• 41 minutes ago

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:05A cold morning in March 2013.
00:11At St Bartholomew's Church in Winchester, the rector is preparing for an unusual day.
00:25Gathering here is a team of local historians, archaeologists and a bishop.
00:31May God's peace be in our hearts. May God's peace be with us in our homes.
00:37This group is hoping to resolve a long-standing mystery about this unmarked grave in their local parish church.
00:52To some, what these archaeologists are doing may seem like sacrilege.
01:00But this could be the culmination of an incredible story that began over a thousand years ago.
01:07I can see Oscoxa, there's a humerus down there, there's a mandible, tibia, ephemera.
01:17For 150 years, it's been claimed that this unmarked grave contains the remains of one of England's greatest kings.
01:26The man who laid the foundations of the English nation.
01:30Alfred the Great.
01:32Oh, that was extraordinary.
01:35Oh, wow.
01:37Died by moving indeed.
01:41No one knows for sure where Alfred the Great's remains lie buried.
01:46So why does the team believe that these might be his bones?
01:50And why would they be mixed together with other skeletons in this unmarked grave?
02:01To answer these questions, I'm going to explore the story of Alfred's life and death.
02:11I'll team up with specialists to test the bones.
02:18And we'll discover how they came to be buried in the graveyard of this modest parish church.
02:25And whether they really are the remains of King Alfred the Great.
02:31This is an extraordinary historical mystery concerning a great Anglo-Saxon king.
02:37If it hadn't been for Alfred, we would probably have a different national identity.
02:43We might even speak a different language.
02:46Alfred the Great was a hugely significant leader in our history.
02:49So it's important that we find out the truth about the remains exhumed from the unmarked grave.
02:55And if they do turn out to be those of Alfred, then they can be re-buried with all the
03:00dignity they deserve,
03:02well over a thousand years after his death.
03:22On the 26th of October 899, the people of Wessex were in mourning for the death of their king.
03:30A grand procession bore the body of King Alfred through the streets of Winchester, the royal capital of Wessex.
03:40It was a fitting tribute to the king who had forged the beginnings of the English nation.
03:46Alfred had bound his people together through the power of language, religion and military force.
03:56This is precisely the sort of place where you would expect to find a great king buried, Winchester Cathedral.
04:02But in fact, this great cathedral wasn't even built until two centuries after Alfred's death.
04:20When Alfred was buried in 899, it was at the Anglo-Saxon Oldminster, a much smaller church.
04:30It stood on a site right next to this cathedral.
04:34If you look down there, you can see where the foundations of the Old Minster have been picked out in
04:40brick in the cathedral lawns.
04:42And you can also see that it's been orientated on a slightly different direction.
04:55But Alfred didn't rest in peace in the Old Minster for long.
05:01Before his death, Alfred had been in the process of commissioning a new monastery, the New Minster, right next door
05:08to the Old Minster.
05:10He wanted it to become a mausoleum for him and his family.
05:15It was Alfred's dying wish to be buried in the New Minster.
05:19So in honour of his father, Alfred's son, Edward, completed the building.
05:23And in 903, Alfred's remains were exhumed just four years after his burial, together with those of his wife who
05:30had died the previous year.
05:31And with great ceremony, they were carried in procession from the Old Minster to the New, and there reinterred.
05:38But that was only the start of the story.
05:41Alfred's remains weren't just exhumed once, but at least three times during the course of the next thousand years.
05:53The team leading the exhumation at St Bart's Church wants to find out if this really is the final resting
05:59place of King Alfred and his family.
06:03But before any work can begin on the bones, they have to wait for the Church of England to give
06:08permission for scientific testing to go ahead.
06:23For five months, the bones are securely stored at the University of Winchester.
06:31Finally, in August 2013, permission is granted.
06:39Dr Katie Tucker can begin the process of unlocking their secrets.
06:47Today, I've been able to start washing the bones.
06:54Essentially, we just use normal tap water and soft toothbrushes to wash the bones with, and just very, very gently
07:01cleaning away any soil or any mud.
07:04To get them as clean as they can possibly be, to look at them properly for an analysis.
07:13To be able to actually look at the bones properly for the first time, to be able to get the
07:17process underway,
07:18it's actually very exciting and it's very interesting already.
07:22There's the potential that these could be, remain some very, very important individuals in the history of this country.
07:41Alfred the Great was born in 849 in the town of Wantage, now in Oxfordshire.
07:49He was born the son of Æthelwulf, King of Wessex.
07:53As the youngest of five brothers, Alfred was never expected to become King.
08:01Today, we would scarcely recognise the England that Alfred was born into.
08:06In fact, it was a land of many kingdoms and many kings.
08:10Post-Roman Britain had been invaded by a succession of tribes from Northern Europe.
08:15Jutes, Angles and Saxons.
08:17By the 9th century, there were four Anglo-Saxon kingdoms in England.
08:21Mercia, East Anglia, Northumbria and Wessex.
08:28In the 850s, these four kingdoms would come under increasing attack from another invading force.
08:37The Vikings.
08:39Alfred would grow up in the shadow of the Viking threat.
08:47Alfred is the only English king to be named the Great.
08:51But we know very little about his formative years.
08:55The information we do have comes from the writings of a monk called Asser from St David's in Wales.
09:02In later life, Alfred commissioned him to be his biographer.
09:07Asser tells us that Alfred was ignorant of letters throughout his childhood and that for all of his life, he
09:13regretted not having had the benefit of an education.
09:16But the story goes that his mother, Osber, had a book, a treasured book of poems.
09:22And that one day, she said to her sons that whichever one of them could learn the poems by heart
09:27could keep the book.
09:29So, dutifully, Alfred set to work.
09:31And there came the day when he was able to demonstrate that he could indeed perform all of the poems
09:36in the book.
09:36And so he kept it.
09:37This love of literature and of learning was a character trait.
09:41And it contributed to the making of a great king.
09:51Another powerful influence on Alfred came not in England, but hundreds of miles away, in Rome.
10:03In the 9th century, Rome was the centre of the Western world and of the Christian faith.
10:17The Anglo-Saxons had accepted Christianity as their primary religion just 200 years earlier.
10:23But they were soon enthusiastic about making pilgrimages to Rome.
10:27Alfred's father was no exception and he sent young Alfred on two visits to the city.
10:31The first in 853, when the boy was just four years old.
10:35These visits to the most impressive and powerful city in the Western world
10:39made a huge impression on the boy who would be king.
10:50This was a city of towering stone, quite unlike the simpler buildings back home.
11:04Alfred almost certainly stayed somewhere around here, in what was once a fully fledged Saxon quarter.
11:10It was founded by Saxons who came to Rome on pilgrimage and on business.
11:15And over time it became a permanent Saxon base.
11:18Which is why it's still called Borgo today, from the Anglo-Saxon word borough, meaning a fortified town.
11:24And Sassia, from the word Saxon, is still seen on street signs around here.
11:36In the 9th century, Rome suffered repeated raids by Saracen bandits.
11:43One attack had terrorised the city just a few years before Alfred's first visit.
11:49The solution was to build a network of giant walls, and this is part of them here.
11:54They were built by Pope Leo IV.
11:56And in 853, the year of Alfred's first visit to Rome,
12:01Leo initiated a tradition of barefoot walks around the walls,
12:03praying for the protection of the city as he did so.
12:06This vivid display of Christian faith coupled with military readiness
12:10made a lasting impression on Alfred.
12:13It shaped his thinking as an adult, as a warrior and as a king.
12:23Then came the real reason for Alfred's visit.
12:26The moment that probably impressed the young boy more than any other.
12:30You have to try and imagine what it must have been like for the boy.
12:34Alfred's only four years old at this point,
12:36and ushered into the presence of the Pope himself.
12:39What an occasion!
12:40Asser tells us that the Pope anointed the child Alfred as king,
12:44ordaining him properly, received him as an adoptive son and confirmed him.
12:53As Alfred's biographer, Asser was possibly being a little bit creative with the truth here,
12:59to build up Alfred's legend.
13:01It seems unlikely that the Pope would have anointed Alfred as king.
13:06But we do know that a ceremony took place.
13:09In a letter to Alfred's father,
13:11Pope Leo confirms that it had diplomatic as well as spiritual significance.
13:18The Pope wrote that we have decorated him as a spiritual son,
13:22with the dignity of the belt and the vestments of the consulate.
13:26This may have been a special ceremony to honour a son of the Royal House of Wessex.
13:30It could, possibly, have been papal recognition of Alfred as a potential future king.
13:36Whatever it really meant, it clearly had a huge significance for young Alfred,
13:41because he was to grow into a committed, devout Christian,
13:44who absolutely believed in his divine right to be king.
14:02Back in the lab, Dr Katie Tucker continues her examination of the exhumed bones.
14:09I think we've got bones from adult individuals, both males and females represented,
14:15and it's looking like we've probably got five or six individuals,
14:21mostly cranial remains and long bones, though we do have pieces of the pelvis,
14:26and quite a few small bones, like quite a few ribs, bones of the hands and feet,
14:31parts of the spine, but it does seem to be largely cranial remains and long bones that we have.
14:41We do need to separate them out to try and work out which bones go with different sets of remains,
14:49to see if we can get different individuals.
14:53I have to be scientific about it and remember that all human remains are essentially the same.
14:59You have to treat them all with the same amount of respect.
15:05It will take two weeks to piece the skeletons together.
15:09If one of them turns out to be King Alfred, it will have been on an extraordinary journey.
15:22Buried first in Winchester's old Minster in 899,
15:27Alfred was exhumed and reburied next door in the new Minster just four years later.
15:33But Alfred's bones would soon be disturbed for a second time.
15:38In 1066, William the Conqueror invaded England.
15:43The country he captured was a valuable prize.
15:46It was one of the best organised states in Europe,
15:50with a reliable currency and an efficient centralised legal system.
15:56This was a great triumph for William.
15:59But for Anglo-Saxon England, it was a catastrophe.
16:04The Anglo-Saxon aristocracy was cut down at the Battle of Hastings
16:08and in their place came Norman nobles who took control of the country
16:12and crushed any opposition violently.
16:16King William stamped his authority by building stone castles all over the country
16:20that dominated the landscape.
16:22The Normans also tore down the Saxon churches
16:25and replaced them with their own towering cathedrals,
16:29like this one at Winchester.
16:33First, the Normans demolished the old Minster.
16:37Then, in 1109, they destroyed the new Minster,
16:41the church where Alfred and his wife lay buried,
16:44along with their son, Edward the Elder.
16:51The monks moved to a new home, Hyde Abbey.
16:54It was built on farmland outside the city walls.
16:58This gatehouse is one of the last fragments of Hyde Abbey still standing.
17:03According to the Anglo-Saxon chronicles,
17:05In 1110, in the presence of William the Conqueror's son Henry I and his Queen Maud,
17:11the monks walked in procession to their new home,
17:14carrying the remains of King Alfred, his wife Aylesworth,
17:17and members of the royal family.
17:23The monks carried the remains to the new Hyde Abbey.
17:31And the journey ended here, where the high altar of Hyde Abbey used to stand.
17:37Alfred and his family were entombed in sepulchres,
17:39beneath the floor and in front of the high altar,
17:42a final resting place, fit for a king.
17:49Alfred's bones would lie undisturbed under the high altar of Hyde Abbey
17:53for the next four centuries.
18:06Back in 868, the young Alfred came to a very different church,
18:11a small wooden Anglo-Saxon church, much like this one in Essex.
18:21Alfred was about to enter a diplomatic alliance with the neighbouring kingdom of Mercia.
18:27An act which would begin the process of unifying the four Anglo-Saxon kingdoms.
18:37In 868, Alfred, accompanied by members of his family,
18:41came to be married to a member of the nobility.
18:44Her father was a Mercian nobleman.
18:46Her mother was a member of the Mercian royal family.
18:49The bride's name was Ailsworth.
18:57Alfred's marriage to Ailsworth was a diplomatic coup that would increase his power and influence.
19:04But at the wedding feast, Alfred was suddenly struck down with excruciating stomach pain.
19:10He would never fully recover.
19:13Asser said that the pain plagued him remorselessly by day and night.
19:19Asser tells us Alfred was in so much pain his guests thought it must be witchcraft or perhaps even the
19:25devil's work.
19:26More recently, experts have suggested that the ailment that struck him down and affected him for years to come
19:32might have been Crohn's disease, which is a digestive disorder that, amongst other things, causes severe stomach pain.
19:38In any event, it was so bad that Alfred wrote to rulers and physicians all across Europe in hope of
19:44a cure.
19:54Despite his chronic illness, Alfred outlived his older brothers.
19:58One by one, they became king.
20:01One by one, they died.
20:06So, in 871, just three years after his wedding, the youngest son, who was never expected to rule, took the
20:15throne of Wessex.
20:19Alfred was immediately called upon to defend his kingdom.
20:23By the time of Alfred's coronation, the Vikings had cut a swathe across the kingdoms of England.
20:29East Anglia and Northumbria were the first to fall.
20:34Mercia fell next.
20:36Then the Vikings turned their full force on the only remaining English kingdom, Wessex.
20:44Alfred was driven into hiding in a wasteland known as the Somerset Levels.
20:53Today, the Somerset Levels are dominated by farmland, flat farmland, as far as the eye can see.
20:59But in the ninth century, when Alfred came to power, this was primarily marshland.
21:04And it was just after he had taken the throne that he faced one of his greatest challenges.
21:10Alfred had fought alongside his brothers, so he was no stranger to the battlefield.
21:14But in the year 875, a new foe appeared on the horizon.
21:19A Viking warlord called Guthrum.
21:22And in 878, when Alfred was celebrating the Yuletide at Chippenham,
21:27Guthrum and his men mounted a surprise attack.
21:29And it was into this terrain that Alfred fled, in fear of his life.
21:43This was Alfred's lowest point as king.
21:50With a core band of men, he was forced to set up a secret fortified base, deep within the wetlands
21:57of Somerset.
22:00When Alfred was here, this landscape was a watery maze of rivers and little streams,
22:06marshland, ponds, reed beds and little islands.
22:10In fact, it was the perfect place to hide.
22:20Alfred found a way through the treacherous bogs and marshes.
22:24And right in the middle of it all, he made his camp.
22:28On a low-lying hill called the Isle of Athelmy.
22:33He rebuilt his forces and waited for an opportunity to strike back at the Vikings.
22:41According to one of the best known legends about Alfred,
22:43it's around here that he sought shelter from a farmer's wife
22:47and then inadvertently let her cakes burn because he was too distracted worrying about his own future.
22:54It's almost certainly a myth and possibly drawn from Norse legend.
22:58But archaeological digs up here have found not just the remains of an abbey founded by Alfred,
23:04but also traces of iron smelting,
23:06which makes it possible that he and his men were smelting weapons
23:10while they spent time up here in a temporary camp.
23:16In May 878, Alfred decided to make his move.
23:21He rallied his forces and Asser says he was joined by
23:24all the inhabitants of Somerset and Wiltshire and Hampshire.
23:33The precise location of the battlefield has never been identified,
23:37but it's thought to have taken place down here on the low ground.
23:40It takes its name from the nearby village of Eddington.
23:47Asser writes that Alfred destroyed the Vikings with great slaughter and pursued those who fled,
23:53hacking them down.
24:02At the Battle of Eddington, Alfred won a stunning victory for Wessex and for Anglo-Saxon England.
24:12According to local folklore, this white horse was cut in the 18th century to commemorate the victory,
24:18a fitting tribute.
24:20In the aftermath of the battle, Alfred persuaded Guthrum to convert to Christianity.
24:26With Alfred acting as godfather to Guthrum, all of it taking place amid much feasting and celebration.
24:34The two soon agreed to divide the country.
24:38Alfred would keep Wessex to the south-west, Guthrum, the lands the Vikings had conquered, to the north-east.
24:47In battle, and through diplomacy, Alfred had established himself as the king above all the other kings in the land.
24:55And the nation had taken a step closer to being a united England.
25:12In Winchester, Dr Katie Tucker has finally assembled all the bones found in the unmarked grave.
25:21I must admit my first reaction is I'm amazed by how much is here.
25:26It's a lot of bones from the individuals.
25:28Well, we have five skulls, you can see here.
25:32And then we have the remains of six post-cranial skeletons, so the rest of the skeleton that isn't the
25:38skull.
25:39Is it both sexes represented here?
25:41Yes, we do have males and females. This individual is definitely a female.
25:46You can see the pelvis is very, very wide.
25:50And of course they would generally tend to be smaller than males.
25:53So it's one woman definitely.
25:55And then the likelihood that it's five males.
25:59We have a definite male here.
26:02This one, probably a male.
26:07And this individual is also probably a male.
26:11So, based on that, this could be Alfred.
26:15That could be, that could be.
26:17That could be, and this one definitely not.
26:20That one's definitely female, yes.
26:22And when you look at these skeletons, what story do they tell about the kind of lives lived by the
26:29people?
26:30For such a small number of individuals, they've got a lot going on in terms of disease.
26:34You can see the vertebrae.
26:36You can see they're all fused together into one lump.
26:40And this is because all the ligaments that attach all the vertebrae together and the tendons, they've all turned to
26:47bone.
26:48They've all ossified.
26:49Right.
26:50So it would have left the individual with very, very limited movement.
26:55Surely that makes it unlikely that this would be Alfred.
26:59There are historical reports that Alfred had some form of chronic health problem.
27:04It suggested maybe it was Crohn's disease.
27:07But that, you probably would not be able to see that in the skeleton.
27:12So in terms of the search for Alfred and his relatives, what is next?
27:16Well, the next stage is to take some samples for radiocarbon dating.
27:20So actually be able to work out the age of the bones from bone samples.
27:34By the early 16th century, we know that Alfred's remains had twice been exhumed and reburied.
27:40They were now buried with those of his family beneath the high altar of Hyde Abbey.
27:44But the story was about to take another extraordinary turn.
27:55Hyde Abbey was about to fall victim to one of the greatest acts of state vandalism England had ever seen.
28:02Vandal in chief in Hampshire was one Thomas Roisley, who built himself a hunting lodge here at Bewley.
28:10Thomas Roisley was a highly ambitious young man.
28:13At the age of just 19, he dropped out of a law degree at Cambridge to become assistant to a
28:19man who was on his way to becoming the most powerful person in the court of King Henry VIII, Thomas
28:24Cromwell.
28:25Roisley would rise up through the ranks, eventually becoming Lord Chancellor himself.
28:30And he made his name, helping Henry resolve one of the greatest crises of his reign.
28:37In the early 16th century, a religious revolution was sweeping across Northern Europe.
28:43In protest at the corruption and extravagance of the Catholic Church, many people rejected Rome, turned to the Protestant faith
28:51and embraced a simpler, more austere form of worship.
29:01When the Pope refused to grant Henry VIII a divorce from his first wife, Henry II decided to break from
29:07Rome and establish the Church of England.
29:11Men like Thomas Roisley were employed to close down the wealthy Catholic abbeys and monasteries.
29:18Anything that symbolised the pomp and ritual of Roman Catholicism was destroyed or stolen.
29:25Religious images were defaced.
29:28Holy relics and bones were smashed to pieces.
29:32Within four years, 800 monasteries were attacked, including this one at Bewley.
29:44It's almost unbelievable, and it's certainly hard to imagine, that this vast empty space was once the interior of a
29:50magnificent abbey church.
29:52You still do get a sense of the scale though, and the scale of this church would have been similar
29:57to that of Hyde Abbey Church.
29:59The fragments that remain let you recreate it in your mind's eye.
30:03Each of these piles of rubble marks the footing for an enormous column, each of them about 60 or 70
30:10feet high supporting the roof.
30:11And then all the way down at the end of this paving, in the east end, would have been the
30:16high altar.
30:22The dissolution of the monasteries meant yet another disturbance of Alfred's resting place.
30:30In 1538, Thomas Roisley turned his attention to Hyde Abbey, one of the richest abbeys in Hampshire.
30:43Roisley wrote to his boss, Thomas Cromwell, to assure him that at Hyde, he was hard at work sweeping away
30:49the old bones, that were known as relics.
30:52It was all about destroying for the last time the abomination of idolatry.
30:57Hyde Abbey itself was quickly demolished.
31:00It became little more than a fine stone quarry, to be used for building and rebuilding all over the area.
31:05And you can sometimes see fragments of the abbey incorporated into the new.
31:10Look up there and you'll see a horned head, heavily weathered.
31:13But that was once a decorative item on the abbey.
31:17And all the while, King Alfred and his family were silently under the ground.
31:24With the abbey demolished, there was no longer any visible monument to mark the location of Alfred's remains.
31:30They now lay hidden, possibly lost forever.
31:41By 880, King Alfred was at the height of his powers.
31:47He'd taken control of large swathes of a country.
31:51His kingdom would form the basis of what would become England.
31:56But only if he could keep it safe from attack.
32:03Alfred built new forts, protected by great defensive earthworks, like these at Wallingford in Oxfordshire.
32:11Overgrown as they are, these earthworks are still incredibly impressive.
32:15But they're made even more so when you realise that all of this was put in place as part of
32:20a kingdom-wide system of defences
32:22that date back to King Alfred the Great himself.
32:26Now, it's about 8 metres deep at the moment.
32:29But in the 9th century, it would have been even bigger.
32:32Probably with a timber palisade running around the top, all of it acting together to turn the town into a
32:37fortress.
32:42These earthworks surrounded the village on three sides, with a river defending the fort.
32:50Such fort-like defences were called burrs, from which we get the word borough.
32:57Beginning with his capital, Winchester, Alfred chose strategic locations, intersecting roads and rivers,
33:03and commissioned 33 of these fortified towns, all across southern England, from Devon to Kent, and as far north as
33:11Warwick.
33:13These fortified towns were placed strategically no more than 40 miles apart,
33:19meaning Alfred's soldiers could be summoned quickly to defend the nearest town, and the people could take refuge from attack.
33:27With his defences spread across this network of fortified towns, King Alfred and his kingdom became almost impossible to conquer.
33:36It was nothing less than a masterstroke.
33:41But Alfred's new defences needed another resource.
33:45An army.
33:50Instead of just rallying the men to help him, Alfred came up with a much more efficient way of doing
33:54things.
33:55He basically used a mathematical formula to enable him to calculate exactly how many men were needed to defend each
34:02town.
34:03And it came out at approximately one man for every four foot of wall.
34:08He was also careful to keep half the men in reserve, so that if half were committed, he had the
34:13rest waiting fresh to join the fray.
34:16He was organising the military in a way that hadn't been seen since the time of the Romans.
34:21A new England was emerging under his rule.
34:34Once his kingdom's defences were established, Alfred was able to realise his other great ambition.
34:40This would come to define his reign and help earn him the title Alfred the Great.
34:47Alfred mourned the loss in England of all the culture and art and literacy that he'd enjoyed in Rome.
34:53And so he summoned from all across Europe some of the great scribes.
34:58John the Old Saxon from Germany, Grimbold from France, and significantly Asser from Wales.
35:04And he had them teach him Latin, so that he could personally supervise the translation into Old English of the
35:11books most necessary for man to know.
35:14He was building a bridge between Anglo-Saxon England and the great minds of the classical world.
35:28I've come to the Bodleian Library in Oxford to see evidence of Alfred's determination to educate and unite his subjects.
35:37This is the oldest surviving book written entirely in the English language.
35:43It was translated by King Alfred in the early 890s.
35:47It's Pope Gregory's pastoral care, and it's a guide explaining to the clergy how they should be looking after the
35:54people in their congregations.
35:55It's the best example of Alfred's translations.
36:00It reveals his passion, not just for the language, but also for the nurturing and the care of his subjects.
36:07In the preface, he explains his wider ambition for the project.
36:12He wanted a copy of this to be sent to every bishop in his kingdom.
36:17It was for the benefit of the less well-educated clergy, those who couldn't read Latin.
36:24Hundreds of years after it was first written, the wisdom here was still regarded as essential reading for churchmen.
36:35This was the beginning of a new age of Anglo-Saxon literacy and knowledge.
36:40At court, Alfred established a school to instruct the children of the nobility,
36:45and he required his elder men and reeves, the local rulers, to learn to read on pain of losing their
36:52offices.
36:57Here at the Ashmolean Museum, there's another remarkable symbol of Alfred's eagerness to celebrate the power of learning.
37:05This stunning little object is about as close to the man and his beliefs as we're likely to get.
37:14It's called the Alfred Jewel, and it's the most unique item associated with King Alfred himself.
37:22And it is a wonder to behold.
37:25It's beautifully crafted, gold, cloisoni enamel.
37:31Underneath this single piece of highly polished crystal is a Christ-like image that's thought to represent learning or wisdom.
37:42It's almost certainly the handle of an eistel, which is a special pointer.
37:47There would have been a piece of ivory or wood coming out here.
37:51And it's used to point out the individual words line by line on a page of manuscript while reading aloud.
37:59And then worked into the outside, and going all around this teardrop shape, are the words in Old English,
38:07Alfred ordered me to be made.
38:12This isn't just about love of learning.
38:15It's more than that.
38:17It's the belief that kingship entails the responsibility to be mindful of the wellbeing of the people.
38:23And it had an extraordinary consequence.
38:26It unified the languages of the people, their beliefs and knowledge.
38:32Several disparate kingdoms were coming together as one.
38:38Anglia.
38:38England.
38:46Today in Oxford, Dr Katie Tucker is handing over some of the bones from the unmarked grave to Professor Tom
38:53Hyam for radiocarbon dating.
38:57So, how old do you think this is?
39:00This is the big question.
39:02Okay.
39:02If they're Royal House of Wessex, we're hoping they're, well, Saxon, 900 AD-ish.
39:11Professor Hyam begins by taking a small sample of bone.
39:15He'll test it with a cutting edge carbon dating technique.
39:20Of all of the global carbon, a very, very small proportion of it is what we call radioactive.
39:25About one atom in a trillion atoms of carbon is radioactive carbon or radiocarbon.
39:30And all of us, all living organisms, take up in food carbon, which we use to build our bones and
39:37build our bodies.
39:38But once death occurs, the amount of radioactive carbon begins to slowly decline and disappear.
39:45The key to the dating technique is that we know how rapid this decay is.
39:49And so, our job is to measure how much radiocarbon there is and thereby date the bones.
39:56The tiny sample of bone is dissolved in acid and placed into an accelerator.
40:04Travelling at a speed of 15 million miles an hour, the carbon is broken down into individual atoms.
40:11One of which is the radioactive carbon-14.
40:16Carbon-14 is what gives scientists the age of the specimen.
40:21But it'll be a couple of weeks before we get the results.
40:29We know that after Alfred's death in 899, he was buried and exhumed twice, before being laid to rest in
40:36Hyde Abbey.
40:39When the abbey was demolished in the 16th century, Alfred's coffin remained under the ground and the land returned to
40:46farming.
40:49250 years later, the story of Alfred's bones took another dramatic turn.
40:58I've come to Hampshire record office to find out what happened.
41:05In the late 18th century, interest in King Alfred was growing.
41:10This pamphlet was written by an amateur historian called Captain Henry Howard.
41:16Howard came to Winchester in 1797 to try to find out what had happened to Alfred's grave.
41:23Howard provides the next piece of the jigsaw puzzle.
41:27About 10 years earlier, in 1788, the site of Hyde Abbey had been acquired by the county for the construction
41:35of a different sort of building altogether.
41:37Bride Well, the new town jail.
41:40According to Howard, the keeper of the jail was a man by the name of Mr Page.
41:44And Mr Page told him that in advance of the building work, the convicts themselves were brought in to prepare
41:51the ground, to clear the rubble and so forth.
41:53And while they were doing that, and while they were digging the foundation trenches, they also found a stone coffin
41:59cased with lead both within and without, and containing some bones and remains of garments.
42:07Howard was convinced that Alfred's remains had been exhumed for the third time.
42:13Howard was appalled by what happened next.
42:16The stone coffin was broken into pieces, the lead from it was sold for two guineas and the bones were
42:24thrown around.
42:25It seemed likely to Howard that the remains of the great Alfred, after having been scattered about by the rude
42:32hands of convicts, are now probably covered by a building erected for their confinement and punishment.
42:41As well as writing this account of what had happened to Alfred's remains, Howard also drew a map showing the
42:47foundations of the demolished Abbey Church.
42:51Howard marked the spot where the graves had been in front of the high altar, but he had no way
42:56of knowing what had happened to the bones after they were scattered around.
43:01To me, this is the most critical moment in the extraordinary journey of Alfred's remains after his death.
43:08Reburied somewhere within the foundations of a prison, they might have been lost now for all time.
43:21In the years after Howard wrote his pamphlet, national interest in King Alfred continued to grow.
43:28With his famous defence of country, Christianity and education, Alfred was seen by many Victorians as the perfect English king.
43:41Fueled by growing national and imperial pride, they erected statues in his memory.
43:48By this time, the site of Alfred's grave was under the local prison, but that was demolished too in the
43:541840s, and the area returned to farmland.
43:57This though, was the era of great British enthusiasm for the Anglo-Saxon hero, and more and more people wanted
44:04to find his remains.
44:08One amateur enthusiast came to Winchester in 1866, determined to find Alfred.
44:15His name was John Mellor, and he was captivated by Captain Howard's account of the desecration of Alfred's grave.
44:24Mellor added a new twist. He claimed that Mr Page, the keeper of the jail, had told Captain Howard that
44:31he had re-buried the bones from the stone coffin in a vault beside a spring on the side.
44:36Now, Mellor was convinced enough to find the spring, and here is where he started digging.
44:44This memorial garden is built on the site of the high altar of Hyde Abbey.
44:51These three stones represent the graves of Alfred, his wife Ailswith, and his son, Edward the Elder.
45:00Using Captain Howard's hand-drawn map as a guide, Mellor claimed he found five skulls and their skeletons.
45:06He was convinced that these were the remains of King Alfred and his family.
45:14Mellor said he felt he'd proved beyond the possibility of a doubt that he'd found Alfred's remains.
45:20To record his discovery, he took these photographs.
45:24But even with photographic evidence, Mellor wasn't given a warm welcome in Winchester.
45:31All of this activity was scandalous to some.
45:35It was technically illegal, as well as sacrilegious, to disturb human remains in this way.
45:40It made the local papers.
45:41One writer, identified as Mr Q, said that he had visited the site and had seen
45:46numerous arm bones and skulls and long bones lying huddled together in a candle box.
45:52Mellor responded to his critics by publishing a pamphlet of his own.
45:56He insisted that he wanted to save the bones from further mutilation and violence
46:00and transfer them to more hallowed ground.
46:04And he invited the people of Winchester to come and view the bones of their long-lost King.
46:09But in an age before carbon dating, it was impossible for Mellor to prove
46:14that the remains were indeed Alfred's.
46:16He won little support.
46:17Maybe he was too much of an amateur to be taken seriously.
46:22Mellor went on to sell the bones for just ten shillings.
46:26That's 38 pounds in today's money.
46:28And the buyer, the Reverend William Williams, vicar of the local parish church.
46:33This church, St Bartholomew's in Hyde.
46:40This small church once stood in the grounds of Hyde Abbey.
46:44It's only a few hundred metres from the site of the Abbey's high altar.
46:49The Reverend Williams reburied the bones here, in this unmarked grave.
46:55Ever since, it's been said that this is the last resting place of King Alfred the Great.
47:04If these were the remains of Alfred and his family, then by now they had been exhumed and reburied four
47:10times.
47:12But did Mr Page, the keeper of the jail, really put them back exactly where he found them?
47:18And did John Mellor discover them again nearly a hundred years later?
47:27The bones lay undisturbed in this unmarked grave for nearly 150 years.
47:35But three years ago, a local history group called Hyde 900 began the legal process that would lead to the
47:41bones being exhumed and tested.
47:45They'd pieced together all the available historical evidence and decided to find out once and for all if the unmarked
47:52grave in their local church art really was the final resting place of King Alfred the Great.
47:58Well that is extraordinary.
48:01Oh wow!
48:02It's very moving, actually seeing it in the flesh, so to speak.
48:07It's almost one of those slightly heart-stopping moments.
48:10Circumstitial evidence suggests it might be Alfred and his family, but frankly we don't know and we won't know until
48:17the scientists do their job, but I'm very excited.
48:23Six months after the exhumation, Professor Tom Hyam has finally established the age of the bones from the unmarked grave.
48:31Okay Tom, the radiocarbon dates are back. You know that we're looking for a date around 900 AD. What have
48:40you got?
48:41Okay, so these are the results and they're in calendar years and what you can see is that four of
48:46the five specimens are actually quite a lot later.
48:48They're in the period of 1300 to about 1420 AD.
48:52So way off.
48:53Way off, I'm afraid to say. There is one that's older, but I'm afraid it's not as old as you'd
48:59hope.
49:00That's individual. See this single skull here, and that one is older than those.
49:04It centres on around 1100 AD, but I'm afraid it's still not as old as King Alfred's death date.
49:12So the earliest date we've got is a skull that went into the ground around the time of the building
49:17of the abbey?
49:18Yeah, so around 1110 was Hyde Abbey. So there's no possibility that that could be much further, far enough back.
49:27Yeah, I'm afraid I was really disappointed when I saw the results. I was hoping like you that they'd be
49:32at least one in the right ball pack, but unfortunately not.
49:37So who on earth are they then, these five, six individuals that all end up bundled together into an unmarked
49:43grave?
49:43It seems unfortunately these are individuals either from other graves within the church or other graves within the precincts of
49:51Hyde Abbey, rather than being from in front of the high altar and Alfred and his family.
49:58So, it does make you wonder, where is Alfred?
50:13We now know that the mysterious unmarked grave in St. Bartholomew's churchyard is not the final resting place of Alfred
50:21the Great.
50:24It seems that John Mellor was either mistaken or lying about the identity of the bones he excavated and sold
50:31to the church.
50:33This suggests that Alfred's remains are still lying somewhere near the site of the high altar of Hyde Abbey, where
50:40we know the convicts scattered them in the late 18th century.
50:52Just as the trail looks like it's gone cold, there's an extraordinary twist.
50:59Back in 1999, there was a community excavation of the Hyde Abbey site.
51:05They found traces of Mellor's excavation and what they thought to be animal bones.
51:13These were boxed and stored in Winchester's City Museum.
51:20While waiting for the test results from the unmarked grave, Dr. Katie Tucker decided to see what else the animal
51:26bones from the 1999 dig could tell her about the history of the site.
51:33But when Katie asked the museum for permission to study them, she was told there were also two boxes of
51:40human bones.
51:42Because funding for the community excavation ran out, they hadn't been fully examined at the time.
51:50Katie decided to examine the bones to find out if they could be the remains of Alfred and his family.
51:57So this is more potential material that could be related to the Royal House of Wessex.
52:05Yes, there's a possibility that any one of these or more than one could be the right date.
52:10And what have we got?
52:11These are the bones that were found closest to the site of the high altar.
52:16I can see obviously leg bones, but is this skull material?
52:19Yes, we have parts of a single skull here that's probably an adult female.
52:25We've got another part of a skull here that might be an adult male, but it's quite fragmentary.
52:32We have parts of a humerus here, so this is the upper arm.
52:37And yes, we have quite a lot of a single individual here.
52:39We've got parts of both arms, the majority of one of the legs and part of the other leg.
52:45And then we have here a part of the male pelvis.
52:49So in terms of looking for Alfred the Great, have you had these bones dated?
52:55Yes, we've sent a small fragment of bone from each of the groups of bone off.
53:01And we're now just waiting for Tom Hyam. He's abroad at the moment, but he's hopefully got the results for
53:08us.
53:08And he's going to join us on the screen.
53:10Come to the map.
53:11Okay.
53:18Hi, Tom.
53:19Hi, Tom.
53:20Hi, Katie. Hi, Neil. How are you?
53:22We're well.
53:24Yeah, pretty good.
53:24We've got some new, um, we've got five new dates.
53:28Yeah.
53:28Three of them all wants to get into the 1300s period, so they're consistent with the previous patch.
53:34There's one which is a little bit older than that, but there's the fifth one, which is this piece of
53:39male pelvis.
53:40That's older than anything we've actually done before.
53:43And it's actually falling into the late part of the 800s and into the 900s.
53:48No, really?
53:49Fantastic.
53:50Very, very old indeed.
53:51You're joking. So it's right from the right time for Alfred and family.
53:55It's paying on the money.
53:57That's fantastic, Tom.
53:59Great stuff.
53:59Yeah, that's great news. Thank you very much.
54:02It's a pleasure for having me now.
54:03Bye, Tom.
54:05Well, what do you make of that?
54:07That is unexpected, I would say, but yeah, very good news.
54:11I was sceptical.
54:12What does it mean if we add it up, what we've got here?
54:16It's this bone here, isn't it?
54:17Yeah, it's the part of the male pelvis.
54:21Well, the part of the pelvis that we have, it's from a male, from an adult male in their 40s.
54:29So that would tie in with quite well with either Alfred or his son, Edward the Elder.
54:37And basically, as far as we know from the chronicles and from the records, the only individuals close to the
54:45site of the High Altar, who are the right age when they died and the right date when they died,
54:52would either be Alfred or Edward.
54:55So in terms of circumstantial evidence, this is pretty good.
55:00And at the distance that we're reaching back into time to find the pelvis of a 40-something man who
55:08died around 900-ish in that location by the High Altar in Hyde Abbey, the likelihood is, or the strong
55:17possibility is…
55:18…there's a good chance, I would say, because just from the records, who else could it be?
55:23What more would you need then, in a court of law, I suppose, to say conclusively?
55:32Well, really, because we only have that one piece, there really isn't much else we can do from that.
55:38We haven't got anybody else we could compare it with, so from that piece of bone there isn't really anything
55:44else that we could do.
55:46However, there is the possibility of going back to the site to re-excavate.
55:51So more of Alfred or his son or both could be there still?
55:55Yeah, there's the potential that in areas that were not excavated in the 90s, there may still be fragments of
56:01bone to be found.
56:03But imagine, I mean, even given all of that, the possibility as we stand here is that, you know, the
56:09life and the legend of Alfred the Great comes down to this enigmatic fragment of bone.
56:16Yeah, it's quite amazing really, yeah.
56:28This isn't quite the conclusion the members of Hyde 900 had been expecting.
56:34But it's an exciting development in the thousand year long story of Alfred the Great's remains.
56:48I was just very thrilled. I can't tell you. In fact, I can't tell you. Words can't say.
56:53What's fantastic about it is that, you know, we've come full circle. We've come back to the side of the
56:57Hyde Abbey and we've got the right sort of in the right context.
57:01And so I think that's really exciting, you know, and it is not by any means the end of the
57:06story.
57:06We've been excited on several occasions through this project, but yes, it's another very important step.
57:11I think it's taken as where we, perhaps unanticipated being, where we set out on looking at the bones in
57:15the churchyard, but it's nonetheless following the story through.
57:17This really is an opportunity for us, working with our partners locally, to do further excavation on the site, to
57:22see what else has turned up.
57:24I think it's also important that we seize the opportunity to convey the wider message about the significance of Alfred
57:30the Great and his era.
57:35Alfred the Great was the king who began the unification of England, who fought off the Viking threat, and who
57:46inspired a cultural renaissance.
57:49Without him, England would be a very different place.
57:55And now we have evidence indicating where his remains might be.
58:01Our investigation has brought us back here, to Hyde Abbey, and it seems highly likely that Alfred's remains are still
58:08buried here, probably close by the site of the high altar.
58:11It's not clear exactly what will happen next. There may in time be a full-scale archaeological excavation of the
58:18site.
58:18And if that work turns up more of Alfred's remains, there are those who believe they should then be reburied
58:24with all the ceremony and honour that they deserve.
58:27But if history has taught us anything, it's that Alfred the Great's best memorial is probably all around us.
58:34The nation that he helped inspire.
58:38England.
58:38England.
58:43Over on BBC4 now, an insight into the Victorian explorer who transformed field archaeology.
58:48The man who discovered Egypt is just starting.
58:51Here on BBC2, time to enter the House of Fools.
58:54And if you tell Vic and Bob not to eat a pork pie, you can just about guess what's going
58:59to happen next.

Recommended