• 17 minutes ago
Coverage of Modi's FICCI address, economic analysis, Shenzhen summit, political tensions, cricket controversy, and agricultural drone initiatives.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Good evening, hello and welcome. You're with the news today. This is your prime time destination news.
00:05Newsmakers talking point, the big talking point tonight.
00:09China's bid to drive the new world order. Xi, Putin and Trump. Is China calling the shots?
00:17Also, Prime Minister Modi has given a very strong message to India Inc.
00:23But what is the elephant in the room? Corporate greed or concentration of economic and political power?
00:32Also, two major exclusives. The Italian leader who raised Raul Gandhi's slogan that has caused so much controversy over Vokchori.
00:41Giacomo Felibak joins me and the world's top cricket journalist on Australia's civil war in cricket.
00:49Lots to look forward to. But our top story tonight. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has talked tough to corporate India.
00:57In a speech of a kind that the Prime Minister has not given, speaking at a FIKI event,
01:03the Prime Minister spotlighted or appeared to put the spotlight on what he called corporate greed
01:09and highlighted how the private sector has not hiked salaries or increased hiring despite getting various corporate tax cuts.
01:20Industry has not reacted yet to the Prime Minister's comments, but the opposition is squarely blaming the government,
01:27saying that they have created an environment in which investment has declined
01:33because of a centralisation of economic and political power.
01:38A crux of what the Prime Minister said first.
01:41He urged Indian businesses not to take Indian consumers for granted, but improve product quality instead.
01:47Asked the industry to make India first their motto in investment for the next 20 years.
01:53Urged them to make full use of free trade agreements and get access to global markets.
01:58The Prime Minister highlighted how the government has cut income tax and corporate tax
02:02and indicated the private sector needs to increase salaries and hiring.
02:07He asked the industry to reduce dependence on imported pharmaceutical ingredients
02:12to invest more in agriculture and food processing.
02:15And follow Gandhi's message of Swadeshi to focus on self-reliance.
02:21Listen in to what the Prime Minister said.
02:23You can see that in 2014, the basic corporate tax rate was 30% of the government was 30%
02:38of the government.
02:40We have reduced it and reached 22% of the government to reach 22% of the government.
02:53I am RADM shampoo, for example, FNC Commonwealth, the entire economy has come.
03:23you have increased your salary of your employee, did you have increased your salary of your employee?
03:32No, let's do it. We will see.
03:37That's how it goes.
03:43But, with the income tax, there was such a big chance to give us.
03:51With this, the purchasing power of our people is very big.
03:59We have made the return and reference to the cost of the tax payers.
04:03The cost of the tax payers is very small in the system.
04:33These are some of the questions I will raise.
04:36Jain Krishna, Senior Fellow, Center for Strategic and International Studies.
04:39Someone who has worked closely with this PMO, both on skill development.
04:44He's also been part of the Indo-UK Business Council.
04:48Joins me from Washington.
04:49And Dr. Shekhar Iyer, Director and Chief Executive of the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations.
04:55I want to come to Dr. Iyer first because the Prime Minister perhaps is strongest statement to corporate India.
05:06Saying that corporate India is being driven by greed that despite all the tax cuts and benefits they've been giving,
05:12they've not increased salaries, they don't seem to have increased their investments, haven't done enough in terms of making India.
05:19What do you make out of what the Prime Minister is saying?
05:22Is it a sign of frustration or is it just a message to corporate India that you need to get
05:31your act together?
05:35Look, all this is happening against a backdrop of very high growth, first of all.
05:40And I think it's very good that the message is coming from the top political leadership that they are very
05:45concerned about economic growth and manufacturing growth in particular.
05:49That said, I find the call to corporate India a bit misplaced.
05:53The call should really be to the machinery of the government.
05:56Businesses ultimately are profit maximizing entities that work within a system of incentives.
06:02So if they are not producing outcomes that that are to your liking, then the blame is probably to the
06:09incentive system within which they're operating.
06:12And there are several things in my view that could be done to better incentives to increase manufacturing growth, to
06:18increase export led growth.
06:20I think, you know, by and large, lots of good things has been done, but there's a lot of uncovered
06:27ground that still needs to be done in order to take advantage of all the free trade agreements that we've
06:32signed.
06:35But just, Dr. Iyer, to push you on a bit, are you saying, therefore, that Tali, you know, to use
06:41the Indian line, Tali do hat se bachti hai?
06:44It's one thing for the Prime Minister to say, you know, we've got, we've done corporate tax cuts.
06:49Why have you not responded?
06:50There are those, including the likes of Jairam Ramesh, who have just tweeted saying,
06:54this government has allowed unprecedented concentration of economic power in industry after industry, oligopoly is destroying competition.
07:03He's clearly referring to what is being called cronyism, that a few cronies of this government are benefiting disproportionately.
07:11Do you believe that's a fairer reason for explaining why private investment has been tepid over the last eight years?
07:21Look, I think, I think the, the machinery of government in India has been very slow and unresponsive for a
07:28long time cutting across governments.
07:30So, you know, as I said, I think the FTAs are an excellent step forward, but they're only a start.
07:37And I think one of the, one of the strange things coming out of the Prime Minister's statement is the
07:43focus on Atmanir Bhart, because remember that imports are the lifeblood of exports.
07:48So, in fact, I would say that you need to liberalize India's import regime much more in order to take
07:55advantage of the new export opportunities that have opened up as a result of our FTAs.
08:00You know, and it's not just tariff rates, which continue to be among the highest in the world, but also
08:06non-tariff barriers.
08:07You know, in India, a manufacturing firm takes about 30 days to get customs clearance for an import compared to
08:14an average of 12 days for G20 countries and nine days for the universe of emerging markets average.
08:20So, I think there's a lot of work to be done, a lot of things that can be done.
08:25And Atmanir Bhart should really be about self-confidence in navigating the global stage rather than a strict focus on
08:32import substitution, which is not the right way to go.
08:35Jayant Krishna, you want to respond to that? Yes, it's good that we are having these free trade agreements, as
08:41Dr. Iyer points out, gets us access to global markets.
08:44But we've got to reform much faster internally. I mean, the fact is that in far too many industries, there
08:50is still far too much red-tapism.
08:54So, absolutely, Rajdeep. You know, I mean, the good thing in what Prime Minister told at FIKI's, you know, 100
09:00years celebration was that this government, you know, since it's always in a perpetual celebration mode, that everything is hunky
09:08-dory, economy is doing extremely well, at least there's some admission of weak areas where a lot of improvements are
09:14required.
09:15So, in that way, I see, you know, some promise in what he has talked about today. But, you know…
09:22No, but he's passing on the blame to corporate India. He's passing on the blame to corporate India. He's saying,
09:27I have done my bit by reducing income tax. I have done my bit by giving you corporate tax breaks.
09:33Now, it's your turn to contribute.
09:36So, Rajdeep, you know, few areas are continuing to be of major, major worry in the country, right? I mean,
09:42ease of doing business, you know, while our rank did improve. But beyond that, I think at the state level
09:48where industry interfaces with state governments, you know, I think there has not been any tangible improvement at all, right?
09:53I think that's one area which is very, very important.
09:56Yes, FTAs have been signed with a number of countries. But, you know, those FTAs, the real benefit of that,
10:01those FTAs have yet to be realized, right? So, I think jobs, when he talks that industry is not adding
10:07jobs despite the tax cut given by the government, you know, see, industry is not totally to be blamed.
10:13If you look at manufacturing sector, one is that our share of manufacturing in the overall economy remains at about
10:2016% or so, right? Which has not risen sharply, right?
10:23Now, other thing what is happening is most of the manufacturing investments which are happening in the country, they are
10:29capital intensive, they are technology intensive, they are automation intensive, right? So, those are not, I mean, a lot of
10:35sectors where PLI is being given, you know, the jobs, incremental jobs getting created are few and far between, right?
10:42So, I think government needs to focus on sectors which are employment centric where technology has not played havoc so
10:48far when it comes to jobs, you know, like leather, like apparel manufacturing. So, that's very important.
10:54Now, if you shift to the services sector, which is more than 50% of the economy where jobs happen
10:59in very large numbers, that is, and the biggest sector there is IT enabled services, right?
11:05So, that sector has also taken a huge beating because of AI, you know, their hiring has come down, the
11:11top recruiters like TCS, Infosys, Wipro, HCL, they have all talked about how, you know, they are not hiring, going
11:18to hire from campuses the same numbers as they were doing it earlier.
11:21So, I think, you know, we as a nation, we need to have a strategy in place that, you know,
11:26what do we do that, you know, IT, which used to be the largest employer, you know, is getting affected
11:32because of AI, you know, how we are going to deal with it.
11:36So, I think blaming the industry is not totally correct to my mind.
11:41You're saying blaming industry is not totally correct, but, Shekhar, do you believe that, therefore, the focus should be on
11:52reform also at the state level?
11:54Many believe that many of the roadblocks that we are facing at the moment in this country are because different
12:00states are moving at different speeds.
12:02And that's increasingly clear.
12:04You look at some of the southern states and look at their growth rates and you compare with them with
12:09growth rates in eastern India, northern India, there's a huge difference.
12:13And we're not seeing that actually, you know, it's all very well to have all these summits, you know, magnetic
12:21Maharashtra or something else, Madhya Pradesh and invest in Bengal.
12:27But the truth of the matter is, there's a huge gap.
12:30So, how do you, is that what really industry also is expecting?
12:35That industry expects that other states also now start joining this growth engine?
12:43Absolutely, Rajdeep.
12:44I think you've put your finger on it.
12:46And, in fact, I remember a recent interview that you had with Arvind Subramaniam and Devesh Kapoor,
12:52who document the difference between southern and other states in their book, A Sixth of Humanity.
12:58So, it's definitely a major issue.
13:02One good example here is the labor codes, right?
13:05So, 29 labor codes were consolidated into about four.
13:11All kinds of red tape were cut.
13:12But now this has gone to the states.
13:14The states are going to have to implement this.
13:17And the ball is in the states' courts to take advantage of what's been done at the center.
13:21And, unfortunately, the speed of progress is very different.
13:25In terms of investment facilitation, investment protection, there are big differences between states.
13:30The southern states stand out as far more hospitable, with better infrastructure, with better facilities.
13:37So, all of these are areas where other states can up their game and the center can sort of help.
13:44So, for example, if the center, for example, were to join the WTO's investment facilitation agreement,
13:50that would send a strong signal that the center is invested in helping states to improve the investment climate.
13:57So, I think, indeed, there's a lot to be done in terms of what's happening at the state level.
14:03And the center can play a role in that type of convergence.
14:06Let me ask you, therefore, Jayant Krishna, a final question.
14:11Because I know there are industrialists who talk in private.
14:16They don't say it in government.
14:17But the over-centralization of economic power in the hands of a few.
14:23And the fear factor that results because of the way regulatory agencies operate,
14:28the way enforcement agencies operate, creates an element of fear.
14:32And they believe that the rent-seeking politicians get away still.
14:36There are still rent-seeking politicians and bureaucrats.
14:39They get away.
14:40And industry is expected to pull its way.
14:43Do you agree?
14:44Has anything really changed there?
14:46Do we still have far too many rent-seeking politicians and bureaucrats,
14:50the so-called Neta-Babu nexus, still in place?
14:55Oh, yes, Rajdeep.
14:56A quick response.
14:57There are far too many rent-seeking politicians and people in bureaucracy,
15:01you know, which play havoc and, you know, do a lot of damage to the business sentiments.
15:07You know, and, you know, I think this government, at least, you know,
15:12even people who don't admire the current ruling dispensation,
15:15they agree that they have a lot of guts to take difficult decisions, right?
15:19But nothing has been done to even reduce corruption, leave aside eradicating it.
15:24You know, corruption is paramount everywhere, wherever you look at.
15:28And therefore, you know, it becomes very, very difficult.
15:33And large groups, large players are better placed to, you know,
15:37have workarounds and move forward and expand their business footprints.
15:42MSME sector there suffers quite a lot.
15:45And even the not-so-large, you know, not-so-huge groups,
15:50but the large companies in the country, they are facing the music.
15:54I think there is no doubt about that.
15:56I think that's one area this government has to do a far more improvement.
16:01And, you know.
16:03Right.
16:04Because, you know, Shekhar, I'll just ask you this very quickly.
16:07Do you go along with the theory that oligopolies are being built,
16:10that two or three people are benefiting disproportionately at the cost of many?
16:16Is that a fair argument, a quick response?
16:19Well, I think oligopolies are always likely to be bad for the consumer.
16:25This is true all over the world, not just in India.
16:27So, indeed, I think every effort should be made to increase competition in the Indian landscape.
16:34Okay, I'm going to leave it there.
16:35Clearly, whether industry and the so-called corporate greed is to blame
16:41for tepid private investment growth over this last decade,
16:45or is it governments which have not done enough when it comes to really ensuring genuine reform on the ground?
16:54That debate is still open.
16:55I want to appreciate Shekhar Iyer, Jain Krishna, joining me here on my top story tonight.
17:00I want to turn from there to our top international story,
17:03one which has a connect to India as well,
17:06because the image of the day came from Shenzhen in China,
17:09the power axis where Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin held a trilateral summit.
17:15When the Shenzhen summit is being compared by some to the Yalta mood meet after the World War II,
17:21which redrew the global map, this one is not quite as far-reaching,
17:25but it certainly indicates China's ambition to shape a new world order.
17:30Take a look at what happened at that trilateral, which many are saying was almost historic.
17:41Three leaders, three nuclear powers, one historic summit.
17:48Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping came together in Shenzhen,
17:54issuing a joint peace declaration with commitments on nuclear security,
17:59global stability, UN reform, and energy cooperation.
18:03The three powers have agreed to hold dialogue on reducing nuclear risk
18:08and preventing proliferation, reaffirming that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.
18:15They have also called for UN reforms, greater production and supply of refined petroleum products,
18:22stable energy flows, and respect for state sovereignty.
18:30We naturally discuss the potential reform and enhancement of the United Nations' capabilities.
18:36We all acknowledge the necessity of this,
18:38of adapting the work of this universal organization to the realities of the present day.
18:44We addressed security issues in the broadest sense,
18:48including the prevention of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and nuclear weapons.
18:56But several major global issues find no mention.
19:00The Ukraine and Iran wars, artificial intelligence, semiconductors,
19:05Taiwan and global supply chains are all absent from the joint statement.
19:09Xi Jinping called nuclear weapons a sword of Damocles hanging over humanity,
19:15demanding their complete prohibition and destruction.
19:19Trump backed nuclear arms reduction, but he drew a firm red line on Iran.
19:24We're going to be discussing the war between Russia and Iran.
19:27The United States, Russia and China are uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on
19:33Earth
19:33and also to lessen the risk that those weapons will ever be used.
19:38But it's also vital that we cooperate to combat the threat of nuclear proliferation in other countries around the world.
19:45That's what we're doing in Iran.
19:47We're not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon.
19:51Russian President Putin invoked the legacy of the Second World War,
19:55recalling that the three countries were on the victorious side
19:58and stressing that they shared responsibility for international peace and security.
20:05For my part, I'm convinced that Russia, China and the United States
20:10and our respective people are capable of making a significant contribution
20:14to strengthening global security and stability,
20:17providing they engage in constructive partnership-based cooperation
20:21rooted in mutual respect, equality and a balance of interests.
20:26Putin's Yalta reference added historical significance to the summit.
20:31But unlike the wartime allies of 1945,
20:34today's three leaders represent competing powers with different strategic interests.
20:43So while there is a four-point consensus in the broad framework of the Shenzhen Peace Declaration,
20:49the fine print is still awaited.
20:52But the big question does remain,
20:54does the road to peace between Russia and Ukraine and US and Iran go through Shenzhen in China?
21:02We're tracking that very closely.
21:05Gaurav Savant in Shenzhen, China for India Today.
21:11Okay, let's raise the big questions.
21:14Does Shenzhen meet China's attempt to try and now drive and control a new world order?
21:21Is Donald Trump unwilling to take on China any longer?
21:24How should India see the Shenzhen summit?
21:27Who better to tell us that is than Gautam Bambawale,
21:30former Indian ambassador to China,
21:31someone who really is a China expert.
21:34Mr. Bambawale, good to have you on the show.
21:35So let's start with that last question that I put.
21:38What does, what happened in Shenzhen?
21:41Three major leaders, Putin, Xi and Donald Trump meeting mean for India.
21:46How should India be viewing the Shenzhen summit?
21:50That's an excellent question, Rajdeep.
21:52And let me try answering at least some aspects of that question.
21:56First of all, there is very little doubt, as you said,
21:59and your reporters said that this is an important event.
22:03It is a significant event where three of the most powerful countries in the world,
22:08their top leaders have met together.
22:11However, we must keep in mind that though these countries are trying their best
22:17to achieve some kind of strategic stability,
22:21and that can be true for a short term,
22:25but in the long term, international politics is characterized by strategic competition,
22:32especially between the two major powers,
22:35namely the United States on the one hand and China on the other.
22:39Thirdly, you must keep in mind that the, you know,
22:44the power of these three countries taken together
22:47is definitely not as much as the countries which were involved at the Yalta summit.
22:52So for all these three reasons, I would say while this is an important event,
22:58I wouldn't place too much emphasis on it.
23:01On the question of what India should be doing,
23:04look, the way I see it is that one of the aspects on which the three leaders
23:09said they will work is United Nations reform.
23:13But I do not think that any one of them is going to back India
23:18to be a new member of the UN Security Council with a veto.
23:22And therefore, we should not put too much store by this meeting.
23:27We have to play our own cards,
23:29and we must continue to do what we have been doing so far in international politics.
23:34But one of the intriguing and interesting aspects, Mr. Bambawale,
23:39is that the, till a few months ago,
23:41it appeared that Trump and China were engaged in an eye-to-eye conflict of sorts,
23:47particularly over tariffs.
23:49Now, suddenly, you have the two of them,
23:51along with Vladimir Putin, who's facing his own wars in Ukraine,
23:56trying to achieve some kind of a consensus and cooperation.
23:59How should one interpret it?
24:01Should one interpret it as China looking at the U.S. in the eye
24:05and managing to win this round in some way?
24:09Or does it just reflect a new, more multi-aligned, multi-polar world
24:15where everyone is looking at their self-interest?
24:18You're absolutely right, Rajdeep,
24:21that what this signifies,
24:23this attempt to have some kind of strategic stability
24:26with the three major powers of the world meeting today or yesterday,
24:30is a clear recognition by Washington, D.C.,
24:35that there are limits to its power,
24:39that the U.S. power has declined over the past few decades,
24:43and that today, not just China, but even Russia,
24:47and also China and Russia together, hand in hand,
24:52do present a conundrum for Washington, D.C.
24:56So there is an attempt, at least in the short run,
25:00in the short term,
25:02to have some kind of strategic stability between the three of them.
25:06But I believe that that strategic stability
25:09can only happen for a few years,
25:12but in the longer term, over decades,
25:14it is strategic competition,
25:16which will rear its head again,
25:18and then the United States will probably take another tack,
25:23maybe after President Trump has finished his presidency of the United States.
25:28So you believe that the Chinese-U.S. competition
25:32is now firmly embedded in any world order that is formed,
25:36that this is China versus the U.S.,
25:38where does Russia fit in to this piece at all?
25:41Because as we've seen,
25:42Russia is facing its own battles on the frontiers
25:45with Ukraine in Europe.
25:47Well, is there a China-Russia axis in a way
25:51to keep the pressure on President Trump?
25:56That's an excellent question, Rajdeep.
25:58And definitely, there is no doubt that Russia is a major power,
26:03not just because it has nuclear weapons,
26:06it has a strong military,
26:07but also because it has a fair amount of economic strength.
26:11The fact that it is a producer of oil and an exporter of oil,
26:16some of which is imported by us,
26:18some of which is imported by China,
26:20makes Russia a major power.
26:23But I'd like to make one point to you, Rajdeep,
26:26and to your viewers also,
26:28that normally power,
26:30and I talk about not just economic power,
26:34but also power as a whole,
26:35is measured by GDP.
26:37Now, I would argue that you should measure GDP
26:41and the power of nation-states
26:43using purchasing power parity.
26:47And if you do that,
26:48you find that today,
26:50the number one country in the world
26:51in terms of power is China,
26:53because it has a GDP in PPP terms of $41 trillion.
26:59The United States is second with $31 trillion.
27:03Guess which country is third?
27:05It's India with $18.5 trillion,
27:08almost $19 trillion.
27:10And fourth,
27:12far away fourth is Russia
27:13with $7.5 trillion.
27:15So my point to my fellow Indians
27:17and to you, Rajdeep,
27:19is that India is very much a part of this mix.
27:22Yes, I accept and agree per capita incomes
27:25and per capita GDP is still very low in India.
27:28But I would argue that India
27:31is also one of the major powers of the world.
27:34And perhaps we should continue to work on that
27:38both domestically and externally.
27:41Let me ask you one final question.
27:43What we've seen is that their statement
27:44did not have any reference to Iran or Ukraine.
27:47It almost leaves you to believe
27:49that the conflicts that have convulsed the world
27:51over the last few years,
27:54who is going to actually put enough pressure
27:57on the Russians or on Donald Trump
27:59to end these conflicts?
28:00Is there anyone who has that kind of clout
28:03that maybe America had at one time
28:06to play the role of a global super cop?
28:09At the moment, it seems that they're staying away
28:11from those issues of conflict and confrontation.
28:16You are right, Rajdeep.
28:18You know, the statement or the joint declaration
28:21which came out of this meeting
28:23talks about a declaration for peace.
28:27And two of these members,
28:29or two of the three members
28:30who have signed this declaration
28:32or have signed on to this declaration
28:35are involved in wars.
28:37And the third one, China,
28:38is playing in the gray zone.
28:40So, you know, I take this with a pinch of salt.
28:43Yes, I do agree that if they come to some sort of reduction
28:48in nuclear warheads, in nuclear weapons,
28:51that will be a positive.
28:52It will be a move towards a better world.
28:55But otherwise, you know,
28:57I completely agree with you
28:58that they have signed on to a peace declaration
29:01where each of them is involved
29:04in one way or the other in conflict.
29:07Very interesting report.
29:09Gautam Bambawali, good to have you on the show.
29:10Thank you very much for giving us your bird's eye view
29:13or the larger picture
29:15of what has come from the Shenzhen declaration.
29:18Thank you very much for joining me.
29:20I want to turn from there to our exclusive guest
29:23who's joining us in a moment
29:24because the Supreme Court is now set to hear a petition
29:27to remove statements made by Italian socialist leader
29:30Giacomo Filibeck at a Congress event in Hyderabad,
29:34the Bharat Summit, over the last weekend.
29:37The plea accuses the Italian politician
29:39of interfering in the domestic politics
29:41when he spoke out at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad.
29:44Remember, this is where he had repeated the Congress slogan
29:47Vote Chor Gaddi Chor
29:49which the Congress has used to target the Modi government.
29:52He created a political controversy at a result,
29:54the BJP alleging this was a violation of visa rules
29:57and targeting the Congress
29:59for bringing in anti-Indian voices on that stage.
30:03Well, joining us now to break his silence
30:05is Giacomo Filibeck, the Italian leader
30:08and secondary general of the Party of European Socialists in Italy.
30:12Good to have you, Mr. Filibeck, on the show.
30:14Tell me very clearly, you've seen the controversy you've created.
30:18Do you have any regrets for coming to India
30:21and then attacking the Indian government
30:24in the manner that you did?
30:27I have no regrets whatsoever.
30:29Thank you for having me.
30:30And it was a pleasure to be in Hyderabad
30:33at the invitation of the Bharat Summit.
30:37Now, you're saying you have no regrets,
30:39but please tell me,
30:40when you come to India and say
30:42Vote Chor Gaddi Chor,
30:43you're virtually mouthing
30:45what is being said by the opposition here.
30:48The Congress Party is saying
30:49there's Vote Chor or Vote Theft.
30:50You come to Hyderabad
30:52at the invitation of the Congress Party
30:54and repeat the Congress's politically charged slogan
30:58which targets the Modi government.
31:02Let's be clear.
31:03The leader of the opposition in the Lok Sabha,
31:05Raul Gandhi,
31:06has consistently raised questions
31:09about the electoral integrity.
31:10And he has put evidence in front of the public.
31:13So has India's own press.
31:15The Indian Express reported
31:16that two of the three election commissioners
31:19objected in writing at least 14 times.
31:22Let's remind ourselves that India is bound
31:24by the International Covenant
31:26on Civil and Political Rights.
31:28The Article 25 guarantees
31:30that every citizen should have the right
31:33to vote in genuine periodic elections
31:36that guarantee the free expression
31:38of the voters' will.
31:39when 133 million names
31:43come off the rolls,
31:44that question deserves
31:46an impartial investigation inside India.
31:48And my principle is very simple.
31:50One person, one vote.
31:52The slogan you refer to
31:54belongs to the Indian opposition.
31:57I echo it in solidarity.
31:59No, no, but you're effectively being accused today
32:03of interfering in India's domestic politics.
32:06Italian politicians are accusing you of that.
32:09The government is accusing you.
32:10You have your views on it.
32:12You're coming to India
32:13on a visa that's been granted
32:15by the Indian government.
32:16And then you choose that moment
32:17to virtually wade into domestic politics.
32:21This is an issue to be settled
32:22between the Indian opposition
32:23and the Indian government.
32:25Why should Gya Komo, Philly Bank
32:29enter into this debate
32:30is the question being asked in India.
32:33Let's frame it correctly.
32:35I'm sorry.
32:36What is interference?
32:38Solidarity is not interference.
32:40I am the Secretary General
32:42of the Party of European Socialists.
32:43We bring together socialists,
32:45social democratic, progressive parties.
32:47And we work in international networks
32:49together within the European,
32:51within the progressive alliance
32:52and within the socialist international.
32:54We are internationalists by definition.
32:57The values that we fight for,
32:59such as social justice, human rights,
33:01and the full set of democratic principles,
33:03they don't stop at the borders
33:04of the European Union.
33:06We consider them universal.
33:08When serious questions are raised
33:10about the fairness of elections
33:12in the world's largest democracy,
33:14then it's our duty to stand
33:15with all those social and political players
33:18working to answer them,
33:20like Raoul Gandhi.
33:21And let's be also clear,
33:24conservatives and right-wing nationalist party
33:26work with partners across borders too.
33:29You know, but there will be those,
33:31this was a very partisan intervention
33:33in Indian democracy.
33:35You're saying that you had come here
33:36to express solidarity.
33:37You come to the summit,
33:39you're given a visa by the Indian government,
33:41and you have chosen to accuse that Indian government
33:45of undermining democracy.
33:47You come to a platform in India.
33:49I repeat, in India.
33:50It's one thing for you to build solidarities.
33:53We have every right sitting in Italy to say what you...
33:55But you come to India,
33:57you choose to do that in an attempt,
33:59you're accused of embarrassing the Indian government.
34:03And therefore, in a way,
34:06according to your critics,
34:07misusing the right to free speech.
34:10My intention was not to embarrass the Indian government.
34:13If you claim that they feel embarrassed,
34:16well, then maybe you should ask them
34:18why they feel embarrassed.
34:19I want to respect,
34:21and I think I respect the Indian law fully.
34:24I am not contesting,
34:25I'm not campaigning,
34:26I'm not fundraising.
34:27I spoke at the conference that I was invited to.
34:31And if the authorities have seriously...
34:34Sir, sir, just a minute.
34:35I will answer it properly.
34:37The invitation came from the Congress Party?
34:39Did it come from the organizers?
34:41Did you know that this was a Congress event
34:43when you were coming?
34:45The event of the Bharatsh summit,
34:49it's a second edition of another similar event
34:52that took place last year.
34:54And it is organized and hosted by the Congress Party
34:57in cooperation with many international players,
35:00such as the Progressive Alliance,
35:01which is the organization that we are
35:03sharing the membership with,
35:05European Socialists and Social Democrats
35:07and the Indian Congress Party.
35:10Look...
35:10But when you come and say...
35:12But there was open support
35:13when you came for it,
35:15that you gave Rahul Gandhi.
35:16You said the best way to defend Indian democracy
35:18was to stand by Rahul Gandhi
35:20and the Indian Congress Party.
35:22So you're saying that...
35:23Because he is standing for Indian democracy.
35:26He is the one that is standing for Indian democracy.
35:30No, no, but that is your interpretation.
35:33My limited point, sir,
35:35is that when you are invited for an event like this,
35:39does it become a platform for you
35:41to join hands with India's opposition
35:46to target the Modi government?
35:48It appeared, therefore,
35:49that this entire summit was designed
35:51with a single-point agenda,
35:52according to the critics,
35:54to target the Modi government.
35:56It was not actually about
35:58promoting international values
36:00as much as becoming
36:02a politically-driven event.
36:05The Bharat Summit has discussed
36:07plenty of topics and issues.
36:09Democracy was one of them.
36:11And as I said before,
36:14we stand by our friends and colleagues
36:17and partners around the world
36:18that defend the very basic essence of democracy.
36:22One person, one vote.
36:24Nothing else.
36:26This is not campaigning.
36:28This is not, again,
36:30raising funds for a political campaign
36:32of a political party in another country.
36:34That's not what I did.
36:36I am sharing our view.
36:39And our view is that
36:40one person, one vote is what matters.
36:42And if you strip 133 millions of voters
36:46from the electoral list,
36:47then you are not making justice
36:50to one person, one vote principle
36:53in the largest votes of democracy.
36:55You know, that electoral roll, sir,
36:57also had a large number of voters
36:58who are dead, absent.
36:59That debate carries on in this country.
37:01The battle is being fought
37:02in India's Supreme Court.
37:03But I just want to ask you in conclusion,
37:05the BJP says Rahul Gandhi
37:07wants regime change with foreign help.
37:10He's no longer leader of opposition.
37:11He's behaving as a puppet
37:13of foreign powers
37:14wanting instability in India.
37:16Congress is anti-India.
37:18How will you respond to those
37:20who are saying that this,
37:22that you are,
37:23you are here in India
37:25only to promote anti-India sentiments?
37:29What will you tell them?
37:31Listen,
37:34there is something that is
37:36very important for me to say here.
37:39I respect India as a country deeply.
37:43I have a lot of respect
37:45for the history of your country.
37:46And I believe
37:49that a vibrant democracy
37:52is vital
37:53in order to guarantee
37:54Indian-European partnership.
37:57It is to the benefit,
37:59to the mutual benefit
38:00of both sides.
38:02When it comes to Rahul Gandhi,
38:05I mean,
38:06I am nobody here
38:07to tell about his leadership.
38:10I think his life
38:12and his dedication
38:13tells more than anything else.
38:15walking for 4,000 miles
38:18across the country
38:19as he did
38:20is a remarkable action
38:21of leadership.
38:23And I don't think
38:23he needs to be considered
38:25as a puppet
38:26of anybody abroad.
38:28But you will agree,
38:30sir,
38:31that the decision
38:32on who is to be
38:34the Prime Minister
38:35of India,
38:36who is to lead India,
38:37Mr. Filibeck,
38:38will be decided
38:39by the Indian people.
38:40They will not be decided
38:41by Mr. Filibeck.
38:42You agree that
38:43it will be decided
38:44whether Rahul Gandhi
38:45has to lead India
38:46or Narendra Modi
38:47has to lead India.
38:48That decision
38:49will be taken
38:50by Indian people.
38:51It will not be taken
38:52by an Italian politician.
38:55Only by the Indian people,
38:56but all the Indian people
38:57with the right to vote.
38:59That's the whole point.
39:01It's not about
39:02who else should decide.
39:04This is a primary decision
39:06of the Indian voters,
39:07but all of them.
39:08And this is the only point
39:09that we have been supporting.
39:11One person,
39:12one vote.
39:13I don't think
39:14your intervention
39:15in any way,
39:16therefore,
39:16has affected
39:17India-Italian ties.
39:19That India and Italy,
39:20that the ties
39:21between the two countries
39:22have been affected
39:24because an Italian politician
39:25comes to India,
39:26uses a platform
39:27of the Congress Party
39:29to target
39:30the Modi government.
39:31You don't think
39:32that affects
39:32India-Italian ties?
39:33Is that not the issue
39:35here at the moment?
39:37I consider
39:38the friendship
39:39between Italy and India
39:40a crucial one,
39:42a very important partnership.
39:44But between friends,
39:45we speak the truth.
39:47We don't pretend.
39:49We speak the truth.
39:50This is the key
39:51of true friendship.
39:53I'm going to leave it there.
39:55It's your version
39:56of the truth.
39:56As I said,
39:57you have the right
39:58to free speech.
39:59Now,
40:00whether that right
40:00includes
40:02the right
40:03of an Italian politician
40:04to come to India
40:05and speak out
40:06against the government
40:07of India,
40:08we leave that
40:08to the lawmakers
40:09of this country,
40:10particularly the laws
40:11of the land to decide.
40:12I spoke in favor
40:13of the right
40:14of every
40:15citizens in India
40:17to exercise
40:18their supreme
40:19right of voting.
40:21That's what I spoke for.
40:23I've taken your point,
40:25Mr. Filibeck,
40:26for joining me.
40:27Appreciate you
40:28taking the time off.
40:28I know you've had
40:29a very busy day today.
40:30Thank you very much
40:31for joining us
40:32late in this evening.
40:33That was
40:33Giacomo Filibeck,
40:35secondary general
40:36of the Party
40:36of European Socialists
40:37in Italy,
40:38the man in an eye
40:39of a storm.
40:41Well,
40:41there is another
40:41storm brewing,
40:42this time in the world
40:44of cricket.
40:44It could be the biggest
40:45controversy since
40:46match fixing.
40:48Sandpaper gave
40:49back in the spotlight
40:50after that big bombshell
40:52from Australian
40:53Cameron Bancroft
40:54about how sandpaper
40:56was used
40:56on a cricket ball.
40:58The world's leading
40:59cricket journalist,
41:00Gideon Hay,
41:01is joining me
41:02on the other side.
41:03You're watching
41:04the news today.
41:05News
41:06without the noise.
41:16It's been called
41:17by some
41:17as the biggest
41:18controversy
41:18since match fixing.
41:20Australian cricket
41:21is in turmoil
41:22ever since batter
41:23Usman Khwaja
41:24claimed in his
41:25autobiography
41:26that the entire
41:27Australian team
41:27knew in 2018
41:29about the use
41:30of sandpaper
41:31for ball tampering.
41:32But the scandal
41:33exploded yesterday
41:34after Cameron Bancroft,
41:35the cricketer
41:36who was caught
41:37in the act
41:37and banned
41:38for nine months,
41:39spilled the beans.
41:40Bancroft-backed
41:41Khwaja's claim
41:42that the whole
41:42Australian team
41:43knew he was
41:44using sandpaper
41:45on the ball.
41:46Importantly,
41:47he claimed
41:47it was David Warner
41:48who first raised
41:49the possibility
41:50of using sandpaper.
41:51But he implicated
41:52the bowling coach
41:53David Saker,
41:54main coach
41:55Darren Lehman
41:56and importantly
41:57claimed that
41:58all the bowlers
41:58including current
41:59Australian captain
42:00Pat Cummins
42:01not just knew
42:02about ball tampering
42:03but also gave
42:05their feedback.
42:06This contradicts
42:06claims made by
42:07Cummins
42:07that the bowlers
42:08were not aware
42:09of what was happening.
42:11What does all of this
42:12mean for the world
42:13of cricket
42:13and Australian cricket
42:14in particular?
42:15Joining me now
42:15a very special guest
42:16the world's leading
42:17cricket journalist
42:18Gideon Haig
42:19joins us.
42:20Gideon,
42:20what do you make
42:21out of these
42:21crazy events
42:23particularly of the
42:23last 24 hours?
42:25One of the Australian
42:26players Cam Bancroft
42:27now backing
42:27Usman Khwaja's
42:28claim that the
42:29entire Australian
42:30team including
42:31your captain
42:32Pat Cummins
42:33knew that sandpaper
42:34was being used
42:35on a cricket ball
42:35during that
42:36test match
42:37in 2018?
42:40Well,
42:41I think
42:41we're sort of
42:42shocked
42:43but not surprised.
42:45In a sense
42:46since 2018
42:48sort of
42:49no one
42:50was completely
42:50satisfied
42:51with the idea
42:52that the
42:53conspiracy
42:53was hatched
42:54among three players
42:55with the rest
42:56being oblivious.
42:57We sort of
42:58always knew
42:59there was
42:59further
42:59information
43:00to come
43:01to light.
43:02The question
43:02was when.
43:04It probably
43:05always had
43:06to wait
43:06for the
43:07retirement
43:07of a senior
43:08player
43:09at the end
43:09of their
43:10career
43:10with nothing
43:10to lose
43:11and with
43:13the opportunity
43:13to make
43:14a claim
43:14rest of things
43:15and that
43:15was Usman
43:16Khwaja
43:16about 10
43:17days ago
43:17and inevitably
43:19other players
43:21involved
43:22have used
43:24the cover
43:25that he's
43:25offered
43:26to tell
43:26their stories
43:27and Bancroft
43:28is the one
43:29who's borne
43:30the gravest
43:34burden
43:34from the
43:36events of
43:362018.
43:37It really
43:38called a halt
43:39to his
43:39test career
43:40and left
43:42him.
43:43People only
43:44know one
43:44thing about
43:45Cameron Bancroft
43:46even though
43:46he's a very
43:46good domestic
43:47cricketer
43:47that he was
43:48Mr Sandpaper
43:49and not
43:50surprisingly
43:50I think he
43:51sort of
43:51buckled
43:52under that
43:52psychic
43:53strain.
43:54The big
43:55question of
43:56course Gideon
43:57which is being
43:57asked here
43:58in India
43:58and across
43:59the world
43:59is this
43:59the end
44:00of the
44:00captaincy
44:01of Pat
44:01Cummins
44:02a World
44:02Cup
44:02winning
44:03captain
44:03is his
44:03position
44:04untenable
44:05since he
44:06claimed in
44:06that elaborate
44:07press conference
44:08last week
44:08that none
44:09of the
44:09bowlers knew
44:10about Sandpaper
44:11Gate
44:11does that
44:12mean he
44:12was lying
44:13he was
44:13cheating
44:13being economical
44:14with the
44:15truth
44:15can you
44:16have
44:16can Australia
44:17have a
44:17captain
44:17who appears
44:18to have
44:18been caught
44:19out for
44:19now
44:21I mean
44:23it's
44:24interesting
44:24we've
44:24lost
44:24our
44:25last
44:25two
44:25captains
44:26in
44:26sort
44:27of
44:27slightly
44:28squalid
44:29circumstances
44:30both
44:31Steve
44:31Smith
44:32and
44:32Tim
44:33Payne
44:33that would
44:34be an
44:35unholy
44:35hat-trick
44:36if Pat
44:38Cummins
44:38had to
44:39resign
44:39at the
44:40same time
44:40look the
44:41problem
44:41really dates
44:42back to
44:43the way
44:43in which
44:43Cricket
44:43Australia
44:44dealt
44:44with this
44:44problem
44:45in
44:452018
44:46by
44:47singling
44:47out
44:48three
44:49members
44:49of the
44:49team
44:50for
44:51disproportionate
44:51punishment
44:52and the
44:52sentences
44:53were way
44:54too heavy
44:54you know
44:54a year
44:55for each
44:55of
44:55Smith
44:56and
44:56Warner
44:57and
44:57nine
44:58months
44:58for
44:58Bancroft
44:59that's
44:59far
45:00far more
45:01than was
45:01necessary
45:01far more
45:02than was
45:03required
45:03by the
45:03ICC
45:04that had
45:06the effect
45:06of nurturing
45:08their sense
45:08of grievance
45:09and at the
45:10same time
45:10preventing
45:11really any
45:12further
45:12information
45:13coming forward
45:14I mean
45:14who was
45:14going to
45:15put their
45:15hand up
45:15in those
45:16circumstances
45:16when the
45:18stakes were
45:19so high
45:19so it's
45:20ended up
45:21being one
45:21of those
45:21problems
45:22that Cricket
45:23Australia
45:23has kicked
45:24down the
45:24road
45:24for eight
45:25and a
45:25half
45:25years
45:26and
45:27as we
45:28found
45:28with
45:29Shane
45:30Warne
45:30and Mark
45:30Waugh
45:31during the
45:31match fixing
45:32saga
45:32of the
45:331990s
45:34eventually
45:36these things
45:37do come
45:38to light
45:38and they
45:39can come
45:39to very
45:39unflattering
45:40light
45:41because of
45:41the long
45:41period in
45:42which they
45:42remain
45:42secret
45:43you know
45:44it comes
45:44to Australian
45:46cricket
45:46itself
45:47there's
45:48been this
45:48winner
45:48takes
45:49all
45:49or should
45:49I say
45:50win at
45:50all
45:50cost
45:51mentality
45:51many
45:52believe
45:52that's
45:53what
45:53set
45:53up
45:53sandpaper
45:54gate
45:55does this
45:55sort of
45:56put the
45:56entire
45:57Australian
45:58cricket
45:58mantra
45:58winning
45:59at all
45:59costs
46:00under
46:00scrutiny
46:01I know
46:01it's
46:01your
46:01national
46:02game
46:02your
46:02national
46:03obsession
46:07well I
46:08mean the
46:08irony is
46:09that both
46:10Khawaja and
46:12Cummins and
46:13Bancroft
46:14one of the
46:16things that they
46:16are united
46:17about
46:18David Warner
46:18too
46:19is that the
46:20culture of
46:20the Australian
46:21cricket team
46:21in 27-18
46:22left a lot
46:24to be
46:24desired
46:25that it
46:26was a
46:27pretty toxic
46:27environment
46:28that they
46:28were being
46:29forced to
46:31seek
46:32competitive
46:32advantage
46:33and cut
46:34legal corners
46:35in pursuit
46:36of success
46:39and I
46:40think Cummins
46:41has actually
46:41done quite a
46:42lot during
46:43his captaincy
46:44and Tim
46:44Payne before
46:45him to
46:46modify that
46:47culture
46:47to temper
46:48that culture
46:48to remove
46:50some of
46:51those
46:51confrontational
46:52aspects
46:52from the
46:53way in
46:53which the
46:53Australian
46:54cricket team
46:55represents
46:56itself
46:56in a sense
46:57that they
46:57find themselves
46:58on trial
46:59for the
46:59team that
47:00they were
47:00eight years
47:01ago
47:01and a lot
47:02of water
47:02has gone
47:03under the
47:03bridge since
47:03then
47:04you know
47:05a final
47:06question
47:06anger among
47:07the Australian
47:08public
47:08is that
47:09because of
47:09a sense
47:09of betrayal
47:10they feel
47:11that the
47:11players whom
47:11they've
47:12treated as
47:13demigods
47:13may have
47:14lied about
47:14sandpaper
47:15gate
47:15or do
47:16they still
47:16retain
47:17Gideon
47:17a sense of
47:17pride and
47:18faith in
47:18their
47:19cricketers
47:19and the
47:19baggy
47:20green cap
47:23I think
47:23there's a
47:24sense of
47:24confusion
47:25at the
47:25moment
47:25genuine
47:26confusion
47:28there are
47:28just so
47:29many layers
47:29to this
47:30story
47:30not least
47:32of which
47:32is you
47:32know
47:33after eight
47:33and a half
47:34years
47:34how much
47:35can people
47:36conceivably
47:36be expected
47:37to remember
47:38accurately
47:39you know
47:39you remember
47:39feelings
47:40really rather
47:41than events
47:41and you know
47:42the feelings
47:43touched us
47:43very closely
47:44here in
47:442018
47:45all those
47:45feelings are
47:48recrudescing
47:49at the
47:50moment
47:52I think
47:53it will
47:53be
47:55I cannot
47:56believe the
47:57media frenzy
47:58around this
47:59over the last
48:00week or ten
48:00days
48:01just when you
48:01think that
48:02no one's
48:03interested in
48:03cricket anymore
48:04just it has a
48:05way of surprising
48:06you
48:08let me leave
48:10it there
48:10Gideon
48:10clearly this
48:11has shaken
48:12Australian
48:12cricket
48:13it's shaken
48:13world cricket
48:14we don't
48:14know what
48:14will happen
48:15to Pat
48:15Cummins
48:15and the
48:16others
48:16next
48:16but appreciate
48:17you taking
48:18the time
48:18off to
48:19join me
48:19there
48:19from Melbourne
48:21and we
48:22end our
48:23show tonight
48:23with our
48:23special series
48:24Krishi
48:25Wears
48:25we're right
48:26through this
48:26week
48:26we're bringing
48:27you stories
48:28of farmers
48:28who have
48:29boosted
48:29productivity
48:30and incomes
48:30through their
48:31innovations
48:32today we
48:32meet
48:33Karnal's
48:33first drone
48:34didi
48:34Sita Devi
48:35who became
48:36a drone
48:36pilot
48:37and now
48:38works
48:38every day
48:39to spray
48:40farmlands
48:41take a look
48:41at this
48:42report
49:04drones have
49:05brought winds
49:06of change
49:07to rural
49:07Haryana
49:09Sita Devi's
49:11life has
49:11transformed
49:12since she
49:13became
49:13Karnal's
49:14first
49:14drone
49:15didi
49:17hailing
49:18from
49:18Kathlehri
49:18village
49:19she was
49:19a homemaker
49:20earlier
49:20when she
49:21heard about
49:22opportunities
49:22in drone
49:23operations
49:24she latched
49:25on to
49:25it
49:26on to it
49:46Sita
49:46underwent
49:4715 days
49:47of free
49:48training
49:48at the
49:49centre
49:49in
49:49Gurugram
49:50she was
49:50later
49:51provided
49:51with
49:51a drone
49:52facilitated
49:53by
49:53IFCO
49:53along
49:54with
49:54an
49:54auto
49:55rickshaw
49:57Sita
49:57now
49:58uses
49:58drones
49:58to
49:59spray
49:59fertilizers
50:00on
50:00fields
50:00and
50:01earns
50:01350
50:02rupees
50:13per
50:14acre
50:14after
50:20becoming
50:21a drone
50:21pilot
50:22Sita
50:22has
50:23carved
50:23out
50:23an
50:23identity
50:24for
50:24herself
50:38she has
50:40only
50:40one
50:40message
50:41to
50:41other
50:41women
50:57Sita
50:58Devi's
50:58success
50:58as a
50:59drone
50:59pilot
51:00has
51:00inspired
51:01many
51:01others
51:01to
51:02become
51:02drone
51:03babies
51:05Bureau
51:06Report
51:06India
51:07Today

Recommended