🟡Navantia ha ofrecido a Portugal las fragatas F-110 de España. Analizamos la ventajas, desventajas y oportunidades para España y Portugal de esta posible compra de F-110.

ídeos cortesía de:

NavantiaOficial

Canción de fondo: The Enemy de Alexander Nakarada. Licencia CC BY-SA 4.0.

#españa #portugal #spain #f110

Categoría

🗞
Noticias
Transcripción
00:00Hello, thanks for your question and welcome to my channel, Buscadores.
00:04Surriman Garcia, the defense analyst.
00:08We start today's report, starting the week with some good news,
00:14because Navantia's interest in offering its F-110 frigates to Portugal has been revealed,
00:23which will replace its current Vasco da Gama and Bartolomeu Díaz class frigates.
00:31And a very interesting commercial opportunity opens up to export the F-110,
00:39which is also a program that is advancing quite quickly, even with certain advances.
00:45Something that is very surprising in the Spanish defense industry, which is often subject to delays.
00:49In the case of the F-110, no, due to the application of technologies such as the digital twin.
00:54And for this reason, due to the success they are having, well, the F-111 will already be voted on in September,
01:04that we will make a video on the channel about it.
01:06And soon, next week, we'll have the S-22 Narciso Monturiol in the water.
01:12Navantia is on a roll.
01:13So, in this favorable framework for Navantia, it wants to export the F-110s to Portugal.
01:22Although we comment that we see it as difficult, because Portugal usually opts for German or Dutch ships as well.
01:32So, more than Spanish.
01:33But hey, you have to try.
01:36And in today's video we are going to explain the advantages, opportunities, benefits and risks
01:41which could have the export of the F-110 to Portugal.
01:46As you know, the F-110s are next-generation surface vessels.
01:49incorporating advanced technology and a modular design.
01:53It has an approximate displacement of 6,100 tons.
01:57A length of 125 meters and a beam of 18 meters with Coglach propulsion.
02:01It has a diverse armament, including a Leonardo D-127-64 cannon.
02:07A MK-41 ULS vertical launcher with 16 cells.
02:11Although, I comment, because this has been highly criticized of the F-110,
02:16can increase its cell count because it has multi-mission modules.
02:21It can have more cells to launch SM-2 and ESSM missiles.
02:26Also missile capacity for Tomahawk cruise missiles, although Spain does not possess them,
02:31But maybe Portugal, although it is very difficult, could interest them.
02:35It will be equipped with NSM missiles, close-in defense systems, and MK-54 light torpedoes.
02:42It can operate with two helicopters, unmanned aerial vehicles
02:44and also has multi-mission space for additional RIP and UUV payloads.
02:51Making it a versatile platform adaptable to various missions.
02:55And above all, the most important thing is that it significantly surpasses the capabilities of the frigates.
03:01that Portugal currently has and that need urgent renewal
03:08because they are very veteran ships and are not adapted to contemporary combat conditions.
03:16And, for example, the Vasco da Gama class frigates, based on the Meco 200PN design,
03:22They have a displacement of 3,300 tons, 115.9 meters in length and 14.2 meters in width.
03:29A combined diesel and gas turbine propulsion that allows it to reach 32 knots.
03:33The F-110s will supposedly be able to reach speeds of up to 30 or 35 knots, inclusive.
03:39It has Sea Sparrow and Harpoon missiles, M46 antorpedoes, a 100-millimeter cannon
03:44and a Vulcan Phalax point defense system.
03:47And they can operate with a Lynx MK95 helicopter.
03:52So we see that it obviously doesn't compare to the F-110 in any way.
03:58So, there we see the difference, which is quite noticeable.
04:04Its crew is 169 people.
04:06And as for speed, the average speed is 24 knots,
04:10But it is true that 32 knots can be reached in exceptional moments, so to speak.
04:16And as for the Bartolomeu Díaz, they are frigates acquired from the Royal Dutch Navy,
04:24formerly known as the Karel Durman class.
04:27The Bartolomeu Díaz was integrated into the Portuguese Navy in 2009.
04:31It has a displacement of 3,320 tons, 122.3 meters in length and 14.4 meters in width,
04:37being able to reach a maximum speed of 30 knots with Kodog propulsion.
04:40Its armament includes a 66-millimeter cannon, MK48 missiles, VLSC Sparrow,
04:48Harpoon anti-ship missiles, M46 autopederas and a Gull Keeper system,
04:51which is a 30 millimeter point defense system.
04:54And they operate with Westland Lynx MK95 helicopters.
04:58It is important to know the characteristics of these ships so that we can see the difference with the F-110s.
05:03and that the Portuguese realize that they are interested in this Spanish product
05:07because it will significantly increase its combat capabilities and the demand for its waters,
05:13that Portugal's exclusive economic zone is very extensive.
05:17And with the current geopolitical shift, even they may be threatened despite their alliance with the Anglo-Saxons.
05:24They have to take this into account.
05:26And that would have numerous benefits if Portugal buys the F-110s,
05:40who take into account that we could significantly increase our defense cooperation.
05:48For Spain the advantage would be a boost in defense,
05:52because it would be a large-scale Panamanian contract.
05:55Because Vasco de Agama's frigates are 3 and the Bartolomeo Díaz is going up,
05:59so there are 4 frigates.
06:01It is a large-scale Panamanian contract,
06:04consolidating its leadership in military shipbuilding.
06:06This would translate into an increase in workload,
06:09the creation and maintenance of highly qualified employment
06:10and a significant economic boost for the regions where Navantia operates,
06:15strengthening the supply chain of the Spanish defense industry,
06:18benefiting numerous user companies.
06:19And for Portugal the advantage, firstly due to proximity.
06:23Yes, there won't be any problems logistically.
06:26Furthermore, they are built in Ferrol, which is very close to Portugal.
06:30Then there would be an industrial return for Portugal as well.
06:34It is even very likely that part of the frigate was built in the Portuguese Nation.
06:41It is an incentive for them to buy these ships from us.
06:43and although we may lose some income,
06:45But even so, with what the F110 costs, we are going to make a profit.
06:48And it's a workload for Navantia and can also help it gain more clients.
06:54So, it would be a substantial sale that benefits both of us,
06:59not only to Spain, but to Portugal as well.
07:02It would be the most logical request to have this type of ships,
07:05which also has North American systems.
07:07So, first, the United States is going to support this sale.
07:11Second, Portugal, as it has many links with the Anglo-Saxons,
07:14It is also a plus that the F110 has American systems and weapons.
07:19and of these Anglo-Saxon nations.
07:23It would also lead to a strengthening of bilateral nations,
07:26since a joint defense project of this magnitude
07:28would further cement political, economic and military relations
07:32between Spain and Portugal,
07:34which are sorely needed in the face of the threats we face.
07:38Because Spain and Portugal live in many ways separately,
07:41despite being neighboring countries.
07:42So that has to change, especially in defense.
07:45Also, interoperability and synergies in this area,
07:49in the military field.
07:50Since the operation of the same model of frigate,
07:52in part from the Spanish and Portuguese pods,
07:54would substantially improve interoperability
07:56in joint NATO and European Union missions.
07:59And it benefits us, and also for joint defense
08:02from the Iberian Peninsula.
08:04That we have many interests in common and we share many things.
08:07Portugal must banish its old fears,
08:11because we have gone several centuries without any conflict.
08:13So, we have to put that aside.
08:17Then, to the economies of scale and cost reduction.
08:20Since a pedigree of F110 frigate would allow Navanti
08:23to benefit from economies of scale.
08:25Of course, because there would be many ships.
08:27And higher production volumes would optimize remanufacturing processes.
08:32It would reduce the unit costs of acquiring components and raw materials.
08:36and would improve overall efficiency.
08:38This could translate into a lower cost per frigate.
08:41Not only for the Spanish Navy, but also for the Portuguese Navy.
08:44If we take into account that the Spanish Navy wants to acquire
08:45two additional F110s specialized in anti-aircraft combat.
08:49So, there is a benefit for both countries.
08:54So that we can see the advantages that this can bring
08:57for Portugal to buy F110 frigates.
09:01Also positioning of the F110 in the international market.
09:04As we mentioned, since the sale of the F110 to Portugal,
09:07an allied country and member of NATO,
09:09would serve as an important endorsement and reference
09:10for frigates on the international market.
09:13Demonstrating Navanti's export capabilities
09:15and the quality and reliability of the F110 design.
09:17Opening new sales opportunities
09:20to others more interested in modernizing their fleets.
09:23Now we go there in our analysis to the weaknesses.
09:27First, a possible delay in the delivery of the Spanish Armada.
09:29Since an additional order from Portugal
09:31could saturate Navanti's production capacity.
09:34Which would potentially result in delays
09:36in the delivery of the F110 frigates
09:38destined for the Spanish Navy.
09:39Especially the two additional ones that the Navy wants
09:44could be affected.
09:45Affecting replacement planning
09:49of the frigates of the class
09:50that we currently have
09:53and the operational capacity of the Spanish Navy.
09:57But this is solved, as we already mentioned,
10:00in a video on the channel a long time ago
10:02with having one more shipyard for Navantia.
10:04The same thing happens with submarines.
10:06Well, with submarines it is even more pressing.
10:08If a country orders submarines
10:11Production in Cartagena is not enough.
10:13We'll have to have another shipyard.
10:14With the F110s it could be solved more
10:17but it would still be necessary to have a larger shipyard
10:20that we discussed that the ideal location would be
10:23in Cantabria, the town of the shipyard.
10:26Besides, he already has the name and he's already leaving it.
10:27quite clear, significant.
10:29We were also evaluating in Asturias
10:31but Asturias already has it too
10:32a fairly large defense conglomerate
10:34and we must support other communities as well.
10:36And Cantabria needs it.
10:38I don't say in the Canary Islands because
10:40because we have a fairly large shipyard
10:44but due to the proximity to its southern neighbor
10:47because it becomes impossible.
10:48And Andalusia already has quite a bit of production.
10:51It could also be valued in other areas of Spain.
10:54But for now we consider Cantabria to be the most suitable.
10:57There is also the transfer of sensitive technology
10:59since the sale of a weapons system
11:01as advanced as the F110
11:03involves the transfer of technology
11:05and technical knowledge to Portugal
11:07because they are going to demand something in return and transfer.
11:11But with Portugal for the moment
11:13we have nothing to have
11:14because we have a very significant advantage
11:16at the economic and military level
11:17and even if they have technology
11:19to develop a ship
11:22This guy is not going to be a problem.
11:24even as a competition
11:26does not have industrial production
11:27nor naval to confront us.
11:29So there will be no fear at that point
11:32but it must be noted.
11:34Now opportunities
11:36which opens the possible purchase
11:38by Portugal
11:39of F110 frigates.
11:41First program development
11:42of industrial cooperation
11:43since the acquisition of the F110
11:46could be the catalyst
11:47for the launch of programs
11:49of this type
11:50between Spain and Portugal
11:51in the defense sector.
11:53With joint development
11:54of new technologies
11:55the production of components
11:57or collaboration
11:58in maintenance and modernization
11:59from other weapons systems
12:00such as patrol cars, armored vehicles
12:02or command and control systems.
12:04This synergy was further strengthened
12:05the defense industrial base
12:06from the Iberian Peninsula.
12:07We can create an Iberian corridor
12:08that would be spectacular
12:10with the creation of an Iberian pole
12:12military shipbuilding
12:14since a strategic collaboration
12:16and continues training
12:17in front of the Portuguese shipyards
12:18could lead to the formation
12:20of this long-awaited
12:21Iberian center
12:22military shipbuilding
12:24allowing both countries
12:25consolidate their capabilities
12:27increase their competitiveness
12:28at European and international level
12:29and position yourself as an actor
12:31relevant in the global market
12:33naval defense.
12:35And then having this
12:37the consequence
12:38a greater weight
12:39from the Iberian Peninsula
12:40in NATO and the European Union
12:41with greater integration
12:42and cooperation
12:43in defense of Spain and Portugal
12:44symbolized by adoption
12:46of common platforms
12:47like the F-110
12:48gaining weight
12:49geopolitical and strategic
12:50from the Iberian Peninsula
12:51within NATO
12:52and the European Union
12:53allowing to influence more actively
12:55security policies
12:56and European and Atlantic defense
12:58and defending the interests
13:00from Spain and Portugal
13:00more effectively
13:01let's imagine the repercussions
13:03that I could have.
13:04Now the threats
13:05the risks
13:06first
13:07evidently competition
13:08from other countries
13:09from Damenco
13:10that is Dutch
13:10from Germany
13:12also France
13:13although France is
13:14in the aeronautical field
13:15with the Rafal
13:15but there could be competition
13:18by these countries
13:19and Portugal we already know
13:21that there are certain sectors
13:22who are afraid of him
13:23to Spain
13:24because they fear
13:25a possible dependency
13:26of our country
13:27but they know us
13:28and they know that
13:28we are not going to pressure them
13:30that way
13:30we could put pressure on them
13:31for years now
13:32without any problem
13:33even up to
13:34we gave it up
13:34the savage islands
13:35the terrestrial realm
13:38of the wild islands
13:38we gave it to him
13:39so
13:39They know that
13:41they have nothing to fear
13:42that Spain
13:43will not invade them
13:44then it is
13:45the second point
13:46financing problem
13:47by Portugal
13:48this is a problem
13:50because
13:50these are broken
13:51They are quite expensive
13:53then require
13:53a financial investment
13:54considerable
13:55Portugal
13:56he doesn't have much money
13:58doesn't have a budget
13:59very high defense
14:00apart will be embarked
14:01if it's not the Rafale
14:03is going to buy the F-35
14:04and it's a lot of money
14:05then it is complicated
14:07that I can buy
14:08F-110 frigates
14:10there should be
14:11probably
14:11a loan
14:12on the part of Spain
14:13a return
14:14considerable industrial
14:15then there is
14:17the dependency
14:17from foreign suppliers
14:19because it's true
14:19that the F-110 frigates
14:20part of the systems
14:21They are Americans
14:22oh well
14:23like Portugal
14:24is a faithful ally
14:25from Washington
14:26and from London
14:27Well, there won't be a problem
14:28they will even be happy
14:29that we sell to you
14:31the F-110s
14:31for them to obtain
14:32their companies benefit
14:33what is the strategy
14:34what Navantia has done
14:35with the implementation
14:36of American material
14:37and how successful
14:38has given him
14:38For example
14:39in contact with Agustrali
14:41it has been a tactic
14:42quite interesting
14:44so
14:44What is the question?
14:47in our opinion
14:48about the possibility
14:49acquisition
14:49of F-110 frigates
14:50by Portugal?
14:52it would be an opportunity
14:53immense for both countries
14:54to strengthen
14:55defense cooperation
14:57for Portugal
14:58would give you benefit
14:59even
14:59for development
15:01of its naval industry
15:02it would be beneficial
15:03the industrial return
15:04and improve defense
15:05from the Iberian Peninsula
15:06that we have to see it
15:07on the whole
15:07because as we discussed
15:09the threats
15:10that run
15:11in our times
15:11they are quite tall
15:13then we have to
15:14have a defense
15:15joint
15:16that is very important
15:19so
15:19This sale
15:21would also consolidate
15:23Navantia's position
15:23as a leader
15:24military unconstitutionality
15:25and would center the bases
15:27for cooperation
15:27in defense
15:28deeper
15:29what is it
15:30we really want
15:31and improve the relationship
15:32in defense
15:32with Portugal
15:33that also
15:33they too
15:33can export to us
15:34material
15:35For example
15:36Tekebar drones
15:37or other systems
15:38that they too
15:38have
15:39have
15:41their developments
15:43and we
15:43from Spain
15:44with great pleasure
15:45we would acquire them
15:46so
15:46I would be
15:47a relationship
15:48mutual
15:50bilateral
15:51and
15:52remove the topic
15:53of the Portuguese
15:53that Spain
15:54will take advantage of that
15:54for
15:55take over the country
15:56or do anything
15:57that times have changed
15:58we are in a time
15:59of Philip II
16:00It is the same as
16:01France
16:01who is afraid
16:02and many times
16:03that Spain
16:04going to have
16:05some posture
16:06aggressive with them
16:07when in addition
16:08in the case of France
16:08It also has
16:09more military power
16:10that Spain
16:11that is not going to happen
16:12but with Portugal
16:13we can understand it more
16:14because it is a country
16:14which is smaller
16:15and the geographical position
16:17that has
16:18facilitates an invasion
16:19on the part of Spain
16:19but that
16:20it's not going to happen
16:22besides
16:22Spain
16:24respects the law
16:24international
16:25so
16:26is not going to take over
16:27from other countries
16:28and break down borders
16:29in our opinion
16:30anyway
16:31we see more feasibly
16:33the F-110
16:33offer them an Alfa 4000
16:35or an Alfa 3000
16:36because for the budget
16:38that Portugal has
16:39of defense
16:39it would be more optimal
16:41dispose of
16:42this guy
16:42of light frigates
16:44more than an F-110
16:45an F-110
16:46it would be a jump
16:47of giant
16:47for Portugal
16:48but
16:49we see more feasible
16:51the Alfa 3000
16:52For example
16:53offered them to them
16:53to Sweden
16:54also in his time
16:54Well, for Portugal
16:57could come to them
16:57very good
16:58would be much less
16:59expensive
17:00would obtain industrial return
17:01and also
17:02they would be airplanes
17:03powerful
17:04although it is true
17:05that the jump
17:06of capabilities
17:07it wouldn't be that high
17:08between a Basque
17:10of range
17:10and an Alfa 3000
17:12although the Alfa 3000
17:12it is better
17:13but
17:13it's not the same
17:14or an Alfa 4,000
17:16it's not the same
17:16that
17:17have
17:18an F-110
17:20we do not say
17:21ahead
17:22because they are needed
17:23in the case of Portugal
17:24need
17:24ships
17:25with a radius of action
17:26very high
17:26and autonomy
17:27although the forward
17:28understands it
17:28but a frigate
17:30it is more interesting
17:31for them
17:31because more than for the coast
17:33they are going to fight
17:33on the high seas
17:34so
17:34and for defense
17:35of its economic zone
17:36exclusive
17:37then we see him better
17:38a light frigate
17:41an Alfa 3000
17:42or an Alfa 4000
17:43oh well
17:44if we can sell
17:45the F-110s
17:45obviously
17:46better
17:46no one is marked by a sweet
17:48as the expression says
17:49so
17:50it would be ideal
17:51for Spain
17:52and would lay the foundations
17:53for cooperation
17:54Iberian
17:55quite remarkable
17:57and also
17:58that interests us in Spain
17:58that Portugal
17:59is well defended
18:00because the Iberian Peninsula
18:01you have to see it
18:02as a whole
18:03and if Portugal
18:04is better armed
18:05well, ideal for us
18:06in case of
18:07conflict
18:07that they can do to us
18:09support also
18:10so
18:11what needs to be done
18:12the obstacles
18:13are the competition
18:14and also
18:14Portugal's distrust
18:15with respect to Spain
18:17but let's wait
18:18that they
18:19These fears
18:21they leave
18:22to fade away
18:23that the F-110
18:25we have also seen
18:25that its manufacture
18:26is being
18:27very fast
18:29so
18:29there can be no complaints
18:30about it
18:31and for Portugal
18:32delivered quickly
18:33the Avante
18:33For example
18:342200
18:35are being handed over
18:36in record time
18:37to Saudi Arabia
18:38and the same can happen
18:39with the F-110
18:40thanks to technologies
18:41digital twin
18:42and style 4.0
18:43that could benefit
18:45Portugal too
18:46so
18:46we recommend
18:47to the Portuguese Navy
18:49that is raised
18:51acquire
18:51the F-110s
18:52and if not
18:53the Alfa 3000
18:54or Alfa 4000
18:55that would come to him
18:56pretty good
18:57for defense
18:58of its extensive
18:59exclusive economic zone
19:00that can awaken
19:01the appetite
19:02third-nation
19:04Well, up to here
19:05the defense report
19:06today's
19:06What do you think about that?
19:07Portugal can buy
19:08F-110 chips?
19:10leave your message
19:10in the comments box
19:11from the video
19:12follow us on our channel
19:12from Trenar
19:13writing
19:13Ruimán García
19:14the application finder
19:15I recommend them to you
19:15strongly
19:16because we have
19:17very interesting debates
19:19and all kinds
19:19of themes
19:21that they will like
19:22quite
19:22and see you
19:23in the next
19:25informative
19:26of defense
19:26Thank you!

Recomendada