- 5 minutes ago
«اروپا تودی»؛ نشست سهجانبه تاریخی شی، ترامپ و پوتین
سران چین، روسیه و آمریکا قرار است درباره خلع سلاح هستهای و جنگ ایران، نه اوکراین، گفتوگو کنند. با منتقد کرملین بیل براودر و نیز درباره نشست ائتلاف مایل در برلین با ایگناسی نیمچیتسکی، معاون وزیر خارجه لهستان صحبت میکنیم.
لب بیشتر : http://parsi.euronews.com/2026/11/19/europe-today-xi-trump-and-putin-together-in-a-historic-trilateral-meeting
مشترک شوید: یورونیوز به یازده زبان دیگر در دسترس شماست
سران چین، روسیه و آمریکا قرار است درباره خلع سلاح هستهای و جنگ ایران، نه اوکراین، گفتوگو کنند. با منتقد کرملین بیل براودر و نیز درباره نشست ائتلاف مایل در برلین با ایگناسی نیمچیتسکی، معاون وزیر خارجه لهستان صحبت میکنیم.
لب بیشتر : http://parsi.euronews.com/2026/11/19/europe-today-xi-trump-and-putin-together-in-a-historic-trilateral-meeting
مشترک شوید: یورونیوز به یازده زبان دیگر در دسترس شماست
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:14good morning it's eight o'clock Thursday November 19th you're watching Euronews and this is Europe
00:22today our top stories three powerful world leaders Xi Jinping Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump have
00:29come together for a historic trilateral at the APEC summit in the Chinese city of Shenzhen minutes
00:35ago that's of state of China Russia and the US are expected to discuss denuclearization and the
00:42Iran war but not Ukraine just hours after the summit Trump Trump's envoys Jared Kushner and
00:48Steve Whitcoff will be in Berlin for a meeting of the coalition of the willing with senior officials
00:53from Ukraine and its top European allies as well as NATO and the EU the European Commission has
01:01proposed issuing an additional 45 billion euro support loan to Ukraine backed by joint debt as
01:07the country fights to keep its economy afloat amid relentless Russian airstrikes the loan was unveiled
01:13by commission president Ursula von der Leyen and envisages 20 billion euros for financial aid and
01:1925 billion euros for weapons purchases such as drones missiles and urgently needed air defense
01:26interceptors and the European Central Bank compared the AI boom with the dot-com bubble a wave of large
01:33public offerings could signal late cycle exuberance as tech giants pile on debt leaving markets exposed to
01:40an abrupt sell-off the ECP warned in its biannual financial stability review AI optimism has helped the
01:48economy but now has itself become an elevated risk US tech giants are borrowing at a record pace
01:54increasingly in euros leaving European investors more exposed welcome to the program I'm Stefan Grobe
02:02Donald Trump Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin sitting around the same table marks an extraordinary moment
02:09in global diplomacy bringing together the leaders of the world's three major nuclear powers amid war in
02:16Ukraine tensions over Iran and an increasingly fragile international order for Europe the stakes could
02:22hardly be higher the summit raises uncomfortable questions for Kiev and European capitals could
02:29Donald Trump and Xi Jinping strike understandings with Vladimir Putin that leave Europe and Ukraine paying the
02:36price today's unprecedented trilateral summit in Shenzhen could also reshape the global balance of power
02:43Europe or is it just a photo op for three men with very different ambitions
02:49let's bring in Sasha Vakulina into the conversation our Ukraine correspondent good morning Sasha morning
02:54Stefan now Sasha before we get into this I want to show you a video from Shenzhen the moment that
03:02Donald Trump
03:03greets Vladimir Putin that is obviously before the trilateral they had a bilateral chat and this is what happened take
03:11a look
03:12who is he he's my friend
03:20yeah who is he obviously a light remark and then he is my friend could you imagine uh Ronald Reagan
03:29and
03:29Richard Nixon and Dwight Eisenhower saying this to a Russian leader you know I actually don't think even
03:35Russian leader Vladimir Putin expected this sort of a warm welcome by Donald Trump
03:41in China and clearly even those couple of seconds that we have seen gives they give Putin quite a
03:47big diplomatic you can call it a photo op but at the end of the day what we see is
03:52that indeed
03:53Russia's president five years into full-scale invasion of Ukraine into the largest and the
03:59most serious war in Europe ever since the world war ii is being greeted with a smile and being
04:04called a friend by the US president Stefan this is a guy who has blood on his hands Vladimir Putin
04:09right and the leader of the free world greets him with he is my friend I know it's Trump and
04:15we've been
04:16you know we've heard a lot of things coming out of Donald Trump's mouth but this is quite um extraordinary
04:21so let's talk about that trilateral meeting here historic or not it's at least the first
04:27the first meeting of its kind it is supposed to last less than an hour
04:33is that still does that still justify the label historic well it does no I would say that it definitely
04:39justifies to be called historic for sure because this is a huge deal now these three have been meeting
04:44until now also in bilateral formats and of course for them this isn't interesting because three of them are coming
04:50into this meeting with completely different priorities now but if we have to choose uh the
04:57biggest winner in this trilateral and in all these pictures that we have been seeing is indeed Vladimir
05:02Putin I'll tell you what five years into the full-scale invasion Putin is officially out of any sort of
05:09diplomatic isolation because this is what happened when Russia started full-scale invasion of Ukraine
05:14Putin was not invited anymore to any sort of these meetings now he is moreover he is sitting there
05:19at the summit with the leaders of two of the world's largest economists Stefan what is it if
05:24not the the comeback to the world to the global diplomatic scene now then of course we go into the
05:31substance are there going to be any statements any substance any official decisions even after the three
05:38of them meet that I really don't think so because they are coming with very different priorities
05:43now Xi Jinping clearly wants to to focus more on his relation China relations with the US Trump wants
05:49to talk Iran and the whole denuclearization issue Putin wants to talk Ukraine and Europe's security
05:55architecture three very different menus don't think they're going to discuss any of that but at the end
06:01of the day the meeting did take place you know I I totally agree we have three powerful men here
06:06but but each of
06:07them comes you know with a very big different sort of baggage Donald Trump just coming out of the major
06:18electoral shellacking that was certainly historic so he is weakened domestic and while we're talking here we
06:26have pictures from Chen Chen the bilateral between Donald Trump on the left as speaking to the Chinese
06:34president sitting in front of him so Donald Trump weakened domestically and what about Vladimir Putin I
06:40mean he just suffered the loss of one of his pet projects the loss of the the Crimean Bridge and
06:48it's only the
06:49Chinese president who can basically sit back and see you know how they're interacting he's the only one
06:56who is you know really powerful and not only on paper whereas Trump and Putin come here a little wounded
07:03he's in a very good position when it comes to Xi Jinping he's a real host you know he's hosting
07:08both Donald Trump and Putin also being in a much better stronger position just to add very briefly
07:14overnight today Ukrainian forces again struck Crimean Bridge specifically targeting the remaining rail
07:22sections Stefan so we have to wait a couple of hours to see to assess that damage to indeed Putin's
07:28most
07:29prized site in Russia but to both of them at the same time this meeting brings at least some sort
07:35of a victory when it comes to the international arena you know after the midterm elections Donald
07:40Trump wants to come and to say that you know he did manage to have the conversation with Xi he
07:46did manage
07:46probably to to rearrange some bilateral trade relations with China something that he's very much focused on
07:53Iran of course and you know when it comes to Ukraine something that Putin is going to talk about
07:59is Trump wants to get it done with as soon as possible and not to go much into the details
08:06which
08:06of course Moscow presents as the most maximalist demands but interestingly something this is something
08:11that Xi does not want to go into at all over these five years the leader of China never expressed
08:16any
08:17sort of willingness of getting anywhere close to Russia's war into Ukraine so what is Putin trying to achieve
08:23here what would be a successful outcome for the master of the Kremlin I mean you mentioned the the
08:30diplomatic recognition and all that but in in very concrete terms and I said the meeting is scheduled
08:35to last you know less than an hour and it's not like three pals you know coming to a bar
08:39having a beer
08:39or something there is there's translation so these 60 minutes are reduced to much much less what can you
08:45actually achieve and what again what is Putin's most important you know story I think Putin has already
08:53achieved it as we're speaking now we don't need to really hear the statements even after the
08:58meeting it has happened he has already achieved what he wanted he is there he is meeting the two
09:03most powerful world leaders arguably we also mentioned of course the two of the world's largest
09:08economies he already had his bilateral with Trump and we saw the beginning and the very warm greeting
09:12with the US president Putin's aid Yuri Ushakov also commented on some of the details already and he said that
09:18Putin is quote in excellent mood after he met Trump Ushakov also said that the war in Ukraine Moscow's
09:25invasion of Ukraine was the main topic according to the Kremlin and he also mentioned that the meeting
09:30lasted between 35 to 40 minutes but that's it Putin has already won in this case another thing which of
09:37course we hear a lot about these days is one of those lines that the Kremlin itself is pushing a
09:45lot is how it is
09:46seen in Moscow as sort of Yalta 2.0 and for this the pictures are there we just saw them
09:52we saw the bilateral
09:53meetings we're about to see uh the the trilateral would you would you go that far in saying that this
10:00summit meeting is for Putin mainly for domestic consumption no it's also for the European consumption
10:07it's also him showing to Europe look I don't need you because he we know that he doesn't want Europe
10:12anywhere near any sort of Ukraine negotiations nothing he just disregards Europe all together
10:17and this is what he's showing to the rest of the world specifically to the European Union and
10:21Ukraine allies but I'm going to just quickly bring you back on the Yalta 2.0 issue because you know
10:27yesterday evening on Euronews brand new Euronews tonight show we've heard from the
10:31member of the European parliament Sakis Arnautoglu who commented on whether we can actually make that
10:37comparison with Yalta 2.0 which we are now seeing a lot around I want to come back to the
10:43trilateral
10:44talks we're expecting tomorrow uh Putin Chi and Trump to hold these official talks um you know some
10:53people are drawing a parallelism with the Yalta conference doesn't have anything to do why is that
10:58because 1945 I mean Yalta uh it was uh you know countries back then that they won the war uh
11:05and uh there was they had a common goal just to improve the world now we have a completely different
11:12uh situation where we have three powers with a lot of uh you know trouble with each other so they
11:18try
11:18to find some kind of a common solution in something but they don't even they don't know what exactly
11:23it's going to be so it's a first step I think it's going to be welcoming if it is for
11:28uh the good of
11:29uh the world for the for the global economy for the global trade and for peaceful uh let's say results
11:37in the coming months yeah so that was the scene from last night's um show uh Europe tonight
11:45you talked about the Yalta comparison but what is your point on this I think this is something that
11:51works very well for the Kremlin whether this is the case not really because again when we talk about
11:56the biggest war in Europe since the world war two Europe is not represented here and this is
11:59deliberate because you know the only two sides who do want Europe to be represented actually
12:04Europe and Ukraine it took these two sides great effort and great time to convince Washington to
12:11support the idea of the Europeans participating and being active now it seems like the US administration
12:17warmed up to this idea but Russia still rejecting it and this is not still happening so
12:21it's and you know what Putin wants uh is exactly this is to be able to discuss Ukraine and Europe
12:29it's
12:29not about Ukraine only with the US and without Europe well the the Yalta comparison is a little um
12:35difficult because we had at the time you know Harry Truman uh Joseph Stalin and Winston Churchill who was
12:41the weakest of the three and he was so frustrated after the weekend because he realized that his opinion didn't
12:48matter and Washington and Moscow you know did their own thing if we compare this to today who would be
12:54that Winston Churchill the weak link who would be the most frustrated that's going to be Europe Stefan
13:00they because they're not even represented there at this stage you know in these negotiations as you
13:05know there are these two separate tracks we have been talking about it all week you know two separate
13:09tracks Europe is not even allowed there and when you see the conversations and happening
13:13even they did the way the leaders were greeted in China by Xi Jinping you can see that he also
13:20is
13:20not much interested in in having Europe there at the table we uh you could you know at the same
13:26time
13:26the Europeans are participating late today in the uh in the coalition of the building in the larger format
13:30Berlin yeah but at the same time it's a very tricky it's a very tricky when you say tricky what
13:38does Europe um
13:40need to fear from the meeting in Shenzhen especially especially Ukraine and its its top European allies to be
13:48are Europeans looking at this like uh the mouse is looking at the snake and and we we don't know
13:54what's
13:55what's coming out of it is is there some concrete danger for Europe uh concrete danger is already there
14:01and it already happened you're already not there when the talk is taking place between the world's largest
14:06economies you're already not there and when the conversations and the negotiations are taking place with
14:11Russia that started the largest war in Europe you are not there so I think the worst has already happened
14:16in this
14:16case you know and as about whether the concrete steps will be there listen no matter what is going to
14:21be discussed nowadays
14:23in China I don't think the consequences will be so concrete when it comes to the war in Ukraine only
14:28I'm not going to go it here into trade when it comes to geopolitics and Europe security architecture because
14:33Donald Trump already exited any sort of support for Ukraine ever since he's back in the White House
14:39so it's the Europeans were taking the uh everything and the financing and all the support and the military
14:44support so what is it that you know what what can go worse there are few moments here the US
14:49can't stop
14:49sharing intel with Ukraine which will be a very damaging step uh and also the Starlink issue of
14:56course the connection which is very important but interesting because when the uh the recent hits
15:01on the Crimea bridge uh happened already with the Starlink connection being restricted um
15:08Donald Trump and his administration have been unpredictable when it comes to Ukraine
15:12and um sided one day with Ukraine um another day with rather with Moscow what is the situation now I
15:21mean there have been signs very recently over the past days that um um Trump is is getting fed up
15:28with
15:29Ukraine and and the the administration has criticized the attack on the bridge for example
15:34why not criticizing the daily attacks on civilian targets uh all across Ukraine do you think now
15:41that this this trilateral is is proof that Trump is now definitely siding with Moscow in this uh conflict
15:49I think Trump is siding with himself in this conflict honestly he just wants to get to get done with
15:54to be
15:54done with it and to do it as quickly as possible you remember even during the election campaign he was
16:00saying that he can get this done with within 24 hours and it went into a few days 100 days
16:04and here
16:05we are years later so you see what I mean uh he just wants to get it done with because
16:11it doesn't give him
16:11a good look still now not to have this war over and he said that it's going to be an
16:17easy task all right
16:18Sasha Vakulina great conversation thank you so much for now meanwhile the EU's energy commissioner
16:24Dan Juergensen has warned that Europe is heading into yet another difficult winter as a result of
16:30the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz on Wednesday he announced the political agreement to speed up the
16:35permitting of the for the rollout of renewables and electricity infrastructure arguing that Europe
16:41cannot afford to remain trapped by the geopolitical volatility of fossil fuels he spoke to our editor
16:48Maria Tadeo take a listen first of all some are drawing parallels between this trilateral meeting
16:55between Trump Putin and so this is about making sure that we have the infrastructure to actually
17:02electrify our societies to to get the renewable energy into our systems so that we can drive our
17:08cars on electricity we can have heat pumps and so forth and today that is probably the biggest
17:13bottleneck we have with regards to this electrification and one of the reasons is that
17:17the permitting times are way too long today it easily takes five years even a decade to get a permit
17:22now we're fundamentally slashing these times so that in the future in most projects it'll be six months
17:29that's a big difference how do you make that happen but ultimately what is this going to mean
17:33for energy bills this is what our audience really cares about how does that reflect into energy bills and
17:38cost yeah so this is totally necessary for us to bring down prices because the main way of bringing
17:45down prices is to deploy more renewables because renewables are more cheap than the fossil alternative
17:49double down on renewals double down on renewables but double down also on energy efficiency because
17:54electrification is a way to become more efficient in the way we use energy so for those two reasons
17:59that will bring down prices but the third reason is just as important but sometimes overlooked
18:04instead of being 27 member states we are actually trying to create one energy union and because we're
18:10doing that we are connected with with cables and infrastructure interconnectors and so forth we're
18:14actually already now saving more than 30 billion euros every year on our energy bills because we are as
18:20connected as we are but the potential is much much bigger and then in the future because of this
18:24legislation that will happen so we'll be able to save more money when it comes to fossil fuels however there
18:30is still a very volatile situation in the middle east what is your assessment around the strait of
18:35her moves and when are we going to see oil prices come down if at all so we don't even
18:40know if they
18:40will come down what we do know is that it's a very unstable winter that we are that we are
18:46going into we
18:47also know that even if there's a normalization of the situation it'll take months for for the prices to
18:54normalize so we probably have to prepare or not probably we unfortunately for sure have to prepare
18:59for difficult winter do whatever we can to bring down prices become more energy efficient support
19:05member states in subsidizing and helping citizens to electrify and replace the gas and oil broiler
19:12with a heat pump replace the combustion engine car with a electric vehicle insulate houses new windows
19:19all of these things that can be done and by the way fortunately is being done for thousands and
19:24thousands and thousands of homes in europe right now but just on this point as a final question
19:28the bills we talk about something very short term the member states are singing they cannot and will
19:34not cut electricity taxes because simply they do not have a budget situation that allows for it
19:39what is the plan b then we urge member states to cut electricity bills by lowering the tax on electricity
19:44because right now too many member states they're actually taxing electricity more than they're
19:49taxing gas it's the exact opposite of what we what we want
19:55maria tadeo in a conversation with eu energy commissioner dan jorgensen migration is once again
20:02testing europe's political unity and its commitment to human rights five eu countries have announced plans
20:08to send rejected asylum seekers to a return hub in rwanda signaling a major shift
20:14towards outsourcing migration control beyond europe's borders supporters say tougher measures
20:20are essential to regain control and deter irregular arrivals critics warn of legal challenges human
20:27rights violations and a dangerous erosion of europe's values so is europe finally getting tough on
20:33migration or is it crossing a line it should never cross that was the topic and our debate showed the
20:39ring
20:39this week both contenders fought for their arguments take a listen i'm also wondering lena what makes you
20:47sure that rwanda rwanda's dictatorship de facto will send these people home will create in rwanda also job
20:55opportunities they will take care of their families they will protect these people we have no evidence on
21:01that opposite we have evidence from also from trans uh trump's administration that it didn't work
21:08that the bread the bread of the human rights violations in uh in this country is serious
21:15and for me also as a paul you know i'm polish and from my historical memory i have terrible terrible
21:23memories on camps really when i hear camps that people by force you think these are deportation camps
21:30because the word the word really matters these people don't want to go to rwanda they will not be
21:35willing to go to rwanda they will be by force illegally in my opinion sent to rwanda and kept that
21:43in albania
21:45but do you have access to albanian return hub even there is human rights organizations well robert
21:57well there is not functioning look at looking at the policies you know by just throwing in you know
22:02trump a bit there and russia a bit there and camp emotionally there's a history in europe that does
22:07not solve problems and believe me i've been investing time in that field exactly because i don't want to
22:13do want us to do it right but without overloading the debate with what unbalanced comparisons i would
22:22say well and i really really appreciate your stance on really pointing the fingers on the respect for
22:28human rights because this is what makes us humans this is what makes us europeans but you changed your
22:33mind you you went the extreme right way no i didn't voted with you extreme right way we put forward
22:39an
22:40epp proposal and we had invited you all the way long to be part of it you for whatever reason
22:46and
22:47i respect that decided not to be part of it because we didn't want to participate in human rights violation
22:52standards not all the policies that you're just not fine with are far right honestly
23:00that was part of your news debate show the ring pakistan's deputy prime minister and foreign
23:06minister mohammed ishaq dar described to your news in a wide-ranging interview in islamabad how his
23:12government took the initiative in the peace mediations between the united states and iran in the early
23:18phases of the war in a new edition of our world conversation interview program dar told our colleague
23:26jane witherspoon that the first negotiations took no less than 21 hours without breaks ultimately resulting
23:33in the islamabad memorandum of understanding signed in june by the us and iran here is a sneak peek
23:41to what extent you know is your country trying to reduce those tensions between iran and the us we
23:49see the results or we hear about as things are progressing what is happening behind closed doors
23:55and what are the major challenges with that well you see the the day one of the war i was
23:59traveling
23:59is about 28th of february yes and uh it was early morning uh in the middle east we were the
24:05first one
24:06to condemn uh israel for that attack and the second thing i did is called uh for mr raxi that
24:14please
24:14exercise the strain and don't react because i was i was wondering that they might react to uh to the
24:21gulf
24:21countries yes which unfortunately did come up uh as true and uh this uh you know entire process began
24:31on the day yes uh you know it ended up uh through uh the efforts of prime minister uh field
24:39marshal
24:39sayidas muneer uh foreign office you know we all worked hard uh to bring them on the table so the
24:46condition was that pakistan must be present if direct talks they shook hand they sat on the same
24:52you know table and pakistan had to be there as represented pakistan with field marshal and the
24:58national security advisor so uh you see uh if you're very close to stitching the deal it was 21 hours
25:05marathon session with no real breaks only consultative breaks yes short breaks and after fifth round i was
25:13sure that in the sixth round we have we have covered so much uh of the mileage and we reached
25:19a point
25:20but obviously every sovereign country has its own plans and its own preference uh one party was very
25:27keen to go back to the capital uh consult to the leadership and then come back and restart so again
25:35we
25:35didn't give up uh and we came up with uh you know 18th of so islamabad talks 10th 11th april
25:42ended up
25:43on 18th of june signing off islamabad memorandum understanding
25:49that was pakistan's deputy prime minister muhammad ishak dar in a conversation with jane witherspoon
25:57when we come back in half an hour we have more guests and we will be talking about the summit
26:02in
26:02china and hopefully sasha will have real pictures we were waiting for them all morning but we will
26:08continue the conversation and indeed the trilateral meeting this most anticipated moment must have
26:14been done already an hour ago but they seem to be late maybe there is something we're going to be
26:18seeing unusual in that meeting still stephan right and sasha i look forward to seeing you again on the
26:24the set here in half an hour that's it for now i'm stefan grober we'll be back stay with us
26:58so
27:03so
27:04so
27:04so
Comments