00:00For more on this developing story, I'm joined live by Fabrice Pottier, the CEO of Rasmussen Global,
00:06who previously served as Director of Policy Planning for the NATO Alliance.
00:11So good to have you with us. First, just on these trilateral talks in China, first of all,
00:17you know, a lot of parallelisms being drawn with the Yalta conference.
00:21Is that a fair comparison in your view?
00:25The table was much bigger. Actually, there was no table in 1945 in Yalta.
00:30At least in the photo, the big historic photo.
00:33But I think the parallel actually is not so inaccurate when you look at the joint statement.
00:40You have here, when you look at these points, the mirror image of these world powers
00:46want to be doing deals together outside international law and outside multilateral infrastructure.
00:53So I think it's actually worse than what you could have expected,
00:57as initially a lot of people were expecting purely a photo op.
01:01But I think these three powers came together and are saying, essentially,
01:05we keep on breaking the UN, but we want the UN to work.
01:09Then they make a deal about gasoline and fuel.
01:13And then they say the ICC has no jurisdiction and we don't want international law to...
01:19We're immune from international law.
01:20And they conclude with a tiny bit of hope on nuclear proliferation,
01:25which is essentially a dialogue. So it doesn't go very far.
01:28And in terms of Ukraine, I must ask you, because, you know,
01:32we're seeing the warmth in the relationship once again between the US president and the Russian leader.
01:38We are hearing that Trump has called into that meeting taking place in Berlin of the Coalition of the Willing,
01:43and that he's been questioning Europe's insistence on continuing to back and fund Ukraine.
01:48How much of a setback has this bilateral between Putin and Trump been for Kyiv, but also for the Europeans?
01:56I think it's more of the same in terms of Trump has clearly sided with Vladimir Putin.
02:02At least that's the big shift of this year.
02:05Before, you had the pendulum of him supporting Ukraine and then going a bit more towards Russia and getting tough
02:11on Russia.
02:12I think since before the midterms, you have seen a clear shift where Trump is embracing Vladimir Putin.
02:18And I think he's seeking to resume some big business as usual and make some deals.
02:23And the problem for him and for Putin is that Ukraine is standing in a way, Ukraine and Europe.
02:28And this is where we are now.
02:30We also heard from the Russian president saying he will now invite European negotiators to Moscow to set out their
02:37positions.
02:38Do you see that as a prospect? Do you see Europeans taking up this invitation?
02:44I mean, the issue is that Putin and his people are masters in the theater of pretending and theater of
02:52diplomacy,
02:53whilst at the same time killing and destroying people, destroying cities.
02:59A ballistic missile just basically exploded 150 meters from Rasmussen Global's office in Kyiv.
03:07So I think this is the double talk that Putin is an expert in.
03:12And I think going to Moscow, like you might remember, high representative Josef Borrell went to Moscow and it was
03:18a complete disaster because it's a trap.
03:20You don't go to Moscow to talk to the Russians, at least not at the beginning of such a difficult
03:25dialogue.
03:25You go to a neutral place and you try to lay out your key red lines and terms.
03:31Yet at the same time, Trump seems really intent on ending this war.
03:38That's become clear from the scenes we've seen from China today.
03:42Do you think Europeans can resist that invitation or do they risk deepening the transatlantic rift even more?
03:50I think that it is Trump who is deepening the transatlantic rift and who is joining the world autocracies.
03:58Let's be clear about that.
03:59And I think Europe and Ukraine have no choice but to resist.
04:04The cost for Ukraine is obviously very high and is likely to increase in the coming month.
04:09But Europe has no other choice than to support Ukraine because European security ends and starts in Ukraine.
04:17What about this team of negotiators that European leaders have recently appointed?
04:23Is it the right approach?
04:24Is a team of seven going to be able to speak with one voice in these potential talks?
04:29Talks by committee is obviously not always the most efficient thing to do, especially when you're facing pretty good negotiators
04:38and pretty harsh negotiators like the Russians and even the Trump.
04:43This is not the optimum setup.
04:46This is typical Europe trying to reach a consensus about things where you need to have one person, one phone
04:51number, one voice.
04:54Finally, we know that there's another meeting happening right now as we speak.
04:57It's just wrapped up, I believe, in Berlin, the coalition of the willing.
05:02You know, is there a future to this coalition?
05:05Do you really believe that the security guarantees and the plans that they're drafting will become a reality?
05:14Actually, I think the big mistake, even though the coalition of the willing is a great diplomatic concept, the big
05:20mistake is there should be a presence to it, meaning it should already be supporting the Ukrainians in Ukraine.
05:26That was the talk a year ago, and this receded, and now we're talking about having the coalition moving after
05:32a peace agreement.
05:33That means for Vladimir Putin, there's zero interest in reaching a peace agreement because he obviously doesn't want to have
05:39European forces on Ukrainian soil.
05:42We should have created a fair complete to force him then to the negotiation table.
05:47I think we've got the sequence wrong.
05:49Okay, Fabrice Poitier, thank you so much for your insights and for joining us this evening on Europe Tonight.