00:00Hi, and welcome to 10 Minute Neuroscience.
00:03In this installment, I'll be focusing on the neuroscience of consciousness.
00:07When neuroscientists talk about consciousness, they're usually referring to subjective experience,
00:12the fact that there is something it is like to see a color, feel pain, think a thought,
00:18or simply be aware.
00:20We often associate consciousness with being awake because waking life is full of subjective
00:24experiences.
00:24Right now, for example, you're probably conscious of the screen in front of you, my
00:29voice, and maybe thoughts or feelings in the background, among other things.
00:33But consciousness is not the same thing as wakefulness.
00:36While we're awake, consciousness is usually directed toward the external world, but conscious
00:41experiences can also occur during sleep.
00:44When we dream, for example, we may be disconnected from our surroundings, but we can still have
00:49vivid experiences.
00:49We can see places, interact with people, feel emotions, and experience events that seem
00:55completely real in a dream.
00:57In other words, even though we're asleep, some degree of consciousness is present.
01:02But consciousness seems to disappear at other times when people are not awake, like during
01:07periods of dreamless sleep and under some forms of general anesthesia.
01:12In those states, people often report no experiences at all.
01:15From their perspective, there were no sights, sounds, or thoughts.
01:18This suggests that when someone is not awake, they might be conscious or they might not
01:22be, and that raises an important question in consciousness research.
01:27How can we determine for sure whether someone is conscious?
01:31In everyday life, we usually infer that a person is conscious from their behavior.
01:36If they can respond to questions, follow instructions, or describe their experiences, we assume they're
01:41conscious.
01:42But behavior isn't always a reliable indicator of consciousness.
01:45A person may be unable to communicate or respond, even if some degree of awareness remains.
01:52This possibility became clear through studies of patients diagnosed with what was traditionally
01:56called a vegetative state, but is now often referred to as unresponsive wakefulness syndrome.
02:02These patients may open their eyes and show normal sleep-wake cycles, but they don't display
02:07clear signs of purposeful behavior.
02:08For many years, it was typically assumed these patients were entirely unaware.
02:13That assumption, however, was challenged by a brain imaging study that was published
02:17in 2006.
02:18The study involved a 23-year-old woman who had experienced a traumatic brain injury and been
02:23unresponsive for about five months.
02:25She was diagnosed as being in a vegetative state and showed no signs of awareness.
02:30In the study, researchers asked her to imagine playing tennis and then to imagine walking
02:35through her home.
02:36During this time, they monitored her brain activity.
02:39When they asked her to imagine playing tennis, activity increased in the supplementary motor
02:43area, a region involved in planning and mentally simulating movements.
02:48When they asked her to imagine walking through her home, activity increased in brain regions
02:52associated with spatial navigation like the parahippocampal gyrus and posterior parietal cortex.
02:59These patterns closely matched those seen in healthy participants given the same instructions,
03:05suggesting that she may have understood the commands and altered her mental activity in
03:10response to them.
03:11Subsequent studies have found that a small number of patients with disorders of consciousness
03:15seem to be able to change their brain activity in response to commands, suggesting they might
03:20be aware, able to understand language, and able to follow instructions despite being unable
03:25to communicate.
03:27Findings like these highlight one of the biggest challenges in consciousness research.
03:31We can't observe consciousness directly.
03:34Instead, we have to infer its presence from behavior, physiological responses, or patterns
03:39of brain activity.
03:40And while behavior is often a useful guide, it's not always reliable because a person might
03:45be conscious without being able to show it.
03:48This is one reason neuroscientists are interested in identifying the neural basis of consciousness.
03:54If consciousness arises from brain activity, then understanding the neural mechanisms associated
03:59with conscious experience may help reveal when consciousness is present and how it emerges.
04:05This search has led researchers to focus on what are known as the neural correlates of consciousness,
04:10which are defined as the minimal neural mechanisms sufficient for having a conscious experience.
04:15In other words, researchers are trying to identify the brain activity that most directly supports
04:21consciousness rather than activity that merely precedes it or results from it.
04:26One way scientists try to do this is by comparing situations in which consciousness is present with
04:32situations in which it is absent or altered.
04:34For example, they might compare wakefulness with anesthesia, or compare brain activity when
04:39a stimulus is consciously perceived with activity when the same stimulus is processed without
04:44awareness.
04:46These approaches help researchers identify brain activity that's most closely associated with
04:51conscious experience, but still, the picture that has emerged is very complex.
04:55Some brain areas, for example, are clearly important for enabling consciousness, but they may not
05:01directly determine the contents of experience.
05:04The brainstem, for instance, contains systems involved in arousal and wakefulness.
05:09Severe damage to those systems can lead to a coma, suggesting that the brainstem helps provide
05:14the background conditions that allow consciousness to occur.
05:17But brainstem activity alone doesn't seem to be sufficient for normal conscious experience, because
05:22patients with severe damage to areas like the cerebral cortex, but relatively preserved brainstem
05:28function may remain in a vegetative or unresponsive state.
05:32The thalamus also appears to be important, especially through its interactions with the cerebral cortex.
05:38Damage to certain parts of the thalamus can impair consciousness, and stimulation of the thalamus
05:43has even been associated with improvements in responsiveness in some minimally conscious patients.
05:48But the exact role of the thalamus is debated.
05:51It may help to coordinate communication among regions of the cortex, rather than directly
05:56generating conscious experience itself.
05:59Many researchers think the specific contents of consciousness might depend primarily on activity
06:03in the cerebral cortex.
06:05Within the cerebral cortex, there has been considerable debate about which regions are most important
06:10for consciousness.
06:12Earlier studies often pointed to regions in the frontal and parietal lobes, because those areas
06:17became active when people reported conscious experiences.
06:21More recent research, however, suggests that some of this activity may be related to attention,
06:26decision making, or just reporting an experience rather than the experience itself.
06:31As a result, many researchers have shifted their focus toward a set of regions closer to
06:35the back of the brain, particularly parts of the parietal, temporal, and occipital lobes, because
06:42areas in these lobes appear to be closely linked to the contents of conscious experience.
06:47Even if we identify the brain regions most closely associated with consciousness, however, an important
06:53question remains.
06:54Have we actually explained consciousness, or have we only identified correlations between
06:59brain activity and consciousness?
07:02Some philosophers and scientists argue that identifying the neural correlates of consciousness
07:06would still leave open the deeper question of why does that brain activity feel like anything
07:11from the inside at all?
07:14This is where a famous distinction between what are known as the easy problems and the
07:18hard problem of consciousness becomes relevant.
07:21The easy problems involve explaining the neural functions associated with consciousness, like
07:27how we recognize a face, focus our attention, or make a decision.
07:31These problems are not easy in the ordinary sense, but are considered relatively easier because
07:37they seem approachable using standard scientific methods.
07:40We have, for example, made considerable progress in understanding how patterns of neural activity
07:45contribute to the construction of visual experiences.
07:49The hard problem asks why any physical process should be accompanied by subjective experience
07:55in the first place.
07:56Even if we identified the neural correlates of consciousness perfectly, we could still ask,
08:02why does that neural activity feel like anything from the inside at all?
08:06Why does activity in the visual cortex, for example, produce the experience of seeing, rather
08:12than just unconscious information processing?
08:15This is why identifying neural correlates of consciousness may not be the same as fully explaining consciousness.
08:23Neural correlates of consciousness research can tell us which neural mechanisms are associated
08:28with consciousness and maybe which are necessary or sufficient for it, but some researchers
08:33argue that a complete theory of consciousness has to go further and explain why those mechanisms
08:38give rise to subjective experience at all.
08:40And most researchers would agree that we're not very close to being able to explain that.
08:45Several competing theories of consciousness have been developed to attempt to explain how subjective
08:49experience arises.
08:51But it's important to note that these theories don't always address the same question.
08:55Some focus on why certain information becomes available for thought and action, while others
09:00focus on why conscious experience has the particular qualities it does.
09:04One influential idea is global workspace theory.
09:08According to this view, much of the brain's processing occurs unconsciously in specialized systems.
09:14Information becomes conscious when it gains access to a global workspace, where it can be shared
09:19with systems involved in attention, memory, decision-making, etc.
09:23A common analogy is the theater stage.
09:26Many processes occur behind the scenes, but when information reaches the stage and enters
09:30the spotlight, it becomes available to other systems throughout the brain.
09:34In neural versions of the theory, this global broadcasting is thought to involve large-scale
09:39networks in the cerebral cortex, often emphasizing frontal and parietal regions of the brain.
09:44Another major idea is integrated information theory, or IIT.
09:50IIT begins with the observation that at any moment, your experience contains many distinct
09:55elements like sights, sounds, thoughts, and bodily sensations, but these elements are experienced
10:00together as a single unified conscious scene.
10:03IIT proposes that this unity depends on the brain's ability to integrate information across
10:09many interacting parts.
10:11According to IIT, consciousness is not produced by individual brain regions acting independently,
10:16but by the way their activities are integrated into a coherent whole.
10:21Another framework involves a mechanism known as predictive processing.
10:25According to this view, the brain is constantly generating expectations about the world, and comparing
10:31them with incoming sensory information.
10:33When sensory input differs from what was expected, the brain revises its model of the world.
10:39Rather than serving as a passive recorder of reality, the brain actively interprets sensory
10:44information to determine what is most likely out there.
10:47In this way, conscious experience can be understood as the brain's best current interpretation of
10:53the causes of its sensory inputs, shaped by both incoming evidence and prior expectations.
10:57None of these theories has fully explained consciousness, and researchers continue to debate their strengths
11:03and weaknesses.
11:04But each provides a useful framework for asking questions and designing experiments.
11:10So consciousness remains one of the deepest mysteries in neuroscience.
11:14It doesn't appear likely to be explained by a single brain region, but probably depends on complex interactions
11:20among distributed brain systems involved in communication, integration, prediction, and information sharing.
11:28We've made progress in identifying brain systems associated with conscious experience, in detecting
11:33signs of awareness in some people who can't respond behaviorally, and in developing theories
11:38that try to explain how experience might arise from brain activity.
11:42But we still don't have a complete answer to why the activity of the brain is accompanied
11:46by the internal subjective reality of experience.
11:50So, that's a brief introduction to the very complex topic of consciousness.
11:55If you have any questions, feel free to ask them in the comments, and I'll do my best to answer
11:59them.