• 3 years ago
How will time of day pricing affect the #electricity consumption in India?
In conversation with The Infravision Foundation's Vinayak Chatterjee.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 Hi, thanks so much for tuning in.
00:17 You are watching BQ Prime.
00:18 My name is Alex Matthew and this is Infravisioning, the show where we talk about various developments
00:24 in the infrastructure sector in India.
00:27 Now you have been using electricity for quite a while now I am sure, but were you aware
00:33 of the possibility of different pricing at different points of the day, depending on
00:39 the peak and the off-peak times.
00:42 Well that is something that is in the works here in India and it could in fact change
00:47 the way that you consume electricity.
00:50 That is what we are talking about on today's show.
00:53 And joining me as always is Vinayak Chatterjee, the founder and managing trustee at the Infravision
01:01 Foundation.
01:02 Thank you so much Vinayak as always for taking the time.
01:05 And let's start talking about what TOD or time of day is and why is it so significant.
01:13 So time of day Alex, if I were to use jargon, in fact let me start with jargon and simplify
01:20 it later, is what market analysts call dynamic pricing.
01:30 So TOD is the dynamic pricing for electricity charges across different hours of the day.
01:38 Now while dynamic pricing sounds like intense jargon, for your viewers and for the average
01:45 consumer actually it's not scary at all because the Indian consumer is used to dynamic pricing
01:50 in two everyday areas.
01:51 One is airline fares.
01:52 You see that when there is just before a public holiday, say 15th August or Christmas or Diwali,
02:02 the airfares spike up.
02:06 And when the traffic is less, demand is less, the airfare comes down.
02:10 That is a straightforward example of dynamic pricing, that a business offering adjusts
02:15 its pricing to equate demand and supply.
02:18 Similarly you will see that in cinema tickets, multiplex.
02:22 You know the tickets, the shows in the afternoon on a weekday are far far cheaper than the
02:29 tea cars on a weekend.
02:31 That itself is an example of dynamic pricing.
02:34 Or you could even say time of day tariff.
02:37 In the case of airline it's possibly time of, it's day of month, whereas in the case
02:42 of multiplex tickets it's very clearly time of day.
02:45 So the Indian customer is used to it, but the innovation now, actually between you and
02:50 me, people are seeing it in Uber, Ola fares also, what people call surge pricing.
02:56 Surge pricing is nothing but dynamic pricing, equating demand and supply of the vehicles.
03:01 So the Indian customers are telling.
03:03 But does this exist in other parts of the globe and are we essentially using a tried
03:08 and tested formula?
03:09 We are.
03:10 So in the electricity sector, this is the first time that the Indian consumers are going
03:15 to be exposed to time of day pricing.
03:18 And to answer your question, all mature electricity markets, US, UK, parts of Europe, Australia,
03:25 etc. all have TOD, time of day pricing, which basically equates demand and supply.
03:33 Now the important point, Alex, is that why is it structurally important for India to
03:40 do this?
03:41 You know, with every passing month, we are moving from a situation where the share of
03:50 renewables is increasing by the day.
03:55 But as you well know, the sun doesn't shine through the day, nor does the wind blow every
04:01 time.
04:02 The maximum electricity supply is within those hours when the sun is shining brightly.
04:08 But the maximum peak demand is in the evenings when people turn on all household gadgets,
04:13 etc., when the solar and renewable power is at its lowest.
04:18 So there is always this business of grid instability accentuated or exaggerated by the increasing
04:26 share of renewables in the total supply of electricity.
04:30 So historically, the electricity supply system, which is people like POSCO and PowerGrid and
04:37 the load dispatch centers, they would cut supply if there was inadequate load to meet
04:42 demand and that was called load shedding or power cuts.
04:45 But you can achieve the same objective by having lesser customers demand electricity
04:50 by shifting their load to hours when there is peak supply.
04:55 So there is also an important structural reason why this helps in what I would call grid balancing.
05:01 But over to you, Alex.
05:03 So we've kind of laid the context as to why this is happening.
05:07 And as somebody that grew up in Pune during the summer months, I've experienced exactly
05:12 what you're talking about in terms of load shedding, which is why I think a lot of households
05:16 in Pune have invested in that inverter that switches on and gives you power at least to
05:22 run your fans for a little while.
05:25 It's something that Mumbai doesn't experience at all because there's always power.
05:29 But having said that, let's talk about how this is going to be implemented.
05:34 Because I believe that it's something that has been in the works for some time.
05:38 There is significant outlay that the government has put forward and I believe it started in
05:43 FY22.
05:45 So the background is like this.
05:47 Alex, you can only do time of day metering and billing if you have smart meters.
05:53 Now, across the length and breadth of the country, we do not have most of our households
05:58 yet, shall we say, equipped with smart meters.
06:02 The government recognizes this.
06:04 And about two years ago, a year ago, it basically announced a new scheme in the budget, if you
06:10 recall, called RDSS, revamped distribution sector scheme, with a massive outlay of just
06:16 a little over three lakh crores over a period of three years.
06:22 Is it three years or five years?
06:24 Let me just check.
06:25 You're right.
06:26 You're right, Alex.
06:27 Three lakh crores over five years.
06:29 And the bulk of it is for, you know, to install smart meters.
06:37 As of now, we have kind of done, we are targeting to do about two and a half, you know, 25 crores
06:45 of smart metering by 2020.
06:50 Sorry, we've currently got about 6 billion smart meters installed, and we need to move
06:56 the needle to about 26 billion smart meters.
06:58 Now, that's a fairly long journey.
07:01 And that is why I think for the general consumers, the government has mandated that time of day
07:06 pricing won't kick in immediately, but will kick in from 1st April of 2025 for the general
07:14 consumers, the households basically.
07:16 So that's to give enough time for the grid to implement time of day at the dispatch level
07:23 and connect to the suppliers, as well as hoping that a much larger population of smart meters
07:29 would have got installed by then, if not fully, but at least substantially across most geographies.
07:36 So for your viewers and for the Indian consumer, household consumer, 1st April 2025 would make
07:43 for a very interesting beginning, where most householders will now have to start thinking,
07:47 when do I put on my AC?
07:49 When shall I put on my washing machine?
07:51 If you have an electric two wheeler or four wheeler, when will I charge it?
07:55 So the household has to go through some very interesting household decisions as to how
08:00 to plan its electricity usage, which Indian households haven't done ever, ever.
08:06 I'm also curious Vinayak, because we've been reading about companies that are engaged in
08:12 smart metering and getting tenders for smart meters.
08:16 But how does that work?
08:18 And what do you have to do?
08:20 Do you have to do something as a consumer to get a smart meter assigned to you?
08:25 No, no, no, no, it's just the DISCOM will contact you as soon as your local area DISCOM
08:30 is ready with their supply of smart meters, and their people who will take out the old
08:35 meter and install the new meter.
08:36 So as a consumer, you just have to wait in the DISCOM contacts, you don't have to do
08:40 anything.
08:41 So how does it work?
08:42 It basically works by the smart meter sending signals back to the control tower, control
08:48 room of the DISCOM every 15 minutes.
08:51 So every 15 minutes it knows how much power the household is consuming.
08:55 And hopefully, along with your bill, the DISCOM as a customer service should also give you
09:00 a printout of your consumption, daily average consumption pattern.
09:04 So I will know that Mr. Alex uses maximum electricity at home at 8 o'clock, when he
09:08 switches on his oven and switches on his AC and the washing machine simultaneously.
09:13 And that's interesting.
09:14 And that's a very big shift from the current system where a reading is simply taken at
09:18 the end of the month, where you're saying, okay, you over this period, you've used this
09:22 many units that puts you in this threshold of usage, and therefore you're charged this
09:27 much.
09:28 Yeah, the current electricity bill is very boring document.
09:31 But once TOD kicks in, Alex, believe me, there's going to be much excitement in the household.
09:36 You know, people are going to ask each other, how come last month was cheaper and this month
09:40 we didn't schedule our usage properly.
09:43 And conversely, there can be challenge to the household also to say, how can you now
09:47 intelligently bring down your household electricity cost by 20%.
09:52 So if you're a household that is, let's say in Mumbai or other parts of the country, that's
09:56 today spending say 9000 rupees on a monthly electricity bill.
10:00 If you can shave off 2000 out of it, then you've got an annual saving of 25,000 rupees,
10:05 you know.
10:06 It's a big deal.
10:08 So interestingly, it's going to lead to some very interesting changes in household behavior
10:15 of adjusting to a TOD regime.
10:19 And more importantly, you know, today the consumer was a passive recipient of electricity
10:25 without being a participant in the green process or in the process of reform.
10:30 This one instance brings the householder, the average electricity user, to becoming
10:36 a willing player in the whole electricity reforms game.
10:39 So it's a very interesting movement.
10:41 No, certainly.
10:42 And there are certain other social implications as well.
10:45 I can think of a situation where a college-going individual is playing truant and his father
10:53 looks at the bill and says, hey, you were supposed to be in college at 2pm, whereas
10:57 I can see that the air conditioner was on and consuming electricity.
11:00 So that is an implication.
11:02 But also, I'm just curious, and just to close out this conversation, the industrial users
11:09 of the companies will have this kick in one year earlier, right?
11:13 So what is the implication for them, because they're large consumers of electricity as
11:17 well?
11:18 They're already used to it.
11:19 To be honest with you, for the large industrial and commercial consumers, it's kicking in
11:23 one year earlier.
11:24 It's kicking in from first to zero to four.
11:28 Many of them already have smart meters and many of them have their own energy divisions,
11:32 which have hooked on to energy efficiency measures, you know, years ago.
11:36 So it's going to be less of a, shall we say, interesting development for them as much as
11:41 it is going to be for the householder.
11:42 But remember, it could have a negative effect also.
11:43 Think of a working couple, husband and wife working, the whole day the flat is closed,
11:50 right?
11:51 They both come home at seven in the evening.
11:53 And as soon as they come home at seven, and that is the period when the pricing is higher,
11:57 it's 20% higher, it's peak pricing, right?
12:00 And then at that point of time, they switch on washing machine, TV, air conditioner.
12:05 So they may actually end up paying higher than they do today.
12:09 So there is a potential, shall we say, downside to it also, if you are somebody who is not
12:16 at home during to enjoy solar hours, as they say, you know, the cheaper rates between 10
12:21 in the morning to five in the afternoon, where you get the cheaper rates.
12:25 If you're not at home, then you missed out.
12:27 Unless the consumer durables market itself with internet becomes smart, and you're able
12:33 to switch on and off your devices offline, but you don't really want your air conditioner
12:38 when you're not there, right?
12:40 Yeah, no, I completely understand that.
12:42 And also, I would think things like washing machine, etc, you can try and get something
12:47 done like that already.
12:49 But implications, I think, for, you know, a whole gamut of experiences for the consumer,
12:55 and very interesting conversation.
12:57 I think we'll touch base on it once it is nearing the implementation stage as well.
13:04 But Vinay, thank you so much, as always, for taking the time.
13:06 Pleasure speaking with you.
13:07 Thank you for that interesting conversation.
13:08 Thanks.
13:08 Transcribed by https://otter.ai
13:10 [Music]
13:23 [BLANK_AUDIO]

Recommended