- 3 years ago
#ChairmanPTI #ToshakhanaCase #SalmanAkramRaja #JahangirJadoon #SawalYehHai
(Current Affairs)
Host:
- Maria Memon
Guests:
- Salman Akram Raja (Lawyer)
- Jahangir Khan Jadoon (Lawyer)
- Ahmed Bilal Mehboob (CEO - PILDAT)
- Hamid Mir (Analyst)
Legal Expert Salman Akram Raja speaks up on Chairman PTI's arrest in Toshakhana Case
Can an appeal be submitted against PTI Chief's arrest?
(Current Affairs)
Host:
- Maria Memon
Guests:
- Salman Akram Raja (Lawyer)
- Jahangir Khan Jadoon (Lawyer)
- Ahmed Bilal Mehboob (CEO - PILDAT)
- Hamid Mir (Analyst)
Legal Expert Salman Akram Raja speaks up on Chairman PTI's arrest in Toshakhana Case
Can an appeal be submitted against PTI Chief's arrest?
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 Asalam o alikum, program sewale ke saath main hui maria meywan, aaj ki top stories hai.
00:09 Ek aur Wazir-e-Azam, na ahli ki nazar, Tehreek-e-Insaaf ke chairman, sabik chairman agar hum kahen
00:14 kuch din ho baad ho jayenge toh galat na hoga.
00:16 Unko ab atak jail pohncha diya gaya hai, badi major development hai, jo aage siyasi manzar
00:21 nama hai uske upar asan nadaaz hogi.
00:23 Program ke pehle SMS pe baat karenge uske baad.
00:25 Mardam Shumari kya ek neya aayini aur siyasi boraan khada hone jaa raha hai, digital mardam
00:30 shumari ki manzoori ke baad ab election mein taakhir har lehaas se mumkin nazar aa rahi
00:35 hai.
00:36 Program ke doosra SMS pe baat hoga.
00:37 Iske baad Pembra ordinance, committee ke supurdh sahafiyon ke tahafuzat hain, aaj sune gaye
00:42 hain.
00:43 Let's see ke iss hawale se jo misinformation, disinformation ki khaas taur pe censorship
00:47 ke arena mein jaane ke khadshat hain, usko hukumat kis tariqat se address karte hai.
00:51 Program ke aakhari SMS pe baat hoga, lekin aagaaz karte hain.
00:53 Aaj district and session ne Pakistan tariqat insaaf ke sarbara Imran Khan sahab ko teen
00:58 saal ke liye kaid suna di, iske alaawa paan saal ke liye naahil kar diya.
01:03 Tosha khana reference yeh case tha, aaj yeh faisla saamne aaya, uske baad humne badi hi
01:08 kuch anokhi cheezein bhi dekhi, lekin sabse pehle agar hum faisle ke upar nazar daal lein
01:12 to hum dekhte hain ke uske andar corrupt practices ka murtaraar diya hai tariqat insaaf ke chairman
01:17 ko.
01:18 Chairman PTI ke khilaf Tosha khana faujdaari karwaai case ka tehriri faisla jaari ho chuka
01:22 hai, teen saal kaid, ek laag jurmana aur paan saal naahili ki sazaa suna di gayi hai.
01:27 Shikait kunanda mulzim ke khilaf musaddika shabahit pesh karne mein kaamiyaab raha.
01:31 Shabahit ki nazar mein mulzim ke khilaf ilzamaat saabit hote hain.
01:35 Chairman PTI ne Tosha khana se hasal kiye gaye tahay se mutaalik malumat mein dhokhe baazi
01:40 se kaam liya.
01:41 Chairman PTI ne 2018 se 2020 ke duran asaason ki jhooti tafseelat jamaa karain faisle ke
01:46 mataabik.
01:47 5 Mai aur 8 Julai ko kaable samaat hone ke liye deye gaye dalayal par durkhas mustard
01:52 ki jati hai.
01:53 Additional Session Judge Humayun Dilawar ne yeh faisla jaari kiya aur case se mutaalik
01:57 tafseeli faisla takreban 30 safaat par mushtamil hai.
02:00 Iske andar jo 2-3 aise nukaat hai junki upar technical hi sawalat uthe jaa sakte hain because
02:04 obviously Tehreek-e-Insaaf ne announce kiya hai, Shah Mahmood Qureshi saab ne aake ke
02:07 isko challenge karne jaa rahe hain.
02:09 Kya conviction stay karegi lekin jo naahili hai wo khatam karane ke yahan pe mumkinat
02:14 hai yeh saare sawalat hai ki kya agar unki qaid khatam ho jati hai lekin naahili barkaraar
02:19 rakti hai to usko reverse karne ki koi mumkinat hai.
02:22 Bohot saare technical sawalat aur kuch petitions PTI ki almost agle hafte lagne wale thi Islamabad
02:27 High Court mein uske upar bhi sawalat hai ki kya unki ab kya status hoga.
02:32 So aise bohot saare kanuni technical sawalat humare saath hai.
02:34 Jahangir Jadoon sahab, Mahir-e-Kanun Islamabad studio mein hai, Baris Maan Akram Raja sahab
02:38 humare saath maujood hai.
02:39 Lekin ek jo sawal jiske upar aaj Tehreek-e-Insaaf ke lawyers argue bhi kar rahe the ki ji jo is
02:43 case mein kaah gaya hai, is faisla ke andar kaah gaya hai ki Islamabad High Court ne
02:46 kaable samaat hone ke point par Judge Humayun Dilawar ke do faisla hai, yaani ki 5 Mai aur
02:51 jo 8 Mai ka faisla hai usko kalardam karar diya tha.
02:54 Lekin ab bhi is faisla mein dubara likha gaya hai ki 5 Mai aur 8 Julai ke faisla mein di
02:58 gayi wajuhat ki binapari darkhas thisi dafa bhi khaaraj ki jaati hai.
03:02 To usse pehle humne dekha tha ki yeh case do martaba wapas bhej diya gaya tha aur ek
03:08 martaba yeh 5 Mai ko aur ek dafa yeh 8 Julai ko hua tha.
03:11 So yeh sawal bhi technically uthaya jaata hai.
03:14 Lekin zayir si baat hai is poore case ka ek siyasi ansar bhi hai.
03:16 Pakistan ke andar jo Wazir-e-Azam hain humesha ghariftaar hote raha hai aur agar hum 2008
03:20 se dekhen to shayad ek Raja Parvez Ashraf sahab hi aise Wazir-e-Azam hain gaali man jo ghariftaar
03:27 na huya ho.
03:28 Jahangir Jadoon sahab se baat karenge, Baisar Salman Akhirur Raja sahab se baat karenge.
03:32 Raja sahab aap se aagaz karte sir, aaj kis faisla ke upar pehle aapke initial comments
03:35 kyunke PTS ko challenge to karne jaa rahi hai.
03:42 Jis tariqah se yeh faisla aaya aaya aur phir uspe implementation bhi badi bhoota hua.
03:45 12.40 pe faisla aata hai, 1 baje intizami harkat mein aajaat hai, 1.15 baje election
03:50 commission harkat mein aajaat hai, ghariftaar kar ke aatak jail poncha bhi diya jaata hai.
03:54 Is faisla pe aapke initial radhe amal kya?
03:57 Lekin mazar ka khiz faisla hai.
04:00 Main poori aapko ghar janikdaari se yeh raay de raha hu.
04:03 Aur yeh bilkul waze hai baat ke yeh tamaam mansooba pehle se tyaar tha, har idaari ko
04:07 pata tha, kab kitne wajah faisla aana hai, kya wo faisla hoga aur uspe kya karna hai.
04:12 Dekhiyen faisla hai kya yeh samjhna bohot zaruri hai.
04:15 Yeh faisla sirf teen saalon ke hawaale se hai.
04:18 2018, 2019, 2020 aur 2021.
04:21 Aur yaha yeh baat bohot aaham hai saamne rakhna, ki teen August ko Islamabad High Court ne
04:27 yeh kaha, ki jo gawaakh pesh karne ki stada hai Imran Khan saab ki, uspe jo gauhar hai
04:33 wo agli hafte hoga, Election Commission ko notice jaari kiya.
04:36 Dekhin ussi din, teen August ko, Islamabad High Court ne Trial Court ko yeh kaha ki
04:41 aap faisla kar dijiye, yaani chaar August ko jo date, Trial Court me thi niche, National
04:46 District Session Judge sahab ke paas, unhe kaha gaya ki aap faisla kar dege iska.
04:50 Yeh kajeeb aur ghareeb soorat-e-haal hai, ki ek taraf High Court abhi yeh faisla karne
04:55 baitha hai, ki gawaahan ki ijazat deni hai, mulzim ko ya nahi deni.
04:59 Aur yeh bhi ek anokhi soorat-e-haal hai, ki mulzim ko gawaah pesh karne ki ijazat nahi
05:04 di jaari.
05:05 Aur Islamabad High Court kahte hai, is baamle ko bhi hum dekhenge agli hafte.
05:08 Aur saath hi Trial Court ko kahte hai, ki tum faisla kar do.
05:11 Aur Trial Court faisla kar dete hai, bghar gawaahan ke.
05:14 Aur faisla kya karte hai?
05:16 Dekhin faisla sirf yeh hai, ki 2018, 2019 me Imran Khan saab ne kaha, ki maine 21 million
05:22 rupee cables, kuch tohfe kharide the, jinn mein wo ghari bhi shamil hai, jo bahut mashoor
05:26 rahi.
05:27 Aur wo maine 5 crore 80 lakh ke bech diye.
05:30 Aur jo rakam thi, wo sawal poocha gaya, ki wo rakam kaha hai, unhone kaha, ki jo uspe
05:35 mujhe munafa hua, 21 million aur 58 million, wo maine Bank Al-Falah me jamaah kara diya.
05:41 Judge saab yeh kahte hai, ki humne Bank Al-Falah me account ki jo statement hai, wo dekhi hai,
05:46 usme hume 58 million ka koi figure nazar nahi aaya, bhihaaza yeh ghalat beyaani hui
05:50 hai.
05:51 Aur humne saab dekhi hai, ki humne munafa jamaah karaya hai, baaki maamla, humne income
05:55 tax goshwari dekh liye, cash in hand, ek cheez hoti hai, unhone Al-Falah bank ke hawale se
06:00 sirf munafa ka kaha tha, yeh nahi kaha tha, ki 58 million jamaah karaya hai.
06:05 Aur yeh statement, unke jo section 342 ka beyaan hai, wo bhi maine padha hai, usme bilkul
06:10 wazaahat se mauchood hai.
06:11 Ek toh yeh ground banaya gaya, 2018, 2019 ke liye.
06:14 Phir 1920 pe aajaeyen, 1920 ke liye, unhe yeh kahte hain, ki unhone 3 ya 4 tahaif yeh
06:22 kahte hain, ki is saal ke dauran maine liye, aur isi saal ke dauran maine unko aagey muntakil
06:26 kar diya, kisi ko de diya.
06:28 Lekin unhone un tahaif ki tafseel jo hai, jo form B 2019-20 ka hai, usme zahir nahi ki.
06:36 Iska jawab yeh hai, ya jawab yeh diya, unhone apne 342 ki statement mein, ki mujhe mere
06:42 wakala aur financial advisors ne yeh bataya tha, ki jo 30 June ko asaasey hotey hain, unka
06:47 izhaar karna hotey, chunki 30 June ko yeh asaasey mere paas nahi the, aur bhi choti rakam ki
06:53 tohfey hain, liyaaza maine unka izhaar mere consultants ne nahi kiya, aap unko aane de
06:57in, gawa ke taur pe wo aake samjha denge, ki unhone kyu nahi kiya, is dauran jo rakam
07:02 musool hui, wo sab disclosed hai, liyaaza in asaaseyon ka disclose na hona, 30 June
07:08 ko koi maani nahi rakta aur mere gawaan jo hain, wo aake bata denge, khair judge sahab
07:13 kehte hai nahi, main gawaan toh aap peshi nahi dunga, jo aapke tax consultant the,
07:17 ya financial advisor the, unko main ijazat nahi deta pesh hone ki, aur saath hi yeh
07:22 keh rahe hain, ki usk goshware mein, jo tehreer ki gayi hai, wo theek nahi hai, dekin agar
07:27 koi samjhana chahata hai, ki jee yeh kyu nahi isme diya gaya, toh usko aane se unhone
07:31 rokhtiya, yeh surte haal hai, phir aajaeyen, 2020-21 pe wo yeh kahte hain, ki unhone yeh
07:39 kaha, ki precious items hain mere paas itni maaliyat ki, inhe unki tafseerat deni chahiye
07:44 thi, aur jewellery ka jo khaana hai, usme arayda se batana chahiye tha, ki jewellery
07:48 kitni hai, aur baaki cheezin kitni hai, ab yeh kya corruption hai, wo kahte hai,
07:52 maine precious items hai, usme maine beyan kar diya, ki mere paas precious items,
07:57 kis lagat ki hai, usko wo kahte hai, ki chunki tafseel nahi di, isliye yeh corruption
08:02 hai, toh yeh ek muzaqqa khiz faisla hai, jahan aapne munzim ko gawa peshne karne diye.
08:08 Yeh jo gawa na pesh karne wali baat hai na, jo Jadoon sahab maaise studio mein maujood
08:12 hai, main shaam ko bhi aapka maukaf sun rahi thi, aapka maukaf se sawale se yeh tha,
08:16 ki case meh dum hai, case strong hai, lekin procedurally, bohot chahari cheezon ko,
08:21 chunki overlook kiya gaya hai, toh appeal mein jaake iska faida, Tariq Insaaf ko ho
08:25 sakta hai.
08:27 Sir yeh unka, main Jadoon sahab se poochin hoon ki unka case hai.
08:30 Dekhiye merits me bhi bhai toh arus karna hoon ki koi case nahi banta hai, lekin isme
08:34 faash ghaliti ki gayi hai, Islamabad High Court abhi betha waahe hai, agle hafte ka notice
08:39 hai, unne abhi isbaat ko...
08:40 Sir aap keh rahe hai ki procedurally bhi masla hai aur case me bhi dum nahi hai, lekin
08:44 Jadoon sahab ko thoda different point of view hai usme, zarab wo bhi sun letein.
08:47 Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim, bohot shukriya, dekhiye yeh case jo tha, basically election
08:51 commission me file kiya gaya, unhone request yeh ki thi ki bus at one F in pe laga ke
08:55 toh disqualify karein for life.
08:57 Toh election commission ne unke wakalaat ko moka diya, waha pe argument hua, toh wo
09:01 is natijiye ponche ke unka case bus at one F ka nahi banta, yeh case corrupt practices
09:06 ka hai, unhone concealment of the item, jo bhi statement ke nahi conceal ki hai, age
09:11 phir unhe ek session court ko bhejaaye ki aap isko mazeed jaanch padtaal karein, kyunki
09:15 criminals had ka case unhone banaaya hai.
09:17 Ab criminal me yeh hota hai ki prosecution ko saabd karna padta hai ki jee yeh cheeze
09:20 hain ya nahi hain, koi doubt nahi hona chahiye, kyunki aap ek bandik ko penalize karein, conviction
09:25 de rahein.
09:26 Ab usme yeh case gaya hai November 2022 mein, yeh summary trial hota hai, isme Rajat sahab
09:30 yeh cheeze ikhtifa karenge, lamba nahi chalta hai, yeh koi murder case nahi hai ki do saal
09:34 chalega.
09:35 Ab pehle PTI walo ne is case ko serious hi nahi liya, unhone ka khair chala denge, aur yeh
09:39 charge frame nahi unhe de rahe the, unhone ne court ke saath koi taawan nahi kiya, mutaddad
09:43 moka diya gaye, phir ek judge sahab beez mein transfer ho gaye, phir dusri judge sahab
09:46 bhi, phir jab Imran Khanna rest ho gaye, toh phir unpe usfakat charge frame ho hai.
09:50 Ab ek ladda controversy hai, ke wahan pe kis tarah charge frame ho hai, lekar agar wo
09:53 rest nahi hote, toh ho sakta hai abhi tak charge hi nahi frame hota hai.
09:55 Yeh usko chale nahi de rahe the, yeh baat record ki main kaha rahe ho.
09:58 Yeh saare, munzum, aar tarikh mein nahi pesh hota hai, yeh teen dafa pesh ho hai saare case
10:02 mein, wo badi mushkal se.
10:03 Yeh toh ek facts ki baat hai.
10:05 Ab jab aakhar mein, judge sahab ne ka jee, main day to day proceeding karunga.
10:09 Phir inhone yeh samjhaya hai, yeh toh kaam abhi serious ho raha hai, humein toh koi karna
10:14 chahiye.
10:15 Inhone teen grounds se technically wo liye hai, ek toh jee yeh limitation is case mein
10:18 section 134 ki sab class 4 hai, usmein ne kaha hai, 120 days ke andar aap file karein.
10:22 Ho sakta hai ismein jaan ho inke case mein.
10:24 Ab doosra unhone ne kaha hai, yeh authorization jo hai na, wo jo likha ho hai, wo commission
10:28 authorize karta hai kisi bande ko.
10:30 Toh secretary election commission jo hai, wo nahi kar sakta hai.
10:32 Lafaz waqay, wahan pe commission hi likha hoa hai.
10:34 Wo teesra unhone kaha hai, technicality is basically, technicality.
10:37 Teesra unhone kaha hai, jurisdiction, jo aap kisi complaint ke andar criminal trial karte
10:41 hai, toh moomin magistrate ke paas astagasa pesh hota hai.
10:44 Toh astagasa ke baad jo hai, phir wo summary cursory statement record karne ke baad phir
10:48 aage, session court ka agar case ho toh usko refer karte hai.
10:50 Yeh teen unhone ke basically points hai, technically.
10:52 Ab merit pe unhone ne, toh udhar toh court mein ko aisi baat nahi, unhone yeh admit ki
10:56 hai, ki jee humne iske detail of the assets jo hai, wo nahi di.
10:59 Ab yeh ke aapgar saal ke andar, 30 June ke andar, uske yeh toh ke 30 December tak aapne
11:03 asset, ki jee humne yeh dispose of kar di asset.
11:06 Lekar unhone kaha hai, yeh me dispose of ki, unke liye zaruri nahi hai, ki me detail do.
11:10 Toh ismein, meri opinion hai, ki unhone ne merit pe case ko liya hi nahi hai.
11:14 Unhone technicalities pe liya hai.
11:16 Phir jab judge sahab ka aakhar mein yeh hua hai, unhone 5, jo aaj August ta unhone ka last
11:21 working day tha, summer vacation hai, chhutki ho rahi hai.
11:24 Toh unhone jaldbazi ke halein, ya jaldi mein ke halein, yeh is cheez mein bada wazan hai,
11:28 legally.
11:29 Aap agar High Court ke andar yeh case pending hai, ya High Court ke judge ko bhi waise,
11:33 unhone ne pata, unhone ne yeh bhi order kar di hai, ke aap final argument jo hai, wo ja
11:38 ke deyen aur sunen.
11:39 Unhone ne phir yeh final order, jo faisla tha, isko bhi nahi roka.
11:42 Ke aap final argument de rahe hain, toh final faisla na karein.
11:44 So aapke nazi ke jaldbazi ke andar kya procedural cheeze overlook hui hai, kyu khaas taur pe
11:48 PTI ke kuch petitions akle hafte bhi, chun jismein gawaahon ko sabzi kar liye.
11:51 Yeh iske andar, yeh sabse badi important jo cheeze hai na, agar aap, dikhein, kisi bande
11:55 ki evidence ko discord kar deyen.
11:57 Usko record pe lalane deyena, chalein wo relevancy nahi banti, toh aap usko record pe leke aate
12:02 hai, ki these are the facts, aur yeh evidence toh hai, iske saath koi linkage nahi hai,
12:06 koi iske saath is case ka talak nahi, bhi waasta nahi banta.
12:09 Yeh reasons hai, is waise se me iske evidence ko discord bata.
12:12 So yeh appeal level me jaag kar aapko lagta hai, ki yeh strong argument hoga hai?
12:15 Yeh dekhein na, agar, primarily aap dekhein, constitutionally dekhein, article 10A ka jo
12:19 takaza hota hai, chahe aapne conviction deni hai, acquittal karni hai, lekin aap ek bande
12:24 ko fair trial ka right, usko fundamental right hai, koi bhi banda ho.
12:27 Agar adalat yeh samti hai, I-Court, constitutional direction mein, yeh criminal reviewer ke andar
12:31 yeh samti hai, ki is trial ke andar, fundamental rights ho hai, article 10A ko violated ki
12:36 gaye, toh phir usme yeh faisla de sakte hai, ki inka trial jo hai.
12:39 Kyunki already I-Court ke andar yeh wali application, agar dispose aap karte hai na, toh situation
12:42 different hoti hai.
12:43 Toh ne ka aaji, agle hafte ke liye notice hai, ki aapne yeh evidence, yeh hi hota hai,
12:47 ke case remand ho jata hai, ki ji, inki evidence hai, yeh record karein, aur phir faisla karein.
12:50 Lekin ispe ek aur issue bhi hai, jo khas tohar pe social media, Facebook, post ke hawale se,
12:54 kal ke Islamabad I-Court ke faisla mein, toh ne ka hai, ki report bana kar, 15 din me batai
12:58 audit kara ke, ki yeh, inki kya status hai, kya yeh theek hai, yeh ghalat hai, yeh ghalat
13:02 banaya toh, jisne banaya hai, usko, toh wo cheez bhi toh abhi saamne manjarein aapne ke,
13:07 wo asur andaas hogi?
13:09 Ji, FIA ko yeh ka tha, yeh kehte hain, ki judge sahab ke post lagi hoon, yeh unki Facebook
13:14 hai, aur aapki report kuch aur kahi rahi hai.
13:16 Toh is wahi se, ke ek aap court ke liye badnaami ka sabab hi banta hai, ke agar unki post nahi
13:20 thi, toh un par allegation kyu lagi hai yeh?
13:23 Ya agar unki post thi, toh bhi uska kya consequences hai?
13:25 Lekin woh tehkikat ki report toh 15 din baad aani, usse pehle faisla aa jaye, toh bhi baad
13:29 mein aap takht hai, ki koi complications aayenge kaanooni taur pe, appeal ke level pe, woh
13:32 jaa sakti hai, report hi?
13:33 Woh toh aap is tarah le sakte hain, ke aap bias ka ansar jo hai na, woh toh judge sahab
13:36 ne usko totally ignore kar di, unki application di hai, ke yeh aap case na sune, ek yeh isme
13:51 technical yeh bhi point tha, ke jab inki kal transfer application hai, toh woh jo section
13:56 5 to 6 hai, sub section 8 hai, usme hi hota hai, ke agar aapki transfer application pending
13:59 ho, toh final decision jo hai, woh nahi diya jata.
14:01 Toh kal unka woh jo cheez thi, woh khatam ho gayi, kyunki unki transfer application sari
14:04 kar rahi hain, woh cooperate nahi kar rahi hain.
14:06 So jo agle hafte appeale lagi bhi thi Islamabad High Court mein, ab kya woh unki koi value
14:10 nahi rahi hai, ab chunki faisla aaj aagaya hai, woh dubara take up ho sakti hai, unko
14:13 bhi?
14:14 Nahi, woh toh dikhen, jis ground pe unhone le thi, woh toh evidence toh discord hai, evidence
14:18 toh nahi record ho jaha, woh unhone kha, 12.30 pe aap guwa le aaye, meni kaha hai na, pehle
14:22 PTI wale cooperate nahi kar rahi the, jab unhone dekha hai, judge sahab ho gaye hai,
14:26 tyaar, ab yeh case ka faisla karne jate hain, aap phir yeh jo hai.
14:29 So jo agar gawa paesh karne diye jate hai, toh zahir saab.
14:32 Mera hamne betar hota hai, usmein kyunki fair trial ka phir unpe yeh na, objection hota
14:36 hai, ki aap jo hai, humein gawa ka, chahe gawa relevant their ya nahi thei, mere me
14:40 zaati opinion hai, legal opinion hai, unko record ka hissa zarur dola hai.
14:43 Jadul sahab mein dekha hai, 12.30 ke karee faisla aata hai, 12.45 karee implementation
14:47 shuru ho jati hai, woh Lahore se ghariftaar ho ke, election commission ke, woh sare, jaise
14:52 sare, jo purze thei, woh tayyaar thei, bas ek, yeh toh phir aapko bataye, yeh bisi
14:56 common practice hai waise, aap chuke karn hote hai.
14:59 Nahi nahi, common practice nahi hoti hai, kabhi bhi jati hai, kitne dee lagti hai, order
15:01 jaane mein, jaake pata karne mein, ghariftaari mein.
15:03 Yeh toh pass ke thane ke paas jaana pade toh, mere hal mein 10 din, 2-4 din toh lazmi lagte
15:07 hai, itna, main ne kaana hai, woh jaij sahab saari cheezein thei, unhone aaj jaana tha,
15:11 unhone yeh judgement deke jaani thei, isse woh koi chance nahi tha, jo bhi baat hoti
15:15 ho, unhone judgment aa, aaj unhone determine kiya ho, toh mene deke jaani thei.
15:18 Yeh bhi ek question uthta hai, ke bhai aapne chutkiyon pe jaana hai, toh chutkiyon baat
15:23 case rak le na, yeh 2 aftak ke baat, aap jo hai, woh chutkiyon, ek aftak ke baat kar le,
15:27 paans ke bhaja, ya 13 se chutki chale jaaen, ab zaruri the nahi hai, ke bharal.
15:31 Bharal, jaise aap keh rahe hai, ke case tagda hai, lekin procedural maamlaat ki wajah se
15:34 ab jo hai, isme...
15:35 Mere ek swaal isli uthke hai na, ke ek jaij sahab ne, both, matlab aakhar mein aakhe,
15:39 case waise toh both isme 40 dekho peshe ho hi hai, inhone pehle cooperate nahi kiya, yeh
15:43 2, inki side bhi yeh nahi kaisakte hai, ki hum bilkul beguna hai, wo case humare upar
15:47 thhoopa gaya hai, aur humne court ke saath taawan ke hai, chahe aapka case nahi bantata
15:50 tha, toh ab tak toh yeh case Supreme Court se bhi faisla ho jata, iska summary teller
15:53 ho tha, aap November, December, January tak agar yeh jaij sahab faisla de jate hai, yeh
15:57 anse pehle jo jaij the, jo transfer ho gaye, wo dete hai, toh aap High Court me jaate,
16:00 appeal ab tak...
16:01 Sir, wo transfer bhi badi, bahut hi zyada uske hawale se bhi badi...
16:04 Matlab, inki aapka maja se bhi case de rahe hai na...
16:07 Jai, jai, kuchh sehar ke log, ifar zaalish ke toh humein marne ka saum bhi thi, yeh bilkul
16:10 kaafi, isme, poora hota tha, Salman sahab, aaj ek aur development hui hai, sir, yeh
16:15 Council of Common Interest ne, finally, Digital Madan Chumari yeh uske manzoori de di hai, aur
16:21 ab jo hai, 120 din uske upar honge, phir kuch election ki, uske baad surat-e-haal banegi,
16:28 ab ek naya aayini crisis toh saamne nahi khada, chaar maheene baad humare...
16:33 Dekhi, yeh hi toh khaish hai, suba saazon ki, ke ek aayini bohraan ki surat rahe, aur election
16:39 na karane pade, maqsat toh sirf election se bhaagna hai, warna yeh census jo hai, aaj se
16:44 chaar meene pehle bhi notify ho sakta tha, uske baad agar halka bandiya honi thi, toh
16:48 ho jaati, dekhi ab ek aur surat-e-haal hai na, dekhi ab yeh kaha jaa raha hai, ke aayini
16:53 kaameem ke baghar, aap subo mein jo nishastein hain, unmein izafa aur kami kar denge, Balochistan
16:59 ki bar jayenge, Punjab ki aat kam ho jayenge, aur yeh jo Council of Common Interest hai,
17:04 yeh kya hai? Isme toh do ghar muntakhab Wazir-e-Aala the, jinka kaam sirf aur sirf election karana
17:09 hota hai, is nauyat ke maamlaat mein manzoori dena, unke faraiz mein shamili nahi hai.
17:14 Toh yeh bilkul yeh, mukamal taur pe ab Pakistan jo hai, ek ghar aayini khaai mein gir chuka
17:19 hai, hum har kaam aayin ke bar khilaf kar rahi hai, Council of Common Interest, bilkul
17:24 ek khukli council humne kaim kar di hai, election na kara ke navye din mein. Ab yeh council
17:30 kuch keh deti hai, uske baad mukadme chale jaate hain, adalaton mein, toh unka kaam ho
17:34 gaya, mansuba saazon ka, ki election nahi ho paayenge, navye din mein, ya saakht din
17:38 mein, jo aayin ka takaza hai, wo chahate hi yeh hai, ke aayin ke takaze poore na ho,
17:42 yeh maamla latka rahe, fir census ke upar objection aa jayenge, koi waha pe, koi ek
17:47 fariq, kya doosra fariq, koi jamaat, wo census pe itraaz karegi, uske upar appeal der appeal
17:52 jalti regi, toh yeh toh jo mansuba hai, yeh teen chaar, chhe mahine ke iltawaaka nahi
17:57 hai, yeh lambe iltawaaka laga. Lambe iltawaaka laga, jeetung sahab aapko kya lag raha hai,
18:00 kyunki yeh jo caretaker CM wali baat hai, toh technically, legally, humari baat Ahmed
18:04 Bilal Mahboob sahab se bhi, unhone bhi kaha, ki toh challenge bhi kar sakta hai, koi iske.
18:08 Yeh main Rai sahab se ittifaq kartu hun ki, chief ministers are not constitutionally
18:12 elected chief ministers. Toh kise ho gaya sir? Yeh common of, common, jo interest ki
18:17 composition hai, yeh constitutionally defective hai. Do CM jo hai na, wo kis tarah population
18:22 ko represent kar sakte hai, they are not elected. Chief minister ke, jo prime minister ke definition
18:26 hai constitution ke andar, wo elected chief minister ki hai. Aur inke jo akhtaraat hai,
18:29 wo specify ki jayenge. Yeh toh policy decision dehi nahi sakta hai, elected chief. Nikhar
18:33 un meetings me chief secretary baitha hai aur CM na baitha hai, toh phir hiye ho sakta
18:36 hai? Nahi, nahi, wo chief secretary baitha nahi, toh composition jo hai na, wo three
18:39 chief ministers, four chief ministers, prime minister, minister planning hai, minister
18:43 railway hai, uski composition bani hui hai. Aur iska yeh ke, dekho na, ek Punjab bohot
18:47 bada subah hai, uski population hai, sixty, seventy percent of the Pakistan hai. Uska
18:50 ek jo chief minister hai, wo constitutionally defective hai, wo kis tarah common of, common,
18:54 council of common interest me kaise. Toh yeh toh koi bhi challenge kar sakta hai. I think
18:58 somebody go to the Supreme Court and challenge it, ke jee yeh jo constitutionally defective
19:02 composition hai, council of common interest ki. Aur phir isme council of common interest
19:05 me agar decision de diya hai, toh phir aap election toh uske consensus jo last weh, uske
19:09 article fifty-one hai, uske matlabak toh ho nahi sakte. Phir agar aap seating badhate
19:13 hai, aur kam karte hai, toh phir bhi article fifty-one ke andar, aapko amendment karne
19:17 bhi election nahi ho sakte. Toh yeh agar inka yeh koi back end pe mujhe nahi pata, yeh
19:21 delay karne chahate hai, toh phir toh definitely sir, as sab ne kaha hai, agar yeh hoga toh
19:25 phir chances hai ke election delay ho jayenge. Ek aur kanuni, ek aur ayni boran ki taraf
19:28 hum badh rahe hain. Bahut shukri aap dono azaraat ka. Jate jate chunki is poore, hum
19:33 ne legal aspect pe toh baat ki, siyasi aspect pe. Is mulke andar sabiq wuzurah-e-azam misha
19:37 gireftar hote rahe hain. Hum aapko zarar quickly dikhana chahate hain, taariq ke jhroko me,
19:41 Hussain Shaheed Sarwardi sahab, nineteen sixty-two, Dawn akhbar ki yeh khabar, unko gireftar
19:45 kar liya gaya tha, aur uspe kaha gaya tha, ke wo anti-Pakistan activities me unho indulge
19:49 kiya. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto sahab ki, hatkadiyon wali tasveer, hum sab ne bahut martaba,
19:53 aapne bachpan se lekar aaj tak dekhi hai, yeh ek bada iconic image hai, yeh aapko dubara
19:57 dikhata hain. Benazir Bhutto sahiba gireftar hui thi, house arrest hui thi, yeh bhi bahut
20:01 zyada iconic image hai, yeh aap dekh sakte hain apne screen ke upar. Nawaz Sharif sahab
20:04 pehle nineteen ninety-nine me gireftar hote hain, phir two-zahar-atara ke andar wo dubara
20:08 gireftar hote hain, jahas ke antar se utarte hain, toh ek sabiq wazir-e-azam ko hatkadiyon
20:11 lagayi jati hain. Uske baad hum dekhte hain, Shahid Khan Abbasi sahab jo ke kuch waqt
20:15 ke liye wazir-e-azam the, unko bhi gireftari ka saamna karna padta hai, wo bhi jate hain
20:21 zandaan ke peechhe aur Pakistan Tariq-e-Insaf ke sabir Imran Khan sahab jo hain aaj unko
20:25 bhi gireftar kar liya gaya. Yaha tak toh us mulke andar agar koi ek created post ho jisme
20:30 wo vice prime minister ho, toh usko bhi jail ki hawa khaani padti hai, jaise ke Parvez
20:36 Elahi sahab. Break pe jaayenge, jab wapas aayenge toh Council of Common Interest ke hawale
20:40 se baat karenge, yeh jo announcement hui hain, isme ayani, kanuni aur bahut saare jo
20:44 na, usme baat karenge, break ke baad tumhare saath hai.
20:46 Welcome back, aaj ke badi khabar, Mushtarkha Mufat Aad Council ne Digital Mardam Shomari
20:51 ki aaj manzoori de diye, bahut hi important development isliye hai, kyunki election hone
20:56 ki jo timeline hai, is ailaan ke baad wo mukamal taur par ab badal badal jaayegi. Jo nai
21:02 Idara Shomariyaat ki findings aayi hain, wo badi khosh ruba hain, jitne tezi se Pakistan
21:07 ki abadi badh rahi hai, yeh ek alaida lama fikriya hai, lekin ab hume bataya gaya hai,
21:11 jo aaj announce kiya gaya hai, ke 24 crore ke karib jo hai, humaari abadi badh chuki
21:18 hai, aur abhi bhi badi tezi se isme izafa ho raha hai. Ab juke Digital Mardam Shomari
21:23 ko approve kar diya gaya hai, so isse jude bahut saare technical, legal, aur zahir si
21:28 baat hai, subsequently political sawal bhi uthte hain. Lekin pehlein aapko bataayein
21:33 ki, Mardam Shomari ke hawale se, siyasi Jamaaton ke nazaryaat, unke jo muwakaf hai,
21:38 badlte rahe hain. Aaj ki iss meeting ke andar sabhne unanimously vote kiya, jisme People's
21:43 Party ke CM bhi the, lekin iss se pehle People's Party ke kya itarazat rahe hain, sawale se
21:48 Bilawal Bhutto sahab ne, jo khas tohar pe kaha, ke jo tariqaikar hai, uske upar People's
21:52 Party ko itaraz hain, aur pehle Raza Rabbani sahab ne jo technicality point out ki, ki
21:57 kis tariqaise do caretaker CM jab baithe honge, toh uske jo nataiz hain usko baad mein challenge
22:01 kiya jaa skega, People's Party ki itarazat aapko sunwate hain.
22:05 Ab jab elections saamne nazar aarey hain, toh ussi waqt yeh ailaan hona, ki digital
22:11 census hoga, mein samjhta hu ki yeh hamara itarazat jo the, unka toh hal nahi hain. Aur
22:18 jis tariqaise aur jo feedback, hume mila hai iss digital census pe, Pakistan People's
22:24 Party ke, magar bahut se sube se taluk rakne wale awaam ke bhi itarazat hain. Iss kism
22:32 ka hum shortcut toh bilkul kabul nahi.
22:35 Is waqt jo CCI ki composition hai, us composition ki andar doh subon ke caretaker CM maujood
22:44 hain. Ab agar caretaker CMs baith ke census ke upar koi faisla lete hain, toh that will
22:51 affect the capacity of any, or the authority, the exercise of authority of the future elected
22:57 governments. The census is already disputed and it will become further disputed if the
23:04 caretakers take part in it and come to some decision.
23:08 Bade waze policy hai People's Party ki, aur technically Razar Abhayi saab ka sawal bilkul
23:12 durust hai ki caretaker CM kaise, kis mandate ki tahez udhar baith kar vote kar sakte hain.
23:16 People's Party ki jo ek position thi, ki jis tariqaise hi kiya gaya, usse controversy
23:20 badegi. Bahara lekin aaj unke CM ne udhar vote diya, iss digital mardam shumari ke haq
23:25 mein, aur bade consensus se yeh faisla hua. PMLN ke toh U-turns iss se bhi zyada zabadast
23:30 hai, bade kalabaziyaan khai hai. Kyunki jab KP aur Punjab ke elections ko aage karna
23:35 tha, toh uss waqt se woh kehte rahe hai, ki jab tak ki iss mardam shumari ke nitaayi
23:39 je nahi aate halka bandiya nahi hoti. Elections nahi hoti, aade mulke election kya purani
23:43 mardam shumari par, aur agle jo elections honge nahi mardam shumari pe honge aisa hota
23:47 nahi hai, aise jo mulke woh tarakki nahi karte. Badei lambi chaudi waha uss waqt ek
23:51 narrative adalat ke andar bhi, aur political arena mein bhi unhone liya. Lekin par hum
23:55 ne dekha, ki chand hafte pehle aise hi ek din Rana Sanaullah sahab ne kaha, ki iss mardam
24:01 shumari ke nitaayi jom notify nahi karna chaha hai. Aur uske baad humne ye bhi dekha,
24:05 ki Ahsan Iqbal sahab ne bhi yeh sawal aat uthaaye, ki yeh nahi mardam shumari ke upar
24:09 election hone ke waqt, yeh time nahi hai. So, 6 mahine ke andar, inhi election ke results
24:14 me kaise fark aata hai, aur mardam shumari conclude karna hai, yeh nahi karna hai,
24:19 isse upar PMLN ka kya U-turn hai? Zara aapko dikhaatein.
24:26 Jo agla general election hai, wo nahi mardam shumari ke antahat hoga.
24:31 Jab election ka waqt aana hai, August-September mein, National Assembly ka, toh wo census
24:39 mukamol ho chuke hu, balki usse pehle mukamol ho chuke hu, taake kahin usse taakhir na ho
24:46 seke.
24:47 Election ki ab taarikh hai, jo muddat hai, Assembly ki tahleel hone ke baad, toh usko
24:52 agar 4 mahine ke liye aap halka bandhi leh cover nahi kar sakte. Toh isliye ghalib imkaan
24:56 yeh hi hai, ki election commission ne iska aatmi faisla karna hai, lekin agar humne mukarrara
25:01 muddat me election karane hai, toh phir 2017 ki halka bandhi par hi election karane ho
25:07 gaye.
25:08 Hukummat ne yeh faisla kiya hai, ke wo isse notify nahi karegi, aur bas agni aapne muddat
25:13 poori karke resolve rongi, toh usse baad pe election commission paabhan hoga, ke wo
25:18 parhaane census ki bilaag ke liye halka bandhi leh ki reserve nahi bhi hai, tohre din,
25:23 kuch 6 maath pehle.
25:24 Nahi mardam chumari ke taht hi, election mein hume jaana hai.
25:28 So, election nahi mardam chumari ki mutaabik hoga, phir beech mein kahaan nahi hoga, aap
25:35 kehte hain usko mutaabik hoga, will the real PMLN please stand up, ke aapki actual, is
25:40 poore maamle ke andar ideological stance kya hai, kyunki badal ta raha hai guzashta 6
25:45 mahinon ke dauran. Ek aur aitaraaz, Fawad Chaudhary sahab ne aaj ek tweet ki, isme unhone
25:50 bataya, ke kis tariqe se unke poore zillai ki seats isme kam hone ka khadsha hai. Unka
25:55 aitaraaz hai, wo yeh hai, ki nahi mardam chumari Punjab ke siyasi hakook par daaka hai. Punjab
26:00 ki abadi itni kam hogi hai, ke QAAT nishiste kam hongi. Nahi tariqe kaat pe behas hui,
26:05 nahi nataayesh ki shafafiyat ka pata hai. Iske natije mein Jhelum aur Chakwal jaise azlaat
26:09 nishiske azlaa ban jayenge. Lahore aur Gujrawala ko bhi nishiste khoni padengi. Punjab ke siyasa
26:15 daano karwaaiyya mayuskun hai. Aur usko wo challenge karne ja rahe hain, unhone kaha.
26:18 Qamar Dilshad sahab aaj YRY News mein ek transmission pe the, unhone kaha, ab jo yeh nahi timeline
26:24 aaj government ne announce kar di hai, iske baad at least wo 15 Febri se pehle to election
26:29 hote hui, nahi dekh rahe hain. Kya kehna tha unka zara suni.
26:32 Takheeban 4 se 6 mehne aap yeh samjh lein ki Wasim Badami sahab ke 15 Febri se pehle tak
26:39 yeh harka bandiya ka jo hai saara marhala taya hona mushkil hai aur 15 Febri ke baad hi
26:44 fir election commission Pakistan intikhabi schedule jaari karne ka majaz hoga.
26:48 Kya mardum shumari ka bahana banaakar election ko delay karne ki tayyariyaan to nahi ki jaari
26:55 hai, ek bada aaham sawal hai aur yeh sawal hum nahi sirf utha rahe hai. Sherry Rehman
26:59 sahab ki Senate ke andar mardum shumari ka issue dubhara laakar election ko multavi karne
27:04 ka bahana banane ki baat ki hai, unhi ki zabani suni.
27:07 Census ke haware se Chairman sahab, kyunki yaha debate chhadi gayi hai, yeh mauqif hamara
27:12 hai ki yeh census ki baat aur sabko pata hai, mutnaaze hoti hai aur logon ko ispar objections
27:17 hain, ke kaunse census par election honge, yeh na istamar kiya jaye elections me takheer
27:22 ke liye.
27:23 Ahmed Bilal Mahmood sahab, Sir Barapil Datt humaine saath maujood hai, bahot shukri Ahmed
27:27 sahab hume join karne ke liye, kya aapko taajub hua, yeh ekdham se election ke itne kareeb
27:32 aake caretaker set up ke jub guftubu honi thi, to ekdham se announce kar diya Wazir-e-Azam
27:37 sahab ne ki nai mardum shumari ke upar elections hongi. Ab yeh aap bhi samjhte hain, main bhi
27:42 jaanate hu ki MQM ke dabao me aake istara ki kabhi federal parties jo hain, baaki unhone
27:46 koi faisle kiye nahi hain. So yeh aachanak se yeh kaha se aaya aur yeh aaj jab yeh announce
27:52 hua hai, to iske baad jo nai khadshat janam le rahe hain, unko aap kaise dekhte hain?
27:57 Bahut shukriya, mujhe bhi taajub hua tha, isliye ke consistent position rahi thi, teen chaar
28:04 wafaqi waziraat ke taraf se, ke wo 2017 ke census ke upar election karwaayenge, kyunke
28:10 ek cheez to waazit hi, ke sabse bada jo uske andar faisla karna hota hai, wo yeh hai ki
28:16 subah ko kitti QA ki nishaste milenge, aur uske andar tabdili isliye nahi hoti thi, ke
28:22 humare paas aayin ko tabdil karne ka, uspe tarbeem karne ki taidaad muaythar nahi thi.
28:28 To isliye mera khayal tha ki galwan 2017 pe hi chale jaayenge. Lekin phir yeh aachanak
28:33 jab waziraat hain bhi yeh aalan kiya, to bilkul dharust hai, ki mujhe bhi taajub hua,
28:38 aur phir maine isko thoda tha ghaur se dekha, to phir mujhe andaaza hua, ke iske kya
28:43 implications hungi, iske implications to badi waazay hain, ke chaar maine to intikhabat
28:48 ki taarikh, teen se chaar maine to kamas kam bada jaayegi, aur jo February ki date
28:53 batayi jaa rahi thi, wo mere khaal mein kaafi realistic date hai, is nahi haalaat ke baad.
28:58 Sir, iske laawa jab yeh poori halka bandiya hungi, phir logon ne appealen bhi karne hai,
29:02 jin ko lagega ki unki jo constituency hai, usme kaant shant hui hai, ya unki umango
29:06 ke tarjumani nahi karti yeh nahi halka bandiya, phir wo appeal mein bhi jaayenge,
29:10 to phir usme bhi kuch waqt lagega, uski bhi kuch aage duration hogi, usme phir aur delay
29:16 hoga?
29:17 No, yeh poora period jo hota hai, chaar maine ka, jo Election Commission ne diya hota hai,
29:23 usme ek mahina appealon ke liye hota hai, aur unki resolution ke liye hota hai, to wo
29:29 uske andar included hai, chaar maine mein total time hai, jiske andar yeh saari adjudication
29:34 bhi ho jaayegi, uspe itrazaab bhi shamil ho jaayenge, uske andar demarcation bhi ho jaayegi,
29:39 to chaar maine ke andar sab kuch ho jaana chahiye mera khaal mein.
29:42 Sir Ahmed sahab, ab issue yeh hai, ke pehle jab aap zikr karte the, ke ek aayini tarmeem
29:47 ki zarurat hai, chuke isfak House in order nahi hai, quorum poora nahi hai, to yeh do
29:52 tahay ki aayini tarmeem to nahi ho sakti hai.
29:55 Jo hukumat ke tarah se taujiye aayi aaj mein sun rahi thi, wo kare the, ki je subon ke andar
29:59 nashiston ki takseem effect nahi hogi, jo shehro ke andar hoge, wo subayi hukumton ne
30:04 apna taur pe usko manage karna hai. Is this a fair strategy?
30:09 Ji yeh darust hai, jo provincial allocation hai, seats ki, National Assembly ki seats
30:17 ki, uspe koi tabdeli nahi aayegi, wo to 2017 ke mutaabak hi chalegi.
30:22 Wo isliye chalegi, ki humare paas Qaumi Assembly me aayini tarmeem ke liye tadaat nahi hai.
30:27 Lekin intra-provincial, within the province, jo mukhtalif zilon ko seate allocate ki hui
30:35 hai, wo kisi zile ki agar abadi badh gayi hai, wo uske saabse seete badh jayengi, wo kisi
30:42 zile ki kaam ho gayi hai, to usse saabse kaam ho jayengi, lekin total seats allocated to
30:47 that province, wo tabdeli nahi hogi. To chuke yeh districts ki seete badh lene ke liye aayini
30:53 tarmeem ki zaroorat nahi hai, isliye yeh ho jayega, wo phir subho ki seete badh lene
30:58 ka, wo phir zahir hai jab subho ki seete badh lenge, to uske saabse district ki seete phir
31:03 badh lenge. To ek baar phir demarcation hogi, agla intikhaab se pehle.
31:08 Sir, does this make sense to you? Election ke itne paas aakar, pehle hum yeh exercise
31:12 abhi karenge, uske baad hum dubara 2 tahai, jab humare paas maujood hoga poora house,
31:17 mein hum laakar apni jo bhi majority ke zariye, ek defa dubara usko demarcation karenge, yeh
31:23 to mazaak nahi hai, jisne election ladna hai constituency level pe jaake?
31:28 Mera zaati taur pe apni assessment yeh hai, ke ek siyasi faisla tha. Yeh ko aayini faisla
31:35 nahi tha, lekin kayi logon ki raayeg yeh hai, ab chuke census ho chuka tha, liyaaza us
31:41 census ko notify na karna, ghar aayini hota, isliye unhone yeh kiya hai. Lekin meri raay
31:48 bhaaral yeh hai, ke agar unhone karna tha, to wo zara pehle kar sakte the, itne kareeb
31:53 aake is baad ki announcement karna ek siyasi faisla hai, unhose siyasi faida yeh hi ho sakta
31:58 tha, ke intikhaabaat chaar ek mahine aage chale jaaye.
32:01 Sir, yeh article 51 hai mere haath mein, aur yeh kayta hai, "seeds in National Assembly
32:06 shall be allocated to each province and federal capital on the basis of population in accordance
32:11 with the last proceeding census officially published." To article 51, sir, yeh toh
32:16 keh raha hai, ke toh subho ki bhi nishiste hai, toh baara review hongi, is nahi census
32:21 ki basis pe.
32:22 Ki honi chahiye, lekin chuke upar jo hai, article 51-3 bhi hai, toh usmein wo table
32:28 diya hao hai, jisme allocation pehle maujood hai, ab usko tabdil karna padega, yeh article
32:34 51-5 ke is hisse pe amal karne ke liye, ke subho ki allocation bhi badhlegi uske mataabik.
32:40 Toh chuke yeh ek ajeeb si situation hai, jisme mahini tarbeem kar nahi sakte, toh subho
32:46 ki allocation toh nahi badhlegi. Lekin mai phir bhi yeh kayta hoon, ke yeh hathmi baat
32:51 nahi hai. Iske upar sawal uthaya jaa sakta hai, Supreme Court ke andar, ultimate uski
32:56 interpretation Supreme Court hi karega. Yeh toh mai api raay de raha hoon, aur kuch
33:00 doosre logon ki raay bhi ho sakti hai, lekin mera khayal hai yeh maamla adalat pe jayega
33:04 aur shayad ho sakta hai ke kuch din, waha pe bhi lag jayein, isko adjudicate hone bhi.
33:09 Sir, is poore faisle mein, doh subho ki caretaker CM maujood the, yeh technically sawal pehle
33:14 bhi utha, kanuni taur pe iske upar pehle bhi tarazaat the, lekin hume dekha ki the process
33:19 hua, caretaker CM jo the, unhone wah pe vote diya, uske basis pe consensus decision ho gaya,
33:24 iski aayini aur legal standing kya hai, iske decision, kya isko koi challenge kar sakta
33:28 hai baad mein kisi aur mokhe pe jaa ke? Bilkul kar sakta hai, main zaati taur pe bhi
33:33 yeh yaqeen rakhta hoon, ki chukke Elections Act 2017 ke andar jo section 230 hai, uska
33:40 jo zeli shikh hai, 2A, wo waze taur pe kahta hai ki the caretaker government shall not
33:49 take major policy decisions. Toh mera khayal mein census ke upar, ki kya census pishli
33:56 hai, ya maujooda pe election hona chahiye, yeh ek major policy decision hai, aur yeh
34:01 major policy decision caretaker CM isme nahi le sakte the decision. Isliye mera bhi ye
34:07 khayal tha, ki caretaker chukke Council of Common Interest ke andar, 2 CM ki jagah
34:13 khali hai, elected CM ki, caretaker CM aam chote bote faisle toh kar sakte the, tek
34:20 itna bada faisla wo nahi kar sakte the, liyaaza yeh census ka jo faisla hai, Council of Common
34:26 Interest pe, yeh mere khayal mein durst nahi hai. Main is baare mein Raza Abani sahab
34:30 me jo position li thi, main usse muttafik hoon.
34:32 Theek hai, bahut shukriya humare saath Ahmed Bilal Mehboob sahab, technically unhone
34:35 ne kaha ki jo caretaker set up ke representative CMs hai, wo vote de nahi sakte hai, aur yeh
34:41 decision wo kar nahi sakte hai, lekin baaral Pakistan me sab kuch hota hai, sab kuch
34:45 mungkin hai, aaj humne dekha, Council of Common Interest me wo bethe bhi, vote bhi hua, aur
34:49 unanimous decision le liya, in dono caretaker CMs ne, ya unke representatives ne. Baaral
34:56 ji, break pe jaayenge, jab wapas aayenge, toh PEMRA Act ke hawale se, aaj jo sahafi baradri
35:00 thi, wo Senate ki committee ke andar mulaqat hui, wahaan par kya guftagu hui, baat karenge,
35:05 hum iss hawale se break ke baat waal saath rahein.
35:07 Welcome back, Pakistan me jamuhuriyat bahut hi tezi se, tanzali ki taraf badhi, lekin
35:13 Senate ghaliban ek ayawan aisa hai, jahan kuch abhi bhi jamuhuri ravaiyon ki ramak baaki
35:17 hai, aaj humne dekha ki Senate ki Qaema Committee barah-e-talaat ka jalas hua, jo PEMRA
35:22 tarmeemi bill hai, uski jaldi manzoori na karne ke liye, jo sahafiyon ka muhaqaf tha, uski
35:27 taayid ki bahut haare Senators ne, sahafi baradri ki muhaqaf ki taayid karne wale jo
35:31 Senators hain, unmein Irfan Siddiqui sahab, Kamran Michael, Senator Tahir Buzinjo, Senator
35:35 Waqar Mehdi the, aaj sahafi wahaan par maujood bhi the, iss hearing ke andar, Amir Mateen
35:40 sahab, Mohammad Malik, Kashif Abbasi, Nusrat Javed aur Hamid Mir sahab bhi wahaan the, wahaan
35:45 pe Wazirat-e-Tilaat sahiba bhi thi, kya hua wahaan par, kya commitments di gayi, sahafiyon
35:49 ki chunwai hone ka imkaanat hai, iss pe baat karenge, Hamid Mir sahab maaise saath maujood
35:52 hai, bahut shukriya Hamid sahab, aaj finally aapki do dafa meeting delay hui, wo phir
35:57 4 bhaji ke baad ho hi gayi, saare 10 bhaji pehle bulaya, phir 1.30 bhaji kaha, phir 4
36:01 bhaji kaha, lekin aap log hele nahi wahaan se, aapne kaha, bethe hain aap, bishak aaj
36:05 ho na ho meeting.
36:06 Ji haan yeh bada ek dilchas maamla tha aur aaj jab poore 4 bhaji meeting shuru hui toh
36:13 us wak bhi Maryam Aurangzeb sahiba jo hain, wo iss meeting mein maujood nahi thi, jis
36:17 pe jo Muslim League Noon ke Senator Irfan Siddiqui sahab hain, unhone jo chair kari thi, Fauzi
36:23 Arshad sahiba, unko yeh kaha ki yeh meeting jo hai shuru karne se pehle, mera, meri taraf
36:28 se yeh itijaz ko record pe leke aayein, ke pehle humein subah 11 bhaji bulaya gaya, uske
36:33 baad 2.30 bhaji bulaya gaya, aur phir kaha gaya ke 4 bhaji hoga, toh hum Senators itne
36:37 fariq log nahi hain.
36:39 Toh, yeh nahi ka Muslim League Noon ke hain Irfan Siddiqui sahab, aur wo bhi kaafi ghus
36:44 hai, ke yeh ijdaas baar baar, bagahir kisi wajah ke isko delay kiya gaya.
36:48 Aur phir, jab Secretary Information hain Suhail Khan sahab, unhone briefing shuru ki, toh
36:55 is duran mein, takreeban 4.15 bhaji, Maryam Aurangzeb sahiba aagayi, phir unhone take
37:00 over kar liya, phir wohi bole jaa rahi thi.
37:02 Toh phir, finally phir jo Fauzi Arshad sahiba hain, jinka taluk Tehreek-e-Insaaf se hai,
37:05 woh aaj pehli dafa is meeting ko chair kar rahi thi, unhone phir mujhe kaha ke aap ispe
37:09 baad karein, phir maine bhi baad ki, Amir Mateen sahab ne, Muhammad Malik sahab ne baad ki,
37:13 Rawalpindi Islamabad Union of Journalists ke President hai, Abid Abbasi sahab, unhone
37:16 baad ki, ek aur journalist hain, Asif Bashir Chaudhry, unhone bhi baad ki.
37:20 Aur isme ek jo aaj Fauzi Arshad sahiba unhone isko notice kiya aur baar baar unhone toka,
37:27 ke jo Maryam Aurangzeb sahiba hain, wo humari guftu ke duran, wo hume baar baar interrupt
37:32 karne ki koshish karti thi aur even unhone ek mauka pe jo convener hain is committee ki,
37:37 Fauzi Arshad sahiba, unko bhi dabaane ki koshish ki, jis pe unhone bhi iska bura manaya.
37:42 Aur achi baat yeh thi, ke jo senators the, masalan Kamran Michael sahab hain aur Irfans
37:48 Dikhi sahab hain, unka taluk Muslim League non se hai, Tahir Bazinjo sahab National Party
37:52 ke hain, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan sahab, kyunki unhone amendments propose kiya, unko bhi waha pe
37:56 bulaya gaya tha, Waqar Mehdi sahab ka taluk People's Party se hai.
38:00 To in sabne, humare is muhaqab se ittifaq kiya, ke yeh bahut jald bazi me kanun laya gaya.
38:06 Humne unse yeh poocha Maryam Aurangzeb sahiba se, humne unko technical trikay se bhi unko,
38:12 unki jo amendments thi, unka jo law tha, usko humne oppose kiya aur humne yeh ka, ke yeh
38:17 aap Supreme Court ke faisalon ki khilabarzi kar rahi hain.
38:19 Ek swaal ko unke paad jawab nahi tha, hum baar baar unse pooch rahe the, yeh batayin
38:22 aapko jaldi kya hai, aap kyun itni jaldi me karna hai, unhone yeh ek muqa pe dawa kiya,
38:27 ke maine Qaumi Assembly me 10 din me is bil ko manzoor kar waya, jis pe humne unko contradict
38:33 kiya aur humne ka, ki aapne 10 min, 10 din me nahi, 10 minute me bhi nahi, aapne 1 minute
38:39 ke sirf 40 second me bil manzoor kar waya, jis pe maine unko ka, ke mai Qaumi Assembly
38:44 ki press gallery me maujood tha, aapne idhar se bil pesh kiya aur udhar se speaker ne house
38:49 ki sense le ke bil manzoor kar liya.
38:51 To yeh aap send up to nahi karee.
38:53 So ab, ab, ab, Mir sahib hoga kya?
38:54 Mere khayal hai, Pir tak unhone multavi kiya hai, wahan par sifarishaat kuch sahafi bhi
38:57 lekar jaayenge aur wo jo khaas taur pe unho jo kehti hain, ke jo tankeed kar raha hai,
39:01 usne bil pada nahi hai.
39:02 Ab to kaafi saar logon ne bil pad liya hai, fir bhi unko samjh nahi aari wo baat, jo
39:05 Mariam Aurangzeb sahiba sanjhana jaa rahi hain.
39:07 Mariam Aurangzeb sahiba ne wahan pe baar baar yeh plea le ki jo log is bil ki mukhalfat
39:12 karein, wo chhatein yeh hai, ke darsal jo Parvez Musharraf daur ka, daur ka, jo Pemra
39:16 ordinance hai, 2002 ka, wohi jo hai, woh chalta rahe.
39:18 To wo hme Parvez Musharraf ka naam leke, to hme pressurize karne ki koshish kar rahi thi,
39:23 blackmail karne ki koshish kar rahi thi, jab ke humne unko, humne aaj jo committee ke
39:28 memberaan hai, unko mene media commission ki report dakhayi.
39:31 Mene kha, jee, yeh 2013 me media commission ki report aayi thi.
39:34 Media commission ki report ne kaha tha, ke jo chairman Pemra ka takarur hai, yeh hukumat
39:38 nahi kar sakti, iska takarur parliament karegi, jaise ke chief election commissioner ka takarur
39:42 hota hai, ispe Mariam Aurangzeb sahiba ko humse ittifaq karna pada.
39:45 Unhone ka thik hai, aap amendment propose karein.
39:47 Wo chahari thi ke, hum aaj hi amendment de deyen aur kal itwar ke din senate ka jilas
39:51 hai aur itwar ko yeh bil joya manzoor ho jaye.
39:53 To uspe Fauzi Arshad sahiba ko humne kaha tha, ke humne tamam media ki tanzimon ke saath
39:57 salaam-e-ishfira karna hai.
39:58 Kamas kam humne Monday tak, Monday tak ka time deyen.
40:00 To Monday ko dubehar 2 wajah jilas dubara hoga, Monday ki subah tak hum apni jo proposed
40:05 amendments hai, wo de denge.
40:07 Aur uske baad phir, jo yeh senate ki committee hai, isme wo amendments discuss hogi.
40:12 Aur uske baad phir agar hukumat humse ittifaq karegi, to phir mamla joya wo dubara senate
40:16 mein jayega.
40:17 To isper hum jo tamam senators hai, unka shukriya bhi da karte hain, ke unhone hamara saath
40:21 diya.
40:22 Aur khaas taur pe ispe aaj humne yeh bhi unko bataya, ke yeh jo bil hai, yeh bil na sirf
40:28 workers jo hai, unke rights ko violate kar raha hai, labour laws ko violate kar raha
40:32 hai, balke isme unhone clause da liya hai.
40:34 Aur mene waha pe misaal di, mene ka Shaheed Arshad Sharif sahab jo hai, unper Pakistan
40:38 ke mustaqil, mukhtalif shairon mein unpe muqadmaat the.
40:40 To ab unhone is kanun ke ziliye pabandh kiya, ke agar main Islamabad mein rahata hu, to
40:45 main sirf Islamabad ki adalat se hi zamanat le sakta hu, ya Islamabad ki adalat mein hi
40:50 jaa sakta hu.
40:51 Main Lahore mein hi jaa sakta, main Karachi mein hi jaa sakta.
40:54 To yeh TV channels ko pabandh karein, sahafiyon ko pabandh karein, ke jis shair mein aap rahate
40:58 hain, sirf usi shair ki aap court mein jayenge aur kisi aur court mein aap nahi jaa sakte.
41:03 To humne unko yeh kaha, ki yeh illegal hai, humne to unko yeh kaha, ki pura ka pura kanun
41:08 jo hai, yeh humne na manzoor hai.
41:10 Lekin jab humne Wazir Arshad sahaba ne kaha, ki aap amendments propose karein, to fir
41:14 humne agree kya.
41:15 Fair enough, chalein hum is puri khabar pe nazar rakhenge, bahot shukriya, Hamid Mir
41:17 sahab aaye saath maujood the, ab tak yeh jilas multavi hua hai, isme sahafi baradari jo kaafi
41:24 arse se cheekh rahi hai, chila rahi hai, kiske andar bahot sahi draconian aur censorship
41:26 lanewali clauses maujood hai, at least unki shunwai ho rahi hai.
41:28 Program kab khatam ho gaya, apna feedback dena mat boolega, khilal rakhi hai, khuda hafiz.