- 13 minutes ago
The line between investing and gambling has never been blurrier. Join us as we break down the history, mechanics, and controversies surrounding prediction markets, from early political wagering to billion-dollar platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket, and explore how this booming industry is challenging financial regulations and reshaping how we think about risk, chance, and the future.
Transcript
00:00Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we're examining the history and mechanics of prediction markets
00:05to speculate on the future of investment platforms.
00:08And in the end, it matters to bettors and the markets alike.
00:13On October 22, 2026, the National Basketball Association partnered with the prediction
00:19market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket. Their stated objective was to help regulate how users
00:25invest in sports events. But many saw this unprecedented deal as further legitimizing
00:30a buddy industry that blurs the line between commercial gambling and stock exchange.
00:35So just last year, federal prosecutors charged multiple current and former NBA players and coaches
00:40in this far-reaching gambling scandal. So why team up with gambling sites now?
00:46The NBA said something really interesting in their partnership, and they said,
00:49this is where our fans are engaging, this is where they are participating,
00:52and this is where they're engaging in fantasy sports. Shortly before the NBA's deal,
00:56their American football counterpart, the NFL, stated plainly to the U.S. Supreme Court
01:01that prediction markets are gambling. This split of authority and the
01:05consequent uncertainty about the regulatory oversight of sports wagering on DCMS, or designated contract
01:13markets, pose a significant challenge to the NFL's game integrity and consumer protection efforts.
01:22While sports betting is the most quintessential service offered by such platforms, users can
01:26invest in scenarios involving industries, political activity, pop culture, and even the weather.
01:32A CNN analysis in late October 2026 found that the U.S. midterm elections inspired over 1.4 billion
01:40dollars in trading volume. So prediction markets are becoming lucrative and potentially consequential.
01:46Look at the volume that you see being traded on Texas Senate, but also I'm going to note the volume
01:52you see there on Michigan Senate. Speculating on the trajectory of an industry is a matter of
01:58understanding the product. How the game is played. A prediction market is an online platform where users
02:08exchange stock in a future scenario, usually formatted as a binary question of whether it happens.
02:14The basic thing that you can trade on a prediction market is called an event contract. It's based
02:19on a yes or no question around some future event. Traders can buy this event contract at a price set
02:25by trade market metrics, with the option to resell before the event. Once that happens though,
02:30those who invested correctly earn a profit, while those who didn't get nothing. The mechanics are
02:36similar to the stock exchange industry, which is widely accessible in most democratic capitalist countries.
02:41Look at that angle. However, the short-term investment in random fate is more like commercial
02:47gambling. That industry is more aggressively regulated in most countries, with several states
02:52in the US banning it outright. Legality gets more ambiguous with skill-driven games of chance
02:57that employ analysis of raw data. But as long as prediction markets make money off of fees,
03:03while users only trade with each other, they don't fit the legal definition of gambling in the US.
03:08The explosion of the industry there still signals the next phase in legal debates surrounding
03:13financial investment. Pattern of predictions. For as long as there have been economies,
03:21there's been betting on their trajectory. This was industrialized into commercial gambling after the
03:2515th century. Governments then moved from banning the practice to supporting it with regulations to
03:31protect consumers, public safety, and financial integrity. This made governments beneficiaries of the
03:36industry. It did not directly develop into stock exchanges, wherein merchants are financed by
03:42shareholders who are entitled to a cut of profit. You look at successful countries and they all have
03:47stock markets. And countries that tried to shut them down are coming around and instituting them now.
03:53But that profit still comes down to extenuating factors like fate. Future markets evolved to tie
03:59investments into speculation on such factors. The futures market allows the people who sell and buy
04:05large quantities of corn to insulate you, the consumer, from those changes. Meanwhile, prediction markets
04:13grew out of traders directly wagering shares on consequential events like political elections. But even when we
04:19look at pretty close elections, which are the hard ones to call, they're quite accurate. They get more
04:25accurate as election day gets closer, as you can imagine. In 1988, the University of Iowa experimented in
04:32centralizing the practice with electronic markets, whose predictions proved more consistently accurate than
04:37political polls. It's illegal to bet on elections, right? It's not illegal to have markets. But markets are
04:44regulated in the U.S. to protect traders. So our market run for research and teaching purposes. We stay
04:50small. What couldn't have been predicted was how this practice would look in the digital age. Keeping up
04:56with the modern world and industries doesn't have to be so hard. Scan the QR to get your scoop on
05:00the 24
05:017 WatchMojo pop culture live stream. The point is, that sure looks like gambling. The market boom. With new
05:09developments in digital commerce, including cryptocurrency, the prediction market platform
05:13Augur demonstrated the standard for the field in 2018. Augur uses its own cryptocurrency. However,
05:19it's built on Ethereum blockchain. This included blockchain-based event contracts that were gradually
05:25legally refined. The investment novelty then became an industry, though the U.S.-based Kalshi and Polymarket
05:31soon dominated it. The people who never stop asking are the ones who find answers. Supporters hailed their
05:39simple concepts and interface as making stock exchanges more accessible to non-professional
05:44traders. Critics argued that prediction markets meticulously use legal derivative frameworks to get
05:50around regulation on commercial gambling. It's a pretty fascinating debate. And ultimately,
05:55it comes down to kind of an existential question about these markets, which is, are they similar to a
06:03casino where everyone's gambling? Or are they more like the stock market where people are investing?
06:07They're placing trades. They're making informed decisions. The debate goes back to 2004, when Hedge
06:13Street, later renamed Nadex, was designated as a legitimate contract market by the U.S. Commodity
06:19Futures Commission. Nadex hourly, daily, and weekly contracts offer continuous opportunities in all market
06:26conditions. Four years later, this institution issued formal questions about how short-term investment in a
06:33singular event is different from gambling. Years of legal disputes coincided with the embrace of
06:39prediction markets by consumers, capitalists, and world leaders alike. Risk capital. Controversies
06:46surrounding commercial gambling include dangerously compulsive practice, criminal exploitation, and
06:52unstable revenue-based economics. If you want to have a healthy market, you need to have healthy
06:56people who are participating in that market that don't feel like that market is taking advantage of
07:01them, but giving them real opportunities to learn, to participate, to grow in ways that don't result in
07:06them losing their skin. Controversies surrounding stock exchange are fairly similar, but with potentially
07:11systematic implications. Prediction markets ostensibly apply stock exchange safeguards to lower stakes games of
07:17chance. Because the speculations are rooted in hard data, the practice doubles as a game of skill.
07:23That's the crux of sports betting having more legal ground than traditional gambling. Still,
07:28there remains the risk of users abusing the platform and vice versa. Gambling is just like
07:33many other drugs. It's highly addictive. A concern unique to prediction markets is that they could affect
07:39stock value and human behavior relating to certain topics. Now all of this frivolous gambling might have
07:45you hoping that the world is ending. And I have good news. You can bet on that too!
07:52Industrialists and political leaders can have a financial stake in major events they directly dictate.
07:57In 2026, a US military serviceman and a Google software engineer faced insider trading charges for
08:05using classified information in trading. No one should be able to use insider information to line their own
08:11pockets. This could be the beginning of prediction markets being a major public safety concern.
08:16Market management. The US's 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act
08:22distinctly recognized event contracts as legitimate derivatives while strengthening relevant laws.
08:28Dodd-Frank created a new council made up of bigwigs from the Treasury Secretary, the Fed, the SEC, and more.
08:35As designated contract markets, these exchanges must certify all listings, then monitor for improper
08:41user conduct, fraud, and public harm. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has the authority to
08:48intervene in potentially harmful exchanges. To those who seek to challenge our authority in this space,
08:54let me be clear. We will see you in court. They first did this when they blocked NADx from listing
09:01contracts related to the 2012 US federal election. That same year, they ordered the Irish platform
09:07in trade to bar American users from trading outside of US soil. The platform was shut down over the next
09:13two years, and its parent company fined $3 million in the US in 2018. Even though no one person in
09:21the
09:21crowd knows everything, if the crowd is big enough and it's diverse enough, you just have access to so
09:27much more knowledge than you do if you ask one expert or even a really small team of experts.
09:33The CFTC continued to go after markets for non-compliance issues before the entire industry
09:39changed in 2024. The federal court, allowing Kalshi to list contracts related to that year's elections,
09:45opened the door for event contracts on all sorts of topics. The policy debate became much more
09:51consequential from there. The CFTC believes these wagers are illegal and could harm the integrity of
09:56elections. It appealed the decision shortly after it was issued. Offshore deals. Legal regulation makes
10:03jurisdiction an important factor in prediction markets. When Polymarket tried to launch in Australia
10:09last year, it was banned because it was operating without a commercial gambling license. Many put new
10:15users through a relatively extensive vetting process to ensure location-based compliance. This system was
10:21complicated after exchanges began listing sports topics as lawsuits pressed whether they're subject
10:26to state's individual sports betting laws. Kalshi's called itself the first nationwide legal sports
10:32betting platform. But when asked about it, it later tried to qualify that statement saying the bet
10:37language is only used in the sense that any financial position can be considered a bet on the future.
10:43And that is so dumb, it is almost charming. The most central hurdle in international trade
10:49is the fact that the US is one of the few countries that recognize prediction markets as exchanges.
10:55Most places classify them as gambling and regulate or ban them accordingly. Even for the bets that are
11:01above board, there's a question of whether it's moral to have markets dealing with wars and assassinations.
11:07The classification question doesn't even come up in countries where cryptocurrency exchange is
11:13banned. Before we continue, be sure to check out WatchMojo's 24-hour livestream. All of your
11:19favorite videos in one place, 24-7. Always on, always live.
11:24Are you not entertained?
11:26Market predictions. 2026 has seen more than $300 billion exchanged on Kalshi alone. Users are trading on
11:34politics, financials, pop culture, technology, and more, down to the mere mention of a word in a speech.
11:41Like a word Trevor Noah will say on camera.
11:45Potato. If you had me saying potato on Polly Market, you just made a ton of money.
11:50Traditional sports books remain more popular for wagers, but that feature has led to the
11:55rapid growth of the prediction market industry. So throughout 2026, a number of US states took
12:00legal action against Kalshi over the legalities of its sports marketplace.
12:04But the New York Attorney General Letitia James says the prediction market is essentially gambling,
12:11especially the ability to bet on the outcome of sports.
12:16The rulings have been split, and the US Supreme Court has been petitioned. If prediction markets are
12:21here to stay, policy proposals include stricter CFTC oversight, banning certain contract topics,
12:27and excluding traders with a conflict of interest. Though less risky than capital investment,
12:32these markets could have systematic ramifications as users grow more fixated, institutions more
12:38affected, and legal integrity more shaky. Our message is, you know, we want more guardrails,
12:44and I think this is what they should look like. There's a lot of money on the table with this
12:47industry and a lot of speculation about its future. What's your bet on the future of prediction markets
12:53in the US and beyond? Exchange your predictions in the comments.