• 39 minutes ago
A panel examines the Shenzhen Declaration's role in shifting global power and its effects on key geopolitical issues and regional security.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00So let me now get you a 360 degree perspective on this big developing story.
00:06Shenzhen declaration is out. Is this just optics? Is there something substantive here?
00:12There is an intent that the three powerful world leaders have decided or discussed what next.
00:20Will it bring peace on the Russia-Ukraine front or the US-Iran front?
00:24What about UN reforms? Let's take this step by step and of course denuclearization.
00:29The first big takeaway, let me get our guests and let me introduce our guests joining us on this special
00:34broadcast.
00:35Aynar Tanjan, Senior Fellow, Center for International Governance Innovation, joins us on this broadcast.
00:41Tatiana Kokhreva is a strategist who joins us from Russia.
00:45Dr. Tara Kartha, Strategic Affairs Experts, Professor Brahma Chalani, one of India's foremost strategic voices, joins us on the show.
00:52Also with me, two of my colleagues, Sandeep Punithan and Pradayopadhyay.
00:56Ladies and gentlemen, welcome.
00:58Aynar Tanjan, you're, according to you, the biggest takeaway from the big three meeting here in Shenzhen.
01:08Talking about if the American president said reduce nuclear weapons, the Chinese president said why reduce?
01:14Just get rid of them, comprehensively get rid of nuclear weapons.
01:18Very noble thoughts, sir.
01:20But how will this be translated into action on ground?
01:26Well, as you pointed out, there were four agreements, but these are kind of like, as we say in America,
01:32apple pie and mother's milk.
01:33So, these were not things that have a roadmap to them.
01:39They're aspirational.
01:41And the question is, what was this meeting about?
01:45Remember, this is APEC.
01:46This is not the UN.
01:48Generally, this would be the subject for the UN denuclearization.
01:51You have three of the five Security Council members.
01:55Why couldn't they meet there?
01:57Instead, you had both the United States and Russia bringing, in essence, their dirty laundry to China and, you know,
02:10something that has absolutely nothing to do with that.
02:14Yes, all of these countries are suffering.
02:16Yes, there needs to be addressed.
02:18But this was not the forum.
02:19You have to remember, APEC consisted since last year of 10,000 participants who met in 300 meetings, over 10
02:30different areas of commerce and dialogue, trying to hammer out a way in which you could create a regional stability.
02:38And this has nothing to do with that.
02:41So, yes, it's fine that they said that.
02:43I agree with it.
02:44But how do you get it done?
02:50Absolutely.
02:51And that question remains.
02:52So, is this more optics, great visuals, but not substantive?
02:57Professor Brahmachalani, your reading of, one, the joint declaration, and then subsequently we'll take this point by point, especially on
03:05the Russia-Ukraine war and the U.S.-Iran war.
03:08But overall, the big picture, what does it look like to you, sir?
03:13Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping presented themselves in their opening remarks as joint guardians of global security, with Trump saying
03:23that all three of them had a special responsibility to maintain communication with one another.
03:28Yet the three leaders walked away from the summit with little to show, beyond their big talk and their photo
03:35ops.
03:36To be sure, expectations for the summit were low from the beginning, and the trilateral lived up to those low
03:43expectations.
03:44The biggest loser from the trilateral was, without doubt, the United States.
03:49The trilateral was confirmation that the U.S. has lost its global primacy and that it's willing to settle on
03:57being one of three big powers.
03:59And the biggest winner from the trilateral was China.
04:03The trilateral underscored the world has entered the post-U.S. primacy era.
04:10So we are now looking at a tripolar order.
04:15By sitting as equals at, you know, at this villa on the sidelines of the APEC summit,
04:23Washington gave Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin the exact stage they have spent years demanding.
04:30They have been, you know, they have been looking at a three-way direct rate of great powers managing global
04:38stability.
04:40And for years, Beijing has pushed, quote-unquote, multi-polarity to dilute U.S. hegemony.
04:46And by hosting the first ever U.S.-China-Russia summit, Chinese soil, it, you know, it has boosted its own
04:54image.
04:54And in fact, Beijing has presented itself as the indispensable convener.
05:01China didn't just host the trilateral.
05:04It shaped the output.
05:07The four-point declaration, joint declaration released through Chinese and Russian media
05:14mirrors Beijing's longstanding talking points.
05:18What are those longstanding talking points?
05:20UN reform, state immunity, skepticism of international, like the ICC.
05:25And while leaving out concrete U.S. priorities, like, you know, like enforceable nuclear caps or breakthroughs on Ukraine and
05:36Iraq.
05:37So, China has positioned itself as the pivot between Washington and Moscow.
05:47So, let me now take it to Tatiana Kokareva, who joins us from Moscow, on the story.
05:53Very interesting.
05:54So, it's a big gain for China.
05:56Also, a big gain for Russian President Vladimir Putin, because both United States, under Joe Biden, and Europe, till now,
06:03have tried to isolate the Russian president.
06:06Not only did they fail spectacularly, today, both Europe and President Zelensky are out of the, you know, they're not
06:16in the room.
06:17They're out.
06:18And President Putin is not only in, he's firmly taking the decisions along with the Russian, along with the American
06:26president and the Chinese president.
06:27And on ICC, that ICC that was being seen as targeting the Russian president, the three have decided that ICC
06:35needs to be put in its place.
06:37Tatiana Kokareva, what's the reading of this declaration in Moscow?
06:42Well, the reading, look, first of all, the ICC has not just targeted Vladimir Putin, right?
06:50And it makes perfect sense that, for instance, Donald Trump would step in there, because one of the people who've
06:58been condemned by the ICC is actually Benjamin Netanyahu, for example, with whom Donald Trump has obviously had quite a
07:06productive relationship.
07:07But let me reframe this conversation for a tiny bit, because the way I see it right now, with all
07:18of us seriously discussing the fact that Europe or Ukraine were not in the room at an APEC summit, which
07:25has nothing to do with Europe or Ukraine, or the fact that we're looking at a trilateral order, actually makes
07:34some of the European powers the winner.
07:36Because that was the narrative, because that was the narrative, the whole framing of this as a trilateral G2 plus
07:43one or Yalta summit.
07:45That was very much a European narrative, or a US democratic one, for that matter, because they're the only ones
07:52who would benefit from this narrative altogether.
07:54Look, this was an APEC summit.
07:57The three people in the room were the leaders, of course, of the biggest powers within APEC.
08:08In response to Professor Chalani, well, I don't think, I wouldn't say that the resolution actually mirrors the Chinese position,
08:16because India has been pushing for a UN reform for quite a while.
08:20So this actually represents a BRICS perspective, for that matter, because the UN Security Council does not reflect the realities
08:28of the, yes, the multipolar world, but that is not just the Chinese position, is it?
08:34It is very much a BRICS kind of position.
08:38True.
08:38And the Russian position as well.
08:39India has also been seeking, absolutely, and a long-standing Indian position too, that UN Security Council has to be
08:47reformed, has to reflect realities of the 21st century,
08:50because in its current form, UN is way past its sell-by date or use-by date.
08:54I want to bring in Professor Inart Anjan once again, before I bring in Dr. Tara Kartha.
08:59On the issue of countries will pump more oil for stabilizing global markets, or words to that effect in this
09:06declaration,
09:07they may pump more oil, but the oil market or the global economy will not get stabilized as long as
09:14Strait of Hormuz remains shut.
09:16And that's a huge choke point, sir.
09:18Is there, in your appreciation, any back-channel that China and Russia may mount some kind of pressure or use
09:27some leverage on Iran to open the Strait of Hormuz?
09:32No.
09:33I mean, you can't impose peace, and I disagree with this idea that China is trying to be part of
09:38some sort of directorate or triumvirate.
09:40You look at exactly what they've been doing, it's quite the opposite.
09:44The Belt and Road Initiative was not about seizing power or taking things.
09:48It wasn't about taking Venezuela or claiming that you should have Greenland and things like that.
09:54They are not trying to engage in empire-building.
09:58They've done consistently, and what they've been doing for the last year at AIPAC is trying to put together a
10:04multilateral, multipolar world,
10:06which is based on making the pie bigger.
10:08More trade, less tariffs, more certainty, more predictability.
10:14Right now, this, as I said, was hijacked.
10:18You have people running around saying this was Yalta 2.0, including references by Putin.
10:24Nothing can be further from the truth, because China doesn't want to play that game.
10:29And they do things.
10:30That is the colonial past.
10:32And it's unfortunate that we still have leaders who believe that they are back in that kind of frame of
10:39reference,
10:39who's on top, who gets to tell who, what to do.
10:42Of all countries, India should be very, very wary of this.
10:46Okay.
10:47You know, the idea that powers should be deciding what happens.
10:51Why wasn't India there?
10:52I mean, certainly he paid, what, a 55-minute, including a photo-op, a visit to the Philippines.
11:02But it was a joke.
11:04I mean, come on.
11:05If you're going to have a real multipolar world, you're going to have real peace.
11:10It requires all of the actors to be there.
11:12I mean, Ukraine wasn't there, obviously.
11:15Europe wasn't there.
11:16So how are you going to solve that issue?
11:18And then with Iran, this idea that you can impose on it, how?
11:21Okay.
11:22They'll fight.
11:23They'll continue to fight.
11:24They are very, very ideological.
11:26The IRGC, they're not going to do other people.
11:30Is this, then, isn't that just a photo-op?
11:35Was this then just a photo-op?
11:37Because if I may, when China talks of a multipolar world, does it also talk about a multipolar Asia?
11:44You know, Asia has multiple powers and not just China as the supreme power, 0.1, 0.2.
11:50When China sees more access, seeks more access to the global economy or more integrated global supply chains, does China
11:58want to give India more access to the Chinese markets that India has been seeking for a very long time?
12:03So is there, Professor, in our tangent, before I let you go, I believe you have another appointment.
12:10You know, will China also have to practice what it preaches to the world in terms of giving more access
12:17to others to its markets, sir?
12:20Okay, access to your markets isn't simply saying, okay, you get to sell your things and you don't have to
12:27be competitive.
12:28Indian firms have to be competitive to go in the market.
12:31I mean, they have access to the Russian market, but they don't sell well because they don't have the brands
12:36that are there.
12:37It's not a question of quality or anything like that.
12:39It's just they haven't developed the games, which is very odd given that in the United States, many of the
12:44leading companies, especially in the tech field, are run by people of Indian or Indian descent.
12:50So, I mean, it's a question of India upping its game.
12:54No one's going to give India anything.
12:56And when people get into this whole issue about, well, you know, look at the trade imbalance between China and
13:02India.
13:03Well, most of that trade imbalance is due to the fact that India buys inputs from China.
13:09And those inputs, including a lot of the chemicals that go into generic drugs and things like that, are then
13:16resold abroad.
13:18And that is why India, to a large extent, has a surplus with other nations because it's using what it
13:25gets from China and then repackaging and upping the value of it and then selling.
13:31And a lot of those things are also required in the Chinese market, but there is opacity in the Chinese
13:37market.
13:38There's also opacity in the Chinese market.
13:40So when there's predictability that President Xi Jinping talks about globally, that same predictability should be there in accessing Chinese
13:48markets, for example.
13:50And as far as the Russian markets are concerned, it's not about quality.
13:53It's about sanctions and sanctions not imposed by the United Nations, but sanctions imposed by the United States that was
13:59in the room right here in Shenzhen.
14:02And that is where it's a very unequal place, Dr. Tara Karthar.
14:06You know, where the big three do not practice what they preach.
14:11Hold on.
14:12Hold on.
14:14And the United States, really, there are no sanctions.
14:17There were 25% additional sanctions imposed on India for buying Russian oil.
14:22And companies fear if they were to sell to Russia, they would come under the U.S. sanction regime and
14:28not the U.N. sanction regimes.
14:29Dr. Tara Karthar.
14:31Listen, it's absolute hypocrisy.
14:33Okay, I'm sorry.
14:34I'm going to say this out clear.
14:36Talking of U.N. reforms, these three countries, they are the worst.
14:39The U.S. has absolutely ignored the U.N. in terms of sanctions, in terms of rules, in terms of
14:45everything.
14:46China doesn't care about the U.N. in terms of when it actually comes to the ground in South China
14:51Sea or anywhere else.
14:52So, this is just sheer hypocrisy.
14:55China, by the way, blocked us in terms of, you know, our Security Council membership.
14:59So, I don't know what reform they're talking of.
15:02If, however, big if, if, however, I mean, I'm open to the fact that maybe they genuinely want reform,
15:09will they let in countries like India if they do?
15:12That's true. Fantastic.
15:13That is a huge, huge, what shall I say, plus point for India-China relations.
15:19Number two, who took away the spoils?
15:22Russia did.
15:24Russia and China.
15:25Russia got its oil energy flowing.
15:27So, that's a big plus.
15:28It says it's going to hammer the hell out of Ukraine now, which he didn't say it all this time.
15:33in response to the Crimea attack,
15:36two attacks, he kept quiet.
15:38Third attack, finally, he says,
15:40yeah, we're going to hit you back.
15:41He says, I'm going to G20.
15:43He's got his energy flowing again.
15:45At least that's what has been agreed.
15:47So he gets, and he also has a stake
15:50in making this look even bigger
15:52than it actually is.
15:53You know, he's been talking this up,
15:55saying, you know, this is a great thing and things.
15:58So that is one part.
16:00We don't know how much of it
16:01is actually going to work.
16:02China walked away with energy.
16:04What did the U.S. get?
16:06I really don't know.
16:08Because they're going to lose out
16:10in terms of their LNG,
16:12which they're selling to Europe.
16:13If this war halts,
16:16these guys stopped making money.
16:19Right?
16:19They stopped selling weapons to Europe.
16:22So I'm really puzzled.
16:24I mean, I'm sure there's something there
16:26which we guys, you don't know.
16:28What is it that the U.S. got from this deal?
16:32That, if we know,
16:33then you know where this is going.
16:34Otherwise, this is,
16:35I mean, if the energy flows,
16:37there it is.
16:38So,
16:42if the energy flows, it's good.

Recommended