Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 years ago
What is Industry's wishlist from #Budget2024? 


Tamanna Inamdar speaks to CII President R Dinesh, DG Chandrajit Banerjee, and President Designate Sanjiv Puri.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------
For more videos subscribe to our channel: https://www.youtube.com/@NDTVProfitIndia
Visit NDTV Profit for more news:https://www.ndtvprofit.com/
Don't enter the stock market unaware. Read all Research Reports here: https://www.ndtvprofit.com/research-reports
Follow NDTV Profit here
Twitter: https://twitter.com/NDTVProfitIndia , https://twitter.com/NDTVProfit
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ndtvprofit
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ndtvprofit/

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00 [MUSIC PLAYING]
00:03 [MUSIC PLAYING]
00:06 [MUSIC PLAYING]
00:10 [MUSIC PLAYING]
00:13 [MUSIC PLAYING]
00:37 Welcome to our special coverage here on NDTV Profit,
00:40 where we're talking about budget 2024
00:43 being the year of the takeoff.
00:47 It's a theme that is being recognized the world over
00:50 and not just in India.
00:52 Our path to move towards a developed nation
00:54 is progressing quickly, and a very, very big role
00:57 will be played by industry.
00:59 I have the opportunity today to speak
01:02 with the top brass of the CII.
01:04 I'm speaking today with Mr. R. Dinesh, the CII president,
01:08 Mr. Sanjeev Puri, the CII president-designate,
01:11 and Mr. Chandrajit Banerjee, DG of CII,
01:14 to talk about what they expect from budget 2024.
01:18 Welcome, gentlemen.
01:19 Thank you so much for speaking with us here on NDTV Profit.
01:23 Let me take the first question to the CII president, Mr. R.
01:27 Dinesh.
01:30 Technically, this is an interim budget, a vote and account.
01:32 But if past precedents, especially in 2019,
01:35 has taught us anything, is to expect anything and not
01:39 underestimate what you see.
01:40 Having said that, there is an extensive wish list
01:43 that the CII has put in place.
01:46 My question is, how much of this will
01:48 help prod private capex, which relatively is still lagging?
01:55 So thank you.
01:56 And if you really look at it, I think
01:58 India, as you said, is in a very sweet spot.
02:01 And both from opportunity from the geopolitical side,
02:05 and as well as from the economic growth perspective.
02:07 And I think that's something which, I would call it,
02:10 is a great position to be in.
02:12 So in that background, you actually
02:16 see industries who are, I would call it,
02:19 very positive about the future and the way in which
02:22 the future is going to evolve.
02:24 If you look at the various CII surveys
02:26 which we have been having, all of it
02:27 is coming through as to the growth prospects
02:30 being very high.
02:31 But having said that, let us not forget
02:33 that we are in the midst of a very strong,
02:36 I would call it, uncertain geopolitical world.
02:39 Therefore, if you talk about capex for domestic use,
02:43 for the necessity, for the growth which
02:46 is taking place in India, that's very much happening.
02:49 And I would say that's where you see significant capacity
02:52 utilization taking place, cutting across all sectors.
02:56 And therefore, I do believe that the current growth rates which
03:02 you are speaking of in excess of 7%
03:04 is something which is going to mean even more capex,
03:08 or rather, the utilization of this capacity being used up.
03:11 And therefore, the need to get significant capex coming in
03:15 from a private sector perspective.
03:17 And the final point is, overseas investments into India
03:21 is also seeing a big uptick, which
03:23 is also part of this growth pattern which
03:25 you are speaking of.
03:27 Absolutely.
03:29 Mr. Banerjee, let me take that point to you.
03:32 And yes, we are hearing and reporting constantly.
03:35 And we cover stock markets, so at least in the listed space,
03:39 you have this conversation about more and more private capex,
03:45 more utilization improving, although the RBI says
03:48 it's still sub 75%, which is a bit of a concern.
03:51 What about in the unlisted space?
03:53 What about in the MSME space?
03:56 Is there a bit of push required to actually get
04:00 those investments going?
04:02 Yes, that question.
04:03 It's an important question, because what we really today--
04:08 yeah, thank you, Tawana.
04:09 You know, what's going to be important today
04:11 is to see how the small and mid-sized companies, which
04:15 are going to be very, very critical,
04:17 are able to access liquidity, which much of it
04:23 may not be in the ambit of the budget.
04:26 But important for them is to see to it--
04:29 for us to see to it that MSME sector have
04:34 availability of liquidity.
04:36 Second, what's very, very, very critical
04:38 is to see how we are able--
04:41 one of the things, easy things to be done for them
04:43 is to really ensure payments on time for them,
04:48 which itself helps a lot.
04:50 The third area that I would see coming up for the MSME
04:53 is, yes, a little bit of incentivization for them,
04:59 because from that sector would come in employment.
05:02 From that sector would be the number of trade agreements
05:06 that you see that India has been able to enter.
05:08 They are going to be a very critical part in taking
05:11 and leveraging those trade agreements to enhance
05:17 our exports.
05:18 So facilitation for the MSME sector
05:21 is going to be very, very critical,
05:24 as we are looking at a growth rate for India, which
05:27 is going to be 7% plus over periods of time.
05:31 And that support would be, number one, essential.
05:35 But to support them would be absolutely much more essential
05:39 so that they are able to expand and put in, as you said,
05:43 fresh investments as we go along.
05:46 Absolutely.
05:47 And we'll take that question to Mr. Puri as well in just a bit.
05:51 But a quick follow up there from Mr. Ardhanesh
05:55 in terms of some of the key pointers
05:57 that the CIA has put together in its wish list.
06:00 What I found interesting is on the GST structure,
06:03 though not necessarily within the ambit of what
06:05 the union government can do.
06:08 But I just want you to explain why
06:10 you thought it's interesting or important to move to a three
06:13 rate GST structure, split into essential, standard,
06:16 and luxury/demerit goods.
06:20 Would you say that even as GST collections have
06:22 been very buoyant, some of the problems or hurdles
06:26 of implementation from a corporate view
06:29 still need to be ironed out?
06:30 So if you look at it, I think the settle--
06:38 or people have now got settled down to using GST.
06:41 And that's something which is very clear.
06:43 And if you speak especially to the medium and small scale
06:46 enterprises who have all become, so to say,
06:49 now utilizing this digital method of making GST payments,
06:55 the feedback we have got is that the complexity is
06:58 in because of the different tiers.
07:01 And I would call it the different layers
07:03 within which the GST mechanism is being monitored.
07:07 Therefore, the simple focus is to get these three tier
07:09 structure, which will then enable easy usage,
07:14 and also I would call it remove all the ambiguities, which
07:18 is what I think has actually had been issues with the GST system.
07:23 But if you look at it today, I don't
07:25 think that there is any need to tinker
07:28 with the system in itself.
07:29 It is the three tiers which we are recommending,
07:32 which will make the difference from making it very easy
07:35 for people to use and utilize.
07:37 Yeah.
07:38 Let me come to Mr. Sanjeev Puri, who our president designate.
07:41 And I think you will be taking the reins, Mr. Puri,
07:44 at a very interesting time for India, where on the face of it,
07:49 we are reaching new heights, Mr. Puri.
07:52 We are growing at a great clip.
07:55 Your discretionary consumption is fantastic.
07:58 But there are concerns about consumption
07:59 at the bottom of the pyramid.
08:01 I want to start with your perspective on this question.
08:03 And I'm sure this is something you're seeing, Mr. Puri,
08:06 where your luxury hotels are selling out.
08:09 But then your base sort of products,
08:12 are you seeing a slowdown there?
08:13 Is rural slowdown or consumption something
08:16 you think this budget should at least directionally address?
08:20 OK.
08:26 Let me start by saying I think the focus of the government
08:33 through various policy instruments,
08:35 through the budgets, has been on sustainable and inclusive
08:38 development.
08:39 And that's visible in multiple dimensions.
08:43 And if you look at the various indices,
08:45 they're all moving forward.
08:47 And we've actually seen some good path-breaking stuff
08:49 happen over several years in the past.
08:52 And that's why the economy is doing so well.
08:55 But the reality is that we've all been challenged by COVID.
09:02 And then the challenges of the geopolitical situation,
09:06 which created an enormous amount of inflation in the economy.
09:10 And we are also faced with climate emergency
09:15 on account of the excessive emissions
09:17 in the developed economies.
09:19 And all this puts its stress in the economy,
09:22 in pockets of the economy.
09:24 And that's why in some pockets, we're
09:26 seeing that the progress is not as much as in other pockets.
09:31 And rural is one area.
09:32 I think you're right that--
09:34 and the government is already focusing on it.
09:36 But this is an area where I think perhaps more could be
09:39 done.
09:39 More could be done by way of rural infrastructure,
09:43 improving resilience of agriculture
09:45 through better coverage of irrigation,
09:47 to collectively in a public-private partnership
09:50 working together through what we call
09:53 as a climate-smart agriculture to build resilience.
09:56 There are also opportunities opening up
09:58 through the new policy reform on leasing forest land
10:03 to private sector to create productive capacity.
10:07 And today, because of the growth of certain sectors,
10:09 like, say, the real estate, India
10:11 is actually having to import more amount of wood.
10:14 So once this is enforced with an economic model,
10:18 that will immediately create employment.
10:20 And these are some of the enablers,
10:22 I would say, already in place.
10:24 We need to progress that.
10:26 And maybe in certain areas, press the pedal a little more.
10:30 And ultimately, I think we will get the kind of results
10:34 that are anticipated.
10:35 True, Mr. Puri.
10:36 But the concern or the spoiler seems
10:40 to be things like patchy rainfall, something
10:44 which we experienced last year.
10:45 It contributes to rural distress.
10:47 And then, of course, there are many other factors.
10:49 What can the government do to mitigate this
10:52 in terms of a policy direction and address
10:56 issues like unemployment in a more cohesive fashion?
11:00 So that's what I alluded to in my response.
11:08 I said, as far as the weather events are concerned,
11:11 which have a disproportionate impact on the agricultural
11:14 value chains.
11:16 And we have to really continue the path
11:19 that the government is taking and perhaps do more
11:23 there in a spirit of public-private partnership.
11:26 All of us need to come together.
11:28 It's about improving penetration of irrigation.
11:31 It's being disseminating the information on weather
11:34 and educating farmers on the practices,
11:38 comprehensively, over a period of time,
11:40 bringing in Climate Smart Agriculture,
11:42 the R&D to build resilience in the agri-value chains.
11:45 I think these are the things that need to be done.
11:47 Rainwater harvesting, amongst others.
11:50 These are issues that are already
11:52 being addressed through various policy interventions.
11:55 I think, collectively, we need to come together and perhaps
11:57 see how we can make faster progress on it.
11:59 That's really the point I'm making.
12:02 As far as employment is concerned,
12:04 I think, again, we must keep in mind that many indices
12:08 on the positive track.
12:09 Even if you look at the women participation rate in labor,
12:13 that is also on an upward track.
12:15 Yes, but India does have a lot more youth.
12:19 So we do need to strengthen incomes in the farm area.
12:23 We do need to create other opportunities.
12:26 And I think the focus through PLI
12:28 to make India into a manufacturing hub,
12:31 to also revitalize certain industries that
12:35 have high employment multipliers,
12:38 like the toys and textiles.
12:41 I think these are the areas that will provide value.
12:44 And to support this, CIL also suggested
12:47 some kind of an employment-linked incentive.
12:52 So that provides an impetus to industry
12:54 that is a large employer.
12:56 [MUSIC PLAYING]
13:00 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:04 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:07 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:10 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:13 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:16 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:19 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:22 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:25 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:28 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:31 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:34 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:37 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:40 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:43 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:46 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:49 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:52 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:55 [MUSIC ENDS]
13:58 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:01 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:04 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:07 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:10 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:13 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:16 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:19 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:22 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:25 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:28 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:31 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:34 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:37 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:40 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:43 [MUSIC ENDS]
14:46 [MUSIC ENDS]
15:14 [MUSIC ENDS]
15:17 One of the things that, you know, did catch my eye is the CII recommendation to better target subsidies for food and fertilizer.
15:35 And that sort of links to what we're talking about, rural distress or any kind of pain points.
15:40 So 90% of subsidies are targeted for food and fertilizer.
15:44 The food subsidy specifically has been going on since COVID times.
15:49 Would you say it's time to re-look at the parameters of where it's targeted?
15:54 I think the larger point is that better targeting will bring in efficiencies.
16:03 And better instruments of targeting also will bring in efficiencies.
16:07 I think the government has very, very wisely used the digital infrastructure to actually do direct benefit transfer, for example.
16:15 So it's more about, you know, sharper targeting and better instruments to provide that support to those who need it.
16:22 And we completely, you know, CII completely supports the fact that these welfare measures need to happen and need to be strengthened as we go along.
16:30 But the idea is really to target it more sharply and move more towards direct benefit transfer.
16:38 Right. Target more sharply, move more towards direct benefit transfer.
16:43 I'll come back to you, Mr. Puri, but I want to take off from what you've said on the PLI scheme and I'll come to Mr. Dinesh on it.
16:48 We have, I think, one and a half to two years now of actual implementation and play out of the PLI scheme since it was announced.
16:55 So we have some idea of how it's working out.
16:58 I want to get your assessment. Has the PLI scheme been a hit at this point or ways to go?
17:05 How can there be more incentive and more improvement?
17:08 Because remember, the end goal is to become more atmanirbhar and incentivize companies to get into production, which might not seem too appealing on the face of it.
17:22 It's a very good question. And if you look at it, I think I believe the PLI scheme has been very successful for three, four reasons.
17:29 I think people are first of all, India has obviously become this an issue of most companies to look at, one for its domestic market.
17:38 And secondly, with this focus on the infrastructure and the cost of doing business, its own competitiveness.
17:43 Therefore, in that background, I think the PLI scheme is like adding, I would call it the most, the sweetener for people to come in and start investing in India.
17:55 In that background, that this has been successful. The second issue is that what do we see as action at the ground?
18:02 And if you look at it, I think there have been I mean, these are all I would call it big decisions for people to make,
18:09 especially considering that they have been integrated into very many global value chains across the world.
18:14 And therefore, I think it's very difficult to take a decision or take a view from a one or two year period.
18:21 So our view is that at least it should actually be extended.
18:25 And there is a greater opportunity to attract even more investments to come in, not just from overseas companies,
18:32 but also Indian companies who wish to participate and become part of this global value chains.
18:36 Therefore, in my view, the scheme is being quite successful.
18:41 It needs to be further continued and this will create a large opportunity for both global and Indian companies to invest in India and become part of global value chains.
18:53 And of course, the point which Sanjeev mentioned of generating employment is also a core focus.
18:58 Absolutely. Mr. Puri, just a quick take on the PLI scheme and what are the kind of sectors you would like to see added to the bucket?
19:07 So, I mean, if you look at there are two aspects to it and maybe let me first finish the employment generation side of it,
19:17 because Sanjeev alluded to it and that is the employment incentive.
19:21 What we are basically saying is that ultimately manufacturing is going to be about becoming, as I said, for the domestic market and global.
19:28 But for a short term and to make it more cost competitive, we will need to focus on the employment generation sectors.
19:37 So, for example, logistics, for example, tourism, for example, health, all of these are sectors where you're going to see significant improvement in job creation.
19:46 Therefore, one focus area is to look at those sectors where there is going to be significant employment generation.
19:53 And that's something which CII is looking and looking at as areas of immediate focus.
20:02 If you look at the new sectors within manufacturing, there is toys. Sorry, go ahead.
20:08 Yes. No, no, absolutely. I just wanted to get a quick view from Mr. Puri on it as well. I don't know if he can hear me.
20:14 You know, on the PLI point of it, Mr. Puri, the focus so far has been on sectors to fill the gap.
20:21 So we realize in COVID we need to make APIs locally. We're doing that.
20:25 We realized after the semiconductor crisis that we better get on to the act and make our own.
20:30 What do you think we need to add to that list now?
20:36 So I think Dinesh has kind of covered all the areas that need to be additionally looked at.
20:43 These are all areas that have high index to employment, whether it is areas like tourism or whether it's areas like toys amongst others.
20:50 So nothing more to add from my perspective.
20:53 OK. OK. Mr. Banerjee, I wanted to come to one bit, which I found interesting in the wish list from CII.
20:59 And it's in the MSME segment and contextualized with female labor participation rate, which we want to increase to 50 percent.
21:08 You say that there should be 12 weeks of sort of subsidies given to MSMEs because by law, women are now entitled to six months paternity benefit.
21:18 I suppose that is the context of this. Can you explain this?
21:21 And is it because you are seeing a hesitation to hire women because of this benefit?
21:32 No, I would not say that it's because of any hesitation to hire women.
21:38 But we would like, you know, one of the big areas of success in India, if I would see, is the way in the last few years,
21:50 focus has been given for higher involvement of women in the in the labor force and making it the 50 percent,
22:01 the 50 percent of our possible, you know, workforce to be better engaged and more engaged.
22:10 Much of the schemes that we have seen, the ecosystems which has been created,
22:16 much have been created towards directed towards the welfare of women in our country.
22:23 I mean, I'm not going to going to go into the details, but that's the background.
22:26 When you look at cleaner fuels to everything, so much that has been done.
22:32 But now it's time. And we have some we have developed in the country, if you see,
22:38 if you really look at the number of the 48 percent of our STEM graduates are women.
22:44 So there are some very good numbers coming out now.
22:49 Now, how do we utilize that in our workforce? And there is so much of scope for that.
22:53 And if you see even women in manufacturing, I see that the engagement of women in manufacturing,
23:00 be it heavy machinery companies, that's increasing very strongly.
23:07 So in different types of segments of we see women employment increasing.
23:14 Now, we need to increase that further, facilitate that further.
23:18 And whatever there are, whatever there are in terms of inhibitors that being removed.
23:23 Now, I want to draw an example. When India started focusing through a policy ecosystem on CSR,
23:30 the two percent CSR that came in, we saw how the private sector followed
23:36 and getting more and more engaged into CSR. Now, here there are certain policy enablers
23:42 that we are really looking at, which will help more women, say, for instance,
23:48 like what you said, maternity leave or pay parity, pledging towards a pay parity by companies,
23:58 or even looking at how they develop pressures.
24:01 This is where we will find more and more women being able to contribute to any segment.
24:09 And the special segment could be MSME, where clusters of such could be developed,
24:14 facilities which could be developed. And that would really help more women participation.
24:20 And that would even help us fuel the type of growth rate that we are aspiring for.
24:26 Right, right. Just one last point before I let you go, gentlemen, and I'll take this to Mr. Puri.
24:32 It's about the taxpayer or the salary taxpayer, because if we want to drive consumption,
24:40 not just at the bottom of the pyramid, but throughout, do you think it's important
24:46 to now give relief and incentivize this segment as well, especially if you want to push,
24:52 you know, better manufacturing and consumption?
25:00 No, I think certainly there is a merit in considering some relief to people at the lower end of the tax brackets.
25:11 I think that would spur consumption and in turn aid the virtuous cycle that is already prevailing in the economy.
25:19 So a lot on the plate as far as CII is concerned. It is a big occasion to understand the policy push
25:27 of the government one way or the other in a pre-election budget that also becomes important
25:32 to understand what the vision is going forward. And here is what the industry wants.
25:37 Industry, of course, backbone of that entire dream of moving to a developed nation for India.
25:43 And it is one segment of the economy that needs to fire. Thank you so much to all of you for joining us today
25:49 on our budget takeoff special and hope to hear from you soon, soon after the budget.
25:54 Thank you. Thank you. That was the top brass of the CII on their expectations from the budget.
26:00 You know, the list of what industry wants is not very long because a lot of their expectations
26:07 do get fulfilled outside of the quorum of the budget. But it's important for private capex now
26:13 to push on at a time when maybe government capex will have to take a bit of a setback.
26:18 [Music]

Recommended