• 2 hours ago
Eight people blind taste test seven popular boxed brownie brands to find out which one is best. Ranging from elementary kids and Gen Z to a boomer, world traveler, athlete, pastry chef, food critic, and college student, each brings a different palate. From Betty Crocker and Duncan Hines to Pillsbury, Trader Joe’s, and more, which brands will they love–and which will they be leaving in the box?
Transcript
00:02We've gathered eight people to taste some of the top brands of boxed brownie mix.
00:09All items were made according to the instructions. First up, Duncan Hines.
00:16Smells pretty nice.
00:18This looks good.
00:19We see some cakey on the bottom, a little fudging gooeyness on the inside.
00:24It's what I would expect.
00:26I'm going to bite in and see what we got here.
00:27Yeah, my finger's a little.
00:29Oh, yeah.
00:30Vanilla's coming through.
00:31I'm not gagging over it.
00:33It's really, really yummy.
00:36At first glance, this is not the brownie that I was looking for.
00:40Once I poked my fork inside, it doesn't crumble.
00:43Like, if you see the cross-section here, it's amazing.
00:46It's beautifully moist, and it's not too sweet.
00:48I don't know how I'm going to finish the other brownies.
00:51This is pretty good so far.
00:53It's looking a little pale.
00:54And then I tasted it, and it tasted exactly how it looks, if you know what I mean.
00:58It's just very pale, very one-flavor note, very spongy.
01:04But I feel like I've definitely made something like this before when I was first ever making brownies.
01:08And then it progressed from here.
01:10It was okay.
01:11So looking at this brownie, it's darker in the center, which I like.
01:16I like a gooey moment in the center and a crackly crumble on top.
01:20But I was surprised when I tasted it.
01:23It was very understated.
01:25It was not chocolate-forward, as I would have expected from the smell.
01:29There was kind of a lack of complexity.
01:30It was a really one-note flavor throughout.
01:33It was okay.
01:34It's pretty spongy and stuff.
01:37Doesn't break.
01:38I like that.
01:39So it's pretty good.
01:40The height of this brownie is pretty baller.
01:43Gives you a lot to enjoy.
01:45I think the flint on top is interesting.
01:47Love that texture.
01:49But the inside, you get kind of a dryness on the bottom, fudgy in the middle.
01:53I also get a lot of vanilla.
01:55I don't really get a lot of chocolate.
01:56For me, it needs to be intense in that chocolate delivery to be a brownie.
02:01I don't like the color of it.
02:02It doesn't look like a brownie.
02:04It doesn't taste chocolatey.
02:06I would not buy this.
02:07No thank you.
02:08I liked it a little better than I thought it was, but it still definitely wasn't my favorite.
02:12It kind of tasted like vanilla, but brown.
02:16I would eat this if I was given it, but I wouldn't seek this out.
02:20This checked all the boxes.
02:22I mean, it's moist.
02:23It's chocolatey.
02:24It's not cakey.
02:24It's not crumbly.
02:25It's just not blowing me away.
02:28It looks like we found a sweet spot for Poe, but let's see how the rest of the panel
02:33rates their first brownie of the day.
02:35One out of ten.
02:57Two crumbly.
02:59So much chocolate.
03:01Moving down the aisle, we have another household staple.
03:04Pillsbury Dark Chocolate.
03:06but I'm gonna get into it and see what's...
03:07I don't really like the texture.
03:10I love how moist it is.
03:11I want a glass of milk.
03:13I love it!
03:15Okay, this is dangerous.
03:16This is the kind of brownie where I tell myself
03:18I'm gonna have one, I end up with an empty box.
03:21This is very good.
03:22It's fudgy, it falls apart easily,
03:25it just doesn't have that aroma that I'm looking for.
03:27But overall, this is a really good brownie.
03:30Initial thoughts when I first looked at it.
03:32Better than the last one.
03:33I like the darkness and then this crumble on top
03:36is exactly what I like.
03:38This tastes like when I was getting used to making brownies
03:41for my dad and this was like the next tier.
03:44This is better than the last one that I had.
03:45This brownie is really fudgy.
03:48It smells delicious, very chocolatey,
03:50but when I picked it up, it fell apart.
03:52So I wish there was a little bit more integrity
03:55to the structure, but I enjoyed the rich, soft texture
03:59and how chocolatey it is.
04:01It's a nice chocolatey smell to it.
04:03I like how it's moist.
04:04It doesn't taste the way chocolate should taste.
04:07I would not normally eat this unless I was starving.
04:10So again, no thank you.
04:12When I looked at it, I immediately knew that I was going to like this one
04:16better than the last one, but to me it had like the perfect texture,
04:21like really gooey.
04:22And I do wish it was a little bit more chocolatey.
04:24I really liked this one, especially that gooey texture was so good.
04:28It was exactly what I was expecting, crumbly on the outside.
04:33I don't really like that, but it's chocolate.
04:38And when I ate it, it's like, you see, it's really mushy, right?
04:42So I really like it.
04:43It's actually what I was expecting again.
04:46Well, at first glance, I love it.
04:48Color looks good.
04:50I also love the fact that I can cut it into two even pieces.
04:52Very, very soft inside.
04:54It's not too sweet too.
04:55It's very dangerous.
04:56I could finish the whole box by myself.
04:58Brownie really visually delivers on that intense cocoa note,
05:03but taste-wise really didn't get that.
05:05I do love the little flint on top,
05:07but does it deliver on all the boxes that I would like in a brownie?
05:10Not really, but it's not awful.
05:17Sounds like Pillsbury hit a home run.
05:19Panelists, show us your scores.
05:39Now, it's time for Betty Crocker Delights.
05:43Can I not taste it?
05:45You can taste it now.
05:47No, I said, can I not taste it?
05:49You don't want to taste it?
05:50Yeah.
05:51Why?
05:52Because.
05:54Very, very chewy on the edge.
05:57It really kind of feels like toffee.
05:58I'm not loving this one.
06:00I'm not loving it also.
06:03Oh, this is sad.
06:05I don't know where the good starts,
06:08but I know where the bad starts.
06:09It doesn't know if it's cakey or fudgy.
06:12It's a no for me.
06:13The texture was kind of, it was off.
06:15It's definitely a dense brownie.
06:17It does have a fuller chocolate flavor,
06:19like a very alkalized cocoa powder,
06:21but the flint on top is kind of sad and lackluster.
06:24It almost gives you like a cosmic brownie kind of impression.
06:29This brownie did not bring me joy.
06:31It did not allow my teeth to sink into it,
06:35which is part of the pleasure of eating a brownie.
06:38The flavor was bland.
06:40It wasn't worth it.
06:41I did not try it, but I know I tasted this before.
06:46I know it sinks to my teeth.
06:47I hate it.
06:48It's too crumbly and stuff.
06:52It smells burned.
06:54It's moist.
06:55That's a positive.
06:56But other than that, I don't find anything of value in this brownie.
07:00This one surprised me a little bit.
07:02When I first looked at it, I was a little disappointed.
07:04It kind of looks like the brownies you would get at like a school cafeteria when you were a kid.
07:09Basic, dry, cakey looking.
07:11But then I tasted it and it was actually,
07:13it was actually pretty like chewy and dense, which I really liked.
07:17The texture of it.
07:18Texture, yes.
07:19Taste, no.
07:20This one is not so attractive to me.
07:22The taste, it's not so much either.
07:25I can still taste the aftertaste after the first bite.
07:27It's something that I want to put a napkin over it.
07:29And let's just move on to another one, please.
07:32Okay, so this right here is one bite challenge,
07:36because it was a challenge.
07:37Stuck in my teeth.
07:38In a way, it tasted familiar.
07:40Could I eat it?
07:40Yes, would I?
07:41No.
07:43From highs to lows, let's see how Betty Crocker ranks.
08:01That was a challenging round for Betty Crocker.
08:09Let's see if we can turn things around with Trader Joe's truffle brownie mix.
08:14It's definitely a dark chocolate.
08:16Dark chocolate.
08:18I think those chocolate chips are necessary.
08:20Really, really dry.
08:22Very, very chocolatey.
08:23I wouldn't want it.
08:25This brownie hates to see a glass of milk coming,
08:29because there is no moisture to be found.
08:32My mouth is so dry.
08:34It's crumbly.
08:35It's not a brownie.
08:37It's a dry cake.
08:38It makes me very sad.
08:40Definitely too dry, too crumbly.
08:42Not that like dense, moist, chewiness that I look for in a brownie.
08:45Chocolate chips were trying to deflect from the dryness and it didn't.
08:48And I took a bite in it when my stomach hurt.
08:51So it's a no.
08:52I thought this brownie was super dry.
08:56The chocolate chips in it really helped to add some kind of moisture to it.
09:00But like, it was like biting through something in the desert.
09:03Really didn't love the texture on top.
09:06It wasn't as sweet as the other brownies.
09:08It didn't ever.
09:09I'm okay with this.
09:11Texture wise, I'm not able to cut it into two pieces.
09:14It folds apart easily.
09:15Not the best brownie for today, but last one was a nightmare.
09:18That makes this one a little bit better.
09:20It's way too cakey and not what I was expecting.
09:24No crumbles.
09:26It's just no chocolate.
09:27I hate it.
09:28It's cookie.
09:30It's a cookie.
09:31It's not like a brownie.
09:33So, yeah.
09:34There are bits of chocolate in here when I picked it up and I was very excited about it.
09:39For me, this is a brownie that we're not going to see each other again.
09:44Time to show us those ratings.
09:59The chocolate chips in the brownie failed to impress our tasters.
10:05Oh my gosh.
10:07Oh my gosh.
10:10What the hell?
10:12Simple mills with almond flour.
10:15I don't really know what I'm going to do.
10:18It's a sturdy one.
10:21It kind of tastes like bread.
10:23Like it doesn't even taste like sweet or anything.
10:26Gluten free or something or other.
10:28It does not resemble a brownie.
10:31Okay, so I looked at it and it was like kind of like something you would see in a package.
10:37And then I bit it and I was really confused.
10:40I think I wanted to like it genuinely.
10:43But I think I was like, wait, what's going on?
10:47So it's not a brownie that I would have ever again.
10:49But if it's somebody that wants to have a brownie that can't have one for some reason,
10:54this is where you can go.
10:55When I bit into this brownie, I tasted what I think is coconut oil right away.
11:02So I suspect this might be a plant-based brownie.
11:06I don't think that there's dairy in it.
11:09It also might not have gluten in it.
11:11I'm not sure.
11:12It might be a good brownie for someone with some kind of food allergies.
11:16But if you're looking for a more kind of chocolatey, gooey, fudgy experience,
11:20this is not going to deliver that for you.
11:22It's like the little brownie that could, but just doesn't.
11:25I like this.
11:26Feels like it's from the health aisle.
11:28And I don't mind it.
11:29I think the one thing that it has in common with the good brownie is that they're both edible.
11:33And I certainly will not trade away my bubble tea for this.
11:36This is sad.
11:37Way too much chocolate.
11:39And when I bite it, it fell out, so it's broken.
11:44Broken.
11:45Not good.
11:46And I'm not really picky, but I just would not eat that.
11:59Still in search of a brownie that makes our toughest critic, Joey, happy.
12:10This is a brownie.
12:14Maybe great value will hit the sweet spot.
12:18Very, very good.
12:19Definitely softer.
12:21I do taste a lot of vanilla in it.
12:22It's yum yum.
12:24I think it's a really good brownie.
12:25The best one so far.
12:26Not too chocolatey.
12:28Not too mushy.
12:29It's really good.
12:30It's exactly what I expected.
12:32This is my favorite.
12:33This is, I've spent many years eating sweet foods competitively.
12:38This brownie made me forget that I'm here just to eat one piece.
12:41I want to eat the entire box that you have back there.
12:44This, this is a very good brownie.
12:46I'll tell you why.
12:46It is fudgy.
12:48It has a vanilla chocolatey scent to it.
12:50It's not dry.
12:51It holds itself well together.
12:53It has a nice little crust on top.
12:55I ate another bite before I even thought about it.
12:58It was just, it was that good.
12:59This is my top contender.
13:00I really liked this one.
13:02I'm in between this one and maybe the Pillsbury one, but this one is pretty good.
13:06I like the softness.
13:07It did what it, what it needed to do.
13:08It's very fudgy and dense, but isn't too indulgent in the sense that I wouldn't be able to finish it.
13:15I'm really impressed.
13:16This is a really good brownie.
13:17This one really surprised me.
13:18I like how it looks.
13:20I like that it's moist.
13:21I would purchase this brand putting aside my thoughts about what the ingredients are.
13:25I thought I was already overwhelmed with brownies this morning, but this one made me
13:29the second bite and I would say it's pretty good.
13:32This one was really, for me, the platonic ideal of a brownie.
13:36It checked all of those boxes that I tend to look for.
13:40The only thing there was a little bit of a slight bitterness in the aftertaste.
13:44I'm not really sure where that was coming from,
13:46but it's a really good brownie that was rich and satisfying without being heavy.
13:51I liked it.
13:52I would have loved if it had chocolate chips like the other one.
13:55I think that would have bumped this up a little bit.
13:57Great Value was a favor amongst our professional tasters,
14:00and something tells me it's going to do well again here.
14:10My thoughts are they taste good.
14:13With an average score of 8.06, this one is going to be hard to beat.
14:22Okay, this is a brownie that I would make.
14:25I'm intimidated by it.
14:27But let's see if Ghirardelli dark chocolate can do it.
14:34Wow.
14:36It's my favorite.
14:37I really like the waves on the top.
14:40It's giving like a bed sheet.
14:41And it looks moist, but it felt not as moist as it looks.
14:46I really like the initial bite, but then I got some odd aftertaste.
14:51It was kind of like perfumey.
14:52I think it's like you have to keep eating it so you don't get the aftertaste.
14:55Other than that, it was good.
14:57I think it's really, really attractive.
14:59Has nice height.
15:00My first bite included a lot of the chocolate chips,
15:03so that was kind of an overpowering taste.
15:06That was very, very chocolatey and rich, which I enjoyed.
15:09And then I took another bite without the chocolate chip,
15:11and the texture was not nearly as moist or as fudgy as I had hoped for.
15:17Not as good as last time.
15:19Pretty bad.
15:20Maybe last time it was my only good one, so two crispy and stuff.
15:25I like how, actually, the height of it.
15:27That's nice.
15:28But that's not enough for me to actually purchase this or eat it.
15:31I'm going to have to say no thank you.
15:34Me too.
15:34No thank you.
15:35This one was actually my favorite so far.
15:38I really liked it.
15:39I really found this brownie to be a delight.
15:41I would say this is like almost a brownie that I would make in my own kitchen.
15:45I know this sounds silly, but it kind of, I was a little intimidated by it at first.
15:49It looked perfect, and it followed through.
15:51I want more.
15:51That's how much I love it.
15:53It's probably the best one so far.
15:54I thought I would be sick of brownies right now, but oh boy, I love this.
16:00Hey, can I have some of yours, please?
16:02Yeah.
16:03That's pretty good.
16:04That's how much I love it.
16:05Proves my point.
16:24Okay, tasters, that's a wrap.
16:26Tell me, what were your favorites?
16:28Ghirardelli is my favorite.
16:30Ghirardelli for sure.
16:31It was Walmart.
16:32Walmart.
16:33I think Pillsbury.
16:35Walmart.
16:35I found the Ghirardelli to be the best one.
16:38Ghirardelli and Pillsbury.
16:45What a great day!
16:46kaukas worth goo.
16:51Ye сделать like this and here comes in mind.
16:53Bye, beichtity piernas.