- 21 minutes ago
This debate addresses Rahul Gandhi's claims on India's global role, critiques of Narendra Modi's foreign policy, and insights on India's diplomatic position from experts.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00And let me open this debate and bring in Rakesh Sinha, former Rajya Sabha MP of the BJP.
00:05Dr. Amol Deshmukh is the Congress spokesperson.
00:08Rajiv Bhatia is former Indian ambassador.
00:10We also have Sandeep Unitan, senior journalist.
00:13And here in the studio is my colleague Pranayupadhyay, editor of India Today Global.
00:19Rakesh Sinha, Rahul Gandhi says a Congress prime minister would have been sitting alongside Trump, Xi and Putin.
00:28Should the government be concerned that India was missing from a conversation involving three major powers?
00:38I think Rahul Gandhi has been demonstrating low nationalist morality.
00:46Whenever he goes outside the country, he speaks something which is embarrassment for every Indian, not only the government.
00:53And I think that he is being used by the international forces to defame India.
01:00He is a tool.
01:01And I think this Congress party has do seriously soul-searching.
01:08Outside the country, the way you are defaming the country, you are not defaming the prime minister and the Bharatiya
01:14Janata Party.
01:15For outsiders, India is a nation.
01:20It does not belong to a particular government.
01:22We are not a fractured politics.
01:24That fractured politics is a domestic affairs.
01:27Second important thing is that, you see Prime Minister Narendra Modi's diplomacy,
01:34that he safeguards India's interest in the scenario when the world is not bipolar due to ideological region.
01:43The previous Cold War basis was ideology.
01:49The Soviet Union, former Soviet Union, America, the two Polars, and one communism, other capitalist class.
01:55Here, that was easy to handle.
01:59Here, bipolarization is based on the trades.
02:03Lowest level of the national interest.
02:07America, Russia, or even the Saudi countries are playing.
02:11In that situation, when China is playing its own card, America is playing its own card, Russia is playing its
02:18own card,
02:18in that situation, very diplomatically, Prime Minister created delusions among these world powers.
02:25They consider sometimes that India is very closest to them.
02:28And in that situation, India is safeguarded its national interest.
02:35You see, the minimum impact of war on India.
02:39India could not be dragged into the petty politics between these forces during the war.
02:45We are friends of Israel.
02:47But we could not be dragged.
02:49Okay, Dr. Amul Deshmukh, Rahul Gandhi is saying that Congress Prime Minister would have been sitting at the table.
02:54On what basis?
02:55What specific diplomatic relationships or strategic interventions would have secured India that position?
03:03If you see, Modi has made India a side player on the world stage.
03:08And Rahul Gandhi is saying so is a service to the nation.
03:10Not an insult delivered abroad.
03:13That's number one.
03:14If you look at Pakistan getting a room for Iran and US while India watches,
03:21is a clear sign to that.
03:24If you look at India's trade dependence on China, which is about to hit about 150 billion in deficit,
03:32and through an unresolved border conflict, which has been going on for months,
03:37and that's not been resolved, there's no answer to that.
03:40Given these aspects, it's quite clear that India doesn't get a table amongst US, Russia and China
03:49is symbolic enough for the whole world, where India stands today.
03:54And that is amply clear and made a statement in abroad.
03:59It doesn't differ because we are living in a globalized world.
04:02And that needs to be considered by every citizen.
04:05But India is not a member of APEC.
04:07Why should its absence from this particular meeting be interpreted as a diplomatic failure?
04:12So, it's not an APEC meeting that the US, Russia and China have done.
04:17It is on the sidelines.
04:18So, let's not fool ourselves or anybody else.
04:22No, I mean, there has to be certain explanation.
04:26You are saying that India has become a side player.
04:28What about India's continuing engagement with Russia, the US, the Quad, the BRICS and the global south?
04:37As the general already said, that India has done a mistake by being two together, being very close to Israel
04:44and UAE.
04:45And now we are trying to get away with it.
04:48It already tells that.
04:50India has a history where we had the non-aligned movement started by Nehruji.
04:55And as a fresh country, and by 1983, when Indiraji was at the UN summit, she was talking on behalf
05:03of hundred nations.
05:05And that was the seat that India had way back in 1983.
05:10Coming to even Vajpayeeji's, he was able to handle even the sanctions and take it forward.
05:18What about Modi people out in the US?
05:19Okay, Ragesh Sina, please respond to that and then I'll bring in others.
05:21Ragesh Sina.
05:23No, I am really surprised.
05:27The Congress spokesperson forgets that it was the Nehrubian regime that India lost almost 36,000 square kilometers to China.
05:37And not only 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.
05:39Hundreds of these Jawas martyred because they lacked the weapons.
05:45And they are talking about China.
05:47They made the entire border unsafe.
05:49It is during the Modi regime that the Indo-China border is highly safeguarded.
05:56Infrastructure, the border, unprecedented.
05:58That is a reason for China's anxieties for India.
06:02Second important thing, as for Pakistan, is concern.
06:04Pakistan is merely a tool.
06:06Whatever America or any country does for Pakistan, it lacks the credibility.
06:11You know, during the last 10 years, particularly during the war regime, Prime Minister Modi emerged as a most credible
06:19world leader among the global south.
06:24He is a raise of hope.
06:26You see the way China is trying to hegemonizing and America is openly demonstrating its greed.
06:33Russia is doing everything conditional.
06:36In that situation, it is only India, which is also playing vital role among the so-called superpower developed countries,
06:45as well as it is taking the leadership of the global south.
06:48I think that non-alignment was a bankrupt movement.
06:52It has nothing to do with the national interest.
06:54That was only a must for the country to hide its weakness and not protect its national interest.
07:02Now, the concept of non-alignment was good.
07:04But India, it became more symbolic than substantive.
07:08Here, Modi is playing substantive, and I was listening, you are talking to some diplomat, you know, Prime Minister Modi
07:15used the Indian diaspora as a vibrant, vibrant class.
07:23They all became very active, and they became just like a protector of India's interest.
07:29And that is a pressure group among the countries, in different countries.
07:34They are acting as a pressure group, which were not earlier done.
07:38So, here I consider that, as for foreign policy is concerned, any leader going outside must think that he is
07:48representing India.
07:50There may be differences between the opposition party, the ruling party, but that should not demean our own country, demean
07:56our own foreign policy, demean our own concerns.
08:01Ambassador Rajiv Bhatia.
08:03Ambassador Rajiv Bhatia, should India's absence from this meeting worry us, or is Rahul Gandhi reading too much into a
08:07photograph?
08:08No, I think I would use your previous phrase, this is very much an overstatement.
08:15I think India should be very realistic in terms of dealing with the world today.
08:22There is no basis at all to expect that India would be at that table, as you rightly pointed out.
08:30It is essentially an epic conference.
08:32There is a, on the sideline, a meeting that is being called.
08:36That's okay.
08:36I think as an experienced and mature nation, we should take these things in our stride.
08:42I would also suggest that, you know, this is not a new Yalta.
08:49It is not a defining moment where the world is going to change completely.
08:54India has a very strong role to play in the world affairs today.
08:58We must recognize that foreign policy of India has been always showing a blend of continuity and change.
09:07It is a dynamic foreign policy. It is not a static foreign policy.
09:12It is based on principles and values, but it changes with the change in time, with the change in the
09:19world.
09:20Therefore, my central point would be that if political parties want to make hands of those who run foreign policy
09:30strong,
09:31they must first have a serious dialogue within the country.
09:34And I would actually use this opportunity to call upon some of the leading think tanks of this country
09:41to organize a series of roundtables on foreign policy so that the representatives of various political parties
09:49can sit down, discuss, understand each other, and develop a consensus among themselves.
09:55That will be the sure guarantee to ensure that India's national interests are fully preserved and protected.
10:03Ambassador, is the Trump-Shi-Putin meeting a defining moment in global geopolitics?
10:10Could we be looking at a new G3 that increasingly sidelines other major powers?
10:15On the basis of being a former foreign policy practitioner for 37 years
10:21and a humble student of Indian foreign policy for the past 15 years,
10:26I would say that I'm quite skeptical about this.
10:31In the first stance, it looks more a drama, more optics,
10:36because we know that each of them has serious differences among themselves.
10:41They have not announced yet whether this would be a regular feature.
10:46We have studied and dissected that four-point peace declaration,
10:52which is really without any substance.
10:55So I think this whole storm created by a 90-minute meeting where everything is scripted,
11:03including very much naturally the document which was issued.
11:08We should be a mature nation.
11:10We should take it in our stride.
11:12And we should not feel that this is the end of the world.
11:15India is doing well in terms of foreign policy.
11:18I would not say everything is hunky-dory, essentially,
11:22because this is the world of turbulence.
11:25This is the world of tension.
11:27This is the world of unpredictability.
11:30This is the time when India's political class, India's academia,
11:35India's scholars and thinkers must join hands,
11:38understand India's national interests,
11:40and advise the government together as to how they should play their hand.
11:45Okay, so let me bring in the two editors of our channel.
11:50Come in now, Sandeep Unithan and Pranev Padir.
11:54Pranev, coming to you first,
11:56how do you look at Rahul Gandhi's charge?
11:59You know, there is other criticism that India's foreign policy
12:02is also perhaps becoming too personality.
12:05You know, Maria, as leader of opposition,
12:08he is all entitled to take a dig on, you know,
12:11Prime Minister Modi or, you know, ruling party.
12:14He is well entitled to do that.
12:15But as far as, you know, what exactly he's trying to attribute,
12:19because, you know, I can share those pictures with you.
12:22Just a year ago, when in Tianjin,
12:25Prime Minister Modi, Xi Jinping,
12:27and President Putin were, you know, holding hands,
12:30there was a picture and there was a reaction in Washington, D.C.
12:33U.S. President made a very scathing remark regarding that meeting.
12:38That was also a trilateral meeting taking place on the sidelines of the SCO summit.
12:43And, in fact, it was one of the close aid of President Vladimir Putin,
12:48Khilal Dimitri, who's one of the key interlocutors with Washington, D.C. for Kremlin.
12:52He made a social media post, and I can share that social media post with you.
12:56In that social media post, he said that perhaps these three leaders are missing their friend Donald Trump.
13:03So, as a country, you know, as a rapidly, fastly growing economy,
13:08as an, you know, aspiring country, ambitious country,
13:11Indians or people in India, political class in India,
13:15might have an expectation to be included in every important table.
13:19But, every country decides and defines their own national interests
13:23based on their priorities, their own national objectives,
13:27and India is also well entitled to do so.
13:30India has multiple, you know, forums, multiple trilaterals,
13:33with a similar set of leaders.
13:35India is part of definite and different groupings.
13:38I kind of agree with Ambassador Rajiv Bhatia,
13:41and I completely echo his ideas that there should be some common minimum consensus in this country
13:47as far as the foreign policy objectives are concerned,
13:50because we are dealing with a very turbulent world right now, Maria,
13:53and it is so important to go and convey a very informed messaging
13:58for the larger audience in this country
14:00so that we can have a consensus on our national priorities.
14:05Look, foreign policy objectives should remain same, you know, not static,
14:09but there should be a common approach.
14:12Dana, you know, diplomacy can be dynamic.
14:14Your approach to a story could be different than my approach
14:17towards that story, but obviously the story is important,
14:20and in this case, India's story is a beautiful story,
14:23and we have seen the United States changing its approach.
14:26As far as the Russia-Ukraine conflict is concerned,
14:29you have seen what has changed from Joe Biden administration
14:31to Donald Trump administration.
14:33While if you see India's approach,
14:35India always maintained that the dialogue and diplomacy
14:37is the only way forward.
14:39Now these countries are coming and echoing the same thing,
14:42that dialogue and diplomacy is the only way forward,
14:45and these issues cannot be resolved on the battlefield.
14:48Okay.
14:48Sandeep, the point that has been made by the BJP and the government is
14:53that should this criticism come on a foreign soil?
14:57The leader of opposition is traveling.
15:00He is in Chicago.
15:02He is in other universities.
15:03And for him to say that India has become a side player
15:07sends a wrong message to the world outside.
15:11You know, India is, of course, positioning itself
15:14as an important global power.
15:16There are recent developments to suggest so.
15:19India hosted G20.
15:20One may say that it comes in a, you know,
15:24every country gets a chance.
15:25But then, you know, there are efforts to position India
15:29in a different way,
15:29and here is leader of opposition speaking about it,
15:32the manner in which he did.
15:34How do you view this criticism?
15:37Well, you know, Maria,
15:38I tend to agree with what Pranay said.
15:41It is well within the leader of the opposition's rights
15:45to criticize India's foreign policy.
15:48I mean, how he chooses to do that
15:49is, of course, a matter of debate,
15:51whether he should actually use those words,
15:53whether he should say it on foreign soil.
15:55But he is well within his rights to criticize.
15:58And he has done so.
16:01But, you know, the thing about looking at this photo op
16:06and then, you know, wondering why are we missing at this high table,
16:10you know, there is this expression called parallelomania.
16:14And that is used to refer to, you know,
16:18you're looking for historical parallels with current events.
16:22You're calling it a new Yalta.
16:24You're looking for a new Cold War.
16:26You're looking for a new World War.
16:27All of these things.
16:28And everyone knows, as Ambassador Bhatia pointed out,
16:32that it was nothing but a photo op.
16:34It was President Trump's idea
16:36to get the two permanent members of the UN Security Council,
16:40three of them in a room together to talk.
16:42And they are also APEC members.
16:44So what does India need to get onto that high table?
16:48Firstly, we have to be a member of the UN Security Council,
16:51which we've been arguing for several years.
16:54Congress governments have been arguing for it.
16:55BJP governments have been arguing for an expansion
16:57of the UN Security Council.
16:59And secondly, we need to be a member of APEC.
17:02Now, we are not.
17:03And we haven't been invited either.
17:05So I think we should just take it in our stride and move on.
17:08There are much, much bigger things for us to do.
17:11You know, rather than worry about these photo ops.
17:14And these photo ops will keep happening.
17:16We all know that there are three presidents there
17:20who have their own domestic compulsions.
17:23President Trump has had a very, very severe electoral reversal.
17:27He needs to sell it to his people.
17:30President Putin has been out in the cold for so many years.
17:32The Russia-Ukraine war is entering its sixth year in three months from now.
17:36Now, President Xi Jinping is probably the only one who isn't fighting a war,
17:41but he has to also spin it as a huge victory for the Chinese people.
17:44So these are three presidents with their own, you know, political, domestic compulsion.
17:50So I don't think we should take it that seriously, not being at that table.
17:54There will be other tables and we just have to, you know, wait and hide your strength
17:58and then bide your time as a famous Chinese politician said, Maria.
18:02Okay, so let me go back to the two politicians on the show.
18:05Dr. Amol Deshmukh wants to come in and I am looking at this image
18:11where Prime Minister Modi is holding the hands of Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
18:17Many would say that why is Donald Trump missing?
18:21Is that an argument here, Dr. Deshmukh?
18:26See, I'll come back to the point.
18:28I think the panelists, contrary to what a congressman would say,
18:31require a bit more nationalism than what they can envision.
18:35Because even if you say if it's a photo op,
18:38you don't, you can't forget that India is 1.5 billion.
18:43It's one third of the world's population.
18:44And if you're taking yourself lightly and the government is taking lightly
18:47or the panelists are taking lightly, that doesn't make sense.
18:51Number two, as regards Modi Ji's concern,
18:56he has done handshakes for about 33 times with Xi Jinping
18:59and about 30, 40 more times with the other team members within the government.
19:03And we still don't have answer to what Lieutenant General Rahul Singh said,
19:08that China provided Pakistan real-time operational inputs.
19:11And how did that happen?
19:12There are six questions that has been raised by the congresspeople
19:15regarding Arunachal Pradesh, may it be Lathak, may it be patrolling.
19:19And those issues needs to be answered.
19:21We can't hide behind it.
19:22Not to forget that the three countries when they met today,
19:27there are about three major issues that our countries also need to be party to it.
19:31One is the energy security, which is at stake.
19:34And if you speak to any industrialist in any city of this country,
19:38you'll understand how much costs have gone up,
19:41how many issues they are facing.
19:43And that energy security was being discussed here.
19:45Second is the institutional reforms about UNSC that we are all talking about.
19:49And we are not party to it being the largest populated country.
19:54And third is the economic diplomacy, which everybody mentioned that it's all about trade.
19:57Quickly respond to that, Rakesh Sena.
19:58Please come in.
20:02No, I think that the Congress Party has not brought out even three-page document on the foreign policy.
20:10Inside the country, Rahul Gandhi is abusive to the prime minister.
20:15Outside the country, he remains abusive to the country.
20:19Because once you are going, you have right to do constructive criticism.
20:25But you are not the only first opposition leader.
20:27Atali Bihari Bajpayee was the leader of the opposition.
20:30What did he role play?
20:32So, question is not that what you speak, what you don't speak.
20:36Question is India first.
20:38That is the basic principle of any foreign policy.
20:41Why America is protecting its interests, ethical and non-ethical means?
20:46Russia is doing ethical and non-ethical means.
20:49Israel is doing the same.
20:51So, why you are making India skip God?
20:54Prime Minister Narendra Modi has made the centrality of the foreign policies in India first.
20:59The national interest is the primary.
21:01For that interest, we are not going to be over-ethical people.
21:05What Nehru did?
21:06What Indira Gandhi did?
21:08What they achieved for India?
21:09What did they achieve for India?
21:11Two things are important to be a major player in the global politics.
21:14It is not the lofty words and bigger claims.
21:21It is the economic might, military strength and third, dynamic leadership.
21:25You have three things here.
21:27India for the first time can claim its economic strength among the community of the world.
21:35Second, its own military.
21:36India is moving towards the military self-reliance.
21:41You see the involvement of the private sector and we are producing, we are now exporting things.
21:47And third, it is dynamic leadership.
21:48You see Prime Minister Modi's involvement.
21:50The Islamic world is awarding him and honoring him.
21:53It is not a small thing.
21:55The person who is being degraded as anti-Islamic, anti-Muslim and Hindu nationalist
22:01and that same person is being honored by the modern two that is of Islamic and why?
22:07Are they fools?
22:09Not at all.
22:10So Rahul Gandhi and Congress party, rather all opposition party,
22:14should think in terms of that.
22:15Their domestic politics should not go outside.
22:17Okay, quickly, Dr. Deff, you'll respond to that and then I'll give the last word to the ambassador.
22:21Lastly, lastly, one sentence.
22:24Go ahead.
22:25Go ahead.
22:26One sentence.
22:29Rahul Gandhi's statement, just remove his name and ask any person whose statement is this.
22:34Anybody will tell that it is some Pakistani statement is that.
22:38Why Rahul Gandhi is befooling himself?
22:41That is the question before the Congress and the entire nation.
22:45Okay.
22:46So, Rakesh ji, this is an old rhetoric that BJP can't get through the citizens.
22:51Having said that Pakistan negotiates, India watches.
22:54Second, friendship is not foreign policy.
22:56Third, trade dependence is set to blow past $150 billion in deficit this year.
23:01Through the border crisis, not despite it.
23:04The government's own establishment can't agree on what China did during Operation Sindur.
23:08Congress has officially and repeatedly called out China's aggression and Pakistan's provocations
23:13and demanded action.
23:15So that needs to be answered.
23:17That needs to be responded.
23:18We not being at the stage of being the most populated country needs to be answered.
23:24I think we need to have a vision and to sit on a table to command in the world is
23:30what
23:30tells if you are a diplomatic clout you have in the world or not.
23:35And that answers what is symbolic today.
23:39But the pre-deceasing issues about China, about Pakistan, about Israel, what our stand has been,
23:46that needs to be answered.
23:48And it's a series that needs to be considered.
23:50It's not a symbolic table initiative, as others have said.
23:54But all these things have to be considered to say where India is currently.
24:01Okay, Ambassador Bhatia, if India had been invited to this meeting, would that automatically have
24:06meant greater diplomatic influence?
24:10No, that is, you know, an imaginary question.
24:14Yes, because it's an imaginary tweet, one would say.
24:17Well, I think we have to be very clear.
24:21We discuss foreign policy and diplomacy on the basis of ground-level facts.
24:27The essential issue that we are discussing is how is India's foreign policy doing in the last
24:35one or two or three decades?
24:37I think we can take the past 25 years and we will come to an objective conclusion that
24:44India's professional class, India's diplomats, India's foreign minister, India's prime minister,
24:49they have all contributed to shaping a very calibrated, a very successful, a very productive
24:56approach to the world.
24:58India's foreign policy is widely admired and appreciated by friends and even adversary.
25:06Look at the bilateral relationship.
25:08Look at the role India is playing in the plurilateral groupings.
25:12Look at how beautifully India ran the presidency of G20 and BRICS.
25:17I have to give you the professional view, as I said, as a former diplomat and as an academic,
25:24that we should be, generally speaking, proud of what has been achieved.
25:28We still have many more challenges.
25:31And the way out is we invite the political class to a series of roundtables in Delhi and
25:38other countries to discuss how the foreign policy is doing and what more needs to be done.
25:44That would befit the experience and maturity of our nation.
25:50All right.
25:51Thank you so much for joining us.
25:52Rakesh Sina, Dr. Deshmukh and Ambassador Bharti.