00:00Dear viewers, a former BJP spokesperson has just been recommended to become a judge in the Bombay
00:06High Court. Yes, a political spokesperson. Her name is advocate R.P. Arun Sathe and the move
00:13has triggered an outrage. Hello, I'm Tejas and you're watching Honest Take on Lokmat Times.
00:18In today's episode, we are asking the real question. Should judges ever be politically
00:23appointed? But before we move ahead, please do subscribe to our channel if you haven't already
00:28and press the bell icon to never miss an update. So let's break this down. On July 28, 2025,
00:34the Supreme Court Collegium recommended advocate R.P. Arun Sathe, Ajit Kadehankar and Sushil
00:39Ghodeswar for appointment as judges to the Bombay High Court. But Sathe's name lit the match because
00:46R.P. Sathe was the official spokesperson of the BJP's Maharashtra unit as recently as 2023.
00:52She resigned in January 2024, a year and a half before this appointment. That's the timeline.
00:57Now, the BJP says, what's the problem? She resigned. The opposition says, a year and a half
01:03isn't a clean slate. Rohit Pawar from the NCB called it a blow to democracy. Congress termed it
01:09mockery of the constitution. They are asking the question many of us are thinking. How can someone
01:15who defended political decisions on prime time news be trusted to judge those very decisions from the
01:21bench? Now, let's be clear. This isn't a question about advocate Aarti Sathe's legal capability.
01:27It's about perception, trust and the invisible influence of political loyalty. Here is where
01:32it gets interesting. This isn't the first time India's judiciary has seen people walk in straight
01:38from the political corridors. Take Justice Baharul Islam, a Congress MP, twice elected to the Rajya
01:43Sabha. In 1972, he quit Parliament and was immediately appointed as a High Court judge. No prior judicial
01:50experience. By 1980, he was in the Supreme Court. And guess what? One of the last judgments before
01:56quitting the bench exonerated a Congress Chief Minister in corruption cases. Weeks later, he contested
02:02election again as a Congress candidate. If that's not a political back and forth, what is? Then there is
02:08Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, a CPI leader, former Kerala minister, and one of the most revered judges in
02:14India's history. He brought humanity to judgments. But his political past was deep. He moved from
02:20active CPI politics to the bench in just a few years. Justice K.S. Hegde, Congress MP, later Speaker of the
02:26Lok Sabha under the Janata Party. But in between, Supreme Court judge. Justice Aftab Alam, ex-CPI leader,
02:33later with Congress, then appointed judge. Justice F.I. Rebello, former Janata Party MLA, became Bombay
02:39High Court judge, and later Chief Justice of Allahabad High Court. And our current Chief Justice,
02:44B.R. Gavai, he himself acknowledged his family's deep Congress ties. His father was an MP, governor,
02:50and a lifelong congressman. His brother is still active in Congress politics. These are not fringe cases.
02:56These are names of some of the top names in Indian judicial history. Let's be honest, not everyone who once
03:03held a political post is automatically corrupt. Some of these judges gave landmark verdicts and earned
03:09public respect. But that's not the point here. The issue is this. If justice must not only be done,
03:15but must also be seen to be done, then how do we explain these revolving door between politics and
03:20the bench? Why should someone trust the judiciary to rule against the party they once served? It's not
03:26just about bias. It's about public perception, trust, legitimacy, and timing matters. Aarti Satay left
03:32BJP in 2024. That's not decades ago. That's just 19 months ago. Is that enough time for political
03:38loyalties to fade away? Now let's talk process. India doesn't have political appointments on paper.
03:44Judges are appointed through the Collegium system. A closed door system where senior judges recommend
03:50names. This was supposed to protect judicial independence from political interference.
03:54But here is the problem. When someone with recent political links gets through, it raises questions.
04:00Was there due diligence? Was there political pressure? Was this appointment just merit-based?
04:05And worst of all, why don't we, the public, get to know any of this in advance? The Collegium doesn't
04:12publish minutes. It doesn't offer explanations. So even if the process is clean, it looks opaque.
04:18And that's where the rot begins, in perception. Let's zoom out. In most democracies, politicians can
04:24become judges only after a clear cooling off period. In some countries, it's five years. Others mandate
04:30public vetting, background checks, and confirmation hearings. In India, you can resign from a party and
04:36get recommended within the same year. No mandatory gap. No law to prevent it. So we rely on propriety.
04:42But here is the thing. Propriety doesn't enforce itself. We need hard rules, not just soft ethics.
04:49A mandatory cooling off period. If you have held political office or represented a party publicly,
04:54you must wait before entering the judiciary. Collegium transparency. Let people see why a name
05:00was picked or rejected. A public disclosure norm for candidates. Not just assets, but political
05:06affiliations. And above all, courage from judges. Courage to say no to political nominees. Courage to
05:13recuse when personal links exist. And the current CJI BR Gavai did it. When a case related to Congress
05:19leader Rahul Gandhi came to his bench, he recused saying his family has ties to the Congress. That's
05:26honesty. That's integrity. But sadly, not all the judges have it. Dear viewers, this debate is not
05:31about advocate Aarti Sathe alone or about the BJP or Congress or the left. It's about the boundary line
05:38between justice and politics and how thin it is becoming. We have seen what happens when politicians
05:43become judges. And we have seen what happens when judges become politicians. So maybe the real question
05:49is this. Not whether they can, but whether they should. Because every time a politically connected
05:55person gets a judge's chair, the courtroom gets a little quieter. The public trust gets a little
06:00weaker. And the constitution gets a little blurrier. That was the honest take with me, Tejas. We will
06:05leave the verdict to you, the viewer. Until next time, stay sharp, stay curious and never stop asking your
06:11questions.