Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 7 hours ago
Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning dramatizes Frances Haugen’s decision to expose Facebook’s internal documents, and critics are already debating its triumphant ending. But the movie leaves out the millions of people who were living inside those secrets every day: creators. Starting around 2018, the advice in every creator group quietly shifted, and nobody explained why. The leaked documents eventually revealed what was behind it.

What’s Trending breaks down the scoring system that reshaped what we post, what we see, and why our feeds feel angrier than they used to. We look at what Facebook’s own researchers warned about, what the company chose to change and what it didn’t, and why the incentive behind it never fully went away. If you’ve ever wondered why so much of the internet seems built to make you mad, this is where it started.

Category

🎈
Fun
Transcript
00:00If you walked out of Aaron Sorkin's The Social Reckoning this month feeling a little sick,
00:04you're not the only one. The debate is over. The movie exposes how Facebook created an algorithm
00:10designed to reward meaningful engagement. But what the platform never admitted out loud was
00:15how it actually defined meaningful. Under the hood, an angry emoji reaction was weighted five
00:20times higher than a simple like. And for a platform whose mission statement was connecting people,
00:25they built an engine that actively divided users. And Facebook knew about it. Of course,
00:30there was massive lawsuits, FTC fines, and congressional hearings. So you'd think the
00:35system got fixed, right? So we're gonna get back to our roots and focus on reducing mistakes and
00:40restoring free expression on our platforms. First, we're gonna get rid of fact checkers and replace
00:45them with community notes similar to X starting in the US. That exact same engagement engine is
00:51running fake ad scandals. Because how are you like raising your son and teaching him to scam other
00:56people for money? AI crypto scams. Because the owner of this page, Sean Phil, has actually made over
01:01$3 million off of this meme so far. And 24-7 clip farming factories. YouTube just announced it's going
01:08after re-uploaders or people who grow an audience clipping other people's content and putting it into
01:15their own feed. The name may have changed to meta, but stick around to see how the scoreboard is still
01:20running your feed today. To understand how we ended up here, you have to look back at January
01:25of 2018. This company and that guy are playing an unprecedented role in our lives. Mark Zuckerberg
01:31announced Facebook was overhauling the news feed to focus on meaningful social interactions or MSI.
01:37Which we'll skip past for now. That's a separate session. On paper, it sounded healthy. Show more
01:43posts from family, less from viral noise. But for creators, it was an instant execution. Overnight,
01:49organic reach plummeted. Meanwhile, internal research showed that high arousal content,
01:55specifically anger and outrage, was the ultimate point scorer, getting re-shared at insane rates.
02:01And over time, outrage became the new goldmine for watch time and ad revenue.
02:06My own mother is suing me again. My mother is Nicole Kidman. And she is suing me again. Because,
02:11as you know, I grew up under the floorboards and later found out that she was actually able to put
02:16spells on people. Anyway. When whistleblower Frances Haugen leaked the Facebook papers in 2021,
02:21the leak central to the social reckoning, she exposed the exact math creators had been guessing
02:26at for years. Once those files leaked, and again once the movie released, everyone was able to see
02:32the invisible scoreboard. A like? That's one point. An angry emoji? That's five. A comment? That starts at
02:3915 points, with dynamic multipliers driving long back-and-forth threads even higher.
02:44Now, think about how you use social media. Nobody types a 200-word paragraph in the comments just to
02:50say nice picture. People type long essays when they're mad, when they want to argue, or when they
02:55think someone's wrong. And every time someone replies to that comment, another massive bump on that
03:01scoreboard. With 2025's news cycles dominated by social unrest, debates about the regulation of online
03:08content, our experts noticed that the use of rage bait this year has evolved to signal a deeper shift
03:13in how we talk about attention. And creators didn't need an official memo from Mark Zuckerberg.
03:19They looked at their own analytic dashboards and reverse-engineered the game.
03:29Fast forward to today, and you can see what happens when an entire generation of creators grows up
03:35claim by those rules. Look at the Mighty Mike Plays controversy from September. A father claimed his
03:40nine-year-old gamer son accidentally ran up a staggering $118,000 YouTube ad bill.
03:46Was all a complete scam.
03:47The dad then claimed he was given 30 days to pay it back, and launched an AI merch store selling
03:53expensive t-shirts.
03:54Some of the shirts cost nearly $100 for a piece of fabric that says 118k, 6-7, or I'm definitely
04:01cooked.
04:01It sounded like every parent's worst nightmare, until internet sleuths and commentary channels
04:06questioned whether the unverified $118,000 bill was actually a staged promotion. And while critics
04:12debated whether the massive credit card debt was real or fabricated, the viral drama accomplished
04:16its real goal, flooding the comment section, gaming the algorithm, and generating hundreds
04:21of thousands of views, showing that in today's creator landscape, getting called a liar is just a
04:27marketing strategy. Here's my craziest conspiracy theory. I think that this isn't even a real kid.
04:32Mike and Dave might be the same person.
04:33And if human creators faking scandals wasn't enough, the algorithm just unlocked its final form,
04:39synthetic creators.
04:40This is going to become our new reality very, very soon.
04:43Hi there. My name is Adrienne. Well, not Adrienne, Adrienne, but TikTok's latest
04:48digital avatar.
04:50Meet John Phil. He's a silent blonde bob persona and a houndstooth suit who went massively viral on TikTok
04:56and Instagram for doing shadowboxing clips across Paris. His rapid virality exploded as people
05:02discovered those AI avatars, built using tools like Higgsville to seamlessly inject custom characters
05:08into existing background footage. This sparked a massive wave of user-generated spinoffs and edits,
05:14placing John Phil into endless new settings. Within days, the internet split into two camps.
05:19That debate exploded into hundreds of thousands of comments, triggering the exact same comment multiplier
05:24Facebook designed in 2018. And once the account peaked in popularity, the trap sprung.
05:30The creators behind the account linked to a Solana meme coin called John Phil on Pump.fun.
05:36And the token surged in market cap before collapsing by over 90%, leaving fans to realize they'd been
05:41manipulated into inflating a crypto scheme built around a bot.
05:45So from fake ad bills to synthetic influencers, the game remains exactly the same. Manufacture
05:51the drama, trigger the comment section, and collect the payout. So how does this stay running
05:5624 hours a day? Enter clip farming.
05:59My top clipper makes anywhere from 70 to 100k a month.
06:02On live streaming platforms like Kick, Twitch, and YouTube, streamers don't just play games
06:07anymore. They intentionally engineer stage outbursts, fake creator feuds, and unhinged takes.
06:17Because truly, like, why do I have to lose?
06:19Because armies of paid clippers slice those 10-second outbursts into vertical videos and flood
06:24TikTok reels and YouTube shorts.
06:27Tomorrow I need my cash, bro.
06:28What happens if I don't give you your cash?
06:31You never sleep.
06:32Why? Every clip ignites a brand new comment war, feeding the exact same engagement engine
06:37Facebook unlocked almost a decade ago. It's now an automated factory, where outrage is
06:42the raw material, and your attention is the product. So the social reckoning gives us a
06:47dramatic story about whistleblowers, lawyers, and courtroom battles. It makes it look like
06:52the fight had a beginning, middle, and end.
06:54Enough!
06:55But outside the movie theater, the system they built is still dictating what you see every
07:00time you unlock your phone. Highly political feuds. Manufactured drama.
07:04Get out of the car and fight me. No, you want to start problems at the drive-thru.
07:09Fake $118,000 debts. AI bots running crypto schemes. Showing meta changed its name, but the MSI
07:16engine never stopped running.
07:18It's me. I am the roller skater who fell off the stage during Usher's halftime show.
07:22She was just lying. You could see almost every single one of her videos gets millions of views,
07:26and she's just making up fake stories and lying.
07:29And on today's internet, the only way to win a rigged game is to stop giving it points.
07:34So share this video with someone who needs to break the loop,
07:36and hit that subscribe button to keep up with what's trending.

Recommended