- 11 months ago
The top focus of this episode of 5 Live is on North India's severe air pollution crisis. Despite deteriorating air quality in the national capital, the Winter Session of the Parliament ended with no debate on pollution.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Pollution not a priority for parliamentarians.
00:09Parliament adjourned with no debate on pollution.
00:20All important matters government is ready to discuss and also to find out solution.
00:26Taking along the suggestions from all the members including the principal opposition party led by Raul Gandhiji.
00:34Discussion promised but never materialized.
00:42MPs say environment not conducive for debate.
00:51Capital chokes and leaders pass the buck.
00:55The producer of Delhi was a PR activity for them.
01:02And they will not save their rights.
01:05We don't want to do the rights of our children.
01:09Delay, distraction and denier.
01:12Delhi airpocalypse.
01:22That is our top focus on 5 Live.
01:24Hi there, I'm Sonal Mehrotra Kapoor.
01:34This is 5 Live.
01:36Another day.
01:37Another hour.
01:38And no discussion.
01:39No plan of action on pollution.
01:41For the past 2 months continuously on this program we've been talking about how pollution is taking away your and my life breath by breath.
01:51Slowly but surely.
01:53We've got doctors on the program who say well it is going to strip away years of your life and even make the quality of your life poor.
02:03We also urge the politicians, question them, sometimes grill them as well to try and get some answers.
02:08But so far none.
02:09Zero.
02:10Zero.
02:11Zero hours were dedicated.
02:13Zero minutes were dedicated by the parliamentarians to discuss the issue of pollution.
02:18And here we are.
02:20Today again, pollution remains to be in the very poor category.
02:23In fact, the entire of 2025, barring this last week which is left now, has not seen a single day of good air.
02:33Not a single day that we should be breathing.
02:36Is this what the fourth largest democracy economy is going to really, should be giving its citizens?
02:44Isn't this the top priority that the government should be looking at?
02:48Well, we'll be looking at it.
02:50That's our top focus here on Five Live.
02:52First up, the headlines at this hour.
02:56It's official now.
02:57Pollution is not a priority for our parliamentarians.
02:59The winter session of the parliament has officially ended with no debate on pollution.
03:03Both houses of parliament have been adjourned, synodined, without any discussion taking place on the issue of pollution.
03:10Chocking visuals of psychopath kicking a child in Bengaluru has now gone viral, triggering outrage among citizens.
03:16Now also, residents are demanding arrest of the accused who was let off on bail.
03:23Parliamentarians did find the time to pass the new jobs bill.
03:27The Jiramji bill has been passed in Rajasabha as well and now awaits the president's nod.
03:32But opposition has kept up its protest.
03:36Rahul Gandhi said 20 years of Mandreka have been demolished in one sweep.
03:41Violent anti-Hasina and anti-India protests have gripped Bangladesh.
03:48Vandalization, arson has seen many cities in Bangladesh after the death of an anti-India leader, Sharif Usman Hadi.
03:57Karnataka Chief Minister Sidira Maya and several key Congress leaders gathered for a dinner hosted by Minister Satish Jarkiholi.
04:06The dinner meeting has sparked now speculations amid the ongoing power tussle between the ruling Congress over the CM post.
04:13Ahead of 2026 Assembly polls, Tamil Nadu is witnessing an all-out war of words between Vijay's TVK, DMK and EPS-led AIADMK after Vijay hit out at the DMK during his rally at Arud.
04:30And DMK and AIADMK have now gone all guns blazing at TBK.
04:37After Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar was seen pulling off a woman's hijab, PDP leader Mufti has now sought registration of an FIR against him.
04:46Meanwhile, the Union Minister Giriraj Singh has defended him saying that CM did nothing wrong.
04:51A political firestorm has erupted in West Bengal after Trinamul Congress MLA Madan Mitra allegedly claimed that Lord Ram was a Muslim and did not have a surname, triggering fierce backlash from the BJP.
05:06Names of key global figures have emerged in the Epstein files after US House Democrats released more photographs linked to the late sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
05:21The photo actually includes Bill Gates, Steve Bannon and other high-profile figures as well.
05:27The European Union leaders have stuck a deal to give Ukraine a loan of $105 billion after failing to agree on using frozen Russian assets.
05:44All right.
05:45Exactly one week ago, Parliament had said that they promised to debate on pollution.
05:51Leaders across party lines agreed in Lok Sabha that Delhi's air crisis demanded urgent discussion.
05:58That debate never happened.
06:00It was delayed, it was pushed aside and finally it was quietly dropped.
06:05Parliament has now wrapped up this season.
06:07It was supposed to be the winter session, should have been the pollution session, but no.
06:12Adjourned Cyanidine and the promise to debate, air we breathe, has been conveniently forgotten.
06:17And guess what they said?
06:18The government actually went on to say that environment was not conducive.
06:24What a nasty play of words for holding a discussion on pollution.
06:29And that is why they did not take up the issue.
06:32Inside Parliament, politicians behave as if all is well, while outside the Parliament all is hell.
06:39Instead of responsibility, there is finger pointing, the opposition blames the ruling BJP, the Delhi government blames the previous Amathi Party administration.
06:48When it comes to pollution, everyone has an excuse.
06:52No one has a solution.
06:55Not one leader is willing to own this crisis.
06:58And while they play the BAME game inside Parliament, millions outside continue to choke on toxic air day after day, breath after breath.
07:07This is not politics.
07:09This is a public health emergency.
07:12Question is, when will the government understand that?
07:16Everybody in this House would agree that air pollution, the damage it is doing to our people, is something that we would like to cooperate on.
07:34I think the government should have a discussion in Parliament. We should all have a discussion in Parliament.
07:45All important matters, government is ready to discuss and also to find out a solution, taking along the suggestions from all the members, including the principal opposition party led by Raul Gandhiji.
07:58This was promised to us exactly a week ago.
08:02But like many promises made to us by our netas, this too was unkept.
08:17With both houses being adjourned, the winter session of Parliament is over.
08:22And so is any hope of pollution being debated by the elected representatives of we, the people.
08:31A debate that was originally scheduled at 6pm on Thursday.
08:35Never materialised.
08:41Why can't the pollution happen?
08:43We need to listen to everything.
08:44And while our politicians at the centre ignored the need to discuss our right to breathe, their counterparts at the state took it a step further and continued to pass the buck.
08:57The producer, Delhi is going to ask a PR activity for them.
09:07Why do we want to raise our children's feelings?
09:10If the people in our hearts were twenty, from their hearts and their hearts,
09:15the power of public transport should be fine for Delhi.
09:18The waste management should be fine for Delhi
09:20All this while the daily lives of Delhiites remains impacted
09:25The air quality remains close to the severe mark
09:28And with all doors for discussion shut
09:31Delhiites have no relief in sight anytime soon
09:35Meanwhile, over 150 flights have been cancelled at the Delhi airport today
09:40Airlines including Indigo and Air India have issued travel advisories
09:45With a discussion on pollution unlikely at least until the 2026 budget session
09:52It's official, pollution just isn't the priority of our parliamentarians
09:57Bureau Report, India Today
10:07Sad, sad reality of a nation which is dying breath by breath
10:11But clearly our politicians who can do something about it
10:14Decide to look the other way
10:16Decide to not even recognize it as a problem
10:18Leave apart, come up with a solution
10:20So let's try and understand from these politicians
10:23What exactly do they have in mind?
10:24Joining us next is Saurabh Bharadwaj from the Amadhi Party
10:27Also joining us in a moment will be Neomar Gupta of the BJP
10:31Let me go to Saurabh first
10:33Saurabh Bharadwaj, you have been on the streets
10:36You have been raising the issue of pollution
10:39But the criticism against you is this
10:42That where was all this rage and anger when you were in power?
10:50I think it's a welcome criticism
10:53And like we have always faced media and public scrutiny
10:58When we were in power in Delhi for 10 years
11:01I remember I used to sit in your studios
11:04I used to answer questions
11:06Our chief minister, our deputy chief minister used to answer questions
11:10And we are still here to answer all kinds of questions
11:12One thing we all must understand today is
11:17That this is not just a Delhi issue
11:21If you look at the top 100 most polluted cities across the world
11:28More than 65 cities are from India
11:32And these cities are obviously Delhi, Greater Noida, Ghaziabad, Lucknow, Varanasi, Patna
11:40Cities in Rajasthan
11:42So first thing is that this is not just a Delhi issue
11:47This is an issue which is affecting our generations across North India
11:52And yes, BJP had a very good time in last 10 years
11:59They were very happy with these pollution debates
12:01Because any kind of pollution anywhere in North India
12:05Was there at the step of Arvind Kejriwal
12:10And it was Arvind Kejriwal's job
12:12That he was the one who was responsible for any pollution
12:16Saurabh Bharadaj, would you concede?
12:17I understand what you are saying
12:19I understand what you are saying
12:21I also think that one of the reasons
12:23Aamadi party was thrown out of power
12:25I think, I also think one of the reasons
12:28Why Aamadi party was thrown out of power
12:30Was the issue of pollution
12:31Because people were sick and tired of excuses
12:33I get that
12:34What I am trying to understand today from you is this
12:37Have your MPs in parliament
12:40Done enough on this matter?
12:43Did we hear Aamadi party MPs in parliament
12:46Hold banners, take protests
12:49Go out and say
12:50No, we want a debate on pollution
12:52We want a solution for pollution
12:53I think what you are saying is correct
13:01But the problem is
13:03That we have a kind of a government at centre
13:07Who will not allow
13:09Forget parliamentary debate
13:10Yesterday, there were so many channels
13:13Who had scheduled debates on pollution
13:15And at the last moment
13:18All those debates were cancelled
13:19So we must understand that the kind of government we have in the centre
13:23Forget parliamentary debate
13:25They are not letting even TV debates
13:27I must, you know, appreciate that
13:29You are
13:30How are you saying that I have been doing the debate for the past?
13:32One of the very few anchors
13:32Who are at least talking about it
13:34Every day I have been doing it
13:35Yeah, that's what I am saying
13:40That today anybody and everybody knows Sonal Mehrotra
13:44Because she is among the very few television anchors
13:47Who are possibly taking a big risk at their careers
13:51By, you know, by having debates on pollution
13:54Nobody is talking about it
13:55Nobody wants to talk about it
13:57I don't know what you mean
13:59I don't know what you mean, Saurabh
13:59By saying big risk at career
14:00I think this is basic
14:02I think demanding clean air is basic
14:05Asking questions is basic
14:07And I think we are all just doing that
14:09I don't think it requires applause or criticism
14:12Either way, I don't think it deserves either
14:15I think this is just the job
14:16This is journalism 101
14:17This is basic stuff that we are doing
14:20And I don't, like I said
14:22I don't want criticism
14:23Neither do I want sort of applause for this
14:26I think this is just, you know, bare minimum we can do
14:29But Saurabh, I have to ask you
14:31I have been seeing your videos
14:33That you are going around the streets
14:35You are talking about awareness
14:36You are asking people to do it
14:38Is the same enthusiasm with which Amadi party is approaching
14:42The entire issue of pollution in Delhi
14:45Being taken up in Punjab as well
14:47Because there also, you named the cities
14:49Punjab also has a lot of air pollution
14:51Is the same vigor with which Amadi party is taking it up in Delhi
14:55Are you taking it with the same vigor in Punjab?
14:58Yes
14:58So, I think it is no less than a miracle
15:03That in last four years of our government
15:07In Punjab
15:08We have reduced the stubble burning by 93%
15:13And this is not our data
15:14The central government's commission is saying it
15:18And I think it is a very big thing, you know
15:20Reducing stubble burning by 93%
15:22I think this was the major cause
15:25This was supposedly the major cause
15:26Even we used to think it is a major cause of pollution in Delhi
15:29But now there is no stubble burning happening at all
15:32Across India there is no stubble burning in December
15:35But still we see so much of pollution across North India
15:38I think we must understand that this is something for which the central government and all the state government should come together
15:46And I think parliament was the best place where we could have had such discussion
15:51And central government was very uncomfortable with this discussion
15:55They don't want to participate in such discussion
15:58Because they are the ones who are now planning to, you know, even destroy Aravali mountain ranges
16:03Recently the central government went to the Supreme Court
16:07And they asked to change the definition of Aravali mountain range
16:12Now till now for centuries
16:14Delhi, Punjab, Haryana were protected from being desert
16:19Because of these Aravali mountain ranges
16:21But now they will be destroyed
16:22They will be mining
16:24There will be commercial activities
16:25There will be residential colonies coming up
16:28So I think the government at centre doesn't want to think about environment
16:33They are just commercializing the whole place
16:37That is the basic problem
16:38And these things make them very uncomfortable
16:41And second thing
16:42Why it is bad in Delhi this year
16:46There is a very scientific reason for this
16:48One must understand that why did Supreme Court come up with this graded action response
16:54Which we call it GRAP
16:55Because at certain thresholds
16:58The Supreme Court decided
17:00That at a certain threshold of AQI
17:03We have to curtail certain activities in a city
17:07So that pollution can be controlled
17:09Now what the government in Delhi did
17:12They started manipulating AQI readings
17:15From day one
17:16They wanted to install AQI stations in the forest areas of Delhi
17:20So that AQI can theoretically come down
17:23They started spraying water on the AQI monitoring station
17:26But now GRAP 4 is in place
17:28There is a false narrative that look AQI readings
17:30So what happened?
17:33Now there is GRAP 4
17:35I am coming to it
17:36And I understand that
17:36But can I ask you more fundamental questions Saurabh?
17:39And what are you saying we have done reality checks
17:41We have done all of that
17:41I agree with you
17:43I agree with you
17:44And I am saying
17:45We have done you know reality checks
17:47We understand what you are saying
17:48I want to understand this from you
17:50Do you think Delhiites
17:53Normal citizens
17:54The Ahmad me
17:55If I can call them that
17:56Really cares about pollution so much today
17:59I am trying to understand
18:01Or have we
18:02A majority of people
18:04Just started living with air pollution
18:06As just another inconvenience
18:08Like we live with traffic
18:09Like we live with potholes
18:11Like we live with bad water
18:12We have Delhiites only left the war here
18:15They are only not demanding
18:17Why will the politicians work?
18:19No
18:19No
18:22They are very concerned about pollution
18:24And if you go to any place
18:27You know
18:27You go to a park
18:29You go to a kitty party
18:31You go to a chaiwala ki dukaan
18:34I think everybody
18:35Especially the middle class
18:36And the upper middle class
18:37They are very concerned about this pollution
18:40And they are very concerned
18:42Especially about the elderly
18:44And the kids
18:44Because in last 10 years
18:46Most of the kids
18:48Who are born in last 10 years
18:50Require regular nebulizer
18:52Nebulizer we haven't seen in our generation
18:55You know
18:55We didn't even know
18:56We used to think oxygen
18:57But now
18:58Every home in Delhi
19:00Who can afford
19:01They have a nebulizer
19:03So
19:04This is a big concern
19:06People are very concerned
19:07But the problem is
19:08That people are very scared
19:09To talk about this government
19:10To question this government
19:12Now coming to the graph thing
19:13So the problem with manipulating
19:16AQI sonal is this
19:17That when you have
19:19AQI level of 400
19:20The government is showing it at 200
19:22So the graph
19:23Stage is not triggered
19:25Now you are triggering this
19:27Graph for today
19:29When the government reading is
19:31400
19:32But the actual reading is probably 1000
19:34We don't know
19:35Or probably 800
19:36So all the checks and balances
19:39Which were supposed to be
19:40How do you know it's 800 and 1000
19:41Two months back
19:42I know it because I have a meter
19:44Because I have bought that AQI meter now
19:46Not a thermometer
19:47I have an AQI meter
19:48So with that AQI meter
19:51You can go
19:51You can go to India gate now
19:53I went to India gate just an hour back
19:55At India gate
19:56There is a full on construction activity going on
19:59There is excavation going on
20:00There is a JCB machine
20:01There are hundreds of laborers
20:03Who have you know
20:04Who are just digging mud
20:06There is cement
20:09There are concrete mixers
20:11Everything
20:11You know everything is going around
20:13Just one kilometer away from parliament
20:17So what is graph
20:18Graph is nothing
20:19You know
20:19This is just a sham
20:20I want to conclude now Saurab
20:23And I want to
20:24I want to get something constructive
20:26I want to get something constructive
20:28In the parliament
20:29We heard the opposition come out
20:31And say that
20:32We will work with the government
20:34On the issue of pollution
20:36We will give our support
20:37What is Ahmadi party doing today
20:40To ensure that the government also does
20:43You know
20:43Sort of goes on to do its bit
20:45Any constructive things
20:47That are coming out
20:48From Ahmadi party side
20:49To say that
20:50We will not just use it as a tool
20:52To embarrass you
20:53We will work with you
20:54Are you being that constructive opposition today
20:56One
20:57Yes
20:58So
20:58Very constructive
21:01You know
21:01If they want to have a discussion with us
21:03If they want to take feedback from us
21:05Look whatever they are doing today
21:07Are the same things
21:09Which have been done by us
21:10For last 4-5 years
21:11Except for Evanot
21:12Which they should have triggered
21:13Because of graph 4
21:15Then you should not complain
21:16If it is the same thing
21:17Then you should not complain
21:18But
21:18Anytime
21:20Anytime
21:21No no no
21:22They haven't triggered it at the right time
21:24What they were supposed to do it in October
21:26They are doing it in December
21:28That's why the situation is out of control
21:30You could have managed it in October
21:33By putting restrictions on construction
21:37By putting restrictions on you know
21:39BS6 vehicles
21:40But you did not do it
21:41For political reasons
21:42Because you are more interested in creating a false narrative
21:45That AQI is on lower side
21:47Although AQI was high
21:48That's why you know
21:49So many people are coughing
21:50Doctors are not lying
21:52Hospitals are not lying
21:53Actually there is a grave situation
21:55It's a health emergency
21:56But why would the government do that?
21:57Saurabh help me understand this
21:59If you are right
22:02If you are right
22:03And you say that the government
22:04Is deliberately not doing this
22:06Why do you think that's the case?
22:08It can't be deliberate
22:09How is it deliberate?
22:11Why do you think they are doing it?
22:12Because government is interested in commercial activities
22:13Yes
22:14I am telling you
22:15Look
22:16The government is destroying Uttarakhand
22:18By constructing you know
22:19Four lane highways there
22:20Why?
22:21Because they want commercialization
22:22The government has turned itself
22:24Into a property dealer
22:25They are now a real estate
22:26You know mafia
22:27They want to sell
22:28Everything out and run away
22:30They are doing it in Aravlis
22:32They did it at the center of Delhi
22:34Look
22:34You have been in Delhi for long
22:36We know how Sarojini Nagar
22:38Norojini Nagar was
22:39Ten years back
22:40They were like you know
22:41Sixteen thousand five hundred
22:43Big trees
22:44They cut it all
22:46You know
22:46It has all vanished
22:47They created commercial
22:49You know
22:49Commercial
22:50Cement jungle there
22:52They created residential towers there
22:54All the area has changed today
22:58Now there are you know
22:59Lacks of vehicles
22:59Which are traveling
23:00Right there in the center of Delhi
23:01You have no trees
23:03So basically
23:03You have invited all this
23:05I am not convinced on the numbers of
23:08I am not convinced on the numbers of Bihar crop
23:11Of
23:12Of Punjab crop burning that you have shown
23:14Because now more and more studies are saying
23:16And environmentalists are saying
23:17That those numbers are getting managed as well
23:19But that is a story that we will discuss another day
23:21That is a story we will discuss another day
23:24Thank you so much now for joining us here on 5 Live
23:26We can
23:27I can come again
23:29Sure
23:30Thank you
23:31All right
23:34So that was Amadi Party
23:35Let's get a word from the BJP
23:37Neoma Gupta joins us now
23:38From the BJP
23:40Neoma you just heard the Amadi Party there
23:42They are saying
23:43You have interests of
23:45Of
23:46Real estate people in mind
23:48And that's the reason why
23:49You've
23:49Your commitment towards air pollution
23:51Has been so weak
23:52Because it comes at the cost of construction work
23:55And it comes at the cost of
23:56The transport ministry as well
23:58What do you have to say?
23:59That's a figment of his imagination
24:01Where I don't know where he's getting these thoughts from
24:04Since the time we've come into power
24:05All hands on deck have been taken place
24:07When it comes to steps and measures to curb pollution
24:10Innumerable number of steps
24:12Whether it comes to pothole repair
24:14Paving the roads
24:15Like literally 26-50 kilometers of the roads have been paved
24:18All construction demolition activities were completely banned
24:22Including literally highways, roads, flyovers and power lines
24:25And that's actually economically dysfunctional
24:28Because those are all budgets which are kept within timelines
24:30Steps like you know
24:32Can I just request my producers to put out the
24:35You know the test
24:37And the reality check that our reporters have done yesterday
24:40Of how Grap is being flouted
24:41Look at those visuals and then tell me
24:43And then tell me that construction has stopped
24:45Yeah so you know
24:47Just to tell you
24:48They showed it to us yesterday
24:49When we were on debate
24:50And we have flagged
24:52See you please understand
24:53When we are doing execution
24:54We are doing everything possible
24:57But yes there are certain discrepancies
24:59Which happen on power
25:00By anybody
25:01But those steps
25:02We flagged the ones you showed on TV yesterday
25:05So by pointing out one instant
25:07And just ignoring all the other efforts
25:09Would be belittling us
25:10We are here
25:11As I am repeatedly telling you
25:13By putting every step in the right direction
25:16And we are also seeking the cooperation of citizens
25:19So that this can have a more productive result
25:21And a quicker result
25:22Than one wants it to have
25:24Having said that
25:25Him saying that
25:26Oh we are you know
25:28We are doing it for financial reasons
25:32It's so sad to say
25:34Considering his government failed
25:35Epically 10 years in a row
25:36But not wanting to
25:38Making pollution a political issue
25:41I am here to tell you
25:42That we are fully aware
25:43But you made it a political issue
25:44BJP fought an entire election
25:47BJP constructively got
25:50People of Delhi to vote on pollution
25:52The entire
25:53And I keep saying this
25:54I covered that election
25:55And I can tell you
25:56Amadi party was ousted
25:58They were thrown out of power
25:59People lost deposits etc
26:02Because people said
26:04That Arvind Kejewal makes excuses
26:06BJP saying
26:07They will fix our problem
26:08Because they are at the centre as well
26:10And there will be no more excuses
26:11Why these excuses then?
26:14Okay first of all
26:15Please understand
26:16We are here
26:17Doing what we promised to do
26:19And what was in our manifesto
26:21Which is
26:21Get pollution
26:22Make it a non-debatable topic
26:24If that was the case
26:26Why would we
26:27From the day we came into power
26:29Take extreme steps
26:31Even like
26:31I mean
26:32You know how many potholes were there
26:34Which were accumulating dust
26:35Today 18,000 potholes
26:37Have been taken care of
26:38You think this is only possible
26:40When pollution rises
26:41Or takes time to do such things
26:43Anti-smog guns
26:44I mean
26:45388 anti-smog guns
26:46Are running
26:47Over 5,000 kilometres daily
26:49How much of an increase
26:50Is that from last year?
26:52You said 388
26:53How many of them
26:54Have gone up from last year?
26:55Literally
26:56I have the new
26:57I'll have to take out
26:58The numbers with me
26:59I'll do a comparative for you
27:00When it comes to their sprinklers
27:02And vis-a-vis us
27:04We are literally
27:04Three times more
27:05On the work wing situation
27:07Okay
27:07Even in terms of
27:09Let's say
27:09I told you the roads
27:10They
27:11In their capacity
27:12Over 10 years
27:13Only 68 kilometres
27:15Of road repairs
27:16Have happened
27:16We have done
27:172,650 kilometres
27:20In seven months
27:21So if you want to go on
27:23A comparative status
27:24I'll show it to you
27:25Neoma Gupta
27:25Let's understand air pollution
27:27And let's understand
27:28The science of air pollution
27:29One pothole repair
27:30Will not solve our problem
27:32Of air pollution
27:32I'm sure you are aware
27:33Of that right?
27:34You are a Delhi citizen
27:35You are a Delhi citizen
27:37You are a mother
27:38You have kids
27:39You have read the
27:40You know subject
27:41As much as we have
27:42You understand this right?
27:44Delhi's air pollution problem
27:46Cannot be solved
27:46By fixing potholes
27:48Please stop making it
27:49As a
27:50You know report card
27:51Issue for you
27:52That's hardly an issue
27:53The point is
27:54Where was the winter plan?
27:57Tell me where
27:57Okay let me explain
27:59Something to you
28:00Let me ask you
28:01A very simple question
28:01Where was the winter plan?
28:04You knew winter was coming
28:05You knew this is a problem
28:07That comes every year
28:08Did we see a winter plan
28:10Put out by the Delhi government
28:11That this is what we will do
28:13To ensure it doesn't escalate
28:15To hazardous categories
28:16Yes you cannot solve it
28:18In one year
28:18We agree with you
28:19Yes short term measures
28:20Will be required today
28:21And long term measures
28:22But where is that
28:23Long term measure?
28:24Where is the plan?
28:28Since we've been working
28:29Since the day we came
28:30When you're saying
28:31Roads are a report card issue
28:33That's wrong to say
28:33Because potholes collect dust
28:35Which cause a significant
28:36Part of pollution
28:37When it comes to
28:39Water sprinklers
28:39Mechanical road sweepers
28:41Everything has been ongoing
28:43You're asking me
28:44What have we done?
28:45Increase
28:46Okay you agree to the fact
28:48That legacy waste processing
28:49Is a contributory factor
28:50The waste to energy capacity
28:52Of 7000 tonnes per day
28:54Has been added
28:55And since NCR was affected
28:5760% of PM particle
28:59Particulate matter
29:0060% of pollution
29:02Comes from vehicles
29:04What did you do about that?
29:06The number of
29:0760% comes from there
29:08The number of
29:10E-autos
29:11Each shuttle busses
29:12For last mile connectivity
29:13Has been increased
29:14PS6 compliance
29:16Has taken into place
29:17Halting stone crushers
29:18Mining operations
29:19Across NCR
29:20Closure directions
29:25To even 1556
29:27Non-compliant industrial units
29:29For violation of
29:30Emission and pollution norms
29:31Are you saying
29:32These are non-contributory
29:33Factors to me?
29:34Please try and understand
29:36Everything has to be
29:37Seen in a bubble
29:38So all steps
29:39Which we are identifying
29:41From a scientific perspective
29:42We are taking
29:43And we are continuing
29:44To evolve
29:45Our ways of working
29:46In order to show results
29:48As you correctly said
29:49Results don't happen
29:50Overnight
29:51It's not an extremely
29:52Long-term solution plan
29:54But it is a short-term
29:56Solution plan
29:56To deliver results
29:58Over here
29:58You are mentioning
29:59A statement to me
30:00That no more
30:00Roads don't matter
30:01You are doing a
30:02What?
30:03Report card
30:03If I am not mistaken
30:04Are you trying to tell me
30:06Dust doesn't take
30:06A significant contribution
30:08To pollution?
30:10You know how much
30:11Mechanized sweeping
30:12Vacuum machines
30:13During the day
30:14As well as night
30:15Are preventing suspension
30:16Of dust
30:16Which could have further
30:17Aggravated the pollution?
30:19Public transport
30:20You want to know
30:20Detail?
30:21We increased our budget
30:22To 12,950
30:24I am telling you
30:25Numbers
30:25I want to know
30:26The number
30:26From Awadhi party era
30:27To BJP era
30:28Tell me how much
30:29Of it has increased
30:29Don't say
30:30Random comment
30:31Tell me numbers
30:32Okay let's go on transport
30:33When it came to
30:34An-Mahadhi party
30:35In the financial
30:36Year of 24
30:37They cut their
30:38Transport ministry's
30:39Budget by significant
30:40Margin
30:40They said they would
30:42Bring in 5000
30:42New buses
30:43Instead the number
30:44Of buses reduced
30:45They did nothing
30:46For the last mile
30:47Connectivity
30:47Cut to
30:48I'll tell you
30:49BJP's perspective
30:50We increased
30:51The transport budget
30:52To 12,952
30:54Crores
30:54To be exact
30:55Added 1350 new
30:57E-buses
30:57In 8 months
30:58Almost 2000
30:59To be added
31:00By March 26
31:01We carried out
31:02Route rationalization
31:03Through back
31:04U-buses
31:04After decades
31:06Increased the number
31:07Of E-autos
31:07E-shuttle buses
31:08Heavy metro expansion
31:10In phase 4
31:11Like when it comes
31:13To Indrapasta
31:1312.38 kilometers
31:15Lajpatnagar
31:16Saaket G-block
31:178.39 kilometers
31:1821 kilometers
31:20Of new metro
31:21Let me finish
31:22Listen to me
31:23Miss Gupta
31:23Yet here we are
31:24You are going
31:26Breathless
31:27About all the measures
31:28Which I don't
31:29Have numbers
31:30I'll give you numbers
31:30Yes
31:31But yet here we are
31:32Yet the numbers
31:33Are here
31:33We are careful
31:35We are monitoring
31:36AQI numbers
31:37They haven't dipped
31:37They are the same
31:39So clearly the measures
31:41Are not enough
31:41Okay
31:42Clearly the measures
31:43Are not enough
31:44And you haven't
31:45Answered my question
31:46On where was the plan
31:48There was no
31:49Preparation done
31:50There was no
31:52Plan given out
31:53All these steps
31:54Have happened
31:55Without planning
31:55All these concrete
31:56Steps and numbers
31:57Which you were asking
31:58For have happened
31:59Without planning
32:00Ma'am
32:00I don't think
32:01It works like that
32:02And when it comes
32:03To why the AQI
32:04Has not come down
32:05And why is it
32:05At a spike
32:06Please understand
32:07Delhi has no
32:08Weather system
32:09Of its own
32:09Depending on the
32:11States
32:11We get rain
32:12Smog
32:13Basically all events
32:14Favorable or unfavorable
32:15Thus while we are
32:16Facing smog today
32:17There is no denying it
32:19We are certainly
32:20Still going to tackle it
32:21We must understand
32:23Except that this is
32:24No small
32:24Okay last week
32:26Why was the spike
32:26When the week before
32:27The pollution was less
32:28Can you try and
32:30Explain it to me
32:31The western disturbance
32:32Persisting over
32:34North Pakistan
32:35Which had a sharp
32:36Reduction in wind
32:37Created perfect condition
32:39For small
32:39Climate then we will
32:40Blame everything
32:41Geography
32:41Then we will
32:42Blame everything
32:42I am so sorry
32:43With all due respect
32:44Nobody is blaming
32:45Anybody
32:45My first concept
32:47To you were
32:48Hands on deck
32:49We are taking
32:49Every step
32:50And we will
32:51Continue to take
32:52More and more steps
32:53To ensure
32:54I wish
32:55I wish I could
32:56Believe you
32:56Because
32:57I wish
32:58The MPs
32:59And the government
33:00At the national level
33:01Had taken up
33:02This matter
33:02In parliament
33:03I wish we had
33:05Seen
33:05A winter plan
33:06I wish we had
33:07Seen a more
33:08Proactive government
33:09To say
33:09Okay
33:10Let's not blame
33:11Political parties
33:11Let's work on this
33:12Together
33:13I wish there was
33:14A forum
33:15In which the
33:15Chief ministers
33:16Of Delhi
33:17And Haryana
33:17And Punjab
33:18And UP
33:18And India
33:20At the national level
33:21They had gotten
33:21Together to say
33:22Okay let's fix
33:23The problem now
33:24Because this is
33:24Not a Delhi problem
33:25This is a 60%
33:26Of India problem
33:27This is an air
33:28Emergency that
33:29Requires urgent
33:30Attention
33:30And these numbers
33:32What you are telling
33:32Me and the effort
33:33Right now
33:34Has not worked
33:35Because AQI
33:36It will work
33:37You need to give us
33:38Time
33:38Time is
33:40Time is what
33:41We are losing
33:42With every breath
33:43And time is what
33:44I don't have
33:45On this segment
33:45As well
33:46I have to take a break
33:47And I have to
33:48Thank you there
33:48Ms. Gupta
33:49For coming here
33:50And taking all
33:51Those questions
33:52Visibility in the national capital
33:55Is so low
33:56It feels like our politicians
33:58Cannot even see the obvious
34:00Delhiites are developing
34:01Health conditions
34:02Seen in lifelong smokers
34:04Children are struggling
34:05To breathe
34:06Hospitals are stretched
34:07Doctors warn
34:08Of permanent lung damage
34:11Also permanent damage
34:12To your life
34:13But inside parliament
34:15The response
34:16Will baffle you
34:17In a Rajasabha
34:19In fact
34:20A reply was filed
34:21Minister of State
34:22For Environment
34:23Kirti Vardhan Singh
34:24Said that
34:25Based on the available data
34:26A direct link
34:28Between air quality levels
34:30And lung diseases
34:31Has not
34:33Been firmly established
34:36He is saying
34:38There is no link
34:38Between air pollution
34:40And lung disease
34:41Let that sink in
34:43For a while
34:44This is
34:45Our
34:46Minister of State
34:48For Environment
34:49Kirti Vardhan Singh
34:51While doctors speak
34:53Of shrinking lungs
34:54Fibrosis
34:54Irreversible damage
34:56While health experts
34:57Urge residents
34:58To leave Delhi NCR
34:59If they can
35:00Government says
35:00Science
35:01Is not conclusive
35:02So let's be clear
35:05About what the world's
35:06Most credible
35:07Medical research
35:08Is already telling us
35:10A report by Lancet
35:11Says
35:12One of the most
35:13Lancet of course
35:13One of the most
35:14Respective health journals
35:15In the planet
35:16On the planet
35:17In the world really
35:18Shows that
35:19In 2023
35:20More than 1.5 million
35:22People in India
35:23Died from exposure
35:24To fine particulate matter
35:26Meaning PM 2.5
35:27Making this
35:29One of the biggest killers
35:30In the country today
35:31Science
35:31Could not be clearer
35:33Prolonged exposure
35:34To polluted air
35:36Scars the lungs
35:37Fine particulate matter
35:38PM 2.5
35:39PM 1 as well
35:40Penetrates deep into the lungs
35:41And bloodstream
35:42Triggering chronic
35:43Inflammation
35:44That inflammation
35:45Leads to asthma
35:46COPD
35:47Fibrosis
35:48Heart disease
35:49Premature deaths
35:50The list is
35:51Very very long
35:52Children are growing up
35:54In polluted cities
35:55Those who do show
35:56Stunted lung growth
35:58Adults are losing
35:59Lung capacity
36:00In many cases
36:01By half
36:02And once lung tissues
36:04Harden
36:04It never regenerates
36:06It's not one of those organs
36:07This is not speculation
36:09This is not theory
36:11This is what the evidence
36:12The doctors say
36:13Every day
36:15So when the government
36:16Is asked what to do
36:18To protect people
36:18The answer is not
36:19Emergency action
36:21It is
36:21Awareness booklets
36:23Training programs
36:24And advisories
36:25But alerts
36:26Do not repair lungs
36:27Remember
36:28Forecast
36:29Do not reverse
36:29Fibrosis
36:30And clean cooking fuel
36:32Does not
36:32You know
36:33Does nothing
36:34When the air
36:34Outside is poison
36:36Refusing to acknowledge
36:38A direct link
36:39Is not science
36:41It is delay
36:41Distraction
36:42It is denial
36:44That's the worry
36:46There is no lack
36:48Of data
36:48As we know
36:49There is no
36:50There is perhaps
36:51Lack of political will
36:53To admit the scale
36:54Of this crisis
36:55And do something
36:56About it
36:56That's why
36:58The question
36:58In front of us
36:59Is pretty deadly
37:00Pretty simple
37:01How many more
37:03Will have to die
37:04Before our leaders
37:05Stop treating it
37:06Like an inconvenience
37:08That we've started
37:09Treating air pollution
37:10As just another
37:11Inconvenience
37:12That India lives with
37:13What exactly is happening
37:14If you don't believe us
37:15Listen in from the top
37:17Doctors in the country
37:19Joining me next
37:21Is Dr. Arvind Kumar
37:22He's a leading
37:23Parmenologist
37:24He opens people's lungs
37:26He does surgeries
37:28He also deals with
37:29Lung cancer
37:30Almost on a daily basis
37:31So he really knows
37:32What's going inside
37:33So Dr. Arvind Kumar
37:35I want to understand
37:36From you
37:36The parliament replies
37:38Beyond me
37:39What do you
37:41As one of the
37:43Best pulmonologist
37:44In the country
37:45Feel about this
37:47Reply from the government
37:48Yeah
37:52First of all
37:53Thank you very much
37:53For having me
37:54On the show
37:55Secondly
37:57I would not like
37:59To comment
38:00On what has been
38:01Stated in the parliament
38:03That's probably
38:04Out of my purview
38:05But as a doctor
38:07As a chest surgeon
38:08Who operates
38:10On chest
38:12Every day
38:13And gets a chance
38:15To see
38:15Three to four
38:17Lungs
38:18Every day
38:19For the last
38:2030 years
38:21And has seen
38:22A sea change
38:24In the color
38:25Of the lungs
38:26Of the people
38:27Which is a direct
38:28Impact of air pollution
38:30I would like
38:31To say
38:32That air pollution
38:33Is playing
38:35Havoc
38:36With the health
38:37Of the people
38:37I'll send you
38:39The images
38:39Normally
38:40When we are born
38:42We have
38:42This teen
38:43Pink lungs
38:45Which I rarely
38:46See these days
38:47Even teenagers
38:49When we operate
38:50We find
38:51Black
38:52Black deposits
38:53On their lungs
38:54And this is the image
38:55That you can see
38:57There are black deposits
38:58On the lungs
38:59Of a teenager
39:00And this is the image
39:02Of the lung
39:03Of a non-smoker
39:06From the city
39:07Of Delhi
39:08And you can see
39:09There is hardly
39:10Any normal area
39:12Left in the lungs
39:13I am also
39:15A lung cancer surgeon
39:17And I have seen
39:18The lung cancer
39:19Which used to be
39:20A smoker's disease
39:2225-30 years
39:24Back
39:24Happening
39:26As much
39:26In non-smokers
39:28As in smokers
39:30Today
39:30Number one
39:31And what used
39:32To be a male
39:33Predominant disease
39:3430 years back
39:36Is occurring
39:36Today
39:37In male
39:38As well as female
39:39Especially
39:40Non-smoking female
39:41And is occurring
39:43About 15-20 years
39:45Younger age
39:46Than what it used
39:47To happen
39:48So when
39:49And you ask
39:50Any doctor
39:51Any pediatrician
39:53They will tell
39:54You that these
39:54Days with these
39:55Kind of air
39:56Pollution levels
39:57Our OPDs
39:58Our emergencies
39:59Our wards
40:01Our ICUs
40:01Are flooded
40:03With people
40:04Not only chest
40:05Diseases
40:06People think
40:07That this air
40:08Pollution only
40:09Causes lung diseases
40:10Yes lung diseases
40:11Are in majority
40:13But it also
40:14Causes heart
40:15Attacks
40:15It also
40:16Causes brain
40:17Attacks
40:18And it causes
40:19Whole lot of
40:20Other diseases
40:21Also including
40:22Diabetes
40:23And obesity
40:25There is data
40:26To prove
40:27That each of
40:28These diseases
40:29Is linked
40:30To air pollution
40:31So this is
40:31What I would
40:32Like to submit
40:33As a doctor
40:34Who is seeing
40:36All these diseases
40:37In his clinic
40:38Regularly
40:39Dr. Kumar
40:42Those are
40:43That's a reality
40:45We have known
40:45For a while
40:45We really hope
40:46These words
40:48The reality
40:49You face
40:49Every day
40:50Actually reaches
40:51The government
40:51As well
40:52But let me ask
40:53You this
40:53Year on year
40:54Air pollution
40:55Is not a problem
40:56That has suddenly
40:57Come on us
40:58Right
40:58It's been in the making
40:59For the past
40:5910-20 years
41:00Year on year
41:01Are you seeing
41:02Any change
41:03In your patients
41:05Bodies
41:06On what
41:08Sort of
41:09This extended
41:10Periods of exposure
41:11To polluted air
41:12Is doing to us
41:13Are you seeing
41:15So we have
41:18Increase
41:19In the number
41:20Of patients
41:21Number one
41:22So year on year
41:23If you see
41:24You will find
41:25More and more
41:26Patients coming in
41:27There is a change
41:29In the demography
41:30Of some of the diseases
41:32For example
41:33As I said
41:34Lung cancer
41:35Was virtually unknown
41:37In non-smokers
41:38And today
41:39It is occurring
41:40As much in smokers
41:42As in non-smokers
41:43This is a massive
41:44Change
41:45Which is a cause
41:47For worry
41:47Because if you
41:48Smoke
41:49Earlier we used
41:50To say
41:50Well if you want
41:51To you know
41:53Avoid lung cancer
41:54Don't smoke
41:55But today
41:56The message
41:57Will be
41:57If you want
41:58To avoid
41:58Lung cancer
41:59Stop breathing
42:00So there is a huge
42:05Change in the
42:06Demography
42:07Of serum
42:07Likewise
42:08COPD
42:09Is a disease
42:10Where the lungs
42:11Become kind of
42:12Swollen
42:13And they become
42:14Filled with air
42:15This is a disease
42:17Which was again
42:17Known as
42:18Smoker's disease
42:19Earlier
42:20But these days
42:21We are seeing
42:22Increasing number
42:23Of non-smokers
42:25Especially women
42:26Coming with COPD
42:28So there is
42:29We recently
42:30Curried out
42:31A study
42:32Of the lung
42:33Functions
42:34And lung
42:35Symptoms
42:36Of about
42:364,000
42:37Children
42:38Across 22
42:39Schools
42:40In Delhi
42:41NCR
42:41And were
42:42Horrified
42:43To find
42:44Nearly
42:4460%
42:46Of the
42:46Children
42:47In the
42:47Age
42:48Group
42:4811
42:48To 14
42:49Years
42:50To be
42:51Reporting
42:51Respiratory
42:52Symptoms
42:53Like
42:53Persistent
42:54Cough
42:54Sneezing
42:55Running
42:56Nose
42:56Chest
42:57Pain
42:58Chest
42:58Tightness
42:59Itching
42:59In the
43:00Eyes
43:00Etc
43:01Can you
43:02Believe it
43:0360%
43:04Of the
43:04Children
43:05Reported
43:06These symptoms
43:06To be
43:07Present
43:07And 27%
43:09Of the
43:10Children
43:10Were found
43:11To be
43:12Spirometry
43:13Proved
43:14Asthma
43:15One
43:16Third
43:17Of children
43:18Were having
43:19Spirometry
43:20Proved
43:21Asthma
43:21Though most
43:23Of them
43:23Were not
43:24Aware
43:24And were
43:25Not on
43:26Treatment
43:26So there
43:27Is a
43:27Huge
43:28Amount
43:28Of
43:29Disease
43:29Disability
43:30And even
43:32Premature
43:32Deaths
43:33Which are
43:34Occurring
43:34Out there
43:35Which all
43:36Of us
43:36Doctors
43:37Not me
43:37Alone
43:38All of us
43:39Doctors
43:39Are seeing
43:40It every
43:41Day in our
43:41Clinics
43:42In our
43:42Wards
43:43In our
43:43Emergency
43:44Rooms
43:44All of
43:47You are
43:47Saying it
43:48Data is
43:48Telling us
43:49This
43:49Internationally
43:50People are
43:51Understanding
43:51Why do you
43:52Think our
43:53Politicians
43:53Are not
43:54Understanding
43:54Well I
44:00Can't
44:00Answer that
44:01Question
44:02As a
44:02Doctor
44:02I can
44:03Only
44:04Show
44:05The
44:05Evidence
44:06That I
44:07Am
44:07Seeing
44:07Every
44:08Day
44:08In the
44:08OPD
44:09In the
44:10Ward
44:10In the
44:11Emergency
44:11Rooms
44:12What
44:13Someone
44:13Else's
44:14Belief
44:14Is
44:15I
44:15Cannot
44:15Comment
44:16On
44:16That
44:16Dr.
44:18Kumar
44:19Let's
44:19Talk
44:19Some
44:19Solutions
44:20Now
44:20I
44:21Want
44:21To
44:21Understand
44:21This
44:22Mothers
44:24What
44:25What
44:25Do
44:25Do
44:25Do
44:25Our
44:26Kids
44:26Life
44:27We
44:27Are
44:27Seeing
44:28Them
44:28Suffocate
44:28Every
44:29Day
44:29In
44:29Front
44:29Of
44:30Us
44:30For
44:30Choices
44:30We
44:31Have
44:31Made
44:31Their
44:33Only
44:33Crime
44:33Is
44:34That
44:34They
44:34Were
44:34Born
44:35To
44:35Parents
44:35Who
44:35Live
44:36Deli
44:36What
44:38Do
44:38We
44:38Do
44:38How
44:38Can
44:39We
44:39Salvage
44:39Is
44:40There
44:40A
44:40Way
44:40To
44:40Salvage
44:41The
44:41Lives
44:41Of
44:41Our
44:41Kids
44:42That
44:45Is
44:45A
44:45Very
44:46Difficult
44:46Question
44:47Because
44:47This
44:48Question
44:48Is
44:48Asked
44:49To
44:49Me
44:49Every
44:49Day
44:50Should
44:50We
44:50Move
44:51Out
44:51Of
44:51Delhi
44:52First
44:53Of
44:53All
44:53Moving
44:54Out
44:54Of
44:55A
44:55City
44:56On
44:56The
44:57Basis
44:57Of
44:57Only
44:58Pollution
44:58Existing
44:59Is
44:59Not
45:00An
45:00Answer
45:00To
45:01A
45:01Problem
45:01It
45:02Is
45:02Like
45:02Running
45:02Away
45:03From
45:03The
45:03Problem
45:04That
45:04One
45:04Two
45:05It
45:06Is
45:06A
45:06Misconception
45:07That
45:08Pollution
45:08Is
45:09A
45:09Delhi
45:09Centric
45:10Or
45:10North
45:11Centric
45:11Or
45:12Indo
45:12Candidate
45:13Belt
45:13Centric
45:14Problem
45:14Today
45:15It
45:16Is
45:16A
45:16Pan
45:16Country
45:17Problem
45:17Nearly
45:1898%
45:19Of
45:20The
45:20Surface
45:20Area
45:21Of
45:21The
45:21Country
45:21Is
45:22Affected
45:23By
45:23Pollution
45:24Maybe
45:2430
45:25Years
45:25Back
45:25It
45:25Was
45:25A
45:26Delhi
45:26Problem
45:26But
45:27Today
45:27You
45:28Take
45:28Any
45:29Metro
45:29And
45:30You
45:30Look
45:30At
45:30Their
45:30AQI
45:31Levels
45:32They
45:32May
45:32Not
45:32Be
45:32As
45:33High
45:33As
45:33Delhi
45:34But
45:34They
45:35Are
45:35Certainly
45:36Many
45:37Many
45:37Times
45:38The
45:38Indian
45:38Standards
45:39Which
45:39Are
45:40Actually
45:40Many
45:40Times
45:41The
45:41WHO
45:42Standards
45:42So
45:43The
45:43Whole
45:43Country
45:44Literally
45:44Is
45:44Breathing
45:45Bad
45:46Air
45:46And
45:47This
45:47Problem
45:47Is
45:48Getting
45:48From
45:48Bad
45:49To
45:49Worse
45:49With
45:50Every
45:50Passing
45:50Year
45:51Because
45:51Of
45:51The
45:52Causes
45:53Not
45:53Being
45:53Directly
45:54Addressed
45:55So
45:55My
45:56Answer
45:56To
45:56You
45:57As
45:57A
45:57Mother
45:57Would
45:58Be
45:58That
45:58Like
45:58You
45:59There
45:59Are
45:59Millions
46:00Of
46:00Mothers
46:01Across
46:01The
46:01Country
46:02There
46:02Are
46:02Millions
46:02Of
46:03Fathers
46:03And
46:04Brothers
46:04And
46:04Others
46:05Across
46:05The
46:06Country
46:06Instead
46:07Of
46:07Running
46:08Away
46:08From
46:08One
46:09City
46:09To
46:09Another
46:10I
46:10Think
46:10140
46:11Crore
46:11People
46:12Of
46:12This
46:12Country
46:13Need
46:13To
46:13Put
46:14Their
46:14Act
46:14Together
46:15And
46:15Say
46:15That
46:16Air
46:16Pollution
46:17In
46:17India
46:18Today
46:18Is
46:19A
46:19Serious
46:20Health
46:20Emergency
46:21Which
46:22Needs
46:23As
46:23Quick
46:24A
46:24Response
46:25I
46:26Repeat
46:26As
46:27Quick
46:27And
46:28Major
46:28Response
46:29As
46:29We
46:29Did
46:30At
46:30The
46:30Time
46:31Of
46:31COVID
46:31In
46:32March
46:32Of
46:332020
46:33We
46:34Need
46:35Major
46:35Response
46:36To
46:36This
46:37Problem
46:37Then
46:38Only
46:38Collectively
46:39We
46:39Will
46:40Be
46:40Able
46:40To
46:40Address
46:41This
46:41Problem
46:41There
46:42Are
46:42No
46:42Easy
46:42Solutions
46:43Smog
46:44Tower
46:44Cloud
46:45Seeding
46:45These
46:46Are
46:46All
46:46Cosmetic
46:47Solutions
46:47Which
46:48Don't
46:48Address
46:48The Basic
46:49Problem
46:49The
46:50Basic
46:51Problem
46:51Is
46:51Dhuwa
46:52That
46:53Is
46:53Smoke
46:53And
46:54Dhuul
46:54That
46:55Is
46:55Dust
46:56These
46:56Two
46:57Add
46:57To
46:57The
46:58Particulate
46:58Matter
46:59As
46:59Well
46:59As
47:00The
47:00Chemicals
47:00Which
47:01Are
47:01There
47:01And
47:02We
47:02Know
47:02The
47:02Sources
47:03Of
47:03Dhuwa
47:03We
47:04Know
47:04The
47:05Sources
47:05Of
47:05Dhuul
47:06What
47:06Is
47:06Needed
47:07Is
47:07A
47:07Determined
47:08Effort
47:09Solid
47:10Effort
47:11Well
47:12Meaning
47:12Effort
47:13Some
47:14What
47:14May
47:15To
47:15Be
47:15Implemented
47:16Kind
47:17Of
47:17Effort
47:17To
47:18Tackle
47:18This
47:19Problem
47:19Else
47:20The
47:20Health
47:21Consequences
47:22Will
47:22Be
47:22Very
47:23Very
47:23Serious
47:24For
47:25Everyone
47:25But
47:26More
47:26Serious
47:27For
47:27The
47:28Pregnant
47:28Women
47:29And
47:29Children
47:30The
47:31Two
47:31Most
47:32Vulnerable
47:32Sections
47:33Of
47:33Our
47:33Society
47:34Dr
47:36Dr.
47:37Dr.
47:37You
47:38Couldn't
47:38Have
47:38And
47:39That
47:39Picture
47:39On
47:40The
47:40Screen
47:40Let
47:40That
47:41Sink
47:41In
47:41For
47:41A
47:41While
47:41That's
47:42What's
47:42Happening
47:42To
47:43Our
47:43Lunks
47:43And
47:44Their
47:44Non
47:45Smokers
47:45Lunch
47:46I really don't know what to say
47:48beyond what you have already stated
47:49really hope that this message will go
47:52to the most powerful
47:54individuals in the country
47:56and we really hope that a centralized
47:58solution is found to air pollution
48:00this is just beyond depressing
48:03thank you so much sir by the way
48:04for coming here and sharing all that knowledge with us
48:07alright
48:08if that was not enough for you
48:10and perhaps not enough for our
48:12parliamentarians let's go to
48:14another doctor, Dr Chopra now joins us
48:16next, Dr Chopra is also very popular
48:18online for all the videos
48:20that he has been making and
48:22educating people on what to do on the issue
48:24of pollution, I first have
48:26to start by asking you your reaction
48:28to parliament saying that
48:31air pollution and
48:32escalated levels of AQI
48:34do not cause any
48:36lung issue
48:37that doesn't sound
48:40good to me at all, I mean
48:42how can they say that, see parliament
48:44parliamentarians have got a job to do
48:46and at some level
48:48their jobs are quite high
48:50but that doesn't mean that
48:51the awareness that they should have
48:54has not really seen
48:55what it should be
48:57and this is the problem
48:59people are wanting to leave this place
49:01people are trying to work
49:02only online, it's not good for them
49:04no doubt the parliamentarians
49:06have a lot of other jobs to do
49:08but they cannot at this very moment
49:10cannot overlook what is happening
49:13to our
49:14to our air
49:16to what we are facing
49:17the pollution
49:19and our breathing problems
49:21people are choking
49:22and you know at the long term
49:24it's not just the choking and breathing
49:26you can get cancers
49:27you can get heart disease
49:28I'm not saying really it's going to happen in one day
49:32but people who are already
49:34in a position where their lungs are not good
49:37or they're commonly exposed to throaty issues
49:39or chest issues
49:40they are choking
49:42you know
49:43so that's the thing
49:44we have to do something about it
49:46doesn't matter
49:46whether the parliamentarians are busy
49:48this is one job
49:50that they have to do for the moment
49:52they can come back to their own job
49:53after a while
49:54but let's sort this out
49:55find a way out
49:56I mean I've seen situations in China
49:59where they've got big
50:00big big round places
50:01you know where all the air
50:02in this thing is being sucked in
50:04we can do that
50:05I mean India is now
50:07at the face of a very big place
50:09we're a big daddy's today
50:11but therefore
50:12why are we not adding
50:13a situation
50:15it's like
50:16I mean I've seen this in China
50:18all the bad air
50:19all the polluted air
50:20is sucked in by these places
50:22and we have to do this first
50:23Dr. Chopra
50:27what do you think then
50:28how do we make our politicians understand
50:31the gravity of the situation
50:33we are already in
50:34what do they do
50:39first of all
50:39as I said
50:40that people are choking
50:41when you're choking
50:42you're not breathing
50:43people have forgotten
50:45how to breathe
50:45I mean there are times
50:47when I can explain
50:47at another level
50:48that what is the right way
50:50of breathing
50:51and because of the choking effect
50:53nobody's managing to
50:55blow up their lungs
50:56as they should be
50:57now at the moment
50:58the air quality index
51:00is going up to
51:01400, 500, 700
51:04my god
51:04you know
51:04it's ridiculous
51:05and in different parts of the world
51:07like in London
51:08and various other places
51:09which are not polluted
51:11it's only 50
51:12I mean look at the difference
51:14between 50
51:15versus 700
51:16the AQI
51:18is not acceptable
51:19on any account
51:20we have bad roads
51:22we have bad air
51:23our traffic is so bad
51:25that you know
51:26even from the time
51:27when I stayed
51:28to my place
51:29in my hospital
51:30you know
51:31sometimes
51:32I used to reach there
51:33in about 10 to 15 minutes
51:35today
51:36it takes up to
51:37more than
51:38an hour and a half
51:39you know
51:40it means that
51:41I have to wake up earlier
51:42I have to
51:42you know
51:43I have to run around
51:44between
51:44nobody's willing to
51:46give me space
51:47to overtake me
51:48you know
51:49so the MOS environment
51:53if he's watching right now
51:54listen to the doctors
51:56to the government
51:57and the parliamentarians
51:58watching right now
51:59listen to the experts
52:01and please understand
52:03the connection
52:03stop playing with our lives
52:05we'll end it here today
52:06see you again tomorrow
52:07bye bye
52:07bye bye
52:08bye
52:09bye
52:10bye
52:12bye
52:13bye
52:14bye
52:15bye
52:16bye
52:17bye
52:18bye
52:19bye
52:20bye
52:21bye
52:22bye
52:23bye
52:24bye
52:25bye
52:26bye
52:27bye
52:28bye
52:29bye
52:30bye
52:31bye
52:32bye