- 3 years ago
#CLSA upgrades India to 'overweight', joining #MorganStanley and #Nomura. What's driving their bullish stance?
CLSA India's Economist & Head Of Research, Indranil Sengupta, shares insights. #BQLive
CLSA India's Economist & Head Of Research, Indranil Sengupta, shares insights. #BQLive
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 - Thanks for tuning in to BQ Conversations.
00:04 I'm your host, Nihat Shah,
00:05 and our guest today is Indranil Sen Gupta.
00:08 Lots has happened on the fixed income markets
00:11 and the space, both globally and locally,
00:14 in the last month, month and a half,
00:15 and it's a delight to be talking to him
00:17 to understand his perspective.
00:18 Indranil, great having you.
00:19 Thanks for taking the time out.
00:21 - Thank you.
00:22 My pleasure.
00:23 - Can I start with the global,
00:24 even though your note was, of course,
00:26 talking about how you're becoming more bullish
00:28 on the Indian bonds,
00:29 but can I just start off with the global factors, Indranil?
00:33 A higher for longer,
00:34 even if it means that there are no further rate increases,
00:37 does that augur,
00:39 or what is the kind of implication that that has
00:43 for risk assets worldwide,
00:45 in particularly emerging market bonds and equities?
00:47 - So I think that, you know,
00:52 the Fed obviously is now getting repriced
00:58 in the US bond markets.
01:01 And, you know, I never believed, for example,
01:03 that the Fed would cut in June, July of 2023
01:09 as the US money markets were pricing.
01:11 But now that, you know, a lot of the repricing is done,
01:15 I presume that, you know,
01:17 markets will now stabilize at some stage,
01:21 and, you know, in a range, of course,
01:24 and then look to cuts, you know, as and when they happen.
01:28 I mean, of course, the Fed may hike once more,
01:30 but then somewhere down the line,
01:32 then the markets will begin to price in cuts.
01:35 Now, if you see, it looks like, you know,
01:40 US inflation headline and core are stuck somewhere
01:43 in the threes now,
01:45 and the Fed is in the fives.
01:47 So, you know, 200 basis points is a very high real rate,
01:52 for real policy rate, even by US standards.
01:56 So I think that, you know,
01:57 earlier the markets were underpricing the Fed,
02:00 now to some extent,
02:01 there is a risk that they are overpricing the Fed.
02:04 So I think that as we go along,
02:09 we will find that the dollar will begin to, you know,
02:12 you know, soften as, you know,
02:17 there is a sense that the Fed is done,
02:18 or at least the Fed has paused,
02:20 and that will give headroom to emerging markets
02:25 to, you know, see lower rates.
02:28 - Could it, so how does that therefore impact,
02:33 like you said, it gives a bit of a headroom
02:34 to emerging markets,
02:35 but how does it play into India's and RBI's hands?
02:40 Could idiosyncratic factors like supply side,
02:44 oil issues, or otherwise,
02:47 force the RBI's hand to not do what it ordinarily would
02:52 in the case of Fed doing what you are saying it would?
02:55 - So I will, you know, look at it in three ways.
03:01 Number one, I think that if the dollar were to soften,
03:06 then the primary reason why the RBI is sitting at 6 1/2,
03:10 which is the Fed, will go away.
03:12 So, you know, there's no reason for the RBI
03:13 to sit at 6 1/2 in a country where, you know,
03:17 inflation is averaging around 5 1/2
03:19 in this sort of a global environment.
03:23 Number two, if you look at those,
03:27 in India, typically higher rates
03:35 tend to depreciate the rupee
03:36 and lower rates tend to appreciate the rupee,
03:39 which is, you know, what Governor Subbarao
03:42 once called the Indian exceptionalism.
03:45 So what typically happens is that in India,
03:49 you have foreign equity FII's holding $600, $650 billion,
03:54 local FII's holding, you know, $30, $40 billion,
03:59 debt FII's holding $30, $40 billion.
04:03 So the movements by the equity FII's
04:06 tend to dominate the currency,
04:08 unlike in many other emerging markets,
04:11 where maybe the two are like 50/50.
04:14 So if you cut rates, you know, FII's chasing,
04:18 equity FII's chasing growth coming,
04:21 the currency appreciates, and that brings in debt FII's,
04:24 because they want capital gains and vice versa.
04:27 So therefore, I will say that, you know,
04:30 if you were to lower rates, you know,
04:36 I think that will actually go and support the rupee.
04:40 Now let's come to the case of oil.
04:43 Now, sure, if oil prices go up,
04:47 there is always the risk that, you know,
04:51 this will lead to domestic inflation.
04:53 The government may not immediately pass on,
04:55 because, you know, there's obviously an election nearing,
04:58 but then sooner or later,
05:00 there's a limit to how much you can, you know,
05:02 bear in the fund of risk.
05:04 But at the same time, if the RBI has to sell FX
05:09 to fund the oil bill,
05:11 it will have to do that much larger OMO
05:15 to provide liquidity.
05:16 So, you know, that also will be supportive of bonds.
05:21 So if you stress test the variety of factors,
05:26 you find that the risk reward
05:28 is now in favor of bonds than against,
05:31 given the sell-off that we have seen.
05:32 - Got it.
05:35 There's also this theory that independent of
05:37 what kind of flows start coming in from June,
05:40 because of India's inclusion
05:43 in the JP Morgan Global Emerging Market Bond Index,
05:45 the bond yields will not wait for the event to happen,
05:47 but might be start discounting it
05:49 in the first half of the next calendar as well.
05:52 Is that also supportive, if you will, of the bond markets?
05:57 - See, that's supportive in sentiment,
05:59 but not in numbers.
06:01 Because, you know, what will happen is that
06:03 once the debt FIIs come in with the FX,
06:08 the RBIs will buy the FX and give them rupees to buy bonds.
06:12 And therefore, the RBI will cut down
06:15 its own open market operations, OMO purchases.
06:19 So debt FIIs coming in will not add to the demand
06:22 in the G-Sec market.
06:23 It'll just substitute the demand from RBI
06:27 with the demand from debt FIIs.
06:30 But yes, in terms of sentiment, it's a positive.
06:34 - The event in itself, Indranil,
06:37 there was a lot of fanfare around it
06:39 because it's a long anticipated one.
06:42 There are people or certain quarters who tell me that
06:45 this is maybe not as big a positive as it is.
06:50 A cushion on the downside should events turn worse
06:54 for the rupee.
06:55 What is your thought on India's inclusion there
06:58 in JPM currently, and potentially some other bond indices
07:01 at some point of time on the back of this happening?
07:03 - I think a lot of this would have been true
07:07 had this happened in 2013.
07:09 In 2013, we were talking of 200 billion of AUM
07:14 tied to this index.
07:20 And our FX reserves were about 250 billion to 300 billion.
07:24 So 20 billion coming in in 2013 was a lot of money,
07:29 almost 10% of FX reserves.
07:31 Today our FX reserves are 650, 600, 620.
07:36 So 20 billion today is really very small, 2, 3%.
07:40 So I don't think it'll matter much either way.
07:44 And in fact, FPI investments in debt in the past
07:49 have been much higher even without this 20 billion.
07:53 That is number one.
07:54 And secondly, I think that, I understand that
07:58 a lot of the funds that practice index
08:04 are also active funds.
08:07 So it's not mandatory that you have to go,
08:11 exactly mirror the index, you can go over and below.
08:16 I also think that we may go and list in other indices,
08:21 but the reason why we wanted to get in here
08:24 is that this was the bigger one.
08:26 So I am not so sure whether the others
08:31 are going to be bigger.
08:32 And I also think that some of it may not be additive
08:37 in the sense that, if another index says
08:41 you should have $10 billion in India
08:43 and you already have 20, you don't have to shift.
08:46 - Got it, got it.
08:49 Okay, now last couple of questions
08:51 and I'm coming to the crux of what happens
08:55 from our central bank's perspective.
08:58 And you briefly mentioned it at the start
09:00 of this conversation, but I'm trying to kind of
09:02 extrapolate this conversation now.
09:04 In your note, I read that should the Fed
09:09 be on a pause mode, then it gives the room
09:14 or I'll go to the reserve bank to make a meaningful cut
09:17 if I'm not wrong in the month of,
09:18 starting the month of December itself.
09:20 One, could you elaborate a bit on that?
09:22 And two, are you a contrarian here, Indranil?
09:24 Do you reckon that the street lodges still pricing
09:27 in rate cuts are further down the line in 2024?
09:30 Or do you reckon that mostly this will be
09:33 the most probable scenario of December
09:36 seeing the first of the cuts?
09:37 - So, let me put forth my argument that,
09:41 inflation is going to be around 5%, right?
09:46 I mean, it's going to fall this evening
09:49 and you are at six and a half.
09:50 Your core inflation is already at 5%.
09:54 If you look one year out, the RBI itself
09:56 is projecting four and a half percent inflation.
10:00 So your real rate is at least one and a half percent
10:04 to 2%.
10:05 So, should you be sitting at a real rate this high
10:09 at a time when there's so much of uncertainty,
10:12 when the chances are that US is going to slow down?
10:16 Therefore, I think that while I was projecting higher
10:21 RBI rates when the Fed was hiking,
10:26 now that the Fed is done or looks to be close to done,
10:30 I think that the RBI will want to unwind the tightening.
10:35 Now, of course, the Fed may hike once,
10:37 that may force the RBI to hike once more
10:40 because differential is already just 100 basis points.
10:44 But I'm sure that once the Fed stops,
10:46 maybe again by February, the RBI will want to roll back
10:50 because there are two factors, right?
10:52 I mean, there's the Fed and there's domestic inflation.
10:55 Domestic inflation does not warrant a policy rate
10:59 of six and a half percent for sure.
11:02 So once the Fed constraint goes away,
11:04 I'm sure that the RBI will also begin to cut.
11:08 - You would reckon that some of the domestic
11:11 inflationary factors, crude not withstanding,
11:13 but the domestic factors are also transient in nature
11:16 and difficult to predict whether they sustain
11:17 over a period of time?
11:19 - See, I think you cannot make monetary policy
11:21 depending on the price of vegetables and so on,
11:24 because these go up, these come down.
11:26 Like, you know, we had said El Nino will lead
11:29 to 200 basis point jump in food prices.
11:32 It actually led to a jump of 260 basis points.
11:36 I think the government did a good job of, you know,
11:38 cooling food prices to vet the various measures they took.
11:42 And, you know, if someone had asked you two months ago
11:45 that inflation will fall this sharply,
11:48 you would have said, you know, can that really happen?
11:52 Because these are very, very volatile.
11:54 Ultimately you have to see core.
11:55 Core is now down to 5%.
11:58 So from that perspective, I think that, you know,
12:01 the RBI also will actually see that rather than the overall,
12:06 because that is why, you know,
12:07 this is something the governor said,
12:09 this is something the finance minister also said,
12:12 that we cannot really, you know,
12:13 we are not looking at RBI monetary policy
12:16 to combat what is essentially a rain shock.
12:19 - Okay, got it.
12:21 Inderdeep, so, and hence viewers,
12:25 Inderdeep Sen, Gupta and team have turned bullish on bonds
12:29 and that note lays it out beautifully.
12:31 So we kind of captured all of that in the story
12:33 that we do for this interview as well.
12:34 I have one final question, Inderdeep.
12:36 I'm changing tracks here, but it's a point that is,
12:40 that was raised and debated by a couple of guests
12:44 in the last one month.
12:45 And I thought I'll ask you,
12:46 and that's around the belief around what could happen
12:50 to India's current account deficit numbers
12:52 over the course of the next two years
12:54 and what might actually be desired.
12:56 Now, one, are you in the camp which believes
12:59 that we might be headed towards CAD neutrality
13:01 over the course of the next 24 months?
13:03 Why or why not, part one.
13:05 And part two, is that desirable or would you rather
13:08 that India as a growth country
13:10 remain a current account deficit to a particular extent
13:14 and keeps on funding growth, which might be necessary?
13:16 - So I certainly think India
13:19 should run a current account deficit and fund growth.
13:22 That is number one.
13:24 Number two, you see, there are, you know,
13:27 I know that the argument that is made
13:29 is based on, you know, higher services inflows.
13:35 But when economy recovers fully,
13:39 then import demand also rises very sharply.
13:46 So, you know, you cannot take the import demand of today
13:50 and take the services flows and look at CAD
13:55 because, you know, of course we are in a shallow recovery
13:59 in India, globally, you know, growth is also very suspect,
14:04 but I am guessing like, you know, two years down the line,
14:07 three years down the line,
14:09 the cycle will have meaningfully turned.
14:11 All cycles, you know, you have up cycles and down cycles.
14:14 So when there is a up cycle, which returns in growth terms,
14:19 import demand will also go up.
14:20 - All right. Okay.
14:24 Inderneet, such a pleasure talking to you.
14:25 Thank you for taking the time out and speaking to us
14:28 and look forward to having you more often on our platform.
14:30 - Thank you.
14:32 - Thank you. The pleasure is ours.
14:33 Viewers, thanks for tuning in.
14:35 (upbeat music)
14:37 (upbeat music)
14:40 (upbeat music)
14:42 (upbeat music)
14:45 (upbeat music)
14:48 [BLANK_AUDIO]