Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 9 hours ago
A lawsuit over vehicle damage, spray paint, and an unpaid promissory note takes an unexpected turn when Judge Judy discovers a serious problem with the plaintiff's case. The vehicle was being driven without legally required insurance, and the plaintiff's attempts to hold someone else responsible aren't going over well.

On Judge Judy, Judge Judith Sheindlin invokes the legal principle known as the "clean hands doctrine," explaining why someone who has engaged in unlawful conduct connected to a dispute cannot necessarily seek relief from the court. As the plaintiff continues arguing, Judge Judy loses patience and orders her microphone cut off.

Watch Judge Judy as a dispute over vehicle damage becomes a lesson in legal responsibility, mandatory car insurance, and the importance of coming to court with clean hands.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00It's as okay for him not to pay for the damage as it is for you to drive your car
00:05and lend it to
00:06other people without insurance. Because if instead of hitting a pole, he hit two children and caused
00:12injury and you have no insurance. Your Honor, because like I said, I thought he had insurance
00:17and his insurance was covered. And he has a promissory note that him and his girlfriend
00:21drove saying that they drove my car. And what about him spray painting it?
00:26Bye. You want to drive a car without insurance? So you didn't drive my car? I'm telling you
00:32right now. So you didn't drive my car? Listen to me very carefully. Did you drive my car?
00:36You're lying under oath. Just a second. I don't care whether he drove it or not. Did you drive my
00:40car?
00:40She doesn't understand, Bert. She doesn't understand. So this is what we're going to do.
00:44I'm going to sit here. I'm going to sit here. We're going to cut off her mic. And I'm going
00:49to say right
00:49into the camera, when you come to court, you have to have clean hands. You're supposed to have
00:56insurance. Perfect. Thank you.

Recommended