Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 years ago

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and welcome. You're watching an NDTV Profits special and I'm in conversation with
00:13Dr. Anant Nageshwaran, Chief Economic Advisor to the government and the man of the moment.
00:18Dr. Nageshwaran, thank you so very much for taking time out for us on this very busy day.
00:23So you know, to begin with, I do want to ask you that while you have outlined reasons for
00:28your cautious approach on the GDP forecast for this year, do you expect stronger consumption
00:35as well as private investment and the contribution of government spending to then come down?
00:42No, no, I think you are spelling out the specific elements of GDP growth. I think it's difficult
00:48to say where the impact will be. But what we point out is if the monsoon turns out to
00:55be patchy and uneven, it will have some implications for rural consumption and rural
00:59income growth. And separately, geopolitical disturbances and the manufacturing challenge
01:04being posed by China and given the excess capacity that is out there, creating the potential for
01:11imports increasing in a big way may, I'm not saying will, but may induce some caution
01:20on the part of the private corporate sector with respect to investing.
01:24So it may affect the growth rate, not necessarily the absolute amounts being invested,
01:29it may affect the growth rates of corporate sector capital formation as well.
01:34Okay, all right. So also your comments on equity markets suggest that the Indian market is
01:41overheating. You have spoken about, you know, a cautious approach for retail investors that's
01:46needed and the expectation of greater returns, not aligning with real market conditions. So one,
01:52I do want to ask you if the implication is that markets are currently overheated. And also on
01:58derivatives, the problem now seems to be well identified. Why is policy action then lagging?
02:06Have you already let it run too far? And what is the policy prescription in that case?
02:12I don't think, no, first of all, about the market valuations, etc., I don't comment on it and I
02:17haven't commented specifically on financial market valuation in India. I simply said that
02:22financial market valuations in the developed world have become elevated and there seems to
02:27be some sort of caution that is creeping into the marketplace and normally when the developed
02:33country markets correct, they do have a spillover effect in developing countries and Indian market
02:38has run up a lot in the last several years and that is therefore quite an appropriate condition
02:44for profit-taking to happen, etc. So it is not about valuations in India per se or the growth
02:50opportunities, but what is happening elsewhere can have a spillover effect here as well. That is one.
02:56And second, whether the situation with respect to Indian retail participation in F&O has already
03:02gotten out of hand, I don't think so. It is not a systemic concern, but we actually don't want it
03:07to become a systemic concern. If you look at what the central bank did in December with respect to
03:13raising the risk weights on unsecured personal loan, that was a pre-emptive action. It is not
03:18that things have become out of control at the time, it did not want things to become out of
03:23control. That's exactly the kind of stronger for longer kind of action that needs to be taken
03:30and also it is in the interest of both the retail investor and capital markets and the private
03:35sector with respect to capital formation that we ensure that the financial savings are channelized
03:40into productive investments, both from the point of view of the investor and the corporate sector.
03:48Okay, alright. So the report today has a lot of interesting commentary on the China plus one
03:56policy. Now, you have sort of articulated about the benefit of FDI from China and why that can
04:04be encouraged. But can you tell us a little bit more about that and also adding to that, does it
04:11sort of run contrary to what other parts of the government might be feeling about China related
04:18investments? No, we are not contradicting anyone here. We are simply pointing out the possibility
04:25that if we continue to rely on imports from them, it's not that we are not having a relationship
04:32with them. We are importing a lot of goods from China and that's why our trade deficit with them
04:37bilaterally are running close to about 90 billion dollars. So there is a relationship, there is a
04:42commercial relationship. We are simply asking the question whether there could be a better balance
04:47because continued reliance on imports can also have implications for domestic manufacturing growth
04:53to happen, investments in the manufacturing sector to happen. Because of excess capacity,
05:00because of China's continued presence in low value added goods, etc. If we continue to import
05:06them then we will… and importing from them is actually cost comparative, cost attractive,
05:12and therefore that will continue, which will naturally delay the creation of manufacturing
05:18capability domestically in those areas or even in medium and high-tech areas.
05:22So that's a charge we need to make. What kind of engagement we need to have? We have an engagement
05:27and that is trade-based. We are asking the question whether that is conducive for other
05:32goals that India has, even not only with respect to investment and manufacturing but also with
05:39respect to managing climate change and energy transition. So we are only raising these questions
05:44and asking that maybe there is a need to look at a better balance between importing goods
05:50and importing capital. Okay, all right. Now I'll try and squeeze in one quick last question before
05:56I can let you go. But I do want to ask you about jobs. You've spoken about the improvement we've
06:03seen in economic indicators. We've seen a decline in unemployment rate alongside a rise in labour
06:10force participation. But I do want your help in understanding how do you read this against
06:17the rise we've seen in self-employment. Within that as well we've seen a rise in own account
06:22workers, helpers in household enterprises and that along with the share of salaried employees
06:29having fallen a tad bit from about 23.8 percent in 2018-19 to about 20.9 percent. Not a very
06:36steep decline but I do want some help understanding that. Sure, I think it's a fair point. I think
06:41we can have both of them happening in parallel. You can have increase in own account workers,
06:47by the way, but even though there's an increase in own account workers, increase in own account
06:52workers on account of domestic work has come down. Some of them have actually become their
06:56own employers. And secondly, I think we should remember that between 2013 and 2019 we had the
07:04balance sheet issue in the corporate sector and the banking sector immediately followed by the
07:09pandemic which saw reverse migration happen and plus women coming into labour force in rural India,
07:14etc. So, the two big shocks have created distortions and we should not let those two
07:22big shocks influence or cloud our judgment about the structural capability of the Indian labour
07:29market. Now that these two shocks are behind us and are fading away, I think the economy will see
07:35a resumption of job creation in the right areas of the right quality.
07:42Okay, all right. Thank you so much, sir, for taking time to speak to us today. We're very grateful.
07:49Thank you for watching NDTV Profits. Do continue watching for our continuing
07:53updates on the upcoming budget.

Recommended