00:00 Well, thanks so much for tuning into this conversation with arguably somebody who is
00:03 amongst the largest names in the investing fraternity on the global front.
00:08 Rishi Kapoor of Investcorp with us on NDTV Profit.
00:11 Rishi, thanks so much for taking the time out and speaking to us today.
00:14 Look, Neeraj, as always, it's a pleasure being with you all over here.
00:17 Thank you.
00:18 So, Rishi, how is the world of risk assets looking like in 2024, considering the fact
00:25 that the narrative is of higher for longer rates, but in a year where we might or we
00:32 definitely will see interest rates coming off from the peaks?
00:37 So I think you framed it well, Neeraj.
00:40 It's all about the narrative because the narrative initially at least shapes sentiment and then
00:45 sentiment eventually will result in decisions being made by people like me and others that
00:51 are here and all over the world and those decisions in turn drive outcomes.
00:56 So let's take a step back.
00:59 What has changed in 2024 and in the lead up to 2024, I would say?
01:03 I think the main change that I see is not necessarily the fact that interest rates might
01:10 decline precipitously over the course of the next few months or even the subsequent year
01:16 or so.
01:17 It's actually the narrowing of the bands of uncertainty around the direction of rates.
01:23 What I mean by that is the following.
01:24 Heading into the early part of 2023, there was a lot of uncertainty around where will
01:30 rates peak, how long before we get there, how fast is going to be the pace of hiking
01:36 and will there as a consequence be the potential for a recession or certainly a hard landing
01:43 for the US economy broadly speaking but also beyond that the spillover effect on the global
01:48 economy.
01:49 I think where we stand today a year hence is that whilst it is entirely plausible that
01:56 rates might stay high for long.
01:59 I'm not using higher for longer.
02:01 I'm using high for long but the bands of uncertainty around that level of long-term rates is narrower
02:11 and that informs risk-taking and decision-making.
02:17 People like us that are in the business of deploying capital across multiple asset classes
02:21 all over the world, the one thing that we are most fearful of is uncertainty that is
02:27 difficult to underwrite.
02:30 We are in the risk-taking business so some level of uncertainty obviously is taken for
02:35 granted but beyond certain boundaries, acceptable guardrails of uncertainty, it gets difficult
02:41 to generate the kind of conviction that you need to deploy capital and I think the narrowing
02:47 of the bands of uncertainty is very constructive for risk assets but more importantly for the
02:54 ending of that funding winter that we were talking about last year if you recall.
02:59 In some sense, are you a lot more confident and more certain an investor at the beginning
03:05 of 2024 than what you might have been at the beginning of 2023?
03:10 In 2023, certainly we were tentative, no doubt about it.
03:15 As it played out, 2023 particularly in the public equity markets was a great year and
03:21 we've had some great outcomes ourselves in our portfolio.
03:25 In India, the portfolio that you are most familiar with, we had a fantastic outcome
03:29 with Safari Industries, almost a four times money on money return over there.
03:35 That's nothing to be embarrassed about at all, that's a fantastic outcome but notwithstanding
03:43 how the year actually played out towards the second half in particular, the final quarter,
03:50 our demeanor, our stance was cautious, prudent.
03:54 I'm not suggesting that we are entering 2024 abandoning all of that prudence and caution.
04:01 All I'm saying is that we are more constructive about the outlook for true fundamental growth
04:08 and value creation devoid of the extremities that are driven by monetary policy.
04:16 The direction and pace of monetary tightening is something that we are more sanguine about
04:23 now than we were 12 months back.
04:26 Somebody gave me an acronym in 2023, maybe it didn't turn out well, it didn't age well
04:31 for sure.
04:32 The person said we are moving from a zone of TINA to TARA, which is there are reasonable
04:36 alternatives.
04:37 But is it true now for 2024 that from there being no alternative to equities, there are
04:43 reasonable alternatives now for 2024 and beyond?
04:48 Depends on what your horizon is, number one, what I mean is investment horizon and number
04:53 two, which markets you are focused on.
04:56 So even for most of 2023, despite the fact that there was abundance of caution in terms
05:02 of deployment of capital into equities early on, credit was a fantastic space to be in.
05:09 I mean you were getting equity like returns in private credit.
05:13 I think as we sit here today in January of 2024, looking ahead over the next 12 to 18
05:21 years, that more constructive backdrop for private credit continues to play out.
05:27 So definitely, is there a real alternative?
05:30 Yes, credit is a real alternative.
05:33 Real estate should bounce back with the stabilization of the direction and trajectory of interest
05:41 rates because what you need is price discovery and I think what was missing in 2023 was an
05:46 unwillingness on the part of buyers and sellers to converge on a price point where they could
05:52 transact.
05:53 Now I think that price discovery is likely to happen.
05:56 And private equity as we alluded to earlier, I think now with the general outlook being
06:04 of sidelining the idea of a likely hard landing or a recession and focusing on a narrower
06:13 range of outcomes which may be a soft landing, may be a no landing, where you continue to
06:18 power ahead with 2.5-3% growth, that's actually very constructive for private equity.
06:23 Long-term value creation is pretty much the name of the game for the next 3 to 4 years.
06:30 Any view on public equities more so India simply because of the fact that it seems to
06:35 be the sinus of many eyes, but the valuations out there are maybe a hitch.
06:42 The bull would argue that valuations in India have always been expensive so this is nothing
06:47 new.
06:48 So you know I have gotten into a little bit of trouble with my colleagues and friends
06:53 for proclaiming on occasion that investing in India, particularly in equity markets in
07:01 India is not for the faint-hearted.
07:04 And the reason for that is very simple, precisely what you said, which is valuation multiples
07:09 that we get used to dealing with in the rest of the world basically end up defying gravity
07:16 when you come to India.
07:18 But you are also right in that that's always been the case.
07:23 So ultimately for us when we think about how we shape our investment strategy for the equity
07:29 market in India, we are not in public equity, but being in private equity what happens in
07:34 the public markets is very relevant for outcomes in terms of exits and monetization for us.
07:40 So the way we shape it is we say let's accept the fact that we are going to pay a premium
07:46 over average multiples globally in India for a company that is similarly in a premium segment
07:54 and has that premium level of performance.
07:57 So it is much more a micro assessment of the sector, the industry in which the company
08:02 is and its actual positioning within that industry or sector, its management team, its
08:08 vision and its go-to-market strategy including its cost structure and its efficiency levels,
08:14 not just about naked growth.
08:16 I think that tide has run out, that growth at any cost is not really a supportable business
08:25 value proposition when it comes to private investing.
08:28 It is much more about proving your unit economics and positioning yourself such that you have
08:36 a truly valuable business value proposition from the get-go that you can grow, enhance,
08:43 scale up, hopefully exponentially at higher than market rates and then monetize.
08:49 And I think from that perspective if you stay disciplined on those few areas that I outlined,
08:55 guess what, you are going to get that premium multiple on the way out as well.
08:59 And I think that is where we make ourselves somewhat agnostic to the multiple that we
09:03 are paying on the way in because we think that we can monetize it at the same multiple
09:09 on the way out.
09:10 Got it.
09:11 My final question, Rishi, and that is on the flows to India.
09:14 Now there is a lot of talk about how, I mean people tell me that ex-China funds are getting
09:20 tremendous flows because people are to an extent maybe disillusioned with some of the
09:24 things that are happening there, but that notwithstanding, it is not a market that you
09:27 shrug away.
09:28 But my limited point is still in the near term, do you think markets like India and
09:32 some others of course, benefit out of investors maybe having a little bit of a cold feet when
09:38 it comes to investing truckloads into China?
09:42 So can I be slightly controversial?
09:44 Please do.
09:45 In terms of responding to that.
09:46 I am a firm believer in the absolutist view rather than the relative view.
09:50 And what I mean by that is, you know we are a three and a half trillion dollar economy,
09:54 right?
09:55 Our market cap is actually slightly higher than 100% of GDP.
10:00 And we are at that inflection point in terms of GDP per capita where the level of affluence
10:05 ought to grow.
10:07 On an absolute basis therefore, India should get its fair share and more off the capital
10:15 flows.
10:16 It is not about reallocating, it is about an absolute level of capital flows.
10:22 Because it demands it, there is a need, and it commands it because the fundamentals are
10:27 in place, right?
10:29 You have a young demographic, you have a digitally native population, you have growing levels
10:34 of affluence, you have a growing middle class, you have two major secular trends shaping
10:40 the global economy, both of which are supportive tailwinds for India.
10:44 The energy transition and the embrace of digitalization and artificial intelligence.
10:50 India has been called, I think perhaps wrongly so, the back office of the world because everyone
10:55 wanted to call somebody else the factory of the world, right?
10:59 But what does back office actually mean?
11:01 We have the knowledge workers, but what do you think is going to be the sector that is
11:05 most beneficially impacted in terms of boosting productivity levels as a consequence of artificial
11:12 intelligence?
11:13 Knowledge.
11:14 The knowledge services sector is going to be probably the biggest beneficiary in terms
11:18 of improved productivity.
11:21 And the energy transition, we are the biggest consumer of that energy transition as a country,
11:26 right?
11:27 So I think in an absolute sense, India sits at the crossroads of a moment in time, I guess.
11:34 Maybe we'll look back at today's discussion 20 years hence and we say, "Well, that was
11:39 on the 15th of January, 2024."
11:42 But you get my drift, right?
11:43 I think there is a point in time today for India where it can afford to demand and command
11:50 absolute levels of capital allocation based on fundamental value and merit.
11:54 Well, that's not controversial.
11:56 That's music to the ears, Rishi.
11:58 And to me, as we wrap up this conversation, the takeaway is this, more importantly, but
12:03 also that things like private credit have come off edge and might actually see some
12:07 stupendous growth over the next few years.
12:09 Thank you so much for your time.
12:11 Lovely talking to you.
12:12 Pleasure, as always.
12:13 Yeah.
12:14 And viewers, thanks for tuning in.
12:14 [Music]
12:15 [End of Audio]
12:15 1
12:16 2
12:17 3
12:18 4
12:19 5
12:20 6
12:21 7
12:22 8
12:23 9
12:24 10
12:25 11