Senator Josh Hawley puts a judicial nominee on the spot, presenting two choices: “Justice or rehabilitation.” His pointed question sparks attention during the confirmation hearing, highlighting the debate over criminal justice, judicial philosophy and how courts should balance punishment with opportunities for rehabilitation.


#JoshHawley #JusticeOrRehabilitation #JudicialNominee #SenateHearing #ConfirmationHearing #CriminalJustice #Rehabilitation #JusticeSystem #USSenate #USPolitics #PoliticalNews

~HT.178~ED.194~GR.506~VG.HM~

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and congratulations to the nominees.
00:02I want to start with the judicial nominees, if I could.
00:06And let me start with you, Mr. Campomor Sanchez.
00:09How do you pronounce your name, Ashley? Why don't we start with that?
00:12Oh, really? Well, I was in the neighborhood.
00:16Congratulations on your nomination.
00:17I understand that you spent substantial time as a prosecutor in the district.
00:20Is that correct?
00:20That is correct. 15 years.
00:22Okay, so let me just ask you this.
00:23Drawing on that experience as a prosecutor,
00:26do you think in general criminal laws in the district are,
00:29would you say they're over-enforced?
00:34Well, I'll talk about my experience as a prosecutor.
00:37I did not believe that we were over-enforcing the laws.
00:40Yeah, I don't think so either.
00:41Let me just give you an example.
00:42On Friday, just this last Friday,
00:44a 19-year-old named Darius Drew was sentenced for indiscriminately firing
00:48over 20 rounds of ammunition at two different locations in the district.
00:53One of those 20 rounds struck a young boy
00:56who was out playing basketball at a rec center.
00:58You know, just out shooting hoops.
01:01He gets hit.
01:02Search warrant turns up, two firearms, ammunition,
01:05large amounts of suspected narcotics and marijuana.
01:08He went on to plead guilty to aggravated assault
01:11and to carrying a pistol without a license.
01:14What does he get as his sentence?
01:17Prosecutor asked for five years,
01:19which is the top of the range of the sentencing guidelines.
01:21He got 18 months of probation.
01:2718 months of probation.
01:29He's out there firing a weapon, which he has illegally.
01:33He's got narcotics in his possession.
01:35He shoots a kid, and he gets 18 months of probation.
01:39I could multiply these examples.
01:41I could choose another one from just last week,
01:45where we had another individual, Jordan Grease,
01:49who was sentenced for armed carjacking that he committed in August of 2024.
01:53He and his co-conspirator took a gun,
01:56approached their victim who was sitting in a car.
01:57Grease demanded the car keys and the cell phone.
01:59When the victim exited the car, Grease stole it.
02:02Now, here's the best part.
02:03At the time of his offense, he was wearing a court services GPS monitor.
02:07He was already on probation.
02:09Here again, government asked for 15 years.
02:12He got less than half that, most of it probation.
02:15So here's what I'm driving towards, Mr. Kempemore Sanchez.
02:19If you are confirmed to this position,
02:22how will you weigh punishment as a factor
02:26when you are sentencing criminals like this?
02:29So that we get people like this off the streets,
02:31but keep them off the streets,
02:32so that kids in the district can play basketball in the day
02:35and not be shot at indiscriminately.
02:37Tell me how you would approach your job when it comes to sentencing.
02:42So, Senator, the D.C. code provides the three main pillars
02:47of what a judge has to look at before a sentence is imposed.
02:50And one of those certainly includes the seriousness of the offense
02:54and the impact on the community that has been had as a result of that crime.
02:58So, obviously, I'm going to take that very seriously into account
03:01and fashioning an appropriate sentence.
03:03Where does rehabilitation fit into that?
03:05That is the third, actually, pillar of what the D.C. code requires.
03:10And it's that a sentence be fashioned so that there is a potential for rehabilitation.
03:17Are you willing to forge a sentence,
03:21to fashion a sentence that would meet out appropriate punishment,
03:24even if there's not a rehabilitative purpose in your judgment?
03:28Obviously, I need the facts, and I will follow the law.
03:32But I will make sure to enforce the safety
03:35and impose a sentence that reflects the seriousness of the crime that has been committed.
03:42Judge Glover, let me ask you that same question, just that last question.
03:45As you're weighing the factors, if you've got a fact pattern where you may say,
03:51I don't know how much rehabilitation will be accomplished here,
03:54but there's definitely an opportunity for punishment, for retributive justice,
04:00as in this case with this young boy who was shot, how do you weigh it?
04:04What would you do?
04:04Thank you, Senator. I apologize.
04:07Again, I join in what my colleague referenced, my fellow nominee referenced,
04:12but I also would add that I'd obviously have to view this matter specifically,
04:18but I would obviously forge a, craft a sentence that has both general
04:25and specific determinative effects,
04:28whereas it would serve as a deterrent for the individual that is being sentenced
04:33and as a deterrent for the general public
04:36that this type of behavior would be inappropriate.
04:38Yeah, let me ask it maybe this way.
04:41What's more important?
04:42Is it more important to rehabilitate the offender,
04:44or is it more important to keep young boys like the one who was shot here safe?
04:48If you've got to choose, and you're going to have to choose,
04:50and that's your job, and you're doing it now,
04:52if you have to choose, if you've got to weigh those factors,
04:55which do you weigh more heavily?
04:58Senator, I am statutory obligated to consider all factors,
05:02but community safety is always paramount in my mind.
05:05Good.
05:05Let me just, this will be my last question, Mr. Chairman.
05:08Let me just ask the two remaining nominees.
05:09Same question.
05:11You've got to weigh keeping the public safe versus rehabilitation.
05:15Which one is going to take priority?
05:16I understand you've got to weigh them both.
05:17It's fine.
05:17You're obligated to do so.
05:19But which one's going to take priority when you're inbound equipoise?
05:22So I have three kids in D.C.
05:23I'll take the Metro's buses.
05:24For me, if I have to weigh everything, more important to be on the side
05:27of keeping my kids and anybody else safe.
05:29Very good.
05:31Same answer, Senator.
05:32Very good.
05:33I'll have more questions for all of you for the record.
05:34Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
05:37Subscribe to One India and never miss an update.
05:42Download the One India app now.

Recommended