- 13 minutes ago
Some biopics blur the line between drama and defamation. Join us as we count down the most controversial scenes from biographical films that sparked real-life backlash, lawsuits, and public condemnations from the very people they portrayed!
Category
🎥
Short filmTranscript
00:00Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we're looking at 10 contentious scenes from biopics that stirred a ton of controversy
00:06and led to open criticism from the real-life subjects.
00:09It's not a joke, pal.
00:12People die in fairy tales all the time.
00:15Number 10, Sex for a Scoop, Richard Jewell.
00:18You are good. You're very good.
00:21Yeah.
00:22This kind of puts a clock on things, though. You want to get a room or just go to my
00:25car?
00:25Clint Eastwood's docudrama, Richard Jewell, details the story of the Centennial Olympic Park bombing
00:30and the security guard who was wrongly accused of orchestrating it.
00:33In one highly contentious scene, reporter Kathy Scruggs meets FBI agent Tom Shaw at a bar to identify the prime
00:39suspect in the bombing.
00:40During the encounter, Scruggs offers to trade sexual favors for the classified lead,
00:44asking whether they should get a hotel room or use her car before walking away with Richard Jewell's name.
00:49I mean, you always look at the guy who found the bomb just like you always look at the guy
00:52who found the body,
00:53but this guy, he's got a bad past.
00:56Fits the profile of the hero bomber to a tee.
01:00The sequence provoked swift condemnation from Scruggs' former employer and colleagues.
01:04The Atlanta Journal-Constitution hired an attorney and issued a formal demand to both Warner Brothers and Eastwood.
01:09They threatened a defamation lawsuit unless the studio released a prominent disclaimer acknowledging that the scene was fictionalized.
01:15AJC lawyers demanded the makers of the movie about the Olympic Park bombing add a disclaimer that parts of the
01:21story about the reporter Kathy Scruggs are not true,
01:24but the studio won't budge even as the movie premieres in Atlanta.
01:28Scruggs' former co-workers also condemned the depiction as a baseless smear against a deceased reporter who could not defend
01:34her reputation,
01:35stressing that the real Scruggs never engaged in such behavior.
01:39Warner Brothers defended the film's protected dramatization,
01:42though Olivia Wilde, who played Scruggs, later clarified that she did not believe that Scruggs traded sex for a story.
01:47There's a scene in the movie where she trades sex for the story tip, which is not true.
01:56It never happened.
01:58I just thought, wow, they really did that.
02:01Number nine, inventing Facebook out of spite.
02:03The social network.
02:04You're going to go through life thinking that girls don't like you because you're a nerd.
02:09And I want you to know from the bottom of my heart that that won't be true.
02:14It'll be because you're an asshole.
02:16The narrative engine of the social network ignites when Boston University undergrad Erica Albright breaks up with Mark Zuckerberg at
02:23a campus pub.
02:24Spurred by wounded pride, Zuckerberg retreats to his Kirkland house dorm, drinks some beer, writes blog posts mocking Albright's physical
02:30traits,
02:31and codes Facemash to rate female students.
02:33The truth is she has a nice face.
02:35I need to do something to take my mind off her.
02:37Easy enough, except I need an idea.
02:39Mark Zuckerberg has continuously challenged this narrative, stating that screenwriter Aaron Sorkin
02:43fabricated an entirely false personal motivation for the making of Facebook.
02:47Zuckerberg explained that he wanted to build a social network simply out of an intellectual passion for coding,
02:52rather than a desperate attempt to impress women or gain entry into Harvard's exclusive clubs.
02:56Furthermore, Zuckerberg pointed out that the timeline was historically inaccurate.
03:00He had already begun dating his future wife, Priscilla Chan, in 2003, months before Facebook went online.
03:05In fact, he noted that the only detail the filmmakers accurately replicated from his real life was his wardrobe of
03:10fleece zip-ups.
03:11Sorkin himself has freely admitted that he fabricated certain moments, treating the story as a drama rather than a documentary.
03:17You're not an asshole, Mark.
03:20You're just trying so hard to be.
03:24Number 8.
03:25The royalty dispute over lobster, straight out of Compton.
03:27I'm sorry to interrupt y'all lobster brunch.
03:30But what's up, E?
03:31Where the contract's at, man?
03:32You forgot about me?
03:33During a tense contract discussion inside Ruthless Records, manager Jerry Heller dines on a plate of lobster,
03:39while Ice Cube presses him about overdue accounting statements and unreceived royalty checks.
03:43When Cube demands rightful compensation for his work in the group, Heller casually brushes him off.
03:49At some point, you just gotta trust somebody.
03:51You know?
03:54You gotta trust somebody.
03:56Two months after the film's August 2015 release, the real Jerry Heller filed a $110 million defamation lawsuit
04:02in Los Angeles County Superior Court against NBCUniversal director F. Gary Gray and producers Ice Cube and Dr. Dre.
04:09Heller argued that the lobster scene fabricated a narrative that he was an untrustworthy business manager
04:14who deliberately embezzled earnings from young artists.
04:16Citing his 2006 autobiography, Heller stated that he never withheld contracts, never skimmed client royalties,
04:22and was instrumental in securing the group's landmark Priority Records distribution deal.
04:27While Heller died of a heart attack in September 2016 before the case was settled,
04:31his estate maintained the legal action until a federal judge dismissed the claims in 2018.
04:36They're saying things about me in that film that not only are not true,
04:41but they're very demeaning and degrading.
04:44Want to hear more about biopics and how they relate to real life?
04:47Then head over to our 24-7 live stream.
04:49Just scan the QR code on screen and learn about even more biopics that cause controversy.
04:53The FBI is looking at Richard Jewell as the bomber.
04:58Number 7.
04:59The biased split decision, The Hurricane.
05:02I've seen a lot of things in my time, but it's taken 35 minutes for these judges to tell us
05:07what this hometown crowd already knows.
05:11Joey Giordello is about to lose the crown to Reuben Hurricane Carter.
05:16Before examining Reuben Carter's wrongful murder conviction,
05:19this biopic dramatizes his December 1964 middleweight championship bout
05:23against Joey Giordello in Philadelphia.
05:26In the movie, Carter relentlessly batters Giordello across 15 rounds,
05:30knocking him across the ring and leaving him visibly bloodied.
05:33When the final bell rings, ringside officials award Giordello an unearned win,
05:37which is narratively framed as the outcome of corruption in a racially biased scoring system.
05:40Ladies and gentlemen, it's a unanimous decision.
05:55In February 2000, the real Joey Giordello filed a federal defamation lawsuit against Universal Pictures.
06:01Boxing records, contemporary fight reports, and surviving archival footage demonstrated that
06:05Giordello had systematically outpunched Carter over the second half of the fight
06:09and earned a legitimate win with the scorecards of 852, 942, and 933.
06:14Universal opted to settle the litigation out of court for an undisclosed monetary sum.
06:18As part of the formal settlement agreement, director Norman Jewison
06:20had to state on the DVD commentary that the bout was heavily fictionalized for drama
06:24and that Giordello had won by legitimate means.
06:27Well, all I can say is these Philly judges must have been watching a different fight
06:33because in the one we just saw, Hurricane Carter took the title.
06:37Number 6. The Fatal Incident, Patch Adams
06:54The emotional turning point of Patch Adams centers on the murder of medical student Karin Fisher,
06:59played by Monica Potter. After traveling to counsel an outpatient in his home, Karin is killed with a
07:03shotgun prompting Adams to stand at the edge of a cliff contemplating his own life before recommitting
07:08to his free medical clinic. The real Dr. Hunter Adams publicly condemned the storyline across
07:12several media interviews following the film's release. In reality, the victim was Adams' close
07:16male medical school friend and roommate, who was murdered in 1971 under similar circumstances.
07:32Adams criticized Universal Pictures and director Tom Shadyak for rewriting Olds as a fictionalized
07:37love interest, arguing that the studio altered the gender and nature of their relationship simply to
07:42engineer a conventional romantic tragedy and provide Williams with a dramatic crying scene. Adams also
07:46expressed frustration that both the actors and the studio made hundreds of millions of dollars on
07:50the movie, but nobody donated to his Gesundheit Institute, which he had spent decades developing.
07:55What did you think of Robin Williams' portrayal of your early life? I mean,
07:58was that a strange thing for you to witness? Do you think he did a good job?
08:05Well, the movie promised to build my free hospital and didn't give me a cent, so that part I didn't
08:12like.
08:12Number 5. Max Baer's Taunting, Cinderella Man
08:22To build maximum dramatic tension for James J. Braddock's heavyweight title fight, director Ron
08:27Howard portrayed Max Baer as a sneering and ruthless ring villain. The screenplay shows Baer openly
08:32boasting about killing two men in the ring and crudely propositioning Braddock's wife May,
08:37remarking that she is too pretty to be a widow. Following the film's 2005 release, Baer's son,
08:48actor Max Baer Jr. launched a public campaign against Universal Pictures, calling the portrayal
08:53a complete character assassination and referring to his fictional father as an ogre. Historical records
08:57show that while boxer Frankie Campbell did die following a 1930 bout with Baer, Baer was profoundly
09:03devastated by the tragedy and never boasted about it. He reportedly sobbed uncontrollably at Campbell's
09:08hospital bedside, suffered recurring nightmares about his death, and contributed thousands of
09:12dollars to his widow and children for years. The second death attributed to Baer in the movie,
09:17that of Ernie Schaaf, actually occurred months after their bout, following a separate match with
09:22boxer Primo Carnera. Regardless, the filmmakers were legally protected as deceased figures cannot be
09:27legally defamed under US law. That's not nice, Max. That's not nice. Come on. On second thought,
09:32maybe I can comfort you after he's gone. Hey! I said shut your goddamn mouth, you punk!
09:36Number four. Backstage hostility. All eyes on me. And fate?
09:44Casualty war. Casualty war. Tracing the formative years of Tupac Shakur, this 2017 biographical drama
09:51shows the young artist reading an emotional romantic poem directly to classmate Jada Pinkett. Later,
09:56the two engaged in an angry backstage confrontation over Shakur's escalating legal troubles and reckless
10:01behavior, culminating in a bitter parting of ways. So can't nobody tell you nothing, huh? Huh?
10:09Not about this.
10:13Okay.
10:14On June 16, 2017, the day of the film's theatrical release and Shakur's 46th birthday,
10:20Jada Pinkett Smith posted a series of public statements explicitly refuting the historical
10:24accuracy of both interactions. Pinkett Smith stated that Shakur had never recited that specific poem to
10:29her, noting that the text was actually published posthumously in his 1999 book, The Rose That Grew
10:34From Concrete. She further clarified that they had never had a backstage argument, as Pac explicitly
10:39asked her never to appear at one of his shows, and they did not part on hostile terms. Producer L
10:43.T.
10:44Hutton defended the sequence as narrative condensation, but Pinkett Smith called the manufactured
10:48conflict deeply hurtful to their shared and loving history.
10:50You got the tears in your eyes. The tears flow, and I'm your soul.
10:59Number 3. Coaching by Protection, The Blind Side
11:02When you look at me, son, if you grab them outside here like this or that horse collar thing you
11:07just
11:07did, you're gonna get flagged and I'm gonna be pissed. You hear me?
11:11During a high school football practice in the blind side, coaching staff struggled to teach
11:14offensive tackle Michael Orr basic blocking assignments. The impasse ends when Leigh-Anne
11:19Toohey, the Oscar-winning Sandra Bullock, steps onto the gridiron, grabs Orr by the jersey
11:23pads, and instructs him to treat the quarterback as family. With that, Orr immediately grasps
11:27the sports mechanics and begins dominating the opposing linemen.
11:30Tony, here's your quarterback, alright? You protect his blind side. When you look at
11:34him, you think of me. How you have my back. How you have his. Okay?
11:39Michael Orr addressed the sequence in his 2011 autobiography, I Beat the Odds, describing the
11:44depiction as an insult to his intelligence and career. Orr wrote that the film gave audiences
11:48and NFL personnel the impression that he had zero football instincts and required remedial
11:53instruction to grasp even the most basic plays. Having obsessively studied playbook schemes
11:57and offensive line mechanics since his early childhood, Orr argued that the screenplay erased
12:01years of athletic preparation solely to credit Toohey for his gridiron IQ. In subsequent interviews
12:06during his professional career, Orr maintained that this fictionalized characterization continually
12:10damaged his professional standing among team scouts, coaches, and fellow players.
12:14When you go into a locker room and your teammates don't think you can learn a playbook,
12:19you know, that weighs heavy on someone.
12:222. Soul Food Instruction, Green Book
12:25Kentucky fight chicken. In Kentucky! When's that ever gonna happen?
12:30A pivotal comedic beat in Peter Ferrelli's Green Book occurs inside a car traveling through
12:34Kentucky, where working-class driver Tony Lip buys some KFC and insists that his employer,
12:39a virtuoso pianist named Don Shirley, try a drumstick. Shirley initially recoils, claiming that he has
12:44never consumed fried chicken in his life and is repelled by the prospect of eating without
12:48silverware. However, he relents under Lip's continuous badgering and ends up loving the
12:52chicken. The scene triggered swift condemnation from Dr. Shirley's surviving family members
13:04following the movie's premiere in 2018. His brother and nephew released statements calling the scene an
13:08offensive and tone-deaf racial trope that fabricated cultural alienation. In an open letter sent to the
13:14media, Maurice Shirley wrote,
13:15No one ever had to teach my brother how to eat fried chicken, nor would he have allowed lessons
13:20of such by a white man. Following the family's public backlash, lead actor Mahershala Ali reached out
13:25privately to apologize for any unintended disrespect that his performance caused the family.
13:29Have a breast. Delicious. Take it. Hey. What do we do about the bones?
13:40We do this.
13:43Before we continue, be sure to check out WatchMojo's 24-hour livestream. All of your favorite videos in one place,
13:5024-7. Always on, always live.
13:551. The Bedroom Confrontation – The Apprentice
14:06Directed by Ali Abasi, The Apprentice dramatizes Donald Trump's rise in New York real estate
14:11throughout the 70s and 80s. The film's most contentious scene depicts Sebastian Stan's Trump
14:15in a violent domestic confrontation with his first wife, Ivana. After Ivana insults his increased
14:19weight and baldness following a scalp reduction surgery, Trump shoves her to the ground and
14:23proceeds to sexually assault her. The scene provoked immediate legal backlash from the Trump campaign.
14:40Trump's attorneys issued a formal cease and desist letter to the filmmakers and threatened federal
14:44defamation lawsuits, while Trump himself publicly condemned the movie on social media as a cheap,
14:49defamatory, and politically disgusting hatchet job. Screenwriter Gabriel Sherman based the sequence
14:54on Ivana Trump's sworn deposition, which she gave during divorce proceedings in 1990, in which she
14:59stated that Trump had forcibly attacked her in their penthouse. However, Ivana retracted the statement
15:03in 1993, affirming that she did not want her deposition words interpreted in a literal or criminal
15:08sense. She also claimed during Trump's first presidential campaign that the rumors were totally
15:12without merit. As it is, the sequence remains a focal point of legal conflict and critical
15:17commentary. You don't want to see things like this. You don't want to read things like abuse and
15:23being heartbroken. You don't want to watch them. I mean, it's difficult to watch it. It's difficult
15:27to read it. It's difficult to shoot it. You want to approach it with respect and
15:33depth in it because women like her are survivors and you have to honor that. What do you make of
15:38these
15:38scenes? Let us know in the comments below.