• 19 minutes ago
Experts review structural challenges in India Inc, including investment, jobs, trade policies, and bureaucratic delays amid tax cuts.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Okay, let's raise the big questions then tonight.
00:02What is the Prime Minister's message really to India Inc.?
00:06Is the Prime Minister flagging corporate greed?
00:09Is he justified in saying that?
00:11Is this a direct call to hike investments?
00:14And is concentration of economic and political power the real elephant in the room?
00:20These are some of the questions I will raise.
00:23Jain Krishna, Senior Fellow, Center for Strategic and International Studies,
00:26someone who has worked closely with this PMO, both on skill development.
00:31He's also been part of the Indo-UK Business Council, joins me from Washington.
00:36And Dr. Shekhar Iyer, Director and Chief Executive of the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations,
00:43ICRIA, joining me.
00:44I want to come to you, Dr. Iyer, first, because the Prime Minister perhaps his strongest statement to corporate India,
00:53saying that corporate India is being driven by greed,
00:56that despite all the tax cuts and benefits they've been giving,
01:00they've not increased salaries, they don't seem to have increased their investments,
01:04haven't done enough in terms of making India.
01:06What do you make out of what the Prime Minister is saying?
01:09Is it a sign of frustration?
01:13Or is it just a message to corporate India that you need to get your act together?
01:22Look, all this is happening against a backdrop of very high growth, first of all.
01:27And I think it's very good that the message is coming from the top political leadership
01:32that they are very concerned about economic growth and manufacturing growth in particular.
01:36That said, I find the call to corporate India a bit misplaced.
01:40The call should really be to the machinery of the government.
01:43Businesses ultimately are profit-maximizing entities that work within a system of incentives.
01:49So if they are not producing outcomes that are to your liking,
01:54then the blame is probably to the incentive system within which they're operating.
01:59And there are several things, in my view, that could be done to better incentives,
02:03to increase manufacturing growth, to increase export-led growth.
02:08I think, you know, by and large, lots of good things have been done,
02:12but there's a lot of uncovered ground that still needs to be done
02:15in order to take advantage of all the free trade agreements that we've signed.
02:22But just, Dr. Ayer, to push you on a bit,
02:25are you saying, therefore, that Tali, you know, to use the Indian line,
02:29Tali dohats se bachti hai?
02:31It's one thing for the prime minister to say, you know, we've got,
02:35we've done corporate tax cuts, why have you not responded?
02:38There are those, including the likes of Jairam Ramesh,
02:40who have just tweeted saying,
02:42this government has allowed unprecedented concentration of economic power
02:46in industry after industry.
02:48Oligopoly is destroying competition.
02:50He's clearly referring to what is being called cronyism,
02:54that a few cronies of this government are benefiting disproportionately.
02:58Do you believe that's a fairer reason for explaining why private investment
03:04has been tepid over the last eight years?
03:08Look, I think, I think the machinery of government in India
03:12has been very slow and unresponsive for a long time,
03:16cutting across governments.
03:17So, you know, as I said, I think the FTAs are an excellent step forward,
03:22but they're only a start.
03:25And I think one of the strange things coming out of the prime minister's statement
03:30is the focus on Atmanir Bhart,
03:32because remember that imports are the lifeblood of exports.
03:35So, in fact, I would say that you need to liberalize India's import regime much more
03:41in order to take advantage of the new export opportunities
03:44that have opened up as a result of our FTAs.
03:47You know, and it's not just tariff rates, which continue to be among the highest in the world,
03:52but also non-tariff barriers.
03:54You know, in India, a manufacturing firm takes about 30 days to get customs clearance for an import,
04:00compared to an average of 12 days for G20 countries
04:04and nine days for the universe of emerging markets average.
04:07So I think there's a lot of work to be done, a lot of things that can be done.
04:12And Atmanir Bhart should really be about self-confidence in navigating the global stage,
04:17rather than a strict focus on import substitution, which is not the right way to go.
04:23Jain Krishna, you want to respond to that?
04:25Yes, it's good that we are having these free trade agreements,
04:28as Dr. Iyer points out, gets us access to global markets,
04:31but we've got to reform much faster internally.
04:34I mean, the fact is that in far too many industries,
04:37there is still far too much red-tapism.
04:41Oh, absolutely, Rajdeep.
04:43You know, I mean, the good thing in what Prime Minister told at FIQI's,
04:46you know, 100 years celebration was that this government,
04:51you know, since it's always in a perpetual celebration mode,
04:54that everything is hunky-dory, economy is doing extremely well,
04:57at least there's some admission of weak areas where a lot of improvements are required.
05:02So in that way, I see, you know, some promise in what he has talked about today.
05:09No, but he's passing on the blame to corporate India.
05:12He's passing on the blame to corporate India.
05:14He's saying, I have done my bit by reducing income tax.
05:17I have done my bit by giving you corporate tax breaks.
05:20Now it's your turn to contribute.
05:23So, Rajdeep, you know, few areas are continuing to be of major, major worry in the country, right?
05:29I mean, ease of doing business, you know, while our rank did improve.
05:33But beyond that, I think at the state level where industry interfaces with state governments,
05:37you know, I think there has not been any tangible improvement at all, right?
05:41I think that's one area which is very, very important.
05:43Yes, FTAs have been signed with a number of countries.
05:46But, you know, the real benefit of that, those FTAs have yet to be realized, right?
05:51So I think jobs, when he talks that industry is not adding jobs despite the tax cut given by the
05:57government,
05:58you know, see, industry is not totally to be blamed.
06:00If you look at manufacturing sector, one is that our share of manufacturing in the overall economy remains at about
06:0716% or so, right?
06:09Which has not risen sharply, right?
06:10Now, other thing what is happening is most of the manufacturing investments which are happening in the country,
06:16they are capital intensive, they are technology intensive, they are automation intensive, right?
06:21So those are not, I mean, a lot of sectors where PLI is being given, you know, the jobs,
06:26incremental jobs getting created are few and far between, right?
06:29So I think government needs to focus on sectors which are employment centric,
06:33where technology has not played havoc so far when it comes to jobs, you know,
06:37like leather, like apparel manufacturing.
06:40So that's very important.
06:41Now, if you shift to the services sector, which is more than 50% of the economy where jobs happen
06:46in very large numbers,
06:48that is, and the biggest sector there is IT enabled services, right?
06:52So that sector has also taken a huge beating because of AI, you know, their hiring has come down,
06:58the top recruiters like TCS, Infosys, Wipro, HCL, they have all talked about how, you know,
07:04they are not hiring, going to hire from campuses the same numbers as they were doing it earlier.
07:09So I think, you know, we as a nation, we need to have a strategy in place that, you know,
07:13what do we do that, you know, IT, which used to be the largest employer, you know,
07:18is getting affected because of AI, you know, how we are going to deal with it.
07:23So I think blaming the industry is not totally correct to my mind.
07:28You're saying blaming industry is not totally correct.
07:32But, Shekhar, do you believe that, therefore, the focus should be on reform also at the state level?
07:41Many believe that most, many of the roadblocks that we are facing at the moment in this country
07:46are because different states are moving at different speeds.
07:49And that's increasingly clear.
07:52You look at some of the southern states and look at their growth rates
07:55and you compare with them with growth rates in eastern India, northern India,
07:58there's a huge difference.
08:00And we're not seeing that actually, you know, it's all very well to have all these summits,
08:08you know, magnetic Maharashtra or something else, Madhya Pradesh and invest in Bengal.
08:14But the truth of the matter is, there's a huge gap.
08:18So how do you, is that what really industry also is expecting?
08:23That industry expects that other states also now start joining this growth engine?
08:31Absolutely, Rajdeep.
08:32I think you've put your finger on it.
08:34And in fact, I remember a recent interview that you had with Arvind Subramaniam
08:38and Devesh Kapoor, who document the difference between southern and other states in their book,
08:44A Sixth of Humanity.
08:45So it's definitely a major issue.
08:49One good example here is the labor codes, right?
08:53So 29 labor codes were consolidated into about four.
08:58All kinds of red tape were cut.
09:00But now this has gone to the states.
09:02The states are going to have to implement this.
09:04And the ball is in the states' courts to take advantage of what's being done at the center.
09:08And unfortunately, the speed of progress is very different.
09:12In terms of investment facilitation, investment protection,
09:16there are big differences between states.
09:18The southern states stand out as far more hospitable,
09:21with better infrastructure, with better facilities.
09:25So all of these are areas where other states can up their game
09:29and the center can sort of help.
09:31So, for example, if the center, for example, were to join the WTO's investment facilitation agreement,
09:37that would send a strong signal that the center is invested in helping states
09:42to improve the investment climate.
09:44So I think, indeed, there's a lot to be done in terms of what's happening at the state level.
09:50And the center can play a role in that type of convergence.
09:53Let me ask you, therefore, Jayant Krishna, a final question.
09:58Because I know there are industrialists who talk in private.
10:03They don't say it in government.
10:04But the over-centralization of economic power in the hands of a few
10:10and the fear factor that results because of the way regulatory agencies operate,
10:15the way enforcement agencies operate, creates an element of fear.
10:19And they believe that the rent-seeking politicians get away still.
10:24There's still rent-seeking politicians and bureaucrats.
10:26They get away.
10:27And industry is expected to pull its way.
10:30Do you agree?
10:31Has anything really changed there?
10:33Do we still have far too many rent-seeking politicians and bureaucrats,
10:37the so-called Neta-Babu nexus, still in place?
10:42Oh, yes, Rajdeep.
10:43A quick response.
10:44There are far too many rent-seeking politicians and people in bureaucracy,
10:49you know, which play havoc and, you know, do a lot of damage to the business sentiments,
10:55you know.
10:56And, you know, I think this government, at least, you know,
10:59even people who don't admire the current ruling dispensation,
11:02they agree that they have a lot of guts to take difficult decisions, right?
11:06But nothing has been done to even reduce corruption, leave aside eradicating it.
11:12You know, corruption is paramount everywhere, wherever you look at.
11:16And therefore, you know, it becomes very, very difficult.
11:20And large groups, large players are better placed to, you know,
11:25have workarounds and move forward and expand their business footprints.
11:30MSME sector there suffers quite a lot.
11:32And even the not-so-large, you know, not-so-huge groups,
11:37but the large companies in the country, they are facing the music.
11:41I think there is no doubt about that.
11:43I think that's one area this government has to do far more improvement.
11:48And, you know.
11:50Right.
11:51Because, you know, Shekhar, I'll just ask you this very quickly.
11:54Do you go along with the theory that oligopolies are being built,
11:57that two or three people are benefiting disproportionately at the cost of many?
12:03Is that a fair argument, a quick response?
12:06Well, I think oligopolies are always likely to be bad for the consumer.
12:12This is true all over the world, not just in India.
12:15So, indeed, I think every effort should be made to increase competition in the Indian landscape.
12:21Okay, I'm going to leave it there.
12:23Clearly, whether industry and the so-called corporate greed is to blame
12:29for tepid private investment growth over this last decade,
12:32or is it governments which have not done enough
12:37when it comes to really ensuring genuine reform on the ground?
12:41That debate is still open.
12:42I appreciate Shekhar Iyer, Jayankrishna, joining me here on my top story tonight.

Recommended