• 11 minutes ago
Gideon Haigh discusses the Sandpapergate controversy and pressures facing Australian captain Pat Cummins after new claims emerge about the 2018 scandal.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00It's been called by some as the biggest controversy since match-fixing.
00:03Australian cricket is in turmoil ever since batter Usman Khwaja claimed in his autobiography
00:09that the entire Australian team knew in 2018 about the use of sandpaper for ball tampering.
00:16But the scandal exploded yesterday after Cameron Bancroft,
00:19the cricketer who was caught in the act and banned for nine months, spilled the beans.
00:23Bancroft-backed Khwaja's claim that the whole Australian team knew
00:27he was using sandpaper on the ball.
00:30Importantly, he claimed it was David Warner who first raised the possibility of using sandpaper.
00:35But he implicated the bowling coach, David Saker, main coach Darren Lehman.
00:40And importantly, he claimed that all the bowlers, including current Australian captain Pat Cummins,
00:45not just knew about ball tampering, but also gave their feedback.
00:49This contradicts claims made by Cummins that the bowlers were not aware of what was happening.
00:54What does all of this mean for the world of cricket and Australian cricket in particular?
00:58Joining me now, a very special guest, the world's leading cricket journalist, Gideon Haig joins us.
01:03Gideon, what do you make out of these crazy events, particularly of the last 24 hours?
01:08One of the Australian players, Cam Bancroft, now backing Usman Khwaja's claim
01:12that the entire Australian team, including your captain, Pat Cummins,
01:16knew that sandpaper was being used on a cricket ball during that test match in 2018.
01:24Well, I think we're sort of shocked but not surprised.
01:29In a sense, since 2018, sort of no one was completely satisfied with the idea
01:35that the conspiracy was hatched among three players with the rest being oblivious.
01:41We sort of always knew there was further information to come to light.
01:45The question was when.
01:48It probably always had to wait for the retirement of a senior player
01:52at the end of their career with nothing to lose
01:55and with the opportunity to make a clean rest of things.
01:59And that was Usman Khwaja about 10 days ago.
02:01And inevitably, other players involved have used the cover that he's offered
02:09to tell their stories.
02:11And Bancroft, you know, Bancroft is the one who's borne the gravest burden
02:18from the events of 2018.
02:20You know, it really sort of called a halt to his test career
02:24and left him, you know, people only know one thing about Cameron Bancroft,
02:29even though he's a very good domestic cringeter,
02:31that he was Mr Sandpaper.
02:33And not surprisingly, I think he's sort of buckled under that psychic strain.
02:38You know, the big question, of course, Gideon,
02:40which is being asked here in India and across the world,
02:43is this the end of the captaincy of Pat Cummins,
02:45a World Cup winning captain?
02:47Is his position untenable since he claimed
02:50in that elaborate press conference last week
02:52that none of the bowlers knew about Sandpaper Gate?
02:55Does that mean he was lying, he was cheating,
02:57being economical with the truth?
02:59Can you have, can Australia have a captain
03:01who appears to have been caught out for now?
03:06I mean, it's interesting.
03:08We've lost our last two captains
03:09in sort of slightly squalid circumstances,
03:13both Steve Smith and Tim Payne.
03:17That would be an unholy hat-trick
03:19if Pat Cummins had to resign at the same time.
03:24Look, the problem really dates back to the way
03:26in which Cricket Australia dealt with this problem in 2018.
03:30By singling out three members of the team
03:33for disproportionate punishment,
03:35and the sentences were way too heavy,
03:38you know, a year for each of Smith and Warner
03:41and nine months for Bancroft.
03:43That's far, far more than was necessary,
03:45far more than was required by the ICC.
03:48That had the effect of nurturing their sense of grievance
03:53and at the same time preventing really
03:55any further information coming forward.
03:58I mean, who was going to put their hand up
03:59in those circumstances when the stakes were so high?
04:03So it's ended up being one of those problems
04:06that Cricket Australia has kicked down the road
04:08for eight and a half years.
04:10And as we found with Shane Warne and Mark Waugh
04:14during the match-fixing saga of the 1990s,
04:18eventually, you know, these things do come to light.
04:22And they can come to a very, very unflattering light
04:24because of the long period in which they remain secret.
04:27You know, it comes then, Gideon, to Australian cricket itself.
04:31There's been this winner-takes-all,
04:33or should I say win-at-all-cost mentality.
04:35Many believe that's what set off sandpaper gate.
04:38Does this sort of put the entire Australian cricket mantra,
04:42winning-at-all-costs, under scrutiny?
04:44I know it's your national game, your national obsession.
04:51Well, I mean, the irony is that both Khawaja and Cummins
04:56and Bancroft, one of the things that they are united about,
05:02David Warner too, is that the culture of the Australian cricket team
05:05in 27-18 left a lot to be desired,
05:09that it was a pretty toxic environment,
05:11that they were being forced to seek competitive advantage
05:16and cut legal corners in pursuit of success.
05:22And I think Cummins has actually done quite a lot
05:25during his captaincy and Tim Payne before him
05:29to modify that culture, to temper that culture,
05:32to remove some of those confrontational aspects
05:36from the way in which the Australian cricket team represents itself.
05:40In a sense, they find themselves on trial
05:42for the team that they were eight years ago.
05:45And a lot of water's gone under the bridge since then.
05:48You know, a final question.
05:50Anger among the Australian public?
05:52Is that because of a sense of betrayal?
05:54They feel that the players whom they've treated as demigods
05:57may have lied about Sandpaper Gate?
05:59Or do they still retain Gideon a sense of pride and faith
06:02in their cricketers and the baggy green cap?
06:06I think there's a sense of confusion at the moment,
06:09genuine, genuine confusion.
06:11There are just so many layers to this story,
06:14not least of which is, you know, after eight and a half years,
06:18how much can people conceivably be expected
06:21to remember accurately?
06:22You know, you remember feelings, really, rather than events.
06:25And, you know, the feelings touched us very closely here in 2018.
06:28And all those feelings are recrudescing at the moment.
06:36I think it will be...
06:38I mean, I cannot believe the media frenzy around this
06:43over the last week or ten days.
06:44Just when you think that no one's interested in cricket anymore,
06:48just, it has a way of surprising you.
06:52Let me leave it there, Gideon A.
06:54Clearly, this has shaken Australian cricket.
06:56It's shaken world cricket.
06:57We don't know what will happen to Pat Cummins and the others next.
07:00But I appreciate you taking the time off
07:02to join me there from Melbourne.

Recommended