlier than 10 o'clock at

night.

Judge Roan certified to the conference he had held with

military officials and the chief of police.

In hearing section 115 of the new trial motion, the judge

gave a certificate of approval to the defense's argument upon the

temper of the crowds that attended the trial. He stated that, in his

opinion, the attitude of the majority of the crowds was hostile to

the defendant, and that it was evinced frequently both within and

without the courtroom.

This attitude of the crowds, it is apparent, will be one of the

strongest cards of Frank's counsel in seeking for a new trial. Not

less than fifteen or twenty grounds tendered at Thursday's

session pertained to demonstrations and public temper. Coupled

with these grounds and the evidence to be submitted against

Jurors Henslee and Johenning, the defense seems to have made

decided headway.

Charges Sufficient, If Proved.

Judge Roan, upon reviewing the grounds relating to Henslee

and Johenning's alleged prejudice, said:

If these facts can be proved, it would be hardly necessary

to continue with the hearing.

The volume of 115 grounds was finished at the close of

Thursday's session. Beginning at 9 o'clock this morning, a review

will be made of those which were passed up because of doubt,

following which will come the arguments, which are expected

about 10 o'clock this morning. Affidavits and other evidence will

also be considered today.

New Affidavits Presented.

The defense sprang a surprised Thursday when they

declared affidavits were in their hands contradicting Henslee's

story that he was not in Albany, Ga., at the time he is alleged to

have expressed bias. Colonel Rosser declared that he had

evidence of Henslee's signature upon the hotel register and of an

order which the accused juror

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Proof of charges will mean a new trial, says Court. The Atlanta Constitution, Friday, the 24th of
00:06October, 1913, page 1, column 2. Evidence against jurors, Hensley and Johenning, the most important
00:12to be introduced. Attitude of crowds will be stressed. Verdict in trial was delayed for two
00:18days on account of fear of mob violence, Roan admits. It developed Thursday during frank hearing
00:23for a new trial that the verdict in the original trial was delayed two days for fear of mob violence
00:28to the accused man. Also, that Judge Roan was prevailed upon by the editors of the three
00:33Atlanta newspapers, militia, officials, and the chief of police to make this move of continuance.
00:40It was feared if the verdict was submitted on the trial's final Saturday, during which day the crowds
00:45were largest, that violence might result. During the close of the trial, while Solicitor Dorsey was
00:51ending his historical argument, Judge Roan ordered a German at noon on Saturday, August 2. This was
00:57his action to prevent any possible outbreak of the crowds. Had court not been adjourned at that time,
01:03the solicitor's speech would have been finished before nightfall and the verdict returned by
01:07earlier than ten o'clock at night. Judge Roan certified to the conference he had held with
01:12military officials and the chief of police. In hearing section 115 of the new trial motion,
01:19the judge gave a certificate of approval to the defense's argument upon the temper of the crowds
01:24that attended the trial. He stated that, in his opinion, the attitude of the majority of the
01:29crowds was hostile to the defendant, and that it was evinced frequently both within and without the
01:35courtroom. This attitude of the crowds, it is apparent, will be one of the strongest cards of
01:40Frank's counsel in seeking for a new trial. Not less than fifteen or twenty grounds tendered at
01:46Thursday's session pertain to demonstrations and public temper. Coupled with these grounds and the
01:52evidence to be submitted against jurors Hensley and Joe Henning, the defense seems to have made
01:57decided headway. Charges sufficient if proved. Judge Roan, upon reviewing the grounds relating to
02:03Hensley and Joe Henning's alleged prejudice, said, If these facts can be proved, it would be hardly
02:09necessary to continue with the hearing. The volume of 115 grounds was finished at the close of Thursday's
02:16session. Beginning at nine o'clock this morning, a review will be made of those which were passed up
02:21because of doubt, following which will come the arguments, which are expected about ten o'clock
02:26this morning. Affidavits and other evidence will also be considered to-day. New affidavits presented.
02:32The defense sprang a surprise Thursday when they declared affidavits were in their hands,
02:37contradicting Hensley's story that he was not in Albany Gaye, at the time he is alleged to have
02:42expressed bias. Colonel Rosser declared that he had evidence of Hensley's signature upon the hotel
02:47register and of an order which the accused juror took in Albany on the date in question.
02:52Upon the establishment of this, or jury prejudice, depends the success or failure of the new trial
02:58motion. Judge Roan, in telling of the delayed verdict for fear of an outbreak, stated that he
03:03had prevailed upon continued on page seven. Page seven, column two, proof of charges will mean new trial
03:09continued from page one, by military officers and police officials to defer the end of the trial until
03:15the following Monday. This was done when it looked as though the verdict would be returned Saturday
03:20night. This was done, said the judge, because the temper of the crowd was obviously at high tension.
03:25I do not doubt that the prisoner might have suffered violence if proper steps had not been taken.
03:29Letters from editors. Judge Roan was apprised of the defense's knowledge of a personal communication
03:35which the court had received during the trial from James R. Gray of the Journal, Foster Coates of the
03:41Georgian, and Clark Howell of the Constitution, suggesting that the verdict be deferred until the
03:46following Monday. The judge was asked to certify to this. He would not, on the grounds that the
03:52communication was personal, but said that if the editors gave permission, he would make the desired
03:57certificate. Neither would he certify to the section of the motion appealing for new trial on the ground
04:03that the defense was not officially represented when the verdict was returned. This clause was the subject
04:09of a stubborn battle between the defense and prosecution. Solicitor Dorsey maintained that
04:14Stiles Hopkins, a member of the Rosser and Brandon law firm, was present in the courtroom at the time
04:19the verdict was returned and received it legally. To this, Colonel Rosser replied that Hopkins was given
04:25no instructions to represent the defendant, and that no one connected with the defense was supposed to
04:30have been in the courtroom at the time it was read. Hopkins was called to the hearing to testify.
04:35He stated that he had received no instructions, as stated by Mr. Rosser. First witnesses heard.
04:41The first witnesses were heard Thursday. Mr. Hopkins was the first. Afterwards, a newspaper reporter
04:47testified to the scenes outside the courtroom on the day of the verdict, when the solicitor was hoisted
04:52to the shoulders of a number of men in the crowd. A number of witnesses, it is said, will be
04:56put up today.
04:57An attack was made upon Judge Rohn's charge to the jury in ground 73 of the new trial motion.
05:02His failure to charge the jury to put no credence in Conley's story because of admitted falsehoods
05:08was another contention in a following section. The ground relating to the alleged illegal charge
05:13reads as follows. The court erred in charging the jury as follows. Is Leo Frank guilty? Are you
05:20satisfied with his guilt? Are you satisfied with his statement? Are you satisfied with the evidence?
05:26Is his plea of not guilty the truth? Object to picket letter. A plea is also based upon the injection
05:32into the solicitor's argument of a letter received from District Attorney C. M. Pickett of San Francisco
05:38bearing on the Durant case in California. It is alleged that the use of such material was illegal
05:44and prejudicial, and that the court was in error in not excluding it. References by Dorsey to Oscar Wilde,
05:50the Richeson and Beatle cases, were also objected to. A vigorous protest was made to the solicitor's
05:56accusation that the expert medical testimony introduced by the defense was obtained by
06:02money and influence. In answer to this, Dorsey stated that he never made such an allegation.
06:07I only intimated it, he said. Page 9, Column 3, Professional Cards.
06:12P. H. Brewster, Albert Howell Jr., Hugh M. Dorsey, Arthur Heyman, Dorsey, Brewster, Howell,
06:18and Herman, Attorneys at Law. Offices 202, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 210, Kaiser Building,
06:28Atlanta Gay. Long Distance Telephone 3022, 3024, and 3025, Atlanta Gay.

Recommended