- 40 minutes ago
Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi sparked a political confrontation with the Bharatiya Janata Party following his address at Columbia University in New York.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening and welcome to The Point. Thank you very much for tuning in. I'm Pooja Shali.
00:04This evening we're going to focus on two big issues. One of course, what's unfolding with regard to
00:09Uttar Pradesh elections and huddles. And number two, and that's the debate, should Rahul Gandhi
00:14have made those comments abroad on foreign soil about India's internal situation? Let's begin
00:19first with the headlines. Prime Minister Modi's big drug eradication call getting emotional as
00:29well during this meeting with the ministers over the drug menace, tells ministers to save the youth
00:34from drugs, narcotic substances at any cost. Leader of Opposition's Rahul Gandhi's fresh
00:46attack from foreign soil. Speaking at the Columbia University, Rahul Gandhi cites joblessness and
00:51claims India is sitting on an economic disaster. BJP lashes out, says leader of opposition is
00:57spreading anti-national agenda again on international soil.
01:02The blunt thing is that India is sitting on an economic disaster. That's the reality. And
01:11one can brush it aside, the media can brush it aside, but India's got a massive unemployment problem.
01:23Battle for Uttar Pradesh is also heating up. Inside details of Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath's
01:28Mathura meeting, senior Modi ministers to lead the yathras across Uttar Pradesh. PM may address
01:33the gathering of yathras eventually in Lucknow. U.S. Amit Shah, Nitin Nabeen will also lead the
01:44campaigns. The latest coming in from Kashmir for the Kulgam CRPF terror attack, India avenging the
01:51death. The terrorist who opened fire at the CRPF Naka point and who was a mastermind as is believed by
01:56the forces has been neutralized. Even then, the armed forces maintaining all restraint, eventually also
02:04asking him to surrender, start a new alternate life. When he refused, the procedure was followed
02:10and he was neutralized as he was running out of a place of worship where he was hiding himself.
02:19In the top international news, Shenzhen, China is all set for the biggest trilateral of the world.
02:24Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin meet in China for the APEC summit. All eyes on the
02:30trilateral tomorrow. Big focus on nuclear non-proliferation and wars in Ukraine and Iran.
02:50So let's begin first with this report. It's a political fresh flashpoint that's erupted after the
02:55leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, made one remark after another.
02:59And this time in New York. He was speaking at the Columbia University and multiple engagements
03:04that he was a part of. Rahul Gandhi launched this scathing attack, except on his screen,
03:09targeting the Modi government, questioning India's electoral credibility, economic vision
03:14and the functioning even of the central agencies. Rahul Gandhi's remarks have triggered a sharp
03:19BJP counterattack, expectedly immediately, with the ruling party accusing him of maligning
03:25India on foreign soil. So the question we are asking, is this criticism valid? Is it about
03:31India's reality being mentioned on foreign soil? Or is this about defaming country and
03:37talking about internal politics? And is it a way of asking for foreign actors? All that and
03:43more first in this report.
03:48From questions over the 2024 Lok Sabha election results to serious allegations against central
03:55agencies, Rahul Gandhi has launched a wide-ranging attack on the Narendra Modi government from
04:01foreign soil. During an interaction at Columbia University in New York, the leader of opposition
04:07raised a host of issues, questioning the government's economic vision, electoral credibility and
04:13approach to education. Addressing the recent wave of dissent, Rahul Gandhi said that student
04:19protests had broken the climate of fear in India and warned that the government's response
04:23response to mounting protests could turn violent.
04:29If the pressure goes beyond a certain point, which it will, the government will react nastily.
04:37The government will not be so kind and will probably react violently and aggressively.
04:48Rahul Gandhi stressed that restoring India's electoral system is a priority and a
04:53alleged election rigging. He claimed that insiders in the election commission are sharing
04:58information with the Congress. Rahul also pointed to what he described as growing discontent
05:03within the bureaucracy, claiming that officials within the CBI and the ED are leaking information
05:09about alleged government wrongdoing.
05:12What's interesting is there is also a revolt in the bureaucracy. And there's also a revolt in the
05:19coercive elements of the state. You know, the CBI, the ED, the intelligence agencies, they're also
05:26revolting. And they are giving us information about this type of wrongdoing. So I'm quite positive.
05:35And making a pitch for his own political identity, Rahul said Prime Minister Modi could not compete
05:41with his distinctive style, citing the 4000-kilometre Bharat Joro Yatra.
05:48As a politician, even Mr Modi does not actually compete with anyone. If you think about it, he's
05:57fundamentally different than all other politicians in India. Would you agree with that?
06:02The BJP was quick to hit back, calling Rahul Gandhi immature, anti-India and the Mir Jafar of India.
06:09The BJP has said that every Indian feels ashamed by his statements.
06:30The Saffron party has also gone all guns blazing at Rahul over his dick at the BJP's 2047 Viksit
06:36of Bharat target.
06:39I also don't think GDP is the best number. I think it's a very deceptive number. There's
06:47no GDP number that says how settle your money. So to me, it's, it's a hollow number.
07:11The Rao comes just days after a massive political storm had erupted when an Italian politician raised
07:18the slogan, Vote Chor Gaddi Chor, at a Congress event in Hyderabad.
07:23Vote Chor Gaddi Chor.
07:30Courtesy translation, Vote Thief, leave your seat.
07:35As the showdown intensifies, the question is, do Rahul's remarks abroad amount to defaming the country
07:41or criticism of the government.
07:44Pure report, India Today.
07:54Let's debate and discuss and let's try and understand what is the strategy with our politicians
07:58talking about India's internal politics on foreign soil.
08:01Joining me from the Bharatiya Janata Party, the party has been all guns blazing against Rahul Gandhi.
08:07BJP National Spokesperson Sanju Verma is joining us.
08:11Also the party that's expectedly defending their leader,
08:14Bhavya Narasimha Murthy, Congress National Spokesperson.
08:17And he's been a former senior journalist.
08:20He's joining us as an author, political analyst, Ashutosh as well.
08:24Let's start with Congress.
08:25Bhavya, help me understand this.
08:27Why would a leader of opposition of the country in the Lok Sabha,
08:30senior leader of the opposition party,
08:33consistently speak about these issues of India's internal politics,
08:36realities or defaming is subjective.
08:39But speaking about it, on foreign soil,
08:41if it is not about asking for foreign actors to intervene,
08:45what else is it?
08:49So the problem is where he spoke or about what he spoke?
08:53Both.
08:54I just want to be sure before I answer.
08:55Both.
08:56Both.
08:57Okay.
08:58Starting with what he spoke,
09:00he stated facts from government agencies.
09:05Whether it is about inflation,
09:06the WPI inflation is 22% in October.
09:12All right.
09:13And sorry,
09:1412% in October,
09:15which was 11% in September.
09:17He's speaking about the price hikes,
09:20which is actually affecting the people of India.
09:24All right.
09:25Not just that,
09:26the top 1% of India's population is actually holding 40% of its wealth.
09:32And it is actually the national income is 22.6% of national income has been held by top 1%.
09:41And I don't see anything wrong in what he spoke.
09:45Although now coming to the point of where he spoke.
09:49Yes.
09:50Here, I would like to make two points.
09:51You know,
09:52I am an alumni of Columbia University and the same school,
09:56School of International and Public Affairs.
10:00There,
10:02the master's degree is public administration,
10:04where we,
10:06you know,
10:07prepare ourselves to be policy analysts and experts and policy makers.
10:11When you go there,
10:12and it is not just one country he is speaking in.
10:14Let me tell you,
10:15the class consists,
10:16during my time,
10:17it consisted of students from 89 nationals,
10:22people who are passionate about.
10:23There,
10:24we just not study about India or America.
10:25We study about every country,
10:27the economy of every country,
10:29the politics of every country.
10:31All right.
10:31The second point is,
10:33when Narendra Modi can stand on a political platform in America
10:37and say that he is ashamed of India,
10:39India,
10:40you expect a leader of opposition,
10:42not to speak about the government's inefficiency.
10:47Although,
10:48Mr. Gandhi did not speak anything.
10:48What comment are you referring to when he said...
10:50Let me finish.
10:51No, no.
10:51I am just asking,
10:52what comment are you referring to about PM Modi saying he is ashamed of India?
10:55Oh, PM Modi has said he was ashamed of being an Indian before 2014.
10:5914.
11:01Hmm.
11:01Yeah.
11:01He has said that.
11:02But,
11:03Mr. Gandhi has only said,
11:05and Mr. Gandhi has never spoken about India.
11:08The way BJP is portraying,
11:10BJP is a political party.
11:12BJP is not India.
11:14BJP is at the center forming a government today.
11:18Okay.
11:18They are not there forever.
11:19They cannot identify themselves as India.
11:22India is a country.
11:23Because Rahul Gandhi loves India,
11:26India,
11:26he is speaking for India
11:28and against every corruption that is happening here.
11:31Okay, point, point.
11:31And the inefficiency of the government.
11:33Sure.
11:33So, please do not term this as he is speaking against the country.
11:36He is speaking against the government.
11:37Let the BJP respond to that.
11:39Sanjay Warma, you heard.
11:40What was wrong?
11:41What he said?
11:42Where he said it?
11:43It should be seen as common and normal.
11:46And after all,
11:47he is speaking against BJP government,
11:49not India.
11:51You know, Pooja,
11:52I am an economist,
11:54you know,
11:54by education.
11:55I worked in one of the world's biggest global investment banks,
11:59JP Morgan.
11:59I have served in desks across the United States of America,
12:03UK,
12:04Hong Kong,
12:04Australia.
12:04So I know a lot more than just textbook economics.
12:08You know,
12:09I've been a high profile investment banker,
12:11if that helps.
12:12Now, let me tell you something.
12:13And this is what your audience needs to know.
12:16Rahul Gandhi was spewing gibberish and vicious lies.
12:19From fragile five,
12:22today, India last quarter grew at 7.8%.
12:25In the September quarter,
12:26we are expected to have a GDP growth of 7.7%.
12:30And let's not talk about wholesale inflation.
12:32Between 2023 and 2025,
12:35the wholesale inflation was negative.
12:37And at that time,
12:38Congress,
12:39Darbaris used to come on television channels and say,
12:42oh, wholesale inflation is not the correct yardstick.
12:44It is retail inflation.
12:46So let me tell you,
12:47between May and October,
12:49average retail inflation is 4.8%.
12:53The fiscal deficit today is 4.4%.
12:56Under Congress,
12:57it was 6.7%.
12:58The current account deficit today is less than 1%.
13:01Under Congress,
13:02it was 5.9%.
13:04Forex reserves under Congress were $287 billion.
13:07Today,
13:08it is $720 billion.
13:11And guess what?
13:12You want to reveal the source also, Sanju.
13:14Where are you quoting this from?
13:16Pooja,
13:17I heard her.
13:18You did not interject.
13:19I need my time.
13:20You can then question me.
13:21Sure.
13:21All these data points.
13:24She's asking for source.
13:24Can I please?
13:25You are number to Sanju or not?
13:26Go ahead.
13:27Please hold your horses.
13:27Let Sanju respond.
13:28Yes, go ahead.
13:28Yes.
13:29I don't know why she gets so rattled and starts smiling in a stupid manner without having correct data at
13:34her disposal.
13:34No personal remarks.
13:35Now,
13:36don't interject me,
13:37Pooja.
13:38What is the source?
13:40The source is finance ministry archives.
13:43The source is available in public domain.
13:46Okay.
13:47The source is secondary sources, primary sources.
13:50The whole world knows.
13:51Forget Sanju Varna.
13:52IMF,
13:53World Bank,
13:55OECD,
13:56Asian Development Bank,
13:57Goldman Sachs,
13:58Morgan Stanley.
14:00Till six months back,
14:01each of these institutions were saying India in FY27 will grow at perhaps 6.4% or thereabouts.
14:09Today,
14:10all of them are saying India will grow at 7% or more.
14:13And mind you,
14:14Goldman Sachs barely 48 hours back said the US this year and next year 2.3% and 2.4%.
14:21The world economy this year and next year 2.7% and 2.8%.
14:25China this year and next year 4.5% and 4.4%.
14:30Okay.
14:30And what does Goldman say about India?
14:32One minute.
14:32Goldman says Indian GDP growth will be 7.9% this year.
14:39And 7.2% next year.
14:41This is not WhatsApp University saying so.
14:44We are also putting out data.
14:46We are also putting out data.
14:47We are also putting out data.
14:47Quotings from the World Bank report.
14:48Situation is better.
14:49Sanju.
14:50Second point.
14:51Then second point.
14:52So are facts the issue?
14:54Or the fact that he spoke in the USA is a problem?
14:56Quickly.
14:57Then I'll go to Ashutosh.
14:58No.
14:58I have one little point to make.
15:01What Modi ji said in 2010 or 2012.
15:04I can turn around and say.
15:05Did Narendra Modi,
15:06when he was the Chief Minister of Gujarat,
15:08ever say that
15:10that there was vote kept?
15:13Did he lampoon and criticize the judiciary?
15:16No.
15:16And do you remember Pooja?
15:17In 2013 at the UNGA meet,
15:21the dead Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif
15:23called the dead Prime Minister of India,
15:26Manmohat Singh,
15:27Dehati Aurat.
15:28Who opposed Nawaz Sharif's deplorable comments?
15:32Okay.
15:33It was the BJP.
15:34It was the RSS.
15:35We said calling the sitting Prime Minister of India.
15:38Okay.
15:39Then in 2013,
15:40Dehati Aurat is absolutely condemnable.
15:43But today, Rahul Gandhi,
15:44he's laughing like a spoiled,
15:46entitled brat,
15:48saying,
15:49Vote your gatti chhod.
15:50People say that
15:51on Indian soil
15:52at an Indian event,
15:54Rahul Gandhi
15:54starts cheering,
15:56cheering, sneering,
15:56and clapping.
15:57Shame on Rahul Gandhi,
15:59shame on the Congress party,
16:00and shame on the Italian no-butter.
16:02Is it about,
16:03even when you're targeting the Prime Minister,
16:05the manner in which it's being done,
16:06is it fair?
16:07Ashutosh is joining us.
16:08Also, Sujata Pandey is joining us
16:10as a political analyst.
16:11Ashutosh, first to you.
16:12You've been a journalist as well,
16:13and as political analyst,
16:14you tell me.
16:15What is your understanding?
16:16And this is not about BJP or Congress,
16:17but an opposition leader
16:18going on and on,
16:19constantly about what India has become,
16:22according to him.
16:23Is this fair?
16:24Does it look fine?
16:25Especially when the electorate back home,
16:26getting ready for elections,
16:28is watching.
16:30See, Pujad,
16:31there are three things.
16:31First of all,
16:32who started it?
16:33The Prime Minister Narendra Modi
16:35had gone to Seoul
16:35in May 2015.
16:37And you know what he said?
16:39Before coming,
16:40people said,
16:41we had done a wrong job,
16:43we had done a wrong job
16:43that I had to be born in Hindustan.
16:45You know?
16:46Can anything be more dangerous
16:48than this?
16:48Can it be more insulting
16:49to India than this?
16:51And then you know what,
16:52when the question was asked here,
16:54the Sudhanshu Trivedi has said,
16:56no, no, no, no, no, no,
16:56he was not attacking the India,
16:58he was just only talking about
16:59the policy paralysis in the country.
17:00So now the word has changed
17:02in 12 years.
17:04Now if the Rahul Gandhi
17:05has said something,
17:06now what Rahul Gandhi has said,
17:07I heard the entire conversation,
17:09he has said,
17:10the India is sitting
17:11as an economic disaster.
17:12Is it not a true?
17:14Is it not truth?
17:14The fact of the matter is,
17:16even the foreign...
17:17How are we sitting
17:18on an economic disaster?
17:19IMF says we are a bright spot
17:21in the dark horizon.
17:23Pooja,
17:23let me come,
17:24let me come,
17:25let me come.
17:25Please, please go ahead.
17:26And Sanju,
17:27Sanju Varma was quoting
17:28the foreign institutions,
17:30World Bank and all and all.
17:31Yes, yes.
17:31He has forgotten.
17:33IMF a few months back
17:34has said India's data
17:35should be put
17:36in the category C.
17:37That means Indian data
17:38is doubtful.
17:40Then former foreign,
17:42former finance secretary
17:43who has worked
17:44in the Narendra Modi,
17:45when the data came
17:467.8% GDP growth,
17:48he said it is not 7.8%,
17:49it is 2.6%.
17:51The Surjit Bhalla,
17:53the member of the
17:54Economic Advisory Council,
17:55he said,
17:56in 2013-14,
17:58India was in the
17:58Frasile 5.
17:59Now India is in the
18:00Frasile 2,
18:01along with Turkey.
18:03These are the people
18:04who had worked
18:05with Narendra Modi,
18:06the Prime Minister.
18:07And they do not have
18:08a very high opinion
18:09about Indian economy.
18:11Let me put the third thing.
18:13The WPI inflation
18:15is something around 12.29%,
18:18except the retail is 6.09%
18:21beyond the RBI's apprehensions.
18:24Food inflation is 8.3%,
18:27which is affecting
18:27every Indian in the country.
18:29The fuel and the power
18:30inflation is 32.84%.
18:33Then above all,
18:36India was known as
18:38a software superpower.
18:40In 2011 and 2021-22
18:46to 2024-25,
18:48there is a drop of almost
18:4930% in India's software exports.
18:52Now, a country which was supposed
18:54to be the software superpower,
18:56there is a drop from
18:5811.59 lakh crore
19:00to 7.75 lakh crore,
19:03that speaks volume about it.
19:06So, first of all,
19:07the BJP should answer
19:08to Subhash Garg,
19:10who said India's economy
19:11is not growing at 7.8%,
19:12but 2.6%.
19:14Let everyone have their say,
19:15and I will come back to you.
19:17Sujata Pandey is also joining me.
19:18Sujata, what do you think?
19:19Do you think that India's image
19:21has changed on the global stage
19:23compared to even what our leaders
19:25have been saying earlier,
19:27that compared to, let's say,
19:282014 or 20 or 2000,
19:30in 2026, that pride is more visible
19:33or all of that has been just rhetoric?
19:37Sujata Pandey,
19:37So, Pooja,
19:38First of all,
19:38I think Rahul Gandhi
19:39is sitting in a constitutional post
19:41and nowhere in the world
19:42you will have an example
19:43of an LOP going to a foreign
19:47land in the financial capital
19:48of the world
19:49and going and bashing
19:50his own country.
19:51This is Rahul Gandhi's
19:53own country as well, isn't it?
19:54It is not just Narendra Modi's country,
19:56it is Rahul Gandhi's country as well.
19:57And then I think
19:58it is just not bad optics,
20:00it's bad politics also.
20:02Because, you know,
20:03today, what do you,
20:04what does the youth look for?
20:05what Rahul Gandhi is raising,
20:07unemployment issues and education issues.
20:09And what is he denting at?
20:10He's denting the same investor
20:12which would come here and provide education,
20:15investment in the education sector
20:17and help the youth get employed.
20:20Then second thing is,
20:22I think neither Ashutosh or I don't know the other panelists
20:25is an MBA.
20:26I think Sanju and me can show their MBA degree
20:28and tell that how are the ratings of the whole,
20:31you know, this global education,
20:34global fintech, you know, the ratings have gone up.
20:36You know, S&P upgraded India's rating in 18 years.
20:40It made it BBB.
20:41In the last 18 years, it has never done that.
20:43It's because IMS has set it on record
20:45that India, the way India has been taking people
20:49out of poverty line is something that is for the books.
20:52Then from the IMS to the World Bank,
20:55to the S&P, to the Fitch,
20:57all of these reports are on the thing.
20:59So I think, you know, they would know much more
21:01better economics than Ashutosh for that matter.
21:04Then I think from an LOP perspective,
21:08he can definitely criticize government,
21:10but in here, when he goes out,
21:12he has to have data to show
21:14how Congress government was better than Modi government.
21:17But he knows that those will not fall flat on his face
21:20because the numbers can't even be compared.
21:23We were in Frasal 5.
21:24We were on the World Bank.
21:27Bhavya, you want to respond to that.
21:29She's made a good point, which is,
21:31with the kind of statements going from Rahul Gandhi,
21:34aren't you spreading a fear?
21:36There could have been actually investors,
21:38educationists who would be actually interested,
21:39Aukhin, to invest in India
21:41or take talent pool from here.
21:42Instead, you're giving this negative image
21:45that will impact India and Indians
21:46because going by the data,
21:48it appears that extreme poverty has come down.
21:51The GDP has seen a growth as well.
21:53The real GDP growth at about 7.8%
21:55in the first quarter year.
21:57I'm quoting some of the statistics
21:59that has come in from international organizations as well.
22:02Is this fear-mongering?
22:04Are you bringing in actors
22:05who need not interfere in our internal issues?
22:11Is this, you're asking me?
22:13Bhavya, yes, please go ahead.
22:14Because there was some,
22:15your voice was breaking before.
22:16Yes.
22:22Bhavya, for you, yes.
22:23Let me state some facts.
22:24Let me state some facts, right?
22:27If I state facts,
22:28maybe it's easy for you to understand.
22:30Let me read it out.
22:37Quickly, Bhavya.
22:38The government's latest release.
22:40The government's latest release.
22:42No, I'm reading the facts from
22:43the government websites
22:45that I have researched.
22:47The government's latest release,
22:49the July-September 2026 quarterly bulletin.
22:52All right.
22:52That was released on 10th of November.
22:54Shows the national youth number
22:56easing to 15.3%,
22:57but the improvement in entirely rural story.
22:59The rural youth unemployment
23:01fell from 14% to 13%.
23:04Rural youth employment,
23:05meanwhile,
23:06rose to,
23:07unemployment rose to 18.9%
23:10over the same quarter.
23:12With unemployment among the urban young women
23:15at 26% and urban young men
23:18at 16%.
23:19This is not Congress data.
23:21This is not some random third-party
23:24research person's data.
23:28This is the government's data
23:29recently released.
23:31All right.
23:32When you interpret data,
23:34you just want to be selective
23:36about the data you want to present.
23:38But let's talk about
23:40very common things
23:42that's affecting the common people.
23:44The petrol price,
23:45the diesel price,
23:47the LPG price.
23:49Most importantly,
23:50what's happening to the rupee?
23:52Dollar and rupee.
23:53To which,
23:54quoting Prime Minister Modi Bhavia for you,
23:56he spoke at the Bharat conclave.
23:57What I'm telling you
23:58is what the government says.
23:59Government says
24:00the price rise
24:01for the fuel
24:02could have actually gone much higher
24:04because of the West Asia war.
24:06It was actually the government
24:07absorbing a lot of that pressure.
24:10Okay.
24:13Then why is that pressure
24:15only forced upon the poor
24:18when the top 1% of population
24:22is holding 40% of the wealth?
24:24Okay.
24:25Let's take, let's Sanju take.
24:2624, 22% of national income.
24:27No, no, wait, wait, wait.
24:27One more point.
24:29Ms. Sujata,
24:29Ms. Sujata,
24:31I'm not sure if you actually heard
24:33what Mr. Gandhi said
24:34in Columbia University,
24:36if you had heard,
24:37you wouldn't say
24:38he was bashing India.
24:40He was, yes,
24:41he was exposing
24:43BJP's state of economic disaster.
24:45India is in a state
24:46of economic disaster.
24:48Okay.
24:49Sanju, the fact is,
24:51okay, there are some real concerns
24:52like unemployment,
24:54especially like inflation.
24:57So, if the leader
24:58is talking about...
25:00Bhavia, Bhavia, time's up.
25:01Time's up.
25:02Let Sanju respond now.
25:03Because if there are some real issues
25:05that he's speaking about
25:07in the USA,
25:08is that really a concern?
25:10Do you think that
25:11he's either exaggerating it,
25:13lying about it?
25:14Because some of these
25:14are concerns.
25:15Unemployment,
25:15inflation is a concern for India.
25:19Puja, now I don't wish
25:20to be heckled.
25:21Bhavia Narsimha Murthy
25:23is a rapid liar.
25:24I have the data
25:26from the Ministry
25:26of Statistics
25:27and Programme Implementation
25:29and this is the actual data.
25:31Let your audience know
25:32this dim-witted spokesperson
25:34knows nothing about economy.
25:36Oh my God.
25:37Sanju Verma,
25:38what are you saying?
25:39Puja, can I finish?
25:40You know, you're speaking
25:41on a national chalet
25:42and they can cross-check.
25:44You have to give me...
25:44Remember, they can cross-check.
25:45You have talked about everything.
25:47I did not...
25:48You have been running
25:48your whole life
25:49on television.
25:50Bhavia, let Sanju speak.
25:52Can you moderate the debate?
25:53Remember,
25:54you're on a national television.
25:56Can you moderate the debate,
25:57Puja?
25:57This is not done.
25:58Bhavia, let me speak.
25:59Let her finish your point.
26:00Let her make her clean.
26:01If it's a truth, let her make.
26:02Ladies, please.
26:03You liar.
26:03Yes.
26:04Okay, Sanju.
26:05Sanju, no person.
26:06Can I finish?
26:08No, I need to speak now.
26:09We'll restrict with personal remarks.
26:11Sanju.
26:11Yes.
26:11Only the facts.
26:12Go ahead.
26:13Your audience needs to hear this.
26:15Thank you, Puja.
26:16The Ministry of Statistics
26:18and Program Implementation
26:20has released this data
26:21for the month of October.
26:22The month of November
26:23data is not yet out.
26:25For the month of October,
26:27overall rural unemployment rate
26:294.2%.
26:31Rural male unemployment rate
26:344.3%.
26:35Rural female unemployment rate
26:383.8%.
26:40Overall unemployment rate
26:424.2%.
26:43Rural labor force participation rate
26:46its highest ever
26:48amongst females
26:49at 42%
26:51for males
26:52at more than 79%.
26:54And
26:55Bhavia had the audacity
26:56to say unemployment rate
26:57is 15%.
26:58I don't know
27:00but I will end
27:02very quickly.
27:03Puja,
27:04which is the second largest
27:05steel producing
27:08economy in the world?
27:09India.
27:10Which is the second largest
27:11cement producing economy
27:13in the world?
27:13India.
27:14Which is the second largest
27:15mobile phone
27:16manufacturer in the world?
27:18India.
27:18Which is the third largest
27:19automobile manufacturer
27:21in the world?
27:21India.
27:22Which is the largest
27:23two-wheeler manufacturer
27:24in the world?
27:25India.
27:26Which is the fifth largest
27:27economy in terms of stock market capitalization. India overtook Taiwan last year to become the
27:33fifth largest in terms of stock market capitalization. But Sanju, are you saying that there is no
27:38unemployment? Can I finish? Now, now, now. The IMF, and this is for Ashutosh. Yes, the IMF had
27:48flagged concerns pertaining to India six months back, but barely three weeks back, IMF applauded
27:56Narendra Modi for carrying out structural reforms and saying the fact that the Modi government
28:01changed the pace here from 2011-12 to 2022-23 is a great move. And as for Subhash Garg, I
28:09have
28:09nothing to say about a disgruntled, jobless man looking for opportunities. Well, you made your
28:16point. Sanju, you made your point and you made it how? But Ashutosh, because before I wrap up, I want
28:22everyone to have their say, Ashutosh, here's my question. And you can, of course, respond to what
28:25Sanju is saying. Let's say what Rahul Gandhi had to say. Some of those issues are pertinent.
28:31Make it back home. Elections are coming in. You're making these statements in the USA on
28:37foreign soil, which the BJP is cashing on to say, especially when Prime Minister Modi and the
28:45party still has a strong hold, especially in states like Uttar Pradesh. So come make it back home in the
28:50parliament, debate it. Why go all the way to the US or the UK to make such statements is what
28:55everyone's been asking, Ashutosh.
28:58Say, Pooja, first of all, let me correct my two colleagues on the panel. One, Sujata Pandey has
29:02said the leader of opposition post is a constitutional post. It's not a constitutional post. It's a
29:06statutory post created in 1977 by a law in the parliament.
29:10Okay, I'll tell you about this.
29:11Let's be very clear on this. Second point is, India doesn't manufacture mobile phones. It
29:31is very civil. Pooja, Pooja, I will not let her speak if she doesn't speak like this.
29:46Sanju, there's limited time, limited time. But there is an expansion that India has been
29:51doing in component in some assembly parts as well. Go ahead.
29:54I'm really, I'm really aghast. I'm really aghast that the former banker does not know difference between manufacturing and assembling.
30:03India only assembles mobile phone. It is not manufacturing. Let's be clear on this.
30:09The point number two, have you heard from the BJP in the last six months that India is the third
30:14largest economy?
30:15No, because it has slipped from fourth to sixth.
30:18Have you heard that India's stock market has shrunk and that is why it has slipped from fourth position to
30:23the seventh position?
30:24Have you heard how India's stock market is doing? In the last one year, 30 lakh crore money has slipped
30:32out of the stock market.
30:3430 billion foreign portfolio investment has gone out of India's market.
30:40And then she is critical about Subhash Chendikos. Fine.
30:44But what about the former chief economic advisor, Arvind Subramaniam?
30:47He is saying from the rooftop, writing articles after article, that India's data is doubtful and suspect.
30:54At least it has been artificially inflated by two to three percent.
31:00Final point. Final point.
31:01The IMF World Economic Outlook data says that Indian economy is growing at the rate of 4.2 percent, not
31:097.8 percent.
31:11And then, again I'll quote Sujit Bhala, whose work as economic advisory council, that per capita GDP growth in US
31:18dollar is...
31:19Sanju, Sanju, but I need to get all views. Because before I wrap up, I'm being told that time's run.
31:24Sanju, quickly, I want Sujata also to speak. I'm giving a chance to everyone.
31:29Sujata, as a closing comment that's coming in, at this point, everyone's been asking, especially from the ruling party, and
31:35people are watching it too.
31:36People are also wondering, if you have any view, you're meeting leaders like Ilhan Omar, who's a known India beta,
31:43you're interacting with individuals, do have a questionable authority as well, and importantly, why are you going to the USA,
31:50to the UK on foreign soil?
31:51If you have these issues, valid issues, debate it here on the soil. Voters are going to eventually vote for
31:57either Congress or BJP.
31:59Is it the electorate only that matters, Sujata? Or do you think the worldview also matters?
32:05No, both matters, Pooja, but at the right forum and at the right stage.
32:10In my opinion, any electoral, whether you're a Congress supporter or a BJP supporter, doesn't like India bashing, especially on
32:18a global stage.
32:19And that has been done repeatedly, and that has been used by BJP to counter Rahul Gandhi repeatedly.
32:25And still, Rahul Gandhi keeps on doing... I do not see, as a political analyst, that adds to anything to
32:30Rahul Gandhi's image. Rather, it dents his image.
32:32So, I think, and quoting Prime Minister Modi, I think this was a completely different context and different...
32:38So, you can't really give a panel. Prime Minister Modi never shamed the country. Rahul Gandhi shamed the country.
32:44And first of all, UP elections are coming. Rahul Gandhi should be here.
32:49The Congress spokesperson is short. The BJP spokesperson agrees to it.
32:54But I'm told that's all the time I have for... I'll really have to wrap up. I appreciate all of
32:59you for giving your views.
33:00Eventually, remember, Janata dek rehi hai. The people will vote.
33:04In Uttar Pradesh, in Punjab, in other states as well.
33:07They will decide if Rahul Gandhi is the next big leader.
33:11Is it Prime Minister Modi again? Is it Yogi Adityanath again?
33:14So, I'll leave it to the people watching. Eventually, you'll get to decide.
33:17And that's the voter of India.
33:19Thank you very much for watching this discussion.
33:21I have a big news coming in from Uttar Pradesh. Let's take a look at that.
33:26All right. The top breaking news right now, ladies and gentlemen, ahead of the Uttar Pradesh elections.
33:30Here on To The Point, I'm revealing to you about how Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan released from Dasna Jail
33:37in Ghaziabad.
33:38He's still a big figure when it comes to UP elections.
33:42His son, Abdullah Azam, was present to receive him following his speech.
33:45The Alabad High Court has granted this interim bail to Azam Khan.
33:50And remember, there was a money laundering case against him and it was registered by the enforcement directorate.
33:54Observing that the mandatory provisions governing his arrest were prima facie and not strictly for him.
34:00He was released from the Rampur district jail last month.
34:02He was granted bail in a forgery case and charges against him.
34:06This was 31st October.
34:07Then he was immediately re-arrested by the ED on the same day in a different money laundering investigation that's
34:13been on against him.
34:14Let's listen in to SP Chief Akhilesh Yadavaba.
34:34Samad Shrivastam, my colleague, is joining me for the latest on that.
34:37Samad, while of course this is a court decision, we'll go by that.
34:40But what do you think is now going to be the impact of it?
34:43Does Azam Khan or his politics still hold sway in Uttar Pradesh?
34:48He definitely does if you talk about the Muslim World Bank, Pooja, because Azam Khan has been a key figure.
34:53Also in terms of distributing tickets in Samajwadi Party, especially in those Vedansabad seats, which have the Muslim dominance around.
35:02And at that particular time, when Asad Uddin Ovesi is making the tough damage to Samajwadi Party over the Muslim
35:09leadership,
35:10with remarks like Abdul Dari Nahi Bichai, Azam Khan's release can be a boon for the Akhilesh Yadav and Samajwadi
35:17Party.
35:18Because Azam Khan has been very adamant against Asad Uddin Ovesi.
35:22With calling him Hyderabadi, Abdul Samajwadi Party leaders have already been very vocal about him.
35:27And now Akhilesh Yadav is also slamming Ovesi without taking his name.
35:30So it's going to be worth seeing how Azam Khan goes on in a way.
35:34Because Azam Khan could be the character for Samajwadi Party, which party was missing against Asad Uddin Ovesi.
35:40Though the party has many Muslim figures, but Azam Khan has been the most significant figure since the time of
35:46Ulaam Singh Yadav.
35:47And that's why the release of Azam Khan could be a key significance mode for Samajwadi Party,
35:52especially against Asad Uddin Ovesi, who's all set in a way to damage the Muslim World Bank.
35:57So we'll see how this makes any difference at all when it comes to Uttar Pradesh politics in 2027.
36:02The fact is that Battle for Uttar Pradesh Assembly Elections, heading for 2027, is already in top gear.
36:07Akhilesh Yadav has taken the PDA pitch, Pichada Dalit Alpsankhya, straight into Gorakpur.
36:14Why is Gorakpur so significant?
36:15It is Yogi Aditya Nats, home turf, stronghold still.
36:19It's a show of strength from Akhilesh Yadav, from other parts of the state, especially in Gorakpur this time.
36:26And this is after the Bharatiya Janata Party drafted their Brahmastra in Mathura Mantan.
36:31Focusing on the Krishna Janma Bhoomi as well.
36:34But the opposition seat-sharing negotiation will be in focus.
36:37Why?
36:37The Congress, according to our understanding, is seeking 181 seats out of 403 from the Samajwadi Party for the India
36:45Bloc Alliance.
36:47Will the Samajwadi Party give that number of seats that the Congress wish list is expecting?
36:53Uttar Pradesh is heading for a battle of alliances, calculations, arithmetic and more.
36:57So here's a report for you to understand what the BJP, the India Alliance is up to, and what Samajwadi
37:02Party Congress and the India Bloc Alliance is up to.
37:11As Uttar Pradesh heads closer to the crucial assembly elections in 2027, the battle is intensifying with both the BJP
37:20and the opposition stepping up strategy meeting and political outreach.
37:25The Samajwadi Party has taken the fight to the BJP stronghold, with Akhilesh Yadav holding a 22-kilometer long PDA
37:33Rath Yatra in Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath's turf of Gorapur.
37:37From the Chief Minister Bastion, Akhilesh Yadav declared that the crowds in Gorapur is a sign that BJP is going
37:45to be defeated this election.
38:15This is a title of the
38:19This marks the second major leg of the SP's PDA campaign ahead of the
38:242027 polls. PDA or Pichra Dalit Alpsankhya formula is Akhilesh's attempt at
38:30building a social coalition to counter the BJP. But the BJP has downplayed the
38:36impact of Akhilesh's Rath Yatra. Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya has
38:41called the SP Chief's campaign an eyewash.
39:07Akhilesh's Gorakhpur Rath Yatra came just a day after the BJP concluded its two-day
39:12Mathura Mantan. As a part of the strategy formulated in the meeting, BJP will launch
39:19Jan Ashirwaad Yatras across UP. Prime Minister Modi, Home Minister Shah and
39:24Party President Nitin Nabeen will lead the campaign. BJP will boost worker outreach
39:30and strengthen organizational network. The youth will be BJP's Brahmastra and the
39:36party will rope in district-level YouTubers and influencers to promote Vikas. After the
39:42Mathura Mantan, Chief Minister Yogi travelled to Delhi and met the party's top brass, including
39:47Home Minister Amit Shah and BJP Chief Nitin Nabeen. As strategy meetings and political pitches
39:53continue, the opposition's seat-sharing arithmetic remains in focus. India today has learnt that Congress
40:00is pushing for an early deal and is seeking 181 seats from the Samajwadi Party. Talks are
40:07likely next week with 22 SP held seats on Congress's wish list along with seats won by the RLD.
40:30From the fight over turfs to the high-stakes seat-sharing negotiations, Uttar Pradesh's electoral
40:37showdown is gathering momentum. Bureau Report, India Today.
40:46My colleague Samarth Srivastav is joining me right now. Samarth, what do you think is the
40:51significance here? Gorakhpur that has been chosen a clear show of strength by the Samajwadi
40:56Party definitely in a turf which is known as the BJP or Yogi Adityanath stronghold. So what
41:02do you think is the strategy of Samajwadi Party here? See, one thing is very clear. Both
41:07the parties will be targeting the stronghold of each other. Be it BJP will be targeting
41:11that particular belt which has Tennoj, Manpuri and other areas, while Samajwadi Party is taking
41:16on the Gorakhpur. Not just Gorakhpur, especially the Abad region which also have Ayodhya. And
41:21if you talk about Purwanchal, it's going to be Varanasi. Especially those places which are
41:25more in terms of religious beliefs. And that's why he has chosen this Gorakhpur for the start
41:31of the PDA Yastra. Though earlier we saw he took that particular Ratiyatran rivalry, but the
41:36official start could be set from today onwards where he'll be visiting many other districts in
41:41time to come. Also, many allegations have been put by Samajwadi Party over the BJP about this
41:46particular rally where they claimed that there was a shutdown of internet for some time around.
41:51Akhilesh has claimed this particular thing as well in the media. So it's going to be worth seeing how
41:56other things goes on. Back to you. All right, Samarth will be tracking all the latest on that.
42:00There's been a Ratiyatra in Yogi Adityanath's home turf. The visit is being seen as Samajwadi
42:05Party's direct challenge thrown to BJP's core base and to dent it. And because they've done it in
42:11Ayodhya, this could of course be the next big focus. Look at that on our big screens here. Samajwadi
42:17Party aims to show the strength in BJP dominated Purwanchal region. Gorakhpur therefore becomes the key
42:24gateway to eastern Uttar Pradesh politics because UP even now does fight elections on caste equations,
42:30religious equations and east and western Uttar Pradesh. So Nishad, Malla and other riverine
42:36communities will be in focus for the Samajwadi Party too. But SP also this time is trying to reach
42:43out not just to the traditional Yadav voters but also non-Yadav OBC voters while the BJP aims to
42:49consolidate the Hindu vote of Uttar Pradesh especially for the reason they have chosen
42:54Mathura, the Krishna Janma Bhoomi. Gorakhpur is seen as a test for Samajwadi Party's ground
43:00cadre, their operational and organizational reach. And therefore this Roadshow Ratiyatra was designed
43:06to send a message across Purwanchal about those who if they're angry against the BJP,
43:12the Samajwadi Party is ready for them. Aishwara Paliwal continues to be with us on that as well.
43:18She's been constantly tracking all these huddles since morning. Aishwara, you tell me. Samajwadi
43:22Party said they want to enter into Gorakhpur and how? What is the BJP strategy according to your sources?
43:27How will they ensure they will be in the government? Because SP says too many issues coming up
43:32in UP and by emotional vote bank of religion, they will not be able to get votes this time.
43:40Now, you know, one thing is very, very clear. What we are seeing in the war cry that we will
43:44see
43:45the top leadership of the parties and the parties also speak about Uttar Pradesh. Now, this is something
43:49once the Ayodhya verdict came, there were murmurs. But now we are seeing how this actually is on its
43:54way to become the official war cry for the parties and the parties. They are seeing after Ayodhya,
43:59the next big thing that they are eyeing, the next big thing that they are targeting is Mathura.
44:04This is something which, from what we understand, will be the pole crank. But yes, there are a lot
44:08of issues that the Mahathri Janka Party really needs to work upon. They also, Pooja, let me tell you,
44:12need to consolidate the youth and the women vote bank. That is something that will be the focus
44:16on all 402 groups. From what I understand, so she has told me, there will be a pitch for top
44:22leadership
44:22of the Mahathri Janka Party will be making a big outreach both to the youth and as well as to
44:27the women,
44:27because they want to make sure that this is a consolidated vote bank that saves the BJP.
44:32Ashwara, there are a lot of changes that we have seen this time. For example, more than
44:35Lucknow or Ayodhya, the focus is on Gorakhpur, the focus is on Mathura and also on the other side,
44:41do you think the entry of Chandrasekhar, Azad Ravan and OVSI, their third front, could prove to be an
44:47interesting battle? Will it be a third front? Will they ally with the Congress Party or the SP? How is
44:52the BJP
44:53viewing that? So tell me about these different strategies that all parties are trying this time?
44:58Well, you know, we speak about the Samajwadi party, Pooja, let me tell you, it really is a do or
45:02die,
45:02because over the past 10 years, one decade is a long time when we speak about politics,
45:07you know, they have been out of power in the state of Uttar Pradesh. So for them, this is do
45:10or die.
45:11Also for the Congress party, you know, they want to make sure that they have their presence
45:15in Uttar Pradesh, because see Pooja, you have the delimitation, you don't have the delimitation.
45:19The fact of the matter is, whoever rules Uttar Pradesh, whichever party rules Uttar Pradesh,
45:23has a direct connection with the central government. So this is something that the
45:27Congress Party on the national level clearly understands, which is why they are now pushing
45:31that the seat sharing needs to happen as soon as possible. They need to speak about, and that's
45:35what I understand the larger opposition will do. They will, A, speak about the minority vote
45:40bank, which is huge in the state of Uttar Pradesh, and they will also, in fact, be speaking about
45:44the work that has not been done in Uttar Pradesh. But law and order, and the overall popularity
45:49of the Chief Minister, Yogi Adityanath, is something that the
45:51Maharaj and the party will be banking upon. Pooja.
45:54Well said, fair point. So there are some aspects that the BJP has with them, some that they will
45:59see as a challenge. Samajwadi Party also gearing up in Haushwara. And Samar, thank you very much for
46:04now as well. Let's now move on to what the India bloc, or the Congress of the Samajwadi Party,
46:09individually and collectively, are possibly strategizing and planning. So these meetings
46:13have happened between Home Minister Amit Shah, Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath. What about the
46:18opposition? We now bring you the inside scoop of the Congress-SP seat sharing as well.
46:23The Congress is seeking, according to our information, 181 seats from the Samajwadi Party.
46:31Now for the SP, remember, this is an existential issue. It is the state where they have most prominence.
46:3722 Samajwadi Party-held seats are also on the Congress wish list. 181 out of 403 seats that
46:44the Alliance wants to then be a part of, or of course want to contest on. Congress is seeking,
46:50for example, according to our information, the seat of Chartwal, that is held by the Samajwadi
46:55Party, or has still a stronghold there. Samajwadi Party is still eyeing Gauri Ganj,
47:00Unchahar, and Kalpi. RLD1 seats, including Congress, will be also in the Congress wish list as well.
47:07All of this, eventually, remember, will be about whether SP is willing to give that number. 181 is
47:14a big number for the Samajwadi Party to give away, especially at a time when they know they've managed
47:19to get Ayodhya during Lok Sabha election results. 135 general category in terms of seats 45 SC,
47:27and one ST seat has been sought, according to the wish list from our sources from the Congress Party.
47:34Sources also suggest that Samajwadi Party wants to start very low, possibly even less than 30,
47:40and then go slowly and steadily up, depending on negotiations.
47:44Mossmi Singh is joining me for all the latest on that. Mossmi, what is your understanding?
47:48There will sure be, from what we saw from Sonia Gandhi's book launch event,
47:52Akhilesh Yadav seated next to Sonia Gandhi, so there was clearly a symbol there, a symbolism there.
47:57But do you think they'll give away 181 seats to Congress, or will there have to be a tough negotiation
48:03here?
48:06I don't think that 181 is happening, Puja. You know, it's stepping up the bargain for the Congress
48:14Party. And I think that there was a bit of an embarrassment for the Congress when the Samajwadi
48:21Party, in fact, Akhilesh said that the Congress has asked for 181 seats. And in fact, you know,
48:28you were pointing out the name of the seats was also out. So, you know, many of these seats,
48:34as you rightly pointed out, that the Samajwadi Party says that the Congress has not even got 600
48:42to 700 votes. Many are SP bastions where the Congress has claimed. So importantly, I think now,
48:50from the 23rd November onwards, Puja, the seat sharing talks will be on. And I think they will be
48:56a more reasonable bargain, because special committees have been formed. And then the
49:03final slashing out will happen, actually.
49:07Maasmi, I also do want to understand here that when Mathura is chosen as a location by the BJP,
49:13there's a clear strategy here. Do you think the whole Krishna Janmabhumi movement and the whole
49:18discussion around it could prove to be trouble for Samajwadi Party, for the Congress? It's aiming
49:23for Yadav votes. It's aiming for the OBC votes. It's aiming to consolidate the Hindu vote. Do you
49:29think that is something that the India bloc also will have to look at? And do you think it will
49:33work
49:33for the BJP?
49:35You know, the BJP, if you look at the trajectory, has worked on its weaknesses. It has done a
49:41SWOT analysis in the election-based states always. And I think, thereby, you know, the answer of
49:48Achillesh's TDA has been given in Mathura by the commandal pitch that the BJP has thrown,
49:57clearly putting Krishna Janmabhumi on the center stage. But the question really is that is Achillesh
50:05going to take and bat on that pitch? Because clearly Achillesh is sticking to his PDA pitch
50:12that is also seconded by Rahul Gandhi. So this is going to be, you know, an 80 versus a 20
50:20percent
50:21population. We remember Yogi Adityanath talking about buttenge to kattenge. So whether it is the
50:29mandal versus commandal politics or it is the PDA versus the commandal politics,
50:34UP is going to see a very high-octane election campaign.
50:39I do have one more question, Moshmi, here. Gorakpur is the location where we saw a show of
50:44strength by the Samajwadi Party. So they are, of course, trying to enter into the BJP stronghold.
50:48But challenging their core vote base is Chandrasekhar, Azad Ravan and Ovesi who are making a third front.
50:55Many are wondering, what if the Congress, Chandrasekhar's party and Ovesi's AIMM, they combine?
51:01And if the Samajwadi Party doesn't want to go along, how do you think that combination could work?
51:06Everyone's, I'm sure, trying all sorts of calculations that will work for them.
51:10What I'm trying to understand, do you think the third front coming in could benefit the BJP
51:14and create trouble for especially the Samajwadi Party?
51:19You know, reading between the lines, Pooja, it's a very, very tricky alliance.
51:23But the UP voters are very deeply political. If it is going to be a bipolar contest,
51:31perhaps the voter of UP could think that it should utilize its vote and cast to a winning combination.
51:38And thereby, the third alliance could not gather so many votes.
51:43But, you know, the percentage or the number of votes will actually point out to the fact that whether really,
51:53you know,
51:54the winning margins were very, very small in many constituencies, less than 1,000, 2,000.
52:00So, if Oversea and Hazard can manage to get more than the winning margin in the last assembly elections for
52:09the BJP,
52:10that would actually be very, very, very heavy on the opposition.
52:15Very interesting. Remember, because as Moshmi is also telling us,
52:17there's one state that can impact national politics as well.
52:20And soon, of course, all our colleagues will be on the ground to really understand the ground situation.
52:25And for Moshmi, the next few days, ensure to track her coverage from the state of Uttar Pradesh.
52:30Moshmi, thank you very much for now.
52:31On that note, this was full of discussions and debates.
52:34What is Rahul Gandhi saying? What is the BJP strategy?
52:36Because eventually, they all want to impress their electorate and more.
52:40And the impact of it will be seen in election results.
52:43Thank you very much for watching To The Point.