• 17 minutes ago
On *News Today*, Rajdeep Sardesai looks at what went wrong at SpiceJet and why the airline has struggled financially for years. He then turns to Rajasthan, where the Congress made a strong comeback in the panchayat polls, and examines what the results could mean for the 2028 Assembly elections. Finally, Rajdeep speaks with Sam Pitroda about Rahul Gandhi’s meeting with the Indian diaspora and its political significance.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Good evening, hello and welcome. You're with the news today. This is your primetime destination news, newsmakers, talking points.
00:06Our big talking point tonight, SpiceJet, one of India's leading airlines for a long while, is now in a tailspin.
00:16DGCA issues a notice. Is another Indian airline now collapsing?
00:22Captain Gopinath, among my other guests tonight, on the SpiceJet crisis that could affect thousands of passengers.
00:29Also on my show, Sam Pitroda, a man never far away from the news, on what really does Rahul Gandhi
00:36and the Congress gain from his visits to the United States and foreign universities.
00:41Plenty to talk about on the news today, but first as always, let's get cracking with the nine headlines at
00:47nine tonight.
00:49The future of airline SpiceJet hangs in the balance after the DGCA issues a show cause notice over flight cancellations.
00:59And operational lapses. Pilots claim and crew claims they have not been paid their salaries for four months.
01:06India Today's exclusive report.
01:10A day after Prime Minister Modi's stern message to corporates, leader of the opposition Rahul Gandhi claims remarks amount to
01:18a confession on the failing economy, as he calls it.
01:21It says monopolization won't create jobs.
01:24The BJP hits back, saying their record is far better than the Congress on job creation.
01:33The Congress is sweeping the Rajasthan local panchayat polls takes massive lead in the Zilla Parishad and panchayat samiti seats.
01:42BJP even fails to win on Chief Minister Bhajanlal Sharma's home turf in Bharatpur.
01:51Prime Minister Modi inaugurates the first SCO civilizational dialogue forum in Delhi, says dialogue in India during wars along the
02:00globe.
02:00Paya Pakistan minister, who threatened India over the India's water treaties, also attends the summit.
02:06The first Paya Pakistan official since the Operation Sindhu.
02:12Supreme Court allows the lighting of lamps at the controversial Madurai Hill as a one-time measure subject to security
02:20conditions.
02:20The Apex Court clarifies that interim permission should not be construed as a final endorsement.
02:28Cyclone Akwan makes landfall near Gopalpur on the Odisha coast, bringing significant rainfall but no major damage or loss of
02:36life reported so far.
02:37Authorities prepared extensively across Odisha and Andhra coast.
02:43Amidst the war over the Kaveri River, Supreme Court declines to entertain Tamil Nadu's pleas,
02:49seeking a direction to Karnataka to release 11 TMC of Kaveri water to make up for the alleged shortfall in
02:55its state.
02:58Amidst multiple threats to Bollywood celebrities, film body rights to Maharashtra chief minister and Mumbai police chief,
03:05seeks tighter security for Saip Ali Khan, Amitab and Abhishek Bachchan at all shooting sites.
03:13Workers and students flood Italy's streets in protest against Melanie's policies.
03:18Protests turned tense in Rome after a group of students throw firecrackers and glass bottles at the education ministry meeting.
03:29But our top focus tonight is turbulence in the skies, the kind of turbulence which in this holiday winter season
03:38could affect thousands of passengers across the country.
03:43Because one of the leading airlines of India, SpiceJet, is now on the brink of collapse.
03:50That's right, after rampant flight cancellations, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation has finally stepped in.
03:57Today, the DGCA issued a show cause notice to SpiceJet, asking it to submit an operational plan within a week.
04:04In its notice, the DGCA has listed many concerns.
04:09It has highlighted repeated violations of route dispersal guidelines, failure to meet eligibility for international operations,
04:17declining on-time performance, rising delays and cancellations,
04:21and failure to operate as per an approved winter schedule, persistent passenger inconvenience and overseas regulatory concerns over disruptions linked
04:32to delayed payments of airport dues.
04:35So, it's not the first airline and, worryingly, may not be the last, but an airline which is at the
04:41moment threatening now to go belly up.
04:44Remember, SpiceJet has been struggling for the last few months with videos of cancellations going viral every day.
04:50The company board has cleared raising of 5,500 crore rupees now, but the question is, how deep is the
04:58crisis, particularly with rising fuel prices?
05:02Is SpiceJet going to be the latest Indian airline to be grounded?
05:06Our top story tonight is from Amit Bhardwaj's special report.
05:20Such scenes at SpiceJet airline counters at airports are viral every day now.
05:26The low-cost airline, facing severe financial crunches, unable to clear dues at many airports.
05:32Even its employees have allegedly not been paid their salaries for months.
05:36But how deep is the SpiceJet crisis?
05:40In September 2026, overall cancellation rate of scheduled domestic airlines in India stood at 1.15%, but SpiceJet's cancellation rate
05:50stood at a massive 20.29%.
05:55SpiceJet's market share has been shrinking drastically.
05:58In September, SpiceJet was left with only 0.6% market share, down from 3.9% when the year
06:06started.
06:07To give a comparison, SpiceJet, a national player, has a market share lower than that of Star Air, a regional
06:14airline.
06:16With operational disruptions, the passenger load for SpiceJet continued to shrink, while losses kept increasing.
06:23In the last five financial years, SpiceJet has reported massive financial losses, barring financial year 2025.
06:30In 2024-25, it registered net earnings of 58.1 crore.
06:36But only 6.94 million passengers flew SpiceJet in 2025, which is lower than their COVID-era passengers, when airlines
06:46were worst affected.
06:48While SpiceJet is yet to make its financial statement for financial year 2026 public, in the last quarter of 2025
06:56-26, they had carried just 1.68 million passengers.
07:01ACASA, Air India Group and Indigo carried nearly 2.2 million, 11.6 million and 27.7 million passengers respectively
07:11in the same period.
07:15Notably, cancellations and delays of SpiceJet flights are also happening due to non-payment of airport dues.
07:22All major Indian airport operators have put SpiceJet on cash-and-carry mode.
07:27India today reached out to present and former employees of the airline to learn about their troubles.
07:34One of the crew members, who did not want her identity disclosed, said,
07:38We are facing four months of salary delay.
07:41I am going through a lot of financial issues and emotional stress.
07:45It has affected my peace and mental well-being.
07:49One of the pilots, who left SpiceJet in 2026, also sought anonymity while opening up.
07:56Income tax and PF components were deducted from the salary.
07:59They were never deposited with the concerned government departments.
08:03I haven't been able to file my income tax returns this year because of it.
08:07The Airline Pilots Association is raising air safety concerns too.
08:13Airline Pilot Association's Sam Thomas told India Today that persistent delays in salaries
08:18of pilots and cabin crew create financial insecurity, psychological stress and distraction
08:23among safety-critical personnel.
08:26Amidst the deepening financial and operational crisis, the SpiceJet board met on November 18th.
08:31The board passed a proposal to raise 5,500 crore rupees.
08:37Ajay Singh, Chairman and Managing Director, SpiceJet, said in a press note,
08:41We believe this fundraise will provide an important opportunity to rebuild the airline,
08:45strengthen its operations and restore the brand.
08:48We are conscious of the challenges ahead, but we have a clear plan and are focused on putting
08:53the necessary building blocks in place.
08:55Our priority is to execute the plan with discipline and restore SpiceJet's position
09:00as a strong and competitive airline.
09:03India Today has sent a questionnaire to DGCA and Ministry of Civil Aviation on SpiceJet's operations.
09:10India Today has also sent a detailed questionnaire to SpiceJet over a range of issues,
09:14from delay in salaries to air safety.
09:17Her response is awaited.
09:19Can India's aviation sector, the passengers and staffers continue to face the trouble
09:27being caused by the SpiceJet financial crunch, more so in the air safety context?
09:34And why is the DGCA allowing SpiceJet to continue its booking, even when it is not able to continue
09:42with its operations day in, day out, and it has ended up becoming even smaller than a regional
09:49airline operator in India?
09:52With video journalist Manish Bidhudi, this is Amit Bhardwaj, reporting for India Today from Delhi.
09:58Okay, that big SpiceJet story now breaking on the channel.
10:02Let's go straight across to Karishma Asudhani from Business Today.
10:06Karishma, it appears at the moment that SpiceJet could well become the latest Indian carrier
10:12to face serious, serious crisis that could even eventually also possibly result in the airline
10:19collapsing.
10:20How serious is this threat of a collapse of SpiceJet?
10:26Rajdeep, this is very important to understand that the whole SpiceJet crisis is something
10:31that has not just come in this week, it has been building for years.
10:35And what we are now noticing or what has come into light is actually accumulative impact
10:40of the financial distress that it has been living in, unpaid salaries, lessors taking away
10:47their aircrafts, and of course, management, innovate and watch state.
10:52The big question here is that what is the challenge?
10:55It's definitely not that they don't have aircrafts, it's the fact that they don't have cash to convert
11:01it to manage their aircrafts, their fleet, and to take care of the expenditure.
11:06And the ultimate impact has now come on consumers, on passengers.
11:10The big question I think we must ask here is also the role of the regulator, because while I know
11:16that DGCA is not responsible to rescue a private airline, but SpiceJet is an evident issue.
11:22We've been seeing what has the airline been facing in the past few years.
11:26So when the regulator is preparing its winter schedule or summer schedule or looking into
11:34the operations of aircrafts and airlines, then why was SpiceJet given a green light or go-ahead
11:40signal with the schedule if they are not financially capable to handle that, because the ultimate
11:46and the ultimate impact has now come on passengers.
11:49Amit Bhardwaj, you've been tracking this story, you've been working on it for days,
11:53the DGCA has finally responded. Are they serious enough to even consider grounding
11:58the airline if things don't improve?
12:02Rajiv, well, the joke is on the customers for sure, the passengers for sure,
12:05because last time around, you and I were discussing Indigo crisis when the winter schedule was
12:12there, and we had a similar question, which also we asked to the civil aviation minister
12:17as to why, when it was very evident that this crisis is to unfold because of the FDTL norms,
12:22why was so much of winter schedule given to Indigo this time around? This particular crisis,
12:27as Kharishma was indicating that, was building up. Everybody knew that it's going to snowball,
12:33it's going to get even bigger. And as we speak, just understand the crisis. I mean,
12:39I do not see it only as a financial issue, as experts have pointed out. What about air safety
12:46issue? As Kharishma said that it is not the DGCA's responsibility to take out an airline from a
12:51financial crunch in crisis of this sort. But what about the air safety issue? If you have four months
12:58of unpaid salaries, which have spoken to different employees who, on conditions of anonymity,
13:04by the way, Razif, I was actually taken aback for weeks and weeks, I kept on trying several forms and
13:10methods to reach out to the current and ex-employees of Spice, and everybody was tight-lived.
13:15Something is wrong there, because why would people be so scared? That is also a question.
13:22Number one. Number two, four months of unpaid salaries as per the accounts of these employees.
13:28Don't you think this is a air safety issue? Why would you allow the airlines to carry on
13:32operations in this manner and fashion? And I had spoken to somebody very senior within the DGCA
13:38months back, and that person had told me that, yes, it is a air safety issue for us as well,
13:44because the maintenance of the aircraft is something that we need to look at.
13:47So, even after months being passed, why no action is being taken, I would bring you back to that fact.
13:54December 2014, DGCA had stopped SpiceJet from taking advance booking beyond a month.
14:01No such action has been taken even today when we take up this particular issue. Back to you.
14:06Very quickly, Karishma, you know, I spoke to someone senior at SpiceJet. They said the high fuel prices
14:11is at the core of this problem. We are unable to run the airline because of that. Is that an
14:18argument
14:19that business, that civil aviation industry will accept?
14:25Rajdeep, we are talking about an airline that has been in distress since 2014, and that's been more
14:31than a decade, and crude oil prices have only been volatile recently because of the West Asia crisis.
14:37So, as a passenger also, I wouldn't blame the fuel prices as the single-handed issue,
14:43but I think it is more to do with how the management has taken care of the cost structure,
14:50which is a big problem in Indian aviation, and I will not just blame this airline, but prominently this airline.
14:56Okay, I'm going to leave it there. Karishma Asudhani, Amit Bhardwaj, who's been bringing us that big story on SpiceJet.
15:02Good to have both of you on the show. Let me raise these big questions and widen this debate,
15:06because India's civil aviation sector clearly needs several questions that passengers are now asking.
15:11Why is SpiceJet caught in turbulence? Are rising fuel prices threatening the future of airlines?
15:17Has aviation in India slowly but surely become a duopoly?
15:21Joining me now, Captain Gopinath, founder, Air Deccan, one of the earlier entrepreneurs in the private civil aviation sector.
15:27Good to have you, Captain, on the show. Your take, Captain, do you see an inevitability in what's happened with
15:34SpiceJet?
15:34As Karishma was pointing out, this has been building up for years.
15:38Or do you go along with what people at SpiceJet tell me that this is because of rising fuel prices
15:43that we've got caught in this tangle?
15:45Well, I think Karishma is the right analysis. And this has been an airline in a crisis over a decade.
16:01He's a great entrepreneur and survivor. And like a proverbial cat, he has every time landed on his feet.
16:10But I think he has to sense himself when to let go, maybe hand over the complete airline to a
16:20new buyer, do a distressed sale, whatever it takes to save the airline and the jobs and save his reputation
16:32as a great entrepreneur, which probably will be damaged now.
16:36And as you know, in airlines, when flights get cancelled, disrupted, refunds don't come on time, and it all automatically
16:48translates to lower occupancy because people do not book the airlines.
16:51Only the desperate will book it.
16:53And so there is an increasing snowballing crisis, as Amit said, I think the job of the government is not
17:04to save, but the job of the government is also not to wait and watch till it collapses,
17:10because then everybody will be left holding the can, as it happened in the Jetevis case, where the banks took
17:17over and said that they will infuse equity and they took over 51%, they will put the money.
17:23But they continue to behave like lenders and never put the money and the airline collapsed in the bank, so
17:30are left holding the can.
17:31But can I just raise this, the fact is, you know, that India is slowly, our aviation sector is, according
17:40to some, earning the unfortunate tag of being a graveyard of airlines.
17:4620 airlines have collapsed since the 1990s, I can go on with the list, I'll put it out in a
17:52moment, Kingfisher, Jet Airways, go first, we can go on and on.
17:57From high cost competition debt, add to this, the fact that the aviation sector has projected Captain Gopinath to record
18:05a loss of 95 to 105 billion rupees for FY26, despite rising passenger numbers.
18:12Is there something fundamentally wrong, or is this particularly true of an airline like SpiceJet?
18:19Can we make a generalization that the aviation sector itself is becoming a bit of a graveyard?
18:24I look at the loss, you know, look at Air India, look at other airlines, they are all struggling at
18:28the moment.
18:30Yeah, you're right, I think the largest number of tombstones are there for airlines all over the world, probably more
18:38particularly in India.
18:39Now we have a situation because of many bankruptcies by people who didn't take action and time, the entrepreneurs, and
18:49the government, you know, mistaking the airline to the, you know, punishing the airline for the sins of the promoter,
18:58like it happened in the case of Jet Airways or Kingfisher.
19:03I think the job of even a bankruptcy court is to protect it from bankruptcy, and this will create a
19:11monopoly and duopoly, which is already the case because as it is now, SpiceJet is a non-consequential airline, guys,
19:19hardly, from 100 jets, I think it has come down to 20.
19:21And in that 20, you know, all of them are flying. So, this time for both the entrepreneur to realize
19:28that he's in a crisis, and the government to step in, I think like they did in the Satyam's case,
19:33that was the only case where when the Satyam scandal broke, a great enterprise which was created by them, Satyam
19:40brothers at that time, independent of the scandal that they were in, they stepped in and saved a…
19:46No, but is it the job of the government to save an airline? Do you believe it's the job of
19:52the government to save an airline, or are we inevitably heading towards this unhealthy duopoly?
19:59Air India has 26.3% of the domestic market share, Indigo 65.4%. What is the government supposed to
20:05do?
20:06Yeah, the government has a role. If they could save Air India with 60,000 crores debt, the blood is
20:16same, and the assets, or national assets, the blood of the private sector employee.
20:21See, you punish, if there is fraud, as in even in the West, our bankruptcy code is in that, you
20:27separate it. I'm not suggesting there's fraud here, but if there's fraud, you separate it,
20:31and go after the promoter, in whatever manner legally is permissible. But you have to see how to save the
20:37airline, because it's a national asset, and otherwise, you're going to create monopoly, which will be worse, because monopolies are
20:43monsters.
20:44So, I think that's what we are heading to now.
20:46Can I though ask you this? If you were today starting off on entrepreneurship, would you even consider the aviation
20:52sector on a stance, sir?
20:55Absolutely, yes, because from the time the flight was invented by Wright Brothers, everybody is excited to start an airline.
21:04No, but is it a viable industry? Is it, in your view, a viable industry anymore?
21:08Absolutely, absolutely. Though Indigo is now losing some money, the Ryanair, which is the world's, one of the best low
21:16-cost airlines,
21:17which has got 700 Boeings, flies more passengers than all our airlines put together. So, there's also fundamentally something wrong
21:25in our policies,
21:26which is not enabling the growth of this sector, because it is still not considered a critical infrastructure. It's still
21:35considered as a rich man's thing.
21:36I mean, look at the kind of ministers who are, with no derogatory imputation to the present minister, the ministers
21:45of stature are not put into this ministry since independence.
21:51Okay, I'm going to leave it there, Captain Gopinath. I appreciate you joining us here on the show.
21:59You're calling on the government to step in in some form to prevent what you believe is an inevitable, otherwise
22:06inevitable move towards a duopoly,
22:08and even worse, still a possible monopoly. But good to have you on the show. I want to widen this
22:13debate even further.
22:14I'm joined by Vijay Gopalan. He's former CFO at AirAsia India. And I'm joined by Captain Sam Thomas, President Airlines
22:22Pilots Association of India.
22:24I want to come to you, Captain Thomas, first, to just look at the human angle to what is happening.
22:29We are told, and our reporter, Amit Bhardwaj, has got messages from Spice Jets pilots to say they've not been
22:36paid, some of them,
22:37some of the crew have not been paid for months. Is the Airline Pilots Association going to step in,
22:44and raise this issue? And if so, what leverage do you have to actually get those pilots their allowances?
22:52Good evening, Rajdeep. Good evening to Vijay as well. Firstly, the substantial number of Spice Jets staff would like to
23:02thank Amit Bhardwaj
23:04and yourself, Rajdeep, for having taken up this issue finally. And there are multiple aspects to this.
23:12Now, if you see, there are tiles of employees that are suffering at the moment. Firstly, let's look at the
23:20ground staff.
23:21You've seen the videos of irate passengers and the ground staff bearing the brunt of all these disruptions.
23:29The pilots and the cabin crew, the cabin crew are the ones who are silently suffering in this.
23:35The pilots have not been paid for the umpteenth time now. Because every airline that ends up into bankruptcy,
23:43and I hope they don't go into the route of IBC and NCLT, that's the death knell for any airline
23:49if they enter there.
23:50That's a farce that is enacted. However, now, as far as the pilots are concerned, a lot of them have
23:56written to us.
23:57We have written to Spice Jet Management as well as DGCA stating that you cannot keep pilots unpaid and expect
24:06them to come to work every day.
24:09Because at one end, you're enforcing the enforcement arm of the employer by bringing out CARs which say that you
24:20have a six-month notice
24:21and the additional NOC that has to be given to each of the pilots.
24:28Now, when you ask anything to DGCA about the salaries, they say we are not involved as far as the
24:34employment is concerned.
24:35However, when the pilot wants to leave, the DGCA comes up with the mandatory NOC that has to be given
24:43prior to him joining anywhere else.
24:45Now, this is the dichotomy that has been playing out and we expect the DGCA to step up now and
24:56the government of India to wake up,
25:00Ministry of Civil Aviation wake up and not actually believe that India is a graveyard for aviation.
25:06Aviation turbine fuel in itself is not the major issue.
25:10The policies that are run by the Ministry of Civil Aviation are not conducive for airline operations
25:18and a lot is left to be desired as far as even the new policies that are coming up.
25:25So that is one of the key aspects that need to be looked at.
25:29At the same time, please be cognizant of the fact that air safety, flight safety is affected when you have
25:40an employee
25:40who is not being paid for four or five months.
25:44Engineering deficiencies show up in maintenance when the lack of funds are, you know, evident when the operation.
25:52And having said that, I'm very bullish on Mr. Ajay Singh.
25:56I believe that somehow the government of India has been benevolent to him so far.
26:02They must continue.
26:03I don't want to see this airline going into NCLT or any other airline going into NCLT.
26:09The financial part, of course, I can't put it better than Vijay.
26:13I'm sure Vijay will do a much better job.
26:15Let Vijay take that because, you know, you heard Captain Thomas suggesting that the cost of aviation turbine fuel
26:22which accounts for approximately 40% of airline operating costs can rise even further because of the fuel price shocks
26:30is not the reason why an airline is going belly up.
26:34But when I spoke to senior people at SpiceJet, they said that is one of their main struggles because of
26:40the high fuel prices.
26:41Do you go along with that or do you believe there is something now fundamentally wrong with SpiceJet
26:45and it's not just about Indian aviation, it's about a specific airline?
26:50Given the fact that every airline at the moment, most airlines seem to be making huge losses.
26:56Rajdeep, thanks a lot for taking up this issue.
26:58I echo Captain Sam Thomas' sentiment and a pleasure, Captain, to meet you.
27:03Rajdeep, I think there are two quick parts to this.
27:05One is what happened structurally and the second is what went wrong with SpiceJet.
27:10On this aviation ATF issue, look, ATF prices are high and that is contributing to a global, it's a global
27:21issue.
27:22But I completely agree with Captain Sam that the policies around ATF leaves a lot to be desired in our
27:28country
27:28and this has been going on for decades and decades, especially after GST came in.
27:33The fact that we have kept ATF outside GST is a crime, it's a disservice to such a critical industry
27:40is my view.
27:42Secondly, as regards SpiceJet's issue per se, it's a combination of things.
27:49I think one of the, I heard one of the panelists saying that it's not something that's happened over the
27:53last one year.
27:53This has been in the making for about seven years, ever since pre-COVID.
27:57In fact, from 2019 and from 2024, the issue has only been exacerbated.
28:02Having said which, there are a lot of steps that our government should be taking.
28:08They should have learned when Kingfisher folded.
28:10We did.
28:11We should have learned when Aircoaster or Air Pegasus folded.
28:13We did.
28:14We should have learned at least when Jetta was folded.
28:17We did.
28:18We should have learned when SpiceJet went through its first struggle.
28:21We did.
28:23Now, what should they have learned?
28:25What should they have woken up to?
28:27What should government have woken up to?
28:29There are two or three things that I can make it in.
28:31I'll tell you in brief.
28:32Number one, the ATF should have been brought under the GST regime.
28:38Okay.
28:38This has been a clarion call.
28:40Keep that aside.
28:41Secondly, from 2019, ever since Jetta was folded, we were moving towards a duopoly, which was very, very dangerous.
28:47And the problem with the duopoly Rajdeep is, let's take SpiceJet.
28:51SpiceJet raised funds about 2,000, 2,500 crores in 2024.
28:55They kind of wiped their slate clean and they came back into operations.
28:59But every route that they entered, a company with a duopoly, we talk about the largest airline like Indigo,
29:06it's very easy to just dump fares and push them out of competition.
29:09It's the easiest thing to do.
29:11And the best way to tackle some of these things, Rajdeep, is very simple.
29:15Every time a schedule comes up for renewal, and this is my view,
29:18you know, every time a schedule comes up for renewal, like summer schedule or winter schedule,
29:21say that 10 to 15% of the existing slots of Indigo, given that they are monopolistic players,
29:28will go to players who have less than 10%.
29:31So they have primacy over prime slots.
29:33This is one way of evenly distributing the slots.
29:37Secondly, Captain Sam was perfectly right.
29:40This pilot issue is a huge issue.
29:42Now, even if SpiceJet wants to increase their fleet size,
29:46where are they going to go for the crew?
29:47That is because there's a 6-month and 12-month notice period that is required,
29:52whereas the salaries are not regulated by the government.
29:54One thing that I can think of is to say that, you know what,
29:57reduce that mandatory period down to 3 months,
29:59make it a level playing field for all the airlines in the country,
30:02and if somebody goes out, ask them to pay the training costs on a pro-rata basis
30:06so that it's very, very transparent and clear.
30:08A government that can actually say 12 months NOC can actually implement this.
30:12This way, a lot of startup airlines will start coming in.
30:15Today, an airline cannot start because I don't have the crew primarily.
30:19I can go on.
30:20I can give you multiple such examples.
30:21So, you're saying that for all the talk of the Open Skies policy,
30:27the policy has actually favoured large existing players
30:32and is increasingly squeezing out smaller players
30:35and making it more and more difficult for new players to enter.
30:39Am I right, Vijay?
30:40I'm going to slightly rephrase it.
30:42I'm not saying it favours the large players.
30:43I am saying the policy has not evolved
30:46and they've just been a bit lazy about coping up with times.
30:51Oh, slight difference there.
30:52Okay, one final word from you, Captain Thomas.
30:55You made a point that should worry people about pilots themselves
30:58and their psychological and mental well-being
31:01if they are not paid on time, the crew on time.
31:04Do they have any protection in our system?
31:06Do they?
31:07I know what happened when jet airways went belly up.
31:09You know, pilots suddenly found that their lives were totally disrupted
31:13and found it a big struggle to get their lives back on track.
31:17Is there any protection at all that they have
31:19or is it simply market competition and they've got to live with the fact
31:22that when they've signed up,
31:24they've signed up to the possibility of an airline going belly up?
31:28Well, as far as protection is concerned, Rajdeep,
31:31there is no protection in the Indian law, absolutely,
31:34though it is there in paper.
31:35You can go to the Labour Court, you can do whatever you want,
31:38but that is not a solution because your licence lapses every six months.
31:44So, having said that, what the government of India should come forward
31:50is not to save the airline, at least don't destroy airlines.
31:54That is the thing that we can expect.
31:56Now, for instance, in foreign countries,
31:58the low-cost airlines generally operate to airports
32:01with a little bit of a lower standard as far as facilities are concerned
32:07and therefore pay less landing parking charges.
32:10These are huge sort of expenses that come up in the books of the airline.
32:19So, that must be looked at as well.
32:21But as far as, like Vijay said,
32:25let's bring these notice periods down to three months,
32:28keep it transparent.
32:29If the trainee incurs an expense as far as training is concerned,
32:33he repays that back because, Rajdeep, you have to know,
32:37it's only the pilots, even a neurosurgeon does not have a notice period of six months.
32:44Now, if you want to go from Congress to the BJP, it takes you 15 minutes.
32:49And the explanation that is given is basically, you know,
32:52it's so difficult to train a pilot.
32:54I mean, is it easy to train a politician?
32:57I mean, please think about it.
32:58Look at the dichotomy in this.
32:59So, we would expect the government to, you know.
33:03Please look more benevolently onto this
33:06and don't let another airline fold up.
33:08Please step in right now.
33:09Okay. I'm going to leave it there.
33:11You want the government, in a way,
33:13to at least prevent the destruction of airlines and the aviation sector,
33:18which is, in many ways, one of India's stories post-liberalization,
33:22but a story which, at the moment,
33:24is running through a fair degree of turbulence.
33:27Vijay Gopalan, Captain Thomas,
33:28for joining me here on my top story tonight.
33:31Thank you very much.
33:39Okay, let's turn from there to the big story that's breaking,
33:42the political story that's breaking this evening,
33:44because in a major surprise,
33:47the Congress Party has now made big gains
33:49in Rajasthan's Zilla Panchayat and Gram Panchayat elections.
33:54The Congress is building a heavy lead over the ruling BJP
33:58in the Rajasthan Panchayat polls.
34:00This comes as a big setback for the BJP ahead of the next election cycle.
34:05The BJP has lost ground even in Chief Minister Bhajan Lal Sharma's home turf in Bharatpur.
34:10Hanuman Beliwal's RLP and the Bharat Adivasi Party have also made gains.
34:16This is, remember, a Hindi heartland state and ahead of Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand,
34:25which goes to the polls.
34:26How is it being interpreted?
34:28Joining me now is Moshmi Singh.
34:30Moshmi, for the Congress, a rare victory over the BJP.
34:34The BJP has usually won, even in the urban local bodies in Rajasthan,
34:38a few weeks ago, it was the BJP that eventually got most of the boards.
34:43But here, rural Rajasthan has gone the Congress's way.
34:47How is it being seen?
34:49See, clearly, Rajneet, the Congress sees a silver lining
34:53and the timing is just right for the Congress Party.
34:57We've heard the BJP President, Mr. Rajasthan,
35:00saying that perhaps now the Congress can do away with the vote-suri campaign
35:07and accept this victory and stop this frivolous allegation
35:12about the entire electoral rolls being, you know, hudged.
35:17But on the other hand, the Congress says that this is, you know,
35:21handiwork of the state unit that really, you know,
35:25made sure that the electoral rolls were not rigged
35:28and accountability was ensured as far as maintaining the electoral rolls,
35:34the old electoral rolls are concerned.
35:37So, clearly, this is also a vote-suri battle that we are seeing.
35:41But as far as the Bhajan Lal government is concerned,
35:46the Congress feels that this is a referendum on the Bhajan Lal government
35:50and also Prime Minister Narayan Modi's scene is waiting off.
35:54The Congress seems really upbeat.
35:56But the big question really is that we can really maintain that momentum
36:01to the 2028 elections, assembly elections.
36:06And importantly, we've seen KC Venugopal, who has put out a post,
36:11you know, calling out the agrarian crisis, the rural distress,
36:16the unemployment as the major issues that actually gave BJP that drop-in.
36:22Well, we wait and see.
36:23Clearly, big question for the BJP, which it'll have to answer.
36:27Rajasthan is a state which, remember, swings one way or the other every five years.
36:32But how will this defeat be seen by the BJP leadership?
36:37Will it lead to possibly changes in Rajasthan?
36:40We'll wait and see.
36:41Moshmi Singh joining us on that story.
36:47Okay, let's turn from there to another of our top stories
36:51where the leader of the opposition, Rahul Gandhi,
36:54continued with his sharp attacks on the Modi government's foreign policy
36:58while on his visit to the United States,
37:01claiming India has become a side player in global affairs.
37:04Speaking at the University of Chicago during his U.S. visit,
37:08Rahul Gandhi questioned Prime Minister Modi's diplomatic outreach this time,
37:11arguing that personal friendships cannot drive foreign policies.
37:15He even went further than on social media,
37:17sharing a photograph of the Trump-Zi-Putin trilateral in Shenzhen yesterday
37:22and claimed that a Congress-led government would have secured India a seat at the table.
37:27The BJP has rubbished these charges,
37:29claiming it was the Congress Party which failed during the Nehru years
37:33to secure India a place at the U.N. Security Council
37:38and accusing Rahul Gandhi of echoing Pakistan's narrative.
37:43Union Minister Rajuju urging Rahul Gandhi not to make statements against the country
37:49while being overseas.
37:58So as Rahul Gandhi's statements in American universities continue to stir a controversy back home,
38:06joining me now is the Indian Overseas Congress head
38:09and someone who's been, dare I say, Rahul Gandhi's Sherpa when he's in America,
38:14Sam Pitroda joins me.
38:16Good to have you, Mr. Pitroda, on the show.
38:18I want to understand from you,
38:20we are seeing this happening every time Rahul Gandhi comes to the United States
38:24or indeed any foreign university.
38:26The BJP immediately attacks him.
38:29What purpose do you believe are Rahul Gandhi's visits to these foreign universities
38:35where he takes on the Modi government really achieving?
38:40Well, first of all, this trip,
38:43he addressed a group at Columbia
38:47and a group at University of Chicago.
38:50Both were very well received.
38:54We believe the main purpose of these visits
38:58is to have interactions on global platform
39:02with global experts
39:04like this professor at University of Chicago.
39:08Rahul Gandhi does not get an opportunity like this in India
39:12at the universities.
39:14He's not allowed
39:16to have interactions at the universities,
39:18the kind of one he had here.
39:21In addition,
39:25not only we reach out to the larger audience,
39:29but we also get to learn
39:33from the international community
39:34because India is a global player.
39:38We are the largest democracy in the world
39:41and we need to really be in touch
39:45with many other views.
39:48And it's very productive for us.
39:51It is very productive for the university,
39:53students, professionals.
39:55And he gets an opportunity to express his views
40:00with a person.
40:01But you see,
40:02it's those very views that are contentious.
40:05For example,
40:06it's one thing,
40:06he has every right to go to a foreign university,
40:10criticize the Modi government.
40:11But the remarks that you make
40:13when he says,
40:14for example,
40:15at Columbia University,
40:16India is sitting on an economic disaster
40:19or when he comes to the University of Chicago,
40:22comments that India is becoming
40:23a side player in global affairs.
40:25When you make assertions,
40:28then you have to be open,
40:30you have to open yourself to scrutiny.
40:32You can't.
40:34You can,
40:34he does.
40:35He's open to scrutiny.
40:37Who said he's not open to scrutiny?
40:40Invite him
40:40at a debate like this
40:42at Indian University
40:43and he will talk.
40:46Why don't you invite him
40:47at the,
40:47you know,
40:49one of the best universities in India
40:50for a dialogue like this.
40:52Maybe you invite
40:54Mr. Modi as well.
40:56And then we can have a dialogue.
40:58He has been asking for that.
41:00No,
41:00he's been asking,
41:01he's been asking for a public debate.
41:03The question is,
41:05are you saying therefore
41:06that Rahul Gandhi
41:07is going,
41:07coming,
41:08or going,
41:09or coming to these foreign universities
41:10because he doesn't get
41:11a similar opportunity in India?
41:13If he had a choice,
41:14he would rather say the same,
41:15he would rather speak
41:16in the same language
41:17here in India?
41:18Absolutely.
41:19Give him an opportunity
41:20at the university
41:21or this kind of a platform.
41:22But that's not the only reason
41:24for going abroad.
41:25Reason for going abroad
41:26is also to meet
41:27the Indian overseas congress leaders.
41:30It is also to interact
41:31with many others.
41:32You know,
41:34it is not just that
41:35we meet only with two professors.
41:37But there are,
41:38there are those who will say
41:39that when he,
41:40you know,
41:40he goes to these universities,
41:44challenges,
41:44questions the government,
41:45he doesn't offer
41:46what his vision is.
41:47So it's one thing,
41:48for example,
41:49no, no,
41:49for him to say that
41:51Indian economy
41:52is being destroyed.
41:54What is his vision
41:55for a more inclusive economy?
41:57What is his vision
41:58on foreign affairs?
42:00Criticizing a government
42:00is one thing,
42:02articulate your vision
42:03is another.
42:05Give him a space
42:06and ask that question.
42:07He has a vision.
42:08He has an answer.
42:10Okay?
42:11I'm happy to interview him here.
42:13I'm happy to give him
42:14a platform
42:15at our India Today conclave.
42:16He doesn't seem...
42:17It's not an interview.
42:18No, he...
42:19It's not an interview.
42:20Yes.
42:21It is a pub...
42:22Plus, it is not about
42:23India conclave.
42:24Hmm.
42:25Okay?
42:27For example,
42:28I have never...
42:29I have worked in India
42:30for 45 years.
42:32Hmm.
42:33Okay?
42:33I have never been invited
42:34to Indian conclave.
42:36What are you talking?
42:38When I was chairman
42:39of the Knowledge Commission,
42:41chairman of Innovation Council.
42:43Okay?
42:46So, what do you expect
42:47me to believe?
42:49Is it fair?
42:50It's not fair.
42:52Okay?
42:52Why would I go to that?
42:54Why would I even request
42:55Adha Gandhi to go to that?
42:56No, there were always...
42:59platforms where the likes of you...
43:00Get the university.
43:01There were always platforms
43:02where the likes of you
43:03were given an opportunity.
43:04But beyond that,
43:06but beyond that,
43:06the question is,
43:08do you believe that,
43:10you see,
43:10if he goes abroad,
43:12his critics say
43:12by going abroad
43:13and criticizing the Modi government,
43:15he is in a way
43:16criticizing India
43:18and lowering India's image
43:20in America.
43:21What will you tell those critics?
43:23First,
43:23I would say
43:24Modi government
43:24is not India.
43:27Get rid of this idea
43:29in your mind
43:29that Modi government
43:31is India.
43:32India is much more bigger.
43:36India has
43:39not only 1.5 billion people,
43:41many states,
43:42many languages,
43:43so don't expect
43:47that Modi government
43:49is India
43:50is something
43:50everybody shouldn't believe.
43:52So let's start with that.
43:55It is okay
43:56for opposition leader
43:57to criticize the government.
43:58That's his job.
44:00What are you talking about?
44:04If you feel little
44:05and if you get hurt,
44:07your self-esteem is low.
44:10Okay?
44:12Anything you say,
44:13you get hurt.
44:14You are ready to be hurt.
44:17You are waiting to be hurt.
44:19Have a big heart.
44:22Take criticism.
44:24You are in power.
44:25So it's okay
44:26for people to criticize you.
44:27Is that your message
44:28to Prime Minister Modi
44:29whom you said
44:30only the other day
44:31you had a good relationship with?
44:33Is that your message
44:35to Prime Minister Modi
44:36or to the government
44:37in power in general
44:38or whoever is in power?
44:39To everybody
44:40who is in power,
44:42you must accept criticism.
44:46Not react.
44:47Don't assume
44:48that criticizing you
44:49is criticizing a nation.
44:52But criticism
44:52has to be based on facts.
44:54Criticism then has to,
44:55you have to be able to,
44:57if you are in a college
44:58like Columbia or Chicago,
45:00you are going to have
45:00to make your criticism
45:01based on hard fact.
45:03It can't be rhetoric.
45:04That's why he said it.
45:05He has facts.
45:06That's why he said it.
45:08Okay.
45:08How do you assume
45:09that he doesn't have facts?
45:12I want him to articulate them
45:14his vision better
45:15maybe then.
45:16Give him a platform
45:17with the university,
45:19with students.
45:21Do the debate there
45:22exactly like we did
45:23at Columbia
45:24or at University of Chicago.
45:27Invite him to,
45:28you know,
45:28a large student crowd
45:29on campus
45:32and have a comparable,
45:33you know,
45:34conversation.
45:35Sure,
45:35he'll be happy.
45:36I'm sure.
45:38You know,
45:39but you see in India
45:39everybody
45:40is very quick
45:42to criticize.
45:44The media also is
45:48sort of designed
45:50to create controversy
45:51because it comes
45:52from the top.
45:53Hate idea
45:54comes from the top.
45:56And you can create hate
45:58by creating controversy.
46:00So media
46:01is always looking
46:01for controversy.
46:02Mr. Petroda,
46:03why did you say this
46:03in 2029,
46:052025,
46:0619,
46:07you know,
46:07on February 10th?
46:08I don't care.
46:11I mean,
46:11all media guys
46:12will tell me.
46:13Are you not affected,
46:15Sam Petroda,
46:15every time you
46:18get yourself
46:19dragged into a controversy
46:20and willy-nilly
46:21the Congress party
46:22gets dragged
46:23into a controversy
46:24that Sam Petroda
46:25ahead of Rahul Gandhi's
46:26visit is seen
46:27to be exchanging
46:29Diwali greetings
46:29with Prime Minister Modi.
46:31What's the message
46:31being sent out?
46:32I don't care
46:34about these things.
46:35I do what is right
46:36for me to do.
46:39Okay.
46:40I have set up
46:40principles of my own
46:43rooted in truth,
46:44trust,
46:45love,
46:46diversity,
46:47respect,
46:47dignity.
46:49Okay.
46:50I follow those.
46:51I don't care
46:52what anybody else
46:52will say.
46:53They may not have
46:53the same principle.
46:55Can I ask you
46:58therefore in conclusion,
46:59if you had one piece
46:59of advice,
47:00you seem to have
47:00given a piece of advice
47:01to Prime Minister Modi
47:02and those in power
47:03that have a big heart,
47:05learn to accept criticism.
47:06What would your one
47:07piece of advice
47:08be to Rahul Gandhi?
47:11No,
47:11keep at it.
47:12Keep what you're doing.
47:13You're doing a good job.
47:15Keep at it
47:15as a leader of opposition.
47:17Wish you all the best.
47:20Does he need to do
47:21anything differently
47:21you think at all?
47:23Does he need to do,
47:24does he need to perhaps
47:25take up issues
47:26other than the ones
47:27he is at the moment?
47:28What would,
47:29I mean,
47:29surely you have
47:30one piece of advice
47:31for him?
47:33Look,
47:34even my own children
47:35don't take my advice.
47:37But you can still give it.
47:39But you can still give it.
47:40So I don't give them.
47:41I don't give anybody advice.
47:42You know,
47:43look at my life.
47:44If you want to
47:45learn something
47:46from my life,
47:47fine.
47:47If you want to
47:48hate something
47:48from my life,
47:49that's also fine.
47:50But you know,
47:51you know Prime Minister
47:52Modi well,
47:53reasonably well,
47:54and you know
47:54Rahul Gandhi well.
47:55What's the difference
47:56between the two?
47:58And I'm not trying
47:59to stir a controversy.
48:00I'm trying to
48:01understand from you.
48:03Huge difference.
48:04You know,
48:05I know Rahul Gandhi
48:06reasonably well.
48:07He's a deep thinker,
48:09contrary to what
48:10people think.
48:12He's analytical.
48:13He's strategic.
48:15He reads a lot.
48:16His depth of knowledge
48:18is phenomenal
48:19in many areas,
48:21whether it is
48:22how drone works
48:23to how
48:26space shuttle works
48:27to how
48:29societies
48:30operate in different
48:31parts of the world.
48:32His knowledge of,
48:33for example,
48:33yesterday we had a long,
48:35just he and I
48:35had a long conversation
48:36on Genghis Khan.
48:39And I tell you
48:40the amount of
48:42information he has
48:43on Genghis Khan,
48:44Genghis Khan's family,
48:46father, son,
48:47how they organize
48:48their military and all.
48:49I learned a lot.
48:51I was very impressed.
48:52But then social,
48:53social media,
48:54which,
48:54which clips various
48:55bites of what
48:56he's been saying
48:57in university,
48:57seems to have a very
48:58different opinion
48:59that Rahul Gandhi
49:00is incoherent.
49:02It depends on,
49:03it depends on who is,
49:04you see,
49:04you put 100 guys
49:05to work on social media
49:08and they will create
49:09that,
49:09you know,
49:09atmosphere says,
49:10I don't like
49:10Sam Petra's beard.
49:13Why pay attention
49:14to all this crap?
49:16Okay,
49:16these are paid.
49:17I don't even read
49:18anything written about me.
49:19I don't care.
49:21Okay,
49:21okay,
49:22it has nothing to do
49:23with,
49:23you know,
49:24what people think
49:24or what opinion
49:25has been created,
49:26what is on Facebook,
49:28what is on Twitter,
49:29what is on Instagram.
49:30I don't care.
49:32Okay,
49:32I have to do
49:33what I have to do.
49:34It is your job
49:35to criticize,
49:36are you meaning
49:37somebody else's job
49:38to criticize?
49:39I am not going
49:40to be affected
49:41by that.
49:43So,
49:43you said Rahul Gandhi
49:45is very,
49:46is actually
49:47a deep thinker.
49:48What about
49:48Prime Minister Modi?
49:51I know him more
49:52from my social interaction.
49:55I said it earlier.
49:56I have not,
49:58you know,
50:00gone into his
50:01work in detail,
50:03but he should debate.
50:04I don't understand
50:05why he doesn't have
50:05press conferences.
50:07I just cannot
50:08understand that.
50:09You are calling
50:10for a US president?
50:11Prime Minister of a country,
50:12no,
50:12no,
50:12hold on.
50:13Prime Minister of a country
50:15for 14 years
50:16in power and not have
50:20and not have one single
50:20open conference
50:22with people,
50:23press,
50:25interaction,
50:26fireside chats.
50:27It's just
50:28unthinkable for me.
50:31He's done interviews.
50:33He's done interviews.
50:34He says,
50:35I do interviews
50:35before elections.
50:37Interviews are different.
50:38They're all pep.
50:39They're all,
50:40you know,
50:41bogus according to me.
50:43Pardon me for saying it.
50:45Okay?
50:45Have live conversation
50:47with larger group of people.
50:50Interview guy
50:50might only tell you
50:51what question
50:51he's going to ask
50:52and also you can prepare
50:53all the answers in advance.
50:54What are you talking about?
50:56They're not
50:57same thing.
50:58Okay.
51:00Sam Petroda
51:01for joining me.
51:03As always,
51:04good to have you on the show.
51:06Stay well
51:06and stay warm
51:08in Chicago.
51:09Good to have you on the show.
51:10Thank you very much.
51:11Bye.
51:12Good to see you.
51:13Okay.
51:13Just about enough time
51:14to end tonight
51:15with our special series
51:16right through this week.
51:17Krishi Veers
51:18or Farmer Heroes
51:19where we bring you stories
51:21of farmers
51:21who have boosted productivity
51:23and incomes
51:23through innovation.
51:25Today we tell you
51:25about former army officer
51:27Subhash Deshwal
51:28who started farming
51:29after he retired
51:30from service.
51:31He's now earned
51:32the nickname
51:32the Carrot King.
51:34Take a look.
51:46Jai Jawan, Jai Kisan
51:48Famous words
51:49of Lal Bahadur Shastri
51:52Today,
51:53a living example
51:54of that
51:54is retired
51:55Lieutenant Colonel
51:56Subhash Deshwal.
51:58After serving
51:59in the army
52:00for 21 years,
52:01he opened
52:03a new front
52:03agriculture.
52:06In 1998,
52:08he started farming
52:09by leasing
52:1050 acres
52:11in Bulansheir
52:12in Uttar Pradesh.
52:14Suffered losses
52:15for four years
52:16but giving up
52:18was not
52:19in his nature.
52:20In 2002-2003,
52:22he started cultivating
52:24carrots
52:24on two acres.
52:26This experiment
52:27proved
52:27a turning point.
52:28The journey
52:30that began
52:31with two acres
52:32has reached
52:331,500 acres.
52:35He has formed
52:36his own company
52:37involving
52:38hundreds of farmers,
52:40establishing
52:41a coal storage
52:42capacity
52:43of 25,000 tons,
52:45transforming farming
52:47into a successful
52:48business model
52:49worth cross.
52:52Subhash Deshwal
52:54has proved
52:54that a farmer's
52:55true strength
52:56lies not just
52:58in their land
52:58but also
53:00in their vision,
53:02their use of technology
53:03and their grasp
53:04of the market.
53:07Bureau Report,
53:08India Today.

Recommended