- 3 years ago
-No changes in tax rate
-Push in capex and developmental spending
Here's what ANZ's Dhiraj Nim expects from this budget.
Watch him in conversation with Mimansa Verma.
Stay tuned for #Budget2024 coverage: https://bit.ly/3Sn7gay
-Push in capex and developmental spending
Here's what ANZ's Dhiraj Nim expects from this budget.
Watch him in conversation with Mimansa Verma.
Stay tuned for #Budget2024 coverage: https://bit.ly/3Sn7gay
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:00 As we enter into the budget week,
00:02 I'm here in conversation with Mr. Dheeraj Nim,
00:05 FX Strategist and Economist at ANZ Research.
00:08 Welcome, sir.
00:09 Sir, my first question to you is,
00:12 how are you expecting the budget
00:15 this year for the next three months as it's an interim budget?
00:19 What are your expectations in terms of
00:22 fiscal consolidation part because I believe
00:25 no major announcements are expected for this year right now?
00:30 Well, it's right. It's a vote on account budget,
00:34 which means that typically these budgets are designed to
00:37 keep the fiscal wheels rolling until
00:40 the new government comes in power and represents
00:42 its budget in July reflecting its own economic priorities,
00:46 which means that we are not expecting a lot of
00:48 tinkering around the measures about revenue, for example.
00:52 We don't expect a lot of tax rate changes, so to speak,
00:55 but the government will still be announcing a full spending budget,
01:00 which will reflect its economic priorities,
01:03 its areas of growth that it wants to achieve,
01:06 as well as its thinking on the fiscal glide path,
01:09 which is how much of fiscal consolidation in
01:12 the fiscal deficit can be expected in this year.
01:15 Now, for the FY24 revised estimates,
01:18 that is the fiscal year ending March,
01:20 2024, we expect the government to show that they will be able to
01:23 meet their fiscal deficit target of 5.9 percent of GDP,
01:28 despite all the risks that we
01:30 have noticed occur through the course of the year.
01:32 But for the FY25 is where we see scope for about a 50-60
01:38 bid consolidation in the fiscal deficit to 5.3-5.4 percent of GDP, not more.
01:44 That is my key expectation from the budget.
01:48 How do you expect this FY25?
01:51 How do you see the government is going to meet or fall short
01:56 maybe of the fiscal deficit target for FY25?
01:59 How is the fiscal math looking like there?
02:03 On the question of fiscal math,
02:06 I think there is a need to take a step back and go to
02:09 the first February 2023 budget when the finance minister had
02:12 announced that they plan to take a fiscal deficit target
02:15 to 4.5 percent of GDP by FY26.
02:19 Now, if it has to be linearly spread in two years,
02:23 that means ideally the government should aim for a 70 basis point reduction
02:27 in the fiscal deficit ratio in FY25.
02:30 But I'm expecting about 50-60 basis points,
02:33 which is somewhat less than optimal.
02:35 The way I'm thinking about it is as follows.
02:39 I think the government spending,
02:40 when you look at the combined spending of states and center in GDP,
02:44 has become very important.
02:46 It's risen by about five percentage points in the last three years
02:50 and is perhaps at a historical high since the turn of the century.
02:54 It's not happened since.
02:55 I mean, you have to understand that government spending
02:57 has become the driver of growth.
02:59 There is a very significant push in terms of
03:01 CapEx as well as developmental spending,
03:03 which is benefiting the economy in very visible ways.
03:07 I mean, India is one of the economies which has emerged from
03:10 the pandemic with a high investment rate
03:12 and has a very solid growth fundamental.
03:14 I expect this to continue.
03:16 I don't see any reason for the government to sharply scale down
03:19 its spending in FY25,
03:21 because that would be akin to taking the wind out
03:23 from beneath the wings.
03:26 Now, where would the capacity then come from
03:29 to reduce the fiscal deficit?
03:30 And I think that's where the government should really
03:33 double down on its efforts of raising revenues.
03:35 You know, we've seen in the last three years that
03:38 tax collections have been quite buoyant and more particularly so
03:42 for the direct taxes, such as income taxes from corporate taxes,
03:46 personal income taxes and so on.
03:48 And I think that's where something positive might be growing.
03:51 So I think that, you know, they should aim for better
03:54 revenue mobilization in FY25,
03:57 which should create the fiscal capacity to reduce the fiscal
04:00 deficit ratio without withdrawing the support from growth
04:03 that it has given to the economy the last few years.
04:07 Right.
04:08 When you say a hasty fiscal retreat
04:11 may harm in FY25
04:15 because the GDP growth is expected to slow down.
04:18 What do you exactly mean by that?
04:19 What are the challenges that you see for GDP growth in FY25?
04:24 So three points there.
04:28 I think the first is that, you know, private consumption expenditure
04:31 growth is weak and we've seen that in the GDP prints
04:34 or whatever high frequency indicator of consumption you look at.
04:37 It is not portending a very strong trajectory ahead.
04:40 And mind you, private consumption is about,
04:43 you know, more than half of the GDP. Right.
04:45 So it's a very important component of GDP.
04:48 And if it grows slowly, you know, there's only so much the aggregate GDP can grow.
04:52 Right. This is where the government had stepped in with its expenditures,
04:56 especially on CapEx, which were growing very, very solidly,
04:59 giving that overall buoyancy to growth. Right.
05:01 So that's the spending.
05:03 That's a shortfall in account of private consumption that,
05:06 you know, we expect the government spending to keep plugging to some extent.
05:10 The second risk is around external demand outlook.
05:12 Of course, our exports are past their worst.
05:15 I mean, they have inflected, and that's true for most economies in the region.
05:18 But we're not very sure yet if this upturn will be a very strong upturn
05:23 because the developed market growth is expected to be slower
05:27 in 2024 than it was in 2023.
05:30 So there's going to be a measured upturn in exports, which means that external
05:33 demand conditions will not be a greatly supportive factor for growth. Right.
05:38 And the third bit is on the investment cycle itself.
05:41 So we've seen over the last two or two and a half years,
05:44 it's largely the public CapEx, the government CapEx
05:47 that's been driving the overall investment spending in the economy.
05:50 Now, we've done some calculation looking at, you know, monthly budget data
05:53 as well as the GDP data from the quarterly releases.
05:57 And we figured that that remains the case even until the Q3 of 2023,
06:01 the last GDP data that we have, you know,
06:04 there's been a modest upturn in the private CapEx cycle,
06:07 but it's not yet consistent or strong enough for us to believe that,
06:10 you know, the India's CapEx cycle is going to last long in a very strong manner.
06:15 So we are very hopeful of that happening, but we don't see any signs of that yet.
06:19 So, you know, given these three risks, I believe that, you know,
06:23 government spending support to the economy should continue, perhaps
06:26 for one more year.
06:28 And it should not be sacrificed at the altar of fiscal consolidation
06:32 when you have the opportunity of mobilizing better revenues
06:36 and creating that fiscal capacity that we have not had,
06:39 let's say, prior to the pandemic.
06:41 Right. Because you mentioned about spending.
06:44 So how does the expenditure profile looks like right now?
06:47 Because in the report as well, you mentioned that the spending
06:50 rejig is going to happen from CapEx to current now.
06:55 So what is the expenditure profile that you see for the rest of the year?
07:00 Look, for the year ending March 2024,
07:04 that is the revised estimates of FY24 are likely to show this modest
07:09 spending rejig.
07:10 And I say that because we know that through the course of the year,
07:12 there were extensive subsidy burdens that were not budgeted for
07:16 when the last budget was presented.
07:18 So I think about 50,000 crore rupees of additional, you know,
07:22 outgo is going to happen on account of subsidy burden.
07:24 And that will have to be met, of course, from better direct taxes
07:28 as well as some cut down from the CapEx.
07:31 Now, CapEx was budgeted at 3.3% of GDP.
07:34 And we know that the nominal GDP growth is going to surprise on the downside.
07:38 So even though they may cut, you know, from the nominal numbers,
07:41 some amount of CapEx, it would kind of remain similar around 3.3% of GDP
07:46 in terms of its share.
07:48 So from an economic importance perspective, it's going to remain the same.
07:53 But it's hardly a rejig, you know, of about 20, 30,000 crore rupees here and there.
07:58 That should not matter in the overall scheme of things.
08:00 Now, going ahead into FY25, I believe overall expenditures,
08:04 including revenue as well as CapEx could grow in the range of about 7 to 8%
08:09 over the year.
08:10 OK, when you say better direct taxes right now,
08:15 because the IMF fiscal monitor report has also mentioned that
08:20 there's a vast divergence between India's
08:23 revenues from global peers as well.
08:27 So why do you think that there has not been that good
08:32 direct tax collection revenue coming in?
08:35 What can be done to ensure that there is a higher
08:39 tax return, tax revenue for the government?
08:41 Look, there could be several factors behind, you know, this fiscal impediment
08:49 that, you know, we have not had very strong coverage of direct taxes
08:54 as a proportion of the taxpaying or the tax eligible
08:57 pool of people in the economy or firms, for that matter.
09:01 You know, some of the factors that come to top of the mind is poor compliance
09:05 because there's not enough surveillance or, you know,
09:08 all the processes are very cumbersome or the average incomes
09:12 were lower by themselves.
09:13 So a lot of these people fell into a bracket
09:15 there where they were not eligible to pay tax and not liable to pay taxes,
09:19 more so like.
09:20 And then the fourth factor is, of course, you know how big this pool was
09:24 of the people who are actually supposed to be paying taxes.
09:27 Now, I think there have been some structural factors, structural changes
09:31 which have been quite positive for this story.
09:34 And we finally think that, you know, the key fiscal impediment in India
09:38 or the constraint in India that we have had very poor tax compliance
09:42 could be beginning to ease.
09:43 Now, I've done some work on this and I figured that, you know,
09:46 using some statistical tests here and there,
09:49 we figured that about 20 percent and 10 percent of the rise
09:54 of the indirect taxes and the direct taxes in the annual format
09:58 between the last quarter of 2023 and Q2 of 2020,
10:03 that is during the pandemic, owed to factors like improved compliance.
10:07 Right. So that that's a significant chunk of money coming from the factors
10:11 that, you know, were initially not present.
10:13 Now, this makes us believe that, you know, all these positive
10:17 structural uptrends, whether it's digitalization or rising
10:20 average incomes or an expanding pool of taxpayers that we've seen,
10:24 you know, in the in the statistics of how many people have been filing the returns,
10:27 all of them are positive signs for tax collections to grow.
10:32 And this is where we think the government should really
10:34 double down on its effort and try to make the best of it as possible.
10:39 Right. One question related to the markets,
10:44 as we are expecting inflows to come in
10:46 in FY25, the bond inclusion
10:51 inflows in the GZ market.
10:54 You wanted to understand how does it going to impact the budget expectations
10:59 or how is it going to impact the budget overall?
11:01 And what is your sense on the market borrowing?
11:04 Sure. So I think this is perhaps the most important number
11:10 that everybody's looking for in the budget.
11:13 You know, markets are very quick to react to any signs of fiscal
11:16 indiscipline on the borrowing account.
11:18 But I think FY25 is going to be a relatively easier year for market
11:23 borrowings than than the years that we have seen recently.
11:25 And there's several factors behind it.
11:27 The first is, of course, the fact that, you know, across the board, I mean,
11:31 globally, we're expecting the central banks to cut the policy rates.
11:35 So the interest rate risk will recede, you know, and the market
11:38 should take it favorably for the RBI itself.
11:42 You know, we think that with the recent slip in core inflation below 4 percent,
11:46 the risks of a deeper and an earlier rate cutting cycle have risen.
11:50 And, you know, that bodes well for bond prices
11:54 as such, because the units could go down sooner than we are currently anticipating.
11:58 That's the first factor.
11:59 The second factor is, as you said, we're expecting a lot of inflows,
12:03 the foreign inflows on account of bond index inclusion.
12:06 I think the broader consensus is about 30, 40 billion dollars.
12:09 And we think that could represent a significant chunk of the
12:13 possible net supply in FY25.
12:15 So we think about 15, 20 percent could be digested by the foreign
12:18 institutional investors themselves, you know, which means that for the banks
12:23 and other domestic onshore participants, there will be relatively a smaller
12:27 pie of the net market loans that they will have to digest
12:30 than in recent years, you know, in a relative sense.
12:33 And come to think of it, you know, even the bank's own appetite
12:37 for bonds may improve in FY25.
12:40 We think so because, you know, GDP growth is expected to slow.
12:43 And we think that the loan growth may have peaked as well.
12:46 So as as also indicated by, you know, the RBI data,
12:52 the incremental loan deposit ratio is falling, you know,
12:55 which generally correlates well with yields.
12:57 So yields may come off as well.
12:59 And bond demand may improve.
13:01 And we've already seen some of this playing out, you know, in terms of FII
13:05 inflows and and some anecdotal evidence that banks have
13:09 appetite for bonds improving.
13:10 So overall, I think, you know, even if the government were to go
13:14 for a slightly higher borrowing program, you know, I'm expecting about four
13:17 percent higher gross market borrowing back at 16 trillion rupees.
13:21 Some I think the market consensus is that it will remain unchanged
13:25 to be a way for it to be for or even could be slightly lower.
13:27 I think all of that is within the band of digestibility, so to speak.
13:32 So I think I think it's fine.
13:33 It's a good deal for market borrowings.
13:35 And unless there is a sharp miss on the fiscal deficit targets,
13:42 I don't think markets should take it negatively.
13:44 Right. But are you expecting a sharp miss on the fiscal deficit target?
13:47 Because most of the economists are not expecting that.
13:49 But if you talk about FY26, what are your expectations there?
13:54 And again, my first question that are you expecting a sharp miss in FY26?
13:59 Because then there will be there has to be a balance.
14:02 So. Right, you're right in pointing out that, you know, if we have to hold
14:09 the four and a half percent of GDP fiscal deficit target as sacrosanct,
14:13 then we have to work really, really hard in FY26.
14:16 If we don't work hard in FY25.
14:18 But let me give you an interesting snippet.
14:21 I mean, you look at the history of fiscal consolidation in India,
14:24 whether it was right after GFC or during 2002 to 2005,
14:29 or thereabouts, or in the last decade for the for the good three to five years
14:33 till about 2018, you would realize that the contribution of GDP growth
14:38 to reduction of fiscal deficit ratio was consistently outstripping
14:43 that of actual fiscal discipline.
14:45 That is the cut in the fiscal deficit in nominal terms.
14:48 You know, this is an important reminder that, you know, fiscal discipline
14:53 and growth perhaps are equally important in leading you to the target
14:58 of fiscal deficit at four and a half percent.
15:00 So I would hope that, you know, as the government continues
15:04 to support the economy through its quality spending
15:06 and at the same time is able to mobilize revenues with the help of,
15:11 you know, the structural uptrends I mentioned, improving tax compliance.
15:15 I think it's creating enough fiscal capacity and enough GDP growth
15:19 for itself to land closer to the target, if not at it at FY26.
15:24 So so my bigger hope is that, you know, growth
15:28 will growth is a tide that can lift all the boats and it does so.
15:32 And I think that government should not withdraw its support from that.
15:36 Right. All right.
15:39 Dheeraj, I think we are at the end of the interview.
15:42 It was lovely having you on NDTV Profit.
15:46 Thank you so much for watching NDTV Profit.
15:49 Stay tuned for more news.
15:51 Thank you.
15:52 Thank you.
15:53 (dramatic music)
15:55 (music)