00:02Representative from Pennsylvania, Mr. McKenzie is recognized for five minutes.
00:06Thank you to the chairman, and I appreciate all of the testimony being provided today.
00:11Very important topic, integrating AI into our education system has huge potential benefit
00:17for our students.
00:18I think we're all aware of, even right now in its early stages, what it can do to increase
00:25educational opportunity and customization for students.
00:29So a lot of benefit there.
00:30We are also talking about some of the elements that we need to be aware of to make sure that
00:36we protect privacy and security for our students, great topics.
00:41But earlier we heard from a number of testifiers about bias that can be built into the AI systems
00:48that are being incorporated into the classroom.
00:51And I think we're all aware that depending on who nurtures or trains the AI, they're
00:56going to end up putting out different results at the end of the day.
01:00Ultimately, I think what we want for our students is a maximally seeking truth AI.
01:06We want the truth to be provided to our students.
01:10So it shouldn't be a corporation, it shouldn't be a foreign entity that is maybe weighing
01:14in on the results that are coming from AI.
01:17It shouldn't even be a politician on this panel saying that we need to reweight results
01:22so that we get the accurate outcome that we want for our students.
01:27So how do we and how should everybody be thinking about what AI we are selecting?
01:34What actual critiques or reviews of that AI is being made available publicly when we see
01:41that bias or misinformation is being included in results?
01:44And how does that get communicated to the decision makers in school districts or local
01:49entities that are actually picking the AI systems?
01:52And I'll go first to Dr. Rae Fulber.
01:58Thank you so much.
01:59Incredibly thoughtful.
02:00I think there's a couple of layers to that answer.
02:02I think from our perspective, we think states having AI assurance labs is one place to be
02:08able to examine this.
02:09Having one place where the public has a level of transparency about how the model on the
02:14front end before it is approved for use, what it has gone through to be rigorously
02:19tested.
02:20But then in an ongoing way, looking at the outputs of the model, knowing that these models
02:23evolve over time as people are using them.
02:27But I think you're also hitting a larger topic that we've talked about a few times about
02:30AGI.
02:32What happens when we get to a place where we are working alongside models that are doing
02:37things at the same level of humans, knowing that there's levels of bias within that?
02:42And I think that's where the importance of critical thinking and helping to really infuse
02:47in our students understand about ethics and ethical considerations is such a critical
02:52role of our K-12 system.
02:55And to be able to make sure that we're bringing those conversations often into these community
02:59engagement sessions and thinking about this.
03:02Because we'll never get rid of bias, but we can help to make sure we're shaping a generation
03:07of learners who deeply understand the power and importance of human relationship and when
03:12and where to use AI and under what conditions and how to evaluate those outputs consistently.
03:18I'll go to anybody else on the panel.
03:20Do you guys have any thoughts or are there resources available where people can go and
03:27see which AI systems are actually providing on a whole collectively maximally truth-seeking
03:36information?
03:37Because I think this is going to be a real challenge for everybody that is adopting this
03:42to have this kind of decision made in a classroom.
03:46It's akin to selecting your curriculum or your textbooks.
03:50But at the same time, there is a lot less information out there right now about these
03:54AI systems.
03:55So how do you as educators see that?
04:00I think that's a fantastic question and I want to reinforce what Dr. Rafael Behr has
04:05said.
04:07There's a step back in asking that question.
04:08I think making the analog to textbooks is very important because we're going to have
04:13to think about adoption in the classroom of various platforms in the same way we think
04:17about curricular adoptions of textbooks, both in finance models and in content models.
04:22But I think in answer to your bigger question, this is where the importance of demystifying
04:27these tools becomes critical.
04:29Because if we're going to move into the critical thinking position about having students be
04:34able to evaluate the information that's put before them, they first have to understand
04:38how those systems work, what an LLM does, where the data is pulled from, so that they
04:44can begin those evaluative processes.
04:46In other words, by demystifying the function of a generative AI tech allows the student
04:53then to see the working model and understand these are now the questions I have to ask.
04:59As to resources for identifying which platforms are more viable than others, the first thing
05:05we have to acknowledge is that what we need is more research and development for platforms
05:10specifically designed for education.
05:13We do a lot in education of retrofitting to technologies that have already existed and
05:18put in play in industry and other places.
05:21We actually need platforms that are designed for education specifically.
05:25This is why Mr. Chisholm's approach to having his own independent server and his own model
05:31is a very kind of forward-thinking model.
05:33So I think the demystification process is critical.
05:36Well, I will wrap up.
05:38We are over time.
05:39But I want to thank all of you again for your very thoughtful input today.
05:42I think this is, again, an incredibly important topic as we look to advance education in our
05:47country.
05:48And I appreciate particularly that last point about demystifying the systems, because I'll
05:53date myself very quickly here.
05:56When I was growing up, scientific calculators were a new invention.
06:01But at the same time, we were always trained to actually understand the fundamentals and
06:06the processes before we used the scientific calculators to get the answer in a quicker
06:11fashion.
06:12So thank you again, and I yield back.