• 11 months ago
In this edition of India Today Global, renowned economist Professor Jeffrey D Sachs examines the escalating crisis in Venezuela following the capture of Nicolás Maduro by the US military on Saturday.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00hello and welcome i'm geeta mohan and you're watching india today global today our focus
00:18is venezuela and we'll talk about an update from new york as also on the situation in venezuela
00:25itself here is a report by mahashweta lala as delci rodriguez took oath as the interim president
00:34of venezuela its deposed leader nicolas maduro pleaded not guilty to the narcotics charges
00:40maduro who 63 pleaded innocent in new york federal court to four criminal counts
00:45narco terrorism cocaine importation conspiracy possession of machine guns and destructive
00:51devices maduro's wife cilia floors also pleaded not guilty the next court date has been set for march
00:5817th dozens of protesters both pro and anti maduro gathered outside the courthouse before the half
01:04hour hearing maduro's lawyer barry pollock said he anticipated voluminous and complex litigation over
01:11what he called his client's military abduction he said maduro who was not requesting his release
01:17but may later pollock is famous for negotiating the release of wikileaks founder julian assange flo's
01:23lawyer said she sustained significant injuries including severe bruising on her ribs and asked that
01:30she be provided x-rays and physical evaluation meanwhile venezuelan representative in the unsc condemned
01:38u.s action venezuela is the victim of these attacks because of its natural resources we are faced with
01:47a logic that harks back to the worst practices of colonialism and neocolonialism accepting such a
01:53logic would mean to open the door to a deeply unstable world in which countries with greater military
01:58capacities can decide by force the political and economic destinies of other states
02:07federal prosecutors in new york first indicted maduro in 2020 as part of a long-running narcotics
02:14trafficking case against current and former venezuelan officials and colombian gorillas
02:19with maha shaita lala bureau report india today
02:31venezuela is a developing situation but ramifications and repercussions of it
02:37of america's decisions will be felt far and wide i'm being joined by the person who presented his
02:42testimony at the united nations security council discussing u.s actions in venezuela professor
02:47jeffrey sachs renowned american economist and political analyst thank you so much for joining
02:53us here on india today global it's a pleasure thank you professor sachs you spoke at the unsc
02:59on u.s actions in venezuela you spelled out america's plans of regime change through presidents
03:04not just trump you have globally exposed the regime change playbook of the u.s how has this action
03:11of trump changed the rules based order well there is no rules based order that is a fairy tale
03:19of the united states anybody who believed that in the last 25 years wasn't paying attention the united
03:27states is governed by military security apparatus the cia the pentagon other security agencies largely drive
03:38american foreign policy and one of the pillars of american foreign policy is regime change either
03:45through wars or through so-called color revolutions or through assassinations and coups there are many
03:52ways to change a regime in the case of venezuela the united states has been trying to change this regime
04:01which is a left-wing regime because it's a left-wing regime because it deprives american oil companies of
04:09what they want and for that reason the united states has been trying to change this regime or this government
04:17for more than 20 years it has used many different attempts an outright coup attempt in 2002
04:24uh stoking protests in 2014 draconian economic sanctions in trump's first term and finally trump said okay we're just
04:35going to overthrow this government by military means but it's not happening the way the united states wants
04:43they kidnapped the president but they did not change the regime and most american regime change operations
04:53actually fail uh they certainly fail to achieve the political outcomes that the united states seeks
05:00but they often fail to change the government and it remains to be seen what's going to happen in venezuela
05:06in the meantime it's important to note that president trump is basically out of control right now
05:12he's making demands and threats to countries all over the world to iran to nigeria to denmark with its
05:20uh greenland territory uh to colombia to mexico so this is a a fast developing situation right and
05:31not a happy one right we will talk about the greenland uh question but before that do you buy the
05:36premise that the action was carried out to take out a drug lord or does it have to do with oil power supremacy
05:44many have also said that maduro provoked him with the televised dancing and mockery of trump what do you
05:50think are the primary reasons of provocations over here and we've seen visuals over here did you
05:57anticipate and i've been watching your interviews your conversations you must have anticipated all this
06:02the movement the action but picking up a president from venezuela and bringing him to american soil did you
06:10anticipate that well i anticipated some kind of violent action by the united states they do kidnap
06:22presidents president aristide of haiti was kidnapped by the cia uh about 20 years ago he was marched to
06:33a plane with an unmarked tail and he was flown 23 hours to the central african republic where he was
06:40dumped in this case they kidnapped the president of venezuela and brought him to new york city my my home
06:49in fact what will happen next remains to be seen if we still have the rule of law in the united states
06:56a judge should not look kindly on the u.s government kidnapping the president of another country and
07:03bringing him forcibly to the united states so we'll see what the judiciary actually does whether there is
07:09an independent judiciary still in the united states this is a question but it was clear that the united
07:16states was going to take some kind of violent regime change operation and i just would like to share an
07:24interesting anecdote as part of this in trump's first term in september 2017 in his first year of office
07:33on the margins of the un general assembly in september of 2017 trump had dinner with a number of latin american
07:42presidents and he said even then so we're talking uh basically about eight years ago he said why don't i
07:50just invade venezuela so my point is that this is uh something that has been on the minds of uh the u.s
07:58uh security state for a long time in that dinner eight years ago the latin american leaders talked
08:08him down said mr president that's not a very good idea it could create a lot of instability it might not
08:14be helpful for you uh and for the united states uh well this time he didn't seek advice or listen to
08:22advice uh he just took his uh foot off of the brake uh on our military machine and uh they went after it
08:31but we're in very early days jeff what's the intent here drug trafficking doing away with drug traffickers
08:38or is it oil and supremacy yeah it is two things one any left-wing government is a target of the united
08:48united states so this is decades and decades of regime change operations in the western hemisphere
08:55when there is a left-wing government so this is part of it and this is a left-wing government but the
09:02second target is oil obviously venezuela has vast oil reserves in fact on the official proved reserves
09:12data of the u.s geologic survey and other lists venezuela's approved reserves are the largest in the
09:21world even larger than saudi arabia's of course they're not as economical they're heavy oil but
09:28they're nearby the united states we have the refineries in the southeast of the u.s trump he's a maniac he
09:35he looks for oil he says well that's ours it's like a child frankly but it is part of a deep state
09:43uh which has wanted to overthrow this government for a very long time has he pleased the deep state
09:50because you know we see here a lot of problems between the deep state and trump has he been able
09:54to please the deep state here well the deep state runs the united states uh foreign policy not presidents
10:04the presidents come and go but the deep state remains the deep state and that's why you have in every
10:12administration think about bush jr in the first years of this century the invasions of iraq then obama
10:23who seemed to be a very different person but he launched the cia operation to overthrow the syrian
10:30government he led the nato operation to overthrow muammar qaddafi he oversaw the u.s operation to
10:41overthrow the president of ukraine in february 2014 so he didn't change very much then came trump trump
10:49used various means in venezuela to try to crush the economy by the way the comprehensive sanctions that
10:57trump put on were so excruciating that oil production in venezuela which is their overwhelming export
11:05fell by 75 percent between 2016 and 2020 and the economy completely collapsed but maduro held power
11:15then came biden he had his own uh he had his own deep state operations especially in ukraine and in uh in
11:27gaza uh together with israel now trump is in he's got his operations he's making threats all over the
11:33place but my point is look more deeply at u.s foreign policy while trump is an aberration in
11:40certain ways and if you'll pardon me in the vulgarity of it in the explicitness of it in the
11:47open threats this is how american foreign policy has worked for a very long time it should not work
11:54this way this is very dangerous it's against international law it is uh not a success story
12:02of the united states it has cost us trillions of dollars it has cost millions of lives it does
12:08not produce the results uh that the u.s deep state wants but it is their modus operandi right what is
12:16more egregious to you trump's actions or muted response of the international community well the
12:22response of the international community is interesting uh most countries don't really want to
12:28raise their heads because they don't want to be next uh and uh if in europe these are basically vassal
12:35states almost occupied countries i have to tell you because the u.s military bases are all over europe
12:44europe views the united states as its protector against russia this is a little ironic because
12:51the united states is actually the biggest threat to europe right now not russia trump is talking openly
12:58about uh about uh basically uh invading or taking over greenland which is a territory of denmark and in
13:06fact the european leaders made a statement today extraordinary saying uh that uh greenland belongs to
13:13denmark and don't touch it can you imagine europe having to tell the united states don't invade us
13:19but this is what it's really come to um so the reactions a few leaders have been very forthright
13:27china very very straightforward this is against international law it is a flagrant violation of
13:34international law the russian federation the same way two big superpowers speaking quite plainly the mexican
13:43government uh has spoken uh clearly that this is a violation uh but mexico poor mexico on the border of
13:51the united states and being threatened directly by donald trump uh brazil another major country a partner of
14:00india in the bricks uh president lula was very very clear that this is a gross violation of international
14:08law and a threat to the peace and a threat to latin america so right you see the reactions of
14:15countries that can afford to make those reactions and then you see a lot of the world
14:22leaders just trying to keep their head down so they don't get donald trump's animus right now
14:29but that's absolutely right but president said that he's uh that america is going to control venezuela
14:35until the time there is a smooth transition of power could this professor sacks be trump's vietnam
14:41or afghanistan moment i very much doubt that the united states is going to control anything in this
14:50how can they this is a big country they don't want to be a slave of the united states they don't want to
14:57be a vassal of the united states there are many people who want good relations with the united states in
15:04fact many people who would be thrilled for the u.s to take over a lot of the upper class and uh and uh
15:12the lot a lot of people who have suffered from the economic sanctions actually of the united states
15:19and from uh other causes of the economic collapse in venezuela would welcome the u.s but the fact of the
15:28matter is there's a lot of opposition to the united states running uh this country and i see no prospect
15:35for that actually happening usually when the united states makes a regime change like this the result
15:44is instability on a prolonged basis that's often quite deep instability even civil war in some cases
15:53like in libya a regime change operation followed by a civil war this could happen in venezuela often
16:02it's just it's coups or assassinations or ongoing economic crisis but very rarely do you kidnap a
16:12president say we're going to run the country and that it works out according to this somewhat
16:19uh fantastical idea of mr trump you've already warned that greenland could be next but i have to ask you
16:27this what next panama colombia mexico greenland katie miller stephen miller's wife had put out a post
16:33with american flag over the greenland map saying soon and trump reiterated the same thing so is greenland next
16:41my fear is that iran is next keep an eye on iran the reason is that israel is obsessed with iran wants to
16:57overthrow the iranian government and the united states for reasons that are not a hundred percent clear i have
17:05to say is basically beholden to israel the united states fights wars that israel tells the united states
17:15to fight it's very very dark actually and so when netanyahu came to mar-a-lago last week uh just around new
17:27years they made a joint statement basically saying iran uh you're next or you could be next and trump
17:36has said that with protests in iran if the government cracks down on the protests we are basically locked
17:46and loaded we're ready to fight well this is a clearly clearly a typical deep state provocation
17:54in other words we're lining up the arguments the human rights argument we're going to go in and
18:00invade iran to protect the people of iran this is a standard playbook and so this is where i would
18:10expect the possibility of a real global explosion and i would give a warning that one will be hotter
18:20than venezuela if it happens it would be potentially disastrous because while venezuela is in the
18:27american geographic neighborhood and china and russia don't want to take on the united states in the
18:36western hemisphere iran is in the middle of a lot of major powers and iran is itself with the hypersonic
18:46missiles and a capacity to do a lot of harm and a lot of damage and israel is a nuclear armed country
18:55all in all it's a recipe for potential disaster and sound heads should be saying to the united states
19:04right now stop it this is not a joke this is not a game this is not appealing to your base this is not
19:13social media this is not some play this is reality and stop it before things get out of control right
19:23trump has threatened iran mexico colombia obviously venezuela denmark nigeria in the last couple of weeks
19:35a president of the united states making dire threats against half a dozen other countries he's also saying
19:42that the government of cuba is about to fall all of this is just like lighting the fuse all over the
19:51place and things could get really really dangerous and so world leaders need to wake up you know it's
20:00interesting with the the europeans in panic over the statements about greenland they say don't touch us
20:10but they're so scared so hypocritical by the way that they don't complain about venezuela but they say
20:17don't come after us absolutely european leaders need to stand up and be a real human beings actually
20:26not just vassals and they have to say it's not right in greenland but it's also not right in venezuela
20:32it's not right in iran they have to stop playing the subservient vassals of the united states or gaza
20:41for that matter you know they woke up and voiced concerns for ukraine but when it came to gaza and
20:47now venezuela they're really not speaking the way they spoke earlier and the way they were pushing america
20:52to fight the battle uh but coming back to the reports that we saw earlier about harmonai moving
20:59out of iran and going to russia is putin becoming the global savior here whistleblowers from america
21:06assad from syria and now maybe iranian leadership
21:12i i haven't actually seen the news because i've been traveling so i don't know any details of what's
21:18happening uh specifically in iran in in the last 48 hours or in the most recent days but i believe
21:27that we already have heard the threats very clearly to my mind israel is even more of a rogue state than
21:38the united states and israel absolutely has its eye on some kind of strike to try to overthrow the
21:46government of iran and uh if history is any guide we're in for something that could be extremely
21:56extremely dangerous um monroe doctrine now by some has been recristened donro doctrine and uh we're
22:05looking at a western hemisphere narrative that has been put out by the trump administration isn't that
22:11imperialistic and and and expansionist in nature at a time when maybe it's not just the international
22:17laws but trump has also violated some of the domestic war laws uh by not informing the armed
22:23services committee the congress not being kept in the loop sir look we don't have a constitutional order
22:30right now uh all those tariffs that were put on india for example were the whim of the president of
22:37the united states declaring this emergency or that emergency by executive decree uh congress has the
22:44power of war not the president but doesn't matter and when a congressman complained that this is
22:50unconstitutional trump mocked him constitution what are you what are you whining about he said so
22:58we have a political crisis in the united states it's not called that it's not recognized like that congressmen
23:09still go to their office or they go to the floor of the house or the senate but they don't play a role this
23:17is an executive branch that's on its own right now and this is also very sad and very dangerous thank you
23:26so much for uh letting me be with you uh i i am going to have to run uh at this point all right
23:33before you go just one last question and that has to do with china i have to ask you this before i let
23:38you go uh for the western hemisphere argument by the united by the united states of america does that now
23:44give room for china to play out its plans for a takeover of taiwan at a time when they're saying this is our
23:52region china can say okay we've done nothing there then you do nothing here well i i hope that china
24:01and india indeed the brics countries will say this is not the way we want the world to operate we want
24:09the world to operate according to the un charter to international law i believe that what has happened
24:16is actually an important opportunity for the brics which this year has the indian presidency to say no
24:24we represent uh the uh bulk of humanity in fact the emerging uh and developing economies are 85 percent
24:34of the world population we don't want to go down the road of uh rogue states uh and so i hope that the
24:42bricks actually make a real point right now this is not how we behave this is not how we're going to
24:48behave we will defend the un charter on that note professor jeffrey sachs thank you so much for joining
24:55us here on india today global really a pleasure thank you
25:12um
25:18you
25:20you

Recommended