- 19 minutes ago
A special broadcast from Shenzhen, China, examines the trilateral summit between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the APEC summit
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Hello and a very warm welcome to an India Today special broadcast that comes to you from Shenzhen in China.
00:06I am Gaurav Savan. The optics were all right. The photo op is done. The Shenzhen declaration is out.
00:13There are four points that have been decided between the heads of the world's most powerful nuclear weapons states,
00:21the largest number of nuclear weapons, Russia, United States and China.
00:26And they're talking about nuclear arms reduction. In fact, President Xi Jinping of China took it one step ahead.
00:33He said, why should the sword of democracies hang on the heads of the world and talk about reduction?
00:40They should be comprehensively done away with get rid of nuclear weapons entirely.
00:46While it makes great headlines, the big question is, how will this be actioned?
00:51Who will start reducing the number of nuclear weapons? Will the U.S. take the lead? Will Russia take the
00:57lead?
00:57Or will China take the lead? That's point one. Point two, the three also spoke of a multipolar world.
01:06They spoke of U.N. reforms. And this has been a longstanding demand because, remember,
01:11the United Nations came after the end of the Second World War.
01:1420th century architecture cannot serve the interests of the 21st century world.
01:18The world's most populous nation, India. Now, when you talk of U.N. reforms,
01:23will India be a part of the United Nations Security Council?
01:27Same set of rules for all. And that remains to be seen.
01:31So while there is talk of U.N. reforms, who will bell the cat?
01:35Will China do it? Will the United States do it? Will Russia do it?
01:39And then, talking about limiting the role of the ICC, the International Criminal Court,
01:46this is something that would be a shot in the arm for Russian President Vladimir Putin.
01:51We will get you to listen in to what U.S. President Donald Trump had to say about this.
01:55And, extremely important, the three decided with global economy and tailspin that more oil will be pumped.
02:03There will be normalization of supplies and increased supply of oil across the world.
02:10The big question, what happens to the Strait of Hormuz?
02:13On the 28th of February, when U.S. and Israel started bombing Iran, the Strait of Hormuz was open.
02:20So will there be a back channel? Will China and Russia reach out to Iran and get Iran to accept
02:29that it will open the Strait of Hormuz
02:30so that more oil can be pumped, even if more oil is going to be pumped?
02:34If Strait of Hormuz is shut, then that oil cannot be sent down to other countries.
02:39India, ASEAN countries, rest of Asia, China, all adversely impacted.
02:43And the world in tailspin because of wars being waged between Russia and Ukraine and U.S., Israel and Iran.
02:51And then, of course, what happens on the Russia-Ukraine front?
02:54Because American President Donald Trump, he spoke of it.
02:57He said he's had a long conversation with the Russian President Vladimir Putin about ending the Russia-Ukraine war.
03:04But what about the other side?
03:06Does the other side also want it?
03:09And his special envoy, son-in-law Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, they've flown to Berlin from Shenzhen.
03:16They will be briefing the Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky and the European leadership.
03:21Will they be on board?
03:23Many, many questions.
03:25We'll try and seek answers during the course of this broadcast because the optics have all been right.
03:32What about the deliverables?
03:34Is there something substantive that emerges from it?
03:37We'll get you perspective from China.
03:39We'll get you perspective from Russia, from the United States.
03:42And, of course, what does this mean for India?
03:45360-degree perspective.
03:47I'll be reporting from Shenzhen.
03:49Our guests will be joining us from across the world.
03:51But first, we get you this ground report from Shenzhen.
04:00Three leaders, three nuclear powers, one historic summit.
04:07Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping came together in Shenzhen,
04:13issuing a joint peace declaration with commitments on nuclear security, global stability, UN reform and energy cooperation.
04:22The three powers have agreed to hold dialogue on reducing nuclear risk and preventing proliferation,
04:29reaffirming that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.
04:35They've also called for UN reforms, greater production and supply of refined petroleum products,
04:41stable energy flows and respect for state sovereignty.
04:49We naturally discussed the potential reform and enhancement of the United Nations' capabilities.
04:55We all acknowledge the necessity of this, of adapting the work of this universal organization to the realities of the
05:01present day.
05:04We addressed security issues in the broadest sense,
05:07including the prevention of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and nuclear weapons.
05:15But several major global issues find no mention.
05:19The Ukraine and Iran wars, artificial intelligence, semiconductors, Taiwan and global supply chains are all absent from the joint statement.
05:29Xi Jinping called nuclear weapons a sword of Damocles,
05:33hanging over humanity, demanding their complete prohibition and destruction.
05:37Trump backed nuclear arms reduction, but he drew a firm red line on Iran.
05:43We're going to be discussing the war between Russia and Russia.
05:46The United States, Russia and China are uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on
05:52Earth
05:52and also to lessen the risk that those weapons will ever be used.
05:57But it's also vital that we cooperate to combat the threat of nuclear proliferation in other countries around the world.
06:04That's what we're doing in Iran.
06:06We're not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon.
06:09Russian President Putin invoked the legacy of the Second World War,
06:14recalling that the three countries were on the victorious side
06:17and stressing that they shared responsibility for international peace and security.
06:25For my part, I'm convinced that Russia, China and the United States and our respective people
06:30are capable of making a significant contribution to strengthening global security and stability,
06:36providing they engage in constructive partnership-based cooperation
06:40rooted in mutual respect, equality and a balance of interests.
06:46On Ukraine, Trump revealed that he and Putin had held a lengthy discussion.
06:52We are going to be discussing the war between Russia and Ukraine, and we already have.
06:57President Putin and I have had a long discussion today for quite a while.
07:01That's pretty much what the discussion was about.
07:06And I think things are happening. I think that.
07:09Putin's Yalta reference added historical significance to the summit.
07:13But unlike the wartime allies of 1945, today's three leaders represent competing powers
07:21with different strategic interests.
07:24For India, the message from Shenzhen is clear.
07:27As major powers shape the emerging world order,
07:31New Delhi must safeguard its strategic autonomy,
07:34protect its national interests and ensure its voice remains central to every global conversation.
07:44So, while there is a four-point consensus in the broad framework of the Shenzhen peace declaration,
07:50the fine print is still awaited.
07:53But the big question does remain,
07:55does the road to peace between Russia and Ukraine
07:58and US and Iran go through Shenzhen in China?
08:03We're tracking that very closely.
08:11So, let me now get you a 360-degree perspective on this big developing story.
08:17The Shenzhen declaration is out.
08:19Is this just optics?
08:21Is there something substantive here?
08:24There is an intent that the three powerful world leaders have decided or discussed what next.
08:31Will it bring peace on the Russia-Ukraine front or the US-Iran front?
08:36What about UN reforms?
08:38Let's take this step by step.
08:39And, of course, denuclearization.
08:41The first big takeaway.
08:43Let me get our guests and let me introduce our guests joining us on this special broadcast.
08:47Aynar Tanjan, Senior Fellow, Center for International Governance Innovation,
08:51joins us on this broadcast.
08:53Tatiana Kokhreva is a strategist who joins us from Russia.
08:56Dr. Tara Kartha, Strategic Affairs Experts, Professor Brahma Chalani,
09:00one of India's foremost strategic voices, joins us on the show.
09:04Also with me, two of my colleagues, Sandeep Unnithan and Pradayopadhyay.
09:07Ladies and gentlemen, welcome.
09:09Aynar Tanjan, you're, according to you,
09:14the biggest takeaway from the big three meeting here in Shenzhen.
09:19Talking about if the American president said reduce nuclear weapons,
09:23the Chinese president said, why reduce, just get rid of them,
09:28comprehensively get rid of nuclear weapons.
09:30Very noble thought, sir.
09:31But how will this be translated into action on ground?
09:38Well, as you pointed out, there were four agreements,
09:40but these are kind of like, as we say in America,
09:43apple pie and mother's milk.
09:45These were not things that have a roadmap to them.
09:50They're aspirational.
09:53And the question is, what was this meeting about?
09:57Remember, this is APEC.
09:58This is not the UN.
10:00Generally, this would be the subject for the UN denuclearization.
10:03You have three of the five Security Council members.
10:07Why couldn't they meet there?
10:10Instead, you had both the United States and Russia bringing, in essence,
10:15their dirty laundry to China and, you know,
10:22it's something that has absolutely nothing to do with that.
10:25Yes, all of these countries are suffering.
10:28Yes, there needs to be addressed.
10:30But this was not the forum.
10:31You have to remember, APEC consisted since last year of 10,000 participants
10:38who met in 300 meetings, over 10 different areas of commerce and dialogue,
10:46trying to hammer out a way in which you could create a regional stability.
10:50And this has nothing to do with that.
10:52So, yes, it's fine that they said that.
10:55I agree with it.
10:56But how do you get it done?
10:57Sure.
11:02Absolutely.
11:03And that question remains.
11:04So, is this more optics, great visuals, but not substantive?
11:09Professor Brahmachalani, your reading of, one, the joint declaration,
11:13and then subsequently we'll take this point by point,
11:16especially on the Russia-Ukraine war and the U.S.-Iran war.
11:20But overall, the big picture, what does it look like to you, sir?
11:25Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping presented themselves in their opening remarks
11:30as joint guardians of global security, with Trump saying that all three of them
11:36had a special responsibility to maintain communication with one another.
11:40Yet the three leaders walked away from the summit with little to show,
11:44beyond their big talk and their photo ops.
11:48To be sure, expectations for the summit were low from the beginning,
11:52and the trilateral lived up to those low expectations.
11:56The biggest loser from the trilateral was without doubt the United States.
12:01The trilateral was confirmation that the U.S. has lost its global primacy
12:06and that it's willing to settle on being one of three big powers.
12:11And the biggest winner from the trilateral was China.
12:15The trilateral underscored the world has entered the post-U.S. primacy era.
12:22So we are now looking at a tri-polar order.
12:27By sitting as equals at, you know, at this villa on the sidelines of the apex of it,
12:35Washington gave Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin the exact stage they have spent years demanding.
12:42They have been, you know, they have been looking at a three-way direct rate of great powers
12:49managing global stability.
12:52And for years, Beijing has pushed, quote-unquote,
12:55multi-polarity to dilute U.S. hegemony.
12:58And by hosting the first ever U.S.-China-Russia summit, Chinese soil,
13:04it, you know, it has boosted its own image.
13:06And in fact, Beijing has presented itself as the indispensable convener.
13:13China didn't just host the trilateral.
13:16It shaped the output.
13:18The four-point declaration, joint declaration released through Chinese and Russian media
13:26mirrors Beijing's longstanding talking points.
13:30What are those longstanding talking points?
13:32U.N. reform, state immunity, skepticism of international, like the ICC.
13:37And while leaving out concrete U.S. priorities, like, you know, like enforceable nuclear caps
13:44or breakthroughs on Ukraine and Iraq.
13:49So, China has positioned itself as the pivot between Washington and Moscow.
13:59So, let me now take it to Tatiana Kukareva, who joins us from Moscow on the story.
14:04Very interesting.
14:05So, it's a big gain for China.
14:07Also, a big gain for Russian President Vladimir Putin,
14:10because both United States under Joe Biden and Europe till now have tried to isolate the Russian president.
14:17Not only did they fail spectacularly, today, both Europe and President Zelensky are out of the, you know,
14:27they're not in the room, they're out.
14:29And President Putin is not only in, he's firmly taking the decisions along with the Russian,
14:36along with the American president and the Chinese president.
14:39And on ICC, that ICC that was being seen as targeting the Russian president,
14:45the three have decided that ICC needs to be put in its place.
14:48Tatiana Kukareva, what's the reading of this declaration in Moscow?
14:54Well, the reading, look, first of all, the ICC has not just targeted Vladimir Putin, right?
15:02And it makes perfect sense that, for instance, Donald Trump would step in there,
15:07because one of the people who've been condemned by the ICC is actually Benjamin Netanyahu, for example,
15:13with whom Donald Trump has obviously had quite a productive relationship.
15:19But let me reframe this conversation for a tiny bit,
15:26because the way I see it right now, with all of us seriously discussing the fact that Europe or Ukraine
15:33were not in the room
15:34at an APEC summit, which has nothing to do with Europe or Ukraine,
15:40or the fact that we're looking at a trilateral order,
15:44actually makes some of the European powers the winner,
15:48because that was the narrative, the whole framing of this as a trilateral G2 plus 1 or Yalta summit.
15:57That was very much a European narrative, or a US democratic one, for that matter,
16:02because they're the only ones who would benefit from this narrative altogether.
16:06Look, this was an APEC summit.
16:09The three people in the room were the leaders, of course, of the biggest powers within APEC.
16:19In response to Professor Chalani, well, I don't think,
16:24I wouldn't say that the resolution actually mirrors the Chinese position,
16:27because India has been pushing for a UN reform for quite a while.
16:32So this actually represents a BRICS perspective, for that matter,
16:36because the UN Security Council does not reflect the realities of the, yes, the multipolar world,
16:42but that is not just the Chinese position, is it?
16:46It is very much a BRICS kind of position, and the Russian position as well.
16:51True. India has also been seeking, absolutely, and a long-standing Indian position too,
16:56that UN Security Council has to be reformed, has to reflect realities of the 21st century,
17:02because in its current form, UN is way past its sell-by date or use-by date.
17:06I want to bring in Professor Inart Anjan once again, before I bring in Dr. Tara Kartha.
17:11On the issue of countries will pump more oil for stabilizing global markets,
17:17or words to that effect in this declaration, they may pump more oil,
17:21but the oil market or the global economy will not get stabilized,
17:25as long as Strait of Hormuz remains shut.
17:28And that's a huge choke point, sir.
17:30Is there, in your appreciation, any back-channel that China and Russia may mount some kind of pressure
17:38or use some leverage on Iran to open the Strait of Hormuz?
17:44No. I mean, you can't impose peace.
17:46And I disagree with this idea that China is trying to be part of some sort of directorate or triumvirate.
17:52You look at exactly what they've been doing, it's quite the opposite.
17:55The Belt and Road Initiative was not about seizing power or taking things.
18:00It wasn't about taking Venezuela or claiming that you should have Greenland and things like that.
18:05They are not trying to engage in empire building.
18:10They've done consistently, and what they've been doing for the last year at AIPAC
18:14is trying to put together a multilateral, multipolar world,
18:18which is based on making the pie bigger.
18:20More trade, less tariffs, more certainty, more predictability.
18:25So right now, this, as I said, was hijacked.
18:30You have people running around saying this was Yalta 2.0, including references by Putin.
18:36Nothing can be further from the truth, because China doesn't want to play that game.
18:40And they do things.
18:42That is the colonial past.
18:43And it's unfortunate that we still have leaders who believe that they are back in that kind of frame of
18:51reference,
18:51who's on top, who gets to tell who what to do.
18:54Of all countries, India should be very, very wary of this.
18:58You know, the idea that power should be deciding what happens.
19:03Why wasn't India there?
19:05I mean, certainly he paid, what, a 55-minute, including a photo op, a visit to the Philippines.
19:13But it was a joke.
19:15I mean, come on.
19:17If you're going to have a real multipolar world, you're going to have real peace.
19:21It requires all of the actors to be there.
19:24I mean, Ukraine wasn't there, obviously.
19:26Europe wasn't there.
19:27So how are you going to solve that issue?
19:30And then with Iran, this idea that you can impose on it, how?
19:33They'll fight.
19:34They'll continue to fight.
19:35They are very, very ideological.
19:38The IRGC.
19:39Well, absolutely.
19:40So is this, then, isn't that just a photo op?
19:47Was this then just a photo op?
19:49Because if I may, when China talks of a multipolar world, does it also talk about a multipolar Asia?
19:56You know, Asia has multiple powers and not just China as the supreme power, point one, point two.
20:01When China sees more access, seeks more access to the global economy or more integrated global supply chains,
20:09does China want to give India more access to the Chinese markets that India has been seeking for a very
20:15long time?
20:15So is there, Professor Aynar Tanjin, before I let you go, I believe you have another appointment.
20:22You know, will China also have to practice what it preaches to the world in terms of giving more access
20:28to others, to its markets, sir?
20:32Okay.
20:33Access to your markets isn't simply saying, okay, you get to sell your things and you don't have to be
20:39competitive.
20:40Indian firms have to be competitive to go in the market.
20:42I mean, they have access to the Russian market, but they don't sell well because they don't have the brands
20:48that are there.
20:48It's not a question of quality or anything like that.
20:51It's just they haven't developed the games, which is very odd given that in the United States, many of the
20:56leading companies,
20:57especially in the tech field, are run by people of Indian or Indian descent.
21:02So, I mean, it's a question of India upping its game.
21:06No one's going to give India anything.
21:07And when people get into this whole issue about, well, you know, look at the trade imbalance between China and
21:14India.
21:14Well, most of that trade imbalance is due to the fact that India buys inputs from China.
21:20And those inputs, including a lot of the chemicals that go into generic drugs and things like that, are then
21:28resold abroad.
21:29And that is why India, to a large extent, has a surplus with other nations because it's using what it
21:36gets from China
21:37and then repackaging and upping the value of it and then selling.
21:42So, this is a situation where you cannot blame that comic.
21:44And a lot of those things are also required in the Chinese market, but there is opacity in the Chinese
21:49market.
21:50There's also opacity in the Chinese market.
21:52So, when there's predictability that President Xi Jinping talks about globally,
21:57that same predictability should be there in accessing Chinese markets, for example.
22:01And as far as the Russian markets are concerned, it's not about quality.
22:04It's about sanctions.
22:06And sanctions not imposed by the United Nations, but sanctions imposed by the United States.
22:11That was in the room right here in Shenzhen.
22:13And that is where it's a very unequal place, Dr. Tara Kartha.
22:26Listen, it's absolute hypocrisy, okay? I'm sorry. I'm going to say this is not clear.
22:47Talking of UN reforms, these three countries, they are the worst.
22:51The US has absolutely ignored the UN in terms of sanctions, in terms of rules, in terms of everything.
22:58China doesn't care about the UN in terms of when it actually comes to the ground in South China Sea
23:03or anywhere else.
23:04So, this is just sheer hypocrisy.
23:07China, by the way, blocked us in terms of, you know, our Security Council membership.
23:11So, I don't know what reform they're talking of.
23:13If, however, big if, if, however, I mean, I'm open to the fact that maybe they genuinely want reform, will
23:21they let in countries like India?
23:23If they do, fantastic.
23:25That is a huge, huge, what shall I say, plus point for India-China relations.
23:31Number two, who took away the spoils?
23:34Russia did.
23:35Russia and China.
23:36Russia got its oil energy flowing.
23:39So, that's a big plus.
23:40It says it's going to hammer the hell out of Ukraine now, which he didn't say it all this time.
23:45China, in response to the Crimea attack, two attacks, he kept quiet, third attack, finally he says, yeah, we're going
23:52to hit you back.
23:53He says, I'm going to G20.
23:55He's got his energy flowing again.
23:57I mean, that's what has been agreed.
23:58So, he gets, and he also has a stake in making this look even bigger than it actually is.
24:05You know, he's been talking this up, saying, you know, this is a great thing and things.
24:10So, that is one part.
24:11We don't know how much of it is actually going to work.
24:14China walked away with energy.
24:16What did the U.S. get?
24:18I really don't know.
24:19Because they're going to lose out in terms of their LNG, which they're selling to Europe.
24:25If this war halts, these guys stop making money.
24:30Right?
24:31They stop selling weapons to Europe.
24:34So, I'm really puzzled.
24:36I mean, I'm sure there's something there which we guys, you don't know.
24:40What is it that the U.S. got from this deal?
24:44That, if we know, then you know where this is going.
24:46Otherwise, this is, I mean, if the energy flows, there it is.
24:50So, if the energy flows, it's good.
24:55Before I bring in Ms. Kukreva once again, I want to bring in Sandeep Unnithan and Pranayopadhyay,
25:00who have been waiting and listening very patiently.
25:03Key takeaway, Sandeep, if there is one headline that emerges beyond the beautiful optics here in Shenzhen,
25:10what's that headline for you, Sandeep?
25:12Well, Gaurav, I've just seen the photograph of the post-Cold War world.
25:20The post-Cold War world began in 1991.
25:23It ended roughly around 2020.
25:25The post-Cold War world is what we're living through.
25:28And today, that picture of the three leaders standing side by side,
25:31one, a manufacturing superpower, another, a resource superpower,
25:35and the third, a country that used to be the sole superpower,
25:40which is now having to share space with China and the Russian Federation.
25:44This is the ultimate image in my appreciation, Gaurav,
25:49the fact that we have finally seen in the last five or six years,
25:52the end of U.S. primacy, the way the United States used to dominate the world
25:57after the post-Cold War, during the post-Cold War era,
26:01that has come to an end.
26:03And that is literally this photograph that we're looking at.
26:05It, of course, remains to be seen how things will play out in the next five or ten years.
26:10But for now, I think this is one of the biggest takeaways for me.
26:14The fall of the Berlin Wall was one big image which defined the end of the Cold War.
26:19This is going to be one of those big images that define the post-post-Cold War world, Gaurav.
26:27Okay. Pranay, it's the rise of China.
26:31It's the rise of Russia.
26:32But does it show America on a decline?
26:35Because both China and Russia have something to boast about.
26:39What does U.S. President walk back to United States or fly back to United States with?
26:45What is one tangible gain for him from this journey?
26:50Let's talk about the three takeaways for all these three countries.
26:53Gaurav, first, what did President Xi Jinping got?
26:56He got validation.
26:57And the thing which he mentioned during his last meeting with President Donald Trump,
27:02about the Thucydides trap,
27:04President Donald Trump ended up validating that.
27:06And in fact, China has emerged as a meeting ground of both these big powers to come to China,
27:12talk about their issues and discuss and make it a G3.
27:15A bipolar world has become a G3 world kind of a structure.
27:18And President of the United States has validated it.
27:21But for President Vladimir Putin, this is a showcasing of his mainstreaming.
27:26Those who were trying to alienate Russia,
27:28this is his comeback and to show to them that,
27:31look, I am still relevant and I am still powerful and I am still on the big table.
27:35But as far as the U.S. President Donald Trump is concerned,
27:37his only takeaway is a spectacle.
27:40He wanted to show to the world that he can pull,
27:43he can bring all these three, you know,
27:46these two leaders to one table and he wanted to make an optics of it.
27:50So he got an optics of it.
27:51But besides that, I'll be compelled to reiterate what I've been saying since morning,
27:55that this is high on optics, very low on deliverables and tangibles.
28:02Okay. Okay.
28:04So, Professor Brahma Chalani wants to bring in,
28:06before I bring in Tathya Khuraghan from Russia,
28:08but Professor Chalani, go ahead.
28:10Win for China, win for Russia,
28:13but a loss for the United States of America.
28:15What's that big gain for U.S. that comes out of this?
28:20Well,
28:23Trump tried very hard to bring China into nuclear arms control.
28:27The reason is that China's nuclear force is growing by about 100 warheads every year.
28:36This is a frenzied nuclear weapons buildup by China.
28:40Far from hiding this nuclear frenzy,
28:45China is flaunting it as if to underline that its rapidly growing arsenal
28:49is driven more by political than military considerations.
28:53And the unprecedented speed and scale of the nuclear buildup
28:58appears to be linked to Xi Jinping's international expansionism
29:02as China seeks global privacy by 2049,
29:07the centenary of communist rule.
29:09China wants to be, by 2049,
29:14a world power second to none.
29:17In other words, it's seeking to supplant the U.S.
29:21as the world's foremost power.
29:23That's its ambition.
29:24That's its goal by 2049.
29:27And the nuclear weapons buildup
29:29is part and parcel
29:31of that ambition.
29:34So
29:34with the U.S.,
29:37sorry, with the U.S.-Russia,
29:39New START clearly having expired
29:41in February this year,
29:43the U.S. and Russia
29:45do not want to
29:46get into a bilateral
29:49nuclear arms control agreement
29:51agrain without bringing in China.
29:53But you...
29:55Yes.
29:55China.
29:55But in Shenzhen...
29:57Yes.
29:57Yeah, in Shenzhen,
29:58we heard some lovely words
30:01from Xi Jinping about,
30:02you know, nuclear weapons,
30:04the need to eliminate them,
30:06but no willingness to be part of
30:08nuclear arms control.
30:10And, of course,
30:11there are larger implications
30:12for India from this...
30:14Oh, absolutely.
30:15Lovely words.
30:16Lovely words.
30:18But will they be followed
30:19by action on ground?
30:20I'll come to implications
30:21for India in just a moment, sir.
30:23But for a moment,
30:24I want to talk about
30:25the elephant in the room
30:26or, if I may,
30:27the bear in the room
30:28on the Russia-Ukraine front.
30:30Tatiana Khurewa,
30:32do you see any let-up
30:34in the war
30:35between Russia and Ukraine?
30:36President Trump indicated
30:38that both he and President Putin
30:40had a long conversation
30:41about ending war.
30:42Now it remains to be seen
30:43whether the other side wants it.
30:45Is the other side Ukraine?
30:47Is the other side Europe?
30:48What do you see happen
30:49on the Russia-Ukraine war front now
30:51after this conversation
30:53here in Shenzhen?
30:55Well, first of all, Gaurav,
30:56I see a big problem
30:57that we're actually discussing war
30:59in terms of an economic gathering, right?
31:02And AIPAC is Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation.
31:08So it's not about war.
31:11And this is why primarily,
31:14you know, the most,
31:15we got the most that we wanted
31:16out of this conversation
31:17between the three leaders,
31:19their commitment to kind of,
31:21you know, restoring world peace
31:24and their commitment
31:24to the concept in general.
31:27In the meantime,
31:28while we're still talking
31:29about economics,
31:31I would really like
31:31to remind everybody
31:32that there was one point
31:34in that four-point declaration
31:36that we keep forgetting about.
31:38The three countries
31:40and the three leaders
31:40agreeing to boost
31:43refined oil production.
31:45And we also keep forgetting
31:47that the U.S. is right now...
31:49I'll come to oil in just a moment.
31:49Hold on, hold on.
31:50No, no, Tatiana, Tatiana.
31:51Exactly.
31:51Let me follow.
31:52Let me follow.
31:53No, Tatiana.
31:54Let me follow the line.
31:56I want to stay on
31:57the Russia-Ukraine war for one.
31:58I'll come to oil in just a moment
32:00because that's in the Iran segment.
32:02When we talk about
32:03Russia-Ukraine war,
32:04is there any let-up
32:06or will this war continue
32:08despite this conversation?
32:10Whether it's an economic forum,
32:12war is also all about economics
32:14and it's upsetting global economy
32:15in a big way,
32:16including the APEC economy.
32:18Even though Russian president
32:19said that, you know,
32:20Russia has been providing
32:21as a stable partner
32:22and has been providing oil
32:24and fertilizers
32:25and all of that.
32:28Global economy
32:28isn't tailspin.
32:30Russia-Ukraine war
32:31is one reason.
32:32In your view,
32:33do you see any let-up
32:34in the war
32:35after this conversation?
32:37You're reading.
32:39Global economy
32:40is in tailspin,
32:41but not because of
32:41Russia-Ukraine war.
32:43Because of a different war
32:45in a different part of the world
32:47and with different powers involved.
32:48Also because of this?
32:50Primarily because of this.
32:52No, both are involved.
32:54But every conversation,
32:54to answer your question,
32:56to answer your question,
32:57every single conversation
32:59that Donald Trump
33:00and Vladimir Putin hold
33:02brings us closer
33:03to a form of compromise.
33:07Look, we need to remember,
33:09we've been five years
33:10we've been into this,
33:11almost,
33:12and the fact that
33:13we still think
33:14that this is a war
33:15between Russia and Ukraine
33:17is ridiculous
33:20at this moment in time.
33:21Ukraine is being financed
33:23by very certain powers.
33:25One of them,
33:26wait, one of them,
33:28and the biggest one to date
33:30has been the US.
33:31So they do have a lot
33:33to talk about.
33:34They do have a lot
33:34to agree on
33:36before Europeans
33:37have even have
33:38any place
33:39in this conversation
33:40because they didn't
33:41quite decide
33:42on their own either.
33:43You know,
33:44that was about
33:45NATO expansion.
33:46So this does bring us
33:48closer to a resolution,
33:50but we need to stop
33:51sensationalizing
33:52every summit
33:53in the way
33:55where we expect
33:56a big breakthrough
33:57or an announcement
33:58of peace
33:59or an announcement
33:59of something
34:00to come out
34:01of one summit.
34:02This is a very complex issue
34:03that was
34:04many, many years
34:06in the building.
34:10Sure.
34:11I mean,
34:12if no headline,
34:14it's a great photo op
34:15as Pranay and Sandeep
34:16were also saying.
34:17Wonderful photo opportunity,
34:19but nothing substantive,
34:20at least on the face
34:22of it,
34:22Dr. Tara Kartha,
34:23before I bring in
34:23Sandeep Unitan
34:24and Pranay Upadhyay,
34:25which means
34:26Russia and Ukraine
34:27continue to go
34:28after each other
34:29and what was
34:31achieved here
34:32apart from
34:33great photographs.
34:36I would agree
34:38that the fact
34:39that these three
34:40met
34:40is a step forward,
34:41right?
34:41It's a step
34:42presumably
34:43from global peace,
34:44which in our segment
34:45on India,
34:46we can say
34:46we really need
34:47that peace
34:48and we need it badly.
34:49Did it,
34:50like I said,
34:51the Russians
34:52have come away
34:53with a lot.
34:54There's no doubt.
34:55He's come
34:56with the positioning,
34:57he's got the G20,
34:59all the rest of it,
35:00which I just mentioned.
35:01Putin has got
35:02what he wanted
35:02out of this war.
35:03Number two,
35:04it's not a coincidence
35:06that that Crimea bridge
35:07was attacked
35:08at that point of time.
35:09Who pushed that?
35:11That was off limits.
35:13So there is a question
35:14there.
35:14I think Europe
35:15is trying to sabotage this.
35:17They don't want
35:18a peace done
35:19over their heads.
35:20That is number two.
35:21The takeaway,
35:23Gaurav,
35:23I think is very,
35:24it's very interesting.
35:27You know,
35:27they're talking
35:27of non-proliferation.
35:29Who is the non-proliferator?
35:31The proliferator
35:32here is China.
35:32Okay,
35:33that's a different issue.
35:34I think what
35:35US was also trying
35:36to say is that,
35:37you know,
35:38the whole message
35:38is Iran will not
35:39get a nuclear weapon.
35:41So is he saying
35:42that these are
35:43the countries
35:43who are helping Iran
35:46to get that nuclear deal?
35:48I don't think so
35:48because China
35:49never ever wanted
35:50Iran to go nuclear.
35:52That's a different issue.
35:53So the whole
35:54the nuclear
35:55non-proliferation thing,
35:57I am not sure
35:58how it is being framed.
35:59And I would watch
36:00that very carefully
36:01to see which way
36:03it is going.
36:06Okay.
36:07Okay.
36:08No,
36:08as far as this
36:09Russia-Ukraine war
36:09is concerned,
36:10Sandeep,
36:11the fact that
36:12Jared Kushner
36:13and Steve Witkoff
36:14have flown off
36:14to Berlin
36:15from Shenzhen
36:16and the fact
36:17that they're reaching
36:17out to both
36:18Vladimir Zelensky
36:19and European leaders,
36:20which means
36:21there's some
36:21back channel
36:22that's happening.
36:23But will
36:23President Zelensky
36:24agree
36:25after losing
36:2620% of his country
36:27and lakhs
36:28of his soldiers
36:28if he signs
36:29the dotted line
36:30without any
36:31semblance
36:31of a give
36:32from Russia,
36:33he might as well
36:34start a comedy show
36:35in another part
36:36of the world
36:36but he wouldn't
36:37be able to
36:38survive in Ukraine?
36:39Well,
36:40absolutely,
36:40Gaurav.
36:41You know,
36:41it's going to be
36:42a very hard
36:43act to follow
36:44on losing
36:4620% of your territory
36:47and that is something
36:47that the Ukrainians
36:49have been
36:50opposed to
36:51and what
36:52President Putin
36:52has said today
36:53is significant.
36:54He said that,
36:55look,
36:55you have to accept
36:55the reality
36:56on the ground.
36:57Yalta was about
36:58the reality
36:59on the ground
36:59and so is
37:00the Russia-Ukraine war.
37:01It's a different matter.
37:02It wasn't mentioned
37:02in the joint statement
37:04but the fact is
37:05that it is going
37:05to be extremely
37:06difficult for Ukraine
37:08to, you know,
37:10accept the loss
37:10of territory,
37:11the entire Donbass
37:12which is what
37:12Russia wants.
37:14What does Ukraine
37:15get in exchange
37:16for that?
37:16Will it get
37:17those ironclad
37:18guarantees
37:19that Russia
37:19will not attack
37:20it again
37:21does it get
37:22NATO membership?
37:23But if it gets
37:24NATO membership
37:25then the Russians
37:26are going to be upset
37:26because this is exactly
37:27what they began
37:28the war for
37:29to deny
37:31Ukraine
37:32NATO membership.
37:33They said that
37:33NATO was creeping
37:34at their doorstep.
37:35If Ukraine
37:36becomes a NATO member
37:37that's NATO
37:38at Russia's doorstep
37:40exactly what
37:41they began
37:41this war for.
37:42So it's extremely
37:43complex,
37:44Gaurav,
37:45and that is
37:45one of the reasons
37:46why this war
37:47has been dragging on
37:47for as long
37:48as it has been.
37:49And, you know,
37:50as one of our
37:51panelists mentioned,
37:52it is a fact
37:53that Russia
37:54is fighting
37:54not just Ukraine,
37:55it is fighting
37:56the entire West.
37:57It is fighting
37:58NATO.
37:58It's a proxy war
38:00of a huge...
38:01True.
38:02It's probably
38:02the biggest proxy war
38:03that we've seen
38:04in the 21st century.
38:06And, you know,
38:06that's why
38:07there are many
38:08capitals
38:09that are, you know,
38:11involved in
38:12the peace process.
38:13It's not just
38:14Moscow,
38:15Kiev,
38:15and Washington,
38:16D.C.
38:17got over.
38:20And that's why
38:21perhaps this conversation
38:22in Berlin,
38:23but Berlin has also
38:24been arming Ukraine
38:25to the teeth so far,
38:27even if it,
38:28as many have argued,
38:29Europe has been
38:30cutting its nose
38:31to spite its face.
38:32And Professor Chalani,
38:33before I bring you in,
38:34Pranay,
38:35what are European
38:36capitals,
38:36is there any word
38:38from there?
38:38How are they viewing
38:39the Shenzhen declaration,
38:41the dialogue in Shenzhen
38:42and the journey
38:44of the special envoys
38:45to Berlin?
38:46I think Europe
38:47has largely given up
38:49on President Donald Trump
38:50because they have
38:52their own concerns.
38:53They could see
38:54that the Russia-Ukraine war
38:56is not going to
38:57come to
38:58some kind of a solution,
38:59which Europe expects
39:01or Europe wants.
39:02And therefore,
39:02they are grappling
39:03on one side
39:04with their own
39:05energy crisis.
39:05They have to find
39:06some solution.
39:07Also,
39:08they have to go
39:09for their own deployment.
39:10And if you see
39:11the advancement
39:12of the European military
39:15armament production,
39:16the kind of partnerships
39:18they are forging,
39:18this clearly shows
39:19that Europe
39:20is quite unnerved
39:22with that
39:23and they have to
39:23deal with the situation
39:24and they really
39:25had to beg
39:27United States
39:28to be included
39:29on the big table.
39:30And that's why
39:31this Berlin round
39:32of talks
39:32is taking shape
39:34or taking place.
39:35But we have to see
39:36that, you know,
39:37whether and how,
39:38you know,
39:39Vinayat Sates
39:41balances this.
39:42You know,
39:42their old partners,
39:43their old allies.
39:45President Donald Trump
39:46also proposed
39:46the idea
39:47of a trilateral meeting.
39:49You know,
39:49after Alaska,
39:50you can recall,
39:51Gaurav,
39:51he proposed the idea
39:52of having a trilateral
39:54with Zelensky
39:55and Putin together.
39:56So far,
39:57that hasn't happened
39:58as yet.
39:59But we have to see
40:00that, you know,
40:01what these trilateral powers,
40:03because, you know,
40:04India always said
40:05that, you know,
40:06and I would like
40:07to reiterate
40:08what Prime Minister Modi
40:08has said,
40:09you know,
40:09earlier, Gaurav,
40:11that the trust deficit
40:12is the biggest challenge
40:13in the current
40:14geopolitical setup
40:15and that is the
40:16bigger problem here.
40:17So, on one side,
40:19earlier,
40:19you excluded Ukraine
40:20and had all the
40:22conversations,
40:22including Ukraine.
40:23You excluded Russia
40:26and have all the
40:27conversation with
40:28Ukraine on table
40:28and now you are
40:29including Russia
40:30and not including
40:31Ukraine on the table.
40:35And either ways,
40:36it's unlikely to work
40:37given the fact
40:38that Second World War
40:39lasted between
40:3939 and 45
40:40for five years
40:41and this war
40:42from February 2022
40:43now November 2026,
40:45it's almost five years.
40:47Another three months,
40:48it will be five years.
40:50But I want to do
40:52in this last part,
40:53last segment of our
40:54special show
40:55from Shenzhen.
40:56Professor Chilani,
40:58when these three
40:59big powers talk
41:00about pumping more
41:01oil to stabilize
41:02the world market,
41:03again,
41:04a noble thought,
41:05but if Strait of Hormuz
41:06remains shut,
41:07whatever amount of
41:09oil is pumped
41:09by countries,
41:10if it cannot cross
41:11the Strait of Hormuz,
41:12the problem remains.
41:1320% of the world
41:14oil supplies
41:16remain impacted.
41:17So,
41:18would there be
41:19some kind of
41:20a back channel
41:20that Russia
41:21and China
41:22wane on Iran
41:23to open
41:24the Strait of Hormuz?
41:25Is that a likely
41:26option to ensure
41:28that Shenzhen
41:29declaration
41:29is not just on paper
41:31and there's some
41:32positive action
41:32on ground?
41:34There's little
41:35to indicate,
41:36Gaurav,
41:36that any agreement
41:38on any
41:39major issue
41:41was reached
41:42in Shenzhen.
41:43There are all
41:44these nice-sounding
41:45phrases
41:47in the declaration,
41:48but there's
41:49no indication
41:50whatsoever
41:51that anything
41:52will be translated
41:53into concrete
41:55terms,
41:56including
41:56on the energy
41:57front.
41:59But I think
42:01the summit's
42:02long-term
42:03geopolitical optics
42:04cut directly
42:06against India's
42:07core strategic
42:08interests.
42:10A G3
42:11direct rate
42:12of Washington,
42:13Beijing,
42:13and Moscow
42:14setting the rules
42:15of global order,
42:17can that be
42:18in sync
42:19with India's
42:20long-term interests?
42:21Obviously not.
42:23And a managed
42:24detente
42:25between Washington
42:25and Beijing
42:26can only dilute
42:28India's
42:29Indo-Pacific leverage.
42:31It'll reduce
42:32the urgency
42:32for the U.S.
42:33to rely on India
42:34as a nation
42:36counterweight
42:36to China.
42:38And if
42:39the U.S.
42:40and China
42:41were to
42:42stabilize
42:43their relationship,
42:45New Delhi
42:45loses
42:46bargaining power.
42:48India has been,
42:50has spent
42:51decades
42:51under successive
42:52governments.
42:53Permit me to
42:54intervene on this.
42:56while I may
42:57agree with you
42:58in part,
42:59permit me to
43:00disagree and
43:01bring in
43:01Dr. Tara
43:01Kartha so that
43:02both of you
43:02weigh in on
43:03this.
43:04The U.S.
43:05is world
43:05number one
43:06power.
43:06China aspires
43:07to be world
43:08number one
43:09power.
43:09Would U.S.
43:11continue to
43:11cut its nose
43:12to spite its
43:13face like
43:13Europe did,
43:15realizing in
43:16the long term
43:17it impacted
43:18Europe adversely,
43:19in the long
43:20term it will
43:20impact China,
43:21it will impact
43:22the United States
43:23adversely.
43:23Dr. Tara
43:24Kartha,
43:25if there is
43:26genuine talk
43:26about a
43:27multipolar world,
43:28China may use
43:29multipolar till
43:30the time it
43:30replaces U.S.
43:32as the only
43:33superpower.
43:33Would the U.S.
43:34let that
43:35happen?
43:36Never.
43:38No way.
43:39That's not
43:39going to happen.
43:40That is not
43:41part of U.S.
43:42policy and it
43:42never has been.
43:44All this,
43:45I mean,
43:45Brahma is right
43:46in some ways,
43:47there is a sort
43:48of amicability
43:48going on,
43:49it suits the U.S.
43:50right now.
43:51But they will
43:52not yield the
43:53number one
43:53place,
43:54that is against
43:55everything that
43:56the U.S.
43:56has ever stood
43:57for.
43:58Number two,
43:58the fact is
44:00that even if
44:01there is a,
44:02you know,
44:03maybe they had
44:04something really
44:04written out in
44:05this whole
44:06sentient summit,
44:07they had a
44:07detailed,
44:08you know,
44:09readout,
44:09it still will
44:10not affect,
44:11you know,
44:12the quad.
44:13And by the
44:13way,
44:13I disagree with
44:14the fact the
44:15U.S.
44:15is a spent
44:16power.
44:16It is not.
44:17I think
44:17somebody,
44:18one of your
44:18panelists said
44:19that the
44:20U.S.
44:21is no
44:21longer,
44:22you know,
44:23that is not
44:24the case.
44:25I mean,
44:25China,
44:26a lot of
44:26things are
44:27hidden.
44:27I don't
44:27want to go
44:28there into
44:28all the
44:28problems that
44:29are within
44:29China.
44:30But if I
44:31can just add
44:32one point
44:33here,
44:34Gaurav,
44:34what they
44:34are talking
44:35of,
44:35when we
44:36talk of
44:36this,
44:37the importance
44:37of these
44:38three meetings,
44:39we badly
44:40need stability.
44:42We badly
44:43need inflation
44:44to come down.
44:45And there
44:46is one event
44:47which happened
44:47recently,
44:48which was
44:48Germany
44:49developing
44:50a long-range
44:51missile.
44:52Okay,
44:52that is
44:53dangerous.
44:54So,
44:55which way
44:56are we
44:56going?
44:57So,
44:57somewhere,
44:57you have to
44:58slam the
44:59brakes on
44:59and say
44:59enough is
45:00enough.
45:01Okay.
45:01So,
45:02hopefully,
45:03this will
45:04go somewhere.
45:05I mean,
45:05certainly,
45:05China
45:06wants this
45:06to go.
45:07So,
45:07let's see.
45:09Whereas the
45:10oil issue
45:10is concerned,
45:11I just
45:11wanted to
45:11add one
45:12point here.
45:13You wanted
45:13to come in
45:13because
45:14somewhere down
45:14the line.
45:15Yes.
45:15Yes.
45:15I just
45:16briefly wanted
45:17to bring a
45:18point here
45:18that,
45:19you know,
45:19these three
45:19countries have
45:20decided to
45:21increase the
45:22oil production.
45:23Certainly,
45:23their oil
45:23production facility,
45:25obviously,
45:26China is the
45:26biggest buyer of
45:27the oil,
45:27not the producer
45:28of the oil.
45:29But the
45:29Russian oil and
45:30the Chinese oil
45:31doesn't have to go
45:32to the state of
45:32Hormuz.
45:33But what's
45:34happening here?
45:35It's the United
45:36States making
45:37offer to the
45:37world's biggest
45:38buyer that let's
45:39buy from both
45:41of us,
45:42Russian oil
45:42and the
45:42US oil and
45:44don't get,
45:44you know,
45:45don't support
45:46the Iranian
45:47oil manufacturing
45:48or oil
45:48production
45:48facilities.
45:54Fair enough.
45:55But either
45:55ways,
45:56that may benefit
45:57these three.
45:57We are looking
45:58at how will it
45:59impact countries
46:00like India or
46:01ASEAN countries
46:02that have been
46:03adversely impacted
46:04by this war.
46:06And that is why
46:06multipolarity becomes
46:08extremely important.
46:09But Sandeep,
46:10there are also some
46:10very critical issues
46:11if they were
46:12discussed.
46:13The information is
46:14not there in
46:14public domain.
46:15For example,
46:16what happens to
46:16that high-end
46:17technology that
46:18chip, the big
46:19battle between
46:20the United States
46:21and China?
46:22We haven't heard
46:22of it.
46:23We haven't heard
46:23of, you know,
46:24what happens next
46:25on the Jensen
46:26Huang case.
46:27What happens on
46:28so many of these
46:29critical issues,
46:30there is still
46:30no clarity?
46:33Well,
46:33Gaurav, you know,
46:34what's going on
46:34in the Jensen
46:35Huang case,
46:36it's a bit like
46:37what's playing
46:38out in the,
46:39what used to play
46:39out during the
46:40Cold War.
46:41The space race
46:41between the
46:42USSR and the
46:43US is where
46:44China and the
46:45United States
46:46are today with
46:46the AI race.
46:47And that explains
46:48why Silicon Valley
46:49has suddenly,
46:50you know,
46:51closed forces
46:52and come back
46:54behind Jensen
46:55while Trump wants
46:56Jensen Huang to come
46:57back and lead
47:00NVIDIA.
47:01The fact is that
47:01he's too big to
47:02fail and they've
47:03realized that,
47:03that it is people
47:05like Jensen
47:05Huang that possibly
47:06hold the Trump
47:07card for them.
47:09And I mentioned
47:10this with a lot
47:11of, you know,
47:14going off,
47:15what I've been
47:16looking at over the
47:17last couple of days
47:18is the fact that
47:21they've been,
47:22you know,
47:24reassessing their
47:25war strategy
47:26that if Jensen
47:27Huang takes down
47:28the US AI
47:29market,
47:30they're going to
47:31come off worse
47:32against China.
47:33So this is a race,
47:34this is a race that
47:35Trump has called
47:36not just AI,
47:38he's calling it
47:38super intelligence.
47:39And that tells you
47:40where they are at,
47:41you know,
47:42at this point in time,
47:44at the two countries.
47:45And that is a
47:46separate issue,
47:47Gaurav.
47:48I think it's not
47:48being taken up
47:49adequately,
47:50but that will play
47:51out in the next
47:52couple of weeks.
47:52And I want to come
47:52back to Professor
47:53Brahmachalani.
47:54I want to come
47:54back, exactly,
47:57and I want to bring
47:58in Professor
47:58Brahmachalani back
48:00on this because the
48:00number one power
48:01and the number two
48:02power, do you
48:03actually see them
48:04being best friends
48:05in times to come,
48:06sir, and deciding
48:07the new world order
48:08amongst themselves,
48:09I mean, Russia,
48:10China, and the
48:12United States of
48:13America, Professor
48:13Chalani,
48:14realistically?
48:16You're not talking
48:17about these three
48:18powers, which are
48:19rivals, forging a
48:21united front.
48:22No.
48:23Or building
48:25strategic cooperation.
48:26No.
48:27Nobody expects that.
48:28But what's happening
48:30is that they are
48:33positioning themselves
48:34as joint guardians
48:37of international order.
48:39They met in a way
48:42as if they can't decide
48:44for the world.
48:46These are three
48:48competing powers
48:49that believe that
48:50if they negotiate
48:54between and among
48:56themselves,
48:57they can carve out
49:00spheres of influence,
49:01for example,
49:01or set the rules for
49:04others.
49:04countries, that's not
49:06what the rest of the
49:08world will accept,
49:09and certainly not
49:10India.
49:12A tripolar concert of
49:14nuclear superpowers
49:17will be inimical to the
49:19interests of all
49:20middle powers,
49:21including India,
49:22and also the
49:25Moscow's deeper pivot
49:27to Beijing also holds
49:29important implications
49:30for India.
49:32the Sino-Russian
49:33axis, the tirade
49:34becomes, the greater
49:37the concern in India
49:38because Russia has
49:41been pivotal to
49:42India's long-term
49:43strategic planning.
49:44So, all the
49:45signals.
49:46I can't hear Brahma
49:47at all.
49:49Sorry?
49:50Okay.
49:51What did she say?
49:53So, I will let that
49:54be the last word on
49:55this part of the show.
49:56You're absolutely
49:57right.
49:57You know, the
50:00geoeconomics and
50:01geopolitics, we see
50:03a change here, but
50:05is this, like, really
50:07permanent?
50:08Is this a new world
50:09order that's taking
50:10shape?
50:10We'll be tracking that
50:11story very, very
50:12closely.
50:13I want to thank Dr.
50:14Tara Kartha, Brabha
50:14Chalani, Professor
50:16Brahma Chalani, Sandeep
50:17Unnithan, and Pranayupadhyay
50:18for joining me here on
50:19this part of India
50:21first.
50:21That is all I have
50:23for you on this
50:24special broadcast from
50:25Shenzhen in China.
50:27As I sign off,
50:29thank you very much
50:30for watching.
50:31Keep watching
50:32India Today.