00:00For more on this developing story, I'm joined live in the studio by Teresa Fallon, who is the founder and
00:05director of the Center for Russia, Europe, Asia Studies.
00:09Teresa, good to have you with us in the studio.
00:11Delighted to be here.
00:12So first, just on that meeting in China, the scenes coming out, you know, these three powerful leaders, what do
00:20you make of this?
00:21Is this really the pivotal moment that many analysts seem to think it is?
00:25There was such an incredible buildup before this. Some have christened it Yalta 2.0.
00:30But at the end of the day, it was a bit of a nothing burger.
00:33It was a long photo op. And the four points of the peace declaration is rather weak tea.
00:39It almost sounds like what a beauty pageant contestant would say, like, we don't want nuclear war.
00:44So, yes, everyone can agree on that.
00:46The other topic of that was working together on energy that was clearly for Putin.
00:51There are a lot of sanctions on him. So he's really suffering, his economy is suffering, the attacks on Russian
00:58refineries.
00:58So I think that that point was kind of a clear reminder that Russian economy is really in a difficult
01:05situation.
01:06And you say you describe it as a beauty pageant or a photo op.
01:10But it's clear that for these leaders, this was quite an important photo op.
01:14Why is that? Have they emerged, strengthened from this exchange?
01:18We should keep in mind that this was not a separate event.
01:21It was a side event to a massive 62% of the world economies gathered together in Shenzhen, China to
01:29discuss politics, economics.
01:32And this one really grabbed all the attention.
01:34So at the point where Xi Jinping wants to be kind of a leader of the global south,
01:40he actually kind of telescoped and sent another message that these three players are very important.
01:45But at the end of the day, everyone thought that this would be a big show for Putin.
01:49But I think the biggest winner here is Xi Jinping.
01:51He looks like he's convening. He's in the middle.
01:53He has the U.S. to one side and Russia to the other.
01:56And he's promoting peace.
01:58Indeed. On that, on the question of peace, we know Ukraine did come up,
02:03especially in the bilateral between Putin and Trump.
02:06You know, we did feel this warmth in that relationship of Trump describing Putin as a good friend, for example.
02:14How much of a setback is this now tonight for Europe and for Ukraine?
02:18Well, there's an acceleration of activity because we saw with the blue wave election in the United States,
02:23Donald Trump only has a very short window of opportunity until Congress takes its seat in January.
02:29And he'll find himself, you know, there is a balance of power in the United States.
02:33Trump is a lame duck and he won't be able to do much.
02:36So if he wants to help Putin, now's the time.
02:39But I think it will be very difficult.
02:41We saw in the earlier statement he made to the meeting in Berlin showed the effect of Putin.
02:46Whenever Putin and Trump meet, it seems that Trump kind of also echoes the message that Putin gives him.
02:52You say he's a lame duck, perhaps at home.
02:56But when it comes to the conflict in Ukraine, he seems very intent on pushing both sides to the table
03:02and getting a deal done.
03:04Do you think we are on the verge now of seeing a real movement and both sides really being pressured
03:09by the U.S. to sign a deal?
03:12Well, there has to be a just deal.
03:13And I think that this negotiation that the Europeans will finally be at the table is very important.
03:19But Putin has not changed his position whatsoever.
03:22He has a maximalist position and he has not moved one inch.
03:26He has not negotiated whatsoever.
03:28And we should keep in mind he invaded Ukraine.
03:32So behind all of this and the beautiful peace pose, Xi Jinping, there has been so much evidence, supports Russia's
03:38war in Ukraine.
03:39So he looks like a peacemaker.
03:41But in reality, China is supporting Russia.
03:44NATO has called them the key enabler of the war.
03:47If there was no support from China, the war would end years ago.
03:50So China is helping Russia.
03:53And I think that that's almost too much for some European officials to accept or understand.
03:58I was at some closed-door events last week.
04:01And there was great hope that China would step in and negotiate the peace and also be a peace guarantor,
04:08like put troops on the ground.
04:09So that was really wishful thinking.
04:12And we see just kind of a happy, clappy posturing on behalf of Xi Jinping.
04:17Indeed.
04:18And you say, you know, China has not maybe played the mediator role that some were expecting.
04:23Where does that now leave Europe?
04:26They have nominated a team of negotiators.
04:29Putin is saying today they will be invited to Moscow to lay out their positions.
04:34Do you expect that to really happen while there is no ceasefire in place in Ukraine and the killing continues?
04:41I really hope for peace.
04:43I have to be optimistic.
04:44But I'm deeply concerned that Putin will not change his position.
04:49In Russia, he's opened Pandora's box.
04:51And this war will not end until he's gone.
04:54And it doesn't look like anyone in the Russian oligarchy is going to make a move on him.
04:59You say the war will not end until he's gone.
05:02You do not believe there is a solution while President Putin is in power in Moscow?
05:06He's a dead man if he walks away.
05:08So over 500,000 are dead.
05:11People will wonder why in the world did we go to this war in Ukraine?
05:14He will continue to escalate, I'm afraid.
05:17Finally, I want to ask you again about Europe here,
05:21because we know that the security architecture of Europe is at stake.
05:26We know there's an important meeting happening at the same time in Berlin right now.
05:30You know, do you believe that Europe is well prepared to defend its own interests
05:37if they are brought into these talks?
05:39Let's face it.
05:40Europe has been living off of an eroded defense base for 30 years.
05:45It's been very difficult for them to rebuild it because Beijing has made it difficult to get rare earths.
05:51They've asked all these European companies,
05:53if you want rare earths, you need a license from us,
05:56and then you have to show us what your industry is, show us drawings, who are your clients.
06:02So they have an entire picture of the architecture.
06:05Then they can have more pinch points.
06:07So China has not granted any licenses to any defense producers in Europe for rare earths.
06:13Therefore, they cannot build these things.
06:16And any dual-use goods, so goods that could be used for military or civilian use,
06:20China will also not give licenses for.
06:23So this means that Europe has a double pinch.
06:26Not only the war with Russia,
06:27but China is helping Russia by not allowing Europe to build up their defense base.
06:32So Europe is in really a very, very difficult situation.
06:34The high energy prices, the inflation, all of this makes it very difficult.
06:39And maybe Putin's just thinking,
06:41if I wait with the elections in France, Germany and Spain, maybe things will change.
06:47We know that these parties are far more pro-Putin than the current parties in place.
06:54So you think that the shift potentially coming in Europe politically could play into Putin's hands?
06:59Exactly.
07:00Okay.
07:01Teresa Fallon, thank you so much for joining us here on Europe tonight.
07:04Good to have you.