00:00 So you are seeing elections happening even after December.
00:02 And under which legal provision, because if the matter goes to the court,
00:06 they will claim that we can be allowed to hold elections after 90 days.
00:12 Look, the real matter is the same as you pointed out,
00:18 that this is the decision of the elders.
00:20 And if Pakistan is following the decision of the elders,
00:23 and there is no status of law and order,
00:25 then such decisions are also made by the Election Commission.
00:31 And they have been made in the past.
00:33 So, look, the rule of law is very clear in this regard,
00:37 that elections should be held within 90 days.
00:39 This is the right of the public, not the right of any political party.
00:42 We have already violated the right of the public,
00:45 when we did not hold elections in Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa within 90 days.
00:49 Now it has been 6-7 months, there are unelected governments there,
00:53 and it is being said that there may not be elections for another 6-7 months.
00:57 So this is such a big violation of the rule of law,
01:00 that whatever can be said about it, it is less.
01:04 Now, the saying of the Election Commission,
01:06 that since the Council of Common Interests has formed itself,
01:13 under a question mark, that there are two unelected ministers,
01:18 they considered it appropriate that the census that took place in May,
01:22 which had already come,
01:24 should be done on 5-7 August.
01:29 And the Election Commission is now making an excuse,
01:33 that there will be restrictions, training,
01:36 and this matter will be at least in December.
01:39 And even after that, because the minimum period of election is 60 days,
01:45 then the matter is going on till February.
01:47 Look, here the legal point will come before the court,
01:51 that if there is a census,
01:53 its enlargement is done by the Government or the Council of Common Interests on purpose,
01:59 with delay,
02:01 then after that, the Election Commission is bound to
02:06 deviate from the legal period.
02:08 The article of the law is 51, 51's sub-article is 5,
02:13 which says that the elections will be according to the last census.
02:18 But it is very clear in 51-5,
02:22 that the census of the districts and the seats in Islamabad,
02:27 that which district will get how many seats,
02:29 what will be the seats in Islamabad,
02:31 their calculation will be based on the last census.
02:35 The article does not say anything about delimitation.
02:38 Now it is clear here that the census is not being revised according to the last census.
02:42 At the moment, our article is very clear that which district has how many seats,
02:46 and the changes in those seats can be made only through a constitutional amendment,
02:50 and that can be done by the Parliament.
02:52 And this is a big political and legal storm that is being left,
02:56 People's Party and PMLN,
02:58 and now whatever repercussions there will be,
03:00 political repercussions, all these parties will have to bear.
03:03 But a lot of clarity is also required in this regard.
03:06 Mr. Hassan Azza Pasha, if I ask you,
03:08 now on this occasion, the date of the elections,
03:11 will the Election Commission give it or will the President of Pakistan give it?
03:14 Because a legal opinion is also that the constitution is in the first place,
03:17 on the Election Act, and since there was no constitutional amendment on it,
03:20 so for now, it is the responsibility of the President of Pakistan,
03:23 and the Election Commission cannot be a hindrance to this.
03:25 What is the correct legal position in this?
03:27 See, the Election Act 2017, its section is 57,
03:33 in that, the first law was made in the period of Zia ul Haq,
03:40 in that, the right was given to the President of Pakistan,
03:44 which was again written in the Election Act of 2017.
03:49 No one paid attention, it was written.
03:51 When the system was made, when the previous government's matters were about the election,
03:57 then they thought that no, this was the amendment of Zia ul Haq,
04:03 which was reproduced in it,
04:06 so they made an amendment that no, the President of Pakistan has no right,
04:11 under that, the Election Commission is the domain of Pakistan.
04:15 This amendment came.
04:16 But in Article 48 of the constitution,
04:20 it is that the President of Pakistan will announce the date of the election,
04:25 but in that also, there is one thing that it will be the advice of the Prime Minister of Pakistan,
04:29 or the Cabinet.
04:30 So this is the thing, under the article of the constitution,
04:34 the President of Pakistan will announce the date of the election,
04:37 but the advice will be given by the Prime Minister.
04:40 So the Election Commission has a role in this.
04:41 Because when the elections of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab were taking place,
04:44 then the same legal point was raised that the President of Pakistan cannot give the date.
04:48 And then the matter went to the court,
04:50 the court made a complete markdown that how and who will concentrate on this issue.
04:55 In that, it was that the President of Pakistan needed advice under Article 48,
05:01 and at that time the Prime Minister was not giving advice.
05:04 So as a President, I think,
05:08 that as a President, he cannot give the date.
05:12 That is why he did not give the date.
05:14 And then whatever date will be given,
05:17 the direction given by the Supreme Court of Pakistan,
05:20 that the Election Commission of Pakistan will consult with the President of Pakistan,
05:25 and the date of the President of Pakistan will be announced.
05:29 So under that analogy, the President of Pakistan gave the date.
05:34 So this is a little bit...
05:35 Do you disagree with this?
05:37 Yes, see the matter that went to the Supreme Court,
05:41 was in the case of the Subahi Assemblies.
05:43 In the case of the Subahi Assemblies,
05:45 there is no right of the President in the constitution.
05:48 When the Subahi Assembly is being discussed,
05:50 if the Governor has discussed,
05:52 then under Article 105 of the Constitution,
05:54 the Governor has to decide the date of the election.
05:58 Here the debate was that since the Governor is not deciding the date,
06:02 under Article 105 of the Constitution, then what?
06:05 No, Mr. Salman, there was another point in this.
06:07 Because those elections were being said to be general elections.
06:10 This was also the technicality that since these are general elections in KP Punjab,
06:15 that is why the President of Pakistan can give the date.
06:17 This was a technical debate at that time.
06:19 No, no, I will tell you one thing.
06:21 See, the situation at that time was that
06:23 although the Constitution does not give the right to the President of Pakistan in the case of the Subahi Assemblies,
06:29 but in the section 57 of the Election Act of 2017,
06:33 the President of Pakistan was given the right.
06:36 So this matter was only up to the level of the Subahi Assemblies,
06:39 and that section has now been changed,
06:41 and has been amended,
06:42 and the right has been given to the President of Pakistan and the Election Commission.
06:47 But the current situation is different.
06:50 Now it is also the case of the National Assembly.
06:53 And regarding the National Assembly, the constitution of Pakistan is very clear.
06:57 Article 48.5 of the constitution, my brother just pointed to it,
07:01 it is clear, but one thing that my brother forgot to tell is that
07:06 Article 48.5 has been written in the constitution,
07:10 where the President dissolves the National Assembly,
07:13 notwithstanding anything contained in Clause 1,
07:16 he shall appoint the date not later than 90 days.
07:20 Now what is Clause 1 of Article 48?
07:22 Clause 1 is the clause that says that the President will act on the advice of the Prime Minister.
07:28 Therefore, in terms of date, the constitution itself says that
07:32 there will be no application of the opinion of the consultation,
07:35 and the President of Pakistan will decide the date himself when the assembly is held.
07:41 Now here, since the President of Pakistan has held the assembly,
07:44 he was advised, and he held the assembly according to that advice.
07:48 Now it is his duty in the spirit of the constitution to decide a date
07:53 which is within 90 days, according to the will of the constitution.