Judge Judy Doesn't Buy the Bouncy Ball Excuse

A bathroom renovation dispute takes a ridiculous turn when a bouncy ball enters the picture! On Judge Judy, two former friends are already at odds over unfinished bathroom work when accusations of damage to a car bring another argument into the courtroom.

The defendant insists she never threw a rock at the other woman's car. Her defense? It was a bouncy ball! But Judge Judy isn't interested in debating the difference. She wants to know why the defendant threw anything in the first place. When the woman admits she acted out of anger and frustration, Judy makes it clear that a softer object doesn't excuse bad behavior.

Watch this classic Judge Judy clip as Judy Sheindlin gets to the bottom of one very questionable defense.