Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 years ago
What Budget Masters make of the interim budget. NDTV Profit speaks to

-Pranav Sayta, nternational Tax and Transaction Services Leader, EY India
-Maneesh Dangi, Founder, Macro Mosaic Investing and Research
-Shankkar Aiyar, Political Economy Analyst & Author
-Rajiv Anand, Deputy Managing Director, Axis Bank
-Ravi DharamshiFounder & CIO, ValueQuest Investment Advisors

Also read, what the Budget Masters from NDTV Profit's special budget shows have to say about the economic and financial roadmap announced in the budget: https://bit.ly/47TppS0

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 A few surprises. If people thought it was an interim budget,
00:03 it was only in the length of the budget speech,
00:05 because otherwise some of the announcements that have come out
00:08 are stellar, and we'll talk about it editorially
00:11 and then get in our guests to talk about this.
00:13 But I think what stood out, I mean, it's all the assumptions
00:15 that they've made around receipts, tax receipts and expenditures.
00:19 For FY24, the budgeted actual numbers, and for FY25,
00:23 I think the standout announcement is fiscal deficit
00:26 is a percentage of GDP for FY25 at 5.1%.
00:32 I must say, guys, nobody thought about this
00:35 when they were pencilling their estimates.
00:37 I think the base case was 5.2 at best.
00:39 At best, maybe 5.3.
00:41 Even the net borrowing, and I think the bond markets have reacted,
00:44 not significantly yet.
00:45 The rupee is sub 83, so that's a good thing.
00:48 Bonds have gone down about seven basis points,
00:50 so not a big move on the bond market, but it'll play out.
00:52 Banking stocks as well should be in focus soon.
00:54 So, top takeaways, if you had to put it,
00:57 and Neeraj is absolutely right.
00:59 Fiscal deficit targets are better than expected.
01:01 She's sticking to 4.5% for FY26, no moving from there.
01:07 For the current year, it's below what the government had projected.
01:10 They projected 5.9. It's at 5.8%.
01:14 And remember, for the interim year, how do you get to that 4.6% or 4.5%?
01:19 Well, the figure she's given is 5.1%.
01:22 The estimate was between 5.1 to 5.3.
01:25 Borrowings are lower than expected in FY25.
01:28 Revenue receipts are higher than expected in FY24, and no changes.
01:33 Just a quick one on CAPEX.
01:35 That's what I'm saying.
01:36 Big jump.
01:37 11% odd is better than 10% is what the street was princeling,
01:42 you know, working with.
01:43 The number that she's given out is 11.1% increase in CAPEX.
01:48 So, that number looking far better.
01:50 And I think the street infrastructure, the sectors that we've been talking about,
01:53 railways, we'll see a rally.
01:55 We've seen that play out in the last few minutes.
01:57 Another smaller sector, and I know I talked about this early in the day,
02:00 and I didn't really think much was going to come out, was tourism.
02:03 Those counters also getting excited.
02:04 So, clearly things are working and on track in terms of what the expectation was.
02:10 But Neeraj Tamanna, surprising, I think the equity market would start seeing some buying
02:14 into a bit of a runaway.
02:15 Nothing's happened on the street.
02:16 Well, I think the CAPEX outlay being lower is something that doesn't work.
02:21 It's 11.
02:22 Yeah, but relative to 30%.
02:23 It's a 10% jump.
02:24 It's a 10% jump.
02:25 No, it's 11.1% uptake relative to previous year.
02:33 But the point being, because of the previous three years, and me, what I was with her is
02:36 in the panel, he was saying that anything below 20% might be something that might be
02:40 disappointing for the market because they're used to 30% odd.
02:42 Even I think Citibank's report was exactly that.
02:44 They were working with 20%.
02:46 So multiple things have happened, right?
02:47 And our guests should be with us any moment and we should talk to them.
02:50 But maybe one, the 5.8 trending number and two, the 5.1 confidence comes from these three
02:56 things.
02:57 CAPEX outlay not very high, 11.1, receipts much better and the gross borrowing number
03:01 14.1 lakh crores.
03:03 It is much, much lower.
03:05 Pranjal Bhandari was on record saying that any number lower than 15.2 or 15.1 is going
03:10 to be viewed positively.
03:11 And I think that is what has happened.
03:12 But after the story of the fact that we've made these commitments, right, you've talked
03:16 and also talking about GDP, fiscal deficit, she said below 4.5.
03:20 Yeah.
03:21 Not even 4.6 and not even pointed 4.5.
03:23 Very, very, very positive fact.
03:25 Very, with a lot of conviction, it's going to be below 4.5.
03:27 And also what was probably a way to look at it, not too many populist measures as such.
03:33 That could also be viewed in correct light.
03:37 Some disappointment on the tax front.
03:39 There will be, there will be, I guess, units of people expecting a little bit of tweaking
03:44 on taxation.
03:45 But like me and me discussed this earlier, no tweaking on taxation.
03:49 And which is also great news.
03:51 Which is, well, people would like it.
03:55 But no, we don't want negative taxing.
03:57 But just before we get to our guests, a quick market check.
04:00 So the Sensex and the Nifty are flattish on the index, not too much of a movement really
04:05 because of the budget, if you will.
04:07 On the index heavyweights I'm talking about.
04:09 So auto is still higher and doing okay.
04:12 And that continues.
04:13 So the Maruti's M&M's of the world, no big moves there or no big developments there.
04:18 But I'm just saying that the moves on the index are largely muted because the Sensex
04:23 and the Nifty in fact now 0.22%.
04:26 So kind of reeling a bit under pressure.
04:29 Now if we have our guests ready, we should go to our guests and try and get initial views
04:33 from all of them.
04:34 So let me start with, to my extreme left, Manish.
04:38 Quick initial thoughts, what did you make of the numbers?
04:41 So it's a, as we said, ahead of the budget, it's going to be a bond budget.
04:45 So it's a disinflation budget.
04:48 Basically the expenditure is going up only at 6%, lower than even what I thought, 7%
04:53 primary expenditure is even lower, which is X subsidy, X interest is likely at 4, 5%.
04:59 One of the lowest in last 20 years.
05:02 Capital deficit is actually versus market expectation of 5.3, 5.4, it's 5.1.
05:08 So it's sort of paving way for a pivot for monetary policy.
05:12 That look, we've done enough, Capex, there's been a substantial jump.
05:16 So let's sort of get into a little bit of a conservative mode now so that we pave way
05:21 for monetary policy to ease.
05:23 MIs can come off, liquidity can improve.
05:27 So in a sense, the onus of actually re-stimulating growth at margin, if at all they were to be
05:34 slowed down, is going to be with monetary policy, not fiscal.
05:37 So if purely from the point of view of, let's say, if you're looking for a growth budget,
05:41 it's not a growth budget.
05:42 It's a disinflation budget, and which essentially is going to be for long term, medium term,
05:46 very good, because government has done a lot of things.
05:48 There is going to be disappointment in terms of like market expectation on Capex was about
05:53 14, 15%.
05:54 I was actually thinking of only 11, 12%, so not disappointed, because I mean, even this
06:00 year, there's a 50, 75,000 crore worth of shortfall in terms of total Capex spend so
06:05 far that they've done.
06:07 So it's 11% is a decent number, 3.4% as a percentage of GDP is not going to rise.
06:12 A lot of people were thinking that it will rise to 4% of GDP in terms of Capex.
06:16 I think we've sort of hit a ceiling there.
06:18 And this is all the capacity of the government is right now.
06:21 So I think incrementally, the pivot will be back to a 2016-18 regime, where you'll have
06:27 a four and a half percent fiscal deficit in one or two years time.
06:31 And then, you know, mostly the local household and the private sector actually sort of re-stimulating
06:38 or helping the economy grow, instead of, you know, government pushing it through Capex.
06:42 Do you think the onus now will be on the RBI?
06:44 Yes, yes.
06:45 When they meet for the next policy meeting?
06:46 Absolutely.
06:47 So I think that will be more directional in nature then.
06:48 That's the beauty of this, you know, the SKD and Modi tango, so to say, I kind of call
06:54 it, because, you know, unlike the previous regimes, you know, these guys tango very well.
06:59 So far it was FISC, and then now sort of the FISC is withdrawing so that monetary policy
07:04 can actually be accelerated.
07:05 Oh, that's required.
07:06 Okay.
07:07 Rajiv Anand is also joining us now on our first quick takes of the budget.
07:11 Rajiv Anand, Deputy MD, Axis Bank, with us.
07:14 Very good afternoon to you, Rajiv.
07:17 The conversation in here saying that it is not a growth budget, but positive on all the
07:22 key factors.
07:23 Your fiscal deficit targets matched for this year better than expected.
07:29 Capex at 11 percent, maybe lower than what the street wanted, but you're showing a continuum
07:33 of growth.
07:34 What's your first take?
07:36 I think I don't want to get into the semantics on whether this is a growth budget or not,
07:42 but I think clearly shows the intent that the fiscal deficit is going to be managed
07:49 as we get into the next five years as well, which is fantastic.
07:53 And I think you're already seeing the fact that where the market is expecting fiscal
07:58 deficit at about 5.4 percent, you know, 5.1 percent for next year is a pleasant surprise.
08:05 And I think if you look at the fiscal arithmetic as well, I think it's quite credible at this
08:10 point in time.
08:11 We've already seen the 10-year bond deals rally about 10 basis points on the back of
08:15 that.
08:16 I did hear some conversation around allocation to capital expenditure.
08:21 I think capital expenditure increase is higher than the overall increase in expenses, which
08:28 I think is positive again.
08:30 I would have expected a little more on creating more demand at the rural level, not just more
08:38 importantly creating more rural income, but perhaps that is there in the details and maybe
08:45 we can figure this out as we go forward.
08:46 But I think overall a budget that I think one should be quite satisfied with.
08:51 Rajiv, just a quick follow up in terms of the borrowing figure and the point that the
08:57 finance minister also made that there is going to be a curtailment in government borrowing
09:02 better than what the broad expectations are to be able to give enough room for the private
09:09 sector.
09:10 Do you think that is now expected to play out?
09:12 Are you happy with that number?
09:15 I think, like I said to you, the fiscal arithmetic is credible.
09:20 And so therefore by definition the expectation in terms of the gross borrowing programme
09:25 approximately in the vicinity of about 14 lakh crores, I think is something that the
09:30 markets are quite comfortable to work with as we get into 2024-2025.
09:37 We are certainly seeing private capex has kicked in over the last 8 to 12 quarters.
09:47 One of the things that is certainly happening is the fact that because of the fact that
09:50 corporate cash flows have been quite strong, much of this private capex has been funded
09:57 by internal accruals, not so good as the head of a corporate bank, but I think it just is
10:04 symptomatic of what a solid state corporate balance sheets are at this point in time.
10:10 And perhaps looking at this budget and once we get the uncertainty of the elections out
10:17 of the way, I think it is fair to expect that corporate India will push the pedal on private
10:23 capex as we go forward.
10:26 Rajiv, just a quick follow-up on what you said.
10:29 So net borrowing numbers come in lower than expected.
10:33 You've got that 25 billion that's going to come our way on back of India's inclusion
10:37 in the JPM.
10:38 In terms of, and of course you've got the onus now shifted to the RBI through a monetary
10:43 policy measure in the next meeting.
10:46 In terms of outlook or trajectory on the tenure, what are you working with?
10:50 We've already seen a nine basis point movement, like you said, was an instant knee-jerk reaction
10:54 for now.
10:55 I think though, if you look at the curve, the curve is very flat at the moment.
11:01 I mean, overnight funding rate is at 675, the tenure is close to 712, 713 at this point
11:07 in time.
11:08 I think the focus for all bankers is really to see when the funding rates at the short
11:14 end will begin to ease, which will bring down the short end of the curve from overnight
11:22 to let's say up to five years down at this point in time.
11:27 Liquidity in the system is quite tight.
11:31 And as a result of that, you've already seen the fact that funding rates or cost of funds
11:36 for banks has certainly gone up.
11:39 That has certainly put some pressure on NIMS for banks.
11:43 And I think as banks, not so much about the tenure, but I think the focus is to see when
11:50 liquidity in the system will come back.
11:52 I do hope that perhaps once the first rate cut in the US happens, and two is when the
12:00 flows of money, thanks to the JP Morgan index inclusion happens sometime in June, we will
12:09 see some easing of liquidity.
12:11 So really the focus of attention is around liquidity.
12:14 I think there isn't that much space for the tenure to move at this point in time.
12:19 Rajiv, by the way, I just want to mark that the EY think tank is with us in our studios
12:26 and giving us all the intelligence and will be up on your screen as well.
12:29 In a moment from now, we'll speak to Pranav Setha as well and get his view too.
12:33 But Rajiv, just one quick question before Shankar jumps in, comes in with a question
12:36 too.
12:37 I heard you mention that the state CAPEX has been strong.
12:40 For some people, that's been the story of FY24, if you will, a 40% uptick there.
12:45 Did that play a part in ensuring that the CAPEX momentum stays high?
12:49 Because not that the central government has anyways lived up to the whole amount of the
12:54 CAPEX that was the budget estimate per se.
12:57 So is this not too disappointing or are you disappointed with this 11.1% number?
13:02 I think what I mentioned was the fact that private CAPEX has been quite strong, although
13:10 much of that private CAPEX is getting funded by internal accruals.
13:14 But I think to the point that you're making about state and state CAPEX, I think that's
13:20 really where the game is as far as India is concerned.
13:22 We are seeing healthy competition among states.
13:26 We are seeing execution, although execution is different in terms of quantity and quality
13:33 across all states.
13:35 And given the fact that such a large percentage of central revenues is getting, there is devolution
13:41 to the state governments, ultimately the onus of CAPEX execution will rest with the state
13:47 governments.
13:48 Hi Rajiv, this is Shankar here.
13:50 I had a question.
13:51 I mean, over the past few weeks, particularly after the bank results, there's been a lot
13:56 of conversation about the credit deposit ratio.
14:00 The mystery sort of is why deposits are growing slower than credit.
14:08 And even though the GDP is going faster, do you think that if this budget sort of dips
14:14 in, brings in a disinflationary, brings down the cost of capital, that part of the challenge
14:20 that the financial sector faces will come down?
14:24 I mean, the question is in two parts.
14:26 What explains the lag in deposit growth and would this budget address that?
14:33 I certainly do hope so.
14:37 Like I mentioned to you, the focus of attention of most banks at this point in time, or most
14:42 bankers at this point in time is around liquidity.
14:45 And I think what we've seen is there are multiple issues that we're currently grappling with.
14:53 There is a large cash balance that is sitting with the government that is creating some
14:58 tightness in liquidity.
15:00 Currency in circulation is beginning to inch up as it typically does as we get closer to
15:05 elections.
15:06 And we've seen outflows of FX and to that extent has created some element of pressure
15:14 on the liquidity.
15:16 Ultimately, I think we will have to see some monetary action, whether it is many more VRRRs,
15:26 OMO activity, or even a CRR cut at some point in time for this liquidity to ease as we go
15:34 forward.
15:35 Perhaps some of this liquidity has been tightened because of future cash flows that we are expecting,
15:43 the JP Morgan bond index inclusion flows.
15:47 For example, it is not very clear whether or the RBI has not clearly articulated what
15:54 exactly its thinking is at this point in time around this.
15:58 Okay, that sort of sets up the floor for the financial sector stocks.
16:03 Yes, indeed.
16:05 Rajiv, take a moment to thank you for joining in today and giving us your perspective.
16:09 Really appreciate your time and your thoughts this morning.
16:12 Thank you for having me.
16:15 The pleasure is entirely ours.
16:16 Again, sticking to my left, Ravi, come to you.
16:19 Thanks for joining in.
16:20 A disinflationary budget, rightly pointed out by Manish.
16:22 Rajiv seconds that as well.
16:24 Is that disinflationary for real assets, real estate, equity markets, or do you think this
16:29 CapEx outlay number, not a negative but a dip if you will, but the deficit numbers looking
16:36 positive, the markets will take it in this stride?
16:38 No, I think clearly there is a small bit of disappointment on the CapEx number.
16:43 But coming on the base of a very high number last year, even though they did not achieve
16:48 their budgeted estimate, but it is still a credible number of 30-31%.
16:52 On top of that, another 11% growth is not a bad number.
16:55 So from an equity markets perspective, we were always looking at it from the credibility
17:00 and continuity aspect.
17:02 And I think on both the things the budget has delivered, there is credibility in the
17:07 numbers, whether it is on the revenue estimate side or whether it is on the tax buoyancy
17:12 numbers.
17:13 So we are absolutely okay.
17:15 And there is some positive surprise on the fiscal deficit front.
17:18 So broadly, I think as Manish mentioned earlier, it is more a bond market budget than an equity
17:25 markets budget.
17:27 From our perspective, I think most of the focus is a continuation of which are the sectors
17:33 that the government is going to focus on.
17:35 And it is not so much of a niddle mover, honestly.
17:37 I think the mantle moves now to RBI, the elections up ahead and even in US elections and how
17:45 those events are going to pan out is what is going to determine the way the equity markets
17:49 are going to move.
17:50 Ravi, just a point then, I just want to point out what PSU Bank stocks are doing today and
17:55 you are seeing that uptick quite positively on PSU Bank stocks.
17:59 So the overall market is just, I think, absorbing everything that is happening right now.
18:05 In terms of impact of CapEx, Ravi, I wanted to get a sense from you on what happens to
18:10 all of those pockets of stocks, companies, which have been fuelled by large government
18:16 spends.
18:17 We do not yet know the exact figure for the railway outlay.
18:22 Do you see an impact there on infra, etc.?
18:26 Do you see some cool off there in expectations of how much work is going to flow to these
18:30 individual companies?
18:31 No, so first of all, even though central budget was doing bulk of the heavy lifting, going
18:38 forward that mix has to change.
18:40 Central government cannot be doing that much heavy lifting going on.
18:43 The limits have been reached in terms of how much fiscal space they have.
18:46 It will be the state government and the private CapEx that will have to do bulk of the heavy
18:52 lifting in CapEx going forward.
18:54 From that perspective, railway and defence are two sectors which are dependent on the
18:59 central government CapEx.
19:00 We will have to take a look at what the break-up of that 11% is before I can say that if there
19:05 is going to be any kind of a negative impact.
19:07 In fact, those stocks, rail stocks, some of them have already started seeing a little
19:10 bit of a decline.
19:12 Suppose the budget, all the IRFC, Railtel, RVNL are all trading with some weakness.
19:17 So the reaction, clearly, at least for Navneet Chowk, it may be, is negative.
19:21 Pranav, you want to come in.
19:23 Are you impressed by what numbers are put out?
19:26 I think people are expecting an overshoot in the fiscal deficit for this year.
19:29 We have done really well and going out as well in the next year, those numbers look
19:32 promising.
19:33 Absolutely.
19:34 So the way I look at it is this is a prudent and confident budget.
19:37 I think the Finance Minister seems to have a lot of confidence that growth will sustain
19:42 even if the CapEx is not at the same level as was probably expected by the markets.
19:47 I think here she is also betting a little bit on the fact that if the borrowing of the
19:52 central government is to be lower, automatically there will be more available for the private
19:57 sector and the capital expenditure push at the private sector, which has so far been
20:02 a little elusive, will kick in in a much stronger way.
20:06 So I would feel that she is really betted on a far more confident approach that if I
20:13 control the fiscal deficit, this government has been very prudent on the macros and this
20:19 step again while the whole world seems to be still with a lot of fiscal deficits, already
20:25 seems to be very conservative from a fiscal deficit point of view.
20:29 So I think she is betting on that the fact that the macros will be good, will bring in
20:34 foreign investment, will also push the Indian private sector to invest much more, funds
20:40 will be available for private sector CapEx.
20:42 So I think it is a big bet that she is making on growth sustaining despite this particular
20:47 fact.
20:48 In fact that has been a priority for the Prime Minister, putting India on the global map
20:50 and we have seen that over the last decade.
20:53 Things have changed and they have moved and I think just credibility is what we are currently
20:57 building and the focus is clear.
20:59 Absolutely and that also brings in foreign investment in a much bigger way.
21:03 FDI is a big, big push.
21:04 So I mean if the world feels that India is already very stable, one positive sign and
21:10 if its fiscal and macro policies are going to be continuously prudent, it probably might
21:16 just give a big push to private sector CapEx including foreign investment.
21:20 So the question to the jury at large, does private CapEx kick in in a big way at a point
21:26 of time when the world is not quite certain and in a year which has got massive elections
21:31 lined up.
21:32 Shankar you may want to start this but the question to everybody.
21:35 I think it will depend largely on global cues.
21:38 You see one of the issues has been addressed which is the cost of capital that was inhibiting
21:43 private CapEx growth.
21:46 So by doing this, by reducing the government's footprint in the borrowings market, it has
21:53 created little room for the private sector.
21:56 But that little room also has to be supplanted by rise in deposit which is why Rajiv Anand
22:03 spoke about the CRR issue.
22:05 So the CD ratio, whatever, people have cooked an avial out of it but nobody knows what is
22:11 the actual number that should be there.
22:14 But if the liquidity improves, if the demand improves, but private CapEx is also haunted
22:23 by the sectoral definition of the budget allocations.
22:27 You see the expectation for everyone was there would be something done for rural demand.
22:36 Now that is an area that is sort of still wherever it is.
22:40 CapEx was expected to be higher but is at 11.
22:44 I think it's a very credible figure because there is only so much that governments can
22:47 execute.
22:49 You know the absorptive capacity of the economy has limitations.
22:52 So over a period of time we will see that.
22:56 The money coming in from JP Morgan and other indexes is coming into the debt market which
23:01 will be only sovereign debt so it will sort of create room for private borrowers.
23:07 But they will borrow only when they see a certainty, when they see growth ahead, when
23:11 they see consumption moving up.
23:13 And that's a big if in a year where the global environment is sort of uncertain, mercifully
23:21 the IMF has upped the global output, maybe these wars would sort of clear, the fog of
23:27 war would clear out.
23:29 I still think that there is a latent desire to invest in the private sector which might
23:38 be unleashed if the correct kind of persuasion comes out.
23:43 And the tax policies will play a big role, PLI will play a big role in this.
23:47 We didn't see too much mention on that, maybe we save for the budget.
23:50 Just one second, before we beat the government too much on the growth, just one thing, the
23:54 FY24 capex number has actually been revised downwards from 10 lakh to 9.5 lakh crores.
24:00 So on base of that 11.1 is actually a 17% growth.
24:04 So it's not like…
24:05 You know even the effective capex is a very good number.
24:10 Not beating it because as Manish said in his opening answer, that one if you set the limits
24:14 and we see they have not done this much as well and the state government capex is anyways
24:18 40% growth, so there is a bit of a thing there.
24:21 But the question only is that private capex and household capex not quite there and which
24:25 is my question that if they have not done anything in the budget, what Mr. Sethar said
24:29 that is the FM sounding confident of growth coming back but can private capex come back
24:36 in a year when global growth is looking slightly faulty.
24:39 No, I think they have from the central government's point of view, they have laid the ground in
24:44 terms of like you mentioned about bringing the cost of capital down, building the confidence
24:49 in the business, providing policies which are supportive of particular sector and global
24:56 confidence also in India's economy growing is also on a high.
25:00 So I mean I don't see any missing piece in terms of the jigsaw in terms of private capex
25:04 picking up.
25:05 How much pace and all we can keep debating but directionally for sure private capex has
25:11 to pick up.
25:12 So quick one, there was nothing said on divestment again this time, so that also was a missing
25:15 piece, nothing really expected after the disappointment.
25:16 I think that number lower, lesser said the better.
25:17 Sir, so to be fair.
25:18 I am sorry but just Manish wanted to make a point on capex before we move on.
25:25 Sorry Manish.
25:26 Did I, okay.
25:27 Yeah, because I thought you were wanting to answer.
25:28 No, no, no, I was just keenly listening to him.
25:30 No, no, capex actually, I mean if you have a 100 buck of capex in a country, only 25
25:35 is done by government and 40 is done by household, okay.
25:40 So private capex is not reliance industries and companies of capex, it's about 40% is
25:46 household and that sort of has been pretty weak for very long, for good 8, 10 years and
25:52 because half the households are borrowing money in some form or other, okay, I think
25:57 a monetary policy is a better way to reach them, okay.
26:01 So I mean in the budget speech in the beginning she talked about three major reforms, one
26:07 of them was middle class housing and I think you know in July as and when she sort of unleashes
26:12 the next set of things for the 25 year of a developed country, I mean she would and
26:18 she should and I think you know every dharavi, every slum guy should be able to move to a
26:23 house of a with hours and the size of the world and a decent 2BHK is what the government
26:27 should do, which is to lower interest rates, create subsidies, everything that Hong Kong
26:32 and many other you know East Asian countries have done, if we do that we will have a decent
26:37 capex.
26:38 If you are looking for a capex like 2000s where the you know huge unleashing of telecom
26:43 and power infra happened and you know 20, 25% CAGR happened, that's not going to happen.
26:49 India's sort of basic foundation of a hardcore capital intensive infrastructure is done and
26:55 which is why the private corporations capex is not going to sort of grow very rapidly.
27:02 Anyway we are hitting at 30% GFCF level, maybe 1, 2% meaning that's the total investment
27:09 as a percentage of GDP, it doesn't have much space.
27:12 I think the only way we can accelerate the capex overall if we can get households to
27:16 buy, sorry build more houses, buy more durables like fridge, TV, this, that, everything, two
27:22 wheelers and we want that and for that I think a little bit of a easy monetary policy, a
27:26 little bit of assistance on through great subsidies for buying two wheelers, buying
27:31 houses, if that happens likely we will have a capex.
27:34 So to be fair the finance minister has said, had said that this is an interim budget.
27:39 She has, she has delivered and she has said more to come in July.
27:43 That's why we are seeing a lot of expectations which didn't make it to the speech and affordable
27:50 housing push may be one of them which is why I just quickly want to also show what real
27:53 estate is doing and real estate is getting a bit beaten down this afternoon perhaps on
27:58 those expectations that there would be something coming in.
28:01 In terms of what could be done and do we have the space to wait for July on pushing out
28:08 consumption.
28:09 Let me actually take this question to Mr. Saita.
28:12 If you want to put more money in the hands of people, you're not doing it through taxes
28:16 right now.
28:17 You've said as is the tradition I'm not touching taxes, fair enough.
28:21 Could anything more have been done or we have the room to wait till July for this?
28:27 Yeah, I mean from a tax standpoint I'm not surprised that she says that we'll do something
28:31 in July not right now which is fair.
28:34 Also they want to keep the tax rates a little stable.
28:37 So that's, that's, they've not touched it right now.
28:39 But I do anticipate some stops maybe in July to ensure there's more money in the hands
28:44 of pockets of taxpayers.
28:47 One thing that surprised me a little was she did extend I think from the speech, we have
28:52 to see the fine print, the sunset dates for start-ups and for IFSC which were expiring
28:59 on 31st March 24.
29:01 There was also the expiry of the concessional tax on manufacturing companies which was ending
29:07 on March 24.
29:09 There was a lot of representation that that concessional rate of 15% plus surcharge and
29:14 says should be extended for manufacturing units starting commencing production maybe
29:19 till 31st March 25, 26, whatever.
29:23 That she hasn't mentioned.
29:24 So does that mean she wants that to consciously expire and new manufacturing units are not
29:31 going to get that is one surprising thing because she did extend it for two of those
29:34 who were expiring or the sunset was on 31st March 24.
29:38 But otherwise she's been pretty silent on taxes saying I'll pick it up in July.
29:43 I think the message is clear which this government has been giving.
29:47 They want to build a kind of relationship of trust with taxpayers and say that okay
29:53 let's build that relationship of trust and therefore taxpayer friendly measures in some
29:59 sense from a compliance etc standpoint is I think what she's hinting at.
30:04 But the real measures on tax will come in the July budget or the main budget June July
30:08 whenever it comes.
30:09 Let me take the question to Shankar.
30:11 Is this a populist pre-election budget at all or they're waiting for all of those announcements
30:16 before the election dates are announced and when the actual heat and dust hits.
30:23 So the answer is in two parts.
30:25 Every year somewhere before the budget some major scheme gets extended.
30:31 So the free food free ration scheme got extended last year for next five years.
30:40 Okay.
30:41 There is also the fact that the prime minister has publicly sought responses from various
30:48 people on what they want in their wish list of the Vixit Bharat that will form the template
30:56 for the manifesto.
30:57 So he has kept they have kept some room for the promises now.
31:01 You can't be giving away everything then what what are the people going to vote for.
31:05 So there is a combination of this play here.
31:09 I think it can't be called populist primarily because it is conservative in its approach.
31:16 It has brought down the targeted fiscal deficit number is very impressive.
31:22 The level of borrowings going down is very impressive and even then the capex going up
31:29 is stabilizing.
31:31 I think what's happening here is that the government is betting on the private individual
31:36 and the private consumption.
31:39 Private final consumption is virtually half of GDP growth and that's like a puzzle.
31:44 I mean why isn't it growing which part of the quintile isn't kicking in.
31:49 So I think the cost of capital being brought down may kick some animal spirits in the system
31:56 and that's what they're.
31:57 I also think that much of this will reflect in their presentation one more time they're
32:02 making a presentation to the rating agencies for improving India's rating.
32:07 This has been a constant endeavor of this government that India deserves a better rating
32:12 and so they will pitch this 5.1 lower borrowing inclusion in JP Morgan and Bloomberg.
32:19 Probably one more fund and see this is very attractive to the foreign investors.
32:26 This picture it may not be very attractive today to the real estate stocks or stuff like
32:32 that but on a performance term this is very attractive good for the financial sector because
32:38 there is a potential for bringing down the cost of capital for them.
32:43 Ravi what happens now?
32:45 It is behind us in that sense we've got what we are looking for a little bit of it.
32:51 If you're an investor in this market how do you view this?
32:55 What happens next?
32:56 Does the focus move back to global queues?
32:58 Does it move back to the elections or do we again wait in anticipation for July?
33:04 No I think.
33:05 What will you tell your clients at this stage?
33:06 I think as mentioned on the panel earlier the mantle now moves to RBI.
33:10 The space has been created.
33:12 Government has done its bit in terms of providing space for RBI to start implementing its monetary
33:18 policy.
33:19 So currently the most important thing that we are dealing with is the liquidity deficit
33:26 that we are facing right now and what steps RBI takes to correct that is what is the most
33:33 important thing from equity markets perspective.
33:35 So all that is macro.
33:37 Just last year when the budget happened you saw sectors like defense and railway break
33:42 out.
33:43 Talk to me more micro right now.
33:45 So if I had to pick a sector what would it be?
33:47 Do I have a sector?
33:48 Can I call a trend into this year or best avoid it for now?
33:51 It's the continuation of the trends.
33:53 So you would still buy railway?
33:54 You would still buy defense?
33:55 We are still focused on domestic cyclicals, domestic apex oriented stories.
34:02 There are some noises being made about affordable housing.
34:05 So there is some hope that okay that will also pick up pace.
34:09 But otherwise the weak link continue to be the rural consumption and the exports.
34:14 Those two areas I don't think enough has been done for me to say that the trend is going
34:18 to change over there as of now.
34:21 And hence the current ongoing themes will continue.
34:25 But from the perspective of the valuations these are the exact areas where market has
34:29 recognized and quite a bit of rally has already happened.
34:32 So little bit of transition might be underway over the next six, nine months where these
34:38 already recognized sectors might actually peak out and the ones that are providing the
34:42 opportunity don't yet have the triggers in place yet.
34:46 But those are the areas where valuations are getting attractive now.
34:49 All right.
34:50 We will quickly go across to Janani standing by.
34:53 She has been tracking the entire budget.
34:56 She is in North Block.
34:58 What are the big takeaways Janani?
35:00 That's right Tamanna.
35:05 I think we've all heard the big announcements, the numbers that we've been waiting for.
35:09 But I want to pull focus to some of the key details here.
35:13 If you look at of course the fiscal deficit it's now at 5.1.
35:17 This is a 70 basis point drop from 5.8 which is the revised fiscal deficit estimate for
35:23 FY24.
35:24 Now what I'm more interested is in lakh crore rupees.
35:27 This is 16.86 lakh crore.
35:29 This year it was 17.86.
35:30 So this again we can see in actual terms also there is a big difference.
35:34 Market borrowing lesser than what it was before coming in at 11.75 lakh crore.
35:39 Again a very interesting aspect here.
35:41 When we talk about receipts as a whole an interesting trend that we notice is that the
35:46 estimation for corporate taxes is actually lower in fact than the income taxes this time.
35:51 Income taxes is at 11.56 lakh crore whereas corporate taxes is at 10.42.
35:56 This is a little bit of a deviation considering that corporate tax expectation is always much
36:00 higher.
36:01 Talking of expenditures, the subsidies, ones that we've always been interested in from
36:05 the beginning when we started tracking this, fertilizer subsidies actually gone down.
36:10 It's now stands at 1.64 lakh crore.
36:15 Food risen a little bit more considering the extension of the food subsidy scheme.
36:20 This is at 2 lakh crore rupees.
36:22 Petroleum subsidy significantly increased at 11,000 crores, 12,000 crores almost.
36:30 And other important schemes like the Mandrega scheme has seen an increase in outlay but
36:34 this is very much similar to what was in revised estimates.
36:37 Mandrega scheme's outlay is now 86,000 crores whereas PMAY, the PM Awas Yojana, one that
36:43 the finance minister also announced that will be extended to build 2 crore more houses in
36:49 the next 5 years.
36:50 That has got an outlay bump from 54,000 that we saw last year to 80,000 crores in the FY25
36:57 budget.
36:58 Three things that stood out for me, I will end with that.
37:01 Of course, one, the finance minister's focus on deep tech and perhaps investments through
37:07 that and the second of course is the 1 lakh crore funding towards sunrise sector research
37:13 for private companies.
37:14 We'll have to see which shape and form this will take.
37:17 And of course, the PMGKY enhanced target.
37:20 No tax cuts, no tax changes, might have been a letdown but of course she also spoke about
37:26 how there will be a withdrawal of outstanding tax demands.
37:28 Now in the back of my mind, this will be a cheer for the industry considering that up
37:33 to 25,000 pertaining to FY25 and 10,000 pertaining to FY11 and FY15, these will be withdrawn.
37:42 This will be a cheer for industry, something that has been litigated for quite some time.
37:45 Petty amounts but still an interesting one.
37:47 Back to you.
37:48 Absolutely, Janani, thank you for that.
37:52 Janani there getting us all the highlights of this budget and let's see how markets are
37:55 responding to it.
37:57 No big moves in either direction at least on the Nifty and the Sensex.
38:03 You're seeing real stocks maybe taking a bit of a beating today and to be fair, expectations
38:08 had run up.
38:09 There were all kinds of fantastical figures being put out there on what the real budget
38:16 will look like or the allocation for real will look like.
38:19 Maybe a bit of a cool off that we're seeing there on real estate as well.
38:24 IRB Infra is another one that we can quickly just check and see what's happening there.
38:29 Some of these key names maybe seeing some cool off this morning.
38:34 But Ravi, let me come to you in terms of big themes that you see playing out.
38:39 As far as the market is concerned, will the big relief come from that?
38:42 There is no negative news.
38:44 It's business as usual.
38:45 No, there is a positive news.
38:46 Fiscal deficit number is actually positive.
38:48 I think the markets are becoming mature.
38:51 Why do you think there's no real response or reaction right now?
38:54 Because that was definitely not priced in.
38:57 That's true.
38:58 However, as mentioned earlier, this is a vote on account and interim budget and it is not
39:03 budget as an event for equity markets anyway has been reducing its importance.
39:09 And this one is even lesser, if I were to say, because of it being a vote on account.
39:15 So for all practical purpose, central government and budgeting exercise can only provide this
39:20 much needle moving impetus to the overall scheme of things.
39:25 So the market moving events lie outside of the budget for me.
39:31 Most of the policy announcements do come outside of the budget.
39:34 What RBI does is important, what Fed does is important and how the elections pan out
39:39 in US and India is what is more important from the market's point of view.
39:43 In terms of what the Fed did last night and of course, all of that paled in comparison
39:48 to the very hectic news morning that we had and our budget, etc.
39:52 When everything is digested and goes down, do you think that that's going to be something
39:56 which is not half bad?
39:58 A March cut now out of the way, ruled out.
40:01 Yeah, the market was running ahead of expectations.
40:03 It's not that Fed has done anything that they shouldn't have done.
40:06 It's just that market was running ahead of expectations and I think some reality check
40:10 over there.
40:11 But the fact that we did not have a hard landing last year and now there are expectations of
40:17 a soft landing this year, that itself tells you that the strength in the US economy has
40:23 till now surprised everybody positively.
40:27 Are you taking a cash call on your portfolio right now or are you completely invested?
40:31 No, I mean, so cash call is also divided into what the existing portfolios are and what
40:37 the new money is coming in.
40:39 First of all, a lot of people are taking a call not to accept new money.
40:42 That's not the case with us.
40:43 We are accepting new money.
40:44 And you're allocating?
40:45 But we are not very aggressive in deploying on that front yet.
40:48 So we are sitting on about 25-30% cash on new portfolios, but the old portfolios are
40:52 about 5-10% cash.
40:54 [Music]
41:02 (dramatic music)

Recommended