• 5 months ago
Speculation is intensifying over the upcoming Modi cabinet reshuffle, with a strong focus on increasing representation for poll-bound states like Uttar Pradesh ahead of the 2027 Assembly elections.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Mario Shakil.
00:02For the past three days, we have been closely tracking the buzz around the Modi Cabinet 3.0 reshuffle.
00:08Yesterday, we looked at the key political equations, particularly the demographics, the women, the youth,
00:14and also the OBC factors that could shape the government's next move.
00:19Tonight, the focus shifts to the states.
00:21Which states stand to gain or lose representation in the Union Cabinet?
00:27Will poll-bound states, particularly the states which go to polls immediately in the next six months,
00:35get a bigger share of the ministerial berths?
00:38And will electoral strategy be the defining factor behind the reshuffle?
00:44Before I bring in my colleagues and the panel, here's a report.
00:51I am Narendra Damodalas Modi.
01:12Elections after elections.
01:22One victory after another.
01:32Twelve years of the Modi government have reinforced one political lesson.
01:37That strong grassroots leadership in states often translates into electoral success.
02:11The
02:15Keep moving forward.
02:18The ancient mantra of Charayvati has often defined Prime Minister Modi's political journey.
02:24Now the same question is being asked in political circles, will that philosophy shape the next
02:30expansion of the Union Cabinet?
02:35If a Cabinet reshuffle takes place, all eyes will be on one key factor.
02:40Which states will gain greater representation and will poll-bound states get a bigger share?
02:48The current Council of Ministers reflects a clear regional balance.
02:55Uttar Pradesh has the highest representation with 11 ministers including Prime Minister
03:01Modi.
03:02Bihar has 8, Madhya Pradesh 7, Gujarat and Maharashtra 6 each.
03:08While Karnataka and Rajasthan have 5 each.
03:12Haryana, Andhra Pradesh and Odisha have 3 ministers each.
03:17Assam, Jharkhand, West Bengal and Telangana have 2 each.
03:22While Goa, Jammu and Kashmir, Keralam, Uttarakhand, Delhi, Arunachal Pradesh and Chhattisgarh have
03:31one ministry each.
03:34The spotlight however is once again on Uttar Pradesh, where Assembly elections are just months
03:41away.
03:43With the Prime Minister himself representing the state, speculation is growing over whether
03:49UP's representation in the Cabinet could increase further to strengthen the BJP's election machinery.
03:56The reason for that speculation lies in the 2021 Cabinet expansion.
04:03Ahead of the 2022 UP Assembly elections, 7 of the 36 new ministers inducted were from Uttar
04:11Pradesh, taking the state's total representation to 16.
04:16Today, UP has 11 ministers, including the Prime Minister.
04:21The question is, will that number rise again before the 2027 Assembly polls?
04:27Similar calculations are also being discussed for Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Uttarakhand
04:36and Manipur, all states with upcoming Assembly elections.
04:42Ahead of 2022 Assembly elections, the 2021 reshuffle reflected that strategy.
04:50Two ministers from Gujarat were promoted.
04:53There were new inductions from the state as well.
04:55Anurag Thakur, who comes from Himachal and Hardeep Singh Puri, who hails from Punjab, were
05:02elevated.
05:03And Manipur got a new Minister of State.
05:09Apart from poll-bound states, possible vacancies could also open doors for new faces from Delhi
05:15and Punjab.
05:17West Bengal is another state to look out for.
05:21It currently has two ministers, but no cabinet minister.
05:27With former TMC MPs now aligned with the NDA through the NCPI, there is speculation that
05:35some of them could find a place in the union cabinet.
05:38At the same time, after its recent political gains in the state, the BJP may also look to
05:44strengthen West Bengal's representation in the Council of Ministers.
05:55If the political template of previous cabinet expansion is followed, the next reshuffle may
06:01not be just about governance.
06:03It could also be the BJP's political blueprint for the next round of Assembly elections.
06:10With Himancho Mishra, Bureau Report, India Today.
06:23A news is coming in that a meeting at Home Minister Amit Shah's house began at 7pm.
06:30And BJP Chief Nitin Nabeen has attended that meeting.
06:34And sources are saying that there is likely discussion on the new team of the BJP chief.
06:40Let me bring in Piyush and Himancho are joining us.
06:44Himancho, what has happened in this meeting?
06:47What has happened in this meeting?
06:49What has happened in this meeting?
07:02A meeting can remain in the timely meeting.
07:04We check it in how many girls are going to be working, how many girls want to be
07:06child warrior?
07:08Because inicio 5 girls there are
07:105 girls in the primeiro party, they are very prominent to see what men are.
07:23These 5 girls are very important to see.
07:27You can see there are Whoa girls, пришers, Freshers,
07:31neuters, Publicers etc.
07:33Let's say, who will be the vice president and who will be the vice president, who is the vice president,
07:44who will be the vice president.
07:45in the party, the president of Upadhyaya Kshani, the vice president of the party.
07:54In the symbolic way, because they come from a big constitutional position.
07:59So, in this way, which country will be a great king?
08:06Who will be in North India?
08:09If you look at Himachal, Haryana, Punjab, Jammu Kashmir, who needs to come from the general secretary?
08:16These are all issues. The national executive team is also on the issue.
08:20There are many things on this issue. There are many things on this issue.
08:23There are many things on this issue. There are many things on this issue.
08:26And now you can say that the team has reached the final decision.
08:32When will the final decision come to the international party?
08:34And you will get to see this list.
08:36The team will be so young, experienced, who will be?
08:43And who are those teams who work hard on the team?
08:48Whether they are Sunil Bansal, Vinod Taavde, or the general secretary,
08:53who are all the leaders of the team.
08:55Okay. So, Piyush, are you sensing then that after this meeting,
08:59it's only perhaps a formal announcement that's left of the new team of Nitin Nabeen?
09:05Because earlier he was scheduled to travel to Uttar Pradesh on 3rd and 4th,
09:10and that program was rescheduled.
09:12And now he is undertaking that trip to Uttar Pradesh,
09:16which is a pole-bound state on 4th and 5th.
09:18So, is it likely to be announced in the next 24 hours?
09:22Well, most likely it's likely to be announced in the coming few hours.
09:27Yes, Mare, you would remember that in our earlier conversations,
09:30we have discussed as to how names have already been decided.
09:33It's just that the consultant has to announce the names.
09:38And that is going to happen very soon.
09:40That's what we are now learning from our associates.
09:43It was a late evening meet which happened at the residence of Mr. Amit Shah,
09:47in which BJP's national president Nitin Nabeen was present.
09:51And what we are told is that a final touch has been given to the list,
09:55which has already been decided.
09:57And remember that the BJP is going to give representation from all the castes,
10:03from all the communities.
10:04And the biggest cast which BJP and PM Redmondi has also been talking about,
10:09Yuba and Mahila.
10:11So, you will see a lot of representation from Mahila as well as Yuba.
10:15And Nitin Nabeen himself is Yuba, the president of BJP.
10:20And a lot of leaders likely to be younger leaders in this new team of Bharati Ranta Party.
10:26And what we are also told is that there will be complete overhaul.
10:30Most likely the existing members of the BJP national president,
10:35they are likely to be sent to cabinet.
10:38And a few leaders from cabinet and senior leaders who have proved their mettle in various states,
10:45they could be inducted into the new team of Bharati Ranta Party.
10:49So, final discussions are taking place very soon.
10:52No, but you are now learning is that...
10:55An announcement.
10:55An announcement.
10:56And that list, we'll be able to see that list.
11:00Himanshu and Piyush continue to be with us because,
11:02remember the government is weighing a possible cabinet reshuffle.
11:06Uttar Pradesh is expected to remain central to the BJP's political calculations
11:11ahead of the crucial 2027 assembly elections.
11:14The state had nine union ministers each in 2014 and 2019 cabinets.
11:21And despite the BJP's reduced Lok Sabha tally from Uttar Pradesh in 2024,
11:27its representation in the Union Council of Ministers remains unchanged at nine.
11:32And this has fueled a speculation that the state could receive greater representation
11:37in a future cabinet expansion.
11:40Uttar Pradesh already has the highest representation with 11 ministers,
11:44including the prime minister himself.
11:46So, can UP get representation, more representation?
11:50Rashid Kidwai is joining us.
11:51We also have Sajjan Kumar.
11:53Sajjan, you know, there has been a lot of emphasis particularly on the OBC
11:58and their representation in the Union Council of Ministers.
12:01Now we are seeing also the buzz around Uttar Pradesh.
12:05A poll-bound state, many would say it's a safe guess to have,
12:08an informed guess to have that a state as crucial as UP,
12:13which the BJP must win to continue to send a message that in the run-up to 2029,
12:18there is that momentum in the favor of the party.
12:22That state could see more of their MPs find a place in the Union Council of Ministers
12:27when the reshuffle happens.
12:34Sajjan, you have to unmute yourself.
12:36Yeah, go ahead.
12:38That's a logical likelihood,
12:39reason being that while BJP as of now is the most representative party
12:44as far as the OBCs in UP are concerned,
12:48bearing one caste that is Yadavs.
12:50If you go by the organizational presence,
12:52as well as now the Kurmi caste is the state president.
12:56And before that also, it has been representing non-Yadav UBC blobs.
12:59But nevertheless, in the backdrop of Akhilesh Yadavs' success in 2024,
13:04which was attributed to PDA, Dalit Pichra, and Alp Sankhya,
13:08where in the Pichra constitute the bulk, BJP has a reason to be more cautious,
13:15more kind of aggressive as far as selling the perception on the ground
13:21that it still represents the OBC's interest in terms of representation in the central cabinet also.
13:28So that is one of the reasons.
13:29And in the recent backdrop of many negative news cycles and sort of Akhilesh trying to set the narrative leading
13:39up to 2027,
13:41on the plank of PDA, BJP has a reason certainly to give representation from the UP.
13:47Besides that, Brahmins may also be one of the factors wherein, you know, the narrative of Brahmin anger,
13:54though they end up voting for BJP, but that has been one optics which dominated the news cycle before 2022
14:00assembly election
14:02and right now also.
14:04But as far as Pichdas and Brahmins, these two communities are concerned.
14:09I think BJP would like to go for these optics and dominate the perception in run-up to the 2027
14:16election.
14:16Okay, Rashid, what's your assessment?
14:19Of course, we do not know when the cabinet is happening.
14:21So, let's say that we have spoken about multiple window which is available,
14:26certainly when the Prime Minister could undertake this exercise.
14:31But all certainty is that if the reshuffle happens, one state which will gain is Uttar Pradesh.
14:39So, first of all, Maria, I think there has been just too much of a speculation.
14:43There is a lack of transparency.
14:44There is not even, we do not know what is the kind of report card is there about minister's appraisal
14:50that was done.
14:50We know that when, you know, bureaucratic exercise takes place, then there are some transfers and postings.
14:55So, we get some indication.
14:57But on a political front, there is an absence of it.
14:59So, I think that is going to hurt.
15:00I think what you are emphasizing about Uttar Pradesh, it looks, you know, very good and it looks perhaps something
15:07effective.
15:07But I think it is going to be largely very cosmetic because a big change has happened.
15:12I think these allegations of Chandachori, you know, have really shaken, you know, many people, faithful faith in government, in
15:21people who are on the responsible position.
15:23So, that needs to be, you know, corrected.
15:27That perception needs to be corrected.
15:29The similar thing I would say about Madhya Pradesh, where a sort of credible newspaper, you know, carried a thing
15:35about land allegations and all the BJP is trying to, you know, show that they are in command because of
15:40all those defections and things.
15:42So, there is a lot of, sort of, they are showing as if the regional parties are dying, Congress is
15:48weak, so the BJP is in command.
15:50But on ground level, things are changing and things, it's not the same.
15:53So, I think a cabinet reshuffle is very much required, substantive reshuffle.
15:58It is about accountability, it's about, you know, you know, rebooting the whole system.
16:02There is over emphasis on some certain, you know, bureaucrats and politicians.
16:07I think it is actually politics is about politicians.
16:11So, technocrats, you know, we have seen that find a place in Prime Minister Modi's Council of Ministers.
16:18So, I am going to take that question to Himanshu again.
16:21Himanshu, you know, technocrats finding a place in Prime Minister Modi's Council of Ministers.
16:26We have seen that happen.
16:28The focus has been largely on that they will bring in fresh ideas and perhaps a different approach to the
16:34government and governance.
16:36Look, there are two things on this side.
16:38Whether it's a government, whether it's a UPA or a government government.
16:43There are technocrats coming.
16:46In every government, people come from this way.
16:49There are many experiments here.
16:51S.J. Shankar, Ashwani Vaishnav, Suresh Prabhu.
16:55If you look, there are many R.K. Singh, they are bureaucrats.
16:59They are not bureaucrats.
17:01So, in this way, Haradipuri has been adjusted by many people.
17:04They are adjusted by many people.
17:05If their commitment is to be taken.
17:07You can see Har Singh, he is a Foreign Secretary,
17:09he is also coming.
17:10They have two countries.
17:13They are not in the cabinet, but the country is in Delhi.
17:17So, there are people from this way to this way who are put in the government.
17:22They have new ideas of the government.
17:24Or they can handle the bureaucracy in which by the government should handle the bureaucrats.
17:28can handle it. And in many things there are benefits, such as Ashwani Vaishnam, if you will see them in
17:35the IT sector, there are many things in the railway sector.
17:39So if we look at these issues, the experts are trying to do new things within the government.
17:45If we look at these issues, it can be done by any government. And it can be done by the
17:52cabinet, you have to look at some new faces.
17:56But there is one thing, because you were talking about the organization.
18:01People go to this government and go to this government. I don't remember the government.
18:06One example is that the government came to this government is J.P. Nadda.
18:19Since you are saying that the government has not been introduced to the government, the pattern has not been introduced
18:27to the government.
18:27In the last 12 years.
18:28In the last 12 years.
18:29It is a very important thing to think about that.
18:31It is not going to be anticipated.
18:32This is what we are anticipating.
18:33The people are saying that there are some kind of people who have been responsible for the leadership of the
18:39government.
18:42They have been responsible for the responsibility of the government.
18:45When the people have been given their power to the government, they have been able to perform it.
18:46And the power of the government will be important to them.
18:49Maybe they will take their power to the government.
18:49You can understand many technical things. The British Party has a new trend.
18:56You will be in charge of the government, and you will be in charge of the government.
19:01You can see, like Dharvendra Pradhan, Ashwani Vaisnav, Siyar Patil, Bhupendra Riyadav, J.P. Nada,
19:09when the government was in charge of the Uttar Pradesh.
19:11In charge of the government, many people are given to this way.
19:16Shivra Singh Chauhan, Hemantavish Sharma, Jharkhand, Shivra Singh Chauhan.
19:21When the election of Karnataka was in 2018, Prakash Javadikar was put in charge of Dharvendra Pradhan.
19:27When the election of Karnataka in 2023, Dharvendra Pradhan was in charge of the government.
19:32As a minister, a lot of work in Chunavi Raja is put in charge of the government.
19:41That's why this trend has been reduced in this government.
19:44People come from the government.
19:46People come from the government.
19:49People come from the government.
19:49If the government comes from the government,
19:51if you look from the government,
19:52it's a rare case of Ravishankar Prasad.
19:56When they were removed in 2021,
19:58Prakash Javadikar, Ramesh Pukhriyal, Nishan, Harshwardhan,
20:02or all of these people, they didn't have adjustment in this way.
20:08Yes, it didn't have adjustment in this way.
20:10I agree with you that those were examples that we are seeing before us as well.
20:15Let me go back to Sajjan and Rashid.
20:17Hemant you continue to be with us.
20:19Sajjan, your thoughts certainly, of course, we are building up to it.
20:23We have been discussing multiple factors over the last few days.
20:26State representation will be key.
20:28Because, you know, the fact that if the government,
20:33if the BJP managed to get one MP from the state of Kerala,
20:36that MP found a place in the Council of Ministers.
20:39That was high on optics, high on symbolism.
20:43Yes, precisely.
20:45First of all, when that reshuffle will happen, we do not know.
20:47But it seems that it may be after the monsoon session
20:50because Prime Minister is living for a week tour on Indo-Pacific nations,
20:566th to 12th or 13th July.
20:58And thereafter, they would not like to have a minister freshly inducted
21:02who would be responsible to answering many questions during the monsoon session.
21:05No, but that has happened.
21:06Just ahead of the monsoon session,
21:08seven days before the monsoon session,
21:09there has been one instance of cabinet reshuffle.
21:12In all, in the last 12 years, there have been four cabinet reshuffles.
21:16So, this is the fifth it will happen when, as and when it happens.
21:20Yeah, I mean, if it doesn't happen in next two days,
21:24then after Prime Minister comes.
21:25So, window is there. That is one thing.
21:26But certainly, a state representation is one of the criteria
21:30because certainly, there are expectations that the poll-bound states,
21:34which is next year, you have five states in February, March,
21:38and then Himachal and—sorry, Gujarat and Himachal in the later part of 2027.
21:45That's there.
21:45But more than that, I think the state representation,
21:49Prime Minister is emphasizing one thing.
21:51He has again brought into centrality the optics of or the policy of Vision Viksit Bharat 2047,
22:00and saying that various departments and their administrative structure
22:04needs to align with that vision.
22:07So, there has to be a long-term synchronization.
22:09So, that is why I think, along with the state representation,
22:13we should expect also some of the faces,
22:16because ultimately, the reshuffle and going by Prime Minister's mindset
22:20and outlook that is in the past,
22:22he would like to make it a narrative about the India narrative.
22:25And in the backdrop of the negative news cycle
22:28because of the global uncertainties,
22:30also the domestic incidences,
22:32he would like to, you know, dominate the India narrative via that step.
22:36So, I think state representativeness would be there.
22:39There would be a demographic representativeness,
22:42but he would also like to dominate the India narrative,
22:46and which is about that how all the policies
22:48and the changes are part of a Vision Viksit Bharat 2047.
22:52Okay, okay.
22:53So, this is the cabinet that will be preparing also India for 2047.
22:57That will be the sense, the messaging,
22:59because when the Prime Minister chaired the meeting of the secretaries,
23:02again, that was the agenda.
23:05Rashid, come in.
23:06You have 30 seconds.
23:08I think, Maria, this is all optics and narrative building.
23:12It has very little traction on the ground.
23:15This government is very good at, you know, explaining
23:17and, you know, giving a spin to whatever it does.
23:21The key thing is that anybody moving out of, you know,
23:25cabinet or Council of Ministers are going to organization
23:27is seen as some kind of demotion.
23:29Now, this perception, Mr. Modi, has not been able to change.
23:33So, while you can sugarcoat it that those who are working
23:36for party are doing a bigger thing and, you know,
23:38Seva, Tyag, all those things that you can give.
23:41But the thing is that anybody who is removed,
23:44Council of Ministers that we are going to see in a week's time
23:47or fortnight's time, that will be seen as some kind of punishment
23:50and demotion.
23:50So, this is a real political challenge before Mr. Nareen Modi.
23:54All right, Rashid.
23:57And Sarjan, I appreciate your time.
23:59I think Himanshu continues to be with us.
24:02Himanshu, what's your sense?
24:04How soon do you sense that announcement of the organization
24:07is likely because we have been maintaining that first
24:11the new team of Nitin Nabeen will take shape
24:16and then only the reshuffle will happen?
24:19I'm not sure that the need for our planning is working on this,
24:24we have to come with us.
24:26After this, we will meet the Prime Minister
24:29and we will discuss which place we are getting,
24:34which place we are getting, which place we are getting,
24:35which place we are getting, which place we are getting.
24:37It's been a few years ago,
24:40But the British Party is changing, these discussions are made of social engineering.
24:47It is such a social engineering that when you say who is taking it, you can keep the time.
24:53If you think that today you are making a secret, and tomorrow you have to fight them,
24:57then you will also get rid of them from there.
24:59They will also get rid of them.
25:00And there is a new appointment in that post.
25:04This is a new way that the British Party has developed in the past few years.
25:09And there is a lot of political parties.
25:11There is a lot of experiments that the British Party has done in the past 12 years.
25:15That's right.
25:16The other thing, because when the cabinet reshuffle will happen,
25:19this is the President of the United States.
25:22And they know it in a very good way when they have to do it.
25:26One thing we all know and say is that now the media speculation,
25:30all the knowledge that we talk to each other,
25:33the leaders, the leaders, the leaders, they all fail.
25:38That's right.
25:39Because if I talk about the cricket,
25:41then the President of Narendra Modi,
25:43today's baller's reverse swing is very low.
25:46If you look at the ball, the ball is reverse swing,
25:49they also throw the ball out and throw the ball out.
25:54Thank you for joining us.
26:00Thank you very much.
26:00Thank you for joining us.

Recommended