Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 4 weeks ago
In this episode of The Postmortem, anchor Pooja Shali examines two high-profile crime investigations from Uttar Pradesh.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:03Hello and welcome you're watching the post-mortem and I'm Pooja Shali. A businessman
00:09falls to his death from the fourth floor of an apartment in Lucknow. Minutes later
00:14people rush to the scene. He's taken to hospital but he does not survive. And then
00:20come the allegations. His mother claims her son was being blackmailed, threatened
00:25and physically assaulted. The mother is accusing the girlfriend of driving him into a dangerous
00:31situation and alleges that his death was not an accident. October 9th, 2026. Hazrat Ganj, Lucknow.
00:40At Awad Green Apartments, a businessman falls from the fourth floor of an apartment.
00:44He's rushed to a hospital but eventually doctors declare him dead. His name was Shiva Sharma. 28 year
00:52old millionaire businessman from Lucknow. Now this apartment belongs to one Shraddha
00:59Dube, a social media influencer who according to Shiva Sharma's family had been in a live-in
01:05relationship with Shiva for around four months. But soon what appears to be a death following
01:12a fall on the surface becomes a murder case. This is the footage at the center of the investigation.
01:19The man falling from the building. A passerby appears to stop in shock. People soon rush toward
01:26him. And the injured businessman is rushed to the nearest hospital. The footage has captured
01:32the fall and the immediate reaction on the ground. But it does not by itself establish how did the fall
01:39happen? What happened inside the apartment for this individual to fall? This is where the complaint
01:47filed by Shiva Sharma's mother, Ranjana Sharma, becomes central to the case. On 10th of October, the mother
01:55approaches the Hazrat Ganj police station in Lucknow, alleging that it was simply not an accident. Her son had been
02:14facing harassment and blackmail for approximately four months, the same timeline since he was in a live-in
02:23relationship with the woman. The mother is alleging that Shraddha threatened to implicate him in false cases,
02:30put pressure on him to live with her, and then would physically assault him.
02:35Shraddha Dubey, past four months, I was frustrated. I was tortured. I was hurt. I was hurt. I was
02:44hurt. I was hurt. I was hurt. I was hurt. I was hurt. I was hurt. I was hurt.
03:04The mother is claiming that her son was fearful that he could be sent to jail and sent back to
03:12prison
03:13over a previous criminal case. These allegations now become a part of the investigation but are yet
03:20to be established in court. But Ranjana Sharma's account of the hospital visit is raising further
03:25questions. The mother alleges that when the family reached King George Medical University,
03:32they were shown Shiva Sharma's body from a distance before the people accompanying him left. Her own son's
03:41body, mortal remains, were shown from a distance. So according to her complaint, when she was able to
03:48eventually get to the mortal remains, Shiva had multiple injuries. And some of those injuries
03:54resembling cigarette burns, makeup on his body and on his face. And the family said that he was
04:04wearing only an underwear.
04:06There was a lot of blood from my son,
04:12and there was a lot of blood.
04:15The blood was broken up with a cigarette.
04:19The ribs were broken up with a lot of rubber.
04:24I was like,
04:24I was like,
04:25I was like,
04:25I'm like,
04:26I'm like,
04:31I was like,
04:33I'm like,
04:35I'm like,
04:35I'm like,
04:47These claims now make the post-mortem findings and forensic evidence particularly significant.
04:53Police are reportedly examining the material that was recovered from this influencer's
04:58apartment. It has been sent for forensic analysis. But what those examinations establish remains
05:03to be seen. Meanwhile, investigators are looking beyond the circumstances of the fall, or at
05:10least what appears on surface. Strathar Durbe had built a social media following, a big one,
05:17through her modelling and influencer work. Reports put her Instagram following at about
05:221.41 lakh followers. These videos on your screen, what does it show to the public? A side of the
05:30woman now wanted in connection with Shiva's death. But a social media image often tells
05:37us little about what happens behind closed doors when there is no eyewitness. And that
05:43is why investigators are examining communications, financial records, accounts of people who knew
05:49the couple, together and separately. Shiva Sharma's mother is still alleging that Shraddha used threats
05:55of legal action against him. And claims of influential connections to intimidate the son.
06:03She also handed over some of the conversations reportedly exchanged between the two.
06:08So investigators are expected to examine these communications alongside called records and
06:12financial transactions. Reports have suggested that more than 50 lakh rupees exchanged hands between
06:19Shiva and Shraddha over the past three months. Are the nature of those transactions, whether it had
06:25any connection to the death not yet established, given the information available? There is one more
06:31detail in Shiva Sharma's background. He had previously been accused in a firing incident at the
06:37Tinkle Pink Club in Gomati Nagar. After a reward was reportedly announced on him, the special task
06:44force had taken him in custody and arresting him in Bihar in Patna. Later though, he was released on
06:51pay. His mother is alleging that Shraddha exploited this background and his fear of being pushed into the
06:58prison again. Whether the evidence supports that claim is one of the questions that police will have to
07:03answer. But the investigation has brought attention to an incident from August 20, 25. On 12th August
07:10that year, Shiva's mother filed a complaint against history Sheetar Rishav Rai and his associates.
07:16According to the complaint, an altercation had taken place at a cafe in Kisan Bazaar the previous night.
07:21Rai and his associates were accused of abusing Shiva Sharma and demanding one lakh rupees within two days,
07:27alleging consequences if he fails to pay.
07:31Police reportedly obtained an audio recording connected to the alleged threat.
07:36Reports have now highlighted that there was an alleged past association between Shraddha and this Rai,
07:44along with claims involving call records and financial deals.
07:48Some reports further alleging that threats were made against Shiva Sharma while Rai was in prison.
07:54But there's a crucial distinction I want to point out here. What happened?
07:59The earlier complaint does not prove that Rai was involved in Shiva's death. Nor does an alleged association
08:06establish a criminal conspiracy. So the investigators must determine whether the earlier threat of the
08:11financial dealings and the events of 9th October are connected. As the investigation progressed,
08:18the accused became difficult to trace. Lucknow police announced a reward of 25,000 rupees each for
08:24three wanted accused. Shraddha Dubey, her sister Rashmi Dubey, Tanveer Ali, also known as Dhanash.
08:31Six police teams reportedly deployed to locate them. Searches conducted at suspected hideouts.
08:36Then comes a development from Bahrain. On 14th October, Shraddha's SUV was reportedly found at Shukla parking,
08:44close to the India-Nepal border. The vehicle had allegedly been parked there since 10th of October.
08:51According to information from the parking facility, the person who left it had said she was going to
08:57Nepal. Nobody returned to collect the car. The discovery raised suspicions that Shraddha Dubey
09:04may have attempted to flee across the border, knowing her name is all over and going viral.
09:10Other reports place Shraddha and an acquaintance, Aamir, near the Nepal border. Police teams reportedly
09:15have been sent toward national capital Delhi and nearby areas. But the vehicle discovery does not by itself
09:22again prove that Shraddha crossed into Nepal. Investigators will have to establish who took the
09:28SUV there, who left it behind, where the occupants went afterwards. All of this search is now a crucial
09:35part of the case. Finding the accused could help investigators test the allegations against them,
09:42reconstruct the events surrounding Shiva's death. But there are more and more details coming in
09:47which are under scrutiny. According to reports, a CCTV footage emerged. It shows a white luxury vehicle,
09:56an Audi, arriving at Awad Green apartments approximately 15 minutes after the incident of Shiva
10:04Sharma's fall. Why is this important? The driver reportedly turned around beneath the building and left.
10:12The vehicle was set to display a parking pass on the vehicle and which was about secretariat written on it.
10:23Police are examining therefore about the car's identity, the reason for its visit and if the
10:29secretariat parking pass has anything to do with one specific apartment.
10:38Who was inside that vehicle? Why did that vehicle bearing a secretariat parking pass arrive right after
10:47Shiva Sharma's fall? Was the visit connected to the case at all? At present available information does not
10:55answer these questions. But this vehicle is a line of inquiry. Shiva Sharma's death brings together several
11:02strands, allegations of blackmail assault and torture, a disputed financial relationship, possibly an
11:09earlier extortion complaint and a manhunt still on for three wanted accused. But the bigger issue will
11:18always be about the circumstances that led to the fall. Was that fall accidental or a murder? What happened
11:26inside that fourth floor apartment on 9th October? Do the post-mortem findings support families
11:32allegations? What will be recovered from the chats, call records and financial transactions? Can
11:38investigators establish where the accused went after leaving Lucknow City? CCTV footage shows the fall.
11:46Families complained have the allegations and serious ones. The reported recovery of the SUV,
11:53a secretariat vehicle arriving into the apartment. On its own, these developments do not answer a direct
12:00question, but it can form a thread together. What happened to Shiva Sharma on the fourth floor? The answer
12:08must eventually come from the evidence. Until then, as the investigation continues, all evidence is being
12:14examined and put together. Investigators have a big test ahead of them because Shiva Sharma's final moments
12:22remain to be established. It must for justice for the family.
12:32A husband murdered, his body dismembered and hidden inside a cement-filled blue drum. A case that has become
12:41viral and well-known as the blue drum case. In Mehrat, Saurabh Rajput was killed by his wife Muskan Rastogi
12:49and her
12:50lover Sahil Shukla. Now, the court has pronounced the judgment. And the quantum of punishment is
12:56sentenced to death. How did the murder unfold? How did the crime come to light? This is the story of
13:04the
13:04Mehrat Blue Drum case.
13:08To understand this case, I take you back to 2016. Saurabh Rajput and Muskan Rastogi get married after a
13:16relationship that reportedly faced opposition from their families. But the couple eventually went on to
13:22get married, settling in Mehrat. They even had a daughter. They began to start their life together as
13:29a family. But their relationship soon would become central to a murder investigation. According to
13:36reports, Muskan had got into a relationship with one Sahil Shukla, a man she knew from her
13:42neighborhood. The prosecution would later allege that Muskan and Sahil conspired to eliminate Saurabh.
13:48At the center of this case then becomes a love triangle. But the investigators would have to
13:54establish how that relationship allegedly led to the murder. The events that followed, however,
13:59would shock the country for years. February 2025. Saurabh, a former merchant navy professional,
14:08returns to Mehrat from London, where he had been working earlier. He reaches home around 24th or 25th
14:15February. The following day, Muskan celebrates her birthday with the husband. And for the family,
14:24Saurabh's return marks an opportunity to spend time together. But according to the prosecution,
14:29the days following his return would become the final chapter of his life. Investigators allege that
14:34Muskan and Sahil, the lover, decided to kill him. The prosecution's account described a plan involving
14:41medication so that Saurabh turns unconscious right before the attack. The alleged motive was connected
14:50to Muskan's relationship with this man Sahil and their desire to remove the husband, Saurabh,
14:56from the picture. That they thought a divorce would be more difficult than the murder.
15:04These allegations would later form part of the case presented in court.
15:08This date is central to the investigation. 3rd March 2025. According to the prosecution,
15:15Saurabh was killed at his own residence in Mehrat somewhere between March 3rd and 4th.
15:22Investigators allege that the medication was mixed into his food and then that left him unconscious.
15:30Sahil, the lover, was then allegedly called, invited to the house.
15:34The prosecution's case was that Saurabh was stabbed to death multiple times and brutally.
15:41That was not it. How do you hide the body? The body was then dismembered into parts.
15:49There was no eyewitness to report the killing. Instead, investigators would rely on physical evidence,
15:56forensic findings, witness statements, other circumstances to establish what happened.
16:00The crime did not end with killing. Where do you conceal the body parts? That was now the big test.
16:09And that is where the blue drum enters into the story. According to the investigation,
16:15the accused placed the dismembered remains of the body of Saurabh inside a blue plastic drum.
16:23And then how do you cover it? Cement and sand were used to conceal the remains. Investigators
16:30alleged that the purpose was to hide the body, prevent the crime from being discovered and soon
16:34the people will forget. The drum, in fact, shockingly was kept inside the house. An ordinary household
16:42object nobody would be suspicious about had become the centerpiece of an alleged attempt to conceal a
16:49murder. But there was one weakness that had happened. The remains would eventually begin to produce a
16:56foul smell. Despite the weight, despite the cement placed inside it, could not keep the crime hidden
17:03indefinitely. 4th March 2025, according to the police investigation, Muskan and Sahil, after committing the
17:11crime left for Himachal Pradesh, leaving the daughter that she had had with Saurabh, with her maternal family
17:19before she embarks on this journey. Investigators examined their movements that after leaving Merit and
17:26including their stay at locations in Himachal Pradesh. This journey becomes an important part of the
17:31investigation because police were trying to reconstruct what the accused did after Saurabh's death. The blue
17:38drum remains inside the house. The alleged crime, so to say, according to this couple now, has been
17:45conceived. Nobody is suspicious. In mid-March, the case takes a dramatic turn. 17th March 2025. The remains
17:55of Saurabh Rajput are discovered and how?
18:00Now, accounts of the moment that led to the discovery of the blue drum are differing in nature. Reports
18:06describe a foul smell or the difficulty of moving the heavy drum that eventually led to the drum being
18:12opened and remains being found. And that discovery triggered a murder investigation. Police came in
18:19to examine the house, recover the evidence and began reconstructing the events that led to Saurabh's death.
18:25The condition of the remains makes forensic examination particularly important. Investigators are
18:30looking at the movement of Muskan and Sahil, their relationship with Saurabh, the journey to
18:34Himachal Pradesh and even videos surfacing from the Hill State after the murder was committed and the
18:41couple, Muskan and Sahil, are seen partying in Himachal Pradesh. The question was no longer about
18:48where is Saurabh. Police will have to now establish one who specifically killed him and how the crime was
18:55carried out. That is when the investigation leads to two people at the centre.
19:0118th March 2025. Muskan Rastogi and Sahil Shukla are arrested by the police the moment they return
19:08from Himachal Pradesh. Both become the principal accused in the murder investigation. The case
19:14attracts nationwide attention because of the brutality that was committed for this crime, the attempt to
19:20conceal the remains inside a cement-filled drum and the word blue drum murder turned viral. But
19:28investigators had to move beyond the circumstances of suspicion that had shocked the public. They had
19:33to come down to evidence and chain trail. Police examined forensic material, call detailed records,
19:40CCTV footage, statements from witnesses connected to the investigation. Now investigation looks at the
19:45purchase of the items including the drum, the cement and the knife. Statements are recorded now from
19:52the family members, a cab driver, local shopkeepers and the hotel staff. Each piece of evidence is
20:00intended to help reconstruct the events before and after the murder. On 19th March, the two accused are
20:06sent to judicial custody. The next major step comes in May. 12th May 2025. Police eventually file a
20:14charge sheet running to nearly 1000 pages. The accused are facing charges of murder and destruction of
20:20evidence. The charge sheet brings together the material collected during the probe, including
20:25forensic reports, technical records and witness statements. Police still have no eyewitness to the
20:32killing. The prosecution must therefore rely on a combined strength of the evidence that they have to
20:38establish the case and responsibility on the accused. The trial begins. Examining the circumstances
20:43surrounding Saurabh's death and the alleged prep for the crime, the concealment of the remains, the
20:49movement of the accused afterward. The defence has the opportunity now to challenge the prosecution's
20:55evidence in the court. But the court will have to determine whether the allegations have been proven
20:59beyond reasonable doubt. By November 2025, the case takes a turn. Muskan gives birth to a girl in custody in
21:12jail. Saurabh's family subsequently immediately seeking a DNA test concerning the child's paternity.
21:21The development draws further public attention. But the question still before the court is about the
21:26murder, the charges rising from it. The trial continues through 2026. Over approximately 13 months, the
21:33proceedings involve 126 hearings, the examination of 22 prosecution witnesses. By September, the case has
21:40reached a decisive stage. 17th September 2026, the final arguments conclude. The prosecution seeks the
21:48death penalty for both accused arguing that the gravity of the crime warrants maximum punishment.
21:5430th September, the mayor district court finds Muskan Rastogi and Sahil Chukla guilty of murdering
22:01Saurabh Rajput and destroying evidence. After more than a year of proceedings, the court has delivered the
22:08verdict on their guilt. But one more major stage. The court has to announce the quantum of the punishment.
22:16And that was sentenced for 14th October. For Saurabh's family, this conviction marks a significant moment
22:23in a case that began with the discovery of his remains inside the blue drum in the house.
22:3014th October 2026, the day is here. Muskan Rastogi and Sahil Chukla appear before the court through
22:37video conferencing from the jail. Saurabh's mother, Renu Devi, and his brother are present in the court.
22:44District and Sessions judge Arvind Kumar Mishra pronounces the sentence. Both convicts
22:50sentenced to death. The court also imposing fines of 50,000 rupees each for murder and 20,000
22:57rupees each for destruction of evidence.
22:58Ding setup, this� skull has shown over 200,000 rupees each she and her brothertak Pani Chukla guilty of
23:10having to forget. There is a previous Friends q and her husband. Plus they won't be worthy.
23:45During the proceedings, the judge refers to the Mahabharata, observing that punishing
23:51the guilty in accordance with the gravity of the crime is also a form of dharm.
23:56The reference draws attention to the court's reasoning on punishment.
23:59The prosecution had sought maximum penalty, arguing that the nature of the crime justified it.
24:05The court has now announced it, imposing the death sentence.
24:10But there's one legal step.
24:12Under Indian law, a death sentence imposed by a trial court must be confirmed by the
24:18high court before it can be carried out.
24:19So the Allahabad High Court will therefore have to consider the sentences in accordance
24:24with the law.
24:25The trial court's decision marks a major turning point even then.
24:30But it's not the end of the legal process.
24:58A marriage with expectations, hope and future started in 2016, led to a murder in March 2025.
25:08A dismembered body concealed in a cement-filled blue drum.
25:13And a trial that culminated in a death sentence for Muskaan Rastogi and Sahil Shukla.
25:19The case shocked the country because of the brutality of the crime, the attempt to conceal it.
25:24But you have to appreciate the work done by the investigators in this case.
25:29How they piece together the evidence.
25:31How ensuring that when they approach the court, they have the prosecution's case, which is solid in nature.
25:38With witnesses, with evidence.
25:40And on 14th October 2026, that death sentence showed what the court heard.
25:47The legal process continues.
25:49A confirmation is awaited by the Allahabad High Court.
25:52But it is definitely a precedent that has been set.
25:57That is all from me and my team in the post-mortem for this week.
26:01Keep watching India Today.

Recommended