• 3 years ago
RESPONSE TO 'THE TRUTH ABOUT FORGIVENESS'

I disagree here. You can “forgive” in the sense of letting go of your resentments, without letting them off the hook, and without maintaining your relationship with them. Holding resentment eats away at you and you alone, because it feeds the scars of the trauma they created in you. No trauma can be healed if resentment is still there. Keep your abusers accountable, keep them away from you, but hold no resentment nor love for them: only indifference.

From the Freedomain Livestream 1 Sep 2023

FOR THE FULL SHOW:

Join the PREMIUM philosophy community on the web for free!

Get access to StefBOT-AI, private livestreams, premium call in shows, my new book and the History of Philosophers series!

See you soon!

https://freedomain.locals.com/support/promo/UPB2022

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00 In the Wednesday show, I won't review the case here, but in the Wednesday show I talked
00:05 about this verbal curse of "Resentment eats away at you and you alone because it feeds
00:10 the scars of the trauma they created in you."
00:16 So that is what's called verbal diarrhea.
00:20 And I really do apologize, I don't mean to insult diarrhea here, which has at least the
00:24 value of...
00:26 So I made a big case here.
00:28 I disagree.
00:29 You can "forgive" in the sense of letting go of your resentments without letting them
00:33 off the hook and without maintaining a relationship with them.
00:36 How do you know?
00:38 What case did you make?
00:39 I made like an hour-long case with detailed examples, analogies, moral reasoning, syllogisms,
00:43 and so on.
00:45 I disagree.
00:46 Okay, first of all, why on earth would I care that you disagree?
00:52 Now when someone says, "I disagree," they're priming you without giving an argument.
01:05 You can "forgive" in the sense of letting go of your resentments without letting them
01:09 off the hook and without maintaining a relationship with them.
01:11 So he puts the word "forgive" in quotes.
01:17 What does that mean?
01:18 I'll put the text here.
01:20 Why is the word "forgive" in quotes?
01:25 What does that mean?
01:26 What does that mean?
01:30 Why is it in quotes?
01:31 Does that mean it's not real forgiveness?
01:32 Does he mean he's using the term "forgiveness" in a different sense than I am?
01:37 Because I didn't put the word...
01:38 I didn't say the truth about forgiveness and put the forgiveness in quotes.
01:43 So he can "forgive."
01:44 What does that mean?
01:47 Is it pretend forgiveness?
01:48 Is it forgiveness with quotes?
01:50 Is it fake?
01:51 What does that mean?
01:52 In the sense of letting go of your resentments.
01:56 Now if you look at that analogy, that is that your resentment was not inflicted upon you
02:02 against your will, but you're holding onto it.
02:05 You know what they say?
02:06 "Holding onto your resentments."
02:09 Holding onto your resentments.
02:14 But abuse permanently changes who you are.
02:17 It permanently changes who you are.
02:21 So you know, like if there's some reports that if your kid lies to your baby, the baby's
02:26 skull is soft and hardens later, right?
02:32 So if you lay your baby too much on the back, you get this flat head.
02:34 You get the flat head on the back.
02:37 Not enough tummy time, you've got a flat head, right?
02:39 So if you leave your child on their back as a baby too long, the baby ends up with a differently
02:45 shaped skull.
02:46 Did we follow that right?
02:47 It makes sense, right?
02:48 Like your baby ends up with a differently shaped skull.
02:50 The baby is never going to be as the baby would have been with enough tummy time.
02:54 You've got a permanent flat thing on the back of the skull, right?
02:56 Okay, we were there, right?
02:58 Now that has permanently changed the shape of the baby's skull.
03:04 Now is the baby holding on to that changed head?
03:08 He's just gritting his teeth and with bloody nails he's just holding onto it.
03:13 He's just hanging onto it.
03:16 If you don't feed your child enough and your child grows up short, it's the child just
03:23 holding on to the shortness and he just has to let go of being short.
03:29 He just has to let go of being short and then he won't be short anymore.
03:36 I really, really, I can't tell you how much it annoys me.
03:40 Again, it doesn't mean I'm right, I'm just being honest about my feelings.
03:43 When people say, "You're holding on to your resentments."
03:45 The fuck?
03:49 And they don't say that to other people, right?
03:53 They don't say that to other people.
03:57 They don't say that to other people, do they?
04:03 If they come across a victim of rape, do they say, "Well, you're just holding on to it.
04:07 You're just holding on to it.
04:08 You've got to let it go.
04:09 Let it go."
04:10 Would they go to Nelson Mandela in prison for 27 years?
04:13 Whatever we think of the justice, the common perception about the political prison, "Oh,
04:16 you've just got to let go of your resentment.
04:17 You're holding on to your resentment."
04:20 Only the children, right?
04:21 Only the children.
04:22 "Holding on to it."
04:23 I'm not holding on to it.
04:25 It was done to me.
04:27 If somebody stabs you and leaves a big giant scar on your side, you're just holding on
04:32 to that scar.
04:33 Just let that scar go.
04:34 It's like, "What are you talking about?"
04:38 They would never say that to your parents for their resentment of you either.
04:40 Yeah, yeah.
04:41 Quite right, James.
04:42 "You're holding on, holding on to it."
04:47 How can I hold on to something that was involuntarily and permanently inflicted upon me?
04:56 If your parents didn't give you any dental care when you were younger and fed you nothing
05:00 but sugar and you've got really bad teeth, you've got gum disease, you're missing teeth,
05:05 your teeth have cavities, you've got halitosis, you've got whatever, right?
05:08 "You're just holding on to your bad teeth, man.
05:11 You've just got to let go of the bad teeth."
05:12 It's like, "No, there's a permanent effect.
05:18 Like I have permanently damaged teeth.
05:21 Maybe I can save some, but I have permanently damaged teeth."
05:24 "What does it mean to...
05:30 Well you're just holding on to these bad teeth."
05:32 It's like, "No, that's what was done to me."
05:35 "What do you mean holding on to it?
05:36 How do you hold on to what was done to you?
05:39 That is permanent."
05:40 Now, permanent doesn't mean you can't ever change it.
05:42 You can fix your teeth, you can...
05:46 Oh my God.
05:51 You can forgive in the sense of letting go of your resentments without letting them off
05:54 the hook and without maintaining a relationship with them.
06:03 So what does that mean?
06:04 Letting go of your resentments without letting them off the hook.
06:06 So you continue to judge them immoral and without maintaining a relationship with them.
06:12 So of course my argument is that if someone has done you great harm and that person won't
06:17 abuse...
06:18 Sorry, the abuser won't apologize, make restitution, admit fault or anything like that, then you
06:24 know, the reason why you would be angry and upset is because you continue to be in their
06:28 presence which is provoking the wounds and therefore it may be sensible to have, you
06:32 know, if you get a therapist or whatever, to have some distance from that person to
06:36 let things cool so that you're not so angry.
06:39 Does that...
06:40 I mean you've heard these arguments before, right?
06:42 That your resentment continues as long as the abuse continues.
06:50 We've heard this argument before, right?
06:54 Why are you still angry at your parents?
06:56 Because they still have control over you, they're still abusing you, blah blah blah,
06:58 right?
06:59 Yeah, your anger is your emotional immune system, proximity, yeah, all this stuff.
07:03 So he's saying, "I disagree with you.
07:04 You can forgive in the sense of letting go of your resentments, I don't know what that
07:07 means, without letting your parents off the hook and without maintaining a relationship
07:10 with them.
07:11 Okay, so you judge them morally and if they continue to be abusive you don't have to be
07:14 in a relationship with them, right?
07:16 So other than putting the word "forgiven" quotes and the phrase "letting go of your
07:20 resentments", how is he disagreeing with me?
07:23 It's exactly the same.
07:25 Holding resentment eats away at you and you alone because it feeds the scars of the trauma
07:31 they created in you.
07:33 Okay, so the trauma they created in you but you just got to let it go.
07:39 So they created it in you but you just got to let it go.
07:49 Holding resentment eats away at you and that's the verbal curse, the exact verbal curse that
07:53 I was talking about in the show.
07:55 The exact verbal curse that I was talking about in the show.
07:58 Fuck off with your voodoo verbal curses because you're blaming the victim.
08:04 And tell me, what is wrong with holding resentment?
08:10 Would you go to a black activist group angry about slavery and saying, "Well, you've got
08:16 to let it go"?
08:18 Holding resentment, they wouldn't say that, right?
08:25 So he's putting the exact verbal curse on that I talked about in my show.
08:31 Now, he's perfectly free to do that but he's not even addressing the argument that I made
08:34 about that, right?
08:36 No trauma can be healed if resentment is still there.
08:42 Okay, let me ask you this.
08:52 Can you heal trauma?
08:59 And what does healing even mean in this context?
09:03 Right?
09:04 So when I got cancer, I was healed of my cancer in that I don't have cancer anymore.
09:12 And you know, for the most part, it's as if I never had cancer.
09:15 I got a little scar here, I got a little buzz in my ear, that's it, right?
09:22 If you...
09:27 I have a little scar on my thumb here from a cut.
09:31 I don't think about it.
09:32 My thumb is a tiny little bit numb above it, that's it, right?
09:37 Is it healed?
09:38 Yeah, it's as healed as it's going to be.
09:39 Is it like I never cut my thumb?
09:40 No, because I still have the scar.
09:41 Is it like I never had cancer?
09:43 No, because I have the scar here, I have a bit of a buzz in my ear, and I have a minor
09:46 susceptibility to radiation that I want to make sure I wear a hat for and blah blah blah,
09:50 right?
09:51 So, but I'm healed.
09:52 I'm healed, right?
09:53 Now, is it like I never had it?
09:54 No, of course not.
09:55 So what does healing mean?
09:57 This is really important because if you've got a goal called healing the trauma, what
10:03 does it mean?
10:05 What does it mean to heal from trauma?
10:12 Now, I can tell you what I think it means.
10:15 I can't prove it so logistically, but I can tell you what I think healing from trauma
10:19 means.
10:23 Healing from trauma means preventing repetition of the trauma, right?
10:31 If you're an alcoholic, how are you healed of alcoholism?
10:35 You stop drinking.
10:36 Now, does that mean you were never an alcoholic?
10:40 Nope.
10:43 I don't think you can totally heal trauma, but you can learn to cope and improve your
10:46 life and others, same way a wound is covered in scar tissue.
10:49 It's always there, but sealed off.
10:51 I don't follow that view.
10:54 You could be totally right, of course.
10:55 I don't particularly follow that view because my trauma is not my enemy.
10:58 My trauma is my fucking savior.
11:04 Do you honestly, do you guys think, I don't mean to sound aggressive, I'm genuinely curious,
11:08 do you guys think I would be a peaceful parent as committed to this if I wasn't traumatized
11:13 as a child?
11:15 No, of course not.
11:19 Peaceful parenting came directly out of my trauma and it came out of my trauma because
11:22 I didn't view it as an enemy that I needed to seal off or something that I needed to
11:27 let go of and discard and move on past and be as if it never happened.
11:32 I kind of think you would still be.
11:35 Unlikely.
11:38 I wouldn't even be listening right now if I didn't have an A score of 9.
11:40 Yeah, I'm sorry about that, my friend, I really am.
11:42 That's very tough, very tough.
11:48 So what does it mean to heal trauma?
11:50 Does it mean to be as if you were never hurt?
11:52 Because that's generally what healing means.
11:54 Does it mean to, am I supposed to be, okay, well I have another personality in another
11:58 dimension in an alternate timeline wherein I was loved and respected and treasured as
12:02 a child and I'll just be that person?
12:04 Can I be that person?
12:05 I cannot.
12:09 If I grew up for 20 years speaking English and never heard a word of Japanese, I can
12:12 go learn Japanese, but I can never be somebody who grew up speaking Japanese.
12:17 No symptoms maybe?
12:19 Impossible.
12:20 Impossible.
12:21 How could there be no symptoms of trauma?
12:28 How could there possibly be no symptoms of trauma?
12:30 That would be to erase the first 25, that's why I asked, how long did it take you to morally
12:37 judge your family?
12:38 That would be to erase the first 25 years of your life.
12:40 How could you possibly do that?
12:42 You can't do that.
12:44 It's impossible, I mean, without Alzheimer's and death.
12:47 You cannot do that.
12:48 You cannot erase your history.
12:54 You can't do it.
13:00 Utilize the scars to propel you to the stars.
13:01 Chris, beautifully put, right?
13:04 Steph, you are an independent thinker, not a herd animal.
13:07 You make your own life and an indomitable will.
13:09 I appreciate that, but you might be praising me to try and avoid the conflict, which I
13:13 understand.
13:14 But what does it mean to heal from the trauma?
13:24 I'll tell you what it means to me.
13:25 To heal from the trauma means to be safer and better than if the trauma hadn't happened.
13:38 To let the trauma teach you so well that you become safer and better than if it hadn't
13:45 happened at all.
13:51 To really, really learn from it.
13:54 To have been so harmed that you learn the principles of peace and apply them no matter
14:01 what.
14:02 No matter what.
14:03 No, not war games for life, peace games for life.
14:08 And to help others going through the same trauma, absolutely, but you can't do that
14:11 unless you're in a position of certainty already and closure.
14:20 See to me, this is almost a will of the wisp, like the thing that you chase and you get
14:25 lost in the swamps.
14:28 To me, this is an offer that is kind of devilish, kind of devilish.
14:36 You can be like it never happened.
14:39 You can erase your past.
14:41 You can erase your history.
14:42 You can erase the trauma.
14:43 You can be like it never happened.
14:47 But what happens then?
14:53 That would erase the lessons learned.
14:59 Let me ask you this.
15:00 Do you think my mother tried to live as if she wasn't damaged?
15:12 She did.
15:14 She tried to be cool.
15:15 She tried to be pretty.
15:16 She tried to be, right?
15:17 She tried to live like she wasn't harmed.
15:22 If you sprain your ankle, I remember running through the woods, jumping off a low cliff
15:26 and landing.
15:27 I thought it was in leaves, but it was actually in a bunch of rocks.
15:28 I twisted the hell out of my ankle, right?
15:33 Now, if you twist your ankle and you walk like you're not hurt, what happens?
15:48 Yeah, you eff it up way worse.
15:55 Re-injury.
15:57 You twist it again, you make it more hurt.
15:58 Yeah, you grind the whatever, right?
16:03 Now, what was the purpose of me twisting my ankle?
16:07 Why did it hurt?
16:08 It hurt so that I wouldn't do stupid things like jump off a low cliff and think that there's
16:11 no rocks under the leaves.
16:15 That's what it's for.
16:18 Why on earth would I want to unlearn that lesson or be someone that that never happened
16:23 to?
16:24 Then I'm just going to fuck up my ankle when I'm older and it's harder to heal.
16:29 At least this happened when I was 15 or 16 years old and I could heal in like four days.
16:39 Why would I want to undo the lessons that saved me?
16:48 Now of course, this person would just, I guarantee you, they'll just change the definition.
16:51 "Well, that's not what I mean by healing.
16:53 I get all of that."
16:59 But what does he say?
17:00 "Keep your abusers accountable.
17:02 Keep them away from you."
17:03 "Well, no, I don't think you should keep them away from you if they're..."
17:08 He's saying, I guess, if they're continuing to abuse you.
17:11 "Keep your abusers accountable.
17:12 Keep them away from you, but hold no resentment nor love for them, only indifference.
17:21 Only indifference, which is about as dangerous a set of advice as I can conceive of."
17:33 You learn the lessons and then you gain peace.
17:43 So when I twisted my ankle, it hurt a lot and I was a long way away from...
17:53 I had to walk a long way on uneven surfaces with no...
17:56 I couldn't prop myself up on anything, it was very painful.
18:05 Now what would it mean for me to have complete indifference to the pain I got from twisting
18:13 my ankle?
18:14 What would that mean?
18:18 To have only complete indifference to having twisted my ankle?
18:28 I would act recklessly.
18:29 Of course, I wouldn't have learned my lessons.
18:31 To be indifferent to people who harmed you if they did?
18:36 To be indifferent to people who harmed you for a quarter century straight?
18:41 Have only indifference to all of that?
18:47 Actually his email is straight out of the 12-step meetings which I attended.
18:52 They'd say resentment is the cause of relapse, but they defined resentment as dwelling on
18:56 past hurt in a masochistic way and going into self-pity, not learning from it and growing
19:00 from it.
19:02 I don't know what that is, but that's not what he's saying.
19:07 He's saying be indifferent to your pain of a quarter century.
19:17 Be indifferent to the people who may have mentally or physically or emotionally tortured
19:21 you for 25 years straight.
19:23 Just be indifferent.
19:28 Hold no resentment, no love for them.
19:31 Only be... only feel nothing.
19:32 Feel nothing!
19:33 Feel nothing!
19:36 And that's your solution.
19:43 Now nothing is a bigger time waster of human energy than to give yourself a commandment
19:48 you can't possibly achieve.
19:55 I think I've learned pretty good lessons from my past.
19:57 I think I've Judah rolled them into a pretty good and virtuous life.
20:05 And here's the thing too, do you know, I mean for me to take advice, I'm happy, like I ask
20:11 advice from this group from time to time, for me to take advice you've got to have a
20:14 lot of credibility.
20:24 He says only have indifference.
20:26 Yeah, you're right, he didn't seem to be indifferent to your discussion of forgiveness.
20:30 That's right James, exactly right.
20:31 Perfect.
20:32 Brilliant.
20:33 He says, "It eats away at you, feeds on the scars of the trauma they created in you."
20:37 What does that mean?
20:38 Holding resentment eats away at you and you alone because it feeds the scars of the trauma
20:42 they created in you.
20:43 Here's another key about somebody who's there to mess your head up, and I'm not talking
20:47 about this guy in particular, right?
20:51 Resentment.
20:54 Resentment.
20:55 Now replace resentment with just anger.
21:05 Let go of your just anger.
21:09 Let go of your... but they have to change the word from just anger, the phrase, from
21:13 just anger to resentment so that you feel petty.
21:17 Oh, I just... resentment.
21:19 Resentment is a petty emotion, right?
21:26 Righteous indignation is considered an Aristotelian virtue, yeah.
21:29 Let go of your sense of justice and anger.
21:32 Let go of your anger towards evil doers.
21:36 Let go of your self-protection against those who would do you harm.
21:41 Be a lamb, open your throat to the wolves.
21:48 Be anger, hurt that is supposed to get you away from evil doers.
21:53 Fear, anger, hurt, upset, pain, all of that stuff which is designed to get you away from
22:00 evil doers, let go of that.
22:02 Let them feast on you at will.
22:11 Feeling justice in your life eats away at you and you alone because it feeds off the
22:18 scars of the trauma they created in you.
22:25 No upset can be healed if you still feel just anger at those who harmed you.
22:35 Don't have any just anger for the people who harmed you for a quarter century.
22:40 Feel nothing.
22:41 Oh my god.
22:45 Does this not feel kind of clammy and claustrophobic and manipulative as shit?
23:03 Feel nothing.
23:05 Be nothing.
23:07 Have no history.
23:08 I tempt you with the drug of numbness.
23:15 I tempt you with being an indifferent ghost in the haunted house of your own history and
23:20 present.
23:38 Without letting them off the hook.
23:43 Keep your abuses accountable.
23:46 How are you going to keep your abuses accountable if you feel nothing?
23:50 Oh that Lizzie lady on Podbean said similar stuff and that's why I tried encouraging her
23:56 to talk to you about her childhood but she just gummed up the show instead.
23:59 No, she was great.
24:00 I mean she was great.
24:01 She was very, very clear.
24:03 I mean she didn't want to talk about her childhood and that's totally fine.
24:11 So morally judge your abuses as evil but feel nothing.
24:19 So it's like saying to your immune system, "Judge this as a germ, as an infection, as
24:26 a cancer, as something that's going to kill me but don't act on it."
24:33 Judgment without emotion?
24:42 That's weird to me.
24:45 Keep your abuses accountable.
24:47 Judge them as evil but feel nothing about evildoers.
24:52 What on earth does that mean?
24:58 So you're supposed to be completely indifferent to rampant child abusers if this is what happened,
25:07 right?
25:10 Judge them as evil, keep them away as a plague and a toxin and be completely indifferent
25:17 to everything to do with them.
25:19 Oh my God.
25:25 I want you to have been raised speaking English for 25 years and then have absolutely no knowledge
25:31 of what English is and no ability to understand it and if somebody speaks it you just won't
25:35 know anything about it.
25:39 Yeah, resentment is one of the key words.
25:47 Letting go of your resentments.
25:48 "No, I was stabbed, I have to deal with the wounds and I have to do rehab and I'm not
25:53 holding on.
25:58 You know when I was walking back from twisting my leg in the woods, was I holding on to my
26:03 pain?
26:04 Was I holding on to my limp?
26:05 Was I just unable to let go of my pain and my limp?"
26:09 It's insane.
26:12 It's wild.
26:16 It's a way at you when you're alone.
26:19 And as you say, "Why isn't he talking to the abusers?
26:21 Go talk to the abusers."
26:22 Nope, he's talking to the victims and he's lecturing the victims.
26:27 And he's telling the victims, "Stop feeling.
26:32 Stop feeling and you'll be great.
26:36 Go numb and you'll be great."
26:39 Now do you know who's numb to pain?
26:43 Leprosy and drug addicts.
26:50 Leprosy and drug addicts, right?
26:51 Leprosy, they go to the VSE, visual search of extremities.
26:54 I learned this from Thomas Covenant, right?
27:01 Also the dead are indifferent.
27:04 They have no feelings either way.
27:06 Be a druggie.
27:09 Have leprosy.
27:12 Be dead.
27:20 You know, if you wake up in hospital and there's a doctor using a tongue depressor
27:31 to press against your sole of your foot, right?
27:41 And you feel nothing.
27:44 Your body is indifferent to the presence or absence of the tongue depressor on the bottom
27:49 of your foot.
27:50 Is that a good sign or a bad sign if you're indifferent?
27:54 If your body is indifferent, your nerves won't give you any information.
27:57 Is it a good sign or a bad sign?
27:58 Can you feel your feet?
28:00 Negative, Roger.
28:03 Yeah, that's right.
28:05 Very, very bad.
28:06 You're probably paralyzed.
28:08 Feel nothing.
28:11 So, if you feel nothing about evildoers, you're unprotected against evildoers, right?
28:30 You've created a vacuum of power mongers in your life.
28:33 You're indifferent to the presence of evil.
28:34 More evil people are just going to charge in.
28:36 They're just setting you up for a cycle, right?
28:41 In the same way that if I only had indifference to me twisting my ankle when I was 15, I'd
28:47 still be jumping off things and not caring where I landed.
28:53 You ever have this thing where you're biting away, you're chewing away, and then you bite
28:58 something on your inner lip, right?
29:00 For me, it happens to the bottom inner lip, right?
29:03 And then you're toast, right?
29:04 Because then it swells up, and then you're more likely to bite it again.
29:07 And it's really annoying, right?
29:09 Once or twice a year, I do that, right?
29:12 So what do you do when you have that happen?
29:16 You chew really carefully.
29:19 No, no.
29:22 When you bite your inner lip, and it swells up, and you keep biting it, and blood mixes
29:26 in with your food, be completely indifferent.
29:33 Be the opposite of evolution.
29:35 All animals fear that which gives them harm and danger and destruction, but feel nothing.
29:41 Be a zebra who's had half an ass chewed off by a lion.
29:46 Be completely indifferent to the lions.
29:50 Oh, this is awesome.
29:55 Now look, I mean, I'm not trying to read this guy's mind.
29:59 I'm just going with the text.
30:00 I mean, maybe it was a woman too, but it seems like a guy.
30:03 But yeah, it's not great.
30:11 Lobotomy is a virtue.
30:15 And then someone else said, "Well said, my friend."
30:19 Not well said.
30:25 Not well said.
30:28 I probably have had cancer form in my body in the 10 years since I had cancer.
30:36 Do I want my immune system to be indifferent to that cancer?
30:39 You say, "Well, keep it away."
30:45 Why would you keep something away if you're indifferent to it?
30:49 Why would you keep something away?
30:51 Judge them as evildoers and keep them away from you, but be completely indifferent to
30:55 them.
30:56 What is that?
30:57 That makes no logical sense.
31:01 I'm indifferent to a bird flying overhead so I don't shoot it out of the sky.
31:13 I'm indifferent as to the hobbies my neighbors have, so I don't tell them what they should
31:18 or shouldn't do or try and control anything.
31:22 It's very tempting, "Oh, if I feel nothing."
31:29 But you see, that's what drug addicts do.
31:31 They generally take drugs to feel nothing.
31:34 Not even to feel that high, but just to stop feeling pain.
31:39 To me this is a dealer in a way, like a drug dealer with this drug of indifference.
31:45 I would not recommend it.
31:46 If I was indifferent to the suffering I experienced as a child and indifferent to the evildoers
31:50 who did it, I wouldn't have bounced to the other side of virtue.
31:58 The healing of trauma is doing the opposite, not pretending it never happened and being
32:03 indifferent to the inflictors.
32:12 I never quite get to where I want to get in terms of eloquence.
32:15 I'm chasing this "Will of the Wisp."
32:19 Is it relatively clear?
32:28 You know, when they feel your stomach, right before I had my colonoscopy, they're feeling
32:31 my stomach, do you feel any discomfort?
32:33 Now, if I felt absolutely numb, if I felt nothing, that would be bad, right?
32:42 But the reason I spend some time on this is, again, this is a very common thing.
32:47 Holding resentment eats away at you.
32:48 How do you know?
32:50 Because it feeds the scars of the trauma they created in you.
32:52 How do you know?
32:53 He's just saying words.
32:55 This is a magical spell.
32:56 It's a curse.
32:57 It's like, "It eats away at you.
33:00 It feeds the scars."
33:01 What the fuck?
33:02 How do you know?
33:07 What's the proof?
33:08 I made a case, right?
33:09 I made a case.
33:11 It's just, no trauma can be healed if resentment is still there.
33:16 What does that even mean?
33:17 Do you know what that means?
33:20 I have no idea what that means.
33:21 I don't know what he means by trauma.
33:25 I don't know if he means emotional trauma.
33:27 I don't know if he means the physical trauma that was inflicted against you.
33:29 I don't know what he means by healed.
33:32 I know that he's downgrading just anger to resentment as a manipulative bullshit tactic.
33:38 No trauma can be healed if resentment is still there.
33:41 You start to break that apart.
33:42 It just breaks apart into nothing.
33:45 Into nothing.
33:47 It doesn't exist when you ask it what it means.
33:53 He's saying, "Become a ghost."
33:54 His sentences are ghosts.
33:57 His sentences are ghosts.
33:59 Nothing is there.
34:02 You can forgive in the sense of letting go of your resentments without letting them off
34:06 the hook and without maintaining a relationship with them.
34:09 What does any of that mean?
34:11 Just be aware when these voodoo spells are being cast, holding resentment.
34:18 What does that mean, holding resentment?
34:20 What does that even mean?
34:22 What does resentment mean?
34:23 It eats away at you.
34:24 What does that mean?
34:25 It feeds the scars of the trauma.
34:27 This is all elegant, destructive voodoo spell bullshit.
34:34 I hate the fact that I feel numb plus empty often.
34:37 It's something I've been working through with my therapist and my journaling.
34:40 Sometimes I worry a lot of it may never come back.
34:42 I mean, I'm happy to do a call-in show, but of course you're in therapy, so it may be
34:45 better to go along with that.
34:47 You can make the choice.
34:51 Keep your abusers accountable, then keep them away from you, but hold no resentment or love
34:54 for them, only indifference.
34:55 Why?
34:56 What does any of this mean?
34:58 Is it possible?
34:59 What does it mean?
35:00 What's the definitions of anything?
35:01 Somebody is trying to tell you how to deal with evil and learn from it, and how to handle
35:09 your own internal state, how to become safe from evil, how to deal with trauma, how to
35:13 do all this, that, and the other.
35:15 And he's trying to do it.
35:17 We can take away the "I disagree" here, right?
35:21 He's trying to tell you all of this in 75 fucking words.
35:29 There's also an insult.
35:30 I got to tell you, I experience this as an insult.
35:35 Maybe I'm wrong.
35:36 I don't think I'm wrong.
35:37 When I spend two hours breaking out a detailed argument, and somebody takes 75 words to rebut
35:43 the whole thing, aren't they just basically saying, "Well, you're horribly long-winded.
35:48 I can just boil it down to its essence like this."
35:50 You're saying, "Just do it this way."
35:53 Come on.
35:55 Come on.
36:01 Especially when it's exactly the stuff that I was arguing against, and he doesn't address
36:04 any of the arguments.
36:06 75 words to tell you exactly how to deal with a history of abuse, and the prescription is
36:18 to be completely numb to your abusers.
36:21 That's the solution.
36:22 Based on what?
36:23 Based on what argument?
36:24 What studies?
36:25 What reasoning?
36:26 What morals?
36:27 What ethics?
36:28 What personal experience?
36:29 What?
36:30 Based on what?
36:31 It's insulting, don't you know?
36:32 He just knows more than you.
36:33 "You can forgive in the sense of letting go of your resentment."
36:34 "I don't know, but let me tell you, Laura, do this."
36:38 Why?
36:39 Why the fuck should I do what you said?
36:41 I mean, I'm trying to make a case.
36:42 I tried to make a case throughout the whole ... Why would I do?
36:46 Why would I do what this guy says?
36:48 I mean, he's not making any arguments, he's just saying a bunch of manipulative fluff
36:52 words.
36:53 Anyway, I think you sort of get the point, if that makes sense.
36:57 This is worth breaking out, not because of this guy in particular, but because you're
37:02 going to see this kind of stuff all the time.
37:04 "Oh, thank you for the tip, I appreciate that.
37:07 Breaking down this person's statement has been very useful."
37:09 Well, that's because I view him as negative, and it is maybe just a complete lack of self-knowledge
37:19 or whatever it is.
37:20 And if you wrote this thing and you're upset with me, call in, we can talk about it, and
37:23 you can tell me how I'm wrong and all of that.
37:26 But I'm annoyed at this guy.
37:28 Now, has it been useful that I was annoyed at this guy?
37:31 Would it have been better for me to read this and be completely indifferent?
37:39 To have zero feelings, positive or negative, and just leave it stand no matter what.
37:45 You're happy I'm annoyed?
37:46 Yeah, I mean, I think so.
37:47 I think that the annoyance is helpful, I think that it's good, right?
37:53 Hold no resentment nor love.
37:56 Yeah, so you could have resentment, you could have love, with regards to people who you
38:01 know violently or in a degrading or humiliating manner abused you as a child, you could have
38:05 love, you could have resentment.
38:10 Now here's where you've got love, resentment.
38:15 The opposite of love is resentment.
38:18 Didn't Jesus say, "Better to be hot or cold"?
38:20 I think so, yeah.
38:22 You can't trust someone who's completely indifferent because you know it's BS.
38:25 Yeah, because if he was completely indifferent about things in the world, why would he post
38:28 this message?
38:29 Well, I disagree.
38:31 You can do this, you can do this, do that.
38:35 I don't know.
38:38 To the person who made the statement, if you hold resentment, doesn't it mean you still
38:40 think about the trauma?
38:42 Is it uncontrollable like a habit or addiction?
38:45 No, trauma has shaped you irrevocably, you have no choice about that.
38:56 Child abuse reshapes you irrevocably and you have no choice about that.
39:01 And I say this as somebody who was abused as a child and who has raised a peacefully
39:06 parented child.
39:08 A sprained ankle you can get better from.
39:10 Absolutely, I don't care about my sprained ankle anymore, I haven't thought about it
39:13 in decades.
39:14 So a sprained ankle you can get better from.
39:21 Significant child abuse changes you permanently.
39:25 Now hopefully you can have it, yeah, you will never be someone who had a non-abusive childhood,
39:28 you will never be that.
39:31 And you can use that pain to build a better, virtuous, positive, happy life that was better
39:37 than if you hadn't been abused.
39:40 If I was indifferent as this person I'd still be living with my parents and that's just
39:43 a sad thought.
39:50 And of course if you don't feel any anger towards evil-doers you can't love virtuous
39:56 people.
39:57 See, he says, "Hold no resentment or love for abusers, only indifference."
40:03 So you're indifferent to those who do evil which means you can't feel affection or love
40:07 or any positive emotion towards those who do good.
40:10 You understand?
40:13 He's offering out this "feel nothing, feel nothing and you'll be fine, feel nothing and
40:19 you'll be fine, feel nothing and you'll be fine."
40:20 It's like, no, you're kind of dead.
40:23 Because you get no resentment, you get no love.
40:27 You can't love yourself, you can't be loved by others, you can't love others.
40:33 You feel nothing.
40:34 I will take away your pain.
40:39 I'm not here to take away your pain.
40:41 I'm here to help you harness it for virtue.
40:43 Because I can't take away your pain.
40:45 Because you can't be someone who wasn't abused if you were abused.
40:48 You can't take that.
40:51 I can't take away your pain.
40:52 This guy's offering to take away your pain by taking away your history, your identity,
40:56 your process, your emotions, your thoughts, your judgment, everything.
40:59 I don't want to.
41:00 I can't take that away.
41:03 I can't make you somebody who wasn't abused if you were abused.
41:06 I can't make myself someone who wasn't abused since I was abused.
41:10 I can use that pain to do to myself.
41:13 Yeah, I have become comfortably numb.
41:16 It's a song about a drug addict who will not judge his parents.
41:22 He will not judge his parents.
41:25 No, not ambivalence.
41:29 Ambivalence is when you have strong feelings to both ends.
41:33 Ambivalence is not neutral.
41:34 Ambivalence is two opposing forces, like two people pulling on a rope.
41:40 Thank you sir, powerful discussion, makes so much sense.
41:43 You can't be something other than who you are and you were not in control of the forces
41:50 that shaped you as a child.
41:53 Can you be some...
41:54 Let's say it's got nothing to do with abuse.
41:56 Can you be someone who never learned English?
41:59 No, you can't ever be someone who never learned English.
42:12 You can't be somebody with no history.
42:15 You can't be somebody with no past.
42:17 That's who you are.
42:19 And you can work with it, but you can't undo it.
42:23 I can work with my pain.
42:24 I can work with what happened to me.
42:26 I can't undo it.
42:29 I can learn from it and do the opposite.
42:34 But I can't be somebody who was never hurt.
42:36 I can't be indifferent.
42:38 See, only indifference.
42:41 Keep your abusers accountable, but only be indifferent.
42:44 But if you're indifferent to your abusers, if you're indifferent to your abusers, you're
42:49 indifferent towards your abuse.
42:50 You're indifferent towards your inner child, your child who suffered.
42:55 You're indifferent.
42:57 Because your child who suffered is, "Get me to safety, get me to safety, get me to safety,
43:00 get me to safety, get me to safety, now, forever, get me to safety."
43:03 You know, it's like your child's in a burning building.
43:08 "Oh, it's just half a smoke outside."
43:11 Be observed, like an anthropologist.
43:14 But observe, don't go in and help.
43:15 Are you kidding me?
43:16 Be indifferent.
43:17 Be indifferent.
43:18 Your inner child is, "Save me, save me, get me to safety."
43:33 Can you risk death in a fire to save a child without hating the child's suffering and loving
43:40 his potential to survive?
43:41 "I don't think so.
43:44 I don't think so.
43:46 God, no.
43:48 What a horrifying existence.
43:52 Can I be a peaceful parent without loving my daughter?
43:55 Can I be a peaceful parent without hating abuse?"
44:03 The train, you're walking on the train tracks, your shadow casts ahead of you, you turn around,
44:07 there's a big giant train bearing down, be indifferent.
44:14 The train's bearing down on you and it's going to cream you, man.
44:16 Don't hold onto your fear, let it go.
44:20 Let your fear go.
44:23 Neither love the train nor hate the train.
44:26 Be completely indifferent and act as if the train is not there.
44:36 And you are staying on the snowplow.
44:43 All right.
44:49 Thank you for your tips, my friends.
44:50 I really, really do appreciate it.
44:51 There's value in what I've done.
44:53 In this explication, I had this here that I read today and I was like, "Ooh, I could
44:57 talk about that tonight."
44:58 If you find this helpful, of course, I really, really do appreciate your tips and thank you
45:02 so much for your support of the show.
45:04 It really does absolutely, completely, totally mean the world to me and makes it all worthwhile.
45:09 And thank you so much for those who support the show in helping us bring this to the world,
45:15 to the future, and I promise you, you will absolutely love the Peaceful Parenting book.
45:19 And thank you for those who are helping support the show in that as well.
45:22 Jared is doing a great job in the research and we have just welcomed another member of
45:29 the team for more research and that's going to be great.
45:32 Jared is also doing a great job on The Truth About the French Revolution.
45:36 The Truth About the Wild West will be out soon, not just in audio format, but we could
45:39 do a video on it as well.
45:41 And if you're listening to this later, of course, freedomain.com/donate.
45:44 I would really, really appreciate your help on that.
45:49 Thanks so much for doing these and for all who donate and participate, absolutely.
45:53 Looking forward to the Peaceful Parenting book.
45:55 Yes, it is quite something.
45:56 It is quite something.
45:57 It's really just turning me inside out.
45:59 All right, freedomain.com/donate.
46:02 If you would like to help out the show, don't forget to check out freedomain.com/books for
46:05 some great, great, great books, wonderful books, especially the novels.
46:09 I love them to death, absolutely, completely, and totally.
46:12 And don't forget, if you're listening to this later, you want to join a great local community
46:18 and check out StephBot AI, my artificial intelligence bot on my books.
46:23 If you want to check that out, you can go to freedomain.locals.com.
46:27 You could sign up, use the promo code, all caps, UPB2022, and you get a free month to
46:32 try it out.
46:33 If you'd want to sign up, you can get 12 months for the price of 10.
46:35 Thanks, everyone, so much.
46:36 Have yourself a glorious evening.
46:38 Love you guys.
46:39 For dropping by, it means the world to me.
46:41 I'll talk to you soon.
46:42 Bye.
46:42 [BLANK_AUDIO]

Recommended