• 3 years ago
World View |
- Why does India standout among emerging markets?
- What are repercussions of #IsraelHamasWar?
In conversation with Edward Yardeni. #BQLive

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 for tuning into WorldView. I'm your host, Niyash Shah. And on the show today, we have
00:05 with us Dr. Edward Yardeni. He needs no introduction. It'd be lovely to understand from him how
00:11 does he see risk assets from his prism now that some time has passed between the last
00:16 time that he said that he feared a melt up as opposed to a meltdown. Dr. Yardeni, thank
00:22 you so much for taking the time out. Thank you. I would love to understand a lot of,
00:28 some bit of water or a lot of water has flown under the bridge between the time you made
00:32 that comment about expecting a melt up to now. How do you view risk assets or investment
00:38 grade assets in general from your prism currently? Well, it certainly feels as though over the
00:44 past few years, we've had a couple of melt ups and melt downs. It's been a real rollercoaster
00:49 ride for sure. And, you know, coming into last year's bear market, we had a melt up
00:57 that was led by the mega cap eight is the way I like to call them. Some people call
01:03 them the magnificent seven. Then we had, I guess, meltdown. Really, it was a bear market,
01:10 but it didn't really last that long. And it wasn't that severe. I mean, in some sectors
01:15 like technology, it was terrible. But then we had another melt up that basically started
01:20 on October 12th of 2022, again, led by the mega cap eight. And I was thinking that the
01:30 S&P 500 would get to 4,600 by the end of this year, which was basically a melt up forecast
01:38 simply because I was the most optimistic about where the market could go. There was, as you
01:43 know, a lot of pessimism about the market early in the year. And we got there by July
01:49 31st. So I wasn't optimistic enough. And when we got to 4,600 at the end of July, I concluded
01:56 maybe that's it for a while. And maybe the market will go down for a while, up for a
02:02 while, but we may very well end up at 4,600 again. But I don't know if you call it a melt
02:08 up. Again, I have the high forecast for next year of 5,400. So I think for the S&P 500,
02:16 for stocks generally, risk assets, I think the environment will remain positive. But
02:23 as we can see, there's a lot of volatility. There's a lot of reasons to be worried. And
02:30 I am very aware of those reasons, and I'm constantly analyzing them and trying to conclude
02:37 whether optimism is not the right way to have an approach to the market. But, you know,
02:46 stocks over time tend to go up and risk assets, particularly stocks, do well. Bonds have become
02:51 risk assets. And I think 4.5% to 5% for US Treasury bonds is actually pretty attractive.
02:58 Yeah. Have you moved from there is no alternative or TINA to there are reasonable alternatives
03:06 because you get, I mean, dollar terms, 7%. And is that a bit of a ceiling to the point
03:14 that stocks can go up to or buy?
03:17 Well, it could be. But, you know, the stock market really has changed pretty dramatically.
03:21 We've got now 27% of the market capitalization of the S&P 500 is in these mega cap eight
03:28 and they are highly prized. They're very highly valued. They have valuation multiples of almost
03:35 30. And that, of course, because they're so large in the market, that drives up the valuation
03:41 multiple of the S&P 500. Without them right now, we'd probably be around 15 using forward
03:49 earnings. With them, we're more like at 18. So they're having a dramatic impact on the
03:55 market. And it's interesting that they've actually performed pretty well, surprisingly
04:01 well in the face of rising bond yields. And it may very well be that investors are once
04:05 again finding that they are special. And what's special about them is they actually aren't
04:11 that exposed to higher interest rates because they don't have that much debt. They generate
04:16 a tremendous amount of cash flow. They're sitting on a lot of cash and earning a good
04:20 return on them. So we have to be very flexible when we analyze the markets. You know, history
04:27 repeats itself sometimes, but sometimes it rhymes and sometimes things are different.
04:33 So I understand what you're saying and it's perfectly valid to say that, you know, there's
04:39 more of a hurdle now in terms of an alternative in the bond market. But, you know, there's
04:45 a lot of wealth in the world and wealth needs to be invested somewhere. It needs to be diversified
04:51 and people don't just put all their money in the bond market. And now the bonds have
04:55 turned out to be a fairly risky asset. So they may actually view stocks as actually
05:00 not that risky relative to bonds.
05:02 Yeah, well, certainly wealth destruction in the bond side for sure. Just one thing, this
05:07 higher for longer, Dr. Yadav, doesn't mean that EMs at large will be relatively less
05:17 attractive until rates turn?
05:20 Well, you know, the interesting thing about higher for longer is it's widely viewed as
05:25 a negative, implying that, you know, inflation is going to stay higher for longer and therefore
05:32 the Fed is going to have to keep interest rates higher for longer. But the way I look
05:37 at it, maybe it's because I tend to be an optimist about things. I try to be realistic,
05:42 but these days being an optimist is a contrarian view, as you know, maybe it's been that way
05:45 for a while. But my view is higher for longer also means that the economy is actually doing
05:52 pretty well. The US economy before the great financial crisis, you know, we had this new
06:00 abnormal period between the great financial crisis and the great virus crisis where the
06:05 Federal Reserve and other central banks were trying to raise inflation to 2%. They were
06:13 lowering interest rates to historical lows. We're actually back to yields where they were,
06:20 the interest rates where they were before this period, before the great financial crisis,
06:24 2003, 2007, the 10-year bond yield was 4.5% to 5%, which is where it is right now. And
06:32 the economy was able to withstand that kind of level and it's doing it again. So higher
06:39 for longer has a positive implication that the economy may actually be resilient. We've
06:44 recently gotten some strong employment numbers and I wrote a piece called "Consumers Hotter
06:48 for Longer." Remember at the beginning of the year, there was a lot of recession talk.
06:53 I wasn't in that camp. So the other part of it is I think inflation is turning out to
06:59 be transitory. And I think higher for longer may not be the case that we may see in fact
07:05 four federal funds rate cuts next year instead of the two that the Fed now is talking about.
07:11 So, you know, things can change. And I think what will change is I think there'll be a
07:16 perception that, you know, inflation really isn't as much of a problem as we thought.
07:22 And meanwhile, the economy is doing well. And I think the big surprise in the US at
07:25 least is going to be a return of productivity growth because we need it to offset the shortage
07:31 of labor.
07:32 I presume you write some of this stuff on your website, the Ardini Quicktakes, is where
07:40 we can read more of this?
07:42 Yeah, well, we actually designed a research product for individual investors. Most of
07:50 our client base is institutional investors, but we've had a lot of requests to reach out
07:55 to individual investors. And so we've got something called Yardeni Quicktakes.com. So
08:04 that's www.yardeniquicktakes.com. And it's a quick take every single day, almost every
08:11 single day. I usually take one day off. And we analyze the economic indicators and how
08:17 they affect the market. So it shows the relationship between the macro and the macro of the economy
08:24 global and the micro of investing in stocks and bonds.
08:29 Okay, well, so that's some food for thought and a place where maybe even I can go and
08:35 try and pick up some intelligence. Now, I would love to get some more of that on the
08:40 show, Dr. Yardeni, and try and correlate what your view around rates, which you said, who
08:48 knows, there might be a possibility of more cuts. And what does that mean for emerging
08:53 markets like India?
08:55 Yeah. Well, India really stands out these days among emerging markets. China is doing
09:02 poorly. For several years, global investors invested, maybe even over-invested in China.
09:12 But China's economy has slowed. I think it's a structural problem they have with the property
09:17 bubble bursting in China, and that's depressing their economy. And at the same time, the legacy
09:24 of their one-child policy is terrible. Their population is aging very quickly. And as a
09:33 result of that, that also is combining to slow their economy down. I mean, they've been
09:40 very successful in building state-of-the-art infrastructure, beautiful roads, high-speed
09:47 trains, tremendous airports, but older people don't travel that much, and they don't spend
09:55 as much as younger people. For one thing, they don't know how long they're going to
09:59 live, and they don't know what their health is going to be like. And China doesn't have
10:03 the kind of social safety net that other countries have. And of course, there's the geopolitical
10:10 tensions between China and the West. It's not just the US, it's the West. And so that
10:15 and the supply chain disruptions during the pandemic have made China a very unreliable
10:22 place to put all your manufacturing facilities. So people are certainly looking at India,
10:31 moving to India for alternative ways to invest in manufacturing and other areas. India still
10:40 has a ways to go in infrastructure spending, but I think the government knows that and
10:44 is working on that. So that's a big positive. But when I look around the world, India again
10:51 stands out as a winner. Now, India obviously is going to be affected by the price of oil.
10:57 It's been volatile of late. I don't think the price of oil is going to soar to 100 to
11:02 120. The Saudis would like to see it at 100, but I don't think it's going to sustainably
11:07 be there because I don't think US consumers will tolerate that kind of a gasoline price.
11:13 And we've seen recently gasoline consumption in the US has come down. So when again, when
11:19 I look at the emerging markets, there are interesting places like Vietnam, Indonesia,
11:24 Malaysia in Asia. But again, India stands out in Asia. In Latin America, Brazil tends
11:31 to be a play on commodities and Brazil is very dependent on China's economy. And that
11:37 if it's China's economy is going to be weak, Brazil does not look like a overweight in
11:44 emerging market portfolios. Africa looks very interesting because they like India. They
11:51 have a young population in some parts of Africa, many parts of Africa. English is spoken. So
12:00 that seems to be an important language these days for doing business. So put it all together
12:06 and there are certainly opportunities in the global economy. My preference from a global
12:13 perspective is to overweight the United States among developed nations and to overweight
12:21 India in terms of emerging nations.
12:24 That's music to the ears and good to know. The question is, we hear from a lot of global
12:31 brokerages or brokerages which cater to global clients. So there's a lot of money, investor
12:37 wealth sitting on the sidelines has made applications for making an investment into India. But the
12:43 starting point of high valuations seems to be a hindrance. I would love to understand
12:47 because you've looked at so many cycles. Can expensive valuations in a market which is
12:52 sought out and showing growth in an otherwise, in a world which is otherwise not showing
12:58 growth and starting valuations as a concern be overridden because of the fanfare around
13:04 a market?
13:05 Yeah. Well, look, in a world where growth is challenged, I mean, nobody is really looking
13:11 for a global economic boom. The IMF is downgrading its outlook and that's because China's prospects
13:18 don't look particularly exciting. Europe also has a rapidly aging population. It has mismanaged
13:28 the transition from dirty to clean energy. It's got the geopolitical problems. So nobody's
13:35 looking for the global economy to do all that well. It's still going to grow, but it's going
13:40 to be a slow growing economy. Meanwhile, the US looks like it's doing fine. But that actually
13:46 means that growth stocks are going to be rare in the stock market. And usually growth stocks
13:55 are supposed to not do well when interest rates are going up, not too well when valuations
14:02 are relatively high. But I think the reason their valuation is high is because, again,
14:08 there's different kinds of growth stocks. Growth companies that don't have a lot of
14:11 debt in this world are going to be highly valued and they're going to be highly valued
14:16 also because they are growth stocks and able to find revenue growth and earnings growth.
14:22 So I think they may continue to outperform. That doesn't mean that there aren't opportunities
14:28 in value. I think energy stands out still as an area for overweighting simply because,
14:36 again, the transition from dirty to clean energy is turning out to be very difficult.
14:42 It's not like suddenly we're going to stop using oil. However, the world is moving towards
14:49 electric vehicles and that's going to reduce the demand for gasoline. We're still going
14:53 to need to generate electricity to operate them. But the oil companies have concluded,
14:59 well, you know, maybe they can cut back on their capital spending and just sell what
15:05 they are able to, that they have already at a high price because there's still a demand.
15:13 And so they're generating a lot of cash, which they're using to pay dividends and to buy
15:18 back shares. So I think energy stocks still are going to work.
15:24 Financials. I think some of the bigger financials are actually growth stocks. Let me just kind
15:31 of put kind of a conclusion on this particular subject. And that is, I think that all companies
15:39 in the future have to become technology companies, not in the sense that they have to make or
15:45 produce hardware and software. They have to use it in order to remain competitive. And
15:51 the technology companies tend to have higher multiples. So even financials, I think we
15:56 need to think of them as FinTech, as financial technology companies, healthcare is technology
16:04 and so on.
16:05 Okay. Point well taken. My final question, and that is around geopolitics. If Russia
16:11 and Ukraine wasn't enough, we have one more Middle Eastern conflict going on. What repercussions
16:17 does such a thing have or such a period have?
16:21 Yeah. Well, I've been doing this for a while. I've been doing it for over 40 years. And
16:27 there have been lots of geopolitical crises. There have been some horrible regional wars.
16:36 Fortunately, there haven't been any wars like World War I or World War II. You definitely
16:43 don't want to invest in stocks in a world war. But we've seen that in the past, the
16:50 geopolitical crises, as long as they're not of a disastrous, catastrophic scale, geopolitical
16:58 crises have turned out to be buying opportunities. I mean, the war in Europe is horrible. And
17:05 it certainly has, it's the most serious war that has occurred in Europe since World War
17:14 II. And now it looks like this recent war between Hamas and Israel, that looks like
17:26 it's not going to be the kind that suddenly leads to a ceasefire and life goes on. It
17:32 looks like it's going to have all sorts of geopolitical consequences. But so far, it
17:37 doesn't look like it's spreading to the whole region. If it were to spread to Iran and Saudi
17:41 Arabia and start to affect oil supplies, that would be a real serious problem because all
17:46 recessions in the past have really been associated with higher interest rates or higher oil prices.
17:52 So again, I don't like saying that terrible geopolitical crises are buying opportunities
18:02 for stocks. I don't like the idea of making money when people are suffering in some place
18:08 of the world, but that happens to be the reality. And so what's interesting is so far, we really
18:14 haven't seen much of a reaction in global stock markets other than in the Middle East
18:20 to the crisis in the Middle East. And again, that suggests that investors have concluded
18:26 that geopolitical crises, as long as they're contained, are not reasons to get out of the
18:34 stock market.
18:35 So far, so good. Let's see if that changes.
18:38 So far, so good.
18:39 So far, so good. Dr. Yadeni, such a pleasure talking to you. Thank you for taking the time
18:43 out and speaking to us and looking forward to talk to you more often, sir.
18:48 My pleasure, indeed. Thank you.
18:49 Thank you.
18:50 Thank you.
18:51 Thank you.
18:52 Thank you.
18:52 Thank you.
18:53 Thank you.
18:53 Thank you.
18:54 Thank you.
18:55 Thank you.
18:55 Thank you.
18:56 Thank you.
18:57 Thank you.
18:57 Thank you.
18:58 Thank you.
18:59 Thank you.
18:59 Thank you.
19:00 Thank you.
19:01 Thank you.
19:01 Thank you.
19:02 Thank you.
19:02 Thank you.
19:03 Thank you.
19:04 Thank you.
19:04 Thank you.
19:05 Thank you.
19:06 Thank you.
19:06 Thank you.

Recommended