• 21 minutes ago
This edition of News Today covers major political, sports, environmental, and entrepreneurial developments.
Transcript
00:00Good evening, you're watching News Today at 9pm. I am Preeti Chaudhuri. Our big talking points this evening.
00:06Rahul Gandhi is abroad and he has targeted Prime Minister Modi's government from foreign soil.
00:13Attacking government on foreign soil justified. Sandpaper gate shames Australia.
00:20That's the other point we'll be looking at very closely. The big explosive spot story.
00:25Cricketer Bancroft reveals all. We're going to get you all the details.
00:29But first up, allow me to take you through the headlines.
00:37All eyes on the superpower handshake tomorrow.
00:40Trump, Shri Putin to hold trilateral meet in Shenzhen.
00:44Focus on nuclear non-proliferation and wars in Ukraine and Iran.
00:53LOP Rahul Gandhi's remarks abroad once again spark political war.
00:58Rahul says at Columbia University that India is sitting on an economic disaster.
01:05BJP Films says Rahul spreading anti-national agenda.
01:14Prime Minister Modi holds performance review meet with Council of Ministers.
01:18Gets emotional over issue of drug menace.
01:20Prime Minister tells ministers to save youth from drugs at any cost.
01:30India today accesses BJP's UP poll campaign strategy.
01:34Senior Modi mantris to lead yatras across the state.
01:37Prime Minister may kickstart UP poll campaign from Lucknow.
01:41Home Minister Amitra Nitin Abhin to also lead campaigns.
01:48Right ahead of UP polls, Samajwadi Party strongman Azam Khan released from Dasna Jail in Ghaziabad.
01:56This comes after Supreme Court refused to stay in terror and bail grunted to Samajwadi Party leader in a money
02:02laundering case.
02:10Political war over Mekka Datuk Dam continues to escalate.
02:14Three Tamil Nadu ministers meet union.
02:17Jal Shakti minister in Delhi urging centre to not approve Karnataka project.
02:29ACK 1 intensifies into a severe cyclonic storm in the Bay of Bengal.
02:34Cyclone to make landfall in northern Andhra Pradesh on November 20th.
02:38Red alert also issued in Puducherry and South Odisha.
02:48After a glamorous urge short night in Mumbai, the UK royal couple Prince Williams and Princess Catherine
02:55hold meet with Prime Minister Modi in Delhi before departing back to UK.
03:04And a story that has shocked the world.
03:07Australian cricketer Cameron Bancroft breaks silence on sandpaper gate claims.
03:12Entire Australian team knew about the use of sandpaper and he was made the scapegoat.
03:31Alright, top focus of fresh political flashpoint has erupted over Rahul Gandhi's remarks.
03:36This time from New York.
03:38Speaking at Columbia University, Rahul Gandhi has launched a scathing attack on the Modi government,
03:43questioning India's electoral credibility, economic vision and the functioning of central agencies.
03:49Rahul's remarks have triggered a sharp BJP counter-attack,
03:53with the party accusing him of maligning India on foreign soil.
03:58Here's the full report.
04:03From questions over the 2024 Lok Sabha election results to serious allegations against central agencies,
04:11Rahul Gandhi has launched a wide-ranging attack on the Narendra Modi government from foreign soil.
04:17During an interaction at Columbia University in New York,
04:20The leader of opposition raised a host of issues,
04:24questioning the government's economic vision, electoral credibility and approach to education.
04:30Addressing the recent wave of dissent,
04:32Rahul Gandhi said that student protests had broken the climate of fear in India
04:36and warned that the government's response to mounting protests could turn violent.
04:44If the pressure goes beyond a certain point, which it will,
04:48the government will react nastily.
04:51The government will not be so kind and will probably react violently and aggressively.
05:03Rahul Gandhi stressed that restoring India's electoral system is a priority
05:07and alleged election rigging.
05:10He claimed that insiders in the election commission are sharing information with the Congress.
05:15Rahul also pointed to what he described as growing discontent within the bureaucracy,
05:19claiming that officials within the CBI and the ED are leaking information about alleged government wrongdoing.
05:26What's interesting is there is also a revolt in the bureaucracy.
05:30And there's also a revolt in the coercive elements of the state.
05:35You know, the CBI, the ED, the intelligence agencies,
05:39they're also revolting and they're giving us information about this type of wrongdoing.
05:46So I'm quite positive.
05:50And making a pitch for his own political identity,
05:53Rahul said Prime Minister Modi could not compete with his distinctive style,
05:57citing the 4,000-kilometre Bharat Joro Yatra.
06:03As a politician, even Mr Modi does not actually compete with anyone.
06:09If you think about it, he's fundamentally different than all other politicians in India.
06:16Would you agree with that?
06:17The BJP was quick to hit back, calling Rahul Gandhi immature, anti-India and the Mir Jafar of India.
06:23The BJP has said that every Indian feels ashamed by his statements.
06:44The Saffron party has also gone all guns blazing at Rahul over his dick at the BJP's 2047 Viksit Bharat
06:51target.
06:54I also don't think GDP is the best number.
06:59I think it's a very deceptive number.
07:01There's no GDP number that says how upset are your women.
07:05So to me, it's a hollow number.
07:26The Rao comes just days after a massive political storm had erupted
07:30when an Italian politician raised the slogan,
07:33Vote Chor Gaddi Chor at a Congress event in Hyderabad.
07:37Vote Chor Gaddi Chor.
07:44Courtesy translation, Vote Thief, Leave Your Seat.
07:49As the showdown intensifies, the question is,
07:53do Rahul's remarks abroad amount to defaming the country or criticism of the government?
07:58Your report, India Today.
08:06All right, before we dive into our debate this evening,
08:09the big questions that we ask.
08:11Attacking the government on foreign soil, is it justified?
08:13Is the BJP overreacting to Rahul's statement?
08:17Why do leaders seek diaspora support?
08:19Why are political battles taken abroad?
08:22And is criticising your own government by the LOP abroad tantamount to criticising India?
08:29Let's take all the questions to our guests this evening.
08:33Joining me, Tuhin Sinha, BJP, National Spokesperson.
08:36Mr. Gurdip Singh Sappal, Congress National Spokesperson.
08:40Rajat Sethi, political analyst.
08:41Sanjay Jha, political analyst.
08:44I'd like to begin with Mr. Sappal.
08:47Mr. Sappal, is it responsible opposition politics to what some would suggest an attempt to undermine India's global image?
08:58Thank you, Priti.
09:00This argument has been going on for years now.
09:03For years, our leader Rahul Gandhi has been going to the foreign universities, expressing himself.
09:09And BJP has been criticising it.
09:11So I think your viewers would like to move away from this argument now and see what Rahul Gandhi actually
09:17said in that thing.
09:20Isn't it a reality that the entire developed countries of the world's leading countries, including U.S., including U.K.,
09:28including Germany, including India, have a serious job crisis?
09:32Isn't it a fact that this job crisis is also because of the multi-tech companies which have taken control
09:39of policies?
09:39It is also because of the AI challenge.
09:42It is also because of the China model.
09:44This is not a single nation's problem.
09:46Rahul Gandhi has been pointing out that we need international cooperation, collaboration, and that is not possible until you talk,
09:54frankly, until you talk about data, about figures.
09:57Talking about data has become for BJP an anti-national activity.
10:02The hiding behind national pride will not solve the problem of unemployment in this country.
10:08There is nothing wrong, nothing wrong to discuss that situation, because in the last 12 years, the degrees are not
10:17giving any jobs.
10:18Even in IIT, only 40 percent of the graduates are getting jobs.
10:22And those who have got jobs, their salaries are stagnant for the last 12 years.
10:27Agricultural salaries, wages have actually gone down by 1.2 percent per annum.
10:32The wages are at 0 percent per annum for last 12 years.
10:37And other salaries are at 0.086 percent per annum.
10:41Now, everything is rising.
10:43Every cost is rising.
10:44For the first time, we have a generation who are educated, who are bright, but they cannot buy a house
10:51of their wages.
10:52They cannot buy a house out of wages.
10:54These are problems which are facing the world.
10:56Rahul Gandhi has been talking about them.
10:58Again, our Modi government is silent on these issues.
11:01There is no discussion in India.
11:03There is no discussion in India on the way forward.
11:05And if Indian government hides data, if Indian government doesn't do any discussion,
11:10if there is no blueprint globally, then leader of opposition's duty is to actually raise these questions.
11:16All right.
11:17Okay.
11:17I want to bring in the BJP spokesperson.
11:19Tuhin Sinha, at one end, the BJP and the government has alleged that Rahul Gandhi is defaming India on foreign
11:27soil.
11:27But do we fall into the trap of possibly conflating what is criticizing India and what is criticizing the government?
11:37Some would suggest he's only criticized the government.
11:39He's the LOP.
11:40He has every right to do so.
11:41Why are we conflating the two, of criticizing the Indian government and criticizing India?
11:46It doesn't tantamount to the same thing.
11:49Well, good evening, Preeti.
11:50Good evening, everybody.
11:52You know, Mr. Supple's belabored attempts to give a positive skew to Rahul Gandhi's negativity, I'm afraid, has not cut
11:59any ice.
11:59Rahul Gandhi is given.
12:01He's addicted to, you know, defaming India.
12:04And he seems to be deriving some sort of a cheap thrill out of it.
12:08Now, since you've asked a very specific question, was he, you know, does he criticize the government?
12:14No.
12:14You know, when you pick up a Sikh gentleman or in a crowd and tell him that in India, you're
12:19not even supposed to, you know, you're not even freely allowed to visit a gurudwara.
12:23Mr. Sattpal should be having a problem with that.
12:26That is not defaming a government.
12:27Has it ever happened in the country?
12:29That has never happened in the country.
12:30When you meet Ilhan Omar on the eve of Jammu and Kashmir elections, you know, on the one hand, we
12:36kept telling him to specify his stand on Article 370.
12:39He did not.
12:40He instead chose to, you know, discreetly go and meet Ilhan Omar, whose pro-Pakistan stand on Jammu and Kashmir
12:48is well known.
12:48So, these are not criticizing government.
12:50When he says our economy is on the verge of collapse, I mean, four top global rating agencies, IMF, Moody's,
12:59S&P Global and Goldman Sachs.
13:01Are we to believe them, who all, you know, all of which unanimously predict a 7% plus GDP growth
13:09for the current financial year?
13:10Or are we supposed to believe the Gandhi rating agency, which is, you know, based on negativity and which is
13:18based on, you know, pulling India down?
13:20And besides, you know, when he says that, you know, a democracy is in danger, if you recall, five weeks
13:26ago, he had met the Honorable President.
13:28The Honorable President, if he is to be believed, asked him for evidence.
13:32Why has he not cared to reach out to her once again?
13:35These are very important questions which Mr. Sappal needs to answer.
13:40And by the way, yes, the democracy is in danger in certain parts of the country, particularly in Jharkhand, where
13:46there has been an open abuse of the POSCO law just to shield a sitting Congress MLA accused of raping
13:54a 14-year-old.
13:55And Rahul Gandhi has been silent on that.
13:56You know, the media, the media, the video channel, which broke out the news first, was raided the entire night
14:03two days ago.
14:05These are definitely instances where democracy is in danger in Congress-ruled states.
14:10So I think, you know, there is a very clear attempt to bring infamy to the country.
14:14I think, you know, he's working on a grand plan.
14:17You know, they're not able to crack an alliance in Uttar Pradesh where the Samajwadi Party apparently is not ready
14:22to give them more than 25 seats.
14:24But he seems to be working on a grand global alliance of Dimagi Naksals.
14:30Okay, a grand global alliance of Dimagi Naksals.
14:45Okay, one second, Mr. Siddhar. Now you've asked a question. Go ahead. Make your point.
14:49He's going to answer my pointed question.
14:52When Prime Minister Narendra Modi...
14:52Okay, he's answering. Mr. Toheen Siddhar. Allow him to answer.
14:55Okay, sir. Please make your point.
14:57Mr. Toheen, criticizing government is not anti-national.
15:01What is anti-national is what your leader and our Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, did on foreign soil when he
15:07said that people before 2014 were ashamed to be born as Indians.
15:12That is criticizing India.
15:13Criticizing government policies is not anti-national.
15:16B, you twist the argument.
15:18You said about Sikhs being not allowed to go to Gurdwara.
15:22This is not what Rahul Gandhi said.
15:24Rahul Gandhi asked that Sikh gentleman that would you like somebody to dictate your faith?
15:31Now, there's a huge difference.
15:32No, no, I think you can play the video again.
15:35And, and, and, and, and, Mr. Sinha, BJP RSS wants to dictate others' faith.
15:42There is nothing hidden about it and you are proud of it.
15:44Okay, sir. Okay, your rebuttal can't be an interjection.
15:47Okay, Bambay.
15:47No, no, just, just, okay.
15:48Allow him. Okay, yes, 10 seconds to Mr. Sinha.
15:54Mr. Sappal, yesterday Prime Minister was in Philippines.
15:57Look at the respect he's shown to the Sikh faith.
15:59We acknowledge 26th December as Veer Pal Devas.
16:03And on the other hand, you are condoning...
16:04Okay, I'm going to just open up the debate now.
16:06Do you agree that ISIS doesn't bond every Sikh and all of a Sikh people?
16:11Can we get the faders down?
16:13Okay, I'm going to, I'm going to open up the debate.
16:15There's no point getting into this banter.
16:17Allow me to open up the debate.
16:19Okay, I want to bring in Sanjay Jha.
16:21Sanjay Jha, you're a man of numbers.
16:23You understand numbers.
16:24You understand economics.
16:25So, therefore, there is a charge, which is that Rahul Gandhi repeatedly has picked on numbers
16:32and constantly refused to acknowledge where India has done exceedingly well,
16:37where the economy is concerned vis-a-vis the rest of the world.
16:40He chooses to downplay certain achievements, economic achievements of India,
16:44while paint a picture which is not as rosy.
16:50So, Preeti, let me just bite the bullet on your question.
16:53What is the truth on the numbers of India?
16:56What you hear from the BJP press release is nothing but cherry-picking of a desperate government
17:03that has mislead its own people and failed.
17:06Let's look at the GDP that once upon a time Mr. Modi used to tom-tom about.
17:10Remember that $5 trillion economy?
17:12It was supposed to come a couple of years ago.
17:16Guess where we are, Preeti, at $4 trillion, if at all,
17:19if the exchange rate were to worsen, we'll come below $4 trillion.
17:23It's not just the GDP alone, right?
17:25It's a per capita income.
17:26We are lower than Bangladesh.
17:28And, in fact, several countries which are, well, developing countries,
17:33have higher GDP than ours.
17:34So, look at the Human Development Index, education that Rahul Gandhi raised.
17:38These are pertinent points.
17:40Healthcare.
17:40I mean, the stories that you hear about ordinary Indians dying because they don't have ambulance
17:46or they don't get medicines is of legend.
17:48I mean, even on COVID, the government's figures were absolutely in smokescreen
17:54as we saw the final statements made by the WHO.
17:57So, we are talking about a country under Mr. Modi that, frankly speaking,
18:02whether it's the farmers who protested, whether it's the rampant unemployment
18:06which has destroyed the demographic dividend story, whether it's MSMEs who haven't recovered
18:11even today from the damage of demonetization and the sloppy execution of GSD.
18:16I mean, you can see that India has struggled.
18:18And now, inflation is beginning to rise.
18:21And India's, frankly, the growth story should have been at a real growth rate of 8% and above.
18:27And we are nowhere there at the moment.
18:29The worst thing, Preeti, is that the world even doubts in numbers if we declare.
18:33But I want to make two very quick points before you move on.
18:36I think, you know, when Rahul Gandhi answers these questions abroad,
18:40I'm shocked that Tuhin Sinha and the BJP, even today after so many years,
18:45don't understand the constitution of this country that I'm glad you raised.
18:49Criticizing a government is not criticizing the country at all.
18:54If you go by the BJP logic, then when there is a presidential debate
18:59and both the president candidates criticize each other's policies,
19:03are they being anti-American to the rest of the world?
19:05The whole world watches their program.
19:07Are the two people being anti-national?
19:09Not at all.
19:09And the last point, Rahul Gandhi answers questions from intelligent people, unscripted,
19:15and, you know, they ask him tough questions, he answers them.
19:17Guess what happens to Mr. Modi since Tuhin mentioned Manila?
19:21Let me tell him that when the presser was about to start,
19:25Mr. Modi, because he didn't have a teleprompter
19:28or hasn't given a press conference for 12 years,
19:30had to say, shall we move?
19:32Shall we move?
19:33Allow me to bring in Rajat Sethi into this conversation.
19:36Rajat Sethi, the fact is, one can criticize Rahul Gandhi.
19:40This is not the first time we are having this debate
19:41of possibly criticizing what the Congress says very clearly
19:46is Indian government and not India on foreign soil.
19:49But it's happened before.
19:50And it's happened by, and it's something that has been followed by our own prime minister.
19:56In Denmark, May 2022, India was one of the most backward nations few years ago.
20:00That was said by a prime minister.
20:02In Berlin, Germany, May 22, a hand used to snatch away 85 paisa in one rupee.
20:08Muscat Oman, February 2018, long list of scams harmed India's image.
20:15Shanghai, China, May 2015, earlier you were ashamed of India, but today you are proud.
20:20This is politics.
20:20It happens.
20:23No, no.
20:24So, okay.
20:25Pritiji, let's take a step back on this.
20:27So, fine.
20:28If it is politics, we will have to measure it from the political impact per se.
20:33The prime minister says that he addresses Indian diaspora outside.
20:37I believe Mr. Rahul Gandhi is also addressing the Indian diaspora when he's at Columbia University,
20:44and he's not making a general remark in the university to the Americans, professors, and
20:49all of those.
20:50If that is the case, you know, you need to understand what kind of diaspora is Ilan Umar
20:55when he sits and shares a closed-room discussion, and he has never made it public as to what
21:01sensitive policy-making discussions was he having with Ilan Umar, who clearly, outrightly,
21:07outspokenly says that Kashmir belongs to Pakistan.
21:09Is this what Mr. Rahul Gandhi's position on Kashmir is?
21:13Because till date he has not come out openly and said what this meeting was about.
21:17And there have been many such shady discussions and meetings.
21:20I mean, what I don't understand is, okay, if you were to make a political position or a
21:25statement, you do always, you have this itch of going out.
21:28You go out there, make a presentation, talk ill about India, India's state economic affairs,
21:34India's politics, India's institution, all of that.
21:36But also, while you're indicting India, you're also saying in your own words an indictment
21:42against Tamil Nadu, where your government is an alliance, against Karnataka, against Telangana.
21:48Why on earth that these three states where you have a government in or you have a say
21:53in these states, why haven't you created enough economic opportunities and created a parallel
21:58sort of a model example before the rest of the country that this is what Congress rule
22:02looks like?
22:03See, this is the problem.
22:05You cannot come out and paint the whole country with one brush.
22:08And in that paint, you're also wrongfully painting your own states where you are ruling.
22:14Today, Telangana and Karnataka are the two biggest economic drivers of the country.
22:19They've always been, tell me what is the policy that Congress Party has brought in?
22:25Is there something new?
22:26Something is working there or not?
22:28If not, then what creative thought process do you have in mind?
22:31My problem is that whenever Rahul Gandhi speaks in all of these international platforms, all
22:36that he does is a bunch of negative thoughts.
22:39I haven't seen him come out ever with anything constructive.
22:42If AI is a problem, I also understand AI is a problem.
22:45But I also understand that a bunch of my juniors from IIT are building space rockets, privately
22:50launched space rockets, which don't happen in any other country.
22:53Very, very few, countable number of countries have that capacity.
22:56Each of these space companies hires thousands and thousands of employees.
23:01These economic aspects did not exist before.
23:04My point is very simple.
23:05Rahul Gandhi needs to come up with model solutions around the problems that he positions himself
23:12around.
23:12If he does not have any creative answers to that, he should also say that I don't have
23:16any of those answers to solve the India scale problem.
23:20Otherwise, if you can get on the right and keep on talking bad about India ad nauseum.
23:27Okay.
23:28So, Rajat Sethi's point is, criticism abroad, maybe he can offer a roadmap on how to solve
23:33the issues that plague India.
23:35I want to go right back to Mr. Sapal and possibly final comments from everybody.
23:41But Mr. Sapal, what Rahul Gandhi also did, which some would suggest, make sweeping parallels
23:47with countries like the US, Brazil, France in terms of the kind of Gen Z unrest that these
23:53countries are facing.
23:55Is that fair to make these parallels?
23:58Well, I'll answer to your question and earlier question also.
24:01Sure.
24:01In India, we had a student movement that is intrinsically different from student movements
24:07all over the world.
24:08Rahul Gandhi acknowledges it because in India, we have somehow imbibed Gandhian way.
24:14That is why, despite all police atrocities, the student movement remained peaceful, student
24:20movement remained very disciplined in India because that is the strength of last hundred years
24:25of Gandhian philosophy which has led Congress party and which has led the entire, it has been
24:31imbibed by our nation.
24:33Now, coming to what was said about the overall picture.
24:37You see, we are a country of 150 crore.
24:39We are not a poor country that way.
24:41We are not a weak country.
24:42There will be certain amount of growth always on the basis of consumption and because we
24:47have a strong base.
24:49Issue is, issue is that in last 12 years, the salaries did not go up, but the corporate profit
24:55has gone up by five to ten times.
24:59The issue is that people are now getting poorer and 1% of the people now have 40% of
25:07share
25:07in national wealth.
25:08These are the issues which need to be discussed today.
25:12And as far as saying that we do not have a role model, well, come, have a separate issue
25:18on this, I am willing to discuss how Tilangana government or Karnataka government are doing
25:23things differently.
25:24But this is not the issue today.
25:26Today, the issue is whether political people, they go out, what should they say?
25:31Narendra Modi, before becoming chief minister of Gujarat, spent several years in U.S. as RSS
25:37full-time Pracharak.
25:39In those years, what was he doing?
25:41Was he praising Narsimara government?
25:44Was he lobbying for Narsimara government in those years?
25:46Of course, he was also criticizing the government of India that day.
25:50Then the social media was not there.
25:52The TV medium was not in its current form.
25:54So that is not known to people today.
25:56But this RSS has been doing for decades, going, sending its people to other countries
26:03and criticizing Gandhi, Nehru and Congress way of life.
26:07This is nothing new.
26:08You have been doing it.
26:08All right, but Mr. Sappal, before I go to Mr. Sinha, I want to come back.
26:12Would you agree maybe it was incorrect to then conflate the Gen Z unrest in India with
26:19that of a Brazil, U.S. or France?
26:21Because it's very, very different in nature, some would think.
26:24Issue is not conflating each other.
26:27Issue is that there are reasons for Gen Z unrest.
26:30And the reasons are that degrees are not leading to jobs and jobs are not leading to adequate salary
26:37and not just in India.
26:38You see, in our generation, and you also belong to the same generation,
26:42everybody here belongs to the same generation.
26:44No, no, I don't belong to the same generation.
26:46I don't know.
26:47I'm not doing Gen Z.
26:49I'm making a point.
26:50I'm making a serious point.
26:51Yeah, yeah.
26:51Everybody who's here on this screen, in early 2000 to 2010, 15,
26:59everybody bought a house, bought a car, had their own things out of their salaries.
27:04Now, no young person who comes out of college and has been working for one year, five years,
27:10seven years can buy a house in this country.
27:13All right, okay, Mr. Sappal, you made your point.
27:15Allow me to bring in Tuhin Sinha.
27:16Tuhin Sinha, the issue of GDP was raised at the Columbia University.
27:20Rahul said that that's really not a correct marker.
27:22Some economists might argue on either sides of the divide.
27:25But as we do accuse Rahul Gandhi of possibly selectively picking up data
27:31and not looking at India's economic achievements and focusing on a subset of data,
27:37is the government also somewhere down the line guilty of the same?
27:41Because if you look at multiple reports, and I can start quoting them,
27:43the World Inequality Report, which clearly states top 10% earners capture 58% of the national income.
27:52India has lifted the World Bank report, which says employment has risen,
27:57but earnings remain largely unchanged, and they've even fallen from what the earlier baseline was.
28:02So there are multiple reports to suggest that Rahul Gandhi has a cogent argument.
28:09Well, of course, there are multiple reports, and the most credible of them says that 49.5 crore Indians
28:15have been pulled out of poverty line in the last 12 years.
28:18Then there is a report, since, you know, Sanjay Jha is used to cherry-picking data,
28:22there is a report which has come out yesterday, which says in the last 12 years,
28:26the government's share in health care spending has gone up from 28.6% to 43%,
28:31and individual share has come down from 64% to 42%.
28:35This is absolutely phenomenal.
28:37So, yes, there are multiple ways of looking at data, but I have a point to make to Mr. Sappal.
28:42But there is also a report, the latest report by the Azzam Premji University, sir,
28:46which says 67% of the unemployed in India are graduates.
28:51There is a larger point, we can have a prolonged discussion on it.
28:57The point is Mr. Sappal seemed to justify, you know, that every Prime Minister,
29:01every leader in the past has gone abroad and made these comments.
29:04I think he is grossly mistaken over here.
29:07In March 2023, an octogenarian, a very senior Indian journalist in London,
29:12in March 2023 had to remind Rahul Gandhi, he had to draw the panel of Indira Gandhi
29:18and tell Rahul Gandhi that you need to carry yourself with more grace.
29:22Even Indira Gandhi was given similar questions to answer in 1978 or 79,
29:27and she refused to comment and share details about internal politics in India.
29:33And I think Mr. Sappal is senior enough to remind Rahul Gandhi about these things.
29:37And by the way, during the course of the show,
29:39I checked the video of Rahul Gandhi of 2024 yet again.
29:43And you know what he had said?
29:44In India, if you are a Sikh, it's also a fight for you to wear a turban and a kada.
29:49So Mr. Sappal still has the time to justify whether he can do...
29:53Okay, let Mr. Sappal come in.
29:54Mr. Sappal, now because it's a pointed question, I'm coming back to you.
29:57Please make your point, stick to the point, and then we'll go across to the other two panelists.
30:02Yeah, what's the question?
30:04Mr. Tuhin Sinha just went back to the comment by Rahul Gandhi in 2024 when again he was in foreign
30:12soil
30:12where he spoke to a Sikh gentleman and he suggested that in India...
30:15It's a fight for you to wear a turban or a kada.
30:18I'll request Tuhin Sinha or your viewers to listen to entire conversation.
30:23Conversation has a context that RSS doesn't think that all religions are equal
30:28and all citizens should be equal. And this is what prompted that thing that RSS...
30:33And today, even today, Suin Sinha can say that does RSS feel that in India every citizen should be equal,
30:40all religions are equal, they should have equal privilege, equal rights, equal opportunities.
30:44If you say that, if you say that today, I will withdraw my objection to your thing.
30:49Mr. Sappal, just put your hand on your heart and say that you can freely visit the Gurudwara,
30:55you can freely wear the turban, you can freely wear the kada.
30:58No, we can freely visit, but there is also a struggle within Sikh community
31:03where RSS has been trying to appropriate Sikh identity as Kesh Hari Sikh.
31:08Okay, you know, I'm going to go back to Sanjay Jha and Rajat Sethi.
31:12All right, final comments, final comments. Sanjay Jha, final comments, Rajat Sethi, final comments.
31:17Let me bring them both in. Sanjay Jha, let's begin with you, sir.
31:20Okay, I have two quick observations, Preeti.
31:23First and foremost, let me tell you the irony and the paradox.
31:27Rahul Gandhi is actually the grand ambassador of Indian democracy, and I'll tell you why.
31:33You know, the BJP playbook is now tired and exhausting.
31:37The world is calling us an elected autocracy.
31:40The world is calling us a flawed democracy.
31:43Independent organizations are calling us a democratically elected dictatorship.
31:48Everyone is talking about India's civil liberties having banished, people being put in jail, students facing AK-47.
31:55Rahul Gandhi, you hear him in Colombia. You hear him anywhere else.
31:58He talks about the hope, despite the attempt by the government to strangulate the opposition.
32:04This is the politics of hope. He talks about Gandhi.
32:07Why does the mention of Mahatma Gandhi get the BJP so agitated and worked up?
32:12And one quick point before, because I don't want to take too long.
32:15I know you have, Rajat, to go to.
32:17You know, the issue on the economy, I need to mention one point.
32:20The world is talking about a term that embarrasses me, because I'm part of corporate India as well, called A2
32:27capitalism.
32:27Since you mentioned inequality, let me tell you, everyone knows that in India, two or three favored industrialists are hogging
32:35national assets in broad daylight.
32:38One of them, I need to mention this, because this is a shocker.
32:40One of them in the state I live in, Maharashtra, Preeti, fudged the data of a project to not invest
32:47in wildlife conservation.
32:49I mean, this is happening in broad daylight, right?
32:51A2 capitalism, that is the legacy of the Modi government.
32:54Rajat Sethi, final comment, sir. Make your point.
32:55So, Preeti ji, I have no issues with Rahul Gandhi ji choosing whatever platforms he feels like, talking ill, talking
33:04good.
33:04That is his politics. I will leave it to the voters to decide.
33:08My bigger problem comes in when he says and tries to equate that India's democracy is some sort of a
33:15global good.
33:15And he actively asks for other forces around the world to come in and intervene because of this backsliding, quote
33:24unquote, backsliding that is happening.
33:26This is his words. He has repeated.
33:28It's not about just one instance, but he has said it at least two or three times in the past,
33:33that India's democracy is a global good.
33:36The problem is not also with a global good. The problem really is when you say that it is for
33:41others to come out and protect.
33:43That is where my problem starts.
33:45My problem is when you try to outsource your politics because you can't do politics in this country.
33:51You don't have the wherewithal to win elections in this country.
33:54You don't have the capacity to build an organization, for God's sake, which can go and fight elections and contest
34:00elections before you go out and demand 170 seats in a state like UP, where you're corroded, where your entire
34:06organization is corroded to the absolute highest levels.
34:09They are fighting against each other. And today you go out and sermon about India's democracy on the foreign soil.
34:15Allow me to end this.
34:16That is a stark contrast. He does not wedge this. He will carry on lamenting, carry on going on international
34:21flights to no outcome.
34:23All right. I thank all four of you.
34:25Sir, I'm sorry. I know Mr. Supple wanted to come in, but that's all the time we have for now.
34:29I appreciate all four of you gentlemen. Thank you for taking the time out this evening.
34:33With that, I just want to shift focus to an issue which is far, far more important than what anyone
34:39said anywhere.
34:40And that is pollution, especially in the national capital.
34:43Delhi's air quality has shown very little improvement, prompting now the withdrawal of Grab Stage 3 restrictions.
34:51But does a better AQI mean Delhiites are actually breathing clean air, from dust being kicked up on roads to
34:58pollution sources that are not always visible?
35:02My colleague Shreya Chatterjee takes a closer look at the picture beyond just AQI numbers.
35:11Delhi's air may be showing signs of improvement on government dashboards.
35:15But step out on the roads and the picture looks rather different.
35:21Grab Stage 2 specifically calls for daily mechanical or vacuum-based sweeping of identified roads, along with water sprinkling and
35:29dust suppression.
35:32Yet, our cameras captured manual road sweeping, with dust visibly being kicked back into the air.
35:41Grab 2 implemented in the national capital. Pollutions level still hovering between the very poor category.
35:50We see that these kind of cleaning facilities are given, especially in the central Delhi area.
36:16So around 400 such machines have come in the NDMC area and you can see that how they are vacuum
36:23-cleaning.
36:24But this does not give a cool picture of the natural machines.
36:27We at India today have seen that despite Grab 2 being implemented, even now manual sweeping is being carried out,
36:36contrary to what the guidelines say.
36:39But road dust is only one part of Delhi's pollution problem.
36:44On November 17, the Commission for Air Quality Management withdrew Grab Stage 3 restrictions across Delhi NCR, citing an improvement
36:53in air quality.
36:55Stages 1 and 2, however, continue to remain in force.
37:01On November 14, Delhi's AQI stood at 367.
37:06It fell to 290 on November 15, 275 on November 16 and further to 204 on November 17.
37:15But an improving citywide AQI does not necessarily mean that every part of Delhi is breathing cleaner air.
37:23While the official average showed improvement, independent air quality platforms continued to report high PM2.5 concentrations at several locations.
37:35According to AQI.in, Delhi's pollution level was 435 on November 14 before dipping to 284 on the 15th.
37:44However, the AQI level soared on November 16, reaching 406.
37:50And there is another dimension to Delhi's pollution that is often overlooked.
37:56IITM's source apportionment estimates reveal what is contributing to the city's PM2.5 load.
38:05Secondary organic sources are the biggest contributor, accounting for 29.5% of Delhi's PM2.5 pollution.
38:13Biomass burning, which includes stubble and wood burning, contributes 20.7%.
38:19Vehicular pollution accounts for 18.7%, followed by secondary inorganic sources at 11.1%.
38:27Mixed combustion makes up another 9.4%, while firecrackers contribute 3.3%.
38:33And waste burning accounts for 3.1%, according to the IITM assessment on November 13.
38:41The data makes one thing clear.
38:43Delhi's pollution cannot be attributed to a single source.
38:49Since the last four days, the government official data of the national capital suggests that we are breathing better.
38:55The equality has improved from the severe to the poor category.
38:58Grap 3 have been revoked.
39:00But the Rashtrapati Bhavan behind me is still invisible, raising a question that whether a 24-hour rolling average mechanism
39:09to record AQI is a perfect measure to actually state whether the pollutant levels have actually grown down across the
39:18national capital.
39:19And the invisible Rashtrapati Bhavan behind me is screaming a question before all of us that whether the AQI numbers
39:30we follow actually state that whether or at all the air has gone better or it's just a number masking
39:38the reality.
39:39With video journalist Anurag Saxena, this is Shreya Chattuji for India Today.
39:47And with what its impact, all you need to do is to visit any emergency wing ward of any Delhi
39:54hospital.
39:54You will have the front row seats to what is Delhi's air apocalypse.
39:59With that, we're going to get into a quick break on the other side.
40:02Sandpaper gate back in the spotlight with a huge bombshell.
40:06From Cameron Bancroft threatening to reopen cricket's biggest controversy.
40:12A detailed conversation with our sports editor Nikhil Nas on the other side.
40:24Welcome back viewers, you're watching news today and the resurgence of a huge, massive cricketing scandal.
40:31The sandpaper gate scandal is now snowballing into a massive fiasco all over again.
40:38This time Cameron Bancroft, one of the three people guilty of the controversy in Newlands, has dropped a massive bombshell
40:45in his column that he has written.
40:47Bancroft has said that the whole team knew about the sandpaper gate and has levelled serious allegations about the involvement
40:55of senior players and members of the coaching staff.
41:02Cameron Bancroft has broken his eight year silence on Australia's 2018 ball tampering scandal and has come up with shocking
41:09details about the entire incident.
41:11In a column in the West Australian, Bancroft has given a new detail that will reignite the debate on who
41:18is telling the truth in the entire fiasco.
41:22In the column, Bancroft revealed it was not just three of us, Smith, Warner and I, who knew about me
41:30using sandpaper.
41:32It was the whole team.
41:34It is common knowledge in the aftermath of Sandpaper Gate that Warner, Smith and Bancroft were the instigators.
41:40The former Australian opener Doe has made a series of serious allegations, notably on the fact that senior Australian bowlers
41:49like Cummins, Stark, Hazelwood were giving him advice on whether the ball was swinging enough.
41:55The bowling group has always maintained that they did not know about any foreign object being used in the Sandpaper
42:01Gate fiasco.
42:01But Bancroft has debunked the claims.
42:05Recall conversations with Cummins, Stark, Hazelwood and Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough.
42:13All bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working.
42:17It was helpful.
42:19Bancroft has alleged that head coach Darren Lehman and bowling coach David Saker were present during conversations about how the
42:26team could get the ball to reverse swing.
42:29That was coach David Saker.
42:31We acknowledged ball tampering while giving inaccurate account of material involved.
42:37It was another lie.
42:39One told why we were supposedly taking responsibility.
42:43Why did Bancroft reveal all of this?
42:46It is believed that Pat Cummins' Marathon 68 minute press conference was the tipping point and that he wrote all
42:53of this with nobody forcing him to do it and there was no benefit financially by sharing this.
42:57He felt it was time to tell the truth as he was not honest before this.
43:03Pat Cummins' press conference made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.
43:09Bancroft said.
43:11Didn't give complete truthful account.
43:14Withheld details on sandpaper use, how long it went, involvement and awareness of others.
43:21The scandal was reignited this month with the release of Usman Khwaja's book, Sabal.
43:26And his claims that knowledge of the cheating went beyond the three players.
43:30This comes amidst the development that Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chair David Boone announced players would be
43:38given an opportunity to discuss the sandpaper incident without fear of further sanctions.
43:46I've got nothing to hide.
43:47I'm happy to speak to anyone.
43:48So, I mean, 80 out of 11, because you don't know when the investigation happened.
43:53Because it was all confidential, wasn't it?
43:54It was all confidential, yeah.
43:55So, I was involved in that process and, you know, I didn't know how many players or staff were interviewed.
44:01So, you know, I think this gives everyone that didn't get a chance or the people that did get interviewed
44:06and they want to speak.
44:07That's fine.
44:08I think it gives everyone that little bit of clarity for Cricket Australia board to make a decision from there,
44:14what they release, etc.
44:15So, I think it's a good thing.
44:17However, David Boone has expressed caution about the development and has urged Cricket Australia to be more transparent.
44:25Well, I would have liked a open, independent inquiry.
44:28And the people that were there at the time actually can come forward and speak.
44:32Because we have no idea about what's happened behind closed doors with CA and the previous employees at Cricket Australia.
44:39So, I think that's really important too.
44:41But with Bancroft's revelation, the situation around Sandpaper Gate is not dying anytime soon.
44:51Alright, I'm joined right now by my colleague Nikhil Nars, consulting editor, sports.
44:56Nikhil, this is massive.
44:58Because, A, you're not just indicting the three who were said to be involved earlier.
45:03Practically the entire Australian cricket team and the coaching staff.
45:08Well, that's right, Preeti.
45:10You know, ever since the book came out, Ruswan Kwaja's book, it was his word against the rest of the
45:16bowling cartel as they've been referred to.
45:18And of course, David Warner being Kwaja's friend, many thought it was just two different parties talking about and, you
45:25know, taking two different sides.
45:27But now that Bancroft, and remember, he was the most affected.
45:30In fact, his career got over after that entire cheating scandal that happened eight years ago.
45:35He had kept mum all throughout.
45:38The only time he spoke was in 2021.
45:40And on that occasion also said, when asked the right question that, listen, it's self-explanatory.
45:45If the ball was being meddled with, if there was any sort of external things being put on the ball,
45:51the bowlers would definitely know it's self-explanatory.
45:54And that's what he had left it at.
45:56Now that he's made it clear that after that Pat Cummins press conference where he again felt that he was
46:00thrown under the bus, he thought it was necessary for him to come out and speak the truth.
46:05And I must tell you, Preeti, that what Bancroft has said now in that article that is written is so
46:11crystal clear with so many details.
46:13What 22 pages of Usman Kwaja's book, which actually reignited this debate, couldn't do this one particular article as done
46:21because he's written everything in detail.
46:23You're right, because he's gone into, you know, it's the fine print, I would reckon, you know, Nikhil, that matters
46:28more because he's spoken about events.
46:30He's spoken about, you know, what happened behind the scenes and how practically the coaching staff, the players, and he's
46:38even spoken about individual players and what their reaction was.
46:42So a lot of questions on who were not asked any questions and what remains hidden.
46:48That's right.
46:48Again, I understand that while Usman Kwaja was writing the book, he wasn't a central character.
46:53Yes, he was part of that team, but wasn't a central character like Bancroft was, like Warner was, like Smith
46:59was.
46:59And then you can also take a look at the bowling group.
47:02So you can understand that when he was writing about this incident and that's when you do, what do you
47:06do when you write your autobiography?
47:08Anything that is there within you, you really want to, you know, speak about it after your career is over,
47:12he did that.
47:13But he was a bit cagey.
47:14He didn't get into specifics.
47:16Even that interview that he did after writing the book, because there were allegations that, listen, he wants to sell
47:21his book.
47:21He wants to make money.
47:22That's why he's doing it.
47:23None of that is there with Bancroft.
47:25And as I said, he was a central figure.
47:27Now, whatever he says, you've got to take it very seriously.
47:30And as you said, he's pointed out in details.
47:32He talks about that he regularly spoke to bowlers.
47:35And he now tells you it wasn't just in the third test match in Cape Town, but this was happening
47:41even in the test match prior to that.
47:42Very quickly, what does this really mean for Australian cricket now?
47:46I think if Australian cricket really wants to clear its mess, they need to have an independent inquiry.
47:51What they're saying right now is that let's have an independent forum.
47:55Let's create a safe place for players to come and speak, and we'll take no action retrospectively.
48:00I think that's wrong.
48:02I think cricket Australia should welcome an investigation.
48:05Players, even if you're a pack coming, should welcome an investigation.
48:08Let's look at the matter once again.
48:09A lot of players want interviewed.
48:11They need to be interviewed.
48:12Because what is really coming out now that you threw a couple of players under the bus?
48:17My mind goes to what happened to Steve Smith.
48:19He came to that press conference, broke down.
48:21And why did this happen to him?
48:23Because he was honest enough to come out and say, yes, it was a leadership failure.
48:27Everyone else has refused to make responsibility and they get away with it.
48:31But it's interesting because in Bancroft's entire piece, he speaks of Smith.
48:37And he says that he was very clear about his disapproval.
48:42That's right.
48:42And so there is a sort of uniformity in that, right?
48:46This is what he has said about Steve Smith.
48:49This is what Khwaja has said.
48:51This is what Warner has said.
48:52And this is what Steve Smith said himself, that he did hear murmurs about this.
48:57And he said, listen, leave me out of it.
48:59What Steve Smith did, he said, he came out and said that I knew this was going to happen.
49:04And even though I wasn't part of the plan, it is a failure on my part as captain not to
49:09have stopped them doing it.
49:10He took responsibility.
49:12And guess what happened?
49:12He had to go for 12 months.
49:14He was paraded.
49:15You know, after that, he had to do that press conference with his father standing there.
49:19And he cried.
49:20Why?
49:20All of this happened because he was honest.
49:22Now that same kind of scrutiny is not being done on the current players.
49:25Might I add, Pat Cummins is the current captain of the Australian team.
49:29With these allegations of players that are part of that entire episode, doesn't his position become untenable?
49:35I would like to think so.
49:36Which is why an independent investigation is needed.
49:40True.
49:40And that's the question.
49:40You can have a safe place.
49:41Yes.
49:42And that's the question we're going to end with.
49:43Thank you, Nikhil, for joining us.
49:45I am sure we're going to have you back on the show tomorrow as well, because this is blowing up
49:49and how viewers.
49:51With that, we've reached the end of news today.
49:53But finally, our special series on Krishiveers.
49:56Farmers who adopted new techniques to boost incomes from the brink of financial ruin to building a multi-crore business.
50:04Krishna Yadav's journey is a story of grit, guts and entrepreneurship.
50:23From selling vegetables to building a pickles empire.
50:27Krishna Yadav has seen many ups and downs in life.
50:32They did a small business.
50:34They said, I'll take a car and drive a car.
50:37We'll go to school.
50:38We'll go to school for a good school.
50:40So, it was so big that all of us grew up in a way.
50:45They understood my story very difficult.
50:47And we went to Delhi.
50:49We went to Delhi.
50:51Farming was not a choice but a compulsion for the Yadavs.
50:55They sat in 3 months.
50:58They didn't get married for 3 months.
50:58They'd been married for 3-4 months.
50:59They didn't get married for 3 months.
51:01They'd have been married for a farm house.
51:03They saw it.
51:04We can live here.
51:06My children will find out where we will get to live.
51:09And we will start this.
51:11So, here we came and we took the forest here.
51:13And we took the forest here.
51:14We took the forest here.
51:15And we took the forest in the forest.
51:16We took the forest here.
51:18Krishna decided to do something out of the box.
51:48In 2002, Krishna started with vegetable achars.
51:53They sold their product on the roadside.
52:13The product line has today expanded to over 250 items.
52:18Including various kinds of pickles, chutneys, preserves and syrups.
52:42Krishna Pickles, the small venture Krishna Yadav started,
52:46is now a multi-crore rupee enterprise.
52:50With Om Pratap Shukla, Bureau Report, India Today.

Recommended