• 3 weeks ago
Is the green washing of the beauty industry causing even more harm to the environment?
Transcript
00:01Beach spray.
00:02Marine collagen.
00:05Seaweed.
00:06Everything.
00:07Beauty brands love using the ocean to market new products.
00:12But beneath the surface, the industry is polluting the ocean.
00:17And even if it's recycled, it could still end up here.
00:20It's pretty disgusting.
00:22With few regulations holding it to account,
00:25the personal care industry is operating with impunity.
00:36Green beauty.
00:38This is a radiance mask.
00:41It's a growing movement towards cleaner and more natural products.
00:45As consumers, it seems like a win-win.
00:48Better for us and better for the environment.
00:51In the last 10 years, it's changed dramatically.
00:53Everyone really wants green beauty.
00:55The global industry is expected to reach 21 million in the next five years.
01:01But what if what's supposed to be a solution is actually fueling another problem?
01:06Of course, everyone wants a pretty package.
01:08Yeah.
01:08But I think now people are really savvy and they really want to know what's in the bottle that they're
01:12buying.
01:12Some companies are exploiting the green beauty movement, slapping words like clean, green, or natural on products to mislead consumers.
01:20The tactic is known as greenwashing.
01:24And as I'm about to find out, greenwashing is everywhere in the beauty industry and it's threatening our planet.
01:32And ourselves.
01:33I'm heading to Hawaii, a petri dish for greenwashing's two biggest problems.
01:39Plastic and chemical pollution.
01:42One of the most common essentials found in your beach bag may actually contain harmful toxins.
01:48Hawaii is now the first place in the world with a ban on certain sunscreen lotions.
01:53Two specific chemicals that are believed to cause harm to marine life and coral reefs.
01:58You may have heard that sunscreen could be damaging coral reefs.
02:02In July 2018, Hawaii became the first state to ban sunscreen ingredients oxybenzone and octanoxate.
02:10But it's more complicated than you might expect.
02:15You're right on the verge of full marine life, you know, so you get like big apex spreaders coming in
02:20here.
02:21Right outside there's all of a sudden like full live coral reefs.
02:24Dr. John Burns is studying the true impact of sunscreen on Hawaii's fragile coral ecosystem.
02:31We're seeing such rapid rates of change on these reefs that we can't afford to waste any more time.
02:41One, two, three.
02:50The reefs were hardly the vibrant habitats I was expecting.
02:54Everywhere I looked, I saw dead and dying corals.
03:00I still try to be an optimist, but I have seen changes I didn't think I would see in my
03:07lifetime.
03:07It's a lot of death. It's a lot of destruction.
03:11I wanted to know how sunscreen was impacting this devastation.
03:16So it's really eliminating the ability of corals to reproduce and make new generations.
03:21Corals reproduce in a closely timed event where they release sperm and eggs that float to the surface of the
03:27ocean.
03:28At that stage, they're exceptionally vulnerable.
03:30They're being immersed and exposed to everything that's in the water.
03:35It's hard to know how much reef loss is from sunscreen or from other stressors like climate change.
03:42But one thing is clear. Our reefs are in crisis.
03:46Scientists predict that in about a decade, 90% of the world's reefs could be dead.
03:51We need the reefs for food, we need them for oxygen, we need them for coastal protection.
03:56There's probably a lot of medicines that can save lives that we don't even know about in there.
04:00Absolutely.
04:01And we're destroying them.
04:02Yeah. I think what we need to do is make sure these chemicals are safe before we use them.
04:10But figuring out what's actually safe is harder than you might think.
04:14There's this one that says reef safe on it, but if you look on the back, it's got avobenzone.
04:20We don't know if that's safe for the reef or not.
04:23It's not just a few ingredients.
04:25It's actually an entire category of sunscreens that have experts like Diana Felton concerned.
04:31We have so much more to learn about what some of these chemicals do to both the environment and to
04:36human health.
04:36There are two kinds of sunscreens. Chemical absorbs UV rays, while mineral reflects them.
04:44Chemical sunscreen is the one raising questions.
04:47This would be the style of what I would choose.
04:50That's traditionally what we think of as reef safe, is ones that are mineral only.
04:56Even the historically cautious Food and Drug Administration has said that these ingredients need more research
05:02before confirming that they're safe and effective.
05:04This is the heart of the issue.
05:07The personal care industry largely polices itself.
05:11It's what allows them to greenwash in the first place and to put ingredients in products without knowing what they'll
05:17do.
05:17You could argue that a lot of these chemicals are sort of this great human experiment because we don't know
05:23the long-term potential impacts.
05:26It's not just what's inside the bottles that's wreaking environmental havoc.
05:31The more insidious danger could be the bottles themselves, made out of plastic.
05:37It's hard to imagine a time before it existed.
05:41In fact, plastic as we know it is only about a century old.
05:45In 1907, chemist Leo Bakelund invented the first modern plastic.
05:51It's Bakelite Resinoid.
05:52Durable.
05:53But more importantly, cheap.
05:56It spurred a revolution.
05:58The self-care industry quickly caught on, replacing its glass bottles with plastic ones.
06:04Today, we pump out about 300 million tons of plastic every year.
06:11About the weight of the entire human population.
06:14And it's piling up.
06:16A third of all plastic packaging ends up in the ocean.
06:20And the personal care industry is a major culprit.
06:23More than 60% of the packaging is made out of, you guessed it, plastic.
06:29In Hawaii, the impact is inescapable.
06:32We definitely have our fair share of plastic piling up on our beaches.
06:36We're on our way to Camilo Point, one of the most polluted beaches in the world.
06:41Far from civilization.
06:43It shows us just how much plastic comes from the ocean itself.
06:48We have done, in the past, up to as many as 13 trucks carrying marine debris out.
06:53With, I think, a record-breaking load somewhere around 7,000 pounds of marine debris in one day.
06:58In one day?
06:58Absolutely, yes.
07:06So, yeah.
07:07This is pretty disgusting.
07:09When you're down here actually looking at all of this plastic, I quickly noticed that all of this vegetation is
07:15growing up and over plastic.
07:18It's overwhelming.
07:20It was a chilling reminder that despite our best efforts, these products that we use every day end up in
07:27the ocean and wash up on beaches like this.
07:30I couldn't help but feel complicit.
07:33Shampoo bottle.
07:35Another shampoo bottle.
07:37Another shampoo bottle.
07:40This is a skin antibacterial skin cleanser.
07:45No more gray hair.
07:46No more gray hair.
07:47Hair dye for men and women.
07:49This was definitely some sort of, like, little shampoo or travel size something.
07:53Used this for four uses and now it's on our planet for 500 years.
07:58It's clear that plastic has invaded our oceans.
08:01But what does it mean for the rest of the planet?
08:05Researchers at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration are studying fish to find out.
08:11Oh my gosh.
08:13And what they're finding is pretty shocking.
08:15Two different colored bottle caps that I found in the same stomach.
08:18Bottleneck here.
08:19This is a black plastic bag.
08:20This is probably my craziest find.
08:22A Lego.
08:24So this was all the plastics that we got in about a five minute tow.
08:28This all came from just fishing for five minutes.
08:31Plastic pollution is a lot more pervasive than a lot of people might realize.
08:35It's been pretty shocking to see how many tiny, tiny pieces are out there.
08:40And that they're actually outnumbering the number of fish that we're finding in some of these samples.
08:46Jonathan made the unexpected discovery that diets of these fish contain microplastics.
08:52Tiny pieces only millimeters long.
08:54So that's the plastic.
08:56Right there.
08:56Yeah.
08:57The implications of this are that plastic is slowly accumulating and moving up the food chain, making its way from
09:03the tiniest fish to us.
09:06So it would be safe to say that we've put so much plastic into the environment that plastic is becoming
09:11part of our own diet.
09:13Yeah.
09:14It's hard to trace exactly where individual microplastics come from.
09:18But Jonathan has found one clear link to the beauty industry in his samples.
09:23Microbeads.
09:24Never in my life did I think I was going to be on a military base in a government lab
09:29looking at face wash.
09:30For more than two decades, the personal care industry was obsessed with and even advertised the benefits of these tiny
09:38plastic balls in exfoliating products.
09:41Microbeads are the perfect case study for industry behavior.
09:45Put ingredients into products now.
09:48Ask questions later.
09:50Because microbeads are too small to be caught by filtration systems, they can enter waterways after being washed down the
09:57drain.
09:58Public uproar eventually forced a federal ban on microbead products in 2015.
10:04So far, not a single major company has figured out how to clean its microbead mess.
10:12One of those companies is Procter & Gamble, the largest consumer goods corporation in the world.
10:19The company included microbeads in products from body wash to toothpaste.
10:24When P&G brand Herbal Essences invited me to look at its new ocean-friendly line, I was eager to
10:31see just what positive action the brand was taking.
10:34P&G is a series of brands.
10:37Billion-dollar brands.
10:39Pantene, Head & Shoulders, and of course, my favorite that I work on is Herbal Essences.
10:46Since its beginning, Herbal Essences' biggest marketing tool has always been nature.
10:51You may remember its commercials featuring women's totally organic experiences.
11:00Today, the brand is promoting a new Love Your Sure bottle made from ocean plastic.
11:06It starts as dirty, nasty litter.
11:10And it's ground down.
11:12It's three layers of plastic.
11:13The inner layer that touches your products is made from new, fresh plastic.
11:18And then the next layer, so that middle layer, 70% of that thickness is a blend of the ocean
11:25plastic with some additional plastic mixed in to really give it its full character.
11:30What?
11:31So what percentage of this beach plastic bottle is actually plastic from the ocean?
11:38Okay, so if you add all the pieces together, 25% of the bottle comes from plastic that was removed
11:45from the ocean.
11:46If this beach plastic bottle has Love Your Sure written on the front, it's made with beach plastic, but it's
11:53really only 25%, would some people maybe call that greenwashing?
11:59Who are these people?
12:01Because it's better than we were doing before.
12:04People who are critical.
12:04And this is, okay.
12:05So if you want to think about it, like it is only 25% beach plastic, but that's 25%
12:12more than what we did before.
12:14The bottle itself is costing us more money to produce.
12:20So we make less profits off of the beach plastic bottle.
12:24It's not costing more to an end user that's buying the bottle.
12:29So for us, we're making an investment to drive awareness to this issue.
12:34So it's the beginning of a journey.
12:37And a long one.
12:39According to the numbers provided by Herbal Essences, the Love Your Sure bottles will represent a tenth of 1%
12:47of all the bottles the brand will produce this year.
12:49That means the other 2.5 billion shampoo and conditioner bottles are made of new and often colored plastic, which
12:58turns out might be more problematic than you think.
13:00Is that recyclable?
13:05Unfortunately, it's not recycled right now.
13:10We know how to recycle that plastic, but unfortunately, there's no end buyer that's looking to buy the colored plastic.
13:20So all of our colored bottles are not easily recyclable.
13:25If you're going to flat out ask me, I just have to say no, that they're really not.
13:30I couldn't believe it.
13:32What Rachel's saying is that just because something is recyclable doesn't mean it's actually recycled, especially if it's made out
13:39of colored plastic.
13:40A majority of our products still end up in the trash.
13:44Why?
13:45Because in the U.S., recycling is a business, which means that what gets recycled depends on who's willing to
13:52buy it.
13:54Clear and white plastics are the easiest to recycle and reuse, while colored plastics, like Herbal's bottles, rarely end up
14:02being recycled.
14:03So why would a brand make bottles like that?
14:06Herbal Essences says because of consumers.
14:09Why don't you just make people buy the plastic bottles, just roll it all out, everything's going to be clear,
14:14it's going to be recycled.
14:14Because when you want to stay in business, people tell me, like, I use the blue one, and I'm like,
14:19you mean Hello Hydration.
14:21So when it's part of your brand equity, and we're a 50-year-old brand, so, you know, it's not
14:27an easy change.
14:28When you have an oil company that spills into a gulf, they're forced to clean that up.
14:33So, should the beauty industry be forced to help remove the chemicals that they've put into the oceans, as well
14:39as the plastic?
14:44That's interesting, because how do you know where the source was to begin with?
14:49It's not just the beauty industry, it's all these different industries.
14:53But it's also the beauty industry.
14:55It's also, absolutely, it's still the beauty industry.
14:58So how do you split the bill?
15:00It's a hard situation.
15:02All we can do is do what we think is best at the time.
15:06And the fact that there is nobody telling us what we have to do.
15:10It's true.
15:11There's no regulatory body telling Herbal or any other beauty brand what to do.
15:18Corporations taking these initial steps can feel small.
15:22But it reveals what's possible.
15:24These product lines are proof that corporations are paying attention and testing the waters.
15:31It's up to us to show brands what we want them to make.
15:35And the time to start is now.
15:37Because it's never been more urgent.