• 19 minutes ago
Political debate in India over Pakistani minister Musadik Malik's visit to the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum highlights ongoing tensions and protocol.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00The optics, however, have triggered a political storm here in India.
00:04Congress has questioned the invitation to Pakistan,
00:07invoking the Pehelgham terror attack
00:09and accusing the government of going soft on Islamabad,
00:12even taking a swipe at the Prime Minister with a bidhiyani jive.
00:16The government has defended the invitation,
00:18maintaining that all our CO countries
00:20were invited as part of established multilateral practice.
00:25MEA also underlined that the forum is about civilizational dialogue.
00:30Listen in.
00:32We have no difference between Pakistan and Sanskrit and Pakistan.
00:36We have no difference between 100 and 80 years.
00:40We have no difference between 100 and 80 years.
00:41We have no difference between them.
00:49so that they will be in the coming of the country and people in the middle of the country better
00:57support and support.
00:59The S.C.O.C. Civilizational Dialogue of the I.O.G.I.O.G. 21 and 22 November
01:04in Delhi.
01:06This I.O.G.I.O.G.I.O.G.I.
01:08in Pakistan.
01:09And Pakistan is the author of its minister,
01:11the minister, the minister, the minister, the minister,
01:12the minister, the minister, the minister,
01:13the minister, the minister.
01:16He is the minister,
01:18which has cut our teeth from the Indian government.
01:21It has been dicmedic HA,
01:22a few months before.
01:24Despite understanding the details,
01:25he has stood in his awe and said,
01:28The S.C.O.G.I.O.G.I.O.G.I.
01:29People always want to ask Modeiji,
01:31which is water and water inside Pakistan,
01:33which is dry.
01:38Ranyo Padhya, editor of India Today Global
01:41is joining me.
01:41We also have Sandeep Unithan, senior journalist.
01:44Both of them continue to be with us.
01:46Pranayupad, is this a needless controversy?
01:51I won't say that this is a needless controversy
01:54because it's the Congress Party, which is an opposition party,
01:57obviously taking and giving a challenge to BJP,
02:01challenging their compulsions because it is a multilateral forum.
02:06Look, our external affairs minister, Dr. Jaishankar,
02:09visited Pakistan for the SCO meeting,
02:12and Pakistani minister is also visiting.
02:15This does not change the bilateral dynamics of India-Pakistan relation.
02:19And we have seen in the past that, you know,
02:20on the sidelines of the SAC summit or for the SAC engagement,
02:25for the different multilateral forums,
02:26we have engaged with Pakistan,
02:28and successive governments have maintained this thing.
02:30Despite fighting wars with Pakistan,
02:33despite having, you know, all those terror attacks
02:35and the composite dialogue process,
02:37look, as, you know, the former Prime Minister,
02:39Atal Vihari Vajpayee, said that, you know,
02:41you can change your friends, but you can't change your neighbours.
02:44And that remains a compulsion for a country like India
02:47to deal with difficult neighbours.
02:50Okay.
02:50Sandeep, does Pakistan's participation in a multilateral forum
02:54offer an opportunity to convey India's position directly?
02:57Or does Islamabad risk using such platforms to create diplomatic optics?
03:04Well, surely, Maria, they will use this as an opportunity to say that,
03:08you know, to spin it as a big victory back home,
03:11to say that, you know, that invitation amounts to a lot.
03:14It doesn't, actually.
03:15It's just part of Pakistan being part of a multilateral forum.
03:19As Pranay mentioned,
03:21that External Affairs Minister Dr. Jaishankar visited Pakistan.
03:24Now you have the Minister of Pakistan, Musadi, coming here to New Delhi.
03:29It doesn't really change anything.
03:31The bilateral talks have frozen.
03:33The composite dialogue is frozen.
03:35And there you have to give it to the leader of the opposition, Rahul Gandhi,
03:39for saying abroad where he said that, you know, talks and terror,
03:43he indicated the fact that talks and terror do not go hand in hand
03:47until the time that Pakistan doesn't reverse its, you know,
03:50policy of supporting terrorism, state sponsorship of terrorism.
03:54There cannot be any dialogue.
03:56And for that, it has to, you know, deliver on cracking down on the terrorist organizations
04:00which have state support within Pakistan.
04:03That doesn't seem to be happening because for Pakistan, the deep state,
04:07the terror groups are a strategic arm of the state virtually.
04:11So they have no interest in cracking down on them.
04:13And meanwhile, you know, they will put out these little things
04:17and try and spin these as little victories.
04:19India, for India, I think, SEO is a far bigger, you know, grouping for us.
04:25So it's a minor matter that Pakistan happens to be part of the SEO
04:29because we decided to enter the SEO about nine years back in 2017,
04:36realizing that we need to engage with China, Russia and Central Asia.
04:39So the wins of that are, you know, minor compared to this thing
04:43of having Pakistan in the room and, you know, trying to, you know,
04:48manage the optics of such an engagement.
04:50Also, if I may add that, you know, it was India's idea.
04:54India proposed this civilization dialogue among the SEO member state
04:58and that's why it is taking place.
04:59Pakistan is currently holding the chair of SEO.
05:02But this dialogue, the first dialogue is taking place in India
05:04because during the India's presidency of SEO, it was proposed
05:08and that's why India is hosting this kind of meeting
05:09and that is, as Sandeep rightly pointed it out,
05:13that India has a bigger objective
05:15and India has a lot to offer as far as the civilizational heritage
05:18for this entire region is concerned.
05:21All right, Pranay and Sandeep, really appreciate your time.
05:24Thank you so much for joining us.

Recommended