• 5 minutes ago
Transcript
00:00The question will come down to what 12 teams deserve to be in the college football playoff.
00:06My big question is, why do we need a committee to pick these 12 teams?
00:12Why not have a metric like we used to?
00:15I can't believe I'm sitting here and saying that we're kind of yearning for the days of the BCS.
00:22But we need a formula.
00:24I don't want 12 dudes picking a beauty contest.
00:28I want a metric like every other sport has.
00:31The National Football League doesn't have a committee picking the teams to make the playoffs.
00:36NBA doesn't.
00:38World Series is not determined by a committee of what teams make it to the postseason.
00:44Why do we have a committee?
00:46Why is there a television show on Tuesdays on a committee's decision on what 12 teams make it to the
00:54college football playoff?
00:56How did we get here?
00:58Is it just because the networks want to control what brands make it to the television sets for this 12
01:04-team tournament?
01:05Because that's all it is to me.
01:07I'm not telling you that the teams that will go and play in this tournament aren't deserving to go in.
01:13But what about the outlier teams that have the opportunity to go in?
01:16What's your metric?
01:17I mean, for me, the greatest thing about the National Football League is you play yourself into the tournament.
01:25In college football, you have to impress people to play yourself into the college tournament.
01:31I mean, if you've got two, nine, and three football teams, and you've got two teams that are a three
01:38-loss team, how do you determine who goes in and plays in the college championship?
01:43Do you go by brand?
01:44Do you go by strength of schedule?
01:46Let's be candid here.
01:48ESPN owns the college football playoff.
01:51Do you think they're going to put an outlier team that no one watches, and they're going to put them
01:57in that college playoff?
01:58Absolutely not.
01:59They want the brands.
02:01They don't want the Boise States in the semifinals.
02:05They don't want them moving forward.
02:07That is just a gimme when you put those other teams in.
02:10And by the way, when you put teams in to the college football playoff that aren't worked the same way
02:16that the other teams are when it comes to the metric on how you pick them, it's a jaded system.
02:22Hey, I've got to put Boise State in because why?
02:25I feel sorry for them because they're not at the same level as, say, a Texas or a Tennessee.
02:32Hey, welcome to capitalism here.
02:34Welcome to the real world.
02:36Not everybody's set up to play for the national title.
02:38There's probably six teams that truly have a shot that play for the national title.
02:45The rest of this stuff is theater.
02:48And when you have a committee that's picking this, I have no idea how we got here.
02:52You know, back in the day when I got these championship rings, okay, there used to be a scenario where,
02:59guess what?
03:00You played in the Orange Bowl.
03:01You played in the Rose Bowl.
03:03You played in the Fiesta Bowl.
03:04And you played in the Cotton Bowl.
03:06And you had sports writers that picked who they thought was the best team in the country.
03:12Okay?
03:13At least you played yourself into the recognition of what team did you think, using the eyeball test, that you
03:20thought was the best team in the country.
03:23I actually like that system because the bowl games mattered.
03:26You played in the Cotton Bowl.
03:28You played in the Rose Bowl.
03:29You played in the Orange Bowl.
03:30It mattered.
03:31Now, you have to sit in front of a committee each and every single week.
03:35And you've got to determine how well you look.
03:38Miami didn't look that hot against Duke this past week.
03:41You know what?
03:42People are looking at that metric going, you know, well, maybe Miami didn't play that well because of Malachi Toney.
03:48Let's put that factor in.
03:49Hey, that's not how you should be picking a national champion.
03:54You should play yourself in to the 12-team tournament by some metric.
03:59We've got to figure out how to get away from this committee.
04:02But you know what will never happen?
04:04ESPN and Disney will never, ever let go of that stranglehold of that college football playoff.
04:12It is a gigantic moneymaker.
04:14It's a gigantic way for them to be able to promote all of their shows and all of their properties
04:21that they have.
04:22Think about this and how when Chris Fowler says, we have no real say in what 12 teams.
04:29Well, let me ask you this.
04:30If Disney has the SEC and the ACC and they have them and their television rights, why in God's name
04:39would ESPN want to promote a team that is broadcast on the Fox network like the Big Ten teams?
04:46Kurt Cignetti's right.
04:48You take a look at the SEC teams.
04:50Now, hey, I'm an SEC guy.
04:52I'm not a Big Ten guy.
04:53But the metric is flawed because we have a committee.
04:59Committees should never be picking what teams win a national championship.
05:05Teams should never be put into a tournament based on what we're looking at with what they think that metric
05:12looks like.
05:12Is it strength of schedule?
05:14Is it how they look at whether or not you're looking at tough losses?
05:17Like I said, Kurt Cignetti's complaining about the fact that they ended up getting beat by Ohio State by a
05:23tap of the toe.
05:25That's where they got beat.
05:26We got to fix this.

Recommended