- 5 hours ago
A failed river crossing left 65 American soldiers stranded in a flooded Dutch field—then Canadian command changed the way the 104th Infantry Division fought. In this World War II military history story, the Timberwolves face dikes, canals and German defenses in Holland, where speed and aggression alone could not break a stubborn waterline.
After a costly first attempt, the Americans pause while artillery, engineers and infantry prepare a coordinated assault. The next crossing takes 50 minutes, revealing a hard-earned lesson about patience, firepower and planning—and the limits of any battlefield method. Discover the Canadian Army’s influence on American troops during the campaign to open Antwerp, alongside the courage of the men who fought at the Mark River. This narrated WWII history documentary is for listeners seeking detailed accounts of Allied operations, Canadian military history, American infantry and the Battle of Holland. Explore military history and WW2 stories through immersive historical narration, whether listening closely or using it as background listening.
After a costly first attempt, the Americans pause while artillery, engineers and infantry prepare a coordinated assault. The next crossing takes 50 minutes, revealing a hard-earned lesson about patience, firepower and planning—and the limits of any battlefield method. Discover the Canadian Army’s influence on American troops during the campaign to open Antwerp, alongside the courage of the men who fought at the Mark River. This narrated WWII history documentary is for listeners seeking detailed accounts of Allied operations, Canadian military history, American infantry and the Battle of Holland. Explore military history and WW2 stories through immersive historical narration, whether listening closely or using it as background listening.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00The 31st of October, 1944.
00:03A sugar beet field on the north bank of a Dutch river called the Mark,
00:07a few hundred yards outside a village called Standarbuten.
00:12Sixty-five American soldiers are lying in that field,
00:15and the water is coming up around them.
00:18They had crossed at first light in wooden assault boats,
00:22one rifle battalion of the 415th Infantry,
00:25because the bridge they had been sent to take was already in the river.
00:29The Germans dropped it as soon as the first American patrol came into sight of the approach road.
00:35Getting over the water turned out to be the easy part.
00:38Staying there did not.
00:40By afternoon there were German tanks working the dike road behind them,
00:44and an 88 firing straight down the length of the polder.
00:47And a polder is a field that sits lower than the river beside it,
00:51which means there is nowhere on it that a man can stand up.
00:55Before dark the order came back over the river.
00:58Withdraw.
00:59Most of the battalion got out.
01:01Sixty-five men did not.
01:03Two lieutenants stayed on the German side with them,
01:06Ernest Fox and George Squires,
01:09both of whom had been civilians 18 months earlier and in combat for six days.
01:15Now hold the picture, because I want you to count what those men had.
01:37And here is the detail that never makes it into the official histories, the one you should keep.
01:42They ate the field.
01:45Turnips and sugar beets pulled out of the mud by hand and eaten raw, in the rain, in November,
01:53while armor moved on the road 200 yards away, and the 88 kept working.
01:59Three days later, they were still alive, and still holding, and something came across that river and got them off
02:07it.
02:07It was not an American plan.
02:10Those men belonged to the 104th Infantry Division, United States Army, the Timberwolves.
02:17And on that last day of October 1944, they were not taking orders from an American Corps, or an American
02:24Army, or an American General.
02:26Their orders came down to them through 1st Canadian Army.
02:30No American division had ever taken its orders from a Canadian General, not once, in the entire history of either
02:37country, before or since.
02:40So there is a question inside this story, and it is not which army was braver.
02:45It is narrower than that, and a good deal more uncomfortable.
02:49These were fine American troops, hard trained, led by one of the most aggressive division commanders the United States produced.
02:56They went at that river the way they had been taught to go at things, and it cost them a
03:01failed crossing,
03:02a dead battalion's worth of casualties across the week, and 65 men in a beet field.
03:08Two days later, they crossed the same river against the same Germans, a different way.
03:13I'll give you the price of the second crossing now, because you will want it later.
03:18Fifty minutes.
03:20If what the Canadians did here matters to you, a subscribe helps these stories reach more people.
03:26Let me show you why an American division was there at all, under that particular flag, in that particular week.
03:34In September, the Allies had captured Antwerp, the great port of northern Europe, docks intact, cranes working.
03:42And they could not land a single ton through it, because the Germans still held both banks of the 60
03:49-mile sea approach.
03:50Flooded islands, dikes, coastal batteries.
03:55Every shell fired at Germany was still being trucked up from the Normandy beaches.
04:00In the middle of October, Montgomery issued the directive that put opening Antwerp above everything else on the Northern Front,
04:07and the job of doing it belonged to 1st Canadian Army.
04:12The man running that army was not Harry Crerar. Crerar had been taken out of the line ill at the
04:18end of September.
04:19The officer who took over was Lieutenant General Guy Simons, 41 years old, a gunner by trade, the youngest man
04:27commanding an army on the Allied side, and, by the testimony of nearly everyone who worked for him, the coldest.
04:35Simons had a habit his subordinates dreaded. He would hear a plan out to the end without a word, and
04:41then ask a single question that took the floor out from underneath it.
04:45In the third week of October, Simons was handed an American infantry division that had never fired a shot in
04:51anger.
04:52Consider what he could have done with it. There was a safe answer, and nobody would have faulted him for
04:57it.
04:58Put the new division on a quiet canal somewhere, let it bled itself on patrols for a fortnight, and keep
05:04the real fighting with the men who had been at it since Normandy.
05:07He did the opposite. He put them straight into the attack.
05:11On the 23rd of October, in wet fields near the Belgian village of Wüstwesel, the 413th Infantry moved up and
05:18relieved the British 49th Division.
05:20The first American regiment ever to take over a position from an Allied unit on the Western Front.
05:26On their left, in the same corps, were the Canadians of the 4th Armoured Division, coming north out of Antwerp
05:32with their tanks already scorched.
05:35On their right, the Poles.
05:37The corps headquarters above them was British, the army headquarters above that was Canadian, and its commander had just decided
05:45that the Americans would attack in two days' time.
05:48They were not worried. They had Major General Terry Allen, who had run the 1st Division in Tunisia and Sicily,
05:54and who had turned the Timberwolves into the best night-fighting outfit in the American army.
05:59Thirty hours a week of night training, three times with the regulations required, because Allen had learned the hard way
06:05that darkness is cheaper than daylight.
06:08What no amount of training had prepared them for was the ground. Not hills, not hedgerow, water. A landscape built
06:16by farmers over six centuries, where the fields lie below the rivers, the roads run along the tops of dikes,
06:23with nothing on either side of them, and every drainage ditch is an anti-tank obstacle the enemy never had
06:29to dig.
06:30Four days before that beat field, the Timberwolves came up against one of those ditches, and it stopped a whole
06:36division.
06:37What got them across it was one American captain, one radio, and a piece of the Allied way of war
06:43that no American division had ever been handed before.
06:46The 25th of October, 1944. A start line in the wet fields north of Wüstfesel, twenty minutes before first light.
06:55The Timberwolves went forward that morning the way a confident division goes forward the first time. Fast, on a broad
07:02front, three regiments abreast, with orders to keep going until something stopped them.
07:08Something stopped them almost immediately, and it was not what they expected. It was not a line.
07:15The German regiments in front of them were not holding a line in any sense an American officer would have
07:21recognized from a manual.
07:23They were holding road junctions, farmhouses, and dike crossings, in groups of twenty and thirty, with a machine gun, and
07:31sometimes a self-propelled gun.
07:33And when the pressure came on, they did not break, and they did not stand.
07:38They killed whatever they could in the first ten minutes, and then walked back six hundred yards to the next
07:44ditch, and did it again.
07:46Behind them, every culvert was blown, and every verge was mined, because the water table made mine laying easy and
07:53mine lifting slow.
07:55An American rifle company can take a farmhouse. It costs riflemen.
08:00And when it turns out there are eleven more farmhouses, each one costing riflemen,
08:05a division learns something about arithmetic before it learns anything about tactics.
08:10By the twenty-seventh the Americans had Zundert. The town came out into the street with flags that had been
08:16hidden in roof cavities for four and a half years,
08:19and the men of the four hundred and thirteen walked through it, filthy and astonished, being kissed by strangers.
08:27It was the first Dutch town liberated by American infantry in that campaign, and the Dutch have not forgotten it.
08:34There is a memorial there now, with a timber wolf on it.
08:37It had taken them two days to go a few miles. In front of them lay twelve more.
08:43Now let me take you sixty miles west, to the man whose name was on the orders.
08:48Because on exactly these days, Guy Simons was doing something that tells you more about First Canadian Army than any
08:55tactical pamphlet could.
08:57Out at the mouth of the Scheldt sits the island of Wacheren, shaped like a saucer, with the sea held
09:03off by a dike at West Capella and German coastal batteries dug in on the rim.
09:08Simons had looked at that saucer and concluded that infantry could not take it at an acceptable price.
09:14So he asked for the dike to be broken.
09:17Bomber command opened the sea wall at West Capella at the beginning of October.
09:21The North Sea came through the gap, and the inside of the island went underwater, leaving the German gun positions
09:27sitting on a rim with the sea behind them and the sea in front of them.
09:32Think about what kind of commander asks for that.
09:35He did not ask for it because it was ruthless.
09:38He asked for it because the alternative was a frontal assault by his own infantry across open ground, and he
09:44had run the sum.
09:46That is the arithmetic the Americans had just been placed inside.
09:50Not attack the enemy, break the thing the enemy is standing on, and then walk in.
09:56The Americans hadn't been told this.
09:58Nobody hands a new division a card explaining how their allies think.
10:02They were going to work it out themselves, in the field, at cost.
10:07And while they worked it out, the Canadians on their immediate left were paying for the same lesson in front
10:12of a pine wood.
10:14The wood was at Waus Plantage, and it was the hinge of the whole German position south of Bergen-Obsum.
10:20On the 23rd, the Governor General's foot guards had gone at it over open country with the Lake Superior Regiment,
10:26and the guards were badly mauled.
10:28German anti-tank guns sitting in the tree line, with a clean field of fire, and nothing on the flat
10:34ground to hide a Sherman.
10:36Afterwards, the road running up towards Bergen-Obsum collected so many burnt out tanks and scout cars that the Canadians
10:42gave it a name.
10:44They called it Hulk Alley.
10:47Remember Hulk Alley.
10:49Two days after that, on the same road, a Canadian officer is going to make a decision that looks like
10:55the exact opposite of everything I have just told you about caution.
10:59And he is going to be right.
11:01Back on the American front, four days before that beet field, the Timberwolves ran into a canal.
11:07It was called the Wart, and the Germans had the far bank.
11:12The 414th Infantry came up to it, got its nose across, and was stopped cold.
11:18Machine guns sighted to fire along the water, and a division's worth of American momentum sitting in the mud in
11:24front of it.
11:25What broke it was not a charge.
11:28It was one man with a radio.
11:30Captain Dar Nelson of the Divisional Artillery went forward past the infantry, past cover,
11:35out into ground where a man is visible from three directions at once, and lay there, and began talking.
11:41He was doing the one job in the Allied armies that an artilleryman is trained to die doing,
11:47putting his own eyes on the enemy so that guns miles behind him can be moved, 100 yards at a
11:53time,
11:53onto positions nobody else can see.
11:56He stayed out there.
11:57The shells came down where he said they should come down,
12:00and the crossing that had been impossible at 9 o'clock became possible.
12:04Now I want you to notice something about that,
12:07because it is the first real piece of the answer to the question in the title of this film,
12:11and it is not the piece most people expect.
12:14Nelson was American.
12:16The guns were American.
12:17The courage was his own.
12:19But the army he was inside had built its entire way of fighting around exactly that transaction.
12:25An observer's eyes traded for a battalion's lives.
12:29And it had the switchboard, the grid, the trained gunners, and the sheer weight of ammunition
12:34to make the trade over and over again, all day, on demand.
12:39In 1st Canadian Army, you did not ask whether the artillery could be spared.
12:44You asked what you wanted flattened.
12:47Terry Allen's division had spent two days learning that the ground would not let them run.
12:52They were about to spend three more days learning that they could not stop running fast enough,
12:57because the river ahead of them was eight miles away,
13:00the Germans were already across it,
13:03and the one bridge that mattered was still standing.
13:06For about another eleven hours.
13:09The 27th of October, 1944, on a sand track through Pine Woods,
13:14four miles south of the Dutch city of Bergen-Opzoom,
13:17two Canadian commanding officers are standing beside a Sherman with the engine running,
13:22and they have a decision to make that neither of them has authority to make.
13:26Behind them is the road the Canadians had christened Hulk Alley, and it had earned the name.
13:30The woods at Waus Plantage had cost the Governor General's foot guards a bad afternoon four days earlier,
13:37anti-tank guns sitting back in the tree line with a clean sweep across open farmland,
13:42and nothing on that flat ground for a tank to hide behind.
13:45The Canadians had ground their way through it.
13:48Now the wood was theirs, and in front of them was a city of 40,000 people,
13:52the gateway to the whole German position in West Brabant, and no orders to take it.
13:56What they had instead was Dutch civilians.
14:00Local men had been coming through the lines all morning saying the same thing.
14:04The Germans have gone.
14:06Not falling back fighting, gone.
14:09Out through the north end, on anything with wheels.
14:13Now, the careful answer here is obvious.
14:16Civilians are not reconnaissance.
14:19A city is the worst possible place to put tanks without infantry, at dusk, on hearsay.
14:24Every manual in every army says,
14:28Stop.
14:28Report.
14:29Request.
14:30Wait for the set-piece attack tomorrow morning.
14:33Lieutenant Colonel Gordon Wotherspoon of the South Alberta Regiment,
14:37swatty to every man who served under him,
14:40turned to Lieutenant Colonel Bill Crom of the Lincoln and Welland Regiment
14:44and said eleven words that are still quoted in that city today.
14:48Hell, Bill.
14:50Let's take the damn place.
14:51And they did.
14:55Canadian tanks and Canadian infantry went into Bergen-Obsum that evening,
14:59and took it essentially without a fight.
15:01A city that should have cost a week and a thousand casualties,
15:05taken because two colonels believed some Dutchmen and moved before the door closed.
15:10Now put that beside what I told you in the last part,
15:13because if you are holding both of these in your head at once,
15:16you are starting to see the actual shape of the thing the Americans had been dropped into.
15:21This was an army that would break a sea dike and drown an island rather than send infantry across open
15:27ground.
15:28It was also an army in which a Lieutenant Colonel would take a city on a rumor at last light.
15:33Those two behaviors look like opposites.
15:37They are not.
15:38They are the same rule applied twice.
15:40This army had decided, after Normandy had eaten its infantry,
15:44that ground is bought with steel, with water, with engineering, with time,
15:49with anything except riflemen,
15:51and that when ground comes free you take it that second and you do not ask permission.
15:57The Timberwolves had not yet worked out the first half of that rule.
16:01They were about to run headlong into a place where the second half did not apply.
16:06Because eight miles east of Bergen-Obsum the German command had stopped improvising.
16:12On the 29th of October the Germans in front of the Americans broke contact and went back behind a water
16:18line,
16:19the Mark and the Dintel,
16:21two rivers that run together across the whole neck of that country like a drawn bar.
16:25Behind it they dug.
16:28In front of it they left the ground stripped, culverts blown, roads mined,
16:33every approach visible for a thousand yards.
16:36The Americans came on hard.
16:39They were still moving faster than anybody above them expected,
16:42and they were taking the losses that speed costs.
16:46Outside one village a private of the 414th called Beverly Tipton
16:51walked a machine gun down to point-blank range
16:54and killed it with his automatic rifle,
16:57the kind of act that gets a decoration in a good week and a burial in a bad one.
17:02On the 30th of October they reached the mark.
17:05The bridge at Standarbuten was the prize.
17:09It was the only place on that stretch where a division's vehicles could cross,
17:13and it was still standing when the leading Americans came into sight of it.
17:16They went for it.
17:18The Germans blew it in their faces.
17:21So the 415th Infantry did the thing that any good, confident, aggressive regiment does
17:27when a bridge goes down in front of it.
17:29It decided to cross anyway.
17:32At first light on the 31st, one battalion went over in assault boats,
17:36over the mark, into the polder on the far side,
17:39straight into the ground you have already seen.
17:41They got across.
17:43They got a foothold.
17:44And then the German counterattack came down on them
17:47with self-propelled guns firing along the dikes,
17:50and the foothold stopped being a bridgehead and started being a trap.
17:54Because behind the Americans there was no bridge,
17:57no ferry, no armor, and no way to reinforce.
18:01By dark the battalion was ordered back over the water.
18:04Sixty-five men and two lieutenants could not get back.
18:08Ernest Fox and George Squires organized what was left where it stood,
18:12in the beet field, with German armor on the road and an 88 ranging on them,
18:17and there they stayed.
18:19I am going to be honest with you about what that was.
18:22It was not a clever plan that went wrong.
18:25It was a division trying to take a water obstacle at the speed it had been taking farmhouses,
18:30and the water obstacle winning.
18:32The Timberwolves had been in combat for eight days,
18:34and they had just been handed the first unambiguous failure of their war.
18:39And here is what was happening at the other end of that same army on that same night,
18:44and I want you to decide for yourself whether the two things are connected,
18:48because I am not going to prove it on paper.
18:51While Fox and Squires were digging into wet mud on the wrong side of the mark,
18:56Guy Simons was signing off on an amphibious assault for the following morning,
19:01landing craft, rocket ships, and royal marine commandos,
19:05going straight at the gap his bombers had torn in the sea dike at Vescapel,
19:09into the flooded ruin of Walcheren to finish the Scheldt and open Antwerp.
19:14The 1st of November belonged to that.
19:17And so, on the 1st of November, on the mark, the Americans did nothing.
19:23No attack. No second crossing.
19:25A whole division stood still for a day and a night,
19:29while 65 of its own men lay in a field 200 yards from German tanks,
19:34pulling beets out of the mud to eat.
19:37That day of doing nothing is the most important day in this story,
19:41and the reason for it is the answer to the question in the title.
19:45The 1st of November, 1944.
19:48In a farm building a mile back from the mark,
19:50with the windows blown out and a map of the river pinned up where everyone could see it,
19:56Terry Allen had spent eight days pushing his division forward faster than anyone above him had asked.
20:02On this morning, he stopped it.
20:03That is a harder thing for a commander to do than it sounds,
20:07and it is harder for this commander than for most.
20:11Allen had been relieved of a division once already in this war,
20:14taken away from the 1st Infantry Division in Sicily,
20:17partly for being too aggressive for his superior's taste.
20:21Aggression was his brand.
20:23His men had it printed on their character.
20:26Nothing in hell can stop the Timberwolves.
20:28And on the 1st of November, he told them to sit down.
20:31No attack.
20:33No second try at the river.
20:35Instead, in order to build something.
20:38Here is what that order actually meant on the ground,
20:40and I want to go slowly through it,
20:42because this is the machinery the Americans had never been inside before,
20:46and in three days, it is going to do something for them
20:49that nothing in their own repertoire could do.
20:51It meant survey parties out at the water's edge before daylight,
20:55finding the exact spots where the bank shelved gently enough to run a boat in,
20:59and where a bridge could be seated on the far side.
21:02It meant gunner officers crawling forward with the infantry
21:06to look at the German bank through field glasses
21:08and put grid references on things nobody had bothered to plot.
21:12A machine gun post in a farm building,
21:14a dug-in gun at a road junction,
21:16the mortar pits behind the dike that had been dropping bombs on the beat field for two days.
21:20It meant the artillery regiments moving up into new positions,
21:24registering and then not firing deliberately so as not to advertise.
21:29It meant trucks running all night to stack shells by the hundreds of tons behind the gun lines,
21:34and sappers hauling assault boats forward on their shoulders,
21:38through mud, in the dark,
21:39because a vehicle on a dike road in daylight is a target.
21:43And it meant redoing the arithmetic.
21:46On the 31st, they had put one battalion across.
21:49The new plan put four across at once, on a two-regiment front,
21:54after the guns had already done the killing.
21:56That is the thing that nobody teaches in a fortnight,
21:59and that no amount of courage substitutes for.
22:02Not artillery.
22:03The Americans had artillery, and plenty of it,
22:06and Captain Dar Nelson had already shown what an American observer would do with a radio and no cover.
22:12What the Americans were being handed was the habit of refusing to attack
22:16until the whole weight of an army had been assembled behind the attack,
22:20and the patience to accept that assembling it takes a day and a night,
22:24while your own men are stuck on the wrong side of a river eating raw beets.
22:28Which brings me back to that field.
22:30Because the 1st of November was day two for fox and squires.
22:3465 men.
22:36No resupply.
22:37Water in the furrows.
22:39German armor on the dike road.
22:41An 88 registering on them whenever they moved.
22:45What they were doing out there had no tactical name.
22:48They were being a hole in the German plan.
22:51A piece of the far bank that the Germans could not report as clear,
22:55and could not clean out without committing infantry into their own artillery's field of fire.
23:01And now I need to tell you something that keeps this from being a story about clever Canadians and green
23:06Americans.
23:07Because that is not what the record says.
23:10If it were, this film would be flattering and false.
23:14On the evening of the 31st of October, the very same evening the American battalion was being pulled back over
23:21the mark,
23:22the Canadians nine miles to the west did exactly what the Americans had just done.
23:26The Algonquin regiment attacked out of Moorstraten towards a village called Wellberg to open the road for the armor.
23:34They went in without the full weight behind them.
23:36The Germans in front of them were the 6th Parachute Regiment, a formation that had been destroyed once that year
23:42in the Falaise pocket and rebuilt from nothing.
23:45With Hermann Göring troops beside them.
23:48And they did not sit and receive the attack.
23:51They counterattacked into it with self-propelled guns.
23:54Two Algonquin company headquarters were overrun in the dark.
23:59The Canadian official account of that night does not dress it up.
24:03It was a fiasco.
24:04So hold these two things side by side.
24:07The best night fighting division in the American army had just failed on a river crossing.
24:13A Canadian battalion that had been fighting since Normandy had just been overrun in the dark on the same night,
24:20nine miles away, going at the same German waterline.
24:23The lesson the Americans were being given in Holland was not that their allies were wiser.
24:29It was that this way of fighting is not wisdom, it is a discipline.
24:33It is slow, it is expensive in ammunition, it feels like cowardice to an aggressive infantryman.
24:39And every army on that front broke it whenever it was in a hurry, and got punished for it inside
24:4524 hours.
24:46The Canadians had learned that.
24:48They had learned it at Verrier Ridge, and on the Leopold Canal, and in the Breskin's pocket.
24:53And they had paid the full retail price for the education.
24:57On the 1st of November, the man who had taught them most of it was spending his own bill.
25:02Out at the mouth of the Scheldt, Simons put his assault in that morning.
25:06Landing craft and rocket ships going straight at the gap in the sea dike at Vestkapell.
25:11Royal marine commandos wading into a flooded island.
25:14Another force crossing at Flushing.
25:16He had drowned Vacherun first, precisely so that this would be survivable.
25:21And it was still one of the worst mornings of the campaign for the men in the boats.
25:24That was the whole doctrine on display in one place.
25:28Break the ground, then go in, and accept that even then it costs.
25:33200 feet of sea dike, and 9 miles of Dutch farmland apart, the same army was running the same argument
25:40on the 2nd of November.
25:41That evening, two attacks went in on that water line.
25:44At 7 o'clock, the Canadians crossed their start line in front of Wellberg, with everything the Corps could give
25:50them.
25:50Lincoln and Wellens on the left, Algonquins on the right.
25:54After dark, at Standardbuiten, four American battalions went at the mark.
25:58By midnight, one of those two attacks had 2,000 men on the far bank, and a town behind it.
26:03The other was lying on its start line, pinned, and losing people by the minute.
26:08The 2nd of November, 1944.
26:117 o'clock in the evening, on a start line in open farmland a mile short of a Dutch village
26:16called Wellberg.
26:17The Lincoln and Welland Regiment's war diary records something odd about that day,
26:22and it is the kind of thing only men who were there bother to write down.
26:26It says the day was bright and warm.
26:29After a month of rain in the polders, they got sunshine on the afternoon they were going back into Wellberg.
26:35Some of them would have taken that as a good omen.
26:37The Algonquins on their right, forming up 400 yards away, had been into Wellberg once already, two nights before,
26:44and had two company headquarters overrun in the dark for their trouble.
26:48They were going back in over the same ground, against the same German paratroops.
26:53This time, it was done properly.
26:54At 7 o'clock, the core artillery came down, and with it came something the infantry watched with their mouths
27:01open.
27:02Rocket firing typhoons went in on the village in the last of the light.
27:0660 pound rockets off the rails at 500 feet, and Wellberg caught fire.
27:12Now understand what that meant to the men on the start line,
27:16because it is one of the strangest images of the Canadian war.
27:19The village they were attacking became the lamp they attacked by.
27:24It burned hard enough to light the whole approach, so that Canadian infantry crossing bare fields in the dark
27:31could see the ground in front of their boots, and keep direction off the glow.
27:36Their objective was illuminating their own advance.
27:41And it still went wrong on the left.
27:44The Lincoln and Wellens crossed the start line, and were pinned almost immediately.
27:48Not after 400 yards.
27:51Immediately.
27:52The Germans in front of them were the rebuilt 6th Parachute Regiment,
27:55and part of that regiment had been issued a weapon most Allied soldiers had not yet met.
28:00The new German assault rifle, a thing that fired like a machine carbine at close range,
28:05and turned a section of paratroops into the firepower of a platoon.
28:09The Canadians who wrote about Wellberg afterwards said the defense was extremely effective,
28:15and that is a professional's way of saying men were dying faster than the attack could move.
28:20So the left of the Canadian attack stopped.
28:23200 yards from where it started.
28:25In the dark, in the open, with a burning village in front of them.
28:30On the right, the Algonquins went through.
28:32I want to give that its weight.
28:34This was the battalion that had been mauled here 48 hours earlier.
28:38They knew exactly what was waiting.
28:40They crossed the same fields a second time, in the same dark, and this time,
28:45with the guns and the typhoons having done what one battalion's own weapons could never do,
28:49they broke into the German main defensive line, and stayed in it.
28:54The fighting went on all night, and through the next day, company by company,
28:58house by house, in a village that was still burning.
29:02By the end of the 3rd of November, all four Algonquin companies were on their objectives.
29:08Wellberg was Canadian.
29:11That is the second half of the lesson the Americans were being taught nine miles away,
29:15and it is the half almost every documentary leaves out, so hold on to it.
29:20The method does not make it cheap.
29:23Nobody who was at Wellberg would ever tell you the guns and the aircraft made it cheap.
29:27What the method does is make sure that when men die, the ground actually changes hands.
29:33The Algonquin attack on the 31st of October, without the weight behind it, cost two company headquarters and gained nothing
29:41at all.
29:41The Algonquin attack on the 2nd of November cost more men and gained the village, the road, and the hinge
29:47of the German position.
29:50Same battalion, same enemy, same ground.
29:54The difference was not courage.
29:56The difference was whether an army had been assembled behind them first.
30:00And to make sure the Americans could see the other end of that scale, the Germans provided a demonstration just
30:07up the road.
30:07At Steenbagen, a few miles northwest, the retreating German force turned and dug in.
30:14Roughly 600 men.
30:16Against them came an entire Canadian armor division.
30:20Tanks, infantry brigade, divisional artillery, air support on call.
30:26600 men held the division for five days.
30:30Read that again, because it is the most instructive number in this entire story, and I will come back to
30:36it at the end.
30:37This is what happened when the water lines of Holland were held by men who had decided not to leave.
30:44Five days, against a division, from a force you could fit into a large cinema.
30:49Anybody who ever tells you the Germans were finished by November of 1944 has not stood in Steenbagen.
30:56Out at the far end of the army, Guy Simmons' own bill was coming in at the same hour.
31:01His commandos were fighting along the rim of a drowned island, working from one flooded gun battery to the next,
31:07and Walcheren was not going to be finished for another week.
31:10The man who had drowned an island to save infantry was still, in the first days of November, losing infantry.
31:17He was also, at that moment, close to the end of his tenure.
31:21Crédard was recovering in England and would be back within the week to take the army over again.
31:26Simmons' time as an army commander, the only time a Canadian ever commanded an American division in the field, had
31:32a handful of days left to run.
31:34And in those last few days, the thing that time would remember happened not on his front, but on the
31:39American one.
31:40Because while the Lincoln and Wellens were pinned in front of a burning village, nine miles to the east, on
31:46the bank of the Mark,
31:47the guns that had been sitting silent and registered for a day and a half opened up on the German
31:52positions at Standerbauten.
31:53They fired for one hour.
31:56Waiting in an assault boat at the water's edge, in the noise, was a 36-year-old first lieutenant from
32:02Alabama named Cecil Bolton,
32:04who commanded the weapons platoon of a rifle company and who was, in about 90 minutes,
32:09going to be wading chest deep down a Dutch canal with a two-man bazooka team and two shattered legs.
32:15What happened in the next 50 minutes is the reason this story is worth telling.
32:199 o'clock at night, the 2nd of November, in a cellar under a house on the north bank of
32:24the Mark at Standerbauten.
32:26A German platoon sergeant is holding a field telephone that has stopped working,
32:31and he is shouting at his men to get down off the stairs.
32:33He had been on this bank for four days, and he had already beaten the Americans once here.
32:38He knew the drill by now.
32:40The Americans came at you fast, in daylight or dark, in boats, and you cut them up with grazing fire
32:45along the water
32:46and then hit them with the self-propelled guns before they could get anything heavy across.
32:50It had worked on the 31st.
32:52He had watched them go back over the river.
32:54What was happening now was not that.
32:56It had started as ranging, single shells, a minute apart, walking along the dike.
33:01Then it opened out, and it did not stop.
33:04It came down on the farm buildings, on the road junction, on the mortar pits behind the dike,
33:09on the exact places where a man would sight a gun if he knew his business,
33:13which meant somebody on the other side had spent a day and a half looking at his positions through glasses
33:18and writing them down.
33:20The telephone line to the company was cut in the first two minutes.
33:24The runner he sent out did not come back.
33:27For one hour, the Americans fired, and when it lifted, the sergeant's problem was no longer one battalion in boats.
33:34It was four.
33:35The Timberwolves put two regiments across the mark that night,
33:39four battalions at once, into the ground that had trapped one battalion two days earlier.
33:45The infantry went in over water that had been shelled clean,
33:48onto a bank where the wire had been cut by high explosive,
33:51and the machine gun crews were either dead or still in their holes with their heads down.
33:56They were in Standarbeten and holding it inside fifty minutes.
34:01Fifty minutes.
34:02Against the same regiment, on the same water, at the same place that had cost them a failed crossing,
34:08a mauled battalion and sixty-five men stranded in a beat field.
34:12But I am not going to let you think artillery did it all,
34:16because the men on the far bank that night would find that insulting,
34:19and the record does not support it.
34:21The German positions that survived the hour of shelling were still there,
34:25and they were manned by paratroops who did not run.
34:28In Company E of the 413th Infantry, the weapons platoon commander was First Lieutenant Cecil Bolton,
34:36thirty-six years old, which made him an old man among lieutenants.
34:40Born in Florida, enlisted in Alabama.
34:43Two German machine guns had his company pinned in the open,
34:46firing low and flat across ground already being shelled by German artillery.
34:51Bolton tried to kill them with his own mortars, and he could not see them well enough to do it.
34:56In the moonlight, the positions were camouflaged, and all he had were muzzle flashes.
35:01He kept directing fire anyway, out where he could observe,
35:05until a German shell put both his legs open and knocked him unconscious.
35:09He came round. He gave his platoon its orders.
35:12And then he crawled forward, past his own men, up to where the rifle platoons were lying,
35:18and asked for a bazooka team.
35:20Two men went with him.
35:21With them covering him, Bolton went down a canal,
35:24chest deep in water that was four degrees above freezing,
35:28with his legs torn towards the first machine gun.
35:31He got to within fifteen yards of the house it was firing from.
35:35Then he covered the last of it alone, and killed both gunners with hand grenades.
35:39He came back for his men, and took them across open ground under fire to the second gun.
35:45A German sniper tried to stop them on the way, and was shot.
35:49When the machine gun crew saw them and opened up,
35:51Bolton killed one of the three with his carbine, and his two soldiers killed the others.
35:56There was still an 88 firing into the American ranks,
35:59so he took the bazooka team back into the canal water,
36:03waiting until he could make out the shape of the gun in the dark,
36:06and directed the rockets that destroyed it.
36:09On the way back to his own lines he was hit again.
36:12He refused to be treated where he lay,
36:15because being treated there would mean keeping his two soldiers in the fire with him,
36:19and he ordered them back to safety instead.
36:22Then he crawled after them, and when he reached the American positions, he collapsed.
36:27He lived.
36:28He was given the Medal of Honor, and he stayed in the army,
36:31and he was a colonel by Korea.
36:34All along that bridgehead, men were doing the unglamorous half of it.
36:38A technical sergeant named John Cronin from Mach Chunk in Pennsylvania
36:42worked a platoon that was caught in the open, doing first aid under fire,
36:46and then organizing the evacuation of 21 wounded men off ground that nobody controlled.
36:52By midnight there were close to 2,000 Americans on the north bank.
36:55The engineers had a bridge going in behind them,
36:59and somewhere in that dark the advance reached a flooded sugar beet field
37:03where 65 men and two lieutenants had been lying for three days,
37:07eating the crop raw, waiting for an army to come and get them.
37:11Fox and Squires brought their people in.
37:14Two of their platoon sergeants, James Ferguson and Edward Arbogast,
37:18were commissioned as officers on the strength of what they had done out there.
37:21So here is the answer, and I want to state it plainly because it is not a slogan.
37:26What the American infantry learned in Holland was not how to be brave.
37:31They arrived brave.
37:32It was not how to fight at night.
37:34They were better at that than the army they had joined.
37:37What they learned was the thing 1st Canadian Army had bought with its own dead
37:42all the way from Normandy to the Scheldt.
37:44That against a water line held by men who mean to stay,
37:48you do not attack until the whole weight of an army is standing behind the attack.
37:53And that the day and a half you spend assembling it is not timidity,
37:57it is the difference between three days in a beet field and fifty minutes.
38:02They had one more thing to learn before they left, and the Germans taught them that one.
38:07Because there was a bridge at Moordyke, and the Germans still held it,
38:11and they were not going to let the Timberwolves have it.
38:13The 5th of November, 1944, on top of a dike at the northern edge of Brabant,
38:19with American infantry lying along the crest looking north.
38:23In front of them was the Hollands Dieppe,
38:25not a river in any sense a man from Ohio would recognize,
38:29but a sea channel better than a mile wide, grey, cold and empty.
38:34On the far shore, low and flat, was the province of South Holland,
38:39and it was German, and it was going to stay German for another 6 months.
38:44That was the end of the road for the Timberwolves.
38:46They had come up out of Belgium 13 days earlier,
38:49and they had done everything asked of them.
38:52Zundert, the Fartkanal, the Mark, Sevenbergen.
38:56Now they were standing at the water, with nothing left to attack,
39:00and in the whole of the province behind them,
39:02the Germans held one last corner, the ground around Moordyke,
39:06where the great bridges carried the road and the railway north over the deep.
39:11The Germans in that corner fought for it.
39:13It was the last piece of Brabant they had,
39:16and the fighting for it went on after the rest of the front had gone quiet.
39:20Houses, dikes, a village reduced to rubble.
39:24And when the last of them went out over the water,
39:27they dropped both bridges into the Hollands Dieppe behind them.
39:31Now here is the limit of everything I have been telling you,
39:35and it is important, because this is where the education stops being a triumph
39:39and becomes a fact of life.
39:42The method works.
39:44Assemble the army, break the ground, then go in.
39:47It had taken the Americans over the mark in 50 minutes.
39:51But every time it works, it delivers you to the next water line.
39:55And eventually, you arrive at one that is a mile and a half wide, in November, with winter coming,
40:01and there is no fire plan on earth that gets a rifle company across that.
40:06So the front stops.
40:08It stopped on that line.
40:10And First Canadian Army spent the next three months sitting in flooded farmland watching the Far Bank,
40:16in one of the wettest, coldest winters that country remembers.
40:20Nine miles west, the same story was finishing in a more painful way.
40:25Steenbergen was still holding.
40:27600 Germans, mostly paratroops, against a Canadian armored division.
40:32And they had turned the place into five days of work.
40:35Canadian infantry went in through Velberg and up the dike roads with the guns ahead of them
40:40and the tanks behind.
40:42And the Germans gave ground a house at a time, and then, at the end,
40:46slipped away northwest onto the Sint Philipsland Peninsula, where the Canadians followed them.
40:51Read that sequence carefully, because it is the whole campaign in miniature.
40:57The Canadians took the ground.
40:59They took it the expensive, correct, methodical way,
41:02and the men who had held it against them got away over the water.
41:06Which is exactly what German units on that front did all autumn,
41:10and exactly why nobody in First Canadian Army was writing cheerful letters home in November.
41:16Out on the estuary, Guy Simmons finished his war as an army commander.
41:22Walherrin fell in the first week of the month.
41:25The commandos and the Scots worked their way around the rim of his drowned island
41:29until the last coastal battery stopped firing, and the mouth of the Scheldt was clear.
41:35Then the minesweepers went to work.
41:37Nearly a hundred of them, up sixty miles of channel, for three weeks.
41:41And on the 28th of November, the first allied convoy tied up in the docks at Antwerp.
41:48That is the sentence the whole autumn was for.
41:51Not a town, not a ridge.
41:54A convoy coming into a port.
41:56It had been bought by an army of eleven million people's sons,
42:01fighting in somebody else's corps, with British guns and British doctrine,
42:05and the worst ground on the Western Front.
42:08And it cost First Canadian Army something on the order of thirteen thousand casualties in five weeks.
42:16Canadians, Britons, Poles, and in that last fortnight, Americans.
42:22Simons handed the army back to Harry Crearer in the first week of November,
42:27and went back to his corps.
42:29He never commanded an American division again.
42:32No Canadian ever has.
42:34And the Americans he had been given went away.
42:38In the middle of November, the Timberwolves were pulled out of Holland,
42:42moved to the American First Army front, and put into the line at Aachen,
42:46relieving the 1st Infantry Division, Terry Allen's own old division,
42:51the one that had been taken away from him in Sicily.
42:55Watch what they did with what they had learned, because this is the proof, and it is not sentimental.
43:01In front of them were the German industrial towns on the road to the Rohr,
43:06Eschweiler, Weisweiler, Stolberg.
43:09And the Timberwolves fought through them in a way that no longer looked much like the division
43:14that had rushed a bridge at Standarbuten.
43:17They attacked at night, as they always had.
43:20That was Allen's, and it was theirs.
43:22But now the knights began with the guns,
43:25and the objectives were taken by battalions that went in after the weight had landed,
43:29and the division held what it took.
43:32They forced the Ende at Enden in Lücherberg in exactly that style,
43:37in the sort of fighting where a company changes hands twice before breakfast.
43:42By the spring, the 104th was rated among the best divisions in the United States Army.
43:48They went through the Rhineland, over the Rhine, into the Harts,
43:52and on the 26th of April, 1945, at a place called Pretz on the Mulde,
43:57American soldiers of the Timberwolf Division shook hands with the Red Army.
44:03Thirteen days in Holland under a Canadian general, at the beginning of all that.
44:08The Americans knew what they had been given.
44:11Terry Allen said so, and the corps and army commanders who inherited his division said so,
44:16and the record of how they fought afterwards says so more loudly than any of them.
44:21But the judgment that matters most in this story was written by the Canadian,
44:25and I have been saving it.
44:28Before he handed the army back, Guy Simons,
44:30a man whose own officers describe him as almost incapable of warmth,
44:35who did not hand out compliments and never once in this campaign flattered anybody,
44:40sat down and put on paper what he thought of the American division he had been loaned.
44:46It is one sentence.
44:48It is about teeth.
44:49This is what Guy Simons wrote.
44:52Once the Timberwolves got their teeth into the Bosch,
44:55they showed great dash,
44:56and the British and Canadian troops on their flanks
44:58expressed great admiration for their courage and enthusiasm.
45:03That is the whole of it.
45:05One sentence.
45:06From a man his own staff described as almost incapable of warmth,
45:11about the only American division a Canadian ever commanded.
45:14Now look at what he actually praised.
45:17Dash.
45:19Courage.
45:20Enthusiasm.
45:21He did not praise their planning.
45:23He did not praise their river crossing.
45:25He praised exactly the things the Timberwolves had brought with them from Camp Adair and Fort Jackson
45:31in the night ranges where Terry Allen worked them 30 hours a week in the dark.
45:35The things that were already theirs when they stepped off the boat.
45:39Because the traffic went both ways,
45:41and it is worth being clear about the direction of each half.
45:44What the Americans gave that corps was a division that would attack at night, on a flank,
45:49faster than anyone above it expected,
45:51at a moment when the Canadians and the British had been fighting continuously since June
45:55and were running out of infantry.
45:57What the Americans took away was the method.
46:00The guns first, the whole weight of an army behind the assault,
46:04and the discipline to stand still for a day and a half while it was assembled.
46:08Montgomery, who was not generous either, said the division had done it under appalling conditions.
46:13Anyone who has walked a Brabant polder in November knows he was being precise rather than kind.
46:20So what became of them?
46:22Cecil Bolton lived.
46:23The legs that he dragged down a canal in November of 44 healed enough for him to stay in uniform.
46:29President Truman put the Medal of Honor around his neck at the White House the following year.
46:33He went to Korea and finished as a colonel, and he died in 1965 at 56.
46:38James Ferguson and Edward Arbogast, the two platoon sergeants who had held a corner of a beet field for three
46:44days,
46:45were given commissions for it and went back to the war as officers.
46:49Of Ernest Fox and George Squires, the record says almost nothing further,
46:54which is the ordinary fate of ordinary lieutenants.
46:57Two men kept 65 soldiers alive on turnips for three days on the wrong side of a river,
47:03and the archive gives them a line and a half.
47:06Terry Allen commanded the Timberwolves to the end, took them to the Muld, and brought them home.
47:11He never got another war.
47:14Twenty-two years later, his son, Lieutenant Colonel Terry Allen Jr.,
47:18was killed at the head of an American battalion in Vietnam, and the old man outlived him by two years.
47:24Guy Simons handed 1st Canadian Army back to Harry Crearer in the first week of November,
47:29and finished the war commanding his corps in the flooded ground where this story ends.
47:34He became Chief of the General Staff of the Canadian Army in the 1950s.
47:39He died in 1974, and the argument about him has never really stopped.
47:44The coldest senior officer Canada produced, and the one who found ways to take ground that did not require his
47:51infantry to walk into it.
47:54And the ground itself.
47:55At Bergen-Obsum, the city Swati Wotherspoon and Bill Krom took on a rumor at last light,
48:02because two colonels decided not to wait for morning.
48:05There is a Commonwealth war cemetery with more than a thousand graves in it, most of them Canadian,
48:11a great many of them from those weeks.
48:13The city holds its liberation ceremony every year, and Dutch school children read the names out loud.
48:21In Zündert, there is a memorial with a timber wolf on it, because the Dutch have never much cared which
48:27flag was on the shoulder of the man who came up the road first.
48:31The beet field outside Standarbuten is a beet field. It is farmed.
48:36Every autumn, somebody lifts that crop with a machine, in a few hours, on ground where 65 Americans once pulled
48:44it up with their hands and ate it raw,
48:46because an army was still being assembled behind them and there was nothing to do until it was.
48:52Here is what I take from all of it.
48:54Canada put a volunteer army of a country of 11 million people into someone else's corps,
49:00with British guns and British doctrine, and was handed the jobs nobody else wanted,
49:05the Scheldt, the polders, the winter on the Maas, the estuary that had to be opened before the war could
49:12be won.
49:13It learned, at Verrieres and on the Leopold Canal and in front of Velberg,
49:18a hard and unglamorous way of fighting that spent steel and water instead of men,
49:23and it learned it by losing men.
49:26And when the United States Army needed somewhere to put a brand new division at the most important point on
49:31the northern front,
49:32that is where it went.
49:34For 13 days in Holland, American infantry took their orders from a Canadian,
49:39watched how his army did it, paid for the lesson in a flooded field,
49:43and then used it for the rest of the war, all the way to the Elbe.
49:46The Americans took the lesson to Germany, the Canadians stayed in the water.
49:51They were still there in January, in the same polders,
49:54patrolling the Maas in the cold.
49:56And they were the ones who, in the spring,
49:58went back up into Holland and took the rest of that country town by town,
50:02and the Dutch remember them by name 80 years later.
50:05Thank you for staying with this one to the end.
50:07If you think what the Canadians did in those flooded fields deserves to be remembered,
50:12a like genuinely helps it find more people.
50:14And if you'd like more of these, we're here every week.
50:17One thing I'd like to ask, and I mean it,
50:20if your father, your grandfather, or your uncle served in the Second World War,
50:24in any army, I'd be honored to hear about him in the comments.
50:28Some of you are the last people who knew these men as men rather than names.
50:32Finer Sal.
50:32First, yeah.