Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 weeks ago
In Switzerland, homes destroyed by landslides and rock avalanches are repeatedly rebuilt. Yet the idea of abandoning entire villages to set up new ones in safer locations remains taboo.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:01The mountains are crumbling away, glaciers are breaking apart, and rockslides are burying entire villages.
00:11In the Alps, places that were considered safe for decades are now in danger.
00:20It isn't easy, because this is our home, these are our roots.
00:24When should people be evacuated? You can see there's a problem, but maybe it won't be for another five years.
00:32To move away or to stay? In Switzerland, this is a question nobody wants to talk about. But why?
00:40In 2025, a glacier collapsed in the Lüchenthal Valley, leaving the Swiss village of Blätten almost completely buried and flooded.
00:50The 300 residents were evacuated in time. Only one life was lost, but the village could not be saved.
00:59Just 20 kilometres from Blätten lies the town of Sankt Niklaus, also surrounded by mountains.
01:06But new construction goes on as normal. Companies are investing in Sankt Niklaus, and new apartments are being built.
01:14Life goes on, yet here too the mountains pose a threat.
01:20Andreas Katna has experienced this new reality first-hand.
01:24In winter, a piece of the mountain broke off. Most of the debris landed on the neighbouring sports field.
01:33One piece, however, cleared the railway tracks at the property line and landed on his in-laws' house.
01:39Fortunately, it was unoccupied, unlike the houses in the surrounding area.
01:47Due to this massive boulder, there was nothing more that could be done for the house.
01:53The people of Valais live in constant fear of landslides. The people could no longer ignore the power of nature.
02:01If nothing happens for a long time, it gets forgotten. In that sense, it's good when an event like this
02:07happens every now and then.
02:10It reminds us that nature is more powerful than humans.
02:19Peaks reaching 4,500 metres reign over Sankt Niklaus and its narrow, steep valley.
02:25The mountain slopes consist of jagged rocks, crumbling material that could slide a thousand metres down into the valley.
02:33The landslides are being documented and studied.
02:37For 20 years, geoscientists have been surveying the steep slopes.
02:42Time-lapse photography captures how they are constantly in motion.
02:46The reason for this lies higher up in what are known as blocked glaciers,
02:50sheets of ice and rubble at an altitude of 3,000 metres.
02:55Rising temperatures are causing them to thaw, releasing the debris to tumble down into the valley.
03:00But what does this mean for the residents below?
03:04Should settlements now be relocated? Should the population retreat?
03:08This is a question for policymakers.
03:11But as Brigitte Wolf from the Green Party explains, climate change remains a sensitive issue for politicians.
03:19The first problem is simply acknowledging it.
03:23And there are still political groups, parties that would rather not face this reality,
03:27would rather not say, yes, this is climate change, and would rather put it off a little longer.
03:35When it comes to the village of Blattin, the goal is clear.
03:39Reconstruction, whatever the cost.
03:41The mayor of this village of 300 has secured hundreds of millions of francs from the Swiss government for that
03:47purpose.
03:48The key message is this, we can no longer bring back the old Blattin.
03:53What we want to do is build a new Blattin.
03:57Defying nature is something everyone in Switzerland seems to agree on, even in government.
04:04We also have a duty to make it possible for you to live in the Lütschenthal again, just as you're
04:10used to.
04:12After all, for most people in Switzerland, there is no greater good than the right to one's hometown,
04:18which is why the new Blattin is to be rebuilt in just five years.
04:22Meanwhile, officials in the municipality of Sankt Niklaus are investing in massive retention areas.
04:28These are designed to stop all the debris that the increase in avalanches and rockfalls will rain down in the
04:34future.
04:35We have a capacity here of about 15,000 to 20,000 cubic meters, up to the top edge.
04:44It would take three or four days to haul all that material away.
04:49That means working non-stop until all the material is removed.
04:57The topic of relocating is especially taboo in valleys where the economy and industry continue to grow.
05:03After all, it was only through engineering prowess and significant financial investments
05:08that Switzerland was able to make these steep mountain regions habitable in the first place.
05:13Brigitte Wolf is sad that Swiss politicians can't easily change these norms.
05:18Change is always difficult for society to accept.
05:22Leaving your home is a change that nobody wants.
05:24And a politician who says, now we have to ban everything, change everything, is committing political suicide.
05:32Andreas Katner doesn't see listening to nature and facing the unpleasant consequences as something taboo.
05:39That's why he wants to tear down what's left of the house and leave the property undeveloped.
05:48The day may still come when we have to say, time to go.
05:53That's not easy because this is our home.
05:55These are our roots.
05:58And our roots go deep.
06:00We've just seen what happened with the landslide in Blattin.
06:04It's terrible when you lose everything or have to leave it behind because of danger from the mountains above.
06:14Katner knows that fighting nature's forces is ultimately futile.
06:18But he remains in the minority in Switzerland and not just in Sankt Niklaus.
06:28Now we have to continue to talk about this.
06:30I can take a look at this.
06:30It's an open eye to the forest.
06:30The forest is found in the forest.

Recommended