• 11 minutes ago
یورونیوز ویریفای؛ آیا مجارستان از مشکلات حاکمیت قانون عبور کرده است؟

مجارستان تحت رهبری جدید قرار دارد و اصلاحات در حال انجام است. اما آیا پتر ماجیار می‌تواند حاکمیت قانون را بازگرداند و دوباره اعتماد اتحادیه اروپا را جلب کند؟

لب بیشتر : http://parsi.euronews.com/2026/11/19/euronews-verify-is-hungary-turning-the-page-on-its-rule-of-law-problems

مشترک شوید: یورونیوز به یازده زبان دیگر در دسترس شماست

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hungary has a new government but is the rule of law back on track and later could
00:05the UK rejoin the EU and if so when? This to come on ERA News Verify.
00:16EU ministers met in Brussels today November 19 to examine the state of the
00:21rule of law in Hungary, Cyprus, Lithuania and Luxembourg. Hungary a country long at
00:27odds with Brussels over democracy, judicial independence and fundamental
00:31rights was at the focus. But things have changed there. Viktor Orban is gone and
00:37his successor Peter Maggia has already introduced reforms welcomed by the EU.
00:43So is Hungary turning the page and what more does Brussels want to see? Today's
00:49EU affairs ministers meeting is part of the EU's annual rule of law dialogue which
00:55examines judicial independence, corruption, media freedom and institutional checks and
01:01balances. This is a regular review not a special review against Hungary or a vote
01:08on sanctions. But the timing is significant as Brussels assesses whether the changes
01:14under Maggia are delivering lasting results. Since taking office in 2026 Maggia's
01:21government has moved quickly to reverse some of the policies that put Hungary on a
01:26coalition course with the EU. The emergency rule by decree has ended. The
01:31Controversial Sovereignty Protection Office which investigated civil society
01:35organizations and media outlets has been abolished. Hungary has also joined the
01:41European Public Prosecutor's Office and introduced new anti-corruption and judicial
01:45reforms. New safeguards have also been adopted to strengthen media independence. A European
01:52parliament delegation visiting Hungary in October praised the pace of these changes, describing
01:58them as substantial progress. We asked Tungien, the acting co-director at the Jacques Delors
02:05centres, how significant these reforms are in practice.
02:09I think we have seen clear efforts for a break with the with the rule of law situation that
02:16has that existed under Viktor Orban and that the new government under Maggia has really put
02:22an effort into implementing reforms. Despite the progress, Brussels still has several concerns.
02:30First, judicial independence. The EU wants guarantees that judges can make decisions without political
02:37interference. Then there is corruption. Hungary has introduced stronger safeguards, but Brussels still
02:44wants to see effective investigations and prosecutions in high-level cases. Media freedom is another concern.
02:52Although new safeguards have been introduced, media concentration remains a problem,
02:58as does the distribution of state advertising. And fundamental rights are still under scrutiny.
03:05Some discriminatory provisions affecting LGBTIQ plus people have been repealed, but other restrictions
03:12remain. Concerns also persist over access to asylum procedures. The key question is whether these
03:19reforms are changing how institutions actually work. I think the problem with restoring the rule of law is
03:26always that it is not very easy, especially after the rule of law has been dismantled for many years.
03:33Hungary is also still subject to a separate EU procedure known as Article 7. Launched in 2018,
03:41it addresses concerns about a serious risk to the EU's funding values, including democracy, the rule of law,
03:48and fundamental rights. It can eventually lead to the suspension of certain rights, including voting rights.
03:55But the procedure has not been closed and there is an important distinction. Lifting specific financial
04:03restrictions against Hungary does not mean its wider rule of law problems have been resolved.
04:09The Article 7 procedure is also a very political procedure. So, of course, what we need to see is very
04:16clear
04:16efforts and hopefully implementation of measures. In October, the Council lifted specific budget protection
04:24measures imposed against Hungary in 2022, recognizing progress on reforms. For the EU, the challenge is
04:31now to recognize genuine progress without abandoning scrutiny. And for Magyar's government, the test is
04:39whether new laws translate into independent institutions, stronger accountability and lasting
04:46protection of fundamental rights. I think the two clear standards we could see that would show that Hungary
04:53has really taken a turn are, first of all, the closure of Article 7 and secondly, the unfreezing of EU
05:01money.
05:01Coming up next, the EU-UK summit has reignited a bigger question. Could the UK rejoin the European Union?
05:08And if so, how soon? Lauren Walker has the story.
05:17We will not give Britain the clear path we need into the rest of this century until we decide on
05:24a
05:24long-term relationship with what is still our largest market. Brexit is back 10 years after the UK voted to
05:33leave the EU. This time though, London wants closer ties with Brussels, not a divorce. The reset began
05:42under Keir Starmer and picked up pace under Andy Burnham, who stirred the Brexit debate but stopped short
05:48of committing to rejoining. Public support is there for it. 56% of Britons would now vote to rejoin.
05:57In Brussels, the mood is pragmatic. Five European leaders have called for closer collaboration in
06:04areas such as energy, ahead of a long-awaited EU-UK summit this Friday. We're expecting that at this
06:12summit, the UK Prime Minister may start to lay out some of the next steps in those conversations that
06:17he's having at the national level about what the UK's future relationship with the EU could look like
06:21in the long term. So would this include rejoining the EU and how long would this take? Well, it's
06:29difficult to say, mainly because there are some hurdles. The first is getting the conversation
06:35started in the UK. The often mentioned red lines set out by the previous government under Starmer
06:42slow this part down. This government has been clear that at least until the next election they are still
06:48committed to those red lines. So we wouldn't expect to see the UK's relationship change in this
06:54parliament with the European Union. So big change isn't possible before the 2029 elections. And
07:01anything agreed until then could be undone if reform or the Conservatives win it. For this reason,
07:08the EU has reportedly pushed for a so-called Farage clause, named after reform leader Nigel Farage,
07:14to protect future deals from being reversed. What Brussels would demand is another obstacle.
07:22French President Emmanuel Macron, among others, has warned the UK can't cherry-pick from EU policies.
07:29Would it again allow the UK to opt out of the Schengen border-free area or the Eurozone, both crucial
07:36to
07:37London for public support and political feasibility? If the UK was to rejoin the EU, it would not be
07:44rejoining the EU that it left. It's much more a geopolitical EU. And I think if the UK is ready
07:52to go
07:54fully on the idea that the need to side with the EU as a member state. Another factor is whether
08:02the UK
08:02could skip the queue to join the EU. A group of EU lawmakers said Brussels should not treat the UK
08:10like any third country. But Prime Minister Eddie Rama of Albania, which has been in the waiting room for
08:16some 17 years, joked that the UK should be at the back of the queue. The Brits should wait for
08:23now,
08:23because we waited enough for them. So they are behind Montenegro and Albania. However, there is
08:30no queue system. Joining the bloc requires countries to adopt EU rules and unanimity for member states.
08:38This process defines the timeline. Because the UK was once a member, though, reaccession could happen
08:45more quickly. Since Brexit, there's actually been relatively limited divergence from EU rules. And when
08:51there has been divergence, we're actually seeing the UK choosing to realign with EU rules in some areas,
08:57like SBS, like energy. So taking all this into account, how long would it take for the UK to rejoin
09:05the bloc? We think that the best president out there is Finland, who managed to complete their
09:11negotiations to join from applying to be a candidate to fully entering the European Union in under three years.
09:18And that's why we give that less than five years time frame. But academic counterpoints argue that
09:23the chances of it going so swiftly are small. If the UK wants to have the same rebate, the same
09:31opt-out,
09:32that can take lots of time. And the more it wants opt-outs, the more the ratification also would be
09:39more hazardous. So it could take at least more than a parametri term, and it could take a decade.
09:48This leaves us with one big question. Does the EU even want the UK to rejoin? And do the two
09:55sides
09:56align on what they want from closer ties? The idea that the UK wants to join the EU just for
10:03the sake
10:04of its own GDP and just for the, you know, have a better growth. I think that's not a compelling
10:10reason for the 27 leaders. They want to see the UK be ready to act to be more independent from
10:18the US
10:19when it comes to defence, when it comes to the defence industry, when it comes to AI, tech companies,
10:26companies and in its own public procurements, if it really wants to join this project, or if it just
10:33wants to benefit from a rich, close, big trading partner. Thanks, Lauren. That's all on Euronews Verify.
10:42And as always, stay sceptical, demand the facts, and we'll see you next time.
Comments

Recommended