• 5 months ago
The Indian government has defended its temporary ban on Telegram before the Delhi High Court, labelling the messaging app a hub for organised crime, terror-related content, and exam fraud.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:07Hello and welcome. You're watching Statecraft with me, Geeta Mohan.
00:10Now, can a government protect digital security without restricting digital freedom?
00:15And while one battle unfolds in a courtroom, is another quietly reshaping the map of Asia?
00:21Tonight, two stories about power and control.
00:23One centres around Telegram, a platform used by millions in India, now accused by the government of becoming a hub
00:31for crime, exam fraud and even extremist activities.
00:36But does a platform-wide ban go too far? And then, far out in the South China Sea.
00:42China is turning a tiny reef into what could become a major strategic outpost.
00:47One story is about controlling information, the other is about controlling territory.
00:52Both raise the same question. Who gets to set the rules?
00:56After weeks of intensifying Russian bombing of Kiev, Ukraine now hid back at Moscow with a swarm of drone strikes
01:04and what appeared to be the largest attack on the capital since President Putin plunged the region into a full
01:11-scale war in February 2022.
01:13The barrage, which left at least 17 people injured, was part of a larger Ukrainian attack over a broad swath
01:20of Russia,
01:21with air defences intercepting almost 1,000 drones, according to the Russian Ministry of Defence.
01:28Stunning footage shared online showed a fuel tank detonating, sending part of its roof soaring into the air,
01:34before flames engulfed one of Moscow's most important energy facilities.
01:39The impact of the dramatic Ukrainian strikes will be psychological.
01:43For the first time since the war, Ukraine has brought the consequences of the war closer to ordinary Russians.
01:50The apocalyptic scenes in Moscow serve as a stark reminder that Moscow and its suburbs are no longer insulated from
01:56the conflict
01:57and are increasingly a part of it.
01:59A messaging app used by more than 150 million people in India is now at the centre of a major
02:06legal and political storm.
02:08The government has told the Delhi High Court that Telegram is becoming the new dark web,
02:14a platform increasingly linked to criminals, exam fraud networks and even terror-related content.
02:20At the heart of the dispute is a temporary ban imposed ahead of the NEET-UG re-exam, India's nationwide
02:27medical school entrance examination.
02:29And a fundamental question now before the court,
02:32is this a necessary step to protect public order or a disproportionate strike against free speech?
02:38The centre's argument is stark.
02:41In an affidavit filed before the Delhi High Court, the government says Telegram is no longer just a messaging platform.
02:48It has evolved into a hub for organised criminal activity.
02:51Officials claim it is being used to distribute leaked exam papers, run cheating syndicates and coordinate payment networks for fraud.
03:00The ban was imposed under Section 69A of the Information Technology Act by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology,
03:08temporarily restricting access to the platform in India.
03:11The measure was timed around the National Eligibility Come Entrance Test under graduate re-examination
03:18after allegations of a major paper leak forced cancellation of the original exam held in May 2026.
03:26Government lawyers told the court the concern was not isolated incidents but scale.
03:31One Telegram channel reportedly titled NEET Mafia had over 18,000 subscribers
03:37and was allegedly used to circulate leaked content, arrange payments and promise access to exam material.
03:45Officials argue that this shows how quickly unlawful content can spread
03:49when the platform itself is designed for mass distribution.
03:53The affidavit goes further, describing Telegram's architecture as a structural risk.
03:58It is fully cloud-based, supports channels with up to 2 lakh members and allows broadcasts to unlimited audiences.
04:07It also enables bots and anonymous usernames, making it difficult for investigators to trace real identities behind criminal activity.
04:17Authorities say the platform has been linked not only to exam fraud but also to drug trafficking,
04:23cyber scams, child exploitation material, piracy and extremist propaganda.
04:29The government argues that when unlawful content becomes rampant and repetitive,
04:35selective removal is not enough, leaving blocking as the only effective option.
04:42But Telegram is pushing back hard.
04:44In its challenge before the court, the company says,
04:47the ban is unconstitutional and grossly disproportionate.
04:51It argues that blocking an entire platform is effectively a blanket shutdown of communication
04:58for millions of legitimate users.
05:00The company insists it has already taken down more than 900 links related to the alleged NEET leaks
05:07and is actively using AI tools, machine learning systems and human moderators to detect violations.
05:13It also warns that the government's approach risks setting a dangerous precedent,
05:18one where entire digital platforms can be suspended instead of targeting individual bad actors.
05:25Pavel Durov, who has also questioned the logic of the restriction, saying,
05:31punishing the platform's Indian user base does little to stop insiders who originally leaked the exam material.
05:38At the core of Telegram's argument is a constitutional concern, freedom of speech.
05:43The company says the order violates the rights of users, including students and educators,
05:49who rely on the app for study groups, coaching networks and academic communication.
05:54It warns that allowing such restrictions could open the door to indiscriminate suspension of digital platforms in future cases.
06:03The government argues that the issue now extends far beyond exam fraud.
06:08In court, it described Telegram as increasingly functioning like a dark web in plain sight,
06:15where even terrorist groups can communicate, recruit, distribute propaganda and coordinate activities through encrypted channels.
06:23Officials contend that these growing security concerns justify stronger intervention powers
06:28when public order or national security is at risk.
06:32Critics, however, warn that broad restrictions on major communication platforms
06:37could set a precedent for excessive state control over online speech,
06:42raising concerns about transparency, accountability and civil liberties.
06:48Officials argue that if leaked papers circulate freely ahead of a national exam,
06:53it could undermine trust in public institutions and trigger wider disruption.
06:58So the Delhi High Court now finds itself weighing two competing realities.
07:03One, a platform described by the government as a digital haven for criminals, fraud networks and extremist content.
07:11On the other hand, a global messaging service arguing that a blanket ban punishes millions of ordinary users for the
07:19action of a few.
07:21The outcome will have implications far beyond this case.
07:24If the government's position is upheld, it could strengthen the state's ability to impose temporary platform-wide restrictions during emergencies.
07:32If Telegram succeeds, it could tighten the legal limits on digital censorship
07:36and reinforce stronger protections for intermediary platforms.
07:41For now, the ban remains temporary, but the debate is anything but.
07:46It is no longer just about exam leaks or even one messaging app.
07:50It is about where India draws the line between digital security and digital freedom in an era
07:56where platforms are no longer just tools of communication, but contested battlegrounds of law, power and control.
08:04Something strange is happening in the South China Sea.
08:08China may be building a new military airbase in the South China Sea.
08:12But it is not just what China is building.
08:14It is about why it is being built now.
08:17This is Antelope Reef.
08:20Until recently, it was barely visible above water.
08:24But since October, China has used massive dredging operations to create a 600-hectare artificial atoll.
08:32Millions of tons of sand have been moved from the seabed, creating a new island where there was almost nothing
08:39before.
08:39China says the project is meant to improve living conditions, support workers and boost the local economy.
08:46But that explanation has raised questions, because Antelope Reef is starting to look less like a civilian project and more
08:54like a military facility.
08:55Satellite images show a mostly circular island outline with a long strip of land that could fit a runway nearly
09:042,700 meters long.
09:06That is almost identical to the design of China's military airbase at Mischief Reef.
09:11And if construction continues, Antelope Reef could soon become the largest artificial island in the South China Sea.
09:19So why is China building?
09:22And why after almost a decade of silence?
09:25To understand that, we have to go back.
09:27This is not China's first major land reclamation campaign.
09:31In 2013, Beijing launched one of the largest island-building projects ever seen in the South China Sea.
09:38More than 20 reefs and islands were expanded and seven were transformed into military bases.
09:45The focus was the Spratly Islands, a region where China, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and Taiwan all have competing claims.
09:54China claims almost the entire South China Sea through its controversial nine-dash line,
09:59a boundary that gives Beijing control over a huge area of the waterway.
10:05The problem is that several other countries, including Vietnam, Philippines, Malaysia, Taiwan and Brunei, reject it.
10:12They argue that China's claim overlaps with their own waters and their own islands.
10:18The result was a massive strategic shift.
10:21Tiny reefs that were once underwater became islands with runways, buildings and military infrastructure.
10:27Three locations became especially important.
10:30Mischief Reef, Fury Cross Reef and Subi Reef.
10:35These were not just construction projects.
10:37They changed the balance of power in one of the world's most contested seas.
10:42But then, in 2015, something changed.
10:45China's dredging campaign suddenly stopped.
10:48Why?
10:48There are two major theories.
10:50One explanation is growing international pressure.
10:52The Philippines challenged China's claims at an international tribunal.
10:56And in 2016, the court ruled that China's claims inside the nine-dash line had no legal basis.
11:03The decision was a major diplomatic setback for Beijing.
11:07Another theory is that China had already achieved what it wanted.
11:11The bases were built.
11:12Infrastructure was in place.
11:14China could use those facilities to expand its military and maritime presence without needing to keep creating new islands.
11:21For almost a decade, China did not launch another major reclamation project.
11:26But that does not mean it stepped back.
11:30Instead, Beijing used its existing bases to increase pressure on other claimants,
11:35especially the Philippines, using Coast Guard and maritime forces to strengthen its control.
11:41Then came the surprise.
11:43China returned to land building.
11:45But this time, the location was different.
11:48Antelope Reef is not in the Spatleys.
11:51It is in the Paracel Islands, in the northern part of the South China Sea.
11:56And this is where the mystery deepens.
11:59The Paracels are claimed by both China and Vietnam.
12:02China has controlled them since 1974.
12:05But Vietnam continues to dispute Beijing's claims.
12:08So why build here?
12:10One theory is that this is about Vietnam.
12:14Antelope Reef sits closer to suspected oil and gas deposits and important fishing grounds used by both Chinese and Vietnamese
12:21fishermen.
12:22China has long tried to prevent Vietnam from benefiting from the South China Sea's natural resources.
12:28But another possibility is that Antelope Reef is a response to Vietnam's own expansion.
12:34Over the past few years, Vietnam has launched its own reclamation campaign in the Spatleys Islands.
12:40Using similar dredging technology, Vietnam has created large amounts of new land and built new infrastructure.
12:46At one point, experts believe Vietnam could overtake China in total reclaimed land area.
12:53Antelope Reef may have changed that.
12:55A new round of competition appears to be taking shape.
12:59Not through open conflict, but through sand, concrete and strategic positioning.
13:04Vietnam has called China's construction at Antelope Reef illegal.
13:08China has responded by saying the Paracels are its inherent territory.
13:13But despite the public sentiments and statements, both countries have recently tried to manage their differences quietly.
13:20The biggest surprise here is the reaction from the outside world.
13:24A decade ago, China's island-building campaign triggered strong criticism from countries like the United States.
13:31But today, the response has been much quieter.
13:33The U.S. has shifted its focus toward the first island chain, stretching from Japan through Taiwan, the Philippines and
13:41Malaysia.
13:42The Paracels appear to fall outside that focus.
13:46And that silence may be one of the biggest signals.
13:49Because the South China Sea is entering a new phase.
13:51A phase where countries are no longer waiting for a major agreement.
13:56They are building, expanding and securing whatever territory they already control.
14:02Antelope Reef may just be one small island.
14:05But it represents a much bigger question.
14:08In a region where power is measured not only by ships and weapons, but by who can reshape the map
14:14itself,
14:14who gets to build first may determine who gets to lead.
14:19That's all in this edition of Statecraft.
14:22Before we go, here's a World Cup moment that's grabbing attention far beyond the football field.
14:27Back at the World Cup after 28 years, Norway's fans have gone viral with a synchronized rowing chant,
14:34shouting who, while mimicking the rowing of Viking longships.
14:39The display is a nod to Norway's Viking heritage and has already drawn comparisons with Iceland's famous Viking clap.
14:46A reminder that sometimes the most memorable World Cup moments come from the stands, not the pitch.
14:52Thank you for watching, goodbye and take care.
15:22Go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go,
15:27go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go,
15:28go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go,
15:28go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go,
15:28go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go,
15:30go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go
15:35You

Recommended