Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 18 minutes ago
Political tension arose after Italian politician Giacomo Filibeck chanted a slogan with Rahul Gandhi at the Bharat Summit. BJP filed a complaint over alleged visa violations and foreign interference.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shakhi.
00:03Vot chor gaddi chhod. These were not the words of Rahul Gandhi at a political rally.
00:09They were chanted by an Italian politician invited to attend the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad.
00:16And Rahul Gandhi clapped for those remarks.
00:19The BJP has hit back with Home Minister Amit Shah accusing Rahul Gandhi of using
00:24an international platform, international guests to tarnish India's image.
00:31And he has said that this is essentially targeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi and India.
00:38The BJP has also filed a criminal complaint against the Italian politician here,
00:43Philly Beck, with the Telangana DGP alleging unlawful political interference and violation of Indian laws.
00:50So in this edition of NewsTrack, we ask, can the Congress justify giving a foreign politician
00:57a platform to comment on India's internal affairs?
01:02And why has the Congress Party taken this entire vote chhodi battle global with this statement?
01:10We discuss that with our guests who will be joining me shortly.
01:14But first up, here's a report.
01:16Vot chor gaddi chhod.
01:18A vote chhod slogan by an Italian politician.
01:23Courtesy translation.
01:25Vote thief, leave your seat.
01:27At an event called the Bharat Summit.
01:29On a Congress platform.
01:32The vote chhodi battle, which has largely remained a Desi political fight, got a Videsi touch.
01:39Giacomo Filibeck, the Secretary General of Italy's Party of European Socialists,
01:44stirred hornets' nest by echoing a slogan that Rahul Gandhi has been raising against the Modi government.
01:52Vote chhod, Gandhi chhod.
01:58Courtesy translation.
02:00Vote thief, leave your seat.
02:04Rahul Gandhi, seated right next to him, was seen smiling and clapping.
02:08When it was his turn to speak, the leader of opposition doubled down, saying they were fighting the same battle
02:15against fascism before declaring that Prime Minister Modi's defeat was certain.
02:21I can tell you already, with confidence, that we are going to defeat Mr Modi and we are going to
02:26get rid of Mr Modi.
02:28And you can see it, you can see it on our streets, you can see it in Delhi, you can
02:32see it in the fear that the Prime Minister, Mr Amit Shah, have.
02:36This is already a done deal.
02:39And this is strong, sharp criticism, both at home and abroad.
02:43A senior leader of Italian Prime Minister, Giorgia Melanie's ruling coalition, has criticised Filibeck for commenting on India's internal affairs.
02:52And the BGP too is not letting this issue rest.
02:55Its Stalingana unit has lodged a formal complaint with the Foreigner's Regional Registration Office against the Italian politician, seeking an
03:05investigation into his visa conditions and participation in the political event.
03:10Home Minister Amit Shah has accused Rahul Gandhi and the Congress of using an international platform to tarnish India's image,
03:18alleging that foreign political forces had been brought together to target the Prime Minister and the country.
03:43The BGP had already questioned the Congress over the guest list, alleging that several invitees had links to George Soros
03:53and his network.
03:54He wants foreign interference in Indian democracy.
03:58This proves that Rahul Gandhi is not fighting the BGP only.
04:03Rahul Gandhi is fighting the Indian state.
04:05Rahul Gandhi has become a puppet with foreign powers, which in India wants to change the regime change.
04:13For the Congress, it is global solidarity in its fight against vote-chori.
04:18But this time around, they seem to have shot themselves in the foot by allowing a foreign politician to intervene
04:24in India's internal affairs.
04:26Giorgia Report, India Today.
04:28Vote-chor, Gandhi-chor.
04:36And joining me on the show tonight, Sanjay Kumar, former Indian High Commissioner to Canada and former Indian Ambassador to
04:42Japan.
04:43Ambassador, does this Italian leader in question, Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists,
04:54he raised Rahul Gandhi's political slogan at this conference, which is called Bharat Conference.
05:01Do you see this crossing the line from international solidarity into interference in India's domestic politics?
05:12Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists,
05:38There is one Miss Bergamini, who is from Forza Italia, which is a coalition partner of Prime Minister Milne's government.
05:51She has come out very strongly against it.
05:54And she has clearly said that Mr. Filibeck had no business in interfering with India's internal affairs.
06:02According to you, Ambassador, what diplomatic message does this send when a foreign political functionary uses an Indian platform to
06:10question the state of Indian democracy?
06:16It's bad in precedence.
06:18It's immature in diplomacy.
06:23And therefore, I will not put too much emphasis on this.
06:27He is not Italian-wise in any case.
06:29So why should we even put so much emphasis on what he said?
06:33The government has flagged a possible violation of conference visa conditions.
06:37Could this escalate into a diplomatic issue between India and Italy?
06:41And what are the implications, according to you?
06:45I do not foresee it escalating into a diplomatic issue between India and Italy.
06:52It is completely between the state of India and Mr. Filibeck, who has violated the conditions of the conference visa.
07:01So could you really elaborate for our viewers, how is this really a violation of conference visa?
07:09Because, you know, in the conference and the purpose of this visa did not allow him to interfere in the
07:16domestic affairs of India.
07:18Ambassador Sanjay Kumar, can a foreign political leader openly align himself with one side of India's political contest without undermining
07:27diplomatic conventions?
07:31It is undermining of the maturity which a political leader must display.
07:40But at the same time, it is a violation of the visa conditions.
07:44You cannot go to a country and publicly interfere in the domestic affairs of the country.
07:50You know, many are asking this question also, and I perhaps as a former ambassador, you will be able to
07:56answer this.
07:57How is a speech really an interference with domestic political issues of India?
08:04No, the speech itself is not.
08:06The content of the speech is.
08:07And the content is very clear that he was trying to say that India is not a function, mature democracy,
08:17which itself is an interference in India's internal affairs.
08:24So, therefore, he may align with any political party.
08:27That's the business between the two political parties.
08:30But on a public platform in India, no foreigner can participate in disruption of the domestic affairs in India.
08:42Does this incident expose a larger trend of European political groups seeking to influence political narratives in countries like India,
08:50such as ours?
08:53I would say India is very well respected in Europe, and that's why you are seeing India, European Union, FTA,
08:59very much on the envelope.
09:01So, I will not say that Europe has got anything against India.
09:05There could be sporadic European political parties, which do not have the best interest of European Union-India relations in
09:15their mind.
09:16Last couple of questions, Ambassador.
09:19Should India consider a formal diplomatic protest?
09:25It can, but does it serve any purpose?
09:28Because he is an individual.
09:29He is not an elected leader in Italy.
09:32He doesn't represent the government of Italy.
09:35So, I don't see any point in registering a diplomatic protest.
09:38But, yes, the individual, if the violation is established, then he should be dealt with the law-governing visa violations.
09:49Okay, let me try and sum this up for our viewers, Ambassador Sanjay Kumar.
09:55What does this controversy tell us about diplomatic conventions and protocol?
10:02So, one thing is very clear that whosoever is the organizer of any such conference, in this case Bharat Summit
10:082026, has to make it clear to the foreign participants that they do not have political rights in India.
10:14And, therefore, they should not try to interfere in elected matters of the elected governance in India.
10:21India is the largest electorate in the world, 970 million voters.
10:26So, therefore, no one should question that.
10:28As far as the principles are concerned, there could be debate discussions.
10:34But, again, no foreign citizen is allowed to interfere in India's internal affairs on a valid visa, which doesn't mandate
10:44him or her to do so.
10:45All right, Ambassador Sanjay Kumar, pleasure speaking to you.
10:49Thank you for joining us and putting this story in context as far as protocol and convention are concerned.
10:56Now to the political battle.
10:57We have BJP National Spokesperson Surabhi joining us.
11:01We also have Saral Patel, Congress National Spokesperson.
11:04Saral, many would say that the Congress has set a wrong precedent.
11:09No, I think, see, if anyone has the history of pandering to anti-India leaders, that is none other than
11:16Prime Minister Modi.
11:18President Trump has been insulting India repeatedly, humiliating India, and neither Prime Minister or his government had the coverage to
11:27say a word of fight back against him.
11:29Instead, he went to his election and said, ap ki baar, Trump, sarkar, and we have committed to take our
11:36imports up to $100 billion.
11:39And just now, today, it has come to the news that Pakistan Minister Musadik Masood Malik, who says he's going
11:47to chop off Indian hands, Prime Minister Modi is rolling out a red carpet for him.
11:51And let's, for your viewers, let me break it down that there is this pattern that every time BJP is
11:59cornered, there is this bogey of anti-India, George Soros funding and whatnot.
12:04This has been happening for past 11 years.
12:07More than anything else, this is a reflection on the incompetence of Home Minister Amit Shah because he has failed
12:13to bring a single evidence to the fore till date.
12:16And if Prime Minister Modi has no faith in Amit Shah or India's agencies, then he can invite his favorite
12:23agency, ISI of Pakistan, which he invited to Pathankot, and maybe they should investigate this.
12:30This will put an end to it.
12:31Number one.
12:33Number two, quickly, you know, so why is it that Bharatiya Janata Party is so baffled?
12:39Because their hunger of power is bringing disrepute to India.
12:43And this has been happening.
12:44They are aware of this, but that is why they are deflecting the attack from this.
12:47But Saral, you have Italian leader saying what Rahul Gandhi has been saying at a platform which is Indian.
12:58My question is that when you say that your battle is internal battle, you have been very clear, right, that
13:06this is a fight for the Congress's idea of democratic institutions being compromised, right?
13:14You are trying to counter that.
13:17And here is someone coming and openly making a commentary on what will be seen as internal affairs of India.
13:26So, Maria, on the onset, let me clarify.
13:29He cannot be just described as an Italian politician.
13:32He is a secretary general of a group of parties, 36 parties, of which 13 parties are the ruling parties
13:40of their respective countries.
13:42This ruling bloc holds 134 seats in the European Parliament, four seats in the European Commission, and three seats in
13:51the European Council.
13:53So, he cannot be just brushed under as an Italian politician, number one.
13:59Number two.
14:00Okay, so he is a credible voice.
14:01According to you, he is a respectable leader of his country.
14:05Let me come to that.
14:06But why should he be given a platform to speak against India and then raise slogans against India?
14:12We neither need any certificate or endorsement from a European, American or an African.
14:18But why the world is speaking about this?
14:22Because they know what is BJP doing in the country.
14:26And India would not have to face this humiliation at the international state if it was not the hunger for
14:32power of Mr. Ramit Shah and Narendra Modi.
14:35So, if anybody deserves blame for that, it is Bharatiya Janata Party and nobody else.
14:40Okay, Surabhi.
14:45Surabhi, go ahead.
14:49Please unmute yourself.
14:52Before I get to the international component of this, Mayra, I just want to say that first and foremost, this
14:57event was convened by the government of Telangana.
15:00The first people that should have a problem with this is the Telangana people.
15:04Why did you convene an event saying that you are going to, you know, bridge Global South Corporation, have investments
15:10coming into Telangana, and give a platform to somebody to...
15:13Let's have Saral also on the screen, please. Go ahead, Surabhi.
15:17Having said that, right?
15:18And this, I've seen this happen multiple times in Congress-ruled states, where at the garb of progressive parties coming
15:24together and saving democracy, what they do is attack India and its institutions and its electoral integrity.
15:30So, the first question needs to go there.
15:31Second, you dare to do this from a state where you are in power, then you call vote chori.
15:35Did that same vote chori, are you also saying that Revant Reddy has won through vote chori?
15:40Some questions that I never get answers to.
15:41Now, the international angle and the component that I want to bring to you, the Howdy Modi event that is
15:46referenced constantly by the Congress Party was a diaspora event, not a government-funded, none of that.
15:52It was a diaspora event.
15:54Having said that, today, the person in question, the Italian gentleman, now you're not able to, you know, find resonance
16:00about your vote chori campaign amongst the people of India, amongst the villagers of India, of the dwellers of India.
16:06Therefore, you're bringing in reinforcement from European nations, particularly Italy, that's suspicious and it raises a lot of questions.
16:12But this particular gentleman has been blacklisted by another country for having similar interference in their own issues.
16:18Now, what is the necessity for Rahul Gandhi to sit and laugh?
16:22You say, oh, Amit Shah should do something about it, Prime Minister Modi should do something about it.
16:26What was Rahul Gandhi's excuse to sit and laugh when somebody is saying the slogans?
16:32He was happy.
16:34So, the primary concern that the BJP now has is, yes, I'm asking a question, respond to that and then
16:41you can continue.
16:43The primary concern that the BJP has is that why Rahul Gandhi smiled when he said so.
16:48Is that the concern?
16:50It's not the, no, it's very, it's reductive to say that that is the only concern.
16:55Of course, it adds to it.
16:56People watch every single move of a public representative.
17:00If you're clapping and smiling when somebody is degrading, berating, interfering, we're not saying, let him say BJP is bad,
17:08let him say whatever he wants to.
17:09But coming and saying that the elections that have given a Rewan Tretti, that have given a Prime Minister Modi
17:14is compromised.
17:15When we live in a world, acknowledge that we live in a world where regime change is being called from
17:20within the country as well as outside.
17:22If we're not living in silos, you may want to think that these are conspiracy theories, but any student of
17:29international politics will tell you that this is beyond conspiracy and this is textbook cases of interference.
17:34But Surabhi, help us understand, I believe a number of visas were cancelled.
17:40I believe a number of visas for this summit were cancelled and of course we know that it's the sovereign
17:47discretion of any country.
17:48They can grant visas, they can cancel visas.
17:51In this case, the government of India had cancelled visas.
17:54Why was it granted to Philly Beck?
17:57I mean, to assume that, you know, somebody will make a certain statement or not, that is not, we cannot
18:04anticipate it.
18:05But surely after this statement, today is something that we will keep in mind.
18:09But the organizers need to be questioned as well.
18:12If Rahul Gandhi had stood up, if you are making the argument that his visa should have been cancelled,
18:16it was not in our control what he says or doesn't say, you should not have clapped.
18:21You should have stood up and said, listen, that's all right.
18:23I understand that you can, you know, engagement farm through these ways.
18:28But let's talk about this, let's talk about the topic at hand today.
18:31And that topic was about Telangana, was about investments in Telangana, was about technology.
18:35Yes, that's a point well taken, Saral.
18:37That's a point well taken, you know.
18:39You have been saying that what was said by Prashant Bhushan or, that was not in sync with what the
18:48Congress feels.
18:48That when it is about regime change, that also has to be democratic process through which India goes through.
18:55We believe in democracy, we are an institute, we believe in institutions.
19:00And here is someone coming and mocking in front of leader of opposition, the entire opposition senior leader sitting there.
19:08Do you think the reaction could have been different?
19:12Maria, let me on set answer three questions, counter three claims made by my dear friend from the BJP.
19:20She says, you know, they are making the vote chori claim at a conference that is organized by the government,
19:27which has come to power through the same ballot.
19:29Let us first understand that the entire episode of vote chori, the evidence that we have presented, and these are
19:36not just the claims.
19:37Every single claim we have made has been laid bare with the evidence.
19:41And we have asked 48 more questions today through Supreme Court, happened after 2024 and revolve around 2024 elections.
19:51And elections after that, the government of Karnataka was elected in 2023.
19:55So my friend should understand that, number one.
19:58Number two, Bharti Ajanta Party has been raising this bogey for past 11 years.
20:03And Rahul Gandhi has openly challenged Prime Minister to come on open debate.
20:07And I say this on behalf of Rahul Gandhi and my party.
20:10I would be very happy, Maria, if that debate were to take place on your channel, on your platform, and
20:16you were the moderator.
20:18Or Mr. Puri was the moderator.
20:20Please get the Prime Minister's confirmation.
20:22Within 15 minutes, Rahul Gandhi will agree and let's have an open debate for the benefit of your viewers and
20:27the people of the country.
20:29But the Prime Minister and the Bharti Ajanta Party are running away from that debate because they know that their
20:35incompetence and their claims and life will be exposed.
20:36But sir, I'll respond to the question that I asked.
20:38Could the reaction have been different?
20:40Here is an outsider making comments of this nature.
20:44Of course, this is a slogan which the Congress Party raises.
20:47Could the reaction have been different?
20:49Leader of Opposition is a constitution body.
20:52He is a constitution office holder.
20:55My friend Surbhi said that, you know, before granting visa, they could not have known what he was going to
21:01say.
21:02So, again, Rahul Gandhi or Congress Party is neither who they are.
21:06So, fine enough.
21:06That's a fair point.
21:07So, we did not know what speech he was going to make.
21:09That you also did not know whether he will be saying so or not.
21:13Sorry, I couldn't hear your question.
21:15So, Saral here is saying, Surbhi, that just as the government did not know whether he will be saying such
21:22a thing at a conference, Saral is also saying that they did not know that he would raise a slogan
21:29at the conference.
21:31Well, see, look, Myra, when a decision is made on who to grant visa to or not, a study is
21:38done as per the intelligence available and so on and so forth.
21:41Now, there is good reason as to whether a visa is granted or not.
21:45Like you rightly said, it's the sovereign right.
21:47And therefore, that decision is made.
21:49Now, as an organizer, you should also be thinking what you're encouraging, what conversation you're having.
21:54If you watch that entire clip, he comes to that specific point and Rahul Gandhi reacts the way he did.
21:59If he was so truly unaware, why are you reacting and you're defending it?
22:04It's not just Rahul Gandhi's reaction of laughing and clapping.
22:07It's also defense that has happened.
22:09This argument of this, you know, logical fallacy that they're trying to trap on, which is that, yeah, everybody can
22:14speak.
22:14This is the right issue.
22:15People should speak on it.
22:16But yeah, it's not our problem because we didn't know he was going to talk about it.
22:20Yet they're clapping for it.
22:21Like there's no logic in this, right?
22:23And second, you have been questioning, you have been talking about Votchori regularly.
22:29Even before the, you know, if it was not named as Votchori, EVM was a question that was always discussed
22:34even during the 2024 prior to that also.
22:37Now, the point here is that what was your intention of this conference?
22:41What was your intention of having an Italian person?
22:43And why did you tolerate laugh and clap when somebody is berating the institution in the country of India?
22:49We really appreciate your time.
22:51I'm sure there are several chapters in this story that are still to unfold because of the investigation which has
22:57started and the FIR lodged.
22:58That's all from me on this edition of Newstrap.
23:01Thanks a lot for watching.

Recommended