Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 10 hours ago
The Delhi Police has denotified Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site amid ongoing demonstrations against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over the SIR exercise. Protests have now been redirected to three alternative locations: Ramlila Maidan, the CBD Ground in Shahdara, and Burari Ground. However, two of these newly designated venues are situated significantly farther away from Parliament and central administrative offices, with CBD Ground approximately fourteen kilometres away and Burari Ground nearly twenty-three kilometres away. Moving demonstrations away from the corridors of power introduces logistical challenges, including massive crowd capacities ranging from fifteen thousand to eighty thousand people, expensive booking fees, and mandatory police clearance. Critics point out that shifting demonstrations far from the political centre may isolate demonstrators from policymakers, the media, and spontaneous public participation.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:002011, Anna Hazare's iconic historic anti-corruption movement.
00:06A year later, 2012, protests demanding justice for Nirbhaya.
00:102019, demonstrations against the Citizenship Amendment Act.
00:14In 2023, wrestlers protesting against then-WFI chief Bridge Bushan Singh.
00:202026, months ago, protests over need paper leaks and examination reforms.
00:25What's the one commonality here that I'm referring to?
00:28The address, Jantar Mantar, a space where citizens from all walks of life
00:33gather to raise their voices, to demand accountability and fight for change.
00:38That may now be changing.
00:39Amid protests by opposition parties and civil society groups against CEC Gyanesh Kumar
00:44over the SIR exercise, the Delhi police has denotified Jantar Mantar
00:49as a designated protest site.
00:51Instead, three new venues have been designated for demonstrations.
00:55Which are they? Where will protesters go now?
00:59Ramlila Maidan, Burari Ground and the CBD Ground in Shadra.
01:04But here's the catch.
01:06Two of these venues are far away from central Delhi,
01:09the heart of the government and administration.
01:12To understand what this shift means, let's first look at the distances.
01:16Jantar Mantar is approximately 2km from parliament.
01:21Ramlila Maidan, around 6km away.
01:26CBD Ground in Shadra is about 14km away.
01:32Burari Ground, nearly 23km from parliament.
01:37That's huge.
01:37That difference is significant.
01:39A protest at Jantar Mantar places demonstrators in the heart of the national capital,
01:43close to parliament and the corridors of power.
01:46Moving demonstrations farther away may ease the immediate pressure on central Delhi.
01:51But it also raises a question.
01:52Will protests held away from the political centre
01:56command the same public and media attention?
01:58Because the location of a protest is important.
02:01As important, many would say, as the cause behind it.
02:03Then there's the question of capacity.
02:07Jantar Mantar can accommodate around 3,000 people.
02:11Push that even to 5,000.
02:13Ramlila Maidan can hold approximately 50,000.
02:17CBD Ground, 15,000.
02:19The Burari Ground can accommodate nearly 80,000 people.
02:23These new venues are huge.
02:25They offer more space.
02:26But filling that space, sustaining a demonstration over several days,
02:30could be a big challenge.
02:32Away from central Delhi, protests may also find it harder
02:35to attract spontaneous participation
02:38and that same focus of media attention.
02:41And the geography isn't the only hurdle.
02:43There's also the question of access and accountability.
02:46Take Ramlila Maidan, for instance.
02:48One of the three newly designated venues.
02:51It's jam-packed.
02:53And reportedly has only three dates available for booking this year.
02:57That's December 29th, 30th and 31st, New Year's time.
03:01Booking that 12-acre ground, which can accommodate around 50,000 people,
03:05requires an initial outlay of approximately 1.21 lakh rupees per day.
03:10That includes taxes and a refundable security deposit.
03:14It's the closest, but it's costly, full of hassles.
03:19The venue is booked through the Municipal Corporation of Delhi's Horticulture Department.
03:23A no-objection certificate from Delhi Police is mandatory before permission is granted.
03:28So you can't just gather at your own will and start protesting.
03:31You'll get a smaller portion available, free of charge,
03:34but it can accommodate only around 150 people.
03:36So take your pick, 150 of 50,000.
03:39Then there are traffic concerns.
03:41The ground lies in a busy commercial area,
03:43close to three hospitals and the MCD headquarters.
03:46Let's talk about the CBD ground in Shadra.
03:50Spread across 12 acres, maintained by the Delhi Development Authority.
03:54This is a popular venue for weddings, for large events.
03:58Its location amid densely populated residential and commercial areas
04:02raises questions about traffic management and the impact on surrounding neighborhoods.
04:07Then there's Burari ground.
04:08The largest of the three venues, it spans approximately 50 acres in northwest Delhi,
04:14but far from the capital's central administrative district.
04:18Its size offers room for massive gatherings, but its location raises a different concern.
04:23How visible will demonstrations held there be to policymakers, the media, the wider public?
04:29For example, during the 2024-25 farmers' protest,
04:33the ground was offered as a possible venue,
04:35but the farmers' unions rejected that proposal.
04:38They called it an open jail.
04:40They argued that its isolation and fencing would contain demonstrations
04:44and keep protesters away from public view.
04:47Imagine if the farmers didn't agree
04:49when leaders of, let's say, an opposition bloc protest here.
04:52Sounds like a big no to me.
04:54So what does this shift really mean?
04:57In simple terms, out of sight, out of mind.
05:01Janatar Mantar is more than just a location on Delhi's map.
05:04It's a stage where local grievances become national conversations.
05:08Dissent could unfold within sight of the country's power corridors.
05:11You may move away from here.
05:13You're unseen, unheard, most importantly, irrelevant.
05:17The government has made its decision.
05:19The opposition and civil society groups have raised concerns.
05:22Now the big question is,
05:23if you move the protest away from the corridors of power,
05:26will the voices still be heard?
05:28Will people now have to protest for the right to protest
05:31and for a place to protest?

Recommended