- hace 1 año
Categoría
🛠️
Estilo de vidaTranscripción
00:00:00So, let's continue with this topic that we've set out to discuss during
00:00:29This cycle of Mary as a woman of mystery and controversy. Certainly, both things are present.
00:00:37united, that is, being a mystery, because this often leads us into certain controversial things
00:00:44Because we cannot understand them, or cannot understand them clearly as we should, well
00:00:51Then, as we will see today, different opinions begin to emerge.
00:00:57different visions that then broaden and can, as we will see today, can
00:01:04to come to encompass a very important part of the church and divide it, as was the case
00:01:11where a process called Arianism concludes, already in the 4th century, practically at the end of the
00:01:20Third, fourth century, fifth century, we will be divided by this doctrine of Arius that came to divide
00:01:29Our church. So today we're going to see precisely how all this is coming about and how...
00:01:38The church has had to work for us, more than to combat heresy.
00:01:44We also need to understand it, to better understand the mysteries, right? Because when we think of Jesus
00:01:51Today in the 21st century, we have a whole tradition, that is, for us we say Mary
00:01:58Always virgin, well, that sounds normal to us, right? This is a topic we're familiar with.
00:02:06In other words, we see it as natural when we talk about the assumption, when we talk about divine motherhood,
00:02:11But when we go back two thousand years, when there was no internet, when
00:02:19There are no books when there are no newspapers, when news spreads little by little.
00:02:25through letters, through sermons, from these itinerant preachers who go about proposing
00:02:31For doctrine, when doctrine, as Saint Paul clearly relates, particularly
00:02:39In his letter to the Colossians, in his letter to the Galatians, we see a doctrine that he has not yet achieved
00:02:45to become fully established, because even if Pablo were to spend two years there, he would still be unable to assimilate
00:02:52And to be able to change an entire pagan culture and introduce it into Christian life, well, it wasn't easy,
00:02:59And that is why Saint Paul writes these letters, particularly the one to Galatians and the one to Colossians,
00:03:05in order to clarify the doctrine that he has already presented.
00:03:12If we then expand on this and gradually take it further out of the Jewish context, where
00:03:18There are still many roots, where there is already a faith, let's say a purified faith, which is the
00:03:25faith of Judaism, as we find that it begins to mix with a series of
00:03:30pagan doctrines are combined, and what is known as syncretism develops. We gradually mix them.
00:03:36certain things that we receive from our culture and introduce into the new
00:03:43Faith. And this, then, will result in heresies. So today we're going to look at this topic.
00:03:51which we call Christological heresies and their Marian consequence. The issue essentially
00:03:58It has therefore been a Christological theme, that is, trying to discover and understand more fully
00:04:04Clarity about who Jesus is, what Jesus really is. Because for us, yes, he is God and all,
00:04:10But if you stop to think about it—I don't know if you do it often—you might suddenly realize...
00:04:16It introduces one to the mystery, doesn't it? And one says, let's see, who is Jesus really, right? I mean,
00:04:22when we read texts such as, for example, without leaving the bosom of the father, he becomes a man.
00:04:30You're like, what is this, right? I mean, it's a mystery. But we tried to dig deeper, and since we couldn't...
00:04:39To understand, then we begin to create our stories, right? The mystery must be faced and believed.
00:04:46We shouldn't try to explain it completely because we never could. It remains a mystery.
00:04:54God is more than our poor minds could ever comprehend. So, we have to leave it at that.
00:05:01God is a mystery. And since Mary is directly connected to the mystery, because she is the mother
00:05:08of Jesus Christ, who, as we will see today, is God, and that connection also introduces it into a
00:05:16mystery. And when Mary becomes a mystery, we enter into the same dynamic as with Jesus.
00:05:24We understand. And when we don't understand, let me put it this way, we invent. So, it's not right that
00:05:32Let's invent. So, let's look at this topic a bit, shall we? Then, starting from the first century, let's see
00:05:42How Mary becomes a controversial figure. And as God has revealed his mystery, we can
00:05:48to better understand who he is and what his role is within the mystery of God and the mystery of the church.
00:05:58Yes? Then, he has connected Mary with her mystery and with this mystery that we live, which is the church, which
00:06:06It is also mysterious, because it is the body of Christ. And as a body, well, we say, yes, I understand the
00:06:14part of the body and I kind of understand that he's the head, but what is this, right? So, it's also a mystery, isn't it?
00:06:21So, as Christianity spread throughout the world, as I was saying earlier, it reached the
00:06:29Different cultures developed different ways of thinking that eventually became
00:06:36false doctrines about Christ, which today we call heresies. These are specific thoughts of the
00:06:45doctrines that will create a discrepancy. We will drift apart. And this leads to having to, therefore, make a
00:06:53election. That's where the word heresy comes from, from the word hieresis, which means election. That is, from everything that
00:07:01So, let's listen, and from everything we're learning, we have to do one.
00:07:08choice, a heresis, and a bad choice is made when we separate ourselves from the
00:07:16doctrine proposed by the whole church, to go with the doctrine proposed by, well, a single person, be it
00:07:23a bishop, or a monk, or some other member of the church, who, in doing this exercise of, well,
00:07:32Research or meditation, it reaches false conclusions, they begin to spread, and this, therefore, already gives rise to
00:07:42This is the consequence of what we now call heresy. It is the separation from orthodox doctrine, from the doctrine that...
00:07:49The church has been proposing these false doctrines. However, we must understand that doctrine will...
00:07:58arises from heresy. That is, heresy forces us, or forces the Church, to delve deeper and see if
00:08:06What Marcion, for example, is really saying is either correct or incorrect. And then, he has to
00:08:15enter and make an effort to understand the church itself, who Jesus is, what Jesus is, and from there
00:08:23to propose, in communion with the whole church, what the correct and appropriate doctrine is, and to remove from the way
00:08:32Everything that is not part of our faith. So, the first issues that arise in the process of
00:08:42Understanding Jesus, and obviously Mary, has to do with perpetual virginity. It's one of the themes
00:08:52which, from the first century onwards, will appear as controversial problems, given that the same
00:09:00The writing, as we shall see in a moment, seems to indicate other things. And, at the same time, the other
00:09:08an element that will be developing from the first century, although it's more present from the second century onwards, well, it's going to be
00:09:17The theme of divine motherhood, which has to do with who Jesus really is. So, we're going to go
00:09:26Looking at the series of thoughts that developed from the end of the first century, let's...
00:09:33Learn today about the main energies and how all these thoughts ultimately come together.
00:09:40culminating with Arianism, which will ultimately bring together the majority of these
00:09:47The thoughts of these sects, and, well, it will divide the church because, well, now Arius has the
00:09:54sufficient force to push a doctrine that will spread throughout the world and that
00:10:00It will separate the Catholic Church from the Arian Church. So, as we were saying before we finished...
00:10:08In the first century, the belief, the heresy, arose that Jesus had no body. This was based on the fact that he was not...
00:10:18It is possible that God, who is eternal—if we are to acknowledge that God is eternal—well, how can he die?
00:10:27Therefore, recognizing that Christ is God, then, he cannot have a body. It would be, then, like a
00:10:37Image, that's where the word Docetists comes from, that's where Docetism will be born, right? Because they are going to
00:10:46To say that what truly exists, or what the people who lived with Jesus saw, was not really a
00:10:53body, but as an image, it was a representation. It comes from the Greek word dokesis, which means
00:11:02Appearance. So, it had the appearance of a human being, but in reality, it wasn't a human being. This
00:11:10not yet, then, as directly Docetism, but we still find it, for example, in the Jehovah's Witnesses
00:11:17of Jehovah. Jehovah's Witnesses, in a way, talk about this, because they say that at the moment
00:11:25After death, Christ's body disappears, and then he takes on another body. Then,
00:11:34It doesn't have a body like ours, but a body that disappears, or disintegrates, or something
00:11:41Honestly, one is always left somewhat amazed, or very amazed, by Jehovah's Witnesses.
00:11:47Because their doctrines truly reach a point where they are inexplicable. That is to say,
00:11:52And what happened to the body of Christ? Well, they have a lot of this Docetism thing going on, that is,
00:11:58merely an appearance. And this is why Christian iconography will present Jesus
00:12:07usually naked, so that it can be seen that he is truly a child, like any other
00:12:13The children we know. They won't usually present it, especially the iconography.
00:12:19older. Fortunately, we haven't looked at this in depth either, because we're talking
00:12:25Regarding iconography in a topic, well, it wasn't about this topic. Let's see if we can soon.
00:12:32to talk about this iconographic development, about how Marian iconography came about,
00:12:37along with Christian iconography. But the earliest icons, in the earliest representations
00:12:42Pictographic depictions of Jesus will always show him naked, completely naked, so that he can be seen
00:12:50who truly is a man, and with this we will combat this entire vision of docetism.
00:12:58At the same time, since this Docetic doctrine appears at the end of the first century,
00:13:07pushed very broadly by Gnosticism, which is a sum of thoughts that have to do
00:13:15With this internal state of man's thinking, Saint John continually emphasizes the theme
00:13:27of the crucifixion. In fact, if you look at the Gospel of John,
00:13:35He devotes a considerable amount of space to the subject of the crucifixion, to suffering, to martyrdom,
00:13:45to the crowning with thorns, in short, all these kinds of themes to show that Jesus had a real body,
00:13:53a body that was bleeding, a body like all of ours, because it was very important
00:14:01to combat this heresy of docetism, in order to have a clear vision of the church.
00:14:11St. John, you recall, even includes Thomas, who says, "Unless I put my hand into his side,"
00:14:19And if I don't put my fingers in the nail marks, in the nail holes, I'm not going to believe.
00:14:25These are all elements that the apostle will introduce at the end of the century, right?
00:14:32because this Gospel is being described around the year 90, when Docetism was gaining strength,
00:14:38so that people can be completely clear about what was being played
00:14:44After the resurrection, it was the same body of Christ, which had the nail holes in its hands,
00:14:52and he had the mark of the spear that pierced his side.
00:14:57And that is why he says to him, "Come, Thomas, give me your hand, put it into my side."
00:15:03Put your fingers in my hands now, and stop doubting.
00:15:07When we study, not only the subject of the Gospel,
00:15:12but what is the culture that is driving all of this?
00:15:17where is the apostle directing his writing,
00:15:21We can understand why he has privileged certain elements,
00:15:25For example, for Lucas, in his culture, this wasn't important.
00:15:30because they were not being touched by the issue of docetism.
00:15:37Therefore, it should be clear that Jesus is truly a human being.
00:15:45like all of us.
00:15:47As we cross the first century, Marcion will now appear,
00:15:53Marcion, who will live between the year 95 and the year 161.
00:15:59He was a Greek convert to Christianity,
00:16:03He was a very rich man,
00:16:04And this gave him power, strength,
00:16:07in order to travel enough and spread his doctrine.
00:16:12What shall we call him?
00:16:14Marcionism.
00:16:16He does not accept Marcion, he does not accept the Gospels.
00:16:21The only Gospel he will accept is the Gospel of Luke.
00:16:25without the stories of childhood.
00:16:27What is Marcion doing?
00:16:28Well, Marcion rejects the Old Testament,
00:16:32He says that the law of Moses is wrong,
00:16:36and it is contrary to the teachings of Christ.
00:16:39It will be the first great heresy that will divide the church,
00:16:44and will continue to create the breeding ground,
00:16:47so that afterwards, the following heresies,
00:16:49so they can find a foundation on which to develop.
00:16:55So, here we have a God who is evil,
00:16:58a God who corresponds to the Old Testament,
00:17:01who is a God of war,
00:17:03who is a God who does not forgive his enemies,
00:17:05who is a God who even, well,
00:17:07He cuts off the heads of his own people when they misbehave, etc.
00:17:11And yet, it does not correspond to the image that Jesus presents
00:17:16from a good Father, from a loving Father,
00:17:18from a Father who forgives,
00:17:20which is, therefore, clearly represented in the Gospel of Luke,
00:17:24In the parable of the prodigal son, right?
00:17:26That makes it perfectly clear.
00:17:29That is why he will only take this Gospel,
00:17:32because it is the one that truly presents a loving image of God.
00:17:36So, he says, there is a God who, well,
00:17:40It was from the Old Testament,
00:17:42Who knows where it came from, right?
00:17:44Certainly, when one begins to delve deeper into the doctrines,
00:17:47Today, with all the tools we have,
00:17:49and all knowledge,
00:17:51Well, we see that there are a lot of holes,
00:17:53There are a lot of elements
00:17:55that find no solid foundation
00:17:57in order to be able to sustain itself.
00:18:00But we have to take it in stride.
00:18:01We are in the 2nd century.
00:18:02Then Marcion says,
00:18:05There is a God,
00:18:08Well, it's the one from the Old Testament, right?
00:18:11I believe, therefore, that Moses was wrong.
00:18:14and I wasn't entirely clear on this,
00:18:15But Jesus came and proposed to us,
00:18:17and then the Old Testament
00:18:18That's not what we need to understand.
00:18:21we don't have to live,
00:18:22It's useless.
00:18:23It goes to God.
00:18:25And he keeps only the New Testament,
00:18:27and within the New Testament,
00:18:28He will only accept the Gospel of Luke.
00:18:33which presents us with this loving vision,
00:18:37paternal, charitable and reconciling of the Father.
00:18:43Contemporary with Marcion
00:18:44another doctrine will emerge
00:18:49which will be called Evionism.
00:18:52The Evionites come from the word
00:18:54Evion in Hebrew,
00:18:56which means poor,
00:18:57because they, well,
00:19:00They wanted to live in extreme poverty,
00:19:03accepted out of love for God.
00:19:07These Evionites
00:19:09They denied the pre-existence of Jesus,
00:19:13In other words, it has not existed before.
00:19:17everything that the prologue of Saint John says,
00:19:21Well, it wouldn't exist either.
00:19:23In other words, Jesus did not exist before.
00:19:26Jesus begins to exist at that moment,
00:19:30like all of us,
00:19:31at the moment of our conception,
00:19:35That's where we'll begin to exist.
00:19:37Well, this is what the Evionites say.
00:19:41At the same time he denied that, well,
00:19:46Obviously, then, virgin birth,
00:19:49and believed that Jesus was indeed the Messiah,
00:19:52But he was not divine, he was human.
00:19:55In other words, it was a person who was conceived
00:19:59through Joseph and Mary,
00:20:01who is truly the Messiah,
00:20:03the one who comes to save the world,
00:20:04But he is not God.
00:20:06It is not pre-existing,
00:20:08He still has the idea
00:20:10that the eternal God exists,
00:20:12You see,
00:20:13And well,
00:20:14sends his Messiah,
00:20:16who would be Jesus,
00:20:17but which is begotten
00:20:19of Joseph and Mary,
00:20:21And this man,
00:20:22only this man,
00:20:24endowed with these powerful faculties,
00:20:27like many other prophets
00:20:30from the Old Testament,
00:20:31because he can perform miracles
00:20:33and can perform miraculous signs,
00:20:36but not because he is God,
00:20:38but because God has granted it
00:20:40to this man Jesus Christ,
00:20:42whom he has sent to rescue
00:20:44to his people,
00:20:45that can make these kinds of signals.
00:20:48So, look here
00:20:49how it develops further
00:20:51this breeding ground
00:20:53and things get more complicated,
00:20:56because then,
00:20:57on the one hand,
00:20:58We have this Marcion, right?
00:21:00Marcion who does not accept
00:21:01the Old Testament,
00:21:03who has a vision of God
00:21:04completely strange,
00:21:06the Trinitarian theme,
00:21:07because it practically disappears,
00:21:10the Old Testament
00:21:11is thrown out,
00:21:13then,
00:21:14contemporary,
00:21:15they are more or less
00:21:16from the same period,
00:21:17appears in another region
00:21:19of the world,
00:21:20appears within Christianity,
00:21:22appears in the Evionites,
00:21:24All of this is happening
00:21:25within our church,
00:21:26all this that is happening
00:21:28are with Christians,
00:21:31so you can see that the thing
00:21:32It was very complicated
00:21:34in the early centuries
00:21:35of the church,
00:21:37because it was necessary to understand
00:21:38really all of this,
00:21:40These people,
00:21:41Marcion,
00:21:42Arius,
00:21:43people are
00:21:45it developed,
00:21:46We don't have a creator
00:21:48of Evionism,
00:21:49but rather it was a
00:21:50kind of sect
00:21:51which grew,
00:21:53Well, they weren't bad people.
00:21:54what he said,
00:21:55We are going to destroy the church,
00:21:56and this,
00:21:57not them truly
00:21:58They believed this,
00:22:00bona fide,
00:22:01legally,
00:22:02thinking they were correct,
00:22:04because of his reasoning
00:22:05He was taking them there,
00:22:07That's why it's very dangerous.
00:22:09when we,
00:22:11outside the church
00:22:12and apart from the doctrine,
00:22:14we put
00:22:15to make our speculations
00:22:17about the mysteries,
00:22:18TRUE?
00:22:19The safest
00:22:20is that we arrive
00:22:21to a heresy,
00:22:21I told them
00:22:23to the boys,
00:22:25when I gave them
00:22:25classes there at the seminary,
00:22:27I was telling them,
00:22:30was in charge
00:22:30from some works,
00:22:31And I was telling them,
00:22:32Well,
00:22:32let's see,
00:22:32Let's review
00:22:33the jobs
00:22:33and say here
00:22:34his heresies,
00:22:35TRUE?
00:22:36Because here,
00:22:37Well, I can help you.
00:22:38let's see
00:22:39where your thoughts
00:22:42It defies logic.
00:22:43that's why,
00:22:44in the seminar
00:22:45you study first
00:22:46philosophy,
00:22:47to have
00:22:48a thought
00:22:49tidy
00:22:49that allows us,
00:22:51above all,
00:22:52discover
00:22:52where
00:22:53my thoughts
00:22:54jumps
00:22:55And that's it.
00:22:56to be orderly,
00:22:57and then
00:22:57it becomes
00:22:58in a thought
00:22:59fallacious.
00:23:00I arrive
00:23:00to conclusions
00:23:01wrong
00:23:02because a part
00:23:03of my thoughts
00:23:04is taking
00:23:05a premise
00:23:05that is not
00:23:06correct.
00:23:07so,
00:23:09one must have
00:23:09careful
00:23:10And that's why
00:23:10I always tell them,
00:23:11and you
00:23:12Who told you that?
00:23:14Where from
00:23:15you took out
00:23:16These ideas?
00:23:17It's not that
00:23:18Google,
00:23:19the thing is
00:23:20so-and-so,
00:23:21the thing is
00:23:21basement,
00:23:22let's see,
00:23:23and this person
00:23:24in turn,
00:23:25Where did he get it from?
00:23:26the information?
00:23:27What is the source?
00:23:29Because?
00:23:30And that's it.
00:23:31we can begin
00:23:32to make a reasoning
00:23:33much more organized
00:23:34And logical
00:23:34to say,
00:23:35you notice
00:23:36like here
00:23:36you jump
00:23:37of one thing
00:23:38to another
00:23:39where already
00:23:40There is no connection
00:23:42logic
00:23:42between your first
00:23:43premise
00:23:44and the second
00:23:45And that's why
00:23:45Well, you're going to arrive
00:23:46to a conclusion
00:23:47wrong.
00:23:49I was telling you a little while ago
00:23:50talking
00:23:50precisely
00:23:51of this
00:23:52of the two mushrooms
00:23:54as
00:23:55because they have
00:23:57a lot
00:23:57of holes,
00:23:58that is to say,
00:23:59they have thoughts
00:24:00that do not connect,
00:24:01They lack elements
00:24:02in the middle
00:24:03and jump
00:24:04of a proposal
00:24:06to another
00:24:07that has no basis
00:24:08and then
00:24:09Now they conclude
00:24:11obviously
00:24:11well something
00:24:12that he is wrong.
00:24:14And this
00:24:14siblings
00:24:15occurs
00:24:17to this day,
00:24:20TRUE?
00:24:21Above all
00:24:21Well, that's what happened
00:24:22in the process
00:24:23of the separation
00:24:25of the church
00:24:26through
00:24:26Luther's.
00:24:27Little by little
00:24:28we are creating
00:24:29premises
00:24:30that do not have
00:24:31no basis
00:24:32and then
00:24:33from there
00:24:34we jumped
00:24:34to conclude
00:24:35something
00:24:36which is false
00:24:37because if one
00:24:38of the two premises
00:24:39in a syllogism
00:24:40She is wrong.
00:24:42so
00:24:43the conclusion
00:24:44It will always be
00:24:44wrong.
00:24:46So
00:24:46one must have
00:24:47great care
00:24:48with this
00:24:49because otherwise
00:24:50because we ourselves
00:24:51TRUE?
00:24:53we fall
00:24:54in situations
00:24:55wrong.
00:24:56Let me give you a case
00:24:56very common
00:24:57within our church
00:24:58And it just happened to me
00:24:59this week
00:25:00No?
00:25:01A person
00:25:02He's leaving
00:25:03to confess
00:25:04and
00:25:05he tells me
00:25:06that
00:25:07well
00:25:09He went with the priest
00:25:11that at that moment
00:25:12I was already leaving
00:25:13because I was in a hurry
00:25:14and then
00:25:15he tells her
00:25:16He is a father
00:25:16the thing is
00:25:17I can't wait to take communion
00:25:18He tells him okay
00:25:19communion
00:25:20and then you confess
00:25:21Yeah?
00:25:23I mean
00:25:24That's a mistake
00:25:25in the doctrine
00:25:26TRUE?
00:25:26which has its base
00:25:27in the gospel
00:25:28in the letter
00:25:30to the Corinthians
00:25:31I mean
00:25:31in the letter
00:25:32to the Corinthians
00:25:32in chapter 11
00:25:34the first letter
00:25:35to the Corinthians
00:25:36It clearly states
00:25:37Pablo
00:25:37whoever approaches
00:25:39to receive unworthily
00:25:40the body
00:25:42and the blood
00:25:42of Jesus
00:25:43it is eaten
00:25:44her own
00:25:44condemnation
00:25:45Yeah?
00:25:46that's where it comes from
00:25:47and it is generated
00:25:48the doctrine
00:25:49TRUE?
00:25:49to say
00:25:50First, I confess
00:25:51and then I receive communion
00:25:53I cannot receive communion
00:25:55if I am in grave sin
00:25:57because that would be
00:25:58well, that's sacrilege
00:25:59It is a grave sin
00:26:01against the body
00:26:02and the blood of Jesus
00:26:03Yeah?
00:26:04But this is
00:26:05where from
00:26:06this person
00:26:07this priest
00:26:08at a given moment
00:26:09Get this idea
00:26:10Who knows?
00:26:12But this person
00:26:13who receives this instruction
00:26:14if he doesn't come with me
00:26:15to confess
00:26:16And he doesn't tell me this
00:26:18but nothing more
00:26:19confesses
00:26:19then
00:26:20What is she going to do?
00:26:22Well, he's going to tell her.
00:26:23To another one, right?
00:26:24"That's what a father told me."
00:26:25Well
00:26:26Thus began Marcion
00:26:28Thus began Arius
00:26:30He said it
00:26:32further
00:26:33more serious
00:26:33What will it be?
00:26:34the one who is going to divide
00:26:34the church
00:26:35with Arrio
00:26:36because Arius
00:26:36He was a bishop
00:26:37then imagine
00:26:38a bishop
00:26:39who says the wrong thing
00:26:41Well, now we're talking!
00:26:42worth quesadillas
00:26:45This, right?
00:26:46calling the saint
00:26:47And he doesn't answer, does he?
00:26:49as we were saying
00:26:50When we were little, right?
00:26:51because it is something
00:26:53What am I telling you?
00:26:55And who told you that?
00:26:55A father told me.
00:26:56He told me
00:26:57a bishop
00:26:58Oh Carlitos
00:26:59Now we're in the tower
00:27:00because that person
00:27:02She's going to tell someone else.
00:27:04and then to another
00:27:05and then to another
00:27:06And so they are convenient doctrines.
00:27:08it isn't true?
00:27:09and in the end
00:27:10How does this end?
00:27:11So why bother confessing now?
00:27:12Protestant doctrine
00:27:15go
00:27:16Sir
00:27:16notice that
00:27:17I have sinned greatly
00:27:18Have mercy on me
00:27:19ready
00:27:19let's go
00:27:20forward
00:27:20I confess
00:27:22many say
00:27:23Christians
00:27:25Catholics
00:27:26I confess
00:27:28with God
00:27:28because I don't have
00:27:29Why go and tell him?
00:27:31to a priest
00:27:32doctrine
00:27:33completely
00:27:34wrong
00:27:35because in San Juan
00:27:36in the chapter
00:27:37in chapter 21
00:27:40in chapter 20
00:27:42It clearly states
00:27:43TRUE?
00:27:44whom they forgive
00:27:45I forgive them
00:27:46those who are not forgiven
00:27:48I do not forgive them
00:27:49so
00:27:50there is a
00:27:51an element
00:27:52judicial
00:27:53There is a judge
00:27:55It's us
00:27:56and that we judge
00:27:58at the moment
00:27:59of confession
00:28:00Are you sorry?
00:28:01No
00:28:01Well
00:28:02I cannot absolve you
00:28:03And how do I know you're not there?
00:28:05repentant
00:28:06Or regretful?
00:28:07Because you don't want to change.
00:28:07You haven't done anything
00:28:08purpose of change
00:28:10so
00:28:11we see that the sacrament
00:28:13is connected
00:28:14with a vision
00:28:15of God
00:28:16what does that have to do with it
00:28:16with repentance
00:28:18if there is no repentance
00:28:20So how?
00:28:20And who will judge?
00:28:21that regret?
00:28:23because he gave us
00:28:24that tremendous work
00:28:25our lord
00:28:27so
00:28:27Who says
00:28:28that does not need
00:28:29Go with a priest?
00:28:31well
00:28:31is incorrect
00:28:33his doctrine
00:28:34when this
00:28:35starts to generate
00:28:36a whole
00:28:37a group of people
00:28:39that begins to think
00:28:39So
00:28:40it is
00:28:41beginning to develop
00:28:42a heresy
00:28:43and from there
00:28:44well, a sect
00:28:46TRUE?
00:28:47that will end
00:28:48dividing
00:28:48to our church
00:28:49as he did
00:28:50or has been doing so
00:28:51well, Protestantism
00:28:53in our times
00:28:54No?
00:28:56to combat
00:28:57this heresy
00:28:57tertullian
00:28:59And that's where things are going to get complicated.
00:29:00a little too
00:29:00this topic
00:29:01to combat
00:29:03this heresy
00:29:03so
00:29:04tertullian
00:29:05He lives
00:29:06in the year
00:29:07160
00:29:07to 220
00:29:09will be one
00:29:10parental
00:29:10of the church
00:29:11so
00:29:13It has always been
00:29:13tertullian
00:29:15I mean
00:29:16only a tertullian
00:29:17and origins
00:29:18They are the only ones
00:29:18two parents
00:29:19of the church
00:29:20that were not
00:29:21canonized
00:29:22certainly
00:29:23I think
00:29:23who are saints
00:29:24TRUE?
00:29:24but they weren't
00:29:25canonized
00:29:26for different reasons
00:29:27tertullian
00:29:27because always
00:29:28It was controversial
00:29:30And why?
00:29:32mostly
00:29:32because for
00:29:33combat
00:29:33to the Evonites
00:29:34TRUE?
00:29:36and also
00:29:37to the two-year-olds
00:29:37denied
00:29:38virginity
00:29:39life
00:29:39remember
00:29:40that virginity
00:29:41life
00:29:42it is before
00:29:42in
00:29:43and then
00:29:43of childbirth
00:29:44That's virginity.
00:29:45life
00:29:46We'll see.
00:29:46at a moment
00:29:47further
00:29:47and then
00:29:48What does it say?
00:29:49pundit?
00:29:50that Jesus
00:29:51was born
00:29:51like everyone else
00:29:52the children
00:29:53TRUE?
00:29:54so
00:29:54there is no
00:29:56He doesn't say so.
00:29:57So
00:29:57but so
00:29:59He interprets it
00:29:59there is no
00:30:00a virginity
00:30:01in childbirth
00:30:02right now
00:30:03we'll talk
00:30:04a bit
00:30:04more of this
00:30:05so
00:30:06obviously
00:30:06at the same time
00:30:07because it generates
00:30:08a reaction
00:30:09completely
00:30:10negative
00:30:10on behalf of
00:30:11of the church
00:30:11that always
00:30:12he said
00:30:13that the Virgin
00:30:14Maria
00:30:14it is always
00:30:15virgin
00:30:15and this vision
00:30:17always
00:30:18virgin
00:30:18included
00:30:19these three
00:30:20moments
00:30:20before
00:30:21that is
00:30:21completely
00:30:22witnessed
00:30:23in writing
00:30:24before
00:30:25that had
00:30:26that he lived
00:30:27with José
00:30:27before delivery
00:30:29we don't have
00:30:30no reference
00:30:31for childbirth
00:30:31and then
00:30:32after childbirth
00:30:33well, neither
00:30:34that's why
00:30:34Let's see
00:30:35which is a topic
00:30:35quite complicated
00:30:37and complex
00:30:37if you look closely
00:30:38We are in the century
00:30:39second
00:30:40and it appears
00:30:42the topic
00:30:43where
00:30:44tertullian
00:30:45says
00:30:45no, no, no, no
00:30:46those little planes
00:30:47They're really bad
00:30:48He is a man
00:30:48like anyone else
00:30:49He was born like anyone else.
00:30:50TRUE?
00:30:52so
00:30:53It's going to get complicated.
00:30:55the topic
00:30:55of virginity
00:30:56we see then
00:30:58that already from
00:30:58the dawn
00:30:59of Christianity
00:31:00we found
00:31:00the topic
00:31:01of virginity
00:31:01so
00:31:03It's going to end
00:31:04He's going to leave
00:31:05converting
00:31:07in a
00:31:07on a topic
00:31:08controversial
00:31:09TRUE?
00:31:10about our
00:31:11Holy Mother
00:31:11and then
00:31:12come as
00:31:13Maria now
00:31:14start again
00:31:14to enter
00:31:15in the game
00:31:16No?
00:31:16in the game
00:31:17of the
00:31:17of the
00:31:18of the controversy
00:31:19and then
00:31:20Maria
00:31:21but they notice
00:31:21that is not born
00:31:22her
00:31:23but is born
00:31:24how
00:31:24Jesus was born
00:31:25and when
00:31:27to get into that topic
00:31:28how Jesus was born
00:31:29to combat
00:31:30a heresy
00:31:30of the small planes
00:31:31and of the Dosts
00:31:32then
00:31:33HE
00:31:34Well, it looks like it.
00:31:35involved
00:31:35Our most holy mother
00:31:36because then
00:31:37She is no longer always a virgin
00:31:38Yeah?
00:31:40a topic
00:31:40that comes from Jesus
00:31:41it affects her
00:31:43because the two mysteries
00:31:44they are always
00:31:45because united
00:31:46complete the table
00:31:48to close
00:31:49just a little bit
00:31:50this whole topic
00:31:51of these
00:31:51of these early years
00:31:52of Christianity
00:31:53with the
00:31:54Aryanism
00:31:55that will come
00:31:56to combine
00:31:57a large part
00:31:58of all these
00:31:59doctrines
00:32:00of all these
00:32:00thoughts
00:32:01because of Arianism
00:32:03he will affirm
00:32:03that Jesus Christ
00:32:04was created
00:32:05by God the Father
00:32:07I mean
00:32:07again
00:32:08the vision
00:32:09of the witnesses
00:32:11of Jehovah
00:32:11I tell them
00:32:11that the witnesses
00:32:12of Jehovah
00:32:12They are a wonderful
00:32:14synthesis
00:32:15of heresies
00:32:15of all time
00:32:16TRUE?
00:32:17truly
00:32:19and not to say
00:32:20something offensive
00:32:21but simply
00:32:22Because that's the truth
00:32:23I mean
00:32:25have part
00:32:27of two mushrooms
00:32:27because of the topic
00:32:28after the crucifixion
00:32:29not knowing
00:32:30What happened
00:32:30with that body
00:32:31TRUE?
00:32:32and that God
00:32:32He hands it over
00:32:33because another body
00:32:34and you say
00:32:34it just can't be
00:32:35TRUE?
00:32:36each
00:32:36has a body
00:32:37on the other hand
00:32:38have
00:32:39the topic
00:32:40of Aryanism
00:32:41They are also
00:32:43Arians
00:32:43because?
00:32:44because they deny
00:32:46that Jesus
00:32:47is pre-existing
00:32:49throughout all eternity
00:32:50but they consider it
00:32:52as a creation
00:32:53in fact
00:32:54he
00:32:54in order to sustain
00:32:56this
00:32:57the
00:32:57the witnesses
00:32:58of Jehovah
00:32:59is the only one
00:33:00well church
00:33:02TRUE?
00:33:03or the only sect
00:33:04that
00:33:05well no
00:33:06She is not Christian
00:33:07because they don't recognize
00:33:08nor our baptism
00:33:09nor do they recognize
00:33:10the trinity
00:33:11It is the only sect
00:33:13which has modified
00:33:15writing
00:33:16they modified
00:33:18writing
00:33:19in the prologue
00:33:20from Juan
00:33:20and also
00:33:21in the stories
00:33:22of the institution
00:33:23Eucharistic
00:33:24modified
00:33:26the Greek text
00:33:27so that I could
00:33:29be compliant
00:33:30to his vision
00:33:31Yeah?
00:33:32in such a way
00:33:33that Jesus Christ
00:33:34It is not eternal
00:33:35with the Father
00:33:36but
00:33:37that Jesus Christ
00:33:38It is a creation
00:33:40that I tell them
00:33:41this
00:33:42when
00:33:43I deal with them
00:33:45I tell them
00:33:45Okay, then
00:33:46You are
00:33:46polytheists
00:33:48TRUE?
00:33:49because Jesus
00:33:49is another God
00:33:51to Chihuahua
00:33:52What do you mean, another God?
00:33:55by not recognizing
00:33:56the trinity
00:33:57and recognize
00:33:59that Jesus
00:33:59is God
00:34:00or I'll tell you
00:34:01Well, Jesus is God.
00:34:01or is it not God?
00:34:02I don't know if it's God.
00:34:03Okay then, it's
00:34:04the Father
00:34:07Or how does that work?
00:34:08no, no, no, no
00:34:09It is not another God
00:34:09So you're a polytheist.
00:34:10No
00:34:11So how?
00:34:13Do you notice how?
00:34:14there comes a time
00:34:15in which it jumps
00:34:15if at the time you
00:34:17you're trying
00:34:17to do
00:34:18logical thinking
00:34:19well suddenly
00:34:20It jumps, doesn't it?
00:34:21let's see
00:34:22Do we have two Gods?
00:34:24No
00:34:25How many gods?
00:34:26because they say
00:34:27who is the only God
00:34:28Jehovah
00:34:29or Yahweh
00:34:30He is the only God
00:34:31and Christ
00:34:33Scripture says
00:34:35another God
00:34:36polytheism
00:34:37Yeah?
00:34:39and so
00:34:40they are separating
00:34:41and we have
00:34:42this sect
00:34:43of the witnesses
00:34:44of Jehovah
00:34:44which are
00:34:45because they are not the Arians
00:34:46now they are called
00:34:47Jehovah's Witnesses
00:34:48that they have synthesized
00:34:50how are they fixed
00:34:51many of the heresies
00:34:52that the Church
00:34:53has fought
00:34:54has explained
00:34:55widely
00:34:56so that we can
00:34:57us
00:34:58grasp
00:34:59as Lucas says
00:35:00solidity
00:35:01of the doctrine
00:35:02that we have been taught
00:35:04in the catechism
00:35:05and in evangelization
00:35:06Arrio is going to live
00:35:09in the third century
00:35:10beginning of the fourth
00:35:11250
00:35:12to 335
00:35:14is going to live
00:35:15this
00:35:16this Arius
00:35:18It's going to be
00:35:19firstly
00:35:20presbyter
00:35:21of Alexandria
00:35:22in Egypt
00:35:22and it gets
00:35:23well
00:35:24all these
00:35:25all these
00:35:26items
00:35:27Orthodox
00:35:28of the divine nature
00:35:29for him
00:35:31says
00:35:31There was a time
00:35:32in which God
00:35:33He was not a father
00:35:33but he was alone
00:35:35and then
00:35:36out of nowhere
00:35:36He created the son
00:35:38and it began
00:35:38to be a father
00:35:39let's see
00:35:44the Americans would say
00:35:48wait a minute
00:35:49let's see
00:35:51only exists
00:35:53and then create
00:35:55a son
00:35:56No
00:35:57the children
00:35:58are created
00:35:59not the children
00:36:01are conceived
00:36:01it isn't true
00:36:02That's why we
00:36:03we say begotten
00:36:04of the father
00:36:04how to create a child
00:36:06will have created
00:36:07a creature
00:36:08that is to say
00:36:08created
00:36:09created
00:36:12because it was created
00:36:13like us
00:36:13we are creatures
00:36:14and the angels
00:36:15They are creatures
00:36:15then Jesus Christ
00:36:16It is a creature
00:36:17He is not a son
00:36:18he cannot be a father
00:36:19and then
00:36:20like writing
00:36:21says
00:36:21in the gospels
00:36:22that
00:36:23my father
00:36:24me too
00:36:25we are one
00:36:25let's see
00:36:26moment
00:36:26He is a father
00:36:27or he's not a father
00:36:27Well, if he's a father
00:36:28but
00:36:29but it didn't exist
00:36:30always
00:36:30TRUE
00:36:31There was a time
00:36:32who was alone
00:36:32and then
00:36:33creates his son
00:36:34Did you understand me?
00:36:37No
00:36:37because?
00:36:39because you skip
00:36:40a natural process
00:36:41If I'm going to tell him
00:36:44father to someone
00:36:45It's because I was conceived
00:36:46his
00:36:46or I was adopted
00:36:48And from where
00:36:50Did he adopt him?
00:36:51I mean
00:36:52How did he create it?
00:36:52and then adopts it
00:36:53because
00:36:53let's see
00:36:54I didn't understand anymore
00:36:55Do you notice?
00:36:57as
00:36:57a thought
00:36:59which is poorly founded
00:37:00always ends
00:37:01because it is a heresy
00:37:02And this is what
00:37:03Arrio does
00:37:05no more than Arrius
00:37:06as he was a bishop
00:37:08TRUE?
00:37:09well
00:37:09He's leaving
00:37:12to
00:37:13He's leaving
00:37:14to
00:37:14expand
00:37:16TRUE?
00:37:17throughout
00:37:17he
00:37:18he
00:37:19the territory
00:37:20TRUE?
00:37:21and
00:37:21He's leaving
00:37:21to go
00:37:22dividing
00:37:23our church
00:37:24There will be
00:37:25three centuries
00:37:26in which the doctrine
00:37:28is going to create
00:37:29a great confusion
00:37:30about people
00:37:31about identity
00:37:32of Christ
00:37:33that
00:37:33because of their relationship
00:37:34with Mary
00:37:35because it also falls
00:37:36in this area
00:37:37the end point
00:37:39He's going to put it on
00:37:39Nestorius
00:37:40patriarch
00:37:41of Constantinople
00:37:42for Nestorius
00:37:44It shouldn't be said
00:37:45that Mary
00:37:46is the Theotokos
00:37:47but the
00:37:48Christotocos
00:37:49It's the end point.
00:37:51TRUE?
00:37:52since it states
00:37:53that at birth
00:37:54Jesus
00:37:54and be baptized
00:37:55would receive there
00:37:56the divinity
00:37:57of the Holy Spirit
00:37:58if you look closely
00:38:00We're already on our way.
00:38:00adding
00:38:01a series
00:38:01of elements
00:38:02I mean
00:38:03on the one hand
00:38:03have
00:38:04that Jesus
00:38:05or what is
00:38:07conceived
00:38:07in the bosom
00:38:08of Mary
00:38:08He is not God
00:38:10is a human being
00:38:11as I was saying
00:38:12Marcion
00:38:13TRUE?
00:38:14and then
00:38:15born
00:38:16like everyone else
00:38:17TRUE?
00:38:18and
00:38:18there is no
00:38:19a virginity
00:38:20as such
00:38:21is not begotten
00:38:22of the Holy Spirit
00:38:23but he is a man
00:38:24that is born
00:38:24and receives
00:38:26the divinity
00:38:27through action
00:38:28of the Holy Spirit
00:38:29at his baptism
00:38:30that is to say
00:38:31from birth
00:38:32up to 30
00:38:3430 years
00:38:35who is baptized
00:38:35is a human being
00:38:37like you and me
00:38:38He is not God
00:38:39He is not a divine being
00:38:41is a human being
00:38:42but at the moment
00:38:43is to be baptized
00:38:44and that the Holy Spirit
00:38:45descends
00:38:46so
00:38:47begin
00:38:56to
00:38:57to be divine
00:38:59He begins to be God
00:39:00obviously
00:39:01well this
00:39:02contradicts
00:39:03completely
00:39:04the meaning
00:39:05of writing
00:39:05particularly
00:39:07Lucas
00:39:09so
00:39:10clarifies
00:39:10fully
00:39:11which was
00:39:12begotten
00:39:13the son of God
00:39:15was begotten
00:39:16in the bosom
00:39:17of the Virgin Mary
00:39:18and then
00:39:19He begins to say
00:39:20especially now
00:39:21We are already
00:39:224th century
00:39:22start now
00:39:25Maria has spread
00:39:26already the Marian cult
00:39:28Mary's vision
00:39:29It has already spread
00:39:30and then he says
00:39:31we cannot tell you
00:39:32to Mary
00:39:33Mother of God
00:39:34but we have to tell him
00:39:35Mother of Christ
00:39:37because Christ
00:39:38because Jesus
00:39:39because he is not God
00:39:41Jesus
00:39:42well
00:39:43let's see
00:39:45so
00:39:46who is Jesus
00:39:47oh well
00:39:52ordinary people
00:39:54that cannot
00:39:55reflect
00:39:56deeply
00:39:57about this
00:39:57Well, listen.
00:39:58what he tells her
00:39:59the bishop
00:40:00what he tells her
00:40:01the father
00:40:02TRUE
00:40:03and then
00:40:04well
00:40:05Arrio
00:40:06begin
00:40:07to promote
00:40:08this doctrine
00:40:09as a priest
00:40:10TRUE
00:40:11Who told you that?
00:40:12the father
00:40:13that's how it is
00:40:14and this
00:40:15Who told you that?
00:40:16the bishop
00:40:17Ah, well, that's how it is.
00:40:18we didn't go into detail
00:40:20we're not going
00:40:20to logic
00:40:21of thought
00:40:22I mean, people
00:40:23yourselves
00:40:24No
00:40:25maybe
00:40:26I hope I'm not confusing them
00:40:27You see, these topics
00:40:28that we have been trying
00:40:29this cycle
00:40:30Well, they're a bit
00:40:31more complicated
00:40:33because they are not spiritual
00:40:34but they are
00:40:35theological
00:40:36are known
00:40:37so
00:40:38wait
00:40:40myself
00:40:41not to do it to them
00:40:42balls
00:40:43and then
00:40:46arrive and
00:40:46say
00:40:47It's that the father
00:40:48Ernesto
00:40:49said
00:40:49let's see
00:40:50and what did he say
00:40:52the father
00:40:53Ernesto
00:40:53that's why
00:40:55We are
00:40:55recording
00:40:56so that they have it
00:40:56on the little disc
00:40:57and then check it.
00:40:59because then
00:41:00who knows
00:41:00that we understand
00:41:01And that's normal.
00:41:04In other words, it's not
00:41:06It's not a bad vibe.
00:41:07or anything
00:41:07it's simply
00:41:08that
00:41:08because we are not
00:41:10very used to it
00:41:11as the people of God
00:41:12to do this kind
00:41:13of reflections
00:41:15and these elements
00:41:17of logical theme
00:41:19that then jump out at you
00:41:20TRUE?
00:41:21I mean, at least for me.
00:41:22well it jumps up
00:41:24when someone is telling me
00:41:24let's see
00:41:25let's see
00:41:26Let's see
00:41:27one
00:41:27this
00:41:28two
00:41:28this
00:41:29three
00:41:29false conclusion
00:41:30The number two is false.
00:41:31or one is false
00:41:32because the third conclusion
00:41:34it doesn't give
00:41:35but
00:41:37I do this process
00:41:38and yet
00:41:39I tell him that suddenly
00:41:40I get tangled up
00:41:42And then I have to let go
00:41:43the thing
00:41:44TRUE?
00:41:45Yes, because
00:41:46one begins to advance
00:41:47in the mystery
00:41:48the mystery
00:41:49It won't open
00:41:50to our mind
00:41:51and one
00:41:52force
00:41:54and to force
00:41:56No
00:41:57I'd better let go
00:41:58TRUE?
00:41:58I always try
00:41:59to keep moving forward
00:42:00but always
00:42:02having next to me
00:42:03the holy scripture
00:42:05and the doctrine
00:42:06of the church
00:42:07and when I start
00:42:08to think about things
00:42:09which are not
00:42:09none
00:42:10of these two things
00:42:11I'm feeling unwell
00:42:12something
00:42:13in my mental process
00:42:14in my logical process
00:42:16I'm not doing it right
00:42:17Because if I did it right
00:42:18It had to happen
00:42:19to this conclusion
00:42:19and I'm not getting there
00:42:20Oh my!
00:42:22Yeah?
00:42:23when there is no doctrine
00:42:24even
00:42:26writing
00:42:27because it's barely
00:42:28this
00:42:29developing
00:42:30in the
00:42:30in Christianity
00:42:32Well, it was very easy.
00:42:33that this type
00:42:34of situations
00:42:35occurred
00:42:36No?
00:42:38So, well
00:42:39Well, now we have
00:42:39to this
00:42:40good story
00:42:41He's going to live
00:42:42between the year
00:42:43318
00:42:44and 451
00:42:46patriarch
00:42:47of Constantinople
00:42:48that is to say
00:42:49bishop
00:42:49and then
00:42:50well he
00:42:51He's going to say
00:42:52that need to be told
00:42:53Christotocos
00:42:55and not theotokos
00:42:56I mean
00:42:56Mother of Christ
00:42:57and not
00:42:58Mother of God
00:42:59and this
00:43:01Okay then
00:43:02to
00:43:03scatter
00:43:05widely
00:43:06in the church
00:43:07the problem
00:43:08born here
00:43:09so
00:43:10of the dual nature
00:43:12he was accused
00:43:13of professing
00:43:14a doctrine
00:43:14which consists
00:43:15in a separation
00:43:16total
00:43:17between the divinity
00:43:18and humanity
00:43:19of Christ
00:43:19that is to say
00:43:20in Christ
00:43:20there would be
00:43:21two people
00:43:22the person
00:43:24of the verb
00:43:25that receive it
00:43:26baptism
00:43:27and the person
00:43:28of Christ
00:43:28two people
00:43:32that coexist
00:43:33in a body
00:43:36or like
00:43:37Yeah
00:43:39difficult to explain
00:43:40already
00:43:41in our times
00:43:42No
00:43:42but in time
00:43:43well, so
00:43:45he went away
00:43:46developed
00:43:47and this
00:43:47I had then
00:43:48let's say
00:43:49bases
00:43:50those that at that time
00:43:52they could have had
00:43:53enough to support oneself
00:43:55and be able to cover
00:43:56to society
00:43:57above all
00:43:58to society
00:43:58intellectual of the time
00:43:59which was the one that was
00:44:01spreading
00:44:01all these
00:44:02this heresy
00:44:04so
00:44:05the important thing
00:44:06now it was
00:44:07let's see
00:44:08who
00:44:09if you look closely
00:44:10We're arriving
00:44:11fourth century
00:44:12in the fourth century
00:44:14We have this problem
00:44:16of all these visions
00:44:18that have come
00:44:19developing
00:44:20along
00:44:20of these
00:44:21well
00:44:22350 years
00:44:24a quote will be given
00:44:26to a council
00:44:28What will it be?
00:44:29the council
00:44:29of Ephesus
00:44:30where it will be discussed
00:44:32mostly
00:44:33the topic
00:44:34of the double
00:44:36of the double
00:44:37nature
00:44:38finally
00:44:39well
00:44:40is going to
00:44:42to
00:44:43to be scheduled
00:44:44to the council
00:44:45who goes
00:44:46to read
00:44:47and goes
00:44:48to
00:44:48to validate
00:44:50a letter
00:44:51that wrote
00:44:52Saint Cyril
00:44:53of Alexandria
00:44:53who writes to him
00:44:55to Nestorius
00:44:56to tell him
00:44:57that he is wrong
00:44:58and introduces
00:44:59all points
00:45:00of his mistake
00:45:01It makes him see
00:45:02that his thinking
00:45:03like right now
00:45:03I've been saying it.
00:45:04It's a thought.
00:45:06wrong
00:45:07and makes him see
00:45:08that has to change
00:45:10and it has to be modified
00:45:11thing that
00:45:12Nestorius
00:45:12It won't work
00:45:13to accept
00:45:15so
00:45:15the council
00:45:16of Ephesus
00:45:17that is celebrated
00:45:18in the 431
00:45:19will confirm
00:45:21the letter
00:45:22the second letter
00:45:23of Saint Cyril
00:45:24of Alexandria
00:45:25to Nestorius
00:45:26and with that
00:45:27is going to
00:45:28meet
00:45:29ditch
00:45:30completely
00:45:31the situation
00:45:32this
00:45:33this
00:45:34this part
00:45:35end
00:45:36I'm going to
00:45:37read
00:45:37from a document
00:45:38which is called
00:45:39Densinger
00:45:40that's how it's known
00:45:41like Densinger
00:45:42which is a
00:45:43It is not a document
00:45:45It's a great book
00:45:46TRUE
00:45:47that contains
00:45:48the main ones
00:45:49documents
00:45:50from the beginning
00:45:52until the council
00:45:53Vatican II
00:45:54And so it remains.
00:45:55moving forward
00:45:56There it is
00:45:56content
00:45:57everything that is
00:45:59the doctrine
00:46:00of the church
00:46:01according to what has
00:46:02professed
00:46:02the councils
00:46:04and the holy fathers
00:46:05when they have spoken
00:46:06ex cathedra
00:46:06that is to say
00:46:07with a papal bull
00:46:08where it says
00:46:09This is dogma.
00:46:09and it must be believed that way
00:46:11It's a book
00:46:12big
00:46:13TRUE
00:46:13can you
00:46:14acquire
00:46:15if they want
00:46:16well read
00:46:17with greater
00:46:19depth
00:46:19all this
00:46:20comes
00:46:20in some cases
00:46:22For example
00:46:23those who are
00:46:23the oldest
00:46:25documents
00:46:25They come in Greek
00:46:26Latin
00:46:28and they are translated
00:46:29in our case
00:46:30to Spanish
00:46:31to the language
00:46:31vernacular
00:46:32if they succeed
00:46:33in the United States
00:46:33because it will come
00:46:34in Latin
00:46:35in Greek
00:46:36and in English
00:46:37and so on
00:46:38But it can be done
00:46:40are listed
00:46:41with a number
00:46:42and it is
00:46:43DS
00:46:44Densinger
00:46:45Schotsmeier
00:46:46what is
00:46:47the latest version
00:46:48compilation
00:46:49that is being done
00:46:50Schonsmester
00:46:52Schonsmester
00:46:53Densinger
00:46:54Schonsmester
00:46:55and it gets
00:46:56a number
00:46:57What is the little paragraph?
00:46:58where is
00:46:59that number
00:47:00so
00:47:01in the Densinger
00:47:03250
00:47:04says
00:47:05because we don't say
00:47:08that nature
00:47:08of the verb
00:47:09transformed
00:47:10became flesh
00:47:11but neither
00:47:12it transmuted
00:47:13in the whole man
00:47:15compound
00:47:16of soul and body
00:47:17but rather
00:47:18that having
00:47:19united with himself
00:47:20the verb
00:47:21according to hypostasis
00:47:22or person
00:47:23the animated meat
00:47:25of the rational soul
00:47:26He became a man
00:47:27in an ineffable way
00:47:28and incomprehensible
00:47:29I mean
00:47:30how to
00:47:31joins
00:47:32how it is embodied
00:47:34the person
00:47:36of the verb
00:47:39this person
00:47:40how it is embodied
00:47:41TRUE
00:47:42and it still is
00:47:43the same
00:47:44only person
00:47:45in Christ
00:47:46the only person
00:47:47that exists
00:47:48is the person
00:47:49of the verb
00:47:49eternal with the Father
00:47:51is the only person
00:47:51that exists
00:47:52and
00:47:53share
00:47:55two natures
00:47:57That's why he says so
00:47:57so
00:47:58incomprehensible
00:48:00and he was called
00:48:01son of man
00:48:02not by will alone
00:48:05or complacency
00:48:06but neither
00:48:07by the assumption
00:48:08of the single person
00:48:09and that natures
00:48:11that come together
00:48:12in a true unity
00:48:15They are different
00:48:16two natures
00:48:17human
00:48:18and divine
00:48:18but that both
00:48:20it turns out
00:48:20one Christ
00:48:22and son
00:48:23not as if
00:48:28the difference
00:48:28of nature
00:48:29it would be destroyed
00:48:31through unity
00:48:32but because
00:48:33the divinity
00:48:34and humanity
00:48:35constitute
00:48:36rather
00:48:36for us
00:48:37one Lord
00:48:38and Christ
00:48:39and son
00:48:39due to the concurrence
00:48:40ineffable
00:48:41and mysterious
00:48:42in the unit
00:48:43because he wasn't born
00:48:44firstly
00:48:45a vulgar man
00:48:46evoinists
00:48:49Marcion
00:48:50of the Holy Virgin
00:48:53and then descended
00:48:53about him
00:48:54the verb
00:48:54but
00:48:56united
00:48:56from the mother's womb
00:48:57it is said
00:48:58who submitted
00:48:59to carnal birth
00:49:00as one who makes it their own
00:49:01the birth
00:49:02of the flesh itself
00:49:03this way
00:49:04the holy fathers
00:49:06They didn't have
00:49:07inconvenient
00:49:07call
00:49:08Mother of God
00:49:09to the Holy Virgin
00:49:11OK
00:49:11the proposal
00:49:12of Nestorius
00:49:13remains completely
00:49:14already settled
00:49:15they are settled
00:49:16also
00:49:17all the others
00:49:18everyone else
00:49:19items
00:49:20that we had
00:49:20previously
00:49:21and with this
00:49:23it ends
00:49:23to the controversy
00:49:24and Mary
00:49:25is defined
00:49:26dogmatically
00:49:27as the mother of God
00:49:29I mean
00:49:29can
00:49:30with full propriety
00:49:31say
00:49:32who is the mother of God
00:49:33according
00:49:34to his incarnation
00:49:35no to his eternity
00:49:37Jesus
00:49:39the word of God
00:49:41It is eternal
00:49:42with the father
00:49:42but
00:49:43in his incarnation
00:49:46Maria
00:49:46it begins to
00:49:47true mother
00:49:49of the only person
00:49:50that exists
00:49:51which is the verb
00:49:52There are not two people
00:49:54There is only one person
00:49:56who is the person
00:49:57of the verb
00:49:57as far as it concerns
00:49:59to virginity
00:50:00This will be a topic
00:50:01that will travel
00:50:02the next part
00:50:03of history
00:50:04of Christianity
00:50:06and it will be
00:50:07look
00:50:07We are already
00:50:09in the year
00:50:10647
00:50:11the council
00:50:12Lateran
00:50:13to 653
00:50:15That's where it's going to be
00:50:16defined
00:50:16as dogma
00:50:17virginity
00:50:18life
00:50:19as already
00:50:20I was suggesting it
00:50:21previously
00:50:22well
00:50:23this topic
00:50:24of the brothers
00:50:25of Jesus
00:50:25has traveled
00:50:26well
00:50:27practically
00:50:28lifetime
00:50:29of Christianity
00:50:30up to our dates
00:50:31above all
00:50:32after
00:50:33on the topic
00:50:34Protestant
00:50:35Well, the topic
00:50:36whose are they
00:50:37those brothers
00:50:38of Jesus
00:50:39that appear
00:50:40continuously
00:50:40in writing
00:50:41It's going to be an issue
00:50:42controversial
00:50:43that again
00:50:44calls into question
00:50:45to our mother
00:50:46most holy
00:50:47to say
00:50:47if it is
00:50:48or it's not always
00:50:49virgin
00:50:49if he had
00:50:50or didn't have
00:50:51more children
00:50:52No
00:50:52in different texts
00:50:55because we are told
00:50:55of the brothers
00:50:56we have already seen
00:50:58at another time
00:50:59and spoken
00:50:59later
00:51:00of these
00:51:01Adelfoy
00:51:02of the brothers
00:51:03of Jesus
00:51:04what is
00:51:05a topic
00:51:06complex
00:51:06that is born
00:51:07from the beginning
00:51:09of Christianity
00:51:10we already saw
00:51:11as a panelist
00:51:12well
00:51:13Leave it already
00:51:14glimpse
00:51:15certain elements
00:51:16there
00:51:16of birth
00:51:17natural
00:51:18of Christ
00:51:18in the end
00:51:19other
00:51:22of the elements
00:51:23that appear
00:51:24that's the topic
00:51:25of
00:51:25he
00:51:26in Matthew
00:51:271.25
00:51:28says
00:51:29that José
00:51:30He didn't know her
00:51:31until
00:51:33was born
00:51:34Jesus
00:51:34know
00:51:35how to say
00:51:36had relations
00:51:38with Mary
00:51:39this expression
00:51:40It has been bad
00:51:41misused
00:51:42and confused
00:51:43mostly
00:51:43by the brothers
00:51:44of the reform
00:51:45because
00:51:47does not represent
00:51:48absolutely
00:51:50nothing
00:51:51about what
00:51:52next
00:51:53because it doesn't say
00:51:54what happens next
00:51:55There are some
00:51:57There are several texts
00:51:58in writing
00:51:58I quote him
00:51:59one
00:52:00what is
00:52:01second
00:52:01Samuel's
00:52:026.23
00:52:03where
00:52:05well
00:52:05Mical
00:52:06It's going to be
00:52:06punished
00:52:07Mical
00:52:08wife
00:52:08David's
00:52:09It's going to be
00:52:09punished
00:52:10for having
00:52:11ridiculed
00:52:12to her husband
00:52:13and says
00:52:14in it
00:52:14verse
00:52:1523
00:52:15of this
00:52:16chapter
00:52:166
00:52:17second
00:52:17Samuel's
00:52:18and Mical
00:52:19daughter of
00:52:20Saul
00:52:20he had no
00:52:21children
00:52:22until the
00:52:22day of
00:52:22his death
00:52:23I mean
00:52:24after
00:52:25if he had
00:52:25they fix
00:52:31which is the
00:52:31same expression
00:52:32and not the
00:52:33met
00:52:34until
00:52:35she
00:52:35had
00:52:37Jesus
00:52:38that
00:52:39who wants
00:52:40say
00:52:40no
00:52:41had
00:52:41relations
00:52:42before
00:52:42and then
00:52:43It doesn't say
00:52:47nothing
00:52:47just like
00:52:50this text
00:52:51from Mical
00:52:51daughter of
00:52:52Saul
00:52:52he had no
00:52:53children
00:52:53until the
00:52:54day of
00:52:54his death
00:52:55that is to say
00:52:55he had no
00:52:56children
00:52:57because
00:52:58died
00:52:58later
00:53:00because he can't anymore
00:53:00have children
00:53:01They are all
00:53:02these texts
00:53:03with a certain
00:53:04ambiguity
00:53:05that
00:53:06they push
00:53:08to the
00:53:09people
00:53:10well
00:53:10I don't want to say
00:53:11ignorant
00:53:12but to the
00:53:13people who don't
00:53:13does a
00:53:13reflection
00:53:14deep
00:53:15and it doesn't go
00:53:15to the bases
00:53:16and doesn't take
00:53:16all the
00:53:17items
00:53:18contextual
00:53:19in order to be able to
00:53:19to reach a
00:53:20definition
00:53:21clear
00:53:21however
00:53:24Well, it has been
00:53:24a controversy
00:53:25that has traveled
00:53:26the church
00:53:27without an answer
00:53:28overwhelming
00:53:29especially
00:53:30if we consider
00:53:31the topic
00:53:31of virginity
00:53:32in childbirth
00:53:33that still
00:53:34It remains
00:53:34a problem
00:53:35serious
00:53:36inside
00:53:37of our
00:53:38church
00:53:39the church
00:53:39Catholic
00:53:40apostolic
00:53:41Roman
00:53:41TRUE
00:53:42because there are
00:53:42many theologians
00:53:43or a quantity
00:53:44important
00:53:45of theologians
00:53:46that still
00:53:47question
00:53:48this topic
00:53:49of virginity
00:53:50in childbirth
00:53:50as I already pointed out
00:53:52tertullian
00:53:53as we were saying
00:53:53a moment ago
00:53:54this topic
00:53:57well today
00:53:58it continues
00:53:59discussing
00:54:00some
00:54:01support
00:54:02inside
00:54:03of the church
00:54:03Catholic
00:54:04some
00:54:05support
00:54:05the vision
00:54:06of Saint
00:54:06Bernard
00:54:07that says
00:54:08as well as
00:54:08the light
00:54:09crosses
00:54:09the glass
00:54:10without damaging it
00:54:11so the son
00:54:12of God
00:54:12crossed
00:54:13the breast
00:54:14purest
00:54:14of Mary
00:54:15without damaging
00:54:16that is to say
00:54:16I was one day
00:54:18already
00:54:18appeal
00:54:19the day
00:54:19of birth
00:54:20and was
00:54:21there then
00:54:22in the
00:54:22in that
00:54:23cave
00:54:23of shepherds
00:54:24and suddenly
00:54:25Jesus
00:54:25appeared
00:54:26within it
00:54:27today
00:54:28a wide
00:54:29sector
00:54:30of the church
00:54:31well, like
00:54:32who sees that
00:54:32complicated
00:54:34TRUE
00:54:35I mean
00:54:35It may be a mystery
00:54:38if that's possible
00:54:39Yeah
00:54:40however
00:54:41the controversy
00:54:43go on
00:54:43What are you going to do?
00:54:45throwing
00:54:45now the church
00:54:46where is it going
00:54:47moving forward
00:54:48trying to define
00:54:50what does it mean
00:54:52ever virgin
00:54:53what does it mean
00:54:55or what meaning
00:54:57can at a moment
00:54:58given to have
00:54:59the fact that
00:55:00the Virgin Mary
00:55:01has had
00:55:02naturally
00:55:03or not naturally
00:55:04to Jesus
00:55:05is about what
00:55:06now
00:55:07extends
00:55:08We'll see.
00:55:08a little further on
00:55:09in one of our
00:55:10talks
00:55:11where we will see
00:55:12the new ones
00:55:12Marian developments
00:55:13how progress is being made
00:55:15there
00:55:15to treat
00:55:16to be defined
00:55:16look
00:55:17two thousand years
00:55:19and still
00:55:21There are topics
00:55:21controversial
00:55:22on this topic
00:55:23of virginity
00:55:24TRUE
00:55:25because today
00:55:26People wonder
00:55:27and says
00:55:28Well
00:55:28and the placenta
00:55:30the placenta
00:55:31Yeah
00:55:32the placenta
00:55:32What will we do?
00:55:33with the placenta
00:55:34so
00:55:38the placenta
00:55:38Yes, it came out
00:55:39naturally
00:55:39No
00:55:40they wonder
00:55:42Well
00:55:43and then
00:55:43first of all
00:55:44this problem
00:55:46that we have
00:55:46with brothers
00:55:47separated
00:55:47and all these people
00:55:48well we say
00:55:49and then
00:55:50if you don't have
00:55:52placenta
00:55:53so
00:55:55how it grew
00:55:55in there
00:55:56He's not a child
00:55:57normal
00:55:57He's not a child
00:55:58like us
00:55:59Yeah?
00:56:00they fix
00:56:00I mean
00:56:00logic begins
00:56:01to develop
00:56:03new points
00:56:04of
00:56:04for reflection
00:56:06where you ask yourself
00:56:07wow
00:56:08and then
00:56:08that's how it appeared
00:56:09says
00:56:10hey
00:56:10and everything else
00:56:11that is inside
00:56:11so that the child
00:56:12is formed
00:56:12Wow
00:56:14because I hadn't thought about it
00:56:15in that
00:56:15Well, think about it.
00:56:16think about it
00:56:18and well
00:56:19the investigation
00:56:20on this topic
00:56:21now continue
00:56:22on the topic
00:56:23of
00:56:23what should we
00:56:24understand
00:56:25for virginity
00:56:26life
00:56:26that
00:56:27what situations
00:56:28could
00:56:29affect
00:56:30the mystery
00:56:30of the church
00:56:31and the mystery
00:56:31of Mary
00:56:32if we
00:56:33let's say
00:56:34who was born
00:56:34naturally
00:56:36how they are born
00:56:37all the children
00:56:38this
00:56:38what implications
00:56:39would have
00:56:40for the church
00:56:40and well
00:56:41well there
00:56:43We theologians are here
00:56:45working
00:56:45or trying
00:56:46of working
00:56:47on this topic
00:56:48No?
00:56:49what does it say
00:56:50Densinger 503
00:56:52the statement
00:56:53look
00:56:53in its conciseness
00:56:54from this
00:56:54And that's why
00:56:54the topic
00:56:55of virginity
00:56:55life
00:56:56well still
00:56:57go on
00:56:57well
00:56:58circulating
00:56:59TRUE?
00:57:00Now, on the topic
00:57:01of Mary Ever Virgin
00:57:03that has gone
00:57:04developing
00:57:05through
00:57:05of the sister
00:57:07Connie
00:57:07who has returned
00:57:08to put
00:57:09in the arena
00:57:11the topic
00:57:11because before
00:57:13one said
00:57:14perpetual virginity
00:57:15I'll tell you about it
00:57:16when I studied
00:57:17the doctorate
00:57:17that my topic
00:57:18it is precisely
00:57:19this
00:57:19of virginity
00:57:20of Mary
00:57:21Well, one of them said
00:57:23something like this
00:57:23and no man
00:57:24It was raining on him
00:57:24but by theologians
00:57:26and for all
00:57:26I mean
00:57:27It's a topic
00:57:27today
00:57:28complicated
00:57:29I mean
00:57:29No
00:57:30as I was saying
00:57:31right now
00:57:31And how do you explain it?
00:57:32this
00:57:33well it is
00:57:34complicated
00:57:35so
00:57:36because the definition
00:57:39dogmatic
00:57:39Look at what it says
00:57:40the definition
00:57:40dogmatic
00:57:41in canon 3
00:57:44of this
00:57:45this council
00:57:47that we are
00:57:48right now saying
00:57:49Lateran
00:57:50It says the following
00:57:51if anyone
00:57:53does not confess
00:57:54OK
00:57:54with the saints
00:57:55parents
00:57:55properly
00:57:56and according to
00:57:57TRUE
00:57:57by mother
00:57:58of God
00:57:59to the saint
00:57:59and always
00:58:00virgin
00:58:01and intact
00:58:02Maria
00:58:02However you want
00:58:03that conceived
00:58:04in the last
00:58:05time
00:58:05without semen
00:58:06by work
00:58:07of the Holy Spirit
00:58:08to the same
00:58:08God
00:58:09verb
00:58:10own
00:58:11and truly
00:58:12than before
00:58:13of all centuries
00:58:14born of God
00:58:15father
00:58:15incorruptible
00:58:16he fathered him
00:58:17remaining
00:58:18inviolate
00:58:19even after
00:58:20of childbirth
00:58:21her virginity
00:58:21be condemned
00:58:23oh ok
00:58:26Those who refuse to believe
00:58:30paint yourself in colors
00:58:32Okay
00:58:32bye
00:58:32Hey, but
00:58:35Enough
00:58:36by not leaving
00:58:42that was precisely it
00:58:43well
00:58:44my idea
00:58:44to do
00:58:45my doctoral thesis
00:58:46well try
00:58:47to do
00:58:47a proposal
00:58:49from
00:58:49some perspective
00:58:51biblical
00:58:51theological
00:58:52try to explain
00:58:53and give it elements
00:58:54so that they don't say
00:58:55Well, whoever doesn't want to
00:58:55believe
00:58:56Enough
00:58:56Oh
00:58:57bye
00:58:57well
00:59:01We believe it
00:59:02TRUE?
00:59:04but
00:59:05How do I discuss it?
00:59:07How do I hold it?
00:59:11I am being held
00:59:12only
00:59:12by
00:59:13Yeah
00:59:14the tradition
00:59:15of the church
00:59:15And that's what we believe.
00:59:16And so it is
00:59:18But there has to be
00:59:20elements, right?
00:59:21We have to look for them
00:59:22we've taken a while
00:59:24two thousand years
00:59:24and we haven't even scratched the surface
00:59:25enough
00:59:26We must continue
00:59:26scratching
00:59:27for the first dogma
00:59:29four centuries
00:59:33for the first dogma
00:59:35in thirteen
00:59:37and the following dogma
00:59:39two centuries
00:59:41almost three
00:59:42for the following dogma
00:59:46up to eighteen hundred
00:59:50fifty-four
00:59:51passed
00:59:54nineteen centuries
00:59:56to arrive at a definition
00:59:59that Mary
01:00:00is immaculate
01:00:02nineteen centuries
01:00:05of theological work
01:00:06nineteen centuries
01:00:08of speculation
01:00:09nineteen centuries
01:00:11to fight
01:00:11against the text
01:00:13so
01:00:14obviously
01:00:15It seriously affects
01:00:17of Romans
01:00:18three twenty-nine centuries
01:00:20three twenty-three
01:00:20all sinned
01:00:22all
01:00:26The scripture tells you so.
01:00:27and who are they all?
01:00:29well everyone
01:00:30TRUE?
01:00:31hey
01:00:31And then they ask him
01:00:33to Saint Augustine
01:00:33all sinned
01:00:35Yeah
01:00:35except Maria
01:00:36That's how he responds
01:00:38Saint Thomas
01:00:42It also fails to achieve
01:00:44to arrive at a definition
01:00:46to a conclusion
01:00:48Yeah?
01:00:48century
01:00:49We are in the century
01:00:50thirty
01:00:51of thirteen
01:00:52does not reach conclusions
01:00:53valid
01:00:54and it doesn't explain
01:00:55Saint Thomas
01:00:57TRUE?
01:00:58We're going to have to wait
01:01:00still one more century
01:01:02when
01:01:03dunce escoto
01:01:04we are now
01:01:04in one thousand three hundred and five
01:01:06TRUE?
01:01:06will contribute now
01:01:08definitely
01:01:09to development
01:01:10introducing the topic
01:01:11of redemption
01:01:12is called
01:01:13preservative redemption
01:01:15Yeah?
01:01:17I mean
01:01:17like God
01:01:18He lives in eternity
01:01:19so
01:01:21What will God be?
01:01:23all sinned
01:01:24very good
01:01:25all sinned
01:01:26and all
01:01:26says Saint Paul
01:01:27in this text
01:01:28of Romans
01:01:29six twenty-three
01:01:30I say this
01:01:31three twenty-three
01:01:33It says everyone has sinned
01:01:34very good
01:01:35all sinned
01:01:36and also the Virgin
01:01:37that's where it comes in
01:01:37well yes
01:01:39well too
01:01:40there
01:01:40I say no
01:01:41There are no more
01:01:41It's all
01:01:42He says it very well.
01:01:43and they need
01:01:46of redemption
01:01:46says Pablo
01:01:47all
01:01:48Did the Virgin need
01:01:49be redeemed?
01:01:50Yeah
01:01:51Oh, look what he did!
01:01:52look
01:01:52the
01:01:53introspection
01:01:57and the grace of God
01:01:58about this man
01:01:59dunce escoto
01:02:00says
01:02:00God in his eternity
01:02:03take the credit
01:02:06of Christ
01:02:07Yeah?
01:02:08his death and resurrection
01:02:09which is what redeems us
01:02:10and resumes
01:02:13the merits
01:02:13redeemers of Christ
01:02:15with which he will redeem
01:02:16Adam
01:02:17and from Adam
01:02:18to everyone
01:02:19and applies them
01:02:21at the moment
01:02:23of conception
01:02:24Mary was redeemed
01:02:27Yeah
01:02:27at the moment
01:02:28of its conception
01:02:29so
01:02:31she
01:02:32It no longer has
01:02:33in itself
01:02:34original sin
01:02:36because of that sin
01:02:37that although by nature
01:02:40received
01:02:40is redeemed
01:02:42through Christ
01:02:43but at the moment
01:02:44of its conception
01:02:45in all of us
01:02:46until baptism
01:02:47Yeah?
01:02:50until baptism
01:02:51is
01:02:51is received
01:02:52That opens
01:02:54Pum!
01:02:55opened the door
01:02:56in order to be able to
01:02:57keep moving forward
01:02:58in the process
01:03:00from the reflection
01:03:01theological
01:03:02This caused
01:03:04many
01:03:06many
01:03:07issues
01:03:07litigation
01:03:09divisions
01:03:11especially
01:03:12on the topic
01:03:13how it is transmitted
01:03:15original sin
01:03:16Because that's the issue.
01:03:17TRUE?
01:03:18going so far as to say
01:03:19that is transmitted
01:03:20through sexual intercourse
01:03:21so
01:03:23well everyone
01:03:24like everyone else
01:03:25We come from a relationship
01:03:26sexual
01:03:27then
01:03:27We all have
01:03:28sin
01:03:29It is a vision
01:03:30very negative
01:03:31very negative
01:03:33on the topic
01:03:34of sex
01:03:35No?
01:03:35But that's how it is
01:03:36it was built
01:03:37all this
01:03:38century after century
01:03:40year after year
01:03:41where they see
01:03:43that in the middle
01:03:44at the crossroads
01:03:45There is our
01:03:46Holy Mother
01:03:47always
01:03:48with a
01:03:49with a theme
01:03:50controversial
01:03:51problematic
01:03:52because of the topic
01:03:53of being
01:03:54in the situation
01:03:55of being
01:03:56of being
01:03:58completely
01:03:59well
01:04:00united
01:04:01to the mystery
01:04:02of Christ
01:04:02will arrive
01:04:04finally
01:04:05to be defined
01:04:07in 1854
01:04:12of
01:04:12in
01:04:121516
01:04:17for anyone who wants
01:04:17have around
01:04:18the number
01:04:19TRUE?
01:04:22sorry
01:04:232803
01:04:24says
01:04:28to honor
01:04:29to the saint
01:04:30and undivided
01:04:30trinity
01:04:31for glory
01:04:32and ornament
01:04:33of the Virgin
01:04:33Mary of God
01:04:34for exaltation
01:04:35of the Catholic faith
01:04:36and do
01:04:37and to growth
01:04:38of religion
01:04:39Christian
01:04:39with the authority
01:04:41of our Lord
01:04:41Christ
01:04:42and of the blessed
01:04:44apostles
01:04:44Peter and Paul
01:04:45and with ours
01:04:47we declare
01:04:48we proclaim
01:04:49and we define
01:04:50that the doctrine
01:04:51that supports
01:04:52that the most blessed
01:04:53Virgin Mary
01:04:54was preserved
01:04:55immune
01:04:55from all stain
01:04:56of the guilt
01:04:57original
01:04:57in the first instant
01:04:59There it is
01:05:00where it recaps
01:05:01the topic
01:05:02of duncescot
01:05:04in the first instant
01:05:07of its conception
01:05:08by singular grace
01:05:10and privilege
01:05:10of God
01:05:11omnipotent
01:05:11in attention
01:05:12to merit
01:05:13of Christ
01:05:14Jesus
01:05:15savior
01:05:15of the genre
01:05:16human
01:05:16It has been revealed
01:05:18Oh my god
01:05:18and it must be
01:05:19therefore
01:05:20firm
01:05:20and constantly
01:05:21believed
01:05:21by all
01:05:22the faithful
01:05:23so
01:05:24with this
01:05:25with this
01:05:26bulla
01:05:28TRUE
01:05:29of the Immaculate
01:05:30conception
01:05:31of Pio
01:05:31of Pius IX
01:05:33TRUE
01:05:33which is known
01:05:34like the
01:05:35ineffable
01:05:35deus
01:05:36in 1854
01:05:38well finally
01:05:40is left over
01:05:40already
01:05:41defined
01:05:431853
01:05:45remains completely
01:05:46definite
01:05:47the topic
01:05:48of the Immaculate
01:05:49conception
01:05:50but still
01:05:53we didn't finish
01:05:54They're going to have
01:05:56what to happen
01:05:57still
01:05:58more centuries
01:06:00until the century
01:06:01past
01:06:0220th century
01:06:04in the century
01:06:0620
01:06:07Let's go now
01:06:08to have
01:06:09the
01:06:10encyclical
01:06:11in 1950
01:06:13what is
01:06:16the
01:06:16munifientisimus
01:06:17deus
01:06:18in which
01:06:19finally
01:06:20Pius 12
01:06:21well then
01:06:21declares
01:06:22that
01:06:23the Virgin
01:06:24Maria
01:06:25was
01:06:25alleged
01:06:26to heaven
01:06:26two thousand
01:06:28years
01:06:29a belief
01:06:32coming
01:06:33from the beginning
01:06:34of Christianity
01:06:35I don't waste time
01:06:37with all the development
01:06:38of these two dogmas
01:06:40TRUE
01:06:40But look
01:06:42you
01:06:43that
01:06:44have passed
01:06:46many years
01:06:47research
01:06:48theological
01:06:49developmental
01:06:50of jobs
01:06:51in order to be able to
01:06:53arrive
01:06:53to be defined
01:06:55this
01:06:55these two
01:06:57two topics
01:06:58that they have
01:06:59what to see
01:06:59not so much anymore
01:07:01with themes
01:07:02Christological
01:07:03but
01:07:04these two
01:07:05definitions
01:07:06They have to do
01:07:07with definitions
01:07:08ecclesiastical
01:07:09or ecclesiological
01:07:11because
01:07:12the
01:07:12the
01:07:13the most pure
01:07:15conception
01:07:16He tells us
01:07:17of that state
01:07:19original of man
01:07:20how man
01:07:21was created
01:07:21and the possibility
01:07:23that had
01:07:23of not sinning
01:07:24And so it should be
01:07:26the Christian
01:07:26That's how it should be
01:07:27our church
01:07:28Maria
01:07:29image
01:07:29of the church
01:07:30and finally
01:07:31the assumption
01:07:32Well, that's the vision.
01:07:33of the church
01:07:34in the sky
01:07:35again
01:07:36a topic
01:07:37ecclesiological
01:07:38issues
01:07:39long
01:07:40that have passed
01:07:41along
01:07:41of all centuries
01:07:43this
01:07:44monofontisimus
01:07:45deus
01:07:45of
01:07:46Pius 12
01:07:48this
01:07:48in it
01:07:49Densinger
01:07:503903
01:07:52I read them
01:07:53the latter
01:07:54element
01:07:55for that purpose
01:07:56to conclude
01:07:57already our
01:07:57reflection
01:07:58that's why
01:07:59for glory
01:08:00of God
01:08:00omnipotent
01:08:01that granted
01:08:02his particular
01:08:03benevolence
01:08:04to the Virgin
01:08:04Maria
01:08:05for honor
01:08:06of his son
01:08:06immortal king
01:08:07of the centuries
01:08:08and victorious
01:08:09of sin
01:08:10and of death
01:08:10for increase
01:08:11of glory
01:08:12of the same
01:08:13August mother
01:08:13and joy
01:08:14and recollection
01:08:15of the whole church
01:08:16by the authority
01:08:17of our Lord
01:08:18Christ
01:08:19of the blessed
01:08:20apostles
01:08:21Peter and Paul
01:08:22and our
01:08:23we proclaim
01:08:24we declare
01:08:24and we define
01:08:25to be dogma
01:08:26divinely revealed
01:08:28that the immaculate
01:08:29Mother of God
01:08:30ever virgin
01:08:31Maria
01:08:31course completed
01:08:33of his life
01:08:33land
01:08:34was assumed
01:08:35in body
01:08:35and soul
01:08:36to glory
01:08:37from the sky
01:08:37is left over
01:08:38definite
01:08:39already through the church
01:08:40with this bull
01:08:41that she
01:08:42well
01:08:43what he has believed
01:08:44the church
01:08:44along
01:08:45two thousand years old
01:08:46That's the truth
01:08:47I mean
01:08:48she
01:08:48did not stay
01:08:50among us
01:08:51she was
01:08:51alleged
01:08:52to heaven
01:08:53if you look closely
01:08:54It's a topic
01:08:54that now
01:08:55also
01:08:56in the new
01:08:57developments
01:08:57touch
01:08:58and died
01:09:00They buried her
01:09:05Well
01:09:06These are the topics
01:09:08that
01:09:09well
01:09:10now
01:09:10have
01:09:11No
01:09:11that we have
01:09:12that follow
01:09:12moving forward
01:09:13but already
01:09:14under a
01:09:14definition
01:09:15dogmatic
01:09:16not anymore
01:09:17not anymore
01:09:17this
01:09:18well
01:09:18let's see
01:09:19what does it say
01:09:19yes
01:09:20but
01:09:20etc.
01:09:21I tell them
01:09:21herein
01:09:22I don't anymore
01:09:22I entertain
01:09:23because it's obvious
01:09:23time
01:09:24to go
01:09:25moving forward
01:09:26as they say
01:09:26the others
01:09:27two dogmas
01:09:27that they have
01:09:28what to see
01:09:28with situations
01:09:29Christological
01:09:30and these two
01:09:31dogmas
01:09:32that they have
01:09:32what to see
01:09:33with situations
01:09:34ecclesiological
01:09:35well I advanced them
01:09:36quickly
01:09:37nothing else
01:09:37to give them
01:09:38a panoramic view
01:09:39how
01:09:40the reflection
01:09:41theological
01:09:42about the Virgin
01:09:42Maria
01:09:43It is a process
01:09:44unfinished
01:09:45It's a mystery
01:09:46so big
01:09:47when I start
01:09:48the class
01:09:48in the seminar
01:09:50I tell them
01:09:50Let's get closer
01:09:52with reverence
01:09:54and fear
01:09:55to the mystery
01:09:56of Mary
01:09:56because we
01:09:57we found
01:09:58facing an abyss
01:09:59in the mystery
01:10:01of Mary
01:10:02It's something
01:10:02that still
01:10:03we didn't finish
01:10:04to delve deeper
01:10:05to know
01:10:06to understand
01:10:08for our
01:10:09own
01:10:10for our
01:10:10own life
01:10:11and for life
01:10:12of the church
01:10:12so
01:10:13the developments
01:10:14Mariology
01:10:16continues to advance
01:10:17we'll talk
01:10:17of it
01:10:18in our next
01:10:19meeting
01:10:20in order to be able to
01:10:21grasp
01:10:22now
01:10:22which are
01:10:23the topics
01:10:24theological
01:10:25that they have
01:10:26what to see
01:10:26with this situation
01:10:27the relationship
01:10:28with the brothers
01:10:29separated
01:10:30the relationship
01:10:31with the Muslims
01:10:32which is very interesting
01:10:33this topic
01:10:34of the relationship
01:10:34with the Muslims
01:10:36we'll see
01:10:37well some
01:10:38of these elements
01:10:39that still
01:10:40well, they have remained
01:10:41earrings
01:10:42TRUE?
01:10:42in all dogmas
01:10:44perhaps the least
01:10:45I would be
01:10:46that of divine motherhood
01:10:48but in all other respects
01:10:49if you look closely
01:10:50well, they're becoming available
01:10:51things that don't remain
01:10:53completely clear
01:10:54and?
01:10:55It is mission
01:10:56of us
01:10:56the theologians
01:10:57then continue
01:10:58digging
01:10:59and trying
01:11:00to offer you
01:11:01to the church
01:11:01proposals
01:11:02solutions
01:11:03and she
01:11:04who is in charge
01:11:05to discern
01:11:05if we're okay
01:11:06or we're throwing
01:11:07for the mountain
01:11:08well finally
01:11:09gradually incorporating it
01:11:10to the doctrine
01:11:12official
01:11:12of the church
01:11:13everyone else
01:11:14things
01:11:15things that I can say
01:11:16that will be my thought
01:11:18theological
01:11:19that I try
01:11:20that it is
01:11:20the most logical thing
01:11:21and the closest thing
01:11:22to everything that is
01:11:23already proposed
01:11:24through the church
01:11:25but it is still
01:11:26the thought
01:11:27of the father
01:11:28that is always subject
01:11:30and subjected
01:11:30to the scrutiny
01:11:32of the church
01:11:32It is not a
01:11:34definition
01:11:35on behalf of
01:11:35of the church
01:11:36And this is our mission.
01:11:37of the theologians
01:11:38propose
01:11:39that the church
01:11:40then study
01:11:40unload
01:11:41delve deeper
01:11:42and that God may reveal to him
01:11:43if around there
01:11:44We need to keep moving forward
01:11:46and try to reach
01:11:47to definitions
01:11:47clearer
01:11:48about this
01:11:49mystery
01:11:50immense
01:11:51of the Virgin Mary
01:11:52which precisely
01:11:53that's why
01:11:53it becomes
01:11:54in a woman
01:11:55controversy
01:11:56and often
01:11:58well
01:11:58controversial
01:11:59and
01:12:01and
01:12:02Thanks for watching the video.